The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About12/20/1977r TUESDAY, DECEMBER 20, 1977 THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, MET IN SPECIAL SESSION AT THE COURTHOUSE, VERO BEACH, FLORIDA, ON TUESDAY, DECEMBER 20, 1977, AT 3:00 O'CLOCK P.M. PRESENT WERE WILLIAM C. WODTKE, .JR., CHAIRMAN, ALMA LEE Loy, VICE CHAIRMAN; WILLARD W. SIEBERT, JR.; EDWIN S. SCHMUCKER; AND R. DON DEESON. ALSO PRESENT WERE GEORGE G, COLLINS, .JR., ATTORNEY TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND VIRGINIA HARGREAVES, DEPUTY CLERK. THE CHAIRMAN INFORMED THOSE PRESENT THAT AN EMERGENCY SITUATION HAS ARISEN WITH REGARD TO PULLING NAMES FOR JURY DUTY AND THE BOARD MUST, AT THIS TIME, REVIEW AND APPROVE THE .JURY LIST SUBMITTED BY ROSEMARY RICHEY, SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS. THE COMMISSIONERS SELECTED THE LIST AS SET OUT IN CHAPTER 40 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES AND PERFORMED SUCH PROCEDURE UNDER OATH ADMINIS- TERED BY ATTORNEY. COLLINS, EXECUTING THE CERTIFICATE AS REQUIRED BY LAW. SAID .JURY LIST IS HEREBY MADE A PART OF THE MINUTES. VINCENT L. CASSERLY DEM 1 JOHN W. TH07AS DER IA P.O. BOX 235 W M RT 1 BOX 23 N 9 ROSELAND, FLA. 32957 FELLSUERE, FLA. 32948 THOMAS B. FERNANDER DER 1 GLADYS K. ALDRICH DER 18 ROSELAND- W S FARRARS MOTEL W F RT I BOX 112 RT 3 BOX 94 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 GEORGE HASKO REP 1 RANDOLPH W. BEERETTA REP LB P.O. BOX 413 N M SEBASTIAN HIGHLAtdDS ` {7 F ROSELAND, FLA. 32957 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 P.O. BOX 924 CURTEEN McDONALD DEE N 1A F. LEONARD M. LO�7E SEBASTIAtd, FLA. 32958 1B GRAUT ST. JOHNNY R. LINDSEY REP 1 WILLIAM fi. BURCHETT DEM IB ROSELAND RD N M SEB. TR. PK. LOT 5 W M RT 1 BOX 131 1A PAUL R. NELSON P.O. BOX 555 1B • STATE RD 512 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 F WHISPERING PALUS PK SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 M RT 1 BOX 112 WILLIAM A. NORTHRUP REP 1 DONNA L. CTl7.*1INS DEM IB ROSELAND S.R. 505 W M 841 DUNN TERRACE w F P.O. BOX 417 P.O. BOX 513 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 Fac SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 C. PAL"LYRE SADLER DEM 1 ROBERT P. DONE—TY, JR. IND IB P.O. BOX 403 W F 928 CANAL CIRCLE W M ROSELAND, FLA. 32957 SE$ASTIA:J, FLA. 32958 VIRGTNIA G. VINCENT DEN 1ROSERAYMOND- S: FRRLICF:, JR. DEM 1B P.O. BOXAND 52 W F 689 WIMBRCW DR W M P.O. BOX SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 JOH11 H. BE:tTLEY DER IA M FORD M. HANN ^ IB 118 S. OAK ST. W 308 VALENCIA ST. W W M FELLSMERE, FLA. 32948 SEBASTIAtd, FLA. 32958 JOHNIE M. DOUGLAS DEM N IA F CHARLES W. HUIPHREY REP IB LINCOLtd STREET 452 S.W. MANGO AVE W R. RT. 1 BOX 80—A P.O. BOX 2083 FELLSMERE, FLA. 32948 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32953 FLOSSIE 14. FIARRFLSON OLEat:DER ST, FELLSMERE DEM W IA F HARRIETT D. XITCIENS �' DEM 1B P.O. BOX 652 87 WHISPERI::G PLUS TR. PK W F WABASSO, FLA. 32970 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 CURTEEN McDONALD DEE N 1A F. LEONARD M. LO�7E DEM 1B GRAUT ST. 502 S.W. ALA6'.AtdDA AVE WM ' RT. 1 BOX b4 FELLSMERE, FLA- 32948 SEBASTIAN, SEBASTIAN, FLA.. 32956 FRANCES S. REYNOLDS DER 1A PAUL R. NELSON REP 1B • STATE RD 512 W F WHISPERING PALUS PK W M RT 1 BOX 112 RT 1 L01' FELLSMERE, FLA. 3.3948 . SEBASTIAN,, FLA. 32958 � DEC 2 0 197 Fac AN IF DOUGLAS H. PITMAN REP IB. WENDY A. LEDFORDcLI 925 CANAL CIRCLE W 8 W. SHELL LN SUmV,ERPLACE W. FC SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 RT. 2 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VICTOR F. ROSINSKI REP IB WILBERT J. M1 CtIELL DELI 49 ALISA DRIVE W M P.Q. BOX 392 1C SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 WABASSO, FLA. 32970 N R MARY E. SMITH DELI IB ERNEST T. RG37R73011 DELI 1C - 332 EASY ST. S.W. W F P.O. BOX 127 r W RT. l WABASSO, FLA. 32970 II SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 JOEL D. TLYLOR, JR DEN IB ALMA 911IPP 442 COLUM3US ST W R MILE OF PINES CT DELI 1C RT I P.O. BOX 314 W F SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 SEBASTIAN!, FLA. 32958 JESSICA R. VISON REP IB GEORGIA M. "SAVER 201 EASY ST W F P.O. BOX 413 DEt1 IC P.O. BOX 2033 WABASSO, FLA. 32970 N F SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 LEON H. WINGATE, JR DEM 1B WILLTAM F. CRIC:'LEY N I.R. DRI W H 4295 N. Wl?!TER BCH RD DEIS 2 P.O. BOX 355 RT 2 BOX 710C W L4 SEBASTIAN, FLA. 32958 VERO BEACii, FLA. 32960 EARL W. BACON REP 1C EDGAR K. FZLDER VERO LAKE ESTATES W M 6455 61ST COURT DELT 2 RT 4 BOX 536 RT 4 BOX 362 W B VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 KENNETH G. BROWN DEN 1C LOUIS E. HOLLIES P.O. BOX 384 N B 4530 43RD CT. DZU 2 WABASSO, FLA. 32970VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 N x MAE T. DARLING DEN IC RONALD W. RUFFINI P.O. BOX 714 N F 6336 58TH AVE REP 2 WABASSO, FLA. 32970 P.O. BOX 6188 W LS VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MARGARET L. DYER REP IC JIMMIE L. lILLIAMS P.O. BOX 555 W F 4536 49TH AVE 2 DELI 2 WABASSO, FLA. 32970 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 N LOIS M. HODER IND 1C LEE J. CALLCNAY P.O. BOX 804 W F 2026 86TH AVE DEM 2A WABASSO, FLA. 32970 'VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960' W LS THOMAS G. KENNEDY REP 1C HAROLD A. BENNETT REP 2A BAREFOOT LN SUMMERPLACE W M 2246 88TH AVE • W R.R. 2 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 N VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 C 2 0 1931 Ea : . v PETER G. FROEHLICH REP 2A NORMA E. B0003TAN REP 2B 2976 59TH AVE B R 3080 NASSAU.DR. R F RT 3 BOX 365B VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LEONARD R. CUNNINGHAM DELI 2A ILEEINE W. HANZY REP 2B 2716 52ND AVE N 9 3030 NASSAU DR N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 BRENDA K. HAMILTON DER 2A BILLY C. LAW, JR DEN 28 5900 26TH ST [ F 3350 BUCFINGRAMMOCK TR _ w N P.O. BOX 2261 P.O. BOX 1662 VERO-BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LOMA M. HUNTER DELI 2A MARGARET C. SCHNEIDER REP 2$ 6396 41ST ST R F 3020 11TH AVE R F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 GEORGE LEINS TER, JR. DEET' 2A EVA B. ANDERSON DEN 2C 2186 56TH AVE R N 4135 26TH AVE N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 1615 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 FREDERICK W. VIESSINER REP 2A CLYDE D. 30LDE DEM nid 7300 RT 60 LT 120 R N GIFFORD GARDENS APT 32 N 4C g VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 Y VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RUDOLPH PAVLOVIC REP 2A CARLOS F.-COBB DEET 2C 2465 447H AVE R m 3406 47TH ST N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH,FLA 32960 ' CLARICE ?LIVERS REP 2A JANIS J. DAVIS DESS 2C 4160 41ST ST N F 4525 33RD AVE N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 A14GELA F. SMITH DEE; 2A JAMES E. GIVENS DESS 2C S. SIDE N GIFFORD RD V F 4776 28TH COURT N M RT 3 BOX 292 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CHARLES J. STILLMAN, JR. DEE: 2A FRANKLIN HINES DEN 2C 2605 51ST AVE N 31ST AVE & 42ND ST N H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 GEL! DELIVERY GIFFORD, FLA. 32960 MARY H. WAGNER REP 2A SIR JACKSON REP 2C 2055 ?2ND AVE LT 459 • w F 1705 38TH LANE N . ES VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CLIFFORD WOODRUFF REP 2A BRENDA S. LEAKS DEN 2C 4160 41ST ST N U. 3960 47TH PLACE N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DEC 2 0 1977. ' °6{OK w °E- v UZERA McQUEEN DEM 2C ROLAND H. HOGUET REP 2D 4545 35TH AVE N F 193 SILVER MOSS DR N M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DENISE NEELY DEM 2C JOAN M. LEMLEY REP 2ij 1845 38TH PLACE N F 5400 N. AIA APT 6A W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 3251 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JUANITA PAXTON DES[ 2C KATHY J. b:onrssm - IND 2D 4616 28TH COURT N F 571 SEA OAK DR W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA.. 32960 ANNIE N. RICHARDSON D=U 2C SUSAN M. PATTERSONRS � P 2D 3821 44TH ST N F 100 OCEAN RD N F VERO BEACii, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ' SYLVIA J. SHEPPARD DEN 2C SAIL LEY D. °C!?I":DLFR REP 2D 4680 38TH CT N F 4621 PEBBLE BAY EAS? W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CAROLYN D. SMITH DEN 2C HARRY M. SI3LEY REP 2D 4439 35TH AVE N F 330 PALMETTO 10IN1 N M P.O. BOX 2255 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ELEIOSE 'i;ARPLEY DEN 2C WALTER T. WARRE t, JR. DEM 2D 44TH ST & 25TH AVE. N F 100 CLARKSON LANE W M F'O. BOX 5475 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 GIFFORD, FLA. 32960 HUE E. WILLIANS DEN 2C ETHEL T. BENHAMR.. c P 3B 4755 52ND AVE N M 1835 - 50TH AVE N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32950 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DALLAS YATES DEN 2C PATRICIA L. BYRNE..P � 3B 3810 45TH ST N M 1455 90TH AVE LT 259 W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WILLIAM R. BLACK IIID 2D ELLIOTT W. CURRY, JR DEN 3B 5400 N. AIA APT 26-B V M 1865 49TH AVE Wr M P.O. BOX 6 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WABASSO, FLA. 32970 EVELYN F. COFIELD REP 2D MIMI F. EILAND DEN 3B 5300 N. AIA APT 207 N F TWIN LAKES MOB PK LT 17 N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 6598 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LYNN A. FITZPATRICK DEM 2D GLORIA R. GIBBONS REP 3B 50 JUNGLE TRAIL N F 4905 OSCEOLA BLVD W F RT. 2 P.O. BOX 250 ¢ VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 €C.20 1977 30;mss M PRISCILLA L. HALL DEM 3B BARBARA S. BROOKER REP 3C 1455 90TH AVE LT 109 B F 2186 11TH LN H F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 33 -32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. VINCENT W. HUGHES DER 38 LEONARD CLEVELAND REP 3C HERITAGE VILLAGE MOB PK W a 1395 26TH AVE w R 40 SALEM DR VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 HENRY J. KORDEK DEEB 3B LOVEY B. FISHER - DEN 3C HERITAGE VILLAGE W M 555 4TH ST. LT 54 V F 129 CONGRESS ST. VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WILLIAM W. UcCLUAN REP 38 RAYMON'D P. GILL'AN DEN 3C 1316 45TH AVE w H 955 20TH AVE W m -VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 NANCY T. MOON REP 3B SANDRA 1. HALL REP 3C 5755 20TH ST W F 216 16TH AVE B F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 FLORE.:CE Y. PEPIN DEM 3B DEBORAH J. FEnM AND�L! r. 3C 1870 45TH AVE W F 106 18TH AVE � F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 9 0 GRETCT'Ell c . ROSE REP 38 NELLIE E�. HQ7ARD DEN 3C 1270.4214D AVE W F 885 LOTH CT. W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LEE SMI iLEY DER 3B VARY C. JONES REP 3C 1455 90TH AVE LT 245 V F 1865 5TH STREET F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WILLIAM G. THOMAS REP 3B DANIEL C. KOFKER.. � P 3C ` 1725 46TH AVE W u 151 5TH COURT S.W. N M VERO.BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DEBRA A. ALEXA DEN 3C N AiT � nLI,.. A. LEPOcRED c M 3C 2524 211D PLACE V F 2535 1ST PLACE - R F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 6593 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JLANNE T. SALTOSXONIS DEN 3C FREDERICK J. KAHLE REP 3C 24532ND ST S.W. W F 316 15TH AVE W m VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JOAN BLASBY REP 3C ALBERT W. LO,dCCOR JR. D..c td3 C 1826 4TH ST W F 2554 2ND PL S.W. W p1 VERO BEACH, FLA. 2 0 3 96 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 d EC - c 10 HARRIET S. MAHONEY IND 3D JEAN M. DTIVALL DESS 4A 1265 5TH PLACE N F PINE TREE. PK w g VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RT 1 BOX 336—A VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 PATRICIA C. PARSONS IND 3C CHARLES W. CRESS"JELL REP 4A 1641 11TH PL. 8 F 971 48TH AVE tip N VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JEANNINE B. OUESNIEL DEEB 3C GEORGE R. H°:9LETT REP 4A 1361 12TH AVE. V F 1025 SUI VILLA DR r H M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 E. JANE ROCCO DEN 3C CRAIG lit. COULD DEN 4A 225 20TH AVE N F 4760 STH PLACE W Y VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 HENRY P SCH'WEER, JR. REP 3C ELAINE W. K: OU"IiOUT REP 4A 1216 11TH AVE N m 2746 1ST PL W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RT.1 BOX 134A VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LESTER L. SOLIN, JR. DEN 3C JANICE R. JCHNSONI DEN 4A • 2206 11TH LANE D N 525 38TH AVE R F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 T R 1 BOX 179—A VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RUSSELL C. TRIMM DEEB 3C LENA Z.' MA13RI DEU 4A 1160 27TH AVE. w M REBEL RD NORTH SIDE. N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RT. 1 BOX 289 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MARGARET A. WASHBURNE REP 3C MANICY M. HURRAY REP 4A 325 18TH.AVE N F 471 27TH COURT PI F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 •BERDYNE F. WILLIAMS DEN 3C WILLIAM "at. POPE DEN 4A 656 26TH AVE. W F 906 35TH AVE N N VERO BEACH, -FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ARLYNIE A. ZORC DEN 3C F MATTHc:A SA3A T INIOD..Pd E 4A 790 20TH AVE VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ii 3605 2IID PLACE W !d RT 1 BOX 169 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 COLLEEN F. BFATTY DEET 4A EVERETT R. SPA REP 4A MONROE RD. S OF R037—DALE N F 1161 35TH AVE R RT. 1 BOX 355 — MAIL VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 KIM L. BURDICK DEET 4A GRACIE E. TRFArlYAY DEN 4A N. SIDE REBEL RD W F 735 40TEE AVE N F RT 1 BOX 281' RT 1 BOX 189—T VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MARCIA E. WILLIAMS- DEM* 4A SAMUEL W. PADGETT DEM 4B 2716 6TH PLACE w F 2343 2ND AVE S.E. B x VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JAMES H. ATTKISSON REP 4B MARY'F. PRESiELL DEM 4B 3 VISTA PALM Lit APT 105 V M 2333 2ND CT S.E. N F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ROBERT T. BOND DEM 4B MABEL X. RUNCE REP 4B 1903 5TH COURT S.E. R M I060-U.S.I S.V. V F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 684 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CARL v. CARTLFDGE DEE? 4B LYDIA B. SMITHP.. c P 4B 3 VISTA PALM Liz APT 102 7 VISTA PALM LN APT 106 V F P.O. BOX 536 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RACHEL G. CREDIT REP 4B JAL1ES A. THOMAS �� 2124 SUHRI1 L DRIVE S.W. V F 2109 2ND AVE S.E. DEN 4B VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 V Y • RICHARD J. FORRET REP 4B FREDERICK G. TOWER RLP 4B 15 VISTA PAL:! LN APT 104 V M 411 12TH PLACE S. E. V VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 M ANNE E. DONOVAN DEM 4B GENEVIEVE R. WEISS REP 4B 19 VISTA PALM LN APT 207 V F 2435 30TH AVE. S.W. V F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RT I BOX 80-CJ VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 K. ESTELLE HA`.:SE.i REP 4B WILLIAM B. YOUNG DEN 4B 10 VISTA PAL? LN APT 205 V F 17 VISTA PALM LN APT 201 w M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 • DOROTHEA S. GOR"LEY DEM 4B FRANCES D. SENCREA -LN REP 5$ P VISTA PALS' L•PJ APT 106 CJ F NORFOLK PINE756 V VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RT. 2 BOX 11A F VERO-BEACH, FLA. 32960 CECIL L. ;i0NZYCUTT . DEM 4B JAMES CONNOLLY 743 5TH ST SCJ V M 1546 WYN COVE DR REP 5B VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 V M VIRGINIA i:. JONES DEV 4B ALMA J. DF-YOUNG DEN 5B 508 21ST ST S.W. V F 18 SOUTHGATE VILLAGE V F. VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LLEPJELLYN F. MOSS DEM 48 ROBERT W. EN",ERICK REP SB ' 1950 U•.S. 1 LT 69 V• M PORPOISE POINT V M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 R.R. 2 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DEC ,® taT : • a z :a ti ROSE'M'ARY B. GAGLIARDI DEPS 58 ROBERT A. WEELPS, SR. PELICAN LANE w F 19?5 SURFSIDE TERRACE ' RT. 2 BOX 2C RT. 2 BOX 25-C VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CLIFFORD J. HA'IMETT DEN 5B ELSIE M. ACCETTOLA 1965 117I10yARD WAY V $ CITRUS PK VILLAGE RT 2 BOX 4V P.O. BOX 2399 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JOHN M. JEFFREY DEN 5B 1450 4TH AVE w v RICHARD A. BARLOT A VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 2255 .16TH AVE VERO BEEAC'ri, FLA. 32960 ALVIN J. KORTH REP 5B DEBRA A. CHENEY 4 N. LANE PORPOISE PT R Li 2604 VICTORY BLVD RT 2 VERA BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DOROTHY H. LYON DEPS 5B MARGARET ELAN 1597 PELICAN LN W F 1414 21ST ST P.O. BOX VERO BEACHH,,FLA. 32960 F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 NINA W. :?EFLIER IND 5B ADAIP.S L. GRAHAM SURFSIDE TERRACE W F 2005 CORT:2 AVE RT 2 BOX 25 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ELIZABETH L. NOEL DEN 5B Jr►t�E ?iAILvY 1?81 5TH AVE w rMARY 2446 18TH AVE VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 SUSAN C. PARRELLA' DEN 5B 1580 6TH AVE W F BONNIE L: HUGITART P.O. BOX 501 2041 DELL'AR AVE VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JANE B. R03INSON DEPS 5B BONITA BEACH W F VAX C. LA::'ING P.O. BOX 1883 2255 BUENA VISTA BLVD VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 BRENDA E. SCHAEFER DEPS 5B PAULINE W. MOORE 485 18TH ST VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 W F 2316 19Th AVE APT 3 VERO BEACH,FLA. 32960 LOUISE WALKER SMITH DEN 5B FREDERICK B. PAULSON 1166 6TH AVE W F 2086 28TH AVE P.O. BOX 867 VERO BEACii, FLA. 32966 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 GRANT M. TECYPSON REP 53 2190 MANGROVE DR W R ROBERT W. RIGSBY RT 2 BOX 6-A 2115 33RD AVE' VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 REP 5B R PS REP 3 W F REP 3 W N IND 3 W F DEN 3 W F RLP 3 W F DEN 3 w F DS2 3 W F DEPS 3 W N DEPS 3 W F DELI 3 w M IND 3 W m 6 DEC. 2 0 1977 J v HERBERT W. SCIiJLER DEM 3 2146 31ST AVE W M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JULIA M. SPARKS IND 3 2136 VALENCIA AVE W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 KATHY R. THOMPSON IND 3 3146 ATLANTIC BLVD W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ROGER T. WALKER REP 3 3752 20TH PLACE W M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MARTHA W. YOUNG DEM 3 1938 22ND ST W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 9ARYANN T. PARKER REP 3A 1880 36TH AVE. W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 FAYE I. BROOKS DER 3A 1958 36TH AVE. W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JAMES Y. COPELAND •3A DEB 3A 1916 34TH AVE. 14TII AVE. W 11 P.O. BOX. 1092 1680 28TH AVE W F VERO BEACH., FLA. 32960 JOHN E. LARSON DEM HUBERT 0. EGGLESTON DEN 3A 4141 16TH ST BLDG 12 APT 4 W M VERO BEACH, -FLA. 32960 OSCAR E.H. ENGBORG REP 3A 1901 33RD AVENUE W m VERO BEACH, rLA. 32960 WILLIAM IJ. HOBART REP •3A 1508 43RD AVE W H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 14TII AVE. P.O. BOX 927 MARGARET H. :SEATING DEM 3A 1680 28TH AVE W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MICHAEL A. HEISDERSON DEM 3A JOHN E. LARSON DEM 3A 1824 28TH AVE W M VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO LUCY D. MARINE DEET 3A 1826 34TH AVE. W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CHRISTI!!_ :,:. :JiLFZC'?LER REP 3A 4141 16Th ST APT 2-15 W �• VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 EILEEN N. POSADA DEC 3A 4141 16TH ST APT 4-2 W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 EVELYN G. BCtIAIBLE REP 3A 3121 15TH ST W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WANDA L. SMITH 4141 20TH ST VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 KATHLEEN M. VOCELLE 1887 42ND AVE VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 THOMAS N. WILLIAMS 1756 35TH AVE VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ADDIE S. GRAVES' DEE: 3A JOHN J. AVRIL 1915 34TH AVE. W F 1825 14TII AVE. P.O. BOX 927 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MICHAEL A. HEISDERSON DEM 3A RITA M. BCWLING 40TH AVE PLUM HOLLOW A-301 W M 2045 17TH ST. VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 3960 DEC 210 1977 REP 3A W F DEM 3A W F DEE 3A W M DEET 4 W m DEET 4 W F D PETER CARUSO DET 4 WESLEY A. SPRII:GER DENS 4 1525 26TH AVE M 1925 16TH AVE W ' VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ALBERT E. DANIEL, JR. DESS 4 ROBERT L. TRAENKNER REP 4 1837 23RD AVE w 1 1415 22ND AVE V N VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ROBERT A. ENGLAND REP 4 KENNETH L. WEIGHT, JR. r DEE 4 1922.21ST AVE W H 1906 27TH AVE a H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JEAN T. GOULD DEN 4 JAMES D. ALLBRITTON REP 5 1646 25TH AVE. R F 14 SEA HORSE LANE V NS :VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DAVID M. HEBERT DEII 4 GEORGE A. 7ARXETT REP 5 1912.23RD AVE APT 5 K m 2606 PALC`='.A DR q H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 OLORFE:CE T, HURLBUT A:"*ER 4 MARION C. 1 JRG.iTFAND REP 5 1923 15TH AVE W F 2800 I. R. BLVD APT 8U w F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA, 32960 SANDRA S. KCWALIK DEH 4 ELFA:.OR HILL. KIRCH RSP 5 1926 23RD AVE R F 835 18TH ST APT 205 B F VERA BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 CHARLES F. mcDADE, JR. DEH 4 HELEN B. CHF„ETTE REP 5 1581 OLD DIXIE HWY FAIRLANE HARBOR R F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 164 CORAL LN VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DAVID J. MURDCCCA DENS 4 JOHN H. COREY REP 5 2604 19TH PLACE W 9 26 STARFISH DR W M VERO.BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, -FLA. 32960 GLENN .W. PHILLIPS DENS 4 DANIEL E. DFMPSEY 1550-C OLD DIXIE R NS 1875 CORIA DR APT 204 DEH 5 P.O. BOX 6162 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 � L{ VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LOUISE'D. ROUTH DEN W 4 F STANLEY B. F;DWARDS DEH 5 1748 25TH AVE 2301 LEON AVE P.O. *BOX 207 P.Q. BOX 6522 H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 : FRANK E. SMITH REP 4 ETHEL E. GAGE DEN 5 2046'14TEi DRIVE R H 2521 GRANADA AVE W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DEC 2 01977. 39 fw3-51 DOROTHY G. GRILSES REP 5 CHARLES F. PERRY REP 5 2800 I. R. BLVD APT 5—I W F 2800 IIID RIV BLVD APT 4K W 9 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MARION HARDWICKE REP 5 JESSIE A. QUAY 15 PARK AVE W F 169 FAIRLANE HARBOR DEN $ W VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 F ELIZABETH G. HELMS REP 5 CHARLES E. RCBERTS, III DEET 5 FAIRLANE HARBOR W F 927 16TH PLACE o W 195 CORAL LANE VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 E VERO-BEACH, FLA. 32960 MYRTLE P. HOLMAN REP 5 1 STARFISH DR W g GUDRU:d G. SC:l':FFLER IND 5 P.O. BOX 698 2800 I.R. BLVD APT 10 i W g VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 GARY D. HUDIMON DER 5 CLINTON L. S:'AQUIST REP 5 2675 10rd AVE W N 620 18TH PLACE P.O. BOX 2091 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 W LI VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960. W. HARRY JOHIISON DEN 5 PHOEBE SIIOitT 2706 10TH AVE� W m 2551 I. R. BLVD APT 1 DEH 5 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 W F RICHARD L. KIRlLAND REP 5 HOWARD ;TAF ORD 1815 R03ALO DR APT 205C W N 1825 CO3IA DR H-101 REP 5 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 W l RICHARD I. LASRIS DEN 5 BARFARA A. STRAIN�• 1845 ROBALO DR APT 201D W M 2705 COUNTRY CLUB DR REP5 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA- 32960 W F EDWINA B. McHOSE REP 5 EMITA F. TAYLORDE�1 400 18TH ST APT I-7 W F 1807 7TH AVE r 5 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P,O, BOX 623 W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MARY A. EASTERS REP 5 EVE LYN L. `"ALTERS 2665 COUNTRY CLUB DR W F ?24 18TH PLACE APT 2 DEH 5 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 W F JOHN H. MOREHOUSE REP. 5 " JUDITH M. WILL2AMS IND 5 2800 I. R. BLVD APT 3—P. W 712 18TH STREET VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA.- 32960 w F RICHARD E. NORMAN, JR. IND 5 1 ROYAL PALE: BLVD W 8 i LWIJd C. AiIRAPJD REP 5A P.O. BOX 6144 951 BOUGAINVILLEA LN w tS VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 P.O. BOX 3923 e VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 .,I DEC 201977 $t fK a jiy vt v PHOEBE F. BRADLEY DEN 5A DEBORAH J. POTTS IND 5A 812 DAHLIA LN. N F 555 IRI$ LANE W F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 NELLIE CHANDLER DEN 5A WILLIAM C. REEVES DEL! 5A 505 PAY DRI — RICMAR w F 414 3EAGRAPE DANE R R VERO BEACH, b'LA. :»960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 RICHARD A. CTIBOR REP 5A ANNABFLLE W. SARSFIELD REP 5A 3101 S. OCEAN DR N M 1941 CLUB DRIVE w F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 GORDON E. FAGERLUND REP 5A ALYCE C.SIS'.°!, 805 RIOMAR DR N R 596 AZALEA LANE APT 16 REP R 5A F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 SHARRON E. T. GERLING DER 5A WILLIAM v. STUB3S 1480 S. OCEAN DR APT 2—H w F 768BO:I'u.-'+I;JVILLEA L;! REF' SA VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 � ti GORDON L. HALSEY DER 5A CHARLES E. ',`SAL ;.^,R 525 BAY DRIVE w M 1715 OCL•'AN LF -1111 APT 4A IND � SA VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 Ei SALLY F. !!COVER DEN 5A DA:?LE?lE C.. ++ILLIASiS D LS 5A 545 GARDENIA LANE N F 1441 OCEAN DR VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 F • NANCY S. PARISH REP 5A ROBERT E. BAKER 826 GAYFFATHEP. LANE w F 4410 N. AIA APT 307 DEM 5C VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 w &t ESTHER E. LANGE 637 TULIP LANE REP w 5A F GEORGE L. BRANDON DT -M 5C VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 535 EUGENIA RD V9 N VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 BETTY E. McDOLE 528 TULIP LANE REP N 5A F PATRICIA r'.. C.?: ATWOOD DAG; 5(' VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 770 GREYTWIG ROAD w F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DORIS N. MIDGLEY REP 5A CHARLES w. CRISS REP 5C 831 CAMELIA LN w F 4450 11. AIA APT 302 R VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 m ROBERT J. NOLAND REP 5A 935 $cACRAPE LN N Li RALPH .t. FD:AISTO:! REP. 5C VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 3802 MOCYINGBIR D DRI R H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 EC 01977 12 PALE -353 W. DONALD GILLESPIE REP 50 606 HOLLY RD W Y VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 DOROTHY E. HINDERT DEM 5C 4139 SILVER PALM P4 NO 6 V F VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ROBERT JOHN577O1 DEE1 5..0 4403 SUNSET DRI N R VERO BEACA, FLA. 32960 STANLEY M. YURTYKA DER 50 544 LIVE OAK RD w 9 VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WALTER W. Va-CORKLE DEM 5C 546 EUGENIA RD. W N VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 JAMES R. YONROE IND 54 3545 OCEAN DRIVE w N VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 WAYNE R. OSB:)RN REP -5C 431 LIVE OAK ROAD W IA VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 EDWARD J. POTEET REP 5C 3939 OCEAN, DR APT 204 W M P.O. BOX 4017 BCH STATION VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 MAX 0. SAR ORI DEH 50 4450 N. AIA APT 103 W H VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 ANSON D. SOLEM REP 5C 3554 OC -AN DR APT 602N W R VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 LOUIS J. THELK DEM 50 4803 SUNSET DR. W - m BEACH STATION BOX 3205' VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 HAROLD C. WILLIAMS IND 5C 286 LOLLY RD R m VERO BEACH, FLA. 32960 v C 201977 . DEC Selected December 20, 1977, as possessing the qualifications of Jurors, as prescribed by the Laws of Florida. William C. Wodtke, t GiC:C�n ' ' Lee Loy Willard Siebert; Jr. Edwin . Schmucker R. Don Deeson STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER Before the undersigned authority on this day personally appeared William C.Wodtke, Jr., Alma Lee Loy, Willard W. Siebert, Jr., Edwin S. Schmucker and R. Don Deeson, who being duly sworn says, severally, that as members of the Board of County Commissioners in and for Indian River County, they personally selected and made out the foregoing list of names of persons qualified to serve as jurors in Indian River County, in accordance with the provisions. of law, and that affiants know or have good reason to believe, that each of the persons whose names appear in the said list, possesses the prescribed .qualifications under the law, according to their best information and belief, and is otherwise qualified under the law to serve as a juror° tel! •C ^ z ��'e' ; ' Edwin cA QM'�' Qwa� uc er onDDeeson Subscribed and sworn to before me at Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida this 20th day of December, 1977. Freda Wright Clerk Circuit Co rt THE HOUR OF 3:00 O'CLOCK P.M. HAVING PASSED, THE DEPUTY CLERK READ THE FOLLOWING NOTICE WITH PROOF OF PUBLICATION ATTACHED, TO -WIT: VERO BEACH PRESS -JOURNAL Published Weekly Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER: STATE OF FLORIDA Before the undersigned 'authority personally appeared J. J. Schumann, Jr. who on oath says that he is Business Manager of the Vero Beach Press-Joumal, a weekly newspaper published at Vero Beach /inIndian 'River County, Florida; that the attached copy of advertisement, ming i,, the matter of- 1e. in the Court, was pub - lisped in said newspaper in the issues of �7 y Affiant further says that the said Vero Beach Press-Joumal is a newspaper published at Vero Beach, in said Indian River County, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, weekly and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Vero Beach, in said Indian River County, Florida for a period of one year next preceeding the first publication of the attached copy of adver- tisement; and affiant further says that he has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this adver- tisement for publication in the said newspaper. Sworn to and subscribed before me this `jo vw_,_� ay of /' '� ` • A.D. -7 (B iness Manager) (SEAQ (Clerk of the Circuit Court, Indian R:rer County, Florida) DEC 20197? _ NOTICE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County, Florida, will hold a public hearing an December 20, 1977, at 3:00 o'clock P.M. at the Indian River County Courthouse to consider the adoption of An Ordinance relating to the times during the week that alcoholic beverages may be sold, Consumed or served or permitted to be served or consumed in any place holding a license under the State Beverage Division of Florida, defining the term alcoholic beverage, providing for enforcement and penalties for violations, and providing for an effective date. Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County, Florida. By: William C. WodtkeJr., Chairman Nov. V, 1977. CHAIRMAN WODTKE NOTED THAT WE HAVE HELD ONE PUBLIC HEARING ON THIS MATTER PREVIOUSLY AND HEARD A GREAT DEAL OF TESTIMONY, BUT WE MUST NOW.GO THROUGH THE SAME PROCEDURE AND EVERYONE WILL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD, ATTORNEY SAM BLOCK SPOKE REPRESENTING THE MEMBERS OF THE RETAIL LIQUOR ASSOCIATION. HE REFERRED TO THE LENGTHY PRESENTATION MADE ON THEIR BEHALF AT THE PUBLIC HEARING OF NOVEMBER 17TH AND ASKED THAT THE RECORD OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING REFLECT IT IN FULL. ATTORNEY BLOCK RE- ITERATED THEIR REQUEST FOR AN EXTENSION OF ONE'HOUR AND STATED HE WOULD MAKE NO FURTHER PRESENTATION AT THIS TIME, BUT WOULD RESERVE THE RIGHT TO RESPOND IF THERE IS EXTENSIVE DISCUSSION AT THIS HEARING. Ki 0t CHAIRMAN WODTKE DIRECTED THAT ALL EVIDENCE PRESENTED AT THE FORMER HEARING HELD ON NOVEMBER 17, 1977, BOTH PRO AND_CON, BE ENTERED INTO THESE MINUTES. THE PRESENTATION MADE BY ATTORNEY. BLOCK, INCLUDING LETTERS AND PETITIONS SUBMITTED IN SUPPORT `OF THE REQUESTED ONE-HOUR EXTENSION, IS RECORDED IN OFFICIAL MINUTE BOOK 32, PAGES 2 THROUGH 120. PRESENTATION MADE BY THOSE OPPOSING THE ONE-HOUR EXTENSION, INCLUDING TESTIMONY, LETTERS, PETITIONS, - ETC., IS RECORDED IN OFFICIAL MINUTE BOOK 32, PAGES 120 THROUGH 195. THE CHAIRMAN ASKED IF ANYONE PRESENT WISHED TO BE HEARD. NORMAN BADENHOP OF 4601 SUNSET DRIVE, PRESIDENT OF•VERO BEACH CIVIC ASSOCIATION, SPOKE REPRESENTING THE, 1,378 MEMBERS OF THAT ASSOCIA- TION. HE STATED THAT THIS ASSOCIATION IS OPPOSED TO EXTENSION OF THE BAR HOURS AND WOULD PREFER THAT THE HOURS BE CURTAILED TO MIDNIGHT AS A BETTER SERVICE TO THE PUBLIC. HE POINTED OUT THAT SHERIFF .JOYCE HAS STATED HIS OPPOSITION TO THE ADDITIONAL HOUR AS HAS CHIEF SAM MCCALL OF THE CITY OF VERO BEACH. MR. BADENHOP NOTED THAT THE PRESENT HOURS HAVE BEEN IN EXISTENCE FOR A LONG TIME; THE BAR OPERATORS WERE AWARE OF THEM.WHEN THEY ORGANIZED THEIR BUSINESS; AND THE GOVERNMENT IS NOT HERE FOR THE PURPOSE OF GUARANTEEING PROFIT TO INDIVIDUALS. H. D. BOOTH STATED THAT HE IS UNABLE TO FIGURE ANY BENEFIT TO THE COMMUNITY AND THE COUNTY AT LARGE IF THE REQUESTED EXTENSION IS GRANTED, AND RECOMMENDED THAT THE TIME BE LEFT AS IT IS. FLOYD GRIMM, LOCAL CONTRACTOR AND REAL ESTATE MAN, STATED THAT HE FELT STRONGLY THAT THE HOURS SHOULD NOT BE EXTENPED. HE NOTED THAT MOST OF THE PEOPLE WHO WOULD STAY AND PARTAKE OF ALCOHOL AFTER 1:00 A.M. WOULD BE THOSE WHO TEND TO OVERINDULGE, AND MANY OF THEM CANNOT AFFORD TO DO THIS FINANCIALLY. JOHN DEAN OF 2223 LOTH AVENUE OPPOSED THE EXTENSION OF HOURS AND REFERRED TO THE DRAWING HE PRESENTED IN EVIDENCE AT THE PREVIOUS HEARING WHICH SET OUT MANY STATISTICS IN REGARD TO THE DETRIMENTAL AFFECTS OF THE USE OF ALCOHOL AND ITS RESULTING EXPENSE TO THE TAXPAYER. HE SPOKE ALSO OF THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE BAR OPERATOR, NOTING THAT HE HAS SEEN PIT BULL FIGHTS BEING HELD IN THE PARKING LOT OF A BAR NEAR THE CENTER OF TOWN. 3 DEC 2 0 1.977- A a J JACK HART, PASTOR OF THE PENTECOSTAL CHURCH OF -GOD: SPOKE IN OPPOSITION, CONTENDING THAT THIS SITUATION MUST STOP SOMEWHERE, AND HE FEELS IT SHOULD STOP NOW, VICTOR SMITH OF WABASSO SPOKE AS A FORMER DRUG ADDICT AND ALCOHOLIC, NOTING THAT HE HAS BEEN IN COURT TWICE AND BOTH INSTANCES RELATED BACK TO A BAR. HE STATED THAT THERE ARE MORE DRUGS SOLD IN BARS THAN IN ANY OTHER PLACE IN THE COUNTY AND TO GIVE THEM AN EXTRA HOUR TO DO THIS IS NOT BENEFICIAL TO ANYONE IN ANYWAY. HE, THEREFORE, WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE CLOSING HOURS REVERT BACK TO MIDNIGHT INSTEAD OF AN ADDITIONAL WUR BEING GRANTED. GREGORY GODFREY, PASTOR OF THE FIRST FREE WILL BAPTIST CHURCH, INFORMED THE BOARD THAT HE HAS ONLY BEEN IN THE COUNTY A FEW MONTHS, BUT HE IS TOTALLY OPPOSED TO ANY EXTENSION OF BAR HOURS. HE CITED THE PROBLEM OF CHILDREN IN BROKEN HOMES AND MADE ORPHANS BY ACCIDENTS CAUSED BY DRUNKEN DRIVERS. BOB FOSTER, PASTOR OF TABERNACLE BAPTIST CHURCH, REMINDED THE BOARD THAT AT THE LAST MEETING A GROUP FROM HIS CHURCH APPEARED TO EVI- DENCE THEIR OPPOSITION, AND ANOTHER GROUP IS HERE TODAY. HE STATED THEY ARE STILL OPPOSED AND ALWAYS WILL BE. HARVEY DODSON OF 905 23RD AVENUE, A BUSINESSMAN WITH AN INSUR- ANCE AGENCY, POINTED OUT THAT AN EXTENSION OF BAR HOURS WOULD NOT TEND TO REDUCE INSURANCE RATES. HE ALSO SPOKE IN OPPOSITION AS A PARENT AND FELT THE FACT THAT NEIGHBORING COMMUNITIES HAVE LATER HOURS SHOULD NOT INFLU- ENCE THIS COUNTY. CARL LANGLEY OF SEBASTIAN STATED THAT HE DID NOT FEEL ANY PERSON CAN HONESTLY SAY THAT EXTENDING THE BAR HOURS ONE HOUR WILL HELP ANYONE PHYSICALLY, MENTALLY, MORALLY, OR SPIRITUALLY, AND HE DID NOT BELIEVE IT WILL HELP THE BAR OWNERS FINANCIALLY EITHER. HE POINTED OUT THAT SERIOUS DRINKING USUALLY STARTS FROM C:GG P.M. AND EXTENDS TO 1:00 A.M. IF IT IS EXTENDED ONE HOUR, IT WILL BE INCREASED 14%, AND -EVEN INFLATION DOESNIT JUMP THAT FAST. REVEREND DICK STEVENS OF LIFE FOR YOUTH RANCH APPEARED ON BEHALF OF THE CHILDREN OF THE RANCH AND STATED THEY ARE AGAINST THE EXTENSION. HE FELT IF THE BAR OWNERS ARE GRANTED AN EXTRA HOUR, THEY SHOULD BE MADE RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL THE LIABILITIES IT MAY CAUSE - DETOX EXPENSES, ACCI- DENTS, ETC. m ■1 I DEC 2 01977 " � 5 ALCOHOL, AND IT IS ALSO A KNOWN MEDICAL FACT THAT A CERTAIN PERCENTAGE OF EVERYONE WHO DRINKS BECOMES AN ALCOHOLIC. HE FELT THE PERSON WHO SELLS THE ALCOHOL MUST SHARE IN THE BLAME FOR THIS AND WAS OF THE OPINION THAT MOST OF THE PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY ARE AGAINST EXTENDING THE HOURS. CATHERINE DAVIS, SCHOOL TEACHER, SPOKE IN OPPOSITION, STATING THAT MANY OF THE PROBLEMS SHE HAS ENCOUNTERED BOTH IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOL AND CHURCH SCHOOL SYSTEM STEM FROM HOMES WITH ALCOHOLISM PROBLEMS. HERMAN BROWNING, ASSISTANT PASTOR OF BAPTIST TABERNACLE CHURCH, SPOKE VEHEMENTLY OF DRUNKARDS AND STATED THAT HE IS TOTALLY AGAINST ANY EXTENSION AND, IN FACT, FEELS ALL BARS SHOULD BE CLOSED DOWN. ROBERT CASTALDI SPOKE FOR THE LIQUOR INDUSTRY AND POINTED OUT THAT EVERYONE REALIZES THAT ALCOHOLISM IS A DISEASE AND NOT TO BE TAKEN •LIGHTLY. HE NOTED, HOWEVER, THAT ALCOHOLICS ARE NOT FORCED.TO DRINK, AND STATED THAT ALCOHOLISM DOES NOT ORIGINATE IN A LOUNGE, IT STARTS IN A PERSON. MR. CASTALDI NOTED THAT AT THE PREVIOUS HEARING A MEMBER OF THE OPPOSITION PRESENTED A CHART SHOWING MANY STATLSTICS AND MEDICAL CLAIMS, BUT HE DID NOT FEEL THAT ANY OF THIS HAS BEEN SUBSTANTIATED. HE CONTINUED THAT IN THE TESTIMONY PRESENTED, PEOPLE HAD SPOKEN OF TEENAGERS COMING TO SCHOOL HIGH, WHICH HE FELT IS THE PARENT S RESPONSIBILITY AS THEY SHOULD REGULATE THEIR CHILDREN. HE SPOKE ABOUT SHOP LIFTING AND IN- CREASED CRIME WHEN THE STORES STAY OPEN LONGER AT CHRISTMAS TIME AND FELT.THERE IS A DOUBLE STANDARD. MR. CASTALDI-TALKED ABOUT THE GROWTH RATE IN THE COUNTY IN THE LAST FEW YEARS AND THE NUMBER OF DEPUTIES IT HAS BEEN NECESSARY TO HIRE IN THAT TIME. HE STATED THAT THE LOUNGE OPERATORS RUN CLEAN ESTABLISHMENTS AND PROVIDE SAFE MEETING PLACES FOR PEOPLE TO ENJOY THEMSELVES. HE STATED THAT IF THEY CAN PROVIDE BETTER ENTERTAINMENT IT WILL BRING MORE BUSINESS, AND THEY NEED THE EXTRA HOUR TO OFFSET RISING COSTS. HE REMINDED THE BOARD OF THE EVILS BROUGHT ON BY PROHIBITION. `l EC >; a 7_ MR. CASTALDI CHALLENGED THE COMMISSION TO TAKE 'A GOOD LOOK AT ALL THE FACTS AND POINTED OUT THAT WE ARE SPEAKING OFA LEGAL BUSINESS INESS LICENSED BY BOTH THE STATE AND THE COUNTY. HE STATED THAT THE PETITIONERS HAVE PRESENTED SOLID FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THEIR REQUEST AND FEEL THE OPPOSITION HAS SKIRTED THE ISSUE.. ° VICTOR SMITH REPLIED THAT THIS IS A MORAL ISSUE AND QUOTED FROM THE BIBLE ABOUT "DRUNKARDS NOT INHERITING THE KINGDOM OF GOD." THE CHAIRMAN REQUESTED THAT THIS HEARING NOT TURN INTO A DEBATE BETWEEN TWO PEOPLE AND ASKED ATTORNEY BLOCK TO MAKE A CLOSING STATEMENT. ATTORNEY BLOCK STATED THAT HE WOULDJUSTLIKE TO COMMENT ON PARTICULAR ITEMS BROUGHT UP BY THE OPPOSITIONHE AGREED THAT WE DO NOT WANT TO BE LIKE OTHER COUNTIES, BUT EXPLAINED THEY USED THE OTHER COUNTIES " TO SHOW WHERE SOME OF THE INCOME COULD BE GOING AND TO SHOW THAT WITH E PEOPLE TRAVELING AND DRINKING IN OTHER COUNTIES, IT COULD CAUSE ACCIDENTS. HE REITERATED THAT THEIR PROBLEM IS AN ECONOMIC ONE, AND HE DOES NOT { FEEL IT HAS BEEN ADDRESSED. ATTORNEY BLOCK NOTED THAT ACCUSATIONS WERE MADE IN REGARD TO DRUGS BEING SOLD IN BARS, AND HE WOULD HOPE THAT THE COMMISSIONERS WOULD PUT THESE COMMENTS IN THE PROPER PERSPECTIVE. HE CONTINUED THAT HE FELT MR. BADENHOP DID'NOT IN ACTUALITY SPEAK FOR ALL 1,300 MEMBERS OF THE VERO BEACH CIVIC ASSOCIATION AS HE DID NOT BELIEVE THEY HAD BEEN POLLED. ATTORNEY BLOCK CONTINUED THAT MUCH HAS BEEN MADE OF A STATEMENT BY SHERIFF JOYCE THAT AN EXTENSION OF BAR HOURS WOULD ' F COST THE SHERIFFS DEPARTMENT $1,000 A WEEK. HE STATED THAT HE QUESTIONED SHERIFF JOYCE ABOUT THIS, -AND THE $1,000 PER WEEK ACTUALLY WOULD REPRESENT t HIRING SIX NEW PEOPLE. ATTORNEY BLOCK DID NOT FEEL THIS WOULD REALISTI- CALLY RELATE TO JUST ONE EXTRA HOUR, ATTORNEY BLOCK STATED THAT THEY DO RESPECT THE RELIGIOUS AND MORAL VIEWS OF THE PEOPLE IN THIS COUNTY, BUT THEY ARE TRYING TO ATTACK A REALITY. HE NOTED THAT AN INSURANCE MAN STATEDii THAT WITH THE EXTRA HOUR, INSURANCE RATES WOULD NOT GO DOWN, BUT ON THE OTHER HAND, HE DID NOT BELIEVE THEY WOULD GO UP EITHER. ATTORNEY BLOCK j REQUESTED THAT THE BOARD PUT THEIR PERSONAL VIEWS IN PERSPECTIVE WITH THE DOCUMENTED EVIDENCE PRESENTED. CHAIRMAN WODTKE ASKED THAT AT -THIS TIME THERE BE ENTERED INTO THE RECORD THE 312 POSTCARDS RECEIVED SINCE THE PREVIOUS MEETING IN FAVOR OF GRANTING THE REQUEST AND THE THREE LETTERS, TWO POSTCARDS, AND PETI- TION WITH 66 SIGNATURES RECEIVED IN OPPOSITION TO THE REQUEST. 70~ boalttreuM Wl;(4 Be MAb f A PA +7' 0A 7NF 6 . DEC, 2 77 - BOOK 3 FAGE 360 i 7 Fl, • I 1 L • GAG � fGG.Y.>r��.r^-�G� .�a�ir.�,,� DEC 2 01977 2 Baa K _ i I GORooN F. GILMORE 1 BOBS CLUB DRIVE r VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32980 November 18, 1977 Mr. William Wodtke, Chairman & other Commissioners Indian River County Vero Beach, Florida Gentlemen: - This letter expresses my personal views on the question of closing hours for night spots in the County. Being one of the origctnaI founders of the Vero Beach Civic Association, I feel confident in saying that I am positive that the majority of members living in Indian River County would be unalterably opposed to later closing hours. This is a low key community which is one of its many -charms. We should do nothing to encourage un- desirable night life especially where it involves more time to legally drink at bars. It is unthinkable that this could happen and I am greatly surprised that the Commissioners would even approve a public hearing to discuss the issue. Any Commissioner voting in favor of later closing hours should be removed from office at the next election. KERSHNER TIRE CENTER 835 20th Place VERO BEACH, FIA. 32960 November 19, 1977 William -C. Wodtke, Jr., Chairmen Indian River County CommistAxm Indian River County Court House Vero Beach, Florida Dear Bill, Please add my wifeband my names to the growing list of citizens in opposition to the extension of the closing hours for bars and lounges from 1 to 2 a.m. With the tremendous growth of alcohol-related crimes and accidents over the past few years, together with increased teen—age use of alcohol, our community certainly does not need additional legis— lation which would add to this problem situation. We are in complete agreement with Sheriff Sam Joyce in his opposition to this extension and are grateful for his taking a positive stand in this controversial issue. Together with many other concerned citizens, we seek your support, as well as the other commissioners, in denying this request for extended hours. Thank you for your consideration. A R (Dick) Kershner Copy* Sheriff Sam T. Joyce Sincerely yours, J i/W . O BOLI( 34 ` , r t NO TO RXTM BAR HOURS b i We the undersigned do not, nor feel our -county should, support any efforts to extend the closing hour of our county bars and lounges from 1:00 A•M. to 2:00 A:M: We do not feel or believe that this extension of drinking hours can benefit Indian River County mentally, pbysically, socially, or spiritually. Signed November 1977 Name Address 1 , 1 J NO TO EXTM BAR HOURS 1 '�. We the undersigned do not, nor feel our county should, support any efforts to extend the closing hour of our county bars and, lounges from ltOO A.M. to 2:00 A:M: We do not feel or believe that this extension of drinking hours can benefit Indian River County mentally, pbysically, socially, or spiritually Signed November 1977 Name Address 154 r to 14�WA�6 FWS e — 6 d9 - C 2 01977 - 32 R . - 9 NO TO EXTEND BAR HOURS We the undersigned do not, nor feel our county should,.support any, efforts to extend the closing hour of our county bars and lounges from ltOO A.M. to 2sOO A;.Y., We do not feel or believe that this extension of drinking hours can benefit Indian River County mentally, physically, social3y, or spiritually. Signed November 1977 Name 7VA DEC 2 0.1977 I Address _dam --.- 1-41e 0/0 kjn�AeA4, r -A 27 1�741(f /?o C toll I !Z,( DEC 2 0 1977 'o � 369 r • LL610 330 0 PAi �y<�lxtn � Ove � arc' if✓iY v�^r�= � I t 2-0/ 'AeA � 9 /ice 77 I DEC 2 01977 L- J a�13y- �6 3 z ,?6o 714 2uXi i 1f 2L -Cc . � i� dlNROa Q8y � Q�/i1,3�3k/ ter, �3a0lSSIHt uanos oad °a 03i1t3�3oa b LL61030 I� I ter, �3a0lSSIHt uanos oad °a 03i1t3�3oa b LL61030 DEC 20197? I;vz / 4L tom' 32 mA73 =I =I 1� F w. flc3wd ac vw 10 k. f,r O/D 1 -y -Y 0(-1 '10 I X119- 5 �! SRO' QIdUw► C►3 td Kaaw�ON 3 1 ol\1 �r°c'� :�an�� N��Qrd��-0 S..kuaQssa� ^{y(� •�yyd;� S a MIL N-4aDt(ot) bdW 4T \juD4M 0 jd,4-O j t DEC 2 0 1977" �I ■ iL61oz 330 povy !� khPoo -0,50do-41 clool -a�ij CJ/lld,�9�� zo/Jb j N( �jV h vbr7 C V.0 /v 9 INA% J C) Q ,! Bch � iii'•. ` '%3/(�p �..� L.: • alall 1 1� y,let < • /'q, �b�i4F� • .� ,.�� w � . Q I-IrAL/ C_ n_ 410WO , I9 mog 'LL61 0 Z 330 /-V, . , 4 Y?/ 06J 9 w �,,� �� -mob � �- ,�,u� ..000000�� 17'v I u Ml c po. 4 cq( Cl (o OWN DEC 2.0 1977 3 32 P A GE378 i t4 � Qo 0 o U61 0 Z 330 It DEC 2 01977 \' "IUZ �i d V 0 w i4d M 1 t r" %''`'" t C.`d N �T IS OF rnI CBiveeRvSJ i 'f4!fi(- Pb 0424 o F U E Hatyj) lOLI 4L vwxmtO5 57A OI)eN U�tlTIL. -rt4C atCLO C pERDt t ai C vel g t c tl N e& > 1�R b Pd E>D 40, Tt- e CO,ct-A vUeD aF TwtS c.ovhtA(5a)(Tul 3,e6iba t3c-ST 06 t-10 q WO vae;,iJ w t+0 rle-'IZF Q u E,,IJ r ` rv4-C-se CSTr4r--j,LIS41kvic-AjrS Do AJ6`r C--UCa-) C{C'T 0f F- W o xv, v ev ii L A rn v C u t_ .rrTC-C 146 u I-. ► T 15- o� N(3&Uco 1 N'%acO/us(tt 4-t cc . �w5� T T k 0 —TUC E1cTe- r4- tFZ'W u u G �A o v u m vN s_ vA its V"A d-�- - �� a.00 — i -kh& pIo 1e6l, 6 /0 'Joy $arc a R DEC 2 0 1977 1 a. `v&°vA Z4 � 1 44 d tl -(7r- .Ml 1 .4a kv r N �i s ti"�'►Pe+'� us sDsw�ol � �� Camp a0-ni- R. auo_�. b-,.- llkom� a r Q �� a- • YET (/ �-E%� A/I 0 �QUn 32 f� Fil J .5'4 913 �oflK 32av 384 41n IN 0 0 950 COAWPVAY ao*k 14-i-, DEC 2 0.1977 BOOK 32 fmE385 OOL 3x960 ' �2:0o a.hv. ,�e.�a�w�' BOOK 32 PmUE 386 r im moo9 X61 0 z 330 t+9dz F VIX o 96rjp �3-7n/-J�* -70ayp DEC 2 0.1977 1 Lee- 44;.� 1 k �} FlPIUl e OF T..e ��llv�S To -9-e e�►r�e� �d�� maim. I aom 32 PAcE 388 f If OL9:r =I I .U61 0 Z 330 1009 a zmW 021�tl XV coed —rl � 6 y VI/I im Avu If DEC 2 01977 Booz 32 PuE J i 'Ole i9l;l 3�9�0 DEC 2 01977 CL � z ysJf a ��FfQd��• 3 Q,�lD BOOK a 32 FACE 392 'LL61 0 z 330 dj•J�' la y �! � Oy � //// I U�e L ?Y J r ' i J k %Li oS/,v 6 oc.� �'SSDhu�� J;? ge 6 DEC 2 0 1977 + BOOK 32fAtE 394 NOW n2 y ova -P `C v eb -n// (12 t'17�v u9 (U172. 9X(7 Iq 7Y Nines• PAP 5))/ I w.a.,; .� ✓vY V ✓� V • ¢ ti C 1 ,�. u 159 ..vS - (i cj� .•a DSC 1977 b w RECEIVED. BOARD COUNTY rte.. COMMISSIONERS •.;� 4 1 ��•. •�tv 1 ��I � O�� 3? PmE 396 BOOK 0- vA - - ---- -- - - r � Ge�vzw� ♦ ' 1 p a Iswa i .E37 n all t46 DEC 2 0 1977- BooK 39 PacF 397 ol I xU I • N3. a..R, _ a �. - = y ' �� :. - _ l l.--=2oc t DEC 201977 EQOK 3? 1L"Ic. TAM, _i ..'cam • . DEC 2 01977 r BOOtc f 32 9 l L d '-0 ._- "r -jam-, �'�9'Sw�- .. .� •-e r.x-�^__. �.,... .. �•\A' M�y� r.r 1 1� BOOK 3? PA -UF 410 ' _ . _-�--•---�'�'—,,.err ti�_.�.._.. __- - -... � � , .004 A& 10 f i i • , �� - .� . p jr .ice' . - --,r _� �� L�� .. Olt cz- 4,:6---- a 614�- DEC 2 0 1977, ROOK 3? PAGE DEC 201977 f BOOK 39w FAf,F. 0 J V GAJ ( yl�✓"i�.�Ir r f DEC 2 01977 BOOK 32 pArIP40.5 DEC 2 0.1977 C �v s �K� • I am in favor of eitending the closing hour for liquor establishments to 2:00 a.m. f .39 PAGE4UG R a i3ax y y eo,,A la 3�yGa DEC 2 0 1977.: BOOK 32 FADE 407 -IAC) 19,0067J- AJeot-,O kll<� 7-a J--/-,4rr 7-o Zoe DEC 2 0 1977 soon 32 PAcF 408 L Ii O� �i�- ,�L42tco�. �� Yom•._ ._ � • �� 2• 1�fG--' �'�G b �7'�'t � /� v�'� �Las�/l/�- •��c�j� S I I � i ga 32 PA, -,E 409 M_; 01i�- 3avd GC t Moog 03A13o3U LM 330 : m1p TAII- Pe Vz4a 1-,e � FC- .. 'leg, G9 � r cv-�; . • DEC 2 ®_ 1977 BOOK 32 Fur 4A L 0 ol 7f7��Y�yj7 r ` L944 r jniJ Do," s} �J fill bl T LL610 Z 03 rl fart J'u'Vd ac to 1810 Z 030 �� "rte : � -�. Wye + -//• 77 l � Ll 0 DEC 2 01977 Boa 39 pm;F It - , /--,07 --�, r- --/� /93� 3//�ri�• 2 DEC 2 01977 Boa 32 pv.,E 415 fflll-�� 7 7" 7,;oo��r- .l )fid- ��a� PooK 39 PAGE 416 at U ED 1 .� a 0 CILO 1k) >Y� ,a rn DEC 2 0 IM L- v 2- 0 � �.e�. n� 17 1 N Boax 32 L fLYGC/c, c,2 J/7 L� epee DEC 2 01977 eoox 3,9 PacF 41 IN v i .� 0 � s- 3 6 � Qum 1121� ��7i� ��,��✓ DEC 2 01977 Boom 3,9w. PAGF 419 L- 10 DEC 2 01977 - I 4OF N CIOL- CL- ,? 2- f 9,0' ROOK 39 PAGE CM f Ta Ai r �J 0Q am s e7 y� mo �nra�a d s� 9Q �� 4 o-/ Q atv2)d o 346/9 oA aa3 l T Z+l C -V -D NVI(U kn-7 .wu'C 'A jj_ -�' . LL61 Q Z 330 4 .9 �i.Q o� iod i I i I d �- Yet 6 tel l . kill- Ilej DEC 201977 Boom 32 FAcE 422 fl ck 77 d6aX 1V lti1 �dp�lkkj In ¢A M Ttl1 CAU oRL kA (L �4,00 A.M . CA.bS'kAG- VoSz- SN��Rt�i �ooK 3? PACE423 L- 3-9 PAGE -4 1crLkn�� _ kQG , L '- V esu i I i /Xv _rnV0i,pA.) ,�/ lfL Go 4x d/ Py 5%A f X419 1 J)A" DEC 2 ®1977 BooK 32 PArE 42b a DEC 2 0 1977 �ooK 32 FacF 427 Net -bvi- Cog 0 o� �.� �+� 4 IF 97 clarl L •�c'QSmry Ott ol +k4 V" (2. •Do 4tij e�r 7� v1.0Qet. 46 cfo-o &-s IAO VWXa /3 e -M C AA / .fit W69-' / 70. Gv�LG GiG A14lou 0 dr 7�1 o og4 G "0IfJ0AetCy *0.4 $6 - Lam.. -L1" iJ `e Cios,. DEC 2 0,1977 - BOOK 32 PAGE 429 Oct Haag Om y � .. .. � •ter ".. .. •i wfy 0 Q: �*•� 30Vd X009 10. ,vMA 1 �1--i 8,�7. 1 LL610 Z 330 I o .t 9 -)no / N* i ,CZ� y a•,• sem.' �•�. a 1p am Clt- - - ----------------------------- . Boa 32 PxF 4:33 v IEC 0 1977 a acs- JAW- � i-. nvz BOOK 32 PACE, 434 I o 3574 Fc `7Z - 6,, f LL61 0 330 d y YK-, v (YI CLZS (,f(,r Is tw I/v f vo r of' A Z 4.M, clo5t.1cr-- or 160AIC-LIS I'L/ v 0 0/11'1 OEC 2ol97T- 4-4 157-7� BDo�32 PA c r 43 7 ,I I eiren� S cW . I YW !vl `L ov w°1 2.x�w S;.Sn DEC 2 01977 rh^ ((-70or �<<i Roof 32 438 10 a DEC 2 01977 .a.e.r �0 N& �s-,,vt- e �r%G f`f5h�"c�i C� A t�✓t,� t-11�., 4 OC2/vi�4 ago pAcE 439 it L.-. 1 0 IM I ZC . 6,61 -,/ � 0 C -r 0 Q (2 ........... ... elf, 4 -� Z,l 751 P7 4 ' LL61 0 Z 030 d W Aire, XACO- DEC 2 01977 -I,- 'D, � . n\. Box 39 Aw 442 "A DEC 2 01977 3.2 4 $a� dl IF o -.. Af a;ob e�� . ✓� DEC 2 01977. pom 32 mT,444 i i b. ~ a^An l v- &A24 .,0000/ - 4 ` Lis DEC 2 d 1977 - BOOK ?' im,445 r.� 10 DEC 2 OJ977 N, � 121- 2/;; 1' dVvLkms& �oroe 641A, /It - foo 347 1 11 F COMMISSIONER LOY ASKED THAT THE RECORD REFLECT -THAT SHERIFF' .JOYCE -IS IN THE HOSPITAL AND UNABLE TO ATTEND THIS HEARING. ON 140TION BY COMMISSIONER SIEBERT, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER, THE BOARD UNANIMOUSLY CLOSED THE PUBLIC HEARING. CHAIRMAN WODTKE ASKED FOR THE BOARD'S COMMENTS. COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER NOTED THAT THIS IS A DIFFICULT ISSUE,`` BUT HE FELT A LOT OF THE ARGUMENTS IN 'REGARD TO NOT EXTENDING THE BAR_ HOURS ARE RELATED TO ALCOHOLISM, WHICH HE -DOES NOT FEEL IS THE ISSUE. HE STATED -THAT HE FEELS THE PROBLEM OF ALCOHOLISM IS HERE TO STAY, AND TO COMBAT IT, WE WOULD HAVE TO CLOSE THE BARS DOWN ALTOGETHER. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT ALSO DID NOT FEEL THE QUESTION OF WHETHER DRINKING IS MORAL OR NOT IS WHAT WE ARE HERE TO DECIDE. HE STATED THAT HE CAN EMPATHIZE WITH ANYONE WHO HAS HAD PROBLEMS WITHIN 'THEIR FAMILIES THAT CAN BE ATTRIBUTED DIRECTLY TO ALCOHOL, BUT HE DOES NOT BELIEVE THAT THIS CAN BE RELATED DIRECTLY TO BARS, AND HE DOES NOT BELIEVE THAT CLOSING THE BARS AT 1:00 A.M. OR REVERTING THE HOUR TO MIDNIGHT WOULD SOLVE THIS PROB- LEM AS IT IS THE REASONS FOR PEOPLE BECOMING ALCOHOLICS THAT HAVE TO BE ELIMINATED. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT CONTINUED THAT HE FEELS THE PEOPLE WHO PATRONIZE THE BARS DO SO MORE BECAUSE IT IS A MEETING PLACE WHERE THERE IS ENTERTAINMENT RATHER THAN JUST FOR THE PURPOSE OF DRINKING. HE NOTED .THAT THE TRUE ALCOHOLIC IS FREQUENTLY FOUND IN THE BARS IN THE AFTERNOONS OR MORNINGS, COMMISSIONER SIEBERT STATED THAT HE, TOO, TALKED WITH SHERIFF .JOYCE IN REGARD TO HIS STATEMENT ABOUT INCREASED COSTS, AND SHERIFF JOYCE TOLD HIM THAT ACTUALLY IT WOULD ADD NO MORE TO THE INCREAS- ING COST OF LAW ENFORCEMENT THAN IS BEING CAUSED BY MANY OTHER PROBLEMS. HE NOTED THAT THE SHERIFF AT THE PREVIOUS MEETING REFERRED TO THE DETOX CENTER IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY HAVING 1,265 ADMISSIONS FROM ST. LUCIE AS COMPARED TO 483 FROM INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, WHICH HE RELATED TO THE LATER CLOSING HOUR IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT INFORMED THE BOARD THAT HE LOOKED UP THE FIGURES FOR INDIAN. RIVER COUNTY WHEN THE DETOX CENTER WAS LOCATED IN THIS COUNTY, AND WE HAD OVER 3,000 ADMISSIONS IN COMPARISON TO SOME 2,000 FROM ST. LUCIE COUNTY. HE, THEREFORE, FELT THIS FIGURE WOULD RELATE MORE TO THE LOCATION'OF,THE DETOX CENTER THAN ANY OTHER REASON. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT POINTED OUT THAT OVER 200 BUSINESSES AND APPROXIMATELY 2,500 PEOPLE HAVE SIGNED LETTERS, PETITIONS AND 7 mm . 32 mE448 J e POSTCARDS IN FAVOR OF THE LATER HOUR, AND AMONG -THESE NAMES.ARE MANY -' WHO WERE INSTRUMENTAL IN BUILDING THE COMMUNITY OF WHICH WE ARE SO PROUD. COMMISSIONER Loy STATED THAT IT IS...TRUE THAT THE PETITIONERS HAVE A VERY REGULATED BUSINESS, BUT IT IS'MISUSE AND ABUSES THAT HAVE BROUGHT THIS ABOUT. SHE NOTED THAT THE PARTICIPANTS IN THIS INDUSTRY MADE THEIR OWN CHOICE AND FURTHER NOTED THAT THE LIQUOR INDUSTRY ALREADY MAINTAINS LONGER HOURS THAN MOST RETAIL ESTABLISHMENTS AS THEY CAN BE OPEN IS HOURS A DAY, EXCEPT ON SUNDAYS. SHE FELT THIS INDUSTRY WILL JUST HAVE TO ADJUST TO RISING COSTS AS OTHER HAVE HAD TO. COMMISSIONER Loy THEN DISCUSSED THE GROWTH OF THIS PARTICULAR INDUSTRY IN SPITE OF ALL THE REGULATIONS AND NOTED THAT ATTORNEY BLOCK INFORMED THE BOARD THAT THIS INDUSTRY IS USED TO MAKING A 15 TO 18% PROFIT, WHICH MOST BUSINESSES WOULD GLORY IN. SHE SPOKE OF THE GREAT COST TO TAXPAYERS FOR MENTAL HEALTH, DETOX, REHABILITATION, ETC, COMMISSIONER Loy QUOTED FIGURES FROM A HIGHWAY PATROL REPORT SHOWING THAT. FROM .JANUARY TO NOVEMBER OF THIS YEAR THERE WERE 13 ACCIDENTS IN THIS COUNTY AFTER MIDNIGHT, SIX OF WHICH INVOLVED ALCOHOL. IN REGARD TO TOURISM, COMMISSIONER LOY NOTED THAT THIS AREA HAS DISTINGUISHED ITSELF AS A CLEAN, WHOLESOME COUNTY, AND MANY HAVE RETURNED AND MADE THIS THEIR HOME BECAUSE THEY WERE PLEASED TO FIND A PLACE THAT DID NOT THRIVE ON LATE NIGHT ENTERTAINMENT. SHE FURTHER POINTED OUT THAT THE RAMADA INN PROVIDED ENTERTAINMENT, AND IT WAS NOT SUPPORTED BY EITHER THE RESIDENTS OR THE TOURISTS. COMMISSIONER Loy CONTINUED THAT A MAJORITY OF THE PETITIONERS COME FROM MUNICIPALITIES OVER WHICH WE HAVE NO CONTROL, AND POINTED OUT THAT WE HAVE HAD NO WORD FROM ANY OF THE MUNICIPALITIES WHICH WOULD BE AFFECTED BY SUCH A CHANGE. COMMISSIONER Loy STATED SHE FELT THE PETITIONERS HAVE RECEIVED A FULL HEARING, AND SHE BELIEVES WE SHOULD ADHERE TO THE PRESENT CLOSING HOUR. COMMISSIONER DEESON NOTED THAT WE ARE ADDRESSING AN INDUSTRY INVOLVING APPROXIMATELY 800 EMPLOYEES, WHICH HE POINTED OUT REPRESENTS LESS THAN 2% OF OUR COUNTY'S POPULATION. HE FELT WE MUST CONSIDER THE OTHER 98% THAT MAY BE AFFECTED BY THE USE OF ALCOHOL. HE CONTINUED THAT THE INDUSTRY `S PROBLEM MAY NOT BE THE LACK OF HOURS, BUT POSSIBLY THE PRUBLEM OF SUPPLY AND DEMAND BECAUSE THERE MAY BE TOO MANY BARS, COM- MISSIONER DEESON STATED HE FELT WE SHOULD DO WHAT IS BEST FOR OUR COMMUN- ITY AND VOTE AGAINST THE EXTENSION. I arc 319W pw 449 y CHAIRMAN WODTKE STATED HE APPRECIATED ALL THE TESTIMONY PRE- SENTED, AND HE IS TRYING TO SORT IT.OUT AND LOOK AT WHAT THE PROBLEM' REALLY IS. HE FELT WE ARE ALL RELIGIOUS -PEOPLE AND NOTED THAT HE HAS BEEN INVOLVED WITH MENTAL HEALTH AND DEALT WITH PROBLEMS BROUGHT ABOUT BY ALCOHOLISM, AND HE PERSONALLY WISHES 18 YEAR OLDS WERE NOT ALLOWED TO DRINK. BUT THAT IS THE LAW, MANY PEOPLE WISH ALCOHOL WAS NOT A LEGAL SUBSTANCE AND COULD NOT BE SOLD, BUT -IT CAN. IN REGARD TO THE EXTENSION OF ONE HOUR, HE DID NOT FEEL HE HAD HEARD ANY TESTIMONY PROVING THAT IT WILL OR WILL NOT CAUSE MORE ALCOHOLISM. HE NOTED THAT MANY PEOPLE WHO ARE AT LOUNGES AT 1:00 A.M. DRINK COKE AND GO THERE FOR ENTERTAINMENT AND TO DANCE. THE CHAIRMAN CONTINUED.THAT HE DOES NOT SEE WHERE ONE HOUR WILL MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE, BUT HE DEFINITELY DOES FEEL THAT IT WOULD NOT BE GOOD FOR THE COUNTY TO HAVE A 2:00 A.M. CLOSING AND THE MUNICIPALITIES 1:00 A.M. CHAIRMAN WODTKE THEN ASKED WHAT THE.OTHER MEMBERS OF THE BOARD WOULD FEEL ABOUT HAVING A 2:00 A.M: CLOSING ON FRIDAY AND SATURDAY NIGHTS ONLY AND ON NEW YEARS EVE. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT FELT WE WOULD NOT BE FACING THE ISSUE BY DOING THAT, BUT NOTED THAT HE IS CONCERNED ABOUT THE MUNICIPALITIES AND FELT ANYTHING WE DO SHOULD BE CONTINGENT ON LIKE ACTION, AT LEAST BY THE CITY OF VERO BEACH. ATTORNEY COLLINS NOTED THAT AN ORDINANCE DOES NOT -BECOME EFFEC- TIVE UNTIL APPROVED BY THE BOARD AND MAILED TO THE SECRETARY OF STATE, AND HE FELT AN ORDINANCE COULD BE APPROVED AND THEN NOT MAILED FOR A PERIOD OF TIME, BUT HE WOULD HAVE A PROBLEM WITH AN ORDINANCE BEING MADE CONTINGENT ON ACTION BY OTHERS. AFTER FURTHER DISCUSSION, MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER Loy, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DEESON, THAT THE REQUEST AS PRESENTED BY ATTORNEY BLOCK REPRESENTING THE RETAIL LIQUOR ASSOCIATION BE DENIED AND AN ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED SETTING FORTH THE EXACT SAME HOURS AS ARE PRES- ENTLY ADHERED TO IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREAS OF THE COUNTY, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF NEW YEARS EVE AND THAT HOUR BE ESTABLISHED AT 2:00 O'CLOCK A.M. NO MATTER WHAT DAY OF THE WEEK IT FALLS ON. COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER STATED HE WOULD VOTE AGAINST THIS MOTION AS HE FEELS THERE IS A REALISTIC PROBLEM OF PEOPLE DRIVING TO OTHER COUNTIES BECAUSE OF THEIR LATER HOURS. DEC 2 01977 L- v BOOK 39 FAGF 450 COMMISSIONER DEESON DID NOT FEEL THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER DOING THIS, BUT COMMISSIONER SIEBERT FELT THERE IS A -VERY SIGNIFI- CANT NUMBER, ESPECIALLY ON STATE ROAD AIA.:.: HE NOTED THAT TWO OF THE ACCIDENTS EARLIER REFERRED TO OCCURRED WHEN PEOPLE WERE RETURNING TO VERO BEACH AFTER DRINKING IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY. THE CHAIRMAN CALLED FOR THE QUESTION. AYES: COMMISSIONER Loy NAYES: PHAIRMAN MMISSIONER SCHMUCKER OMMISSIONER DEESON MMISSION�V ER SIEBERT WODTKE THE MOTION WAS DEFEATED. MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER TO EXTEND THE BAR HOURS ONE HALF HOUR FROM .THE WAY THE SCHEDULE IS PRESENTLY SET UP. MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF A SECOND. MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SIEBERT, SECONDED BY COMMIS- SIONER SCHMUCKER, THAT AN ORDINANCE BE DRAWN UP ESTABLISHING A 2:00 A.M. CLOSING FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF ;INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, IN ACCORD- ANCE WITH THE PRESENT SCHEDULE, AND THAT ORDINANCE NOT BE FORWARDED TO THE SECRETARY OF STATE UNTIL WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO SEE WHAT ACTION THE MUNICIPALITIES WILL BE TAKING. ATTORNEY COLLINS STATED HE WOULD PREFER TO SEE SOME KIND OF AFFIRMATIVE ACTION. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT REITERATED THAT HE FEELS HAVING A 2:00 A.M. CLOSING IN THE COUNTY AND NOT IN VERO BEACH WOULD CAUSE A GREAT PROBLEM, COMMISSIONER LOY FELT SUCH A MOTION WOULD PUT GREAT PRESSURE ON THE MUNICIPALITIES. CHAIRMAN WODTKE STATED HE FELT WE MUST TAKE POSITIVE ACTION ONE WAY OR ANOTHER. COMMISSIONER SIEBERT SUGGESTED PUTTING AN EFFECTIVE DATE OF .JANUARY 31ST ON THE ORDINANCE, WHICH HE FELT WOULD ALLOW AMPLE TIME FOR THE CITY TO REACT, BUT THE ATTORNEY DID NOT FEEL THAT WOULD ALLOW SUFFI- CIENT TIME. AFTER FURTHER DISCUSSION, COMMISSIONER SIEBERT WITHDREW HIS MOTION AND COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER WITHDREW HIS SECOND, CHAIRMAN WODTKE AGAIN BROUGHT UP THE POSSIBILITY OF HAVING A 2:00 A.M. CLOSING JUST -ON FRIDAY AND SATURDAY NIGHTS. 10 DEC 20 1977 BOOK 39 pAu 451 IF ON MOTION MADE BY COMMISSIONER SIEBERT,SECONDED BY COMMIS- SIONER Loy, THE BOARD UNANIMOUSLY REOPENED THE'PUBLIC HEARING to ASK. THE BAR OWNERS THEIR OPINION OF CHAIRMAN WODTKEIS SUGGESTION. CHAIRMAN WODTKE ASKED ATTORNEY BLOCK TO RESPOND FOR THE RETAIL LIQUOR ASSOCIATION.. ATTORNEY BLOCK SAID HE FELT THIS IS AN UNFAIR REQUEST AS' -THERE ARE ONLY ONE OR TWO OWNERS PRESENT AND IN ORDER TO ANSWER THE QUESTION, HE WOULD HAVE TO CONTACT ALL THE OWNERS. HE POINTED OUT THAT THE BAR OWNERS FELT THEY WERE HONESTLY ASKING FOR WHAT THEY REALLY NEED AND THAT IT IS A REALISTIC REQUEST. OTHER THAN THAT, HE STATED HE COULD NOT ANSWER THE CHAIRMAN'S QUESTION. ON MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DEESON, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER toy, THE BOARD UNANIMOUSLY CLOSED THE PUBLIC HEARING. REV. DICK STEVENS ASKED IF ANYTHING IS CONSIDERED OTHER THAN WHAT WAS ADVERTISED, ISN IT IT NECESSARY TO HAVE A WHOLE NEW PUBLIC HEARING: ATTORNEY COLLINS ANSWERED THAT EVERYTHING THE BOARD HAS CON- SIDERED IS WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE ADVERTISEMENT. JOHN DEAN REQUESTED TO BE ALLOWED TO SPEAK AND NOTED THAT ON THE WEEKENDS THE EXTRA HOUR COULD MEAN POSSIBLY $100.00 A NIGHT, WHICH HE FIGURED WOULD ADD UP TO AROUND $15,000 A YEAR, HE FELT THIS IS A VALID ALTERNATIVE AND SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AS SUCH. COMMISSIONER LOY NOTED THAT IF THE COUNTY EXTENDS THE HOURS AND THE CITY DOES NOT CONCUR, THE COUNTY WILL BE IN A POSITION OF WANTING TO GO BACK. SHE FELT IT HAS BEEN DEMONSTRATED THAT THE VOTES ARE HERE IF THE CITY WISHES TO MAKE A.CHANGE, BUT FELT IF WE TAKE POSITIVE ACTION, IT WILL EXERT UNDUE PRESSURE, COMMISSIONER SIEBERT DID NOT FEEL THERE WOULD BE ANY LESS PRESSURE WHETHER WE TOOK ACTION OR NOT. MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SIEBERT TO ADOPT AN ORDINANCE EXTENDING THE HOURS FOR DISPENSING OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES ONE HOUR. MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF A SECOND, MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER, SECONDED BY COMMIS- SIONER SIEBERT TO EXTEND THE HOURS FOR DISPENSING OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES s IV �UOI� T2 PmE 452 A ONE ADDITIONAL HOUR ON FRIDAYS AND SATURDAYS AND LEAVE THE -OTHER HOURS THE SAME, EXCEPT NEW YEARS EVE. COMMISSIONER Loy POINTED OUT THAT'THIS IS NOT WHAT THE PETI- TIONERS ARE REQUESTING, THE CHAIRMAN CALLED FOR THE QUESTION AYES: EHAIRMAN OMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER NAYES: COMMISSIONER DEESON WODTKEPOMMISSIONER MMISSIONER Loy SIEBERT THE MOTION WAS DEFEATED. COMMISSIONER Loy SUGGESTED LEAVING THE HOURS EXACTLY AS THEY ARE NOW BECAUSE IF THE MUNICIPALITIES WANT TO CHANGE, THEY WILL KNOW THE VOTES ARE HERE. DISCUSSION CONTINUED IN REGARD TO THE VARIOUS ALTERNATIVES, AND IT WAS FELT AN IMPASSE HAD BEEN REACHED. ATTORNEY COLLINS NOTED THAT ANOTHER MOTION COULD BE MADE OR THERE COULD BE A MOTION TO ADJOURN, BUT HE FELT THE MATTER SHOULD BE RESOLVED AT THIS MEETING. MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER TO TABLE ACTION ON THE PUBLIC HEARING FOR THIRTY DAYS, MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF A SECOND. MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER TO EXTEND THE CLOSING HOURS BY ONE HALF HOUR. MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF A SECOND. AFTER FURTHER DISCUSSION, MOTION WAS MADE BY COMMISSIONER SIEBERT, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER, TO ADOPT RESOLUTION N0. 77- 126, TO BE DRAWN UP BY ATTORNEY COLLINS, INFORMING THE MUNICIPALITIES OF OUR INTENTION TO EXTEND BAR HOURS FOR ONE HOUR AND INTENTION TO TAKE FINAL ACTION ON FEBRUARY 22, 1978. ATTORNEY COLLINS EXPLAINED THAT THIS RESOLUTION IS, IN EFFECT, MERELY A COMMUNICATION FROM ONE GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY TO ANOTHER. THE CHAIRMAN CALLED FOR THE QUESTION. AYES: COMMISSIONER SCHMUCKER NAYES: COMMISSIONER Loy EOMMISSIONER SIEBERT OMMISSIONER DEESON HAIRMAN WODTKE THE MOTION CARRIED. RESOLUTION N0. 77-126 WILL BE MADE A PART OF THE MINUTES WHEN PREPARED.' 12 a ON MOTION MADE BY COMMISSIONER SIEBERT ;SECONDED BY COMMIS SIONER SCHMUCKER, THE BOARD UNANIMOUSLY AUTHORIZED ADVERTISING A PUBLIC HEARING IN REGARD TO A BAR HOURS ORDINANCE FOR FEBRUARY 22, 1978. THERE BEING NO FURTHER BUSINESS, ON MOTION MADE, SECONDED AND CARRIED, THE BOARD ADJOURNED AT 5:30 O'CLOCK P.M. ATTEST: CLERK CHAIRMAN 13 DEC 201977 806W 32 wF-454 mi