Laserfiche WebLink
CERTIFICATE OF DEDICATION <br />STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER, CITY OF SEBASTIAN <br />KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, MA' CROSS CREEK '_AKE ESTATES INC, A FLORIDA CORPORATION, <br />FEE SIMPLE OWNER OF THE LAND DESCRBED AND PLATTED HEREIN AS CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES <br />PLAT ONE. BEING IN ME CITY OF SEBASPAN, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, HAS CAUSED SAID <br />LANDS TO BE SURVEYED AND PATTED AS SHOWN HEREON AND DOES HEREBY DEDICATE AS FOLLOWS <br />1. STREETS AND RIGHT-OF-WAYS: <br />THE STREETS AND RIGHTS-OF-WAY AS SHOWN ARE HEREBY CECLARED TO BE AND SHALL REMAIN PRIVATE <br />THEY ARE DEDICATED TO AND SHALL BE THE THE PERPETUAL MAINTENANCE OBLIGATION CF CROSS CREEK <br />LAKE ESTATES HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATON, INC FOR THE USE AND BENEFIT OF THE OWNERS AND <br />RESIDENTS OF THIS SLBDIVISION- ALL PUBLIC AUTHORITIES, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO POLICE. FIRE, <br />AMBULANCE, INDIAN RIVER MOSWITO CONTROL AND UTILITY PROVOKES SHALL HAVE THE RIGHT TO USE <br />ME STREETS IN THE COURSE OF PERFORMING THEIR RESPECTIVE DOTES THE CITY OF SEBASAN SHALL <br />HAVE NC RESPONSIBILITY, DUTY CR LIABILITY WHATSOEVER REGARDING SUCH STREETS <br />2. UTILITY EASEMENTS <br />THE jME_ EASEMENTS A SHOWN ARE - <br />S S C E HEREBY UCTIO IN A PERPETUITY I INDIAN DEDICATED E EU 0 DA RIVER COVNTY rLORID <br />0. <br />AND THEITIES CITY OF SEBASTIAN FOR M' <br />c CONSTRUCTION, INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE AND OPERATION OF <br />BE ADOPTED <br />ANY UP TY. PROVIDER, IN COMPLIANCE W U SUCH ORDINANCES ARE REGULATIONS AS MAY <br />FLORIDAAND <br />FROM TIME F TIME TI THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS W INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, <br />NRTON AND THE CITY of SEBASTIAN CITY COUNCIL. <br />THE UTILITY EASEMENTS AS SHOWN ARE ALSO EASEMENTS FOR RIE COM1STRUCTCN, NSTALLADON, <br />MAINTENANCE AND OPERATION OF CABLE TELEVISION SERVICES, PROVIDED, HOWEVER, NO SUCH <br />CONSTRUCTION, INSTAIIATW, MAINTENANCE AND OPERA ON <br />OF CABLE TELEVISION SERVICES SHALL <br />INTERFERE W RIE FACILITIES AND SERVCES OF AN ELECTRIC, TELPRIME. GAS OR OTHER P'JEDC <br />UTILITY. IN THE EVENT A CABLE TELEVISION COMPANY DAMAGES RIE FACILITY OF A PUBLIC 'JTIJTY, <br />IT SHALL BE SOLELY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DAMAGES SUCH CONSTRUCTOR, INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE <br />AND OPERATION OF CABLE TELEVISION SFROCES SHALL COMPLY WTu THE NATIONAL ELECTRICAL SAFETY <br />CODE AS ADOPTED BY THE FLORDA PU86C SERMCE CWMSSIOIN, <br />FRONT YARD UTILITY EASEMENTS ARE SUBJECT TO THE RIGHT OF EACH LCT TO HAVE A DRIVEWAY <br />FOR INGRESS AND EGRESS AS APPROVED BY THE CITY OF SEBAST',AN <br />A DRAINAGE EASEMENTS <br />DRAINAGE EASEMENTS AS SHOWN ARE CEOICATED IN PERPETUITY TO AND SHALL BE THE PERPETUAL <br />MAINTENANCE OBLIGATION OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION, INC <br />FOR CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE OF DRAINAGE FACILITES AS PART OF THE STORMWATER <br />MANAGEMENT SYSTEM <br />THE CITY OF SEBASTIAN IS GRANTED ME RIGHT TO USE AND DRAIN INTO THE EASEMENTS AND ALSO <br />GRANTED THE RIGHT, BUT NOT ME OBLIGATICN, TO PERFORM EMERGENCY MAINTENANCE ON ME EASEMENTS <br />4. STORMWATER MANAGEMENT TRACTS AND STORMWATER MAINTENANCE EASEMENTS <br />STCRMWATER MANAGEMENT TRACTS W. '13% 'C', 'D' 'E' AND 'FAS SHOWN ARE DEDICATED IN <br />PERPETUITY TO AND SHALL BE THE PERPETUAL MAINTENANCE OB'_IGATON OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES <br />HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION, INC FOR THE MANAGEMENT AND STORAGE OF STORMWATERS. <br />STOP MWATER MAINTENANCE EASEMENTS AS SHOWN ARE DEDICATED IN PERPETUITY TO AND SHALL <br />BE ME PERPETUAL MAINTENANCE OBLIGATION OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES HOMEOWNERS' <br />ASSOOATON, INC TO PERFORM MAINTENANCE ON ME S-ORMWATER TRACTS <br />ME CITY OF SEBASTIAN IS GRANTED ME RIGHT, BUT NOT ME OBLIGATCN, TO PERFORM EMERGENCY <br />MAINTENANCE ON ME TRACTS THE INDIAN RIVER COUNTY MOSQUITO CONTROL DISTRICT HAS THE <br />RIGHT CF ENTRY UPON MESE TRACTS FOR ME LIMITED PURPOSES OF INSPECTION, PREVENTON <br />OR TREATMENT OF MOSO'J-O INFESTATIONS, AS ALLOWED BY LAW <br />5. EMERGENCY ACCESS TRACT <br />TRACT 'K' AS SHOWN IS CEDICATED TO AND SHALL BE THE PERPEMP MAINTENANCE OBLIGATION <br />OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION, INC FOR EMERGENCY ACCESS TO <br />THE SUBDIVISION AND FOR ACCESS TO THE SUBDIMSON IN CASE OF AN EMERGENCY BY ALL <br />EMERGENCY PROVIDERS <br />BURT STATION TRACT AND EASEMENT <br />TRACT'J' AS SHOWN IS HEREBY DEDICATED TO INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FOR CONSTRUCTOR AND <br />MAINTENANCE CF SANITARY SEWER FACPJTES, <br />THE LIFT STATION EASEMENT AS SHOWN IS HEREBY DEDICATED TO INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FOR <br />CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE CF SANITARY SEWER FACILITES <br />7. FUTURE DEVELOPMENT TRACTS <br />TRACTS 'H', 'L', 'M', N. '0', AND TI ARE 1ERE31 RESERVED BY ME DEVELOPER FOR FUTURE DEVELOPMENT. <br />8. LAKE ACCESS TRACT <br />TRACT T AS SHOWN IS DEDICATED TO AND SHALL BE ME PERPETUAL MAINTENANCE 03_IGARON <br />OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION, INC FOR LAKE ACCESS AND OPEN SPACE <br />FOR USE BY OWNERS OF LOTS IN THIS SUBDIVISION <br />IN WTNESS WHEREOF, ME ABOVE NAMED CORPORATION HAS CAUSED 'HESE PRESENTS TO BE SIGNED <br />BY HENRY A FISCHER, PRESIDENT OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES INC, A FLORIDA CORPORATION, <br />BY AND WITH THE AUTHORITY OF ITS BOARD OF DIRECTORS <br />THIS_ CAY M- <br />2 013 /� �,, /� <br />WTNESS `5_�a. 21'tillr Ln <br />BY HENRY A. PSCHER, PRESIDENT PRINT NAME-Ae&_r .D,// PRINT NA ,.jam B,yy <br />ACKNOWLEDGMENT TO CERTIFICATE OF DEDICATION <br />STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIANRIVER <br />ME FOREGOING INSTRUMENT WAS ACKNOWLEDGED BEFORE ME MISj3CD!DAY OF_ea-�EL_, 2013, <br />BYHENRY A FISCHER, PRESIDENT OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES INC. A FLORIDA CORPORATION, - <br />ON BEHALF OF ME Z. RPORA^CIV HE IS PERSONALLY KNOWN TO ME - <br />NOTARY PUBLIC COMMISSION �RATFt%- V <br />PRINT NAME te__pj,J[i' E%PON GAA TE <br />CITY OF_, EBASTAN CITY;$JA YOR <br />SURVEYOR <br />CLERK OF ME <br />ORCUIT COURT <br />CROSS CREEK LAKE <br />ESTATES NO <br />I� <br />A PLAT OF <br />CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES PLAT ONE <br />A SUBDIVISION OF THE SOUTH 1/2 OF THE NORTHWEST 1/4 OF SECTION 30, TOWNSHIP 31 SOUTH, _ <br />DESCRIPTION RANGE 39 EAST, IN THE CITY OF SEBASTIAN, IN'IAN RIVER COON <br />THE SOUTH 1/2 W THE NORTHWEST 1/4 OF SECTION C. TOWNSHIP 3- SOUTH RANGE 39 EAST, <br />INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, LESS AND EXCEPT THE EAST 3500 FEET THEREOF, SAID LANDS <br />MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS <br />BEGINNING A? T.HF NORTHWEST CORNER OF ME 11,11, ;/2 OE THE NORTHWEST 1/4 OF SAID SECTI. M. <br />PPOOEED NORM 89' 43' 26• EAST ALONG THE NORTH UNE OF SAID SOUTH 1/2 OF THE NORTHWEST 1/4 <br />OF SECTON 30 A DISTANCE OF 2622 89 FEET TO A POINT BEING 3500 FEET WESTERLY OF THE NORTHEAST <br />CORNER OF SAID SOUTH 1/2 OF THE NORTHWEST 1/4 OF SECTION 30, AS MEASURED ALONG SAID <br />NORTH LINE, THENCE SOUTH 00' 07' 35" EAST, ALONG A LINE PARALLEL WITH AND 35 W FEET WESTERLY <br />Of, WHEN MEASURED PERPENDICULAR TO. THE EAST LINE OF SAID NORTHWEST 1/4 W SECTOIN 301 <br />A DISTANCE OF 132985 FEET TO A POINT ON THE SOUTH LINE OF ME NORTHWEST'/4 OF SAID <br />SECTOR 30 SAID PONT BEING A R D FEET WESTERLY SOT ME SW MEAS' CORNER F ' N <br />E O S D ORMWEST <br />1/4 OF SECTION 30 AS MEASURED ALONG SAID SOUTH LINE, 'HENCE SOUTH 89' 0 3E" WEST ALONG <br />SAO SWUM LINE W THE NORTHWEST 1/4 OF SECTION 30 A DISTANCE OF 26285' FEET TO ME <br />ALONG TST CORNER OF SAID NORTHWEST 1/4 OF SECTION 3C. THENCE NORTH 00' 25 59' EAST <br />ALONG NT WEST LINE OF SAID NORMKEST 1/4 OF SECTION 30 A DISTANCE Of 1 <br />FEET TO <br />TME POINT OF BEGINNING <br />SAID PARCEL CONTAINS 80 02 ACRES. MOPE OR LESS <br />CERTIFICATE OF TITLE <br />STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER <br />I, WARREN W DILL, ESWIRE, OF DILL & EVANS, PL. HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE EXAMINED ME TITLE OF THE <br />HEREON DESCFIBEC PROPERTY. AND I FIND THAT THE 'ANDS AS DESCRIBED AND SHOWN ON THIS PLAT ARE <br />IN TIE NAME OF, AND APPARENT RECORD TITLE IS HELD 81 GROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES INC, A FLORIDA <br />CORPORATION, AND THAT ALL TAXES HAVE BEEN PAID ON SAID PROPERTY AS REWIRED BY SEC71CN 197192. <br />FLORIDA STATUTES AS AMENDED, AMC THAT MORTGAGES, LENS OR OTHER ENCUMBRANCES ARE AS FOLLOWS: <br />1. MORTGAGE TO MARINE BANK AND TRUST RECORDED IN OR. BCOK 2120, PAGE BOB, OR. BOOK 2318. <br />PAGE 1665, OR. BOOK 2357, PAGE 1673, OR BCOK 2363, PAGE 2351, OR BOOK 2369, PAGE 1161 AND <br />0 R BOOK 2632, PAGE 2086 <br />2 COLLATERAL ASS,CJNMENi OF LEASES, TEN'S AND PROFITS RECORDED IN OR BOOK 2120, PACE 922. <br />3 UCC/FINANCING STATEMENT RECORDED IN OR BOOK 2120, PAGE 927, CONTINUATION RECORDED IN <br />OR BOOK 2512, PAGE '055 <br />4 DECLARATIONS OF COVENANTS AND RESTRCTCNS ON LAND RECCRDEC IN O.R BOOK 1749, PAGE 400 <br />5 CROSS ACCESS EASEMENT RECORDED IN OR BOOK 2571, PAGE 1361. <br />6 JOINT DRAINAGE AND UTILITY EASEMENT RECORDED IN 0 R BOOK 2571, PAGE 1331 <br />7 ACCESS AMC USE AGREEMENT RECORDED IN OR. BOOK 2571, PAGE 1371 <br />ALL OF ME ABOVE INSTRUMENTS RECORDED IN ME PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA <br />MIS SEARCH IS UP TO AND INCLUDING MARCH 12, 2013 <br />l� <br />W1gRR_� "IT <br />N W GILL, ESQUIRE T <br />CERTIFICATE OF SURVEYOR <br />KNOW A_'_ MEN BY MESE PRESENTS, THAT ME UNDERSIGNED, BEING A DILLY JCENSED AND REGISTERED <br />LAND SLRVEVOR, DOES HEREBY CERTIFY THAT ON OCT03ER 15, 2012 HE COMPLETED THE SURVEY OF <br />ME LANDS AS SHOWN IN MF FOREGOING PLAT, THAT SAID PLAT WAS PREPARED UNDER HIS DIRECTION AND <br />SUPERVISION AND THAT THE PLAT COMPLIES WH A_L ME SURVEY REQUIREMENTS OF PART 1, CHAPTER 177, <br />FLORIDA STATUTES. THAT SAID PLAT ,S A CORRECT REPRESENTATION OF THE LANDS MEREIV DESCR BED <br />AND PLATTED OR SUBDIVIDED. THAT PERMANENT REFERENCE MONUMENTS, PERMANENT CONTROL POINTS AMC <br />LOT CORNERS HAVE BEEN SE- AS SHOWN HEREON AS REQUIRED BY CHAPTER 177, FLORIDA STATUTES AND <br />ARTCLE XIX, SUBDIVISION, LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, CITY OF SE3ASTIAIF AND MA' SAID LAND IS LOCATE] <br />IN THE CITY OF SEBASTIAN, IND AN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA A <br />WILLIAM B ZENTZ, PLS. -46ROPESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR DATE <br />REGISTRATION No 5276, STATE OF FLORIDA <br />WLLIAM B ZENTZ & ASSOCIATES. INC. - 684 OLD DIXIE HIGHWAY <br />VERO BEACH, FL 32962 (772; 567-7552 LB NP 6840 <br />CITY SURVEYOR'S CERTIFICATE <br />THIS PLAT OF CROSS CREEK LAKE ESTATES PLAT ONE HAS BEEN RENEWED BY ME UNDER9GNED <br />PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR AND MAPPER EMPLOYED BY ME CITY OF SEBASTIAN, WHO HEREBY <br />CERTFIES MAT LES PLAT CONFORMS TO ME REQUIREMENTS OF CHAPTER 177, FLORIDA STATUTES <br />C2_ <br />DAVID M. JONES, FLORIPA'PROEESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR, CERTIFICATE No 3909 'DATE <br />ZONING RS -'.0 LANE USE RES <br />-PACT 1 -_ C'I Ml, I LIIiI <br />,TIF TP[ <br />THIS PLAT ''` <br />I TF ACT I I' <br />JIL2I`,� Ll_ <br />I� <br />_ ZONING' RS -10 <br />- ` LAND USE: LDR <br />Y <br />SHEET 2 <br />1=.. r SHEET 3 <br />SHEET 4 I INDEX/ZONING MAP <br />I T _A_. E, <br />�I�yf■4I•' <br />al -TI <br />TP. N' <br />1 <br />ZONING RS -10 1'FT A I A Ft1 a1 <br />.AND 111 R11 <br />TY, FLORIDA coLxT <br />B -BE, ST -20th ALE 1� <br />1 <br />5'rFE-_I 510 <br />1- `.T z <br />A1a <br />1 <br />LOCATION SKETCH � <br />(N'' TO SCALE) '1 _ <br />PLAT BOOK z6 <br />PACE`7 0 <br />DOCKET No 501300111 <br />THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY <br />WILLIAM B ZENTZ <br />PROFESSIONAL AND SURVEYORN '276 <br />WILLIAM B ZENTZ &ASSOCIATES, INC <br />VER OLD DIXIE <br />IL GHWAY <br />32962 <br />VENO BEACH, FE 32962 <br />LICENSED BUSINESS (LB) /E840 <br />(T]2) 56 7- 7552 <br />CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL AND ACCEPTANCE BY CITY COUNCIL <br />THIS IS 70 CERTIFY THAT ON Mayf8 2013_ THIS PLAT WAS jAPPROVED BY ME CITY OF <br />MAB RTS COU_J� HE EASEMENTS CIYO <br />TD1CITE1 TO ENGINEER L=A_%� <br />808 �McPARTT' N FRANK WATANABE, P E, NEEL-SCHAFFER <br />CITY CLERK _4zCLt �_ CITY ATTORNE _�4 <br />SALLA' A MAIO ROBERT A GI,NSBUR <br />(ATTEST TO MAYORS SIGNATURE) <br />CLERK'S CERTIFICATION <br />STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER <br />I, CLERK OF CIRCUIT COIRT OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, DO HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE <br />EXAMINED THIS PLAT OF CROSS GREEK LAKE ESTATES PLAT ONE, AND PIAT IT COMPLIES HIM ALL <br />ME REQUIREMENTS OF CHAPTER 177 OF ME LAWS OF FLORIDA. THIS - WAS FU'D FOR RECORD <br />MIS--"--DAYOF�'TX[LY 2013, AND RECORDED ON PAGE _!I OF P AT BOOK lU <br />IN THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE CVCU!T COURT OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, F'_ORIDA. <br />JEFFREY R SMITH, CLERK OF COURT <br />BY S.Loa.��..r: DATE <br />DEPUTY CLERK OFCIRCUIT COURT, INDIAN R:VER COUNTY, FLORIDA <br />MORTGAGEE'S CONSENT <br />STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN R VER <br />THE UNDERSIGNED HEREBY CERTFIES THAT IT IS ME HOLDER OF A MORTGAGE UPON ME PROPERTY DESCRIBED <br />HEREON AND DOES HEREBY ON IN AND CONSENT TO ME DEDICATION OF ME LAND DESCRIBED IN SAID DEDICATION <br />BY ME OWNER THEREOF AND AGREES THAT ITS MORTGAGE, UENS OR OWER ENCUMBRANCES WHICH ARE RECORDED <br />IN OFFICIAL RECORDS BOCK 2120, PAGE 909, OR BOOK 2318, PACE 1665, OR BOOK 2357, PAGE 1673, OR BOOK <br />2363, PAGE 2351, OR BOOK 2369, PAGE 1161, OR BOOK 2632, PAGE 2066, OR. BOCK 2120, PAGE 922 <br />AND OR BOOK 2120, PAGE 927 W M CONTINUATICN IN OR BOOK 2512. PAGE 1055. OF THE PUBLIC <br />RECORDS OF INDIAN EVER COUNTY, FLORIDA SHALL BE SUBORDINATED -0 ME DEDICATION SH -WN HEREON - <br />IN WMESS WHEREOF, ME SAID BANK HAS CAUSE] ME PRESENTS TO BE SIGNED BY ITS _ <br />ANO ITS CORPORATE SEA_ TO BE AFFIXED H NEON BY AND WITH THE AUMORITY OF ITS BOARD OF <br />DIRECTORS MI5 __ DAY OF _ _L 2013 <br />MARINE BANK AND TRUST COMPANY <br />BY _ PRINT NAME _aOLNAIJ GI r -L vc <br />THE FOREGOING INSTRUMENT WAS ACKNOWLEDGED BEFORE ME THIS_jV!DAY OFAia,L 2013 <br />BY _JIRINJ_L fNVl Fy_E__ OF MARINE BANK AND TRUST COMPANY ON BEHALF OF THE <br />BANK HE I F N ME OR HAS PRODUCED ft _ AS DENTFICATON <br />NOTARY PUBLC : _ __ PRINT NAME4_.�__ <br />COMMISSION No - F4_ LPEYIb3 __ EXPIRATION DATE1�.� <br />NOTICES <br />i� <br />1. THIS RAT, AS RECORDED IN ITS GRAPHIC FORM IS ME OFFICIAL DEPICTION OF ME SUBDI ADED LANDS <br />DESCRIBED HEREIN AND VALE IN NO CIRCUMSTANCES BE SUPPLANTED IN AUTHOR" BY ANY OTHER <br />GRAPHIC OR DIGITAL FORM OF ME PLAT. <br />2 MERE MAY BE ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS THAT ARE NOT RECORDED ON MIS PLAT <br />THAT MAY BE FOUND IN ME PUBLIC RECORDS OF THIS COUNTY. <br />3 NO CONSTRUCTION, TREES OR SHRUBS WLL BE PLACED IN EASEMENTS WTHOUT O -Y OF SEBASTIAN APPROVAL <br />4 ROUTNE MAINTENANCE (EG MOWN., ETC) OF EASEMENTS SHALL BE THE RESPONS'EIL'TY <br />OF THE LOT/PROPERTY QWMER(S) AND NOT THE CITY OF SEBASTIAN <br />5 PROPERTY OWNERS ARE PROHIBITED FROM PLANING ANY CARIBBEAN FRJIT FLY AND CITRUS GREENING <br />HOST PLANTS AS SPECIFIED HEREON AND ARE REQUIRED TO REMOVE SAME IF ANY EXISTS CATTLEY GUAVA, <br />COMMON CLAVA, LO'UAT, ROSE APPLE, SURINAM CHERRY, CHINESE BOX ORANGE AND ORANGE JASMINE <br />6 DECLARATION OF COLD TIONS. COVENANTS, EASEMENTS AND RESTRICTIONS AFFECTING ME OWNERSHIP <br />OR USE OF THE PROPERTY SHOWN IN THIS PLAT ARE FILED IN OFFICIAL_ RECORDS BOOKJ"s . <br />PAGE1364, PLBJC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA <br />& TRUST DATE OF PREPARATION DECEMBER 12, 2012 <br />DATE <br />PENSION SHEET <br />REVISE PER COMMENTS, NEW TRACT <br />�:�,t a 26 13 REVISE PER COMMENTS 1 4 <br />