08/12/2025 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Board of County Commissioners Special Call Meeting Minutes - Final August 12, 2025 Waters Edge Resident Shalini Patel questioned how this cost was her responsibility. She felt the County had failed the residents by issuing a final permit for a corrugated pipe instead of a concrete one. Mr. Javed explained IRF was the permitting agency that approved the developer's choice of construction materials, not the County, and that corrugated pipes were an allowable option at that time. Resident Leticia Wood received clarification on from Attorney Hicks that the April assessment hearing was advertised in the newspaper, as required. The County then sent postcards to the residents informing them of this meeting so they could voice their concerns and receive clarification. Mr. Hicks added that the issue of responsibility has been ongoing since 2014, with the County always maintaining they were not responsible for the culverts. Administrator Titkanich read from the referenced email sent by the HOA's Attorney Sweeney on October 9, 2023, which stated there was good news: the association agreed with the County's proposal and approach to the situation. Attorney Shuler also relayed a zoom meeting, attended by Ms. Giordano and Attorney Sweeney after construction had started, where they discussed the final assessment amount and date of the final hearing. Ms. Wood expressed surprise at initially learning each resident would be assessed approximately $6,500 each, and advocated for spreading the assessment along all homes on 1 st Street SW. She received clarification that WEII was only paying for their entry culverts, while the culvert under 1 st Street SW was being paid for by the County. Attorney Hicks stated that the original corrugated pipe was not a mistake; it was a permitted material at the time and was approved by IRF. Ms. Wood received updated information while she was before the Board that the approximate assessment had been revised down to $5,800. Staff reiterated that the culverts provided benefits to only WEII residents and they bore the responsibility for it. Ms. Giordano mentioned an email received from a past County Attorney stating there may be funds to pay for the culverts, and wondered if the County had a budget for road repairs. The Board clarified that the County budget did not include funds for private infrastructure. Ms. Wood appealed to the Board for assistance, and maintained the residents should not have to pay to rectify the inferior materials originally used in the culverts. Vice Chairman Loar explained it was not feasible to pay for all the instances of private infrastructure, and assessments were the mechanism to fund the work. Staff clarified that public infrastructure ended at 1 st Street SW. The developer originally paid to have the culverts constructed, and built that cost into the price of the homes. The following residents addressed the Board: Bill Griffith complained about the price of the culvert replacements Indian River County, Florida Page 6