Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout03/14/2017ER e 0010 ORIP tN' COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FLORIDA COMMISSION AGENDA TUESDAY, MARCH 14, 2017 - 9:00 AM Commission Chambers Indian River County Administration Complex 180127th Street, Building A Vero Beach, Florida, 32960-3388 www.ircgov.com Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman, District 2 Jason E. Brown, County Administrator Peter D. O'Bryan, Vice Chairman, District 4 Dylan Reingold, County Attorney Susan Adams, District I Jeffrey R Smith, Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller Bob Solari, District 5 Tim Zorc, District 3 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. INVOCATION Mr. Philip Katrovitz, Humanist of the Treasure Coast 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Commissioner Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman 4. ADDITIONS/DELETIONS TO THE AGENDA / EMERGENCY ITEMS 5. PROCLAMATIONS and PRESENTATIONS 5.A Presentation of Proclamation Honoring Sharon Hammond on Her Retirement from the Property Appraiser's Office 5.11 Presentation of Proclamation Designating the Day of April 4, 2017, as Equal Pay Day 5.0 Presentation of Proclamation Indian River County Celebrating Children's Week 5.1) Presentation of Proclamation Designating the Month of March, 2017, as American Red Cross Month 5.E Presentation by Larry Boan, Pastor, Central Assembly, on March 16th Event to Honor Indian River County's First Responders 6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES March 14, 2017 Page 1 of 4 7. INFORMATION ITEMS FROM STAFF OR COMMISSIONERS NOT REQUIRING BOARD ACTION 7.A Be part of the Treasure Coast Regional Household Travel Survey. Sign up to Receive your one -day Household Travel Log. 7.11 Proclamation and Retirement Award Honoring Roger D. Coffman on His Retirement From Indian River County Board of County Commissioners Department of General Services/Parks Division with Fifteen Years of Service 7.0 Beach and Shores Preservation Advisory Committee Chair and Vice -Chair 8. CONSENT AGENDA &A Checks and Electronic Payments February 24, 2017 to March 2, 2017 8.B Resolutions Canceling Taxes on Properties Dedicated to the City of Fellsmere for Public Purposes 8.0 Denis and Jennifer Manelski's Request for Release of Easements at 1925 Sears Cove (Sears Cove Subdivision) 8.1) Work Order No. 1 to Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc., 66th Avenue Right-of-way Mapping & Surveying (57th Street - 85th Street) Indian River County Project No. 1505 8.E Work Order No. 15 CB&I Coastal Planning and Engineering, Inc. Sector 3 Beach Restoration Project, 2017 Post Construction Physical Monitoring Services 9. CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS and GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES 10. PUBLIC ITEMS A. PUBLIC HEARINGS 10.A.1 Proposed GoLine Route Changes Associated with the Opening of the New Main Transit Hub (Legislative) 10.A.2 Collier Creek Estates Subdivision Petition Water Assessment Project Utility Phases 1, IA and 1B (UCP) 4125, Public Hearing and the Adoption of Resolution No. III (Legislative) B. PUBLIC DISCUSSION ITEMS C. PUBLIC NOTICE ITEMS 10.C.1 Notice of Public Hearing for March 21, 2017: Florida Power & Light Company's Request for Special Exception Use Approval for a Private Heavy Utility (Solar Energy Center) [SP -SE -17-03-01 / 2016110089-78358] (Quasi -Judicial) 11. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR MATTERS ILA Offer to Purchase 16th Street Ballfields 12. DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS March 14, 2017 Page 2 of 4 March 14, 2017 Page 3 of 4 A. Community Development B. Emergency Services C. General Services 1. Human Services 2. Sandridge Golf Club 3. Recreation D. Human Resources E. Office of Management and Budget 12.E.1 Children's Services Funding Allocation for Fiscal Year 2017/2018 F. Public Works G. Utilities Services 13. COUNTY ATTORNEY MATTERS 14. COMMISSIONERS MATTERS A. Commissioner Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman B. Commissioner Peter D. O'Brvan, Vice Chairman C. Commissioner Susan Adams D. Commissioner Bob Solari E. Commissioner Tim Zorc 15. SPECIAL DISTRICTS AND BOARDS A. Emergency Services District B. Solid Waste Disposal District C. Environmental Control Board 16. ADJOURNMENT March 14, 2017 Page 3 of 4 Except for those matters specifically exempted under the State Statute and Local Ordinance, the Board shall provide an opportunity for public comment prior to the undertaking by the Board of any action on the agenda, including those matters on the Consent Agenda. Public comment shall also be heard on any proposition which the Board is to take action which was either not on the Board agenda or distributed to the public prior to the commencement of the meeting. Anyone who may wish to appeal any decision which may be made at this meeting will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Anyone who needs a special accommodation for this meeting may contact the County's Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Coordinator at (772) 226-1223 at least 48 hours in advance of meeting. Anyone who needs special accommodation with a hearing aid for this meeting may contact the Board of County Commission Office at 772-226-1490 at least 20 hours in advance of the meeting. The full agenda is available on line at the Indian River County Website at www.ircgov.com The full agenda is also available for review in the Board of County Commission Office, the Indian River County Main Library, and the North County Library. Commission Meetings are broadcast live on Comcast Cable Channel 27 Rebroadcasts continuously with the following proposed schedule: Tuesday at 6:00 p.m. until Wednesday at 6:00 a.m., Wednesday at 9:00 a.m. until 5:00 p.m., Thursday at 1:00 p.m. through Friday Morning, and Saturday at 12:00 Noon to 5:00 p.m. March 14, 2017 Page 4 of 4 PROCLAMATION SQ HONORING SHARON HAMMOND ON HER RETIREMENT FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S OFFICE OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY WHEREAS, Sharon Hammond will retire from the Property Appraiser's Office of Indian River County effective, March 17, 2017; and, WHEREAS, she has been employed with the Property Appraiser's Office of Indian River County since April 15, 1985, and has continued in the capacity of Real Estate Appraiser until her retirement; and previously, starting in May, 1982, with Indian River County Clerk of the Circuit Court in their Recording Department; and, WHEREAS, she has served this County and the Public with distinction and selflessness. During her years of service, she was dedicated to her work and was greatly appreciated by Property Appraiser, David C. Nolte, and her co-workers alike. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board applauds her efforts on behalf of the Property Appraiser's Office, and the Board wishes to express their appreciation for the dedicated service she has given to Indian River County for the last thirty-five years; and BE IT FURTHER PROCLAMIED that the Board of County Commissioners and staff extend heartfelt wishes for success in her future endeavors! Adopted this 141h day of March, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA P1 PROCLAMATION 518 DESIGNATING THE DAY OF APRIL 4, 2017, AS EQUAL PAY DAY WHEREAS, more than 50 years after the passage of the Equal Pay Act, women, especially minority women, continue to suffer the consequences of unequal pay; and, WHEREAS, according to the US Census Bureau, women working full time, year round in 2015 typically earned 21 % of what men earned, indicating little change or progress in pay equity; and, WHEREAS, in 2009, the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act was signed into law, which gives back to employees their day in court to challenge a pay gap, and now we must pass the Paycheck Fairness Act, which would amend the Equal Pay Act by closing loopholes and improving the law's effectiveness; and, WHEREAS, according to one estimate, college-educated women working full time earn more than a half million dollars less than their male peers .do over the course of a lifetime; and WHEREAS, nearly four in 10 mothers are primary breadwinners in their households, and nearly two-thirds are primary or significant earners, making pay equity critical to families' economic security; and, WHEREAS, according to The Fight for Pay Equity. A State Roadmap for Florida, published by AAUW and updated in September, 2015, median earnings for men in Florida were $40,971 compared to $34,768 for women — an earnings ratio of just 85%, or 6th out of all states and the District of Columbia; and, WHEREAS, fair pay strengthens the security of families today and eases future retirement costs while enhancing the American economy; and WHEREAS, Tuesday, April 4, 2017, symbolizes the time in 2017 when the wages paid to American women catch up to the wages paid to men from the previous year. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, INDIAN 141VER COUNTY, FLORIDA that the day of April 4, 2017, be designated as Equal Pay Day in Indian River County and the Board encourages all citizens to recognize the full value of women's skills and contributions to the labor force and to further encourage businesses to conduct an internal pay evaluation and to ensure women are being paid fairly and equally. Adopted this 14th day of March, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA Bob Solari Ti P2 sc PROCLAMATION Indian River County Celebrating Children's Week WHEREAS, the 22nd Annual Children's Week celebrating Parents and Children will take place in Tallahassee from March 26 to March 31, 2047, bringing thousands of parents, children, professionals, policy makers, and community leaders together to share valuable knowledge and information about children's issues across the state and in our Capital City; and, WHEREAS, the purpose of Children's Week is to create a shared vision of the State of Florida's commitment to its children and families, and to engage a long-term process to develop and implement strategies; and, WHEREAS, the Children's Week Committee has teamed up with statewide businesses and non-profit organizations, including the Early Learning Coalition of Indian River, Martin, and Okeechobee Counties, Camelot Community Care, Devereux CBC, Guardian ad Litem, and other local organizations to expand the network of community involvement on a wide array of children and family issues at the local level. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that March 26 — 31, 2017, be recognized and hereby declared as "Children's Week" in Indian River County. Adopted this 14th day of March 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA a.�'dw - eph E. Flescher, Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan, Vice C airman ,.-„ Bob Solari Tim Zor<___() P3 PROCLAMATION 6-0 Designating the Month of March 2017, as AMERICAN RED CROSS MONTH WHEREAS, Indian River County has a long history of helping our neighbors in need. American Red Cross Month is a special time to recognize and thank our heroes — those Red Cross volunteers and donors who give of their time and resources to help community members; and WHEREAS, these heroes help families find shelter after a home fire. They give blood to help trauma victims and cancer patients. They deliver comfort items to military members in the hospital. They use their lifesaving skills to save someone from a heart attack, drowning or choking. They enable children around the globe to be vaccinated against measles and rubella; and WHEREAS, the American Red Cross depends on local heroes to deliver help and hope during a disaster. We applaud our heroes here in Indian River County who give of themselves to assist their neighbors when they need a helping hand; and WHEREAS, across the country and around the world, the American Red Cross responds to disasters big and small. In fact, every eight minutes the organization responds to a community disaster, providing shelter, food, emotional support and other necessities to those affected. It collects nearly 40 percent of the nation's blood supply; provides 24-hour support to military members, veterans and their families; teaches millions lifesaving skills, such as lifeguarding and CPR; and through its Restoring Family Links program, connects family members separated by crisis, conflict or migration; and WHEREAS, the month of March is dedicated to all those who support the American Red Cross mission in preventing and alleviating human suffering in the face of emergencies. Our community depends on the American Red Cross, which relies on donations of time, money and blood to fulfill its humanitarian mission. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that the month of March, 2017, be designated as American Red Cross Month in Indian River County, and the Board encourages all citizens to support this organization and its noble humanitarian mission. Adopted this 14th day of March, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER BOUNTY, FLORIDA D. O'Bryan, Bob Solari Tim Zorc 0 To P4 qFree 0 H DD C:))` 2 SS1017 C�N�L°3L°3�C�G�HC� M/%H(R/%n F&RU--Jv Friday MAY 19th 5:30-9:30 pm Corporate Air Hangar 3450 Airport West Drive Vero Beach Airport LIVE Music! GREAT Food! FAMILY Fun! 43 J!O UU A century of Service American Recd Crass I'Iorida's Coast to Heartland Chapter Information & Sponsorships call Sarah Ruwe @ 772-562-2549 4A-, 5-D. American [fed Cross Florida's Coast to Coast Chapter Learn more about becoming a Red Cross Volunteer at Redcross.org Or call (772) 562-2549 American Red Cross in Indian River County Fiscal Year 2017 24 Disaster Action Team Responses to Home Fires 465 Home Fire Campaign 10 -Yr Smoke Alarm Installs 101 Pillow Case Project Student Contacts S.P • `�A- Z �C C Grand Pavillon Y rraod Rd C � , Riverside Park Or, Vero Beach, FL a Rd m p 32953 Directions Save aim Rd t` 5.0***** 2 reviews Cypress Rd K ®B View larger map $anyan Rd P }09 Park Acacia Rd O verside Beachland Blvd Merril p 8a_rlaer•8ridg?.—� �hildr �� eatreo a tita Azalea Ln [j Grand Pavilion o U Riverside Park Vero Beach Humiston Park Lifegua Museum of Art Flamevrne Ln veterans Gardens Ln Gayfeather Ln Menioira► honeysuckle Ln fsfen`d I irbiscus Ln Ins Ln Sanctuary Sea9u� R•- -n. r Crt" % Riorna: Ur + �orsu l r. harmed Bur If 2� c%. _ Caoogle� ,�hL r C�� _,a X o i L•oogfe • Map dati + i Google . Terms of use Repon a map error P5 -6F> Save the Date EQUAL PAY DAY Tuesday, April 4 The Florida Young Democrats of Indian River Stand in solidarity with The Board of County Commissioners of Indian River Country Together, we recognize the Gender Pay Gap and the full value of women's skills and contributions to the labor force locally, nationally, and worldwide. Find on Facebook or email 1l •mOn�er�rg cn.,..r s�nct %c21 The Fight for Pay Equity: A Federal Road Map Updated February 2017 513 3-w11 In 2015, US. women working full time, year-round were paid just 80 percent of US. men's median earnings - a gap of 20 percent. While a portion of this gap can be explained by various factors, an apples -to -apples comparison looking at workers one year out of college and controlling for factors known to affect earnings, such as major, occupation, and hours worked reveals there is still an unexplainable 7 percent gender.pay gap. Despite this persistent gap, the Equal Pay Act has not been updated since 1963. Immediate legislative and executive action is needed to enable women to bring home the pay they have rightfully earned. 514 issue executive orders and memoranda expanding pay equity protections. President Barack Obama signed several orders to address gaps in federal equal pay protections - thereby protecting segments of the civilian workforce from pay discrimination despite congressional gridlock. ❑Preserve regulations enforcing executive actions. The final regulations issued by agencies to protect workers must be maintained and actively implemented. Q Prohibit retaliation against employees of federal contractors who talk about their salary with their co-workers 0 Collect summary pay data by gender, race and ethnicity through the EEO -1 form (begins March 2018) D Require federal contractors to disclose labor law violations (Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces Order) 0 Ensure more salaried employees receive appropriate overtime pay (Overtime Rule) ❑Pass federal bills advancing pay equity. Congress must take action to dose the gender pay gap by passing legislation that will enable all women to take home a fair paycheck. The Paycheck Fawriess Act would protect workers by dosing loopholes in the Equal Pay Act of 1963 0 The Pay Equity for All Act would prohibit employers from asking about salary history before making a job offer 13The Fair Pay Act would require employers to provide equal pay for work of equal value (comparable worth) Florida: Tell your member of Congress you want fair pay! Member of Congress* District Men Women Earnings Ratio** Rank- ing in State *** Member of Congress* District Men Women Earnings Ratio** Rank- ing in State *** Gaetz (R) FLA $41,764 $32,942 78.9% 26 Ross (R) FL -15 $45,2071$36,439 80.6% 24 Dunn (R) FL -2 $40,764 $34,431 84.5% 17 Buchanan (R) FL -16 $42,757 $36,378 85.1% 1 15 Yoho (R) FL -3 $42,142 $36,968 87.7% 8 Rooney, T (R) FL -17 $39,134 $31,726 81.1%1 23 Rutherford (R) FLA $46,514 $38,506 82.8% 21 Mast (R) FL -18 $45,362 $37,093 81.8% 22 Lawson (D) FL -5 $32,359 $29,565 91.4% 5 Rooney, F (R) FL -19 J$40,456 $36,316 89.8% 6 DeSantis (R) FL -6 J$44,479 $35,461 79.7% 25 Hastings (D) FL -20 $32,189 $31,118 96.7% 2 Murphy (D) FL -7 $45,994 $40,132 87.3% 10 Frankel (D) FL -21 $50,071 $41,612 83.1% 19 Posey (R) FL -8 $44,745 $34,869 77.9% 27 Deutch (D) FL -22 $48,349 $41,129 85.1% 15 Soto (D) FL -9 $36,228 $31,462 86.90A 12 Wasserman Schultz (D) FL -23 $46,723 $41,382 88.6% 7 Demings (D) FL -10 $42,061 $36,549 86.9% 11 Wilson (D) FL -24 $35,917 $31,004 86.3% 13 Webster (R) FL -11 $36,431 $31,837 87.4% 9 Diaz-Balart (R) FL -2-5 $38,420 $31,842 82.9% 20 Bilirakis (R) FL -12 $47,465 $39,768 83.8% 18 Curbelo (R) FL -26 $35,571 $35,319 99.3% 1 Crist (D) FL -13 $42,053 $39,048 92.9% 3 Ros-Lehtinen (R) FL -271$35,9231$30,978186.2% 14 Castor (D) FL -14 $39,756 $36,782 92.5% 4 "'rhe above co gression/ daft1s represent the 115th Congress -"The pay gap figures are from 2015 the mast recently available data. 'The congressional districts are ranked from smatlest gAp to laniest AAUW - 1310 L St. NW, Washington, DC 20005 - www.aauw.org - www.fightforfairpay.org - 202.785.7793 AAU emDe..enrg .!Omen sync_ E.'.El The Fight for Pay Equity: A State Road Map for @ Median earnings for men in Florida were $41,105 compared to $35,604 for women — an earnings ratio of just 87 percent, or 3rd out of all states and the District of Columbia. The gap is worse for women of color and moms. Compared to white men's wages, in Florida Asian American women are paid 74 percent,! African American women are paid 61 percent, Native American women are paid 65 percent, and Hispanic and Latina women take home just 59 percent. As efforts stall at the federal level, states can enact legislation to help women and families at the local leve!. AAUW Member Engagement. AAUW members care about equal pay and have tools from AAUW to make progress on state equal pay laws! Equal Pay. Employers must provide men and women with equal pay for equal work. [3Cover All Employees. Public, private, and small business employers are all covered, no exceptions for those covered by the federal Fair Labor Standards Act. DOffer Protections. Protect employees from intentional and unintentional discrimination. 0 Employer can't retaliate or discriminate against individuals involved in legal proceedings to enforce the law 0 No retaliation or discrimination against employees who discuss their wages Q State contractors must comply with nondiscrimination laws Q Employers can't reduce another employee's pay to comply with the law Q Pay discrimination hotline Employers can't request salary history 0 Employers must post a salary range in job advertisements 0 Employers can't provide less favorable career opportunities or tracking based on sex (mommy tracking) [3CIarify Employer Defenses. Employer defenses should be well -tailored and narrow to ensure pay disparities only exist in appropriate situations. 0 Employer defenses must be job-related, a business necessity, and not based on a sex -based differential Q Defense does not apply if there is an attemative employment practice available Q Agreement for lesser wage is not a defense [3Establish Strong Legal Procedures and Remedies. Appropriate protections will incentivize employers to pay an equal wage to begin with in order to avoid litigation. 0 Employer is liable for damages Q Class actions or joint claims permitted ElAttorney's fees, experts' costs, and other litigation costs covered by employer Q High fines act as a deterrent; increased fines for employers who have multiple violations [37hke Preemptive Action. Employers and the state must act to investigate and close the pay gap. Q Employers must keep records of wages 0 state provides education programs on pay disparity Q State collects and publishes data on the pay gap from all employers Q State creates an advisory committee on pay equity Comparable Worth. Employers must compensate men and women equally for jobs that are comparable but not identical and provide guidelines for designating jobs as dominated by one sex, race, or national origin. To learn more, contact AAUW Public Policy and Government Relations staff: 202.785.7793, @AAUWPolicy, advocacy@aauw.ore, or visit www.aauw.ore/resource/state-equal-pay-laws. AAUW .(2016).TheSfmpfe TruMabMMe GendefftYCW.'v 2auw.orgJresearch/the.simoie-troth-about-the-eender-pay.Tho pay Bapis the difference M man's and women's twicaleamirtm usuaft neiortad as eMterthe eaminp raft between men and women or as an actual pay gap. The median value is the middle value, with equal numbers of full-time workers earning more and earning less. len 2015. median annual aamkngs In the US. for women end men working full time year-round ween W,742 and 553,212, respectively. r Wsaggregating the data whin the Asian American and Pacific Islander aommunhy reveals that wM a some woman are among the highest paid workers, mostethnkMes experience much laW pay gaps. ?.s Equal pay or employment discrimination law All or most employees covered No retallatlon/discrimination for Involvementln legal proceedings No dtscriminatlon/retallatlon for discussing wages State contractors must comply with nondiscrimination laws Can't reduce another employee's pay to comply with law Pay discrimination hotline No salary history required Employment listings must Include salary range Can't provide less favorable career opportunities or tracking based on sex Clarified employer defenses for pay differences Consider alternative employment practices that avoid pay disparity Agreement to a lesser wage Is not a defense Employer liable for damages �o Allow for a class action lawsult or clalms to be Joined Employer liable for costs and reasonable attorney's fees penalties for multiple violations 131 1 Employers must keep records of wages -I I I State education programs on pay disparity p State collects and publishes data on pay gap from all employers State advisory committee on pay equity Comparable worth law Guidelines for designating Jobs as ++ dominated by one sex, race, or national origin Senator Linda Stewart 0District 13 Contact: Matt Alford Alford.Matt@flsenate.gov 850-487-5013 a' Representative Janet Cruz District 62 Contact: Carlos Ramos Carlos.Ramos@myfloridahouse.gov 850-717-5062 Representative Lori Berman District 90 Contact: Abby Ross Abby.Ross@myfloridahouse.gov 850-717-5090 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE January 20, 2017 SENATOR LINDA STEWART, HOUSE DEMOCRATIC LEADER JANET CRUZ AND REPRESENTATIVE LORI BERMAN PROPOSE BILL TO ELIMINATE THE GENDER PAY GAP TALLAHASSEE — State Senator Linda Stewart (D -Orlando), House Democratic Leader Janet Cruz (D -Tampa) and Representative Lori Berman (D -Lantana) today filed Senate Bill 410 and House Bill 319, jointly named the Helen Gordon Davis Fair Pay Act, aimed at closing the gender pay gap in Florida. The bills seek to close the pervasive gender pay gap by updating and clarifying Florida's current law to ban employers from paying workers differently based on sex or gender identity. On average, women in Florida take home only 87 cents for every dollar earned by men. "It is unconscionable that in America today women continue to be paid less for the same amount of work as men," declared House. Democratic Leader Janet Cruz. "Our nation was founded on the ideal that all of us are created equal and that ought to hold in all facets of our lives. Paying people fairly for the work they do shouldn't depend on their gender, but rather on the quality of their work." Additionally, SB 410 and HB 319 delineates which reasons employers can use to pay employees differently – things like education, skill -set, and experience. By clarifying these reasons, employers can avoid costly litigation and be clear about which attributes are valued. Moreover, the bills would prohibit "mommy tracking," ensuring that women (and men) are not forced into lower tracks of employment based on assumptions. It would bar employers from inquiring about or screening employees based on their prior salary history – a practice we know can introduce unintended discrimination into the hiring process. It would also increase civil penalties for a violation, thus motivating employers to do the right thing. 2-5 ;4 "I'm honored to be a part of this fight. Reducing an entire group of Floridians take home pay not only hurts their families, but it hurts Florida's economy as a whole. Those groups most affected by this — the single mother; a family stricken by illness or unemployment or tragedy that relies on a female breadwinner; those Floridians whose gender identity isn't even recognized anywhere in our state laws; they deserve policies and protections that reflect the reality of their everyday existence. That's why we need this bill. That's why we were elected to serve," proclaimed Senator Linda Stewart. Efforts to close the gender pay gap are both popular and necessary. Despite having federal legislation on the books since 1963, the .gender wage gap .persists. According to the The American Association of University Women (AAUW) of Florida, over a lifetime of work (47 years), the total estimated loss of earnings of women compared with men is $700,000 for a high school graduate, $1.2 million for a college graduate and $2 million for a professional school graduate. "I am proud and honored to file this legislation along with Senator Stewart and Democratic Leader Cruz. Leader Cruz has championed this bill for 5 years and I have always supported her efforts. While I feel this legislation should be unnecessary, the reality is that in 2017 women are still not earning the same pay as men in the same position. Paying women equally is good for the economy and good for business. It is simply a no-brainer and I invite my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to write this into statute once and for all," said Representative Lori Berman. On 'Tuesday, January 241', 2017 at 11:30am -in front of the Senate Chambers, all three Members will be hosting a press conference announcing this legislation. They invite their colleagues to join them. ,24 Senate Committees Assigned to SB 410 Employment Discrimination Committee on Governmental Oversight and Accountability Chair Senator Dennis Baxley (R) Sumter, parts of Marion and Lake Vice Chair Senator Frank Artiles (R) Part of Miami Senator Bill Galvano (R) Manatee and part of Hillsborough Senator Denise Grimsley (R) Desoto, Glades, Hardee, Highlands, Okeechobee, and parts of Charlotte Lee and Polk Senator Kevin Rader (D) parts of Broward, Palm Beach Senator Darryl Ervin Rouson (D) Parts of Hillsborough and Pinellas Senator Linda Stewart (D) part of Orange Committee on Commerce and Tourism Chair Senator Bill Montford (D) Calhoun, Franklin, Gadsden, Gulf, Hamilton, Jefferson, Leon, Madison Taylor, Wakulla Vice Chair Senator George B. Gainer (R) —Liberty, Bay, Holmes, Jackson, Walton, Washington, and part of Okaloosa Senator Audrey Gibson (D) Part of Duval (center Jacksonville) Senator Travis Hutson (R) Flagler, St. Johns, and part of Volusia Senator Jack Latvala Parts of Pasco, Pinellas Senator Kathleen Passidomo (R) Collier, Hendry and part of Lee Senator Jose Javier Rodriguez (D) Part of Miami -Dade Senator Dana D. Young (R) Part of Hillsborough Committee on Judiciary Chair Senator Greg Steube (R) Sarasota and part of Charlotte Vice Chair Senator Lizbeth Benacquisto (R) Part of Lee (Ft. Myers, Cape Coral, Sanibel) Senator Randolph Bracy (D) Part of Orange Senator Anitere Flores (R) Monroe and part of Miami -Dade Senator Rene Garcia (R) Part of Miami -Dade Senator Audrey Gibson (D) Part of Duval (center Jacksonville) Senator Debbie Mayfield (R) Indian River and part of Brevard Senator Bobby Powell (D) Part of Palm Beach Senator Perry E. Thurston, Jr. (D) Part of Broward Committee on Rules Chair Senator Lizbeth Benacquisto (R) Part of Lee (Ft. Myers, Cape Coral, Sanibel) Vice Chair Senator Perry E. Thurston, Jr. (D) Part of Broward Senator Lauren Frances Book (D) Part of Broward Senator Rob Bradley (R) Baker, Bradford, Clay, Columbia, Dixie, Gilchrist, Lafayette, Levy, Suwannee, Union and part of Marion Senator Jeff Brandes (R) Part of Pinellas Senator Oscar Braynon 11 (D) parts of Broward, Miami -Dade Senator Anitere Flores (R) Monroe and part of Miami -Dade Senator Bill Galvano (R) Manatee and part of Hillsborough Senator Jack Latvala (R) Parts of Pasco, Pinellas Senator Tom Lee (R) Parts of Hillsborough, Pasco, Polk Senator Bill Montford (D) Calhoun, Franklin, Gadsden, Gulf, Hamilton, Jefferson, Leon, Libertv. Madison Taylor, Wakulla Senator Wilton Simpson (R) I Citrus, Hernando and part of Pasco ,2r / U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2016b). Currentpopulation survey annual average data tables. Table 2. www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat02.htm. U.S. Census Bureau. (2014a). Currentpopulation survey: Annual social and economic supple- ments. Table P-38. www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income- poverty/historical-income-p eople.html. U.S. Census Bureau. (2014b). Disability. www.census.gov/people/disability/ methodology/acs.html. U.S. Census Bureau. (2015). 2013Amencan Community Survey 1 year estimates: Median earnings in the past 12 months (in 2015 in)7atzon-adjusted dollars) by disability status by sex for the civilian noninstitutzonali:Zed populatzon 16years and over with earnings—universe: Civilian noninstitulzonali.Zed population 16years and over with earnings in thepast 12 months. Retrieved from American Fact Finder. U.S. Census Bureau. (2016). Fact sheet- Differences between theAmerican Community Survey (ACS) and the Annual Social and Economic Supplement to the Current Populatzon Survey (CPSASEC). www.census.gov/topics/income-poverty/poverty/guidance/data- sources / acs-vs-cps.html. U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2015). Table 318.10. Degrees conferred by postsecondary institutions, by level of degree and sex of student: Selected years, 1869-70 through 2025-26. nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d15/tables/dtl5-318.10.asp. U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2016). nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d15/tables/dtl5-104.1O.asp. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (2015). Sex -based charges FY1997—FY2015. www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/statistics/enforcement/sex.cfm. U.S. Office of Personnel Management. (2014). Governmentwide strategy on advancingpay equality in the federalgovernment, wwwopm.gov/policy-data-oversight/pay-leave/ reference-materials/reports/governmentwide-strategy-on-advancing-pay-equality- in-rhe-federal-government.pdf. U.S. Office of Personnel Management. (2016). Pay and leave salaries and wages. www.opm.gov/pohcy-data-oversight/pay-leave/salaries-wages. Williams Institute. (2007). Bias in the workplace: Consistent evidence of sexual orienta- tion andgender identity discrimination. wiEiamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/ uploads/Badgett-Sears-Lau-Ho-Bias-in-the-Workplace jun-2007.pdf. Williams Institute. (2015). The impact of wage equality on sexual onentaiion povertygaps. wiUiamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads /Impact -of -Wage -Equality - on -Sexual -Orientation -Poverty -Gaps June-2015.pdf. Williams Institute. (2016). How many adults identify as transgender in the United States? wiDiamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads /How-Many-Adults-Idendfy- as-Transgender-in-the-United-States.pdf. Zarya, Valentina. (2016). Salesforce spent $3 million on equal pay—here's how many employees got raises as a result. Fortune. fortune.com/2016/03/08/ salesforce -equal -pay. 32 Table of Contents Foreword 2 Acknowledgments Introduction 4 What Is the Pay Gap? How Does the Pay Gap Affect Women of Different Demographics? 10 What Causes the Pay Gap? 17 How Can I Make a Difference? 21 What Should I Do If I Experience Sex Discrimination at Work? 28 AAUW Resources 29 Bibliography 30 , -05 Foreword If you take one simple truth from this guide, I hope it's this: The pay gap is real. This guide provides the latest evidence about the pay gap as well as ideas for what we can do about it. The American Association of University Women (AAUW) has been a leader on this issue for more than a century, since our first publication on the topic in 1894. The good news is that the gap has narrowed considerably in the last hundred years. The bad news is that the gap is still sizable, it's even worse for women of color, and it doesn't seem likely to go away on its own. That's why AAUW works on multiple fronts to shrink the gender pay gap. Over the last century, our organization has awarded millions of dollars in fellowships to women pursuing graduate education. We have provided research and programs to advance women in nontraditional fields such as computing and engineering. AAUW members and staff have stood in the room when federal equal pay legislation was signed, from the Equal Pay Act in 1963 to the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act in 2009. We have advocated for the comprehensive Paycheck Fairness Act, a long -overdue bill that has come close to passage twice in the last seven years. And we've been proud to support and witness real progress happening at the state level, where law- makers are offering creative new approaches to closing the gender pay gap. Pay equity will continue to be an AAUW priority until women everywhere earn a fair day's pay for a fair day's work. This guide is designed to empower our members and other advocates with the facts and resources they need to tell the simple truth about the pay gap. It's real, it's persistent, and it's undermining the economic security of American women and their families. We hope you will join us in the fight for fair pay in the workplace. Patricia Fae Ho AAUW Board Chair Glynn, S. J. (2014). Breadwinning mothers, then and now. Washington, DC: Center for American Progress. Goldin, C. (2014). A grand gender convergence: Its last chapter. American Economic Review 104(4):1091-119. scholar.harvard.edu/files/goldin/files/goldin_ aeapres s_2014_1.pdf. Grant, J. M., Mottet, L. A., & Tanis, J. (2011). Injustice at every turn: A report of the National Transgender Discrimination Survey. National Transgender Discrimina- tion Survey. www.thetaskforce.Org/static—html/downloads/reports/reports/ ntds—full.pdf. Hartmann, H., Hayes, J., & Clark, J. (2014). How equal j ay for working women would reduce poverty and grow the American economy. Washington, DC: Institute for Wom- en's Policy Research. Hegewisch, A., & Hartmann, H. (2014). Occupational segregation and thegender wagegap: Ajob half done. Washington, DC: Institute for Women's Policy Research. Institute for Women's Policy Research. (2011). Pay secrecy and wage dis- crimination. IWPR Fact Sheet. www.iwpr.org/publications/pubs/pay/ secrecy -and -wage -discrimination -1. Jagsi, R., Griffith, K. A., Stewart, A., Sambuco, D., DeCastro, R., & Ubel, P. A. (2012). Gender differences in the salaries of physician researchers. Journal of the American Medical Association 307(22): 2410-17. Killewald, A. (2013). A reconsideration of the fatherhood premium: Marriage, coresidence, biology, and fathers' wages. American Sociological Review 78(1): 96-116. Kim, H. (2009). Integrating organizational justice into the relationship management theory. (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from All Academic Research. Kricheli-Katz, T. (2012). Choice, discrimination, and the motherhood penalty. Law and Society Review 46(3): 557-87. Legislative Office on the Economic Status of Women (2016). Pay equity: The Minne- sota experience. Table: Average salaries in state government employment by year, 1976-2014. www.oesw.leg.mn/PDFdocs/Pay_Equity—Report2Ol6.pdf. Levanon, A., England, P., & Allison, P. (2009). Occupational feminization and pay: Assessing causal dynamics using 1950-2000 U.S. Census data. Social Forces 88(2): 865-91 sf.oxfordjournals.org/content/88/2/865.short. Minnesota Management and Budget. (n.d.). Local government pay equity. mn.gov/ mmb / employee -relations / compensation/laws /local-gov/local-gov-pay-equity. Proctor, B. D., Semega, J. L., & Kollar, M.A. (2016). U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Reports. Income andpoverty in the United States: 2015. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Schilt, K. (2011). Just one of the guys? Transgender men and the persistence of gender inequal- ity. Chicago: University of Chicago. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2016a). Currentpopulation survey annual average data tables. Table 39. www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat39.htm. 2-123-7 31 Bibliography AAUW. (2012). Graduating to a pay gap: The earnings of women and men one-year after college graduation, by C. Corbett and C. Hill. Washington, DC: Author. AAUW. (2016). Barriers and bias: The status of women in leadersh p, by C. Hill, K. Miller, K. Benson, & G. Handley. Washington, DC: Author. AAUWEducational Foundation. (2007) Behind thepay gap, by J. G. Dey & C. Hill. Washington, DC: Author. Babcock, L., & Laschever, S. (2008). Ask for it: How women can use the power of negotia- tion to get what they really want New York: Bantam Dell. Bertrand, M., Goldin, C., & Katz, L. F. (2010). Dynamics of the gender gap for young professionals in the financial and corporate sectors. American Economic Journal. Applied Economics, 2, 228-55. Blau, F. D., & Kahn, L. M. (2016). The gender wage gap: Extent, trends, and explanations. IZA Discussion Paper Series, 9656. Bonn, Germany: Institute for the Study of Labor. http://ftp.iza.org/dp9656.pdf. Bowles, H. R., & Babcock, L. (2013). How can women escape the compensation negotiation dilemma? Relational accounts are one answer. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 37(1), 80-96. Budig, M. J. (2014). The fatherhood bonus and the motherhood penalty: Parenthood and the gendergap in pay. Washington, DC: Third Way. content.thirdwayorg/ publications/853 /NEXT---Fatherhood—Motherhood.pdf. Carnevale, A. P., Strobl, J., & Melton, M. (2011). Wbat'c it worth? The economic value of college majors. Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce. Washington, DC. cew.georgetown.edu/cew-reports/ whats-it-worth-the-economic-value-of-college-maj ors. Carter, N. M., & Silva, C. (2011). The myth of the ideal worker: Does doing all the right things really get women ahead? Catalyst. www.catalyst.org/system/files/ The—Myth—of the_Ideal—Worker—Does_Doing—All—the—Right_Things_Really— Get—Women—Ahead.pdf. Cohen-Charash, Y., & Spector, P. E. (2001). The role of justice in organizations: A meta-analysis. Organa.Zational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 86, 278-321. Colquitt, J. A., Conlon, D. E., Wesson, M. J., Porter, C. O., & Ng, K. Y. (2001). Justice at the millennium: A meta -analytic review of 25 years of organizational justice research. Journal of Applied Pychology 86, 425-45. Correll, S. J., & Benard, S. (2007). Getting a job: Is there a motherhood penalty? American Journal of Sociology 912 (5): 1297-1338. Fischer, J., & Hayes, J. (2013). The importance of Social Secunty in the incomes of older Americans. Differences bygender, age, race/ethnicity, and marital status. Washington, DC: Institute for Women's Policy Research. Glauber, R. (2008). Race and gender in families and at work: The fatherhood wage. Gender and Society 22(1): 8-30. 2,3 3 Z 30 Acknowledgments The Sample Truth about the Gender Pay Gap was written by AAUW Vice President of Research Catherine Hill in 2011. It was substantially revised by Senior Researcher Kevin Miller and Research Associate Kathleen Benson in 2016. Vice President of Government Relations Lisa Maatz and State Policy Analyst Kate Nielson wrote the section on federal and state policies. Senior Editor Kathryn Bibler and Senior Designer Allison VanKanegan also con- tributed to the report. AAUW thanks our members and supporters for their generous contribu- tions in making this publication and organization possible. M Introduction In 2015, women working full time in the United States typically were paid just 80 percent of what men were paid, a gap of 20 percent (Proctor et al., 2016). The gap has narrowed since 1960, due largely to women's progress in education and workforce participation and to men's wages rising at a slower rate. At the rate of change between 1960 and 2015, women are expected to reach pay equity with men in 2059. But even that slow progress has stalled in recent years. If change continues at the slower rate seen since 2001, women will not reach pay equity with men until 2152 (Figure 1). The gender pay gap has lifelong financial effects. For one, it contributes directly to women's poverty. In 2015, 14 percent of American women ages 18-64 were living below the federal poverty level, compared with 11 per- cent of men. For ages 65 and older, 10 percent of women and 7 percent of FIGURE 1. Women's Median Annual Earnings as a Percentage of Men's Median Annual Earnings for Full -Time, Year -Round Workers, 1960-2015 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% • 50% o° projected Pay equity 2152 �' �° 1" �° o° o`' ° ti'1 yam, .y0 1°� 1°i 'y0 10' 1-111".y0 .10 .y0ti.y0 • Women's earnings as a percentage of men's earnings — 1960-2015 trend — 2001-15 trend Source: AAUW analysis of data from Proctor et al, U.S. Census Bureau, Income and Poverty in the United States. 2015 4 �- / 0 AAUW Resources • Visit the pay equity resources on the AAUW website at wwwaauworg/ tag/equal-pay for current information on the status of legislation, federal policies, and actions that you can take to narrow the pay gap. • join AAUW's Action Network to keep up with equal pay advocacy and receive notices to tell your legislators what you think: www.aauw.org/ actionnetwork. • Learn about your rights at work and what you can do if you believe you're being paid unfairly or otherwise discriminated against by visiting www aauw.org/what-we-do/legal-resources /know -your -rights -at -work. • Get ideas for programming and advocacy at fightforfairpay.org. • If you're a college student or professional, visit AAUW's salary negoti- ation page at www.aauw.org/what-we-do/salary-negotiation-workshops to find out how to attend an AAUW Start Smart or AAUW Work Smart salary negotiation workshop or bring one to your community. • Learn about the status of pay equity laws in your state and take action at www.aauw.org/resource/state-equal-pay-laws. • Read more about the pay gap at www.aauw.org/what-we-do/research. • join AAUW and help ensure pay equity for all: www.aauw.org/join. Z -3s 29 What Should I Do If I Experience Sex Discrimination at Work? Put it in writing. Always put everything in writing so you have a record and a time lune. 2. Do your homework. For more information on your rights, call the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) hotline at 800.669.4000. 3. Seek help. Talk with your supervisor or human resources representative at work to learn about the grievance procedure. 4. Avoid loose lips. While the desire to talk about your case is understand- able, the threat of countersuits for defamation is real. 5. Get legal advice. Talk to a lawyer who has specific experience with sex discrimination in the workplace. For a referral in your state, contact your local bar association. 6. Act quickly. There is a statute of limitations on filing complaints with the EEOC. 7. Watch your nickels and dimes. Talk to a lawyer or an accountant about the financial burdens of a lawsuit. 8. Visit your doctor—yes, your doctor. You may experience a physical and emotional toll that should be addressed and documented. 9. Prepare for the long haul. Filing a discrimination lawsuit is a long process, but others have succeeded in fighting discrimination, and you can too. 10. Find a support network. AAUW branches can help support you. Find a branch near you at www.aauw.org. 28 men were living in poverty (Proctor et al., 2016). Eliminating the gender pay gap by increasing women's levels of pay to those of their male counterparts could cut the poverty rate for working women in half (Hartmann et al., 2014). Even after women leave the workforce, the pay gap follows them. Because women typically are paid less than men during working years, when women retire they receive less income from Social Security, pensions, and other sources than do retired men (Fischer & Hayes, 2013). Other benefits such as disability and life insurance are also smaller for women, because these benefits usually are based on earnings. The impact of the pay gap has also deepened in recent years as a result of changes in family structure. Between 1967 and 2012, the proportion of mothers bringing home at least a quarter of the family's earnings rose from less than a third (28 percent) to nearly two-thirds (63 percent). Today, 40 percent of mothers with children under the age of 18 are their families' primary or sole breadwinners (Glynn, 2014). As families increasingly rely on women's wages to make ends meet, the gender pay gap directly affects men and children as well. This guide provides key facts about the gender pay gap in the United States, along with explanations and resources. Information is organized around five common questions: 1. What is the pay gap? 2. How does the pay gap affect women of different demographics? 3. What causes the pay gap? 4. How can I make a difference? 5. What should I do if I experience sex discrimination at work? What Is the Pay Gap? The pay gap is the difference in men's and women's median earnings, usu- ally reported as either the earnings ratio between men and women or as an actual pay gap, as defined below. The median value is the middle value, with equal numbers of full-time workers earning more and earning less. Earnings ratio = Women's median earninc Men's median earnings Pay gap = [Men's median earnings - women's median earnings] Men's median earnings In 2015, median annual earnings in the United States for women and men working full time, year-round were $40,742 and $51,212, respectively (Proctor et al., 2016). 2015 earnings ratio = $40,742_ 80% $51,212 2015 pay gap = ($51,212 - $40,7421 = 20% $51,212 Earnings can also be reported on a weekly basis. The gender pay gap in weekly earnings tends to be slightly smaller than the pay gap in terms of annual earnings. In 2015, the pay gap in median weekly earnings was 19 percent (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016a). Where do the data come from? Federal agencies such as the U.S. Census Bureau, the U.S. Department of Education, and the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics conduct surveys of indi- viduals, households, and businesses to gather information about people's salaries and other earnings. Most reports on national workforce participation, pay, and pay differences depend on data from the Current Population Survey (CPS) (wwwcensus. gov/cps), the country's primary source of labor force statistics. The CPS is a monthly survey with a sample of 100,000 households sponsored jointly by the Census Bureau and the Bureau of Labor Statistics (U.S. Census Bureau, 2016a). ,;01-/ 2, On the positive side, a handful of states have particularly robust laws governing equal pay. For example • California hrruts the excuses employers can use to pay women less than they pay men to only a "bona fide factor other than gender," such as education, training, or experience (as opposed to reasons based solely on gender stereotypes). • Maryland prohibits employers from assigning or directing employees into less -favorable career tracks—known as "mommy tracking"—or withhold- ing information about promotions. • Massachusetts prohibits employers from asking potential employees about their salary history. • Tennessee subjects employers who violate the law to high fines and damage payments, emphasizing the seriousness of a violation. AAUW advocates for all states to pass and enforce equal pay laws in addi- tion to developing other innovative ideas that chip away at the gap. We con- tinue to push for federal pay equity legislation, regulation, and enforcement to protect employees and assist employers. AAUW also educates the public about this persistent problem and its effect on working families. These efforts are critical as we work to close the gender pay gap. �2J3 � - 27 have major loopholes in those protections that allow employers to continue to pay women less than their male counterparts. For example Louisiana's equal pay protections only apply to public employers in the state. Public employers generally have a more transparent pay structure than do their private counterparts, leaving a major hole in the state's oth- erwise relatively comprehensive equal pay legal structure. Several states, including Arizona, do not prohibit employers from retali- ating against employees who take action to remedy wage discrimination, which makes it risky for women to come forward. As a result, localities such as Phoenix are passing their own protective regulations. FIGURE 10 Map of States with Equal Pay Provisions, 2016 i 40 No equal pay law • Weak equal pay law • Moderate equal pay law 0 Strong equal pay law Source: AAU W 26 Lam- ✓' 2 The estimate of the pay gap using weekly earnings is based on the annual average of median weekly earnings for the previous year, usually released in January of each year by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (www.bls.gov/cps). The estimate of the pay gap using annual earnings is based on the CPS Annual Social and Economic Supplement, which is published each September by the Census Bureau and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The CPS provides more detailed information on income compared with other government surveys. In recent years, this information has been published in the report Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage an the Unated States (Proctor et al., 2016). State -level data A pay gap can also be calculated for each state (Figure 2). The American Community Survey (ACS) (www.census.gov/acs) is a detailed annual survey distributed to a broad sample of U.S. households, and it supplements the U.S. census of all Americans, which only occurs once per decade. The ACS is often used (including in this report) to estimate more detailed analyses of subpopulations and geographical areas, such as the pay gap at the state level and for smaller racial/ethnic groups (e.g., Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander and American Indian and Alaska Native workers) because it includes more households—approximately 3 million per year, compared with the 100,000 surveyed in the CPS (US. Census Bureau, 2016a). The ACS results are released annually in September, and briefs based on the sur- vey can be found on the Census Bureau's website. According to ACS data, in 2015 the pay gap was smallest in New York, where women were paid 89 percent of what men were paid, and largest in Wyoming, where women were paid 64 percent of what men were paid (Figure 2). 13 FIGURE 2 Median Annual Earnings and Earnings Ratio for Full -Time, Year -Round Workers, by State and Gender, 2015 ❑ National pay gap average The states with no state protections from pay discrimination tend to have the biggest pay gaps. However, states with stronger laws do not necessarily have the smallest gaps. Strong pay equity laws help close the pay gap, but the gap itself is affected by other issues such as occupational segregation and access to paid leave. State laws addressing the pay gap vary considerably. For example, each state's laws apply to different subsets of employees, with some states cov- ering all employees, others affecting only public or only private employees, and still others regulating only employers who have more than a certain number of workers. Currently, two states Alabama and Mississippi -have no state pay equity or sex -based employment discrimination regulations. All other states have at least some basic equal pay protections. But roughly one-third of states also 1994 41 The Fair Pay Act, which addresses unequal pay between female -dominated jobs equivalent to male -dominated jobs, was first introduced. The legislation also takes steps to protect employees who discuss their salaries and requires employers to file wage information with the EEOC. As of the 114th Congress, the bill has yet to pass. 1997 40 The Paycheck Fairness Act, an update to the Equal Pay Act, was first introduced. It would close loopholes, strengthen incentives to prevent pay discrimination, and prohibit retaliation against workers who discuss wages. Every year since 1997, the legislation has been reintroduced, even passing the House in 2009 before falling short in the Senate. As of the 114th Congress, the bill has yet to pass. 2009 40 The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act was enacted to address the unfortunate Supreme Court ruling that sided with Ledbetter's employer in her gender discrimination case, thereby overturning 40 years of precedent in discrimination cases. The law clarifies that pay discrimination can occur when a pay decision is made, when an employee is subject to that decision, or at any time that an employee is injured by it. 2014 President Barack Obama signed AAUW-supported executive orders to increase pay protections for women. The provisions collect more wage data and target federal contractors to protect workers from retaliation and labor law violations. ,Z- 3/ 25 Male Female Earnings Ratio 1 New York $52,124 $46,208 89% 2 Delaware $51,037 $45,192 89% 3 Florida $41,105 $35,604 87% 4 District of Columbia $72,230 $62,191 86% 5 North Carolina $42,039 $36,113 86% 6 Rhode Island $51,368 $44,050 86% 7 California $50,562 $43,335 86% 8 New Mexico $41,440 $35,070 85% 9 Hawaii $48,074 $40,434 84% 10 Vermont $47,960 $40,173 84% 11 1 Nevada $43,681 $36,565 84% 12 Maryland $60,591 $50,635 84% 13 Arizona $44,421 $37,084 83% 14 Massachusetts $61,761 $51,343 83% 15 Connecticut $61,666 $50,802 82% 16 Kentucky $43,037 $35,294 82% 17 New Jersey $61,462 $50,373 82% 18 Minnesota $51,979 $42,137 81% 19 Tennessee $42,525 $34,427 81% 20 South Carolina $42,238 $34,182 81% 21 Oregon $48,001 $38,774 81% 22 Colorado $51,628 $41,690 81% 23 Georgia $45,396 $36,650 81% United States $51,212 $40,742 80% 24 Illinois $52,161 $41,327 79% 25 Washington $56,215 $44,422 79% 26 Texas $46,791 $36,934 179% ❑ National pay gap average The states with no state protections from pay discrimination tend to have the biggest pay gaps. However, states with stronger laws do not necessarily have the smallest gaps. Strong pay equity laws help close the pay gap, but the gap itself is affected by other issues such as occupational segregation and access to paid leave. State laws addressing the pay gap vary considerably. For example, each state's laws apply to different subsets of employees, with some states cov- ering all employees, others affecting only public or only private employees, and still others regulating only employers who have more than a certain number of workers. Currently, two states Alabama and Mississippi -have no state pay equity or sex -based employment discrimination regulations. All other states have at least some basic equal pay protections. But roughly one-third of states also 1994 41 The Fair Pay Act, which addresses unequal pay between female -dominated jobs equivalent to male -dominated jobs, was first introduced. The legislation also takes steps to protect employees who discuss their salaries and requires employers to file wage information with the EEOC. As of the 114th Congress, the bill has yet to pass. 1997 40 The Paycheck Fairness Act, an update to the Equal Pay Act, was first introduced. It would close loopholes, strengthen incentives to prevent pay discrimination, and prohibit retaliation against workers who discuss wages. Every year since 1997, the legislation has been reintroduced, even passing the House in 2009 before falling short in the Senate. As of the 114th Congress, the bill has yet to pass. 2009 40 The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act was enacted to address the unfortunate Supreme Court ruling that sided with Ledbetter's employer in her gender discrimination case, thereby overturning 40 years of precedent in discrimination cases. The law clarifies that pay discrimination can occur when a pay decision is made, when an employee is subject to that decision, or at any time that an employee is injured by it. 2014 President Barack Obama signed AAUW-supported executive orders to increase pay protections for women. The provisions collect more wage data and target federal contractors to protect workers from retaliation and labor law violations. ,Z- 3/ 25 Government FEDERAL Congress has a history of considering, and in some cases enacting, laws that address chscrirntnation in employment. Yet these legal protections have not ensured equal pay for women and men. See the below time line of major milestones in federal equal pay policy. STATE As inaction continues at the federal level, states are moving forward with their own laws to ensure that women receive equal pay for equal work. The good news is that nearly every state has a law prohibiting employers from paying workers differently based solely on their gender. The bad news? Many of these laws are limited in scope or are not enforced. Every state has room to make its pay equity laws stronger. Federal Equal Pay Legislation Time Line 1920 • The Department of Labor Women's Bureau was founded to promote the welfare of wage-earning women. 1938 41 The Fair Labor Standards Act was enacted to improve labor conditions and practices for workers by regulating minimum wage, overtime pay, record- keeping, and labor standards. 1945 The Women's Equality Bill, the first federal pay equity legislation, was introduced by AAUW member Rep. Chase Going Woodhouse (D -CT). 1963 The Equal Pay Act became law, requiring employers to give women and men employees equal pay for equal work. 1964 Title VII of the Civil Rights Act was passed, barring employment discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin specifically in hiring, firing, promotion, and wages. 1967 0 The Age Discrimination in Employment Act became law, protecting workers 40 years and older 1972 Title IX of the Education Amendments, the first comprehensive federal law to prohibit sex discrimination in education, was enacted. 1990 Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act was passed to protect against discrimination based on disability status, including in employment. 24 3 v FIGURE 2. (CONT.) Median Annual Earnings and Earnings Ratio for Full -Time, Year -Round Workers, by State and Gender, 2015 Note: National data include workers ages 15 and older and are based on the Current Papulation Survey. State -level statistics include workers ages 16 and older and are based on the American Community Survey. See page 6 for more details on these data sources. 15 0 Male Female Earnings Ratio 27 Pennsylvania $50,976 $40,214 79% 28 Arkansas $40,570 $32,003 79% 29 Nebraska $46,763 $36,834 79% 30 Maine $46,934 $36,841 78% 31 Wisconsin $49,306 $38,594 78% 32 South Dakota $42,605 $33,268 78% 33 Alaska $55,752 $43,455 78% 34 Missouri $45,897 $35,759 78% 35 Virginia $54,392 $42,342 78% 36 Iowa $47,298 $36,264 77% 37 Kansas $47,864 $36,671 77% 38 New Hampshire $56,525 $43,172 76% 39 Alabama $45,057 $34,310 76% 40 Indiana $47,092 $35,753 76% 41 Mississippi $41,092 $31,110 76% 42 Ohio $50,051 $37,365 75% 43 Michigan $50,479 $37,486 74% 44 Idaho $43,264 $31,808 74% 45 Oklahoma $43,829 $32,096 73% 46 Montana $46,123 $33,443 73% 47 North Dakota $52,031 $37,016 71% 48 Utah $50,741 $36,060 71% 49 West Virginia $45,082 $31,824 71% 50 Louisiana $49,730 $33,832 68% 51 Wyoming $55,965 $36,064 64% Note: National data include workers ages 15 and older and are based on the Current Papulation Survey. State -level statistics include workers ages 16 and older and are based on the American Community Survey. See page 6 for more details on these data sources. 15 0 How Does the Pay Gap Affect Women of Different Demographics? The pay gap affects women from all backgrounds, at all ages, and of all levels of educational achievement, although earnings and the gap vary depending on a woman's individual situation. Race/ethnicity Among full-time workers in 2015, Hispanic, American Indian and Alaska Native, African American, and Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander women had lower median annual earnings compared with non -Hispanic white and Asian American women. But African American, Hispanic, American Indian and Alaska Native, and Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander women experienced a smaller gender pay gap compared with men in the same racial/ethruc group than did non -Hispanic white and Asian American women (Figure 3). FIGURE 3 Median Annual Earnings, by Race/Ethnicity and Gender, 2015 $70,000 $60,000 $50,000 $40,000 $30,000 $20,000 $10,000 Hispanic African White Asian Native Hawaiian American Indian or Latina/o American (non -Hispanic) and Other and Alaska Native Pacific Islander 0 Women 0 Men XX% Women's earnings as a percentage of men's earnings Source. U.S. Census Bureau, 2015American Community Survey 1 -Year Estimates In contrast, only 14 percent of public -sector employees reported that pay discussions were either discouraged or prohibited. This higher degree of transparency in the public sector may be related to the greater gender pay equity found in the federal government (see Washington, D.C.'s gender pay gap, Figure 2). Federal workers can easily see how their salaries compare with others at their grade level and geographical location because the U.S. Office of Personnel Management makes public the salary and wage range for each level of federal worker and additional locality pay for areas where the cost of living is higher (U.S. Office of Personnel Manage- ment, 2016). A 2014 report found that, among white collar federal workers, women were paid 87 percent of what men were paid in 2012, compared with 77 percent in the workforce as a whole in 2012 (U.S. Office of Person- nel Management, 2014). Employers can also use audits to monitor and address gender pay dif- ferences, to great effect. Minnesota requires pubhc-sector employers to conduct a pay equity study every few years and eliminate pay disparities between female -dominated and male -dominated jobs that require compa- rable levels of expertise (Minnesota Management and Budget). Employers use a job evaluation tool to compare jobs on dimensions such as the com- plexity of issues encountered, the depth and breadth of knowledge needed, the nature of interpersonal contacts required, and the physical working conditions. Thils allows employers to identify jobs—for example, delivery van drivers and clerk typists—that, despite being different, require similar levels of knowledge and responsibility. An analysis is then done to compare wages of predominantly female jobs with those of predominantly male jobs of comparable skill levels. If the results of the study show that women are consistently paid less than men for jobs requiring similar levels of knowl- edge and responsibility, the employer makes the necessary salary increases. The state's efforts have been hugely successful: Since the 1970s, Minnesota has virtually eliminated the pay gap in public -sector jobs of comparable value (Legislative Office on the Economic Status of Women, 2016). 23 and tweets are just a few examples. Joining an organization like AAUW can make all these activities easier, especially if you use our templates and resources and connect with our network of activists. Employers Companies should know by now that paying workers fairly is necessary for legal and ethical reasons. But fair pay can also be good for the bottom line. Believing that an employer is fair improves workers' morale (Cohen -Cha - rash & Spector, 2001; Kim, 2009). Work performance has also been linked to the perception of organizational justice (Colquitt et al., 2001). In other words, workers who believe that they are paid fairly are more likely to con- tribute their best effort to the job. One employer took this recommendation to heart and decided to volun- tarily audit its pay practices. In 2015, Salesforce performed a comprehensive analysis of 17,000 employees that led to salary adjustments for 6 percent of employees. The result? A 33 percent increase in the number of women who were promoted that year (Zarya, 2016). Salesforce's actions garnered atten- tion across the country, inspiring the Obama administration to announce the White House's Equal Pay Pledge for private sector companies to commit to equal pay for their employees. As of August 2016, more than 50 companies had signed the pledge, including American Airlines, Apple, the Dow Chemical Company, Facebook, General Motors, Johnson & Johnson, Microsoft, PepsiCo, and Staples. As U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once noted, "Sunshine is the best disinfectant." Transparency in compensation can make a difference. A national survey by the Institute for Women's Policy Research JWPR) found that about half of employees said they worked in a setting where discus- sions of wages and salaries are either formally prohibited or discouraged by managers (Institute for Women's Policy Research, 2011). According to IWPR, pay secrecy is much more common in the private sector, where 61 percent of employees are either discouraged or prohibited from discussing wage and salary information. Using a single benchmark provides a more informative picture. Because non - Hispanic white men are the largest demographic group in the labor force, they are often used for that purpose. Compared with salary information for white male workers, Asian American women's salaries show the smallest gender pay gap, at 85 percent of white men's earnings. The gap was largest for Hispanic and Latina women, who were paid only 54 percent of what white men were paid in 2015 (Figure 4). The smaller within -group gender pay gap among African Americans, Hispanics, American Indians and Native Alaskans, and Native Hawaiians and other Pacific Islanders is due solely to the fact that men in those groups were paid substantially less than non -His- panic white men in 2015 (Figure 3). FIGURE 4 Earnings Ratio of Women Compared to White Men, by Race/Ethnicity, 2015 Note: Based on median annual earnings of full-time, year-round workers The CPS includes workers 15 and older, and the ACS includes workers 16 and older. The CPS is the preferred data source for income estimates but lacks sufficient sample size for reporting on smaller demographic groups, which is why percentages for two categories above are unavailable. See page 6 for a more detailed description of the CPS and ACS. Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplements, Table P-38 and U S Census Bureau, 2015 American Community Survey 1 -Year Estimates Age Earnings for both female and male full-time workers tend to increase with age, with a plateau after age 45 and a drop after age 65. The gender pay gap also grows with age, and differences among older workers are considerably larger than differences among younger workers. 22 6 11 Current Population Survey (CPS) American Community Survey (ACS) Hispanic or Latina 54% 54% African American 63% 62% White (non -Hispanic) 75% 76% Asian 85% 90% Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander - 60% American Indian and Alaska Native -- 58% Note: Based on median annual earnings of full-time, year-round workers The CPS includes workers 15 and older, and the ACS includes workers 16 and older. The CPS is the preferred data source for income estimates but lacks sufficient sample size for reporting on smaller demographic groups, which is why percentages for two categories above are unavailable. See page 6 for a more detailed description of the CPS and ACS. Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplements, Table P-38 and U S Census Bureau, 2015 American Community Survey 1 -Year Estimates Age Earnings for both female and male full-time workers tend to increase with age, with a plateau after age 45 and a drop after age 65. The gender pay gap also grows with age, and differences among older workers are considerably larger than differences among younger workers. 22 6 11 90 percent until around the age of 35, at which point median earnings for women start to grow much more slowly than median earnings for men. From age 35 through retirement, women are typically paid 76-81 percent of what men are paid, depending on age. By the time workers reach 55-64 years old, women are paid only 76 percent of what their male peers are paid (Figure 5). Disability Disability status is a challenging population demographic to capture because it covers many definitions. In the current ACS questionnaire, disability is measured by answering questions related to six disability types: hearing, vision, cognitive, ambulatory, self-care, and independent living (U.S. Census Bureau, 2014b). According to the ACS, in 2015, people with disabilities made just 68 percent of what people without disabilities made. And among FIGURE 5 Median Weekly Earnings, by Gender and Age, 2014 $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 $0 16-19 20-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65 years years years years years years years and older O Women ®Men XX% Women's earnings as a percentage of men's earnings Note Based on median usual weekly earnings of full-time wage and salary workers, 2014 annual averages Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, reported in U S. Department of Labor, U S Bureau of Labor Statistics, Highlights of Women's Earnings in 2014, Table 1 How Can I Make a Difference? The gender pay gap is unlikely to go away on its own, but there are many things that we can do in our workplaces and in our communities to make a difference. Here are some steps that individuals, employers, and govern- ments can take to ensure fair pay. Individuals Many personal decisions have profound implications for economic secu- rity. Pursuing a college education has long been viewed as an important step toward ensuring a middle-class lifestyle, and higher degrees are usually associated with higher pay. But choice of college major can profoundly affect future earrungs (Carnevale et al., 2011). In addition, the kinds of jobs pursued early in a career set the stage for an entire career of earnings. Since benefits and subsequent raises are generally based on initial wages, a lower starting salary could mean a lifetime of lower compensation and smaller retirement benefits. Because most employers have some latitude when it comes to salaries, negotiating can pay off. While women can't negotiate around discrimina- tion, knowing what your skills are worth and learning techniques to pro- mote them can help. Traditionally, it has been socially expected (and there- fore accepted) for men to negotiate for raises because negotiating conforms with the stereotype of men as assertive. But negotiation is especially tricky for women because some behaviors that work for men, like self -promotion and assertiveness, may backfire on women (Carter & Silva, 2011; Bowles & Babcock, 2013). Knowing what your skills are worth, making clear what you bring to the table, emphasizing common goals, and maintaining a positive attitude are some negotiation tactics that have been shown to be effective for women (Babcock & Laschever, 2008). AAUW offers Start Smart and Work Smart salary negotiation workshops to teach women how to negotiate with confidence. Beyond their personal lives, individuals can also take steps to influence employers and governments. There are more ways to make your voice heard than ever before—letters to your legislators and local papers, blogs, 1 21 women are also less likely than men to reach the highest -paying leadership and executive positions. In 2015, women held only 26 percent of pri- vate -sector executive positions, with women of color particularly unlikely to hold such positions. (For more information on the leadership gap, see AAUW's 2016 report Bamers and Bias: the Status of lFlomen in Leadersh p.) Gender bias also factors into how our society values some lobs over others. A study of 50 years of U.S. workforce data concluded that when an influx of women enter a previously male -dominated profession, average wages for the occupation as a whole actually decrease (Levanon et al., 2009). And bias affects the choices women make in the first place. Gender norms and pressures influence women's decisions regarding education, occupation, time away from work, and family. These so-called explained factors show that our society has specific expectations and standards for women. So how do we know that discrimination and bias affect women's pay? Because discrimination cannot be directly detected in most records of income and employment, researchers look for the "unexplained" pay gap after statistically accounting for other factors. For instance, after accounting for college major, occupation, economic sector, hours worked, months unemployed since graduation, GPA, type of undergraduate institution, institution selectivity, age, geographical region, and marital status, AAUW found a remaining 7 percent difference between the earnings of male and female college gradu- ates one year after graduation. That gap jumped to 12 percent 10 years after college graduation (AAUW, 2012; AAUW Educational Foundation, 2007). Other researchers have reached similar conclusions about gender discrimi- nation and the pay gap. For instance, a study of medical researchers found an unexplained gap of 6 percent between comparable men and women in the field, and a recent study of the American workforce as a whole found an unexplained gap of 8 percent Qagsi et al., 2012; Blau & Kahn, 2016). These estimates of the unexplained pay gap are often treated as estimates of the effect of discrimination on women's earnings. These numbers may be smaller than the overall pay gap, but all calculations of the gap represent substantial inequalities, real individual struggles, and smaller paychecks for women and their families. people with disabilities, the gender pay gap is substantial: Median pay for women with disabilities is 69 percent that of men with disabilities. (These data include all workers regardless of full-time or year-round status.) Sexual orientation and gender identity According to the Williams Institute, closing the gender pay gap would significantly mitigate the poverty rates of both same-sex and opposite -sex couples. Using 2012 ACS results, an institute study found that eliminating the gender pay gap would lower poverty rates for couples that include at least one woman (Williams Institute, 2015). The Williams Institute also conducted a meta-analysis of studies of the incomes of lesbians, gay men, and bisexuals, finding that gay and bisexual men are paid 10-32 percent less than similarly qualified heterosexual men. The same study found that lesbi- ans may be paid more than heterosexual women but still are paid less than heterosexual or gay men (Williams Institute, 2007). When we analyze the gender pay gap, it's also important to include people who do not identify with the gender they were assigned at birth. The Wil- liams Institute estimates that 1.4 million adults in the United States identify as transgender (2016). Transgender people frequently experience harass- ment and discrimination in the workplace because of their gender identity (Grant et al., 2011). Preliminary evidence from the National Transgender Discrimination Survey also suggests that people who transition from male to female gender expres- sion experience a drop in pay after the transition, while those who transition from female to male gender expression see no difference in pay or even a small increase (Grant et al., 2011). The experiences of transgender people offer a powerful tool for understanding gender stereotypes and bias and how these factors play a role in the gender pay gap. ,2' / 20 13 Education As a rule, earnings increase as years of education increase for both men and women. While more education is an effective tool for increasing earnings (Asian American women and men had the highest college attainment levels of any racial or ethnic group in 2015, according to the U.S. Department of Education), it is not an effective tool against the gender pay gap. At every level of academic achievement, women's median earnings are less than men's median earnings (Figure 6). In some cases, the gender pay gap is larger at higher levels of education. Across all racial and ethnic groups, American women now earn more col- lege and postgraduate degrees than men (U.S. Department of Education, 2016). But education does not eliminate the gender pay gap. In Graduating to a Pay Gap: The Earnings of Women and Men One Year after College Graduation, FIGURE 6 Median Weekly Earnings, by Level of Education and Gender, 2015 $1,900 $1,600 $1,400 $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 so Less than a high High school Some college or Bachelors Advanced school diploma graduate associate degree degree degree * Women ® Men XX% Women's earnings as a percentage of men's earnings Note: Based on median usual weekly earnings of full-time wage and salary workers, ages 25 and older, 2015 annual averages Source. U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, reported in U.S. Department of Labor, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2015 Usual Weekly Earnings Summary, Economic News Release USDL-16-0111, Table 9 14 --20 Parenting and time away from work Becoming a parent is widely acknowledged as a personal choice that affects careers, but it produces different professional outcomes for women and men. Taking time away from the workforce or cutting back hours, both more common scenarios for mothers than fathers, hurts earnings (Bertrand et al., 2010). Many employers and industries still prioritize long, continuous, traditional work hours rather than flexible schedules, a preference that tends to put women with children at a disadvantage (Goldin, 2014). AAUW's Behind the Pay Gap report found that 10 years after college graduation, 23 percent of mothers were out of the workforce, and 17 percent worked part time. Among fathers, only 1 percent were out of the workforce, and only 2 percent worked part time (AAUW Educational Foundation, 2007). Many stay-at-home and part-time working mothers will eventually decide to return to the full-time workforce, and when they do they may encounter a "motherhood penalty" that extends beyond the actual time out of the workforce. Experimental studies have documented that employers are less likely to hire mothers (including mothers who never left the workforce) compared with child -free women, and when employers do make an offer to a mother, they offer her a lower salary than they do other women (Correll & Benard, 2007; Kricheli-Katz, 2012). Fathers, in contrast, do not suffer a penalty compared with other working men. Many fathers actually receive higher wages after having a child, known as the "fatherhood bonus" (Kille- wald, 2013; Budig, 2014). Gender discrimination and bias Not all of the gender pay gap can be "explained away" by choices such as college major, occupation, work hours, and time out of the workforce. Discrimination and bias against women in the workplace are also culprits in the pay gap. Each year, thousands of sex discrimination cases are brought before the federal Equal Opportunity Employment Commission (EEOC), and many of these complaints are decided or settled in favor of the person who filed the charge (EEOC, 2015). Thanks in part to persistent sex discrimination, i' •Z.�— 19 the early 2000s. Occupational segregation also continues to affect some women more than others: Of all racial/ethnic groups, Hispanic women and men are the least likely to work in the same jobs (Hegewisch & Hartmann, 2014). Increasing the number of women in traditionally male fields will likely improve wages for women, but it is unlikely to fully eliminate the pay gap. Women in male -dominated jobs such as computer programming still face a pay gap compared with their male counterparts (Figure 9), even though women in such jobs may be paid higher salaries than women in traditionally female fields are paid. It will take more than individual women pursuing careers in historically male fields to ensure fair pay for all. (See AAUW's reports Why So Few? Women in Science, Technology, Engineenng, and Mathematics and Solving the Equation: The Vanables for IY/omen'r Success in Engineenng and Com- puting for more discussion of career choice and occupational gender gaps.) FIGURE 9 Earnings Ratio in Median Weekly Pay among Full -Time Workers, Selected Occupations, 2015 w Truck drivers t`o m Hand laborers and �, E material movers Oma 3` Software developers Food service managers cNZ5 °^o v � Designers VL 8;E Financial managers Elementary and T v r middle school 0 E s teachers 0 ° 3 Maids and ?oT housekeepers u Otv 3` Registered nurses 84% 0—i $632 $751 8 % $455 $547 81% $1,415 5680 $820 $918 1,099 65% SL130 $957! SL077 86� i $4007 $$4475 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I $0 $500 $1,000 $1.500 $2,000 0 Female median weekly earnings 0 Male median weekly earnings XX% Women's earnings as a percentage of men's earnings Source: U.S. Department of tabor, U.S. Bureau of tabor Statistics, Current Population Survey Annual Average Data Tables, Table 39 18 - 2 (/ AAUW found that just one year after college graduation, women were paid 82 percent of what their male counterparts were paid (AAUW, 2012). Furthermore, earnings are affected by race and ethnicity as well as gender. White women are paid more than African American and Hispanic women at all education levels (Figure 7). Research suggests that differences in education and other measurable factors explain part of the difference In earnings between racial and ethnic groups. However, as is the case with gender, part of the racial/ethnic pay gap cannot be explained by factors known to affect earnings and 1s likely due, at least 111 part, to discrimination. FIGURE 7 Median Weekly Earnings of Women, by Race/Ethnicity and Level of Education, 2015 SL600 $1,400 $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 $o Hispanic women African American women White women Asian American women 0 Less than a high school diploma f High school diploma, no college 0 Some college or associate degree 0 Bachelors degree 0 Advanced degree Note: Based on median usual weekly earnings of full-time wage and salary workers, ages 25 and older, 2015 annual averages Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, reported in U.S. Department of Labor, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2015 Usual Weekly Earnings Summary, Economic News Release USOL-16-0111, Table 9 ,2- 2/ 15 Student debt As noted, the gender pay gap persists across educational levels and is worse for African American and Hispanic women, even among college graduates. As a result, women who complete college degrees are less able than men to pay off their student loans promptly, leaving them paying more in interest and for a longer time. In 2012, among students who graduated in 2007-08, women working full time had paid off 33 percent of their student loan debt on average, while men working full time had paid off 44 percent of their debt. African American and Hispanic women working frill time are paid considerably less than their male counterparts, and they struggle to pay off student loans promptly; four years after graduation, African American and Hispanic women had paid off less than 10 percent of their debt— much ebtmuch less than other women and men (Figure 8). FIGURE 8 Cumulative Student Debt for 2007-08 College Graduates, by Gender and Race/Ethnicity Note: Includes 2007-08 college graduates ages 35 and younger at graduation who were working full time in 2009 or 2012 and had not pursued an additional degree. There were insufficient data to allow for reliable analysis of other racial groups. Source. AAUW analysis of data from U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, 2008-12 Baccalaureate and Beyond Longitudinal Study 16 : �? :Z 7— What Causes the Pay Gap? The gap of 20 cents on the dollar between men and women working full time, year-round is a statistical fact. The pay gap itself is more complicated than a single number, since it summarizes a huge diversity of women and life circumstances. The origins of the pay gap are also more complicated than a single cause. Women and men have always participated in the work- force in different ways—and have been treated differently by employers— and though those differences have shrunk over time, they still contribute to women being paid less than men. Occupation and "choice" In part, the pay gap reflects women's and men's choices. Women and men choose different college mayors and types of jobs after graduation. But women experience pay gaps at every education level and in nearly every line of work, Among the many occupations for which the Bureau of Labor Statistics collects data that allow for valid comparison, men's earnings are higher than women's in the vast majority (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016a). In 2015, the U.S. civilian workforce included nearly 149 million full- and part -tune employed workers; 53 percent were men, and 47 percent were women (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016b). But women and men tend to work in different kinds of jobs. Women are disproportionately repre- sented in education, office and administrative support, and health care occupations, and men are disproportionately represented in construction, maintenance and repair, and production and transportation occupations (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016a). Segregation by occupation is a major factor behind the pay gap. Even though a pay gap exists in nearly every occupational field, jobs traditionally associated with men tend to pay better than traditionally female -dominated jobs that require the same level of skill (Hegewisch & Hartmann, 2014). Occupational gender segregation has decreased over the last 40 years, largely due to women moving into formerly male -dominated jobs, espe- cially during the 1970s and 1980s, and to faster growth of more evenly mixed -gender occupations in the 1990s. But integration has stalled since 1n 17 Total average debt owed, 2009 Total average debt owed, 2012 Percentage of debt paid off, 2009-12 Men $22,656 $12,793 44% Women $24,126 $16,105 33% Asian American women $19,687 $7,679 61% White women $24,479 $15,417 37% African American women $26,535 $24,116 9% Hispanic women $21,626 $21,026 3% Note: Includes 2007-08 college graduates ages 35 and younger at graduation who were working full time in 2009 or 2012 and had not pursued an additional degree. There were insufficient data to allow for reliable analysis of other racial groups. Source. AAUW analysis of data from U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, 2008-12 Baccalaureate and Beyond Longitudinal Study 16 : �? :Z 7— What Causes the Pay Gap? The gap of 20 cents on the dollar between men and women working full time, year-round is a statistical fact. The pay gap itself is more complicated than a single number, since it summarizes a huge diversity of women and life circumstances. The origins of the pay gap are also more complicated than a single cause. Women and men have always participated in the work- force in different ways—and have been treated differently by employers— and though those differences have shrunk over time, they still contribute to women being paid less than men. Occupation and "choice" In part, the pay gap reflects women's and men's choices. Women and men choose different college mayors and types of jobs after graduation. But women experience pay gaps at every education level and in nearly every line of work, Among the many occupations for which the Bureau of Labor Statistics collects data that allow for valid comparison, men's earnings are higher than women's in the vast majority (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016a). In 2015, the U.S. civilian workforce included nearly 149 million full- and part -tune employed workers; 53 percent were men, and 47 percent were women (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016b). But women and men tend to work in different kinds of jobs. Women are disproportionately repre- sented in education, office and administrative support, and health care occupations, and men are disproportionately represented in construction, maintenance and repair, and production and transportation occupations (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2016a). Segregation by occupation is a major factor behind the pay gap. Even though a pay gap exists in nearly every occupational field, jobs traditionally associated with men tend to pay better than traditionally female -dominated jobs that require the same level of skill (Hegewisch & Hartmann, 2014). Occupational gender segregation has decreased over the last 40 years, largely due to women moving into formerly male -dominated jobs, espe- cially during the 1970s and 1980s, and to faster growth of more evenly mixed -gender occupations in the 1990s. But integration has stalled since 1n 17 3-14-17 _ SC. Early Learning Coalition Early Learning Coalition of Indian River, Martin & Okeechobee Counties, Inc. 10 SE Central Parkway, Ste 200, Stuart, FL 34994 Telephone (772) 220-1220 (877) 220-1223, Fax: (772) 220-1229 Please join us for an educational tour of early childhood education programs in celebration of Children's Week 2017! C�-fILi�R�N�s WEEK --CHILDCARE DROVI UDR l"OUIZS~ S chedm& of Eves Indian River County tours - Monday, March 27: • 9 a vw.' L i-tl e,1 R i✓34L1 - Stark - 2855 58th Ave, Vero Beach • 10:15: 77,.e/ Lea rni*io, Neat - 1088 Barber St, Sebastian Okeechobee County tours - Tuesday, March 28: • 9a wv.' Te*wler Carel - 604 SW 5th St, Okeechobee • 10:15 : %Zof ki SOU& ChwCWw(,YvAca de4ny - 401 SW 4th St, Okeechobee Martin County tours - Wednesday, March 29: • 9a*w }EoLv/SOuA& Early Learn Ce ettew- 11580 SE Gomez Ave, Hobe Sound • 10:15: Apple rreeiAcad' *ny Cep 1&a 1 - 2085 S Kanner Hwy, Stuart Tours will begin promptly at the designated time - Join us for as many or as few tours as you would like - Contact Pat Houston for more information at phouston(aD-elcirmo.org or 772/223-3842 Mission Partnering with parents, providers and communities to ensure quality early learning experiences through programmatic and financial support. 46°3EQSML°3E C@L%S7 7,9 Regional Household Travel urvey UNUS MPtABiT(O,FiTiHEil.'O',U,KN-EaY! =`You 'can . be a part of the Treasure Coast's transportation future. Check your mail soon for the Regional Household Travel Survey. This tri - county survey will give you the chance to help planners improve roads and public transit, reduce congestion and enhance walking and bike paths for years to come. Just fill out the simple survey to receive your one - day household travel log. The trips you take in one day will help plan the way forward for generations. Be a part of theTreasure Coast Regional Household Travel Survey. We need you to show us the way. For more information on the survey, visit our website: www.tc-hts.com or call 1-888-201-5226 P6 4L°3EQSML°3E WAST Regional Household Travel urvey • Do you drive or take the bus? • Do you walk to the store? • Do you go to work or school? • How often do you use public transit? • Do you ride your bike to the beach? As Treasure Coast residents, we need your feedback. Tell us where you travel for a day so we can create the transportation systems to meet your needs. T t. 'u - o , I f The power of change is yourLm P7 MAO PROCLAMATION HONORING ROGER D. COFFMAN ON HIS RETIREMENT FROM INDIAN RIVER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES/PARKS DIVISION WHEREAS, Roger D. Coffman retired from Indian River County Department of General. Services, Parks Division, effective March 15, 2017; and WHEREAS, Roger D. Coffman began his career with Indian River County on September 24, 2001, as an Maintenance Worker and was promoted to Senior Maintenance Worker on October 4, 2013 and continued in that capacity until his retirement, and WHEREAS, Roger D. Coffman has served this County and the Public with distinction and selflessness. During his fifteen years of service, he was dedicated, and his work was greatly appreciated by the Parks Division, citizens, and co-workers alike; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY -COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board applauds Roger D. Coffman Is efforts on behalf of the County, and the Board wishes to express their appreciation for the dedicated service he has given to Indian River County for the last fifteen years, and BE IT FURTHER PROCLAIMED that the Board of County Commissioners and staff extend heartfelt wishes for success in his future endeavors! Adopted this 14th day of March 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA J_ _o_�Z e C2� Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman 21iis is to certify that ager �D. Coffman is here6y presented this fttirement Award for outstanding perfo»nance and faithful'service to Indian fiver County hoard of County Commissioners For fifteen years of service On this 15tFc day of911arc(c 2017 - --f� - 9VlichaeCZito Assistant County Administrator Joseph E Flescher Board of County Commissioner, Charman P9 7C March 14, 2017 INFORMATIONAL ITEM INDIAN .RIVER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Members of the Board of County Commissioners DATE: March 8, 2017 SUBJECT: 2017 ELECTION OF BEACH AND SHORE PRESERVATION.ADVISORY COMMITTEE CHAIR AND VICE -CHAIR FROM: Lisa Com o er Assistant At its February 27, 2017, meeting, the Beach and Shore Preservation Advisory Committee members voted to elect Mr. Michael Ochsner as Chairman and Mr. William "Tuck" Ferrell rat, Vice Chairman of the Committee for the year 2017 No Board of County Commissioners action is required. P10 JEFFREY R. SMITH, CPA, CGFO, CGMA Clerk of Circuit Court & Comptroller Finance Department 180127" Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 TO: HONORABLE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FROM: DIANE BERNARDO, FINANCE DIRECTOR THRU: JEFFREY R. SMITH, COMPTROLLER DATE: March 2, 2017 GoMpT U t a C OU13 : SUBJECT: APPROVAL OF CHECKS AND ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS February 24, 2017 to March 2, 2017 In compliance with Chapter 136.06, Florida Statutes, all checks and electronic payments:issued by the Board of County Cotrunissioners are to be recorded in the Board minutes. Approval is requested for the attached lists of checks and electronic payments, issued by the Comptroller's office, for the time period of February 24, 2017 to March 2, 2017. Attachment: P11 CHECKS WRITTEN TRANS NBR DATE VENDOR AMOUNT 350323 02/24/2017 FLORIDA DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 4,000.00 350324 03/01/2017 1135 RENTALS LLC 580.00 350325 03/01/2017 ORANGE COUNTY HOUSING & C D 632.68 350326 03/01/2017 ALL FLORIDA REALTY SERVICES INC 4,108.00 350327 03/01/2017 VERO BEACH EDGEWOOD PLACE LP 956.00 350328 03/01/20I7 GRACES LANDING LTD 9,653.00 350329 03/01/2017 PAULJULIN 389.00 350330 03/01/2017 L NDSEY GARDENS LTD 6,079.00 350331 03/01/2017 BRYAN D BLAIS 756.00 350332 03/01/2017 WILLIE C REAGAN 449.00 350333 03/01/2017 RIVER PARK ASSOCIATES LIMITED 14,658.00 350334 03/01/2017 RICHARD C TIIERIEN 440.00 350335 03/01/2017 CREATIVE CHOICE HOMES XVI LTD 9,998.00 350336 03/01/2017 DAVIDYORK 502.00 350337 03/01/2017 ST FRANCIS MANOR OF VERO BEACH 107.00 350338 03/01/2017 TREASURE COAST HOMELESS SERVICES 1,147.00 350339 03/01/2017 FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT 6.00 350340 03/01/2017 VENETIAN APARTMENTS OF VERO BEACH 391.00 350341 03/01/2017 PINNACLE GROVE LTD 9,443.00 350342 03/01/2017 VERO CLUB PARTNERS LTD 7,796.00 350343 03/01/2017 DAVID SPARKS 384.00 350344 03/01/2017 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY HOUSING AUTHORITY 188.00 350345 03/01/2017 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY HOUSING AUTHORITY 533.00 350346 03/01/2017 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY HOUSING AUTHORITY 534.00 350347 03/01/2017 CRAIG MERRILL 2,062.00 350348 03/01/2017 CHRISTINE SALTER 484.00 350349 03/01/2017 HAGGERTY FAMILY LTD 373.00 350350 03/01/2017 SUNQUEST INC 4,383.00 350351 03/01/2017 THE PALMS AT VERO BEACH 11,991.00 350352 03/01/2017 FELLSMERE COMM ENRICHMENT PROGRAM INC 88.00 350353 03/01/2017 DAVID CONDON 628.00 350354 03/01/20,17 HILARY MCIVOR 490.00 350355 03/01/2017 PAULALANE 451.00 350356 03/01/2017 JOHN A CAPPELLO 327.00 350357 03/01/2017 PELICAN ISLES 1? 7,191.00 350358 03/01/2017 KATE TYSON LYONS 324.00 350359 03/01/2017 SUNCOAST REALTY & RENTAL MGMT LLC 5,493.00 350360 03/01/2017 OAK RIVER PROPERTIES INC 348.00 350361 03/01/2017 SONRISE VILLAS LTD 2,475.00 350362 03/01/2017 ADINA GOLDMAN 545.00 350363 03/01/2017 INDIAN RIVER RDA LP 4,7I5.00 350364 03/01/2017 MAURICE W BROWN 497.00 350365 03/01/2017 RICHARD L DAVENPORT 495.00 350366 03/01/2017 GEORGE THUYNS 683.00 350367 03/01/2017 LAZY J LLC 1,447.00 350368 03/01/2017 SYLVIAMCNEQ.L 723.00 350369 03/01/2017 SKOKIE HOLDINGS INC 750.00 350370 03/01/2017 ROGER WINSLOW 478.00 350371 03/01/2017 VINCENT PILEGGI 242.00 350372 03/01/2017 OSLO VALLEY PROPERTIES INC 319.00 350373 03/01/2017 SAID S MOOBARK 1,302.00 350374 03/01/2017 CORY J HOWELL 355.00 350375 03/01/2017 OSCEOLA COUNTY SECTION 8 625.68 350376 03/01/2017 LINDSEY GARDENS II LTD 5,147.00 350377 03/01/2017 ANTHONYARROYO 446.00 350378 03/01/2017 AHS HOLDINGS GROUP LLC 3,655.00 350379 03/01/2017 DANIEL CORY MARTIN 590.00 350380 03/01/2017 YVONNE KOUTSOFIOS 369.00 P12 TRANS NBR DATE VENDOR AMOUNT 350381 03/01/2017 ALAN R TOKAR 650.00 350382 03/01/2017 VERO BEACH VILLAS I LLC 463.00 350383 03/01/2017 BRIAN E GALLAGHER 524.00 350384 03/01/2017 HOUSING AUTHORITY 967.68 350385 03/01/2017 STEPHANIE WATCHEK FOUNTAIN TRUST 234.00 350386 03/01/2017 MICHAEL STILES 531.00 350387 03/01/2017 RACHEL G SIDMAN 459.00 350388 03/01/2017 SCOT WILKE 503.00 350389 03/01/2017 J & K PALMER ENTERPRISES LLC 199.00 350390 03/01/2017 THEODORE BARTOSIEWICZ 508.00 350391 03/01/2017 FOUNDATION FOR AFFORDABLE RENTAL 21,053.00 350392 03/01/2017 RICHARD KUSSEROW 475.00 350393 03/01/2017 ARE JAY INVESTMENTS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY Ili 5I4.00 350394 03/01/2017 JOHN T STANLEY 795.00 350395 03/01/2017 CSMA SFR HOLDINGS 11-LLC 1,320.00 350396 03/01/2017 YELLOW KID INC 550.00 350397 03/01/2017 WEDGEWOOD RENTALS LLC 1,608.00 , 350398 03/01/2017 ALMA LUCKETT 854.00 350399 03/01/2017 LIVE OAKS REALTY INC 628.00 350400 03/01/2017 IBIS GARDENS APTS LLC 476.00 350401 03/01/2017 MCLAUGHLIN PROPERTIES LLC 653.00 350402 03/02/2017 PORT CONSOLIDATED INC 49,163.30 350403 03/02/2017 TEN-8 FIRE EQUIPMENT INC 3,134.06 350404 03/02/2017 RANGER CONSTRUCTION IND INC 830.96 350405 03/02/2017 VERO CHEMICAL DISTRIBUTORS INC 106.75 350406 03/02/2017 VERMEER SOUTHEAST 107.74 350407 03/02/2017 VELDE FORD INC 13.35 350408 03/02/2017 SAFETY PRODUCTS INC 183.20 350409 03/02/2017 SEWELL HARDWARE CO INC 206.48 350410 03/02/2017 PARAL13E COMPANY INC 500.00 350411 03/02/2017 KELLY TRACTOR CO 3,727.08 350412 03/02/2017 GENES AUTO GLASS INC 230.00 350413 03/02/2017 TEMPLE INC 52,980.00 350414 03/02/2017 MY RECEPTIONIST INC 275.95 350415 03/02/2017 AMBRIGAS EAGLE PROPANE LP 1,364.74 350416 03/02/2017 GAYLORD BROTHERS INC 121.38 350417 03/02/2017 PHYSIO CONTROL INC 27,567.11 350418 03/02/2017 PARKSON CORPORATION 1,819.46 350419 03/02/2017 BOUND TREE MEDICAL LLC 1,118.88 350420 03/02/2017 SCHULKE BITTLE & STODDARD LLC 1,100.00 350421 03/02/2017 TIRESOLES OF BROWARD INC 713.65 350422 03/02/2017 CARTER ASSOCIATES INC 4,550.00 350423 03/02/2017 ARMFIELD WAGNERAPPRAISAL AND RESEARCH INC 5,000.00 350424 03/02/2017 THE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY 1,669.32 350425 03/02/2017 MIDWEST TAPE LLC 1,135.59 350426 03/02/2017 MICROMARKETING LLC 50.94 350427 03/02/2017 BAKER DISTRIBUTING CO LLC 8I7.38 350428 03/02/2017 CENGAGE LEARNING INC 814.22 350429 03/02/2017 PALM TRUCK CENTERS INC 2,064.05 350430 03/02/2017 PENWORTHY COMPANY 995.58 350431 03/02/2017 SOFTWARE HARDWARE INTEGRATION 56,911.77 350432 03/02/2017 SUNSHINE SAFETY COUNCIL INC 141.67 350433 03/02/2017 FLORIDAASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES INC 100.00 350434 03/0212017 CITY OF VERO BEACH 7,472.20 350435 03/02/2017 UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC 12.97 350436 03/02/2017 APCO INTERNATIONAL, INC 169.00 350437 03/02/2017 JANITORIAL DEPOT OF AMERICA INC 265.14 350438 03/02/2017 ACUSHNET COMPANY 4,531.66 350439 03/02/2017 FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL 255.00 350440 03/02/2017 FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL 255.00 P13 TRANS NBR DATE VENDOR AMOUNT 350441 03/02/2017 FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL 255.00 350442 03/02/2017 FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL 255.00 350443 03/02/2017 FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL 405.00 350444 03/02/2017 CALLAWAY GOLF SALES COMPANY 676.05 350445 03/02/2017 FLORIDA POWERAND LIGHT 59,361.64 350446 03/02/2017 FLORIDAPOWER AND LIGHT 2,608.37 350447 03/02/2017 KETTELA ENTERPRISES 436.81 350448 03/02/2017 TOCOMA RUBBER STAMP & MARKING SYSTEM 24.19 350449 03/02/2017 FLORIDA DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 6,000.00 350450 03/02/2017 PROPERTY DAMAGE APPRAISERS 105.00 350451 03/02/2017 FLORIDAASSOCIATION OF COUNTYATTORNEYS 375.00 350452 03/02/2017 MYLES BROWN 54.00 350453 03/02/2017 GIFFORD COMMUNITY CENTER 4,439.27 350454 03/02/2017 ALAN C KAUFFMANN 140.00 350455 03/02/2017 WESTSIDE REPROGRAPHICS OF VERO BEACH INC 422.50 350456 03/02/2017 GOVERNORS HURRICANE CONFERENCE 260.00 350457 03/02/2017 CHILDRENS HOME SOCIETY OF FL 5,500.00 350458 03/02/2017 CELICO PARTNERSHIP 120.03 350459 03/02/2017 VAN WAL INC 338.00 350460 03/02/2017 ELECTRONIC ACCESS SPECIALIST 978.69 350461 03/02/2017 BIG BROTHERS AND BIG SISTERS 1,250.00 350462 03/02/2017 BIG BROTHERS AND BIG SISTERS 3,270.24 350463 03/02/2017 FAIRFIELD INN 166.00 350464 03/02/2017 FAIRFIELD INN 166.00- 350465 03/02/2017 JOHNS EASTERN COMPANY INC 1,200.00 350466 03/02/2017 ETR LLC 1,750.00 350467 03/02/2017 STAPLES CONTRACT & COMMERCIAL INC 149.99 350468 03/02/2017 GARY L EMBREY 94.00 350469 03/02/2017 FLORIDAASSOC OF COUNTY ENG 350.00 350470 03/02/2017 ARJUNA WERAGODA 98.75 350471 03/02/2017 UNDERSEA SYSTEMS INTERNATIONAL INC 620.05 350472 03/02/2017 SCNS INC 95.40 350473 03/02/2017 MUNICIPAL WATER WORKS INC 234.38 350474 03/02/2017 SAINT EDWARDS SCHOOL INC 1,780.00 350475 03/02/2017 EAU GALLIE ELECTRIC INC 4,137.98 350476 03/02/2017 GLOBALSTAR USA 146.43 350477 03/02/2017 MARY HIGHTOWER 726.00 350478 03/02/2017 MICHAEL KORPAR 60.00 350479 03/02/2017 MICHAELABRAHAM 500.00 350480 03/02/2017 TREASURE COAST SPRINKLERS INC 495.00 350481 03/02/2017 WINSUPPLY OF VERO BEACH 29.77 350482 03/02/2017 TRACKER SOFTWARE CORPORATION 4,837.00 350483 03/02/2017 JOSEPH CATALANO 40.00 350484 03/02/2017 DAVID SCHRYVER 255.00 350485 03/02/2017 HJA DESIGN STUD10 LLC 2,908.75 350486 03/02/2017 LLOYD FENDLEY 363.00 350487 03/02/2017 HEATHER HATTON 20.00 350488 03/02/2017 SAMUEL PRYOR 13.00 350489 03/02/2017 MILLIKEN FORESTRY COMPANY INC 500.00 350490 03/02/2017 TIM ZORC 70.31 350491 03/02/2017 LOWES HOME CENTERS INC 1,127.82 350492 03/02/2017 PENGUIN RANDOM HOUSE LLC 311.85 350493 03/02/2017 CARMEN LEWIS 132.00 350494 03/02/2017 SCADA SOLUTIONS LLC 1,700.00 350495 03/02/2017 KANSAS STATE BANK OF MANHATTAN 890.57 350496 03/02/2017 DEBORAH CUEVAS 90.00 350497 • 03/02/2017 KATE P COTNER 431.61 350498 03/02/2017 THE LAW OFFICES OF 376.00 350499 03/02/2017 TREASURE COAST CONSULTING INC 3,750.00 350500 03/02/2017 MELISSA CAMARATA 500.00 P14 TRANS NBR DATE VENDOR AMOUNT 350501 03/02/2017 RICHARD SZPYRKA 140.80 350502 03/02/2017 JOSEPH DIZONNO 60.00 350503 03/02/2017 KENDRA COPE 55.00 350504 03/02/2017 TRIBOND LLC 8,167.44 350505 03/02/2017 UNIFIRST CORPORATION 444.26 350506 03/02/2017 CDA SOLUTIONS INC 10,978.39 350507 03/02/2017 GOTTA GO GREEN ENTERPISES INC 180.90 350508 03/02/2017 ADVANCE STORES COMPANY INCORPORATED 477.73 350509 03/02/2017 EGP DOCUMENT SOLUTIONS LLC 745.16 350510 03/02/2017 FLORIDAEAST COAST HOLDINGS CORP 17,245.39 350511 03/02/2017 EDWARD ILLIDGE 40.00 350512 03/02/2017 COALITION FORATTAINABLE HOMES INC 606.60 350513 03/02/2017 JONATHAN DALESSIO 36.00 350514 03/02/2017 PEOPLE READY INC 7,478.24 350515 03/02/2017 KEITH ADAMS 114.00 350516 03/02/2017 EMILY GOUGE 60.00 350517 03/02/2017 RAUL E VIVANCO 192.00 350518 03/02/2017 MARY C OAKLEY 2,500.00 350519 03/02/2017 COLE AUTO SUPPLY INC 610.39 350520 03/02/2017 KREMEDY LLC 2,696.00 350521 03/02/2017 SAMANTH SANTANATIRU 28.00 350522 03/02/2017 RHOADES AIR & HEAT 1,850.00 350523 03/02/2017 COREY GRALEY 60.00 350524 03/02/2017 BEACHLAND HOMES CORP 500.00 350525 03/02/2017 JUPITER 2 CONSTRUCTION LLC 75.00 350526 03102/20I7 DANBRANLEY LLC 248.00 350527 03/02/2017 SHELTRA & SONS CONTRACTING LLC 1,004.21 350528 03/02/2017 MUJGAN DUNN 85.51 350529 03/02/2017 DB PARTNERS 1 LLC 4,295.41 350530 03/02/2017 VERO BEACH LIFESTYLES LLC 500.00 Grand Total: 580,526.90 4 P15 ELECTRONIC PAYMENT - VISA CARD TRANS. NBR DATE VENDOR AMOUNT 1010826 02/28/2017 COLD AIR DISTRIBUTORS WAREHOUSE 655.69 1010827 02/28/2017 DAVIDSON TITLES INC 1,548.46 1010828 02/28/2017 MIKES GARAGE & WRECKER SERVICE INC 85.00 1010829 02/28/2017 APPLE INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY CO 107.64 1010830 02/28/2017 MEEKS PLUMBING INC 435.00 1010831 02/28/2017 NEWMANS POWER SYSTEMS 3,040.56 1010832 02/28/2017 GROVE WELDERS INC 621.56 1010833 02/28/2017 ECONOLITE CONTROL PRODUCTS INC 1,265.00 1010834 02/28/2017 CAPITAL OFFICE PRODUCTS 754.43 1010835 02/28/2017 METRO FIRE PROTECTION SERVICES INC 15.00 1010836 02/28/2017 BENNETT AUTO SUPPLY INC 109.63 1010837 02/28/2017 AUTO PARTNERS LLC 26.05 1010838 02/28/2017 PACE ANALYTICAL SERVICES INC 108.00 1010839 02/28/2017 CM&S INDUSTRIES INC 2,995.00 1010840 03/01/2017 AT&T 10,053.18 1010841 03/01/2017 OFFICE DEPOT BSD CUSTOMER SVC 1,08731 1010842 03/01/2017 COMCAST 5.99 1010843 03/01/2017 POLYDYNE INC 2,507.00 1010844 03/01/2017 BRIDGESTONE GOLF INC 70.14 Grand Total: 25,490.64 P16 ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS - WIRE & ACH TRANS NBR DATE VENDOR AMOUNT 4950 02/24/2017 RTEGRTTY LAWNS LLC 1,750.00 4951 02/24/2017 C E R SIGNATURE CLEANING 20,410.00 4952 02/24/2017 FL SDU 5,022.70 4953 02/24/2017 NACO/SOiTTHEAST 1,072.84 4954 02/24/2017 ICMA RETIREMENT CORPORATION 12,038.79 4955 02/24/2017 NACO/SOUTHEAST 25,409.52 4956 02/24/2017 FLORIDALEAGUE OF CITIES, INC 5,121.19 4957 02/24/2017 IRC FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOC 6,660.00 4958 02/24/2017 ICMARETIItEMENT CORPORATION 2,705.00 4959 02/24/2017 TEAMSTERS LOCAL UNION #769 5,583.50 4960 02/24/2017 BENEFITS WORKSHOP 10,291.73 4961 02/24/2017 ATLANTIC COASTAL LAND TITLE CO LLC 139,689.00 4962 02/27!2017 IRS -PAYROLL TAXES 415,050.03 4963 02/27/2017 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER 25,273.41 4964 02/28/2017 CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT 80,959.25 4965 02/28/2017 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS 86,512.37 4966 02/28/2017 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY SHERIFF 3,600,453.65 4967 02/28/2017 BANK OF NEW YORK 440,500.00 4968 02/28/2017 WHITNEYBANK 51,133.50 4969 03/01/2017 AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMIN 13,173.89 4970 03/01/2017 JOSEPH G MILLER 1,000.00 Grand Total: 4,949,810.37 P17 CONSENT: 3/14/17 Office of INDIAN RIVER COUNTY ATTORNEY Dylan Reingold, County Attorney William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney MEMORANDUM TO: Board of County Commissioners FROM: Dylan Reingold - County Attorney DATE: March 2, 2017 SUBJECT: Resolutions Canceling Taxes on Properties Dedicated to the City of Fellsmere for Public Purposes In December, 2016 the City of Fellsmere received, by donation, four parcels of land. The City of Fellsmere intends to use these parcels for public purposes, being stormwater management; recreation; public trails and greenways; and cultural facilities. For this reason, two resolutions have been prepared for consideration by the Board for removing the below recited four properties from the tax roll for ad valorem taxes for current and future years. (The 2016 real property taxes have been paid..) 1. part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-1434-00001.1 and part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-1435-00001.1 donated to City of Fellsmere by Fountains of Fellsmere, LLC Warranty Deed recorded in Book 2993, Page 304 2. part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-0000-00003.0 and part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-1434-00001.0 donated to City of Fellsmere by Mirzam Land Investment, LLC Warranty Deed recorded in Book 2993, Page 308 FUNDING: There is no cost associated with this item. P18 RECOMMENDATION: Authorize the Chairman of the Board of County Commissioners to execute the Resolutions to cancel current and future ad valorem taxes upon these publicly owned lands, and the Clerk to send a certified copy of each_ Resolution to the Tax Collector and Property Appraiser so that the current ad valorem taxes and future ad valorem taxes may be cancelled. /nhm Attachments: Letter Request Resolutions cc: Carole Jean Jordan - Tax Collector David Nolte - Property Appraiser Warren W. Dill, City Attorney, City of Fellsmere Putnam Moreman, CPA, CGFM -Finance Director Jason Nunemaker,— City Manager K P19 Joei Tyson Mayor, i6s,bri Nunemaker. City,Manager March 1, 2017 Nancy Mossall Indian River County Attorney's Office 180127' Street Vero Beach., FL 32960 Dear Nancy: In December 2016, the 'City of Fellsmere has had four pieces, of property donated to us that represent parts of parcel IDWs: 31370000001148500001.1 31370000001143400001.1 3137000.0001000000003.0 31370000001143400001.0 Thedonations were from, FOFort.he Mirzam company, and we *Intend to -use thefour parcels for public.stormwater management, public recreation, public trails and greenways and for public cultural facilities in the City of Fellsmere. If you require any additional information from me, please let me know. Thanks, Sincerely, Putnam Moreman, CPA., CGFM Director of Finance & Administration City of _FL -11smere 22 S. Orange k Felismere, FL 32948 772-646-6304 fihancedirL-c-tor@citvoffelismere�.ot.g Cc: Jason Nunemaker Mark Mathes 21 South, Orange Stteet Fe1lsf6erq,Florida 32948-6700 Phone: 772m57-1-1616 Fax: 772-:571.8615 P20 part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-1434-00001.1 and part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-1435-00001.1 donated by Fountains of Fellsmere, LLC public purposes: stormwater management, recreation, trails and greenways; cultural facilities RESOLUTION NO. 2017- A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CANCELLING CERTAIN TAXES UPON PUBLICLY OWNED LANDS, PURSUANT TO SECTION 196.28, FLORIDA STATUTES. WHEREAS, section 196.28, Florida Statutes, allows the Board of County Commissioners of each County to cancel and discharge any and all liens for taxes, delinquent or current, held or owned by the county or the state, upon lands heretofore or hereafter- conveyed to or acquired by any agency, governmental subdivision, or municipality of the state, or the United States, for road purposes, defense purposes, recreation, reforestation, or other public use; and WHEREAS, such cancellation must be by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners, duly adopted and entered upon its minutes properly describing such lands and setting forth the public use to which the same are or will be devoted; and WHEREAS, upon receipt of a certified copy of such resolution, proper officials of the county and of the state are authorized, empowered, and directed to make proper entries upon the records to accomplish such cancellation and to do all things necessary to carry out the provisions of section 196.28, F.S.; P21 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: Any and all liens for taxes delinquent or current against the following described lands, which were donated by Fountains of Fellsmere, LLC to the City of Fellsmere for use by the municipality for stormwater management; recreation; trails and greenways; and cultural facilities, are hereby cancelled pursuant to the authority of section 196.28, F.S. See attached Warranty Deed to City of Fellsmere, Florida describing lands, recorded in Book 2993 at Page 304, Public Records of Indian River County, Florida. The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner , and the motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: Chairman Joseph E. Flescher Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan Commissioner Susan Adams Commissioner Tim Zorc Commissioner Bob Solari 2 P22 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this . day of March, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS .INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA LIZ Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Circuit Court and Comptroller By: Deputy Clerk Tax Certificates Outstanding Yes No Current Prorated Tax Received and Deposited with Tax Collector $ APPROVED AS TO FOR AND LEGAL SUFFICI Y BY D AN REINGOLD C LINTY ATTORNEY 3 P23 3120170001044 RECORDED IN THE RECORDS OF JEFFREY R. SMITH, CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT INDIAN RIVER CO FL BE, 2993 PG: 304,1/6/2017 4:17 PM D DOCTAX PD $0.70 11-1-16 SALE: NONE DOC. STAMPS: S.70 This Instrument was ptepmd by end should be returned to: Warren W Dill, Esq. Dill & Enna. P.L. 1565 V'S' Highway 1 Sebastian. FL 32959 Parcel ID No.. ................................................. (Space above this line jar recording da(a) ...... ......... I ........................... W� DEED This Warranty Deed, executed thisl� y of,, 201_, by FOUNTAINS OF FELLSMERE, LLC a Florida limited liability company, whose address is 930 West Indiantown Road, Suite 204, Iupiter, Florida 33458, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", to, CITY OF FELLSMERE, FLORIDA, a municipal corporation existing under the laws of the State of Florida, whose post office address is 22 South Orange Street, Fellsmere, Florida 32948, hereinafter referred to as'Grantee % WITNESSETH that said Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), and other good and valuable considerations to said Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained and sold to the said Grantee, and Grantee's successors and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, lying and being in Indian River County, Florida, to -wit: See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and by this reference made a part hereof. To Have and to Hold the same together with all and singular tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereunto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said Grantor, either in law or equity, to the proper use, benefit and behoof of the Grantee forever. Subject to governmental regulations, covenants, rights of way, restrictions, easements and reservations of record, if any, but this provision shall not operate to impose the same. And the Grantor hereby covenants with said Grantee that the Grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the Grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land; that the Grantor hereby fully warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all pentons whomsoever. In Witrtess Whereof, the said Grantor has signed and sealed ,these presents the day and year first above written. Signed, seated and delivered in our presence: WITNESSES AS TO ALL ntName: J�6w 8t��i►h A11004/0, Print Name: $P4p,#A A [d'LAD0 10ON9307.130C.1 l Fountains of Fellsmere, LLC, a Florida limited liabilitycomp By: By: _ ^..r---� w d T. Sousa, Manager P24 BK: 2993 PG: 305 11-1-16 STATE OF FLO A // COUNTY OF CX The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this rlo?'��day of / r 204 by Clifford R. Moms, in his capacity as Manager of Fountains of Fellsmere, LLC., who is ersonally known to me or who has produced a Driver's License as ident' Ica ion. SEAL NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLORIDA Type or Print Name: 00 BOGDANA COLLADO ommission No.: $ •: MY COMMISSION 0 G0048778 Wy Commission Expires: tSk /6 • ;Wfq ,� EXPIRES November 16. 2019 I. STATE OF FLO COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this %Z'+kday of PteA�Pr , 2016 by Oswald T. Sousa, in his capacity as Manager of Fountains of.Fellsmere, LLC, who is ersonally known to me or who has produced a Driver's License a`s identi cation. SEAL i �s• BOGDANA COLLADO MY COMMISSION i 0GO48778 EXPIRES November 16, 2019 100049307.DOC.1 I NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLORIDA Type or Print Name: /i60 Commission No.: Q!r S Ff $ My Commission Expires: AW—AL2D/9 WARR+W7Y DEED PAGE P25 BK: 2993 PG: 306 PARCEL. 'A' RIDIR OF WAY OEDICATED; DESCRIPTION OF A RIGHT d WAY DEDICATED TO THE CITY OF FIE LSYERE, FROM FOUNTAINS OF FEU.SAERE STRIATED N PART OF TRACT 1434 AND 1435 Or THE 'PLAT OF FTRLSMW FARMS COMPANY WMIASION OF ALL UNSI VEYED PMT OF TOIN SHOO 51 SOUTH. RMNOE 37 EAST N ST. CONTY, STATE 0F F1.ORDA', AS RECORDED N PLAT DOW $ PAGES T AID 2 OF THE I usL NECOROS a ST. tLtf?F CDYNn FLORIDA. NOW LVIN0 ALO MOO N NOUN RIVER OOLI 9 FTLINDA AND THE NORM 200 FEET OF AN ABANDONED FIOLLS IEiE1S1 FARMS RAENOAO RIGHT OF WAY. COMMENCING AT THE NORTHWEST OOflMER OF TRACT 4434: THENCE S 00.3053' W A DISTANCE OF 16.40 TO THE PONT OF KO61ICA THENCE S SW26'3C' E A DISTANCE OF W&4W; THENCE S 007W7W W A DISTANCE OF F6.W; THENCE N BIT '30' W A CST OF 641.50: THENCE MM A CURVE TURNING TO THE HEFT NTN AN ARC LENGTH OF 12.57. MTH A RAMS OF &W. MM A CHORD BEARING OF S 4571'15' W. MTN A CHORD LENGTH OF 11.37.; THENCE S WWW" W A DISTANCE W 261DW; "404 MM A WRVS TURNING TO THE RXNT MIN AN ARC LENGTH OF 315W. NTH A RADIUS OF 24.00. MTI/ A CHORD BEARING OF S 4674V1' W. 44TH A CH ONG LENGTH OF 34.SW.; THENCE N 6772'14' W A DISTANCE OF 124.5W; THENCE N 027716' E A DISTANCE OF 1100': THENCE S 67"14'14' E A DISTANCE OF 133.00; r4cmrE N 0070$3' E A owmi CE O' 2S&39': NICU IS THE.P4R OF GEONMNO, HAVING AN AREA OF 1677CL73 SQUARE FEET, 636 ACRES PARCEL 'B' EASU"T COGICAOD: OFSCIITION OF EASEMENT OWCAYW TO THE CITY O' FELLSMERE, FROM FOtMTANS OF FELLS ERE. SITUATED N PMT W TRACT 1434 AND 1135 OF THE 'PMT OF F9fFeaee FARMS COMPANY S WWSON OF ALL UNS7RR£TED PMT OF TONFSHP 31 SOUTH, RANGE 37 EAST N ST. WCE 00LNTY, STATE OF FLOIf e. AS ROCOMND N PLAT BOO( 2. PARES T AM 2 01 TME wI6Ue ARDS W ST. NYCE DOCILITY, TL LA, NOW LYING THIO TEND N NDIAN RIY R COLRRY. FL016DA AND THE NORTH 200 FEET OF AN ABANDONED FT ASMEIE FARMS RALROAO RIGHT OF WAY. COMMENCING AT THE NO ITNIIEST CORNIER OF TRACT 1434; THENCE S OOWS ' W A OSTARCE OF 3 &W. THENCE N ar&4-V W A DISTANCE OF T S O2'37'Ir W A DISTANCE OF ta9.9e' TO THE PONT THENCE S 073Y1a' W A DISTANCE OF 10.00; THENCE S ffM44'E A DISTANCE OF 649.27; THENCE N 0737'16' f A OSTANC E OF 10.00' THENCE N 67W44'W A DISTANCE OF 649,22'. WKN IS THE PONT OF 6606NNG NAVNG AN AREA OF a49LOS SQUARE FEET, 0.15 ACRES S 02'37'16' W POB 10.40 P 17 SOT SLUE j PARC N OT3T1W E I( i 16.00• g .G PoB D 11 Lm N0G;M5 1 2Ie.aI B' Sam j 26610 DISTANCE I z � � PARCEL A'—_ m TVALT'ff3S = j i R."Ar T t $ 7X4GTNLT4 ; i DIE .IRHE.8ar2WtrW {��, I�� 2 i ; I � i N029Tt6�E tow 7 1 ( BEARING OF S 7510$ IE NM A CHORD LENGTH OF 41.40': 7NONCE L MM A CURVE TMa/D TO THE RIGHT NM AN ARC LENGTH qF 30.87. '$ j N aao'3W3Ww YX., 1 tl.OW., 22&16'; THENCE NTH A CARVE TURNING TO 11E LEFT MM AN ARC PARM 'C' ' IINW FT OF WAY DEDIrAI 0: N =E % m PARCSYC f1 I FROM FOWTANS OF FEU -%I E STUATm N PART OF TRACT 1434 AND ; 1435 OF 111E 'KAT OF FFLL.SMFRE FARMS COMPANY SUBONWSON OF ALL I L,$ N009tVPE I Mor m TVALT'ff3S = j i R."Ar T t .G_-i2'14SY'� mro , F C LEN.a6.av 1 R i tq .IRHE.8ar2WtrW {��, t � X•24000 R-2do ; `R��SIO.O• CLEW41-q J�iT2rIT 6A6i47S7684W 1 ( KOMPTION OF A RIGHT OF WAY DEDICATED TC THE CITY 0f FaImIENE, C LEWSIAW �$ 9RGKR IN 20.'E , FROM FOWTANS OF FEU -%I E STUATm N PART OF TRACT 1434 AND ; 1435 OF 111E 'KAT OF FFLL.SMFRE FARMS COMPANY SUBONWSON OF ALL I L,$ N009tVPE I Mor UNSIAIEVED PART OF TOWNSHIP 31 SOUTH. RANGE 37 EAST N ST. INCE ' mt .•.-_. COUNIY, STALE OF :HONDA'. AS HCCORDm N PIAT BOOL 2. PACES 1 AND 2 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF ST. UX>E COUNTY, FLORIDA NOW -_. 80P31LW W ' j ' LUNG AND BONG N MOAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORA mro , F AND THE NCIH 200 FLEET Or AN ABA DOLED FELLSMO P FARMS RAILROAD RICHT OF WAY. # COMMENCING AT THE NORTHWEST CORNEA OF TRACT 1434; THENCE S =I ✓ ' 00'30'53' W A DISTANCE OF 31139: THENCE N 6744.' W A DISTANCE p a o OF 133.01' TENCE S 0277'16' W A DISTANCE Of 199.96': THENCE S i 3 6T2744'E A DISTANCE O' 689.16 TO THE PONT OF B60NMNO; R H THENCE S 6772'441= A OMTA14M OF 327.11' TNDOM N 027riCE A � DISTANCE Or 21sT: THENCE WTH A CURVE 111R111G TO THE LEFT MM SI AN ARC LOD1H OF 41.45'. VAIN A RADNS OF 240.08, MM A CLHOO m BEARING OF S 7510$ IE NM A CHORD LENGTH OF 41.40': 7NONCE L MM A CURVE TMa/D TO THE RIGHT NM AN ARC LENGTH qF 30.87. '$ MM A RADAIS OF 95.07, 44TH A C10ND BEMDID OF S 6179'11' W. A CHORD LENGTH OF 36.69'„TNENCE N 8772'44' W A DISTANCE OF °Y{ 7XI�R1.7G 22&16'; THENCE NTH A CARVE TURNING TO 11E LEFT MM AN ARC LENGTH OF 27.7W. MIM A RADIUS OF 42.3W. NTN A WORD BEARNO OF 3 71VO41' W. MM A CHORD LENGTH OF 27.30. NIICI 15 THE PONT OF BEGINNING, It HAWX AN AREA OF 361567 SQUARE FEET, 0.08 ACRES 0' 200' 400' CF"F1EDTa CITY OF FELLSMERE O4prNBIN AtNY 416I10rA .e 1BN RIGHTOFWAY EASEMENT CHARLES ARNOLD DATE SIGNED DEDCIATION ++Lt• 'A'N'��w.t'�'iB iiF�iFwT N'wF7�1R s EPROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR & MAPPER THIS 13 NOT A BOUNDARY SURVEY FLORIDA LICENSE NUM13ER 4971 7PARNOLD SURVEYING, INC. lam a^�SHEET ROFE6NOIIAI SURVEYORS iMAPPERS P1g1 90h SKETCH AND DESCRIPTION FLORIDA LA:DOWWUMANOR no a CITY O INF FELLSMERE NN1R1641FW11MTI4fA F01RFBINL ROAIM fIla1 0.01' Fr ,�. WMATED N PART OF TRAM I” AND 1476 17 �O+naRnlNR�s��aM W4 FIS UNSURVEYID 1pMOW V1 SOWK. PAN4Q W EAR OFTCa gm40Ei211 FAX(M46641214 FBNFO RNV D.N.0, taa12s01 E,x41131T 14" P26 BK: 2993 PG: 307 December 12, 2016 Joel Tyson, Mayor City of Fellsmere 22 S. Orange St. Fellsmere, FL 32948 RE: Preliminary Acquisition Notice (07.02) dated September 18, 2015 FOF Equestrian Trail Dedication — Attached and Labeled Exhibit A Dear Mayor Tyson: This is to acknowledge receipt of your Preliminary Acquisition Notice (07.02) dated September 18, 2015 ("Acquisition Notice). Fountains of Fellsmere, LLC ("FOF") acknowledges its rights under the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 ("URA'), including, specifically, the right to obtain an appraisal of the property referenced in the Acquisition Notice and the right to receive just compensation from the City of Fellsmere (the "City") for such property. Being apprised of these rights, we have elected to release the City from obtaining and providing FOF an appraisal and from the need to receive compensation for the certain parcels to be used by the City. Instead, FOF elects to dedicate to the City the parcel identified by the sketch and legal description attached hereto as Exhibit A ("Subject Property"). Consequently, there is no need for the City to obtain an appraisal or make an offer of fair market value to Milzam as required by the URA. Please acknowledge receipt and acceptance of this letter representing FOF's waiver and release under the URA for the Subject Property. I look forward to our continued collaborative effort to achieve the mutual goals of FOF and the City. Sincerely, FOUNTAINS OF FELLSMERE, LLC By: MIRZAM NTURE CAPITAL, LLC By: CLIFFO R. MO S GER By: \QSWALD T. SOUSA MANAGER • qcar rFufure - Our 1`IA�fpq on IRS".o1N:lM:.4:.;y*v&•tW�Y%G+�e•..�"`rv• , 930W. INDIANTOWN RD. SUITE 2041 JUPITER. FLOR)DA 33458 j PHONE: (561) 741-3000 1 WWW.INVESTOPGREENCA LD.COM M1 RZAM P27 part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-0000-00003.0 and part of Parcel # 31-37-00-00001-1434-00001.0 donated by Mirzam Land Investment, LLC public purposes: stormwater management, recreation, trails and greenways; cultural facilities RESOLUTION NO. 2017- A RESOLUTION OF 'INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CANCELLING CERTAIN TAXES UPON PUBLICLY OWNED LANDS, PURSUANT TO SECTION 196.28, FLORIDA STATUTES. WHEREAS, section 196.28, Florida Statutes, allows the Board of County Commissioners of each County to cancel and discharge any and all. liens for taxes, delinquent or current, held or owned by the county or the state, upon lands heretofore or hereafter conveyed to or acquired by any agency, governmental subdivision, or municipality of the state, or the United States, for road purposes, defense purposes, recreation, reforestation, or other public use; and WHEREAS, such cancellation must be by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners, duly adopted and entered upon its minutes properly describing such lands and setting forth the public use to which the same are or will be devoted; and WHEREAS, upon receipt of a certified copy of such resolution, proper officials of the county and of the state are authorized, empowered, and directed to make proper entries upon the records to accomplish such cancellation and to do all things necessary to carry out the provisions of section 196.28, F.S.; P28 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: Any and all liens for taxes delinquent or current against the following described lands, which were donated by Mirzam Land Investment, LLC to the City of Fellsmere for use by the municipality for stormwater management; recreation; trails and greenways; and cultural facilities, are hereby cancelled pursuant to the authority of section 196.28, F.S. See attached Warranty Deed to City of Fellsmere, Florida describing lands, recorded in Book 2993 at Page 308, Public Records of Indian River County, Florida. The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner , and the motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: Chairman Joseph E. Flescher Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan Commissioner Susan Adams Commissioner Tim Zorc Commissioner Bob Solari I) P29 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day of March, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA .Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Circuit Court and Comptroller By: Deputy Clerk Tax Certificates Outstanding ✓ Yes No Current Prorated Tax Received and Deposited with Tax Collector $ APPROVED AS TO FO AND LEG "'L' SUFFI CY RY YLAN'REINGOLD OOUNTY ATTORNEY K3 P30 3120170001045 RECORDED IN THE RECORDS OF JEFFREY R. SMITH, CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT INDIAN RIVER CO FL BK: 2993 PG: 308,1/6/2017 4:17 PM SALE: NONE 11-1-16 DOC. STAMPS: $.70 This btstmmeat was pmp and by and stwnld be mt mad to: wave. W. Dill, Esq. Dill dt Evans, P.L. 1565 U.S. Highway I Sebastian. FL 32958 Parcel ID No.: ................................................. (Space above [leis line for recording data) ............................................... WARRAlYTY DEED This Warranty Deed, executed this**!moi _r` day of hC—E 4 L , 20 �, by M RZAM LAND INVESTMENT, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, whose address is 930 West Indiantown Road, Suite 204, Jupiter, Florida 33458, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", to, CITY OF FELLSMERE, FLORIDA, a municipal corporation existing under the laws of the State of Florida, whose post office address is 22 South Orange Street, Fellsmere, Florida 32948, hereinafter referred to as "Grantee". P7TIVESSETH that said Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), and other.good and valuable considerations to said Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby adrnowledged, has granted, bargained and sold to the said Grantee, and Grantee's successors and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, lying and being in Indian River County, Florida, to -wit: See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and by this reference made a part hereof: To Have and to Hold the same together with all and singular tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereunto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said Grantor, either in law or equity, to the proper use, benefit and behoof of the Grantee forever. Subject to governmental regulations, covenants, rights of way, restrictions, casements and reservations of record, if any, but this provision shall not operate to impose the same. And the Grantor hereby covenants with said Grantee that the Grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the Grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land; that the Grantor hereby fully warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. In Witness Whereof, the said Grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: WITNESSES AS TO ALL t Name: J . 4 ., >IS . d O. Print Name: A p (00049308.Doc.1 ) Miriam Land Investment, LLC, a Florida limited liability company By: Mirzam Venture Capital, LLC, a Florida limited liability c n any By: or .manager By: T. Sousa, Manager P31 BK: 2993 PG: 309 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged 'before me this 19;( day of AtfM ler 2014 by Clifford R: Morris, in his capacity as Manager of Mirzam Venture Capital, LLC, who is _21M nally known to me or who has produced a Driver's License as identification. SEAL jBOGDANA COLLADO MY COMMISSION # GG048778 ylEXPIRES November 18, 2019 STATE OF.FL DA COUNTY OF M I �"Qoly NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLORIDA Type or Print Name: %A ji0it/A t' 4A.DO Commission No.: 6 FFS My Commission ExpiresA&V/i • 2004 The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this %1* day of A'cLmier , 2014 by Oswald T. Sousa, in his capacity as Manager of Mirzam .Land investment, LLC, who is personally known to me or who has produced a Driver's License as identification. SEAL 4�% BOGDANA COLLADB c MY COMMISSION # GG048778 EXPIRES November 18, 2019 ,00049308.DOC.1 I NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLORIDAm Type or Print Nae: 0 ' q TOIL 00 Commission No.: &M irk My Commission Expires: AOV. - _-2015 WARRANTY DEED PAGE P32 BK: 2993 PG: 310 PARm 'A' NOW OF WAY DEDICATED: CO MPTIDN OF A RIGHT OF WAY DEDICA7M TO 7HE CITY OF FELLSIMM FROM MRZAM LAO NVLSTMENT LLC, SITUATED IN PMT OF TRACT 1434. 1435 NCI 1438 OF THE •PLAT OF FELLSMERE FARMS COMPANY SUBDIVISION OF ALL U45URVEVID PMT OF TOMNSHP 71 SOUTH, RANGE 37 EAST N Sr. LUCE COUNTY, STATE OF FLORIDA'. AS REOORDW MMT BOON 2, PALES 1 AND 2 OF THE PUIlU0 RECORDS OF ST. WOE COUNTY, FLORDA, NOW LUNO AND SENG N 8gIM1 RVER COUNTY. AND THE MO1TH 200 FEET OF AN ABANDONED N4Y A erne FARMS RA6RDAO ROUT OF WAY. COM IENCINO AT 7 E NORT11111M CORNER OF TRACT 1434{ ALSO SEND THE PONT Or SAN MMOL THENCE S x9'26'30' E A DISTANCE OF 88548': TENOE S 80'28'30' E A DISTANCE OF 28.97; THENCE S 8898'33' E A DISTANCE OF 693.35'; THENCE S 007199' W A DISTANCE OF. 823-80': THENCE S 87-22'44' E A DISTANCE OF 66T.SS; 1NDGE S 0079'32" W A DISTANCE OF 3502'; THENCE N 6722.44' W A DISTANCE CIA" TENCE N 0737'18' E A DISTANCE.OF 28.40': THEM E MTN A CURVE TU NI NG TO TME ROOT 44TH M ARC LEIOTX SIF 51.79'. MIN A. RADIUS OF 24600'. WITH A CNOD SEARING OF M 0628'22" E MM A CHORD LENGTH OF S1AW4 THENCE S 6772'44' E A DISTANCE OF 106.66': 7XONCE N 0071'00' C A DISTANCE OF 464.31': THOLE MRN A CLRW TIRbM1M. l0 TE LEFT WM AN ARC LENGTH OF 12.52'. MTX .A RADIUS CF 600'. MIM A CHORD BEARING OF N 44'1714" W, MM A CHORD UD47H OF 11.26'.; THENCE N 8906'33' W A DISTANCE OF 641.69: M04M N 6026'41• W A DISTANCE OF 29.86; THENCE N 0070'38' E A DISTANCE OF 16.00,'; IHELCE N 8926'30" W A DISTANCE OF NS.491; THENCE" 0070'53'r A OISTAMCE ISOG': WION 6 THE PONT OF SECIAININD. HAVING AN AREA OF 69906.1 SOME FEET. 1.6 ACRES tESS AND EXCEPT THE NORM 31' OF COMMUNITY ROAD WHO A 30' RIGHT OF WAY AS RECORDED N THE AFO ESA60 PLAT 8001X $ PACE 1 aM 2 ST. UNN COUNTY, FLORIDA PUBLIC RECORD$, NOW LYING N MOAN RVER CONTY. FIARDA PARCEL b' RCHT OF WAY DEDICATED. DESCRIPTION OF A ANINT OF WAY DEDICATED TO THE CITY OF FELL91ERL FROM wFaAM LAID NVE511ENT LLC, 517UA70 N PART OF TRACT 1434. 1435 AND 1436 OF THE 'PLAT OF FARMS COMPANY SUBOIN11" OF ALL UNAIRVEYFD PMT OF TDVMSW 31 SOUTH, RAHN 37 FAST N ST. LUBE CGUNTY. STATE OF FLORIDA*. AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2. PACES i AND 2 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF ST. WOE OOUNTY, . FLORDti NOW LYING AND BEING N MAN RIVER COUNTY. NO2'2Ft6�E 20A6 AND THE MOM 2OO FEET OF AN ABANDONED FEUD ERE FARMS RA6ROAD RIGHT OF WAY. COMMENCING AT THE NC117H EST CORNER OF TRACT 1434; THENCE S 897723" E A OISTAICE OF MSAO': T ENM S 897699' E A DISTANCE OF 20.97; 7HENCE S 699633' E A DISTANCE OF 666.35: THENCE S 00'29'26' W A OSTANCE OF 523.80': THENCE S 8rM4,C E A DISTANCE OF MAY: THENCE S 0079'32' W A OISTAHM OF 35.09; THENCE N 87-22'44• W A DISTANCE OF 1167.94'. TO THE PONT OF BEN6N/G, : THENCE N 8772'41• W A DISTANCE OF 540.84': TNENCE N OV37'tr 'E A DISTANCE OF 10.00': THENCE S 8772'"' E A DISTANCE K 37533: THENCE MM A CXXVf TURING TO THE _ LEFT MM AN ARC LENGTH OF 27.79'. MM A RADIUS OF 4209. NTH A CHORD 6EAWNO OF S 711393' M, NTH A OIONG LE40M OF 27.29'; MOCH O THE PONT a 6EOHINO, ye HAYNO AN AREA OF 3584.90 SMOAK FEET, 0.1 ACES 1� z,TO �N027r16'E /ARA2;t 8 SROM 00.2E2TE ,16 p Jl' NOD9tVVE fill 31I � l�Ri� sop395rw - -"'I .6NUATED N PMT OF TRAM AND UN { I '�'^•'4'O�'�'�^'�"'�' J A! ` OFFICE X77'2)400-6211 FAUX (772)4b1210 Pam .x,2 ?' I 7OP.FCrt434 z I jjjj�I�A j1 pq ! �! >E. t`. I•l u1!1 093710' E 10.00 PARC3L8�pp { N 007009' E 06 18 a a � , { iX AIA APEA� ' E ! Oryr.Al6.n. , • A SOB PARM B i1f�gz � g !� Al "UCrJ43S qqqZ,I _ 3 �R•24MG7 14•6rsror THE MOM 2OO FEET OF AN ABANDONED FEUD ERE FARMS RA6ROAD RIGHT OF WAY. COMMENCING AT THE NC117H EST CORNER OF TRACT 1434; THENCE S 897723" E A OISTAICE OF MSAO': T ENM S 897699' E A DISTANCE OF 20.97; 7HENCE S 699633' E A DISTANCE OF 666.35: THENCE S 00'29'26' W A OSTANCE OF 523.80': THENCE S 8rM4,C E A DISTANCE OF MAY: THENCE S 0079'32' W A OISTAHM OF 35.09; THENCE N 87-22'44• W A DISTANCE OF 1167.94'. TO THE PONT OF BEN6N/G, : THENCE N 8772'41• W A DISTANCE OF 540.84': TNENCE N OV37'tr 'E A DISTANCE OF 10.00': THENCE S 8772'"' E A DISTANCE K 37533: THENCE MM A CXXVf TURING TO THE _ LEFT MM AN ARC LENGTH OF 27.79'. MM A RADIUS OF 4209. NTH A CHORD 6EAWNO OF S 711393' M, NTH A OIONG LE40M OF 27.29'; MOCH O THE PONT a 6EOHINO, ye HAYNO AN AREA OF 3584.90 SMOAK FEET, 0.1 ACES 1� 600Y932W 1610$ .i 0' 200' 400' 35.02- CERTIFIED s.orCERTIFIED TO: CITY OF FELLSMERE n4m >fwwrM 4i Nw WONT M WAY CHHARLES ARNOLD GATE SIGNED E-04.0% • prM1�ML MK EASEMENT PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR& MAPPER THIS IS NOT A BOUNDARY SURVEY DEDCIA710N FLORIDA LICENSE NUMBER 4871 'N 007DSJ' E ISM i m PARMA EELS AND RNOLD SURVEYING. INC.SHEET PROFESSIONAL. SURVEYORS 8 MAPPERS C tE/N.6t.8W: /ARA2;t 8 SROM 00.2E2TE ,16 ROIRM NC6M4m NAN44l40 NMA1M06U 7441 NOD9tVVE m 4N 36 A ttlp w.mw.• .6NUATED N PMT OF TRAM AND UN '�'^•'4'O�'�'�^'�"'�' M T I 'OF UNIB RVE1'107 TOWNSHIP3160U1N, AMMO! 77 EAST OFFICE X77'2)400-6211 FAUX (772)4b1210 Pam .x,2 3-p• M34F2FVf Q1'7,3 600Y932W 1610$ .i 0' 200' 400' 35.02- CERTIFIED s.orCERTIFIED TO: CITY OF FELLSMERE n4m >fwwrM 4i Nw WONT M WAY CHHARLES ARNOLD GATE SIGNED E-04.0% • prM1�ML MK EASEMENT PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR& MAPPER THIS IS NOT A BOUNDARY SURVEY DEDCIA710N FLORIDA LICENSE NUMBER 4871 'N 007DSJ' E ISM i m PARMA EELS AND RNOLD SURVEYING. INC.SHEET PROFESSIONAL. SURVEYORS 8 MAPPERS -W-6, '�'1 SKETCH AND DESCRIPTION ,16 ROIRM NC6M4m NAN44l40 NMA1M06U 7441 AM p CITY Of FELL$MERE .raN. aMMwA4pMA44v..1A IORTPapL ARnAY. PPn A ttlp w.mw.• .6NUATED N PMT OF TRAM AND UN '�'^•'4'O�'�'�^'�"'�' M T I 'OF UNIB RVE1'107 TOWNSHIP3160U1N, AMMO! 77 EAST OFFICE X77'2)400-6211 FAUX (772)4b1210 Pam .x,2 3-p• M34F2FVf EXH-I % (-1 ••A P33 BK: 2993 PG: 311 (11�r- MIRZAM WYOTM GUM C- W December 12, 2016 Joel Tyson, Mayor City of Fellsmere 22 S. Orange St. Fellsmere, FL 32948 RE: Preliminary Acquisition Notice (07.02) dated September 18 2015 FOF Equestrian Trail Dedication — Attached and Labeled Exhibit A Dear Mayor Tyson: This is to acknowledge receipt of your Preliminary Acquisition Notice (07.02) dated September 18, 2015 ("Acquisition Notice"). Mirzam Land Investments, LLC .("Mirzam") acknowledges its rights under the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 ("URA"), including, specifically, the right to obtain an appraisal of the property referenced in the Acquisition Notice and the right to receive just compensation from the City of Fellsmere (the "City") for such property. Being apprised of these rights, we have elected to release the City from obtaining and providing Mirzam an appraisal and from the need to receive compensation for the certain parcels to be used by the City. Instead, Mirzam elects to dedicate to the City the parcel identified by the sketch and legal description attached hereto as Exhibit A ("Subject Property"). Consequently, there is no need for the City to obtain an appraisal or make an offer of fair market value to Mirzam as required by the URA. Please acknowledge receipt and acceptance of this letter representing Mirzam's waiver and release under the URA for the Subject Property. I look forward to our continued collaborative effort to achieve the mutual goals of Mirzam and the City. Sincerely, Mirzam Land Investments, LLC, By Mirzam Venture Capital, LLC By: CLI MORRIS MANAGER Mirzam Land Investments, LLC, By. OS D .SOUSA MANAGER 22u '"Fulure!Pamion 930 W. 1NDIANTOWN KD. SUITE 2041 JUPITER FLORIDA 33458 PHONE: (561) 741-3000 1 WWW.iNVESTORGREENCAPD.COM P34 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY MEMORANDUM TO: Jason E. Brown County Administrator DEPARTMENT HEAD CONCURRENCE: Stan Boling, AICP Community Development Director THROUGH: Roland M. DeBlois, AICP Chief, Environmental Planning & Code Enforcement FROM: Kelly Buck Code Enforcement Officer DATE: March 7, 2017 RE: Denis and Jennifer Manelski's Request for Release of Easements at 1925 Sears Cove (Sears Cove Subdivision) It is requested that the Board of County Commissioners formally consider the following information at its regular meeting of March 14, 2017. DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS The County has been petitioned by Denis and Jennifer Manelski, owners of three contiguous lots and an oceanfront tract at 1925 Sears Cove in Sears Cove Subdivision, for release of a 30 -foot wide private road and utility easement, as well as a 5 -foot wide walkway easement on their property. The purpose of the request is to eliminate unnecessary easements, in that the Manelskis own all of the parcels within Sears Cove Subdivision and are developing those parcels as one contiguous residential lot, such that the referenced easements serve no public purpose (see attached maps). The Manelskis have already recorded a unity of title in the public records, unifying the parcels for development as one residential lot (see Attachment 2). ANALYSIS The request has been reviewed by AT&T; Comcast Cable Services; the Indian River County Utilities Department; the County Road & Bridge and Engineering Divisions; the City of Vero Beach Electric and Water and Sewer Departments, and the County Surveyor. None of the utility providers or reviewing agencies expressed an objection to the requested release of easements. Therefore, it is staff's position that the requested easements release would have no adverse impact to access, drainage or to utilities being supplied to the subject property or to other properties. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends that the Board, through adoption of the attached resolution, approve release of the 30 -foot private road and utility easement, and 5 -foot walkway easement, as described in the attached resolution. P35 MANELSKI, DENIS & JENNIFER Release of Easement Page 2 ATTACHMENTS Maps depicting easement proposed for release. Recorded Unity of Title. Proposed County Resolution Releasing Easements. ease.becmemo proj./appl. no. 2016120098/78414 P36 .tet•. Sug��T \ wpm Lk'SiY+YITcI'�. _ _ aroxT ilm�lu mi.xelann.ro rni mirior�cwl drtn a 1xd.x THAT WIM OF THE NORTH 35HALF OF GRNNEM 0 FEET OF THE SOUTHOVE b wtlVATE ROAD aUTARY G•EELEM LOTS 1 AND 2 WHICH LIES EAST OF STATE ROAD A•FA IN SECTION 21, TWP. i\ 35 SOUTN,RGT:/OEAST,EXCEPT, HOWEVER. THE NORTH 150FEETTNEREOFI Lw and w. ,ere, AND THAT PART OF GOVERNMENT LOT 1 IN SECTION 22,TWP.33 SOUTH, RGE.00 EAST, WHICH LIES GETK'EEN AN EXTENSION EAST OF TIE NORTH AND SOUTH LINES OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PROPERTY TO THE ATLANTIC �•'^'" . (11 h 121 a Ne+rn: mrn •r•nw•x,nv'ati `novx l an a 1xQ m«vs�'1•mamMa regia. Mm n w �x m�:�i, n �eee'�irLam MTN :1e nm�mrz w`�im d o+o �a narwt.r bleLHa we a�.rt b1e iYT11 ON161M i:10 tnFlmMax�M�/Uel Ia 1RY[ OA OOlean MTOCMTlT1e1 W M U:Oa ewerc.ml M aunaY aaTA MxR1011e1x AMYC•aY! aaMxa1N11Ta d 01wrRx ety. r{Ax:W aTATYf[a,YO ALLRM[11 w FRNaa! Niexaw.: /Io, Nr aa1•Tx:e 1em1�Arx� eP WD OTo•L fAl Ax T1R L•ND VACva4 /xp jA_ALr_ t was x••.w [u•ITl RweilxID Wo Mweei rlwe CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL CERTIFICATE OF CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT 1 ala o. aLxnNe•, Ax •mNerNATa w rxa row Axe xnxea muxr¢wr d w NinAn uvaN owxn, nano•, • retrc:eac awomua a M st•n w wane, irn d r1aro. Baum dnroux afvel _ ea T•wun rtatwwowAxo,Tna wYwT<.. ma, 6. anxs amn:haxxmlra•rre:: m. wa•mmn, .re enllx uNNae.xu l<aa, •Ne � W 1eaaMei: C[Rf1rY 1rt •CC(Iwxt[ d T1aaltaT •110 a0 amem TNT RIl w R•Y AOOxt, NR t, a M 1¢Ma! d ve ema, n:YL[o•v d <1eeaA., erT•. • 11.1M xux:a I.-�. anNn MC1RWItoulrwamla c mntwm.nanw srxa f•oo' vleen — dNY• 1M••rt wAO AN6L,ER5 COVE'----- K•Ta00r a, MOL M —�� PLATBOOK 9 PAGE 8 DOCKET N2 ,soda .w� ' I �Rs�N►�N'r O �\ fS1 � I TRACT •A E r G x . it•� A -- CERTIFICATE OF DEDICATION c°Mw'frt'w weY. xM• ACKNOWLEOEhMNT M raaaarr narArwrt .0 •uxonAwm aaraa a,T1nx3^—'wrw ITAwcw - 1ne aY a� r< ar:wm •xo a•a nsmxma ,u 1NN� aac rcoaN Axe NAeT a xmex, ,1yc'U{.S� t11M ,O l.a AaT110I3 Y1nu.ellltla[fT/IatS,14VICIGYREl1uo.Wdlu�iuM[tOdT w wbl mai au�i d r,au'Au1 w'm �,ci ww>11APCeAO:ai•T TON. W RwKr w TYr Cwr®1•Ten. ATTACHME11T P37 SEARS COVE CERTIFICATE OF TITLE aroxT ilm�lu mi.xelann.ro rni mirior�cwl drtn a 1xd.x THAT WIM OF THE NORTH 35HALF OF GRNNEM 0 FEET OF THE SOUTHOVE N>wNm�xxxh noalw Mr •wrnrt uran r1n[ m M tANe xlscexce eN nax LOTS 1 AND 2 WHICH LIES EAST OF STATE ROAD A•FA IN SECTION 21, TWP. neMrm iu �ewcraclnicp li T°CD1x[�wd ina+wtr xw»ry 35 SOUTN,RGT:/OEAST,EXCEPT, HOWEVER. THE NORTH 150FEETTNEREOFI Lw and w. ,ere, AND THAT PART OF GOVERNMENT LOT 1 IN SECTION 22,TWP.33 SOUTH, RGE.00 EAST, WHICH LIES GETK'EEN AN EXTENSION EAST OF TIE NORTH AND SOUTH LINES OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PROPERTY TO THE ATLANTIC Qp /� OCEANI N1 LTINO AND BEING IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY. FLORIDA. Ne+rn: mrn `novx SURVEYORS CERTIFICATE•v an a 1xQ m«vs�'1•mamMa regia. Mm n w �x m�:�i, n �eee'�irLam MTN :1e nm�mrz w`�im d o+o �a narwt.r bleLHa we a�.rt b1e iYT11 ON161M i:10 tnFlmMax�M�/Uel Ia 1RY[ OA OOlean MTOCMTlT1e1 W M U:Oa ewerc.ml M aunaY aaTA MxR1011e1x AMYC•aY! aaMxa1N11Ta d 01wrRx ety. r{Ax:W aTATYf[a,YO ALLRM[11 w FRNaa! Niexaw.: /Io, Nr aa1•Tx:e 1em1�Arx� eP WD OTo•L fAl Ax T1R L•ND VACva4 /xp jA_ALr_ x••.w [u•ITl RweilxID Wo Mweei rlwe CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL CERTIFICATE OF CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT 1 ala o. aLxnNe•, Ax •mNerNATa w rxa row Axe xnxea muxr¢wr d w NinAn uvaN owxn, nano•, • retrc:eac awomua a M st•n w wane, irn d r1aro. Baum dnroux afvel fiNoeaer mrcm TNAr tm. w.•r Nu aQN UMwm b Arlan [LT1ex w rte r• aow, TNa aoae w oeuvrr mxxsslON[n d T1tt m:wn'. M maaNa:r:laim,lnrcurcoan MxAnbAaIeNMTae •1eM I,anw1 N•vw, r aAa wTNe aeerY tnwT a aow xrvrn ezuNTr, wale•, w x[rsr rae nAr rm..uTw•wa.smw•lwxmlur.wmnra..n:o-.:Anaw- rtatwwowAxo,Tna wYwT<.. ma, 6. anxs amn:haxxmlra•rre:: m. wa•mmn, .re enllx uNNae.xu l<aa, •Ne � W 1eaaMei: C[Rf1rY 1rt •CC(Iwxt[ d T1aaltaT •110 a0 amem TNT RIl w R•Y AOOxt, NR t, a M 1¢Ma! d ve ema, n:YL[o•v d <1eeaA., erT•. • 11.1M xux:a I.-�. anNn MC1RWItoulrwamla c mntwm.nanw CERTIFICATE OF DEDICATION c°Mw'frt'w weY. xM• ACKNOWLEOEhMNT M raaaarr narArwrt .0 •uxonAwm aaraa a,T1nx3^—'wrw ITAwcw - 1ne aY a� r< ar:wm •xo a•a nsmxma ,u 1NN� aac rcoaN Axe NAeT a xmex, ,1yc'U{.S� t11M ,O l.a AaT110I3 Y1nu.ellltla[fT/IatS,14VICIGYREl1uo.Wdlu�iuM[tOdT w wbl mai au�i d r,au'Au1 w'm �,ci ww>11APCeAO:ai•T TON. W RwKr w TYr Cwr®1•Ten. ATTACHME11T P37 "SKETCH EXHIBIT "A" OF LEGAL DESCRIPTION (NOT A SURVEY) ®GRAPHIC SCALE\ y100 0 w 100 LI I A� 0 Z ( IN FEET 1 inch = 10. ft. SKE7CH OF LEGAL DESCR/P770N NOT A BOUNDARYSURVEY PROJ. NO. 16 -039 -EASE Legend & Abbreviations: (symbols not scoleable for size) PLS - PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR PSM - PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR & MAPPER LB - LAND SURVEYING BUSINESS C- CENTERLINE (M�P - MEASURED VALVE (- PLAT VALUE P.B. - PLAT BOOK R/W - RICHT OF WAY O.R.B. - OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK P.O.C. - POINT OF COMMENCEMENT P.O.B - POINT OF BEGINNING {� (OA) - OVERALL CR - COUNTY ROAD SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION h PLAT OF SURVEY FOR: EASEMENT ABANDONMENT, RIGHT OF WAY ABANDONMENT AND EASEMENT CREATION o MERIDIAN 17171NRIVER BW�MEIpI vERO BEACH, FL. J2960 LBN6905 PNONE:772-744713, FA%:772-791-10% EMAIL. MLSLB690SQOMAILCOM y Q��wa 7 a MATCH LINE THIS SURVEY IS NOT VALID AND IS WCOMPL.ETE VATHOUT PAGES i OF 2 AND 2 OF 2. MATCH UNE S ! m a r4 u g�Q k t; z I:I 14 ItA 61 I 1 « 41k, 9Z I ;M h w � eo ``� I `p :d elle G I oa 4 s hi 'Ilia: at -U -k AZI t I i It zz, Td ti co M a 3120160063316 RECORDED IN THE RECORDS OF JEFFREY R. SMITH, CLERK O, .,IRCUIT COURT INDIAN RIVER CO FL BK: 2978 PG: 1703,1117d016 4:34 PM This instrument prepared by Bruce Barkett; Esq. Collins, Brown, Barkea, Gamvaglia & Lawn, Chtd, 756 Beachland Blvd. Vero Beach, FL 32963 DECLARATION OF UNITY OF TITLE WHEREAS, the undersigned are the fee simple owners of the following described property situate in Indian River County, Florida: Parcel I: That part of the North 330 feet of the South half of Government Lots I and 2 which lies East of State Road A-1 -A in S ection 21, Township 33 South, Range 40 East, EXCEPT, however, the North 150 feet thereof; AND That part of Government Lot I in Section 22, Township 33 South, Range 40 East, which lies between an extension East of theNorth.and South lines of the above described property to the Atlantic Ocean; EXCEPT, however, the West 969 feet of all of the above described parcel and LESS AND EXCEPT Lots 1, 2 and 3, Sears Cove, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 9, Page 8, Public Records of Indian River County, -Florida, Parcel ID# 33-40-21-00007-0001-00000/0 Parcel It: Lot 1, Sears Cove Subdivision, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 9, Page 8, Public Records of Indian River County, Florida. Parcel ID# 33-40-21-00007-0000-0000110 Parcel III: Lot 2, Sears Cove Subdivision, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 9, Page 8, Public Records of Indian River County, Florida Parcel ID#: 33-40-21-00007-0000-00002/0 ATTACHMENT 2 P39 Parcel IV: Lot 3, Sears Cove Subdivision, according to the Plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 9, Page 8, Public Records of Indian River County, Florida. Parcel ID#: 33-40-21-00007-0000-00003/0 SUBJECT TO easements, restrictions, rights-of-way and reservations of record; and WHEREAS, said real property described above are adjacent pieces of property; and WHEREAS, the undersigned has made or will make application for issuance of a development order which necessitates the above-described parcels being held in single ownership as one entire parcel. NOW, THEREFORE, the undersigned declares that such parcels will in the future be held and treated as one single parcel of land, which is not to be divided for sale; lease or transfer of ownership other than as a single tract; and FURTHER declares that the covenant stated herein shall be and constitute a covenant running with the land, binding on all future successors and owners of said Parcels, and shall be strictly enforceable by the County of Indian River County, Florida, in accordance with its land development regulations, and shall remain valid until such time as is released in writing by an authorized representative of Indian River County, Florida. WITNESS the hand and seal of the undersigned, this S7 day of rlov�rr4i3.Sr , 2016, Signed and sealed in our presence: 00A) lQ Cl4 w� Witness Name:1,1 i i i C Witness Name:�%rr,�s-%rs�., JL-ky'�' Denis Manelski 1804 O��n Drive, ero ach, FL Je er elski 1 4 Ocean Drive, Vero Beach, FL 32963 ATTACHMENT 2 P40 STATE OFfror:AA COUNTY• - The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this S day of Mo v , 2016, by Denis Manelski and Jennifer Manelski, who are personally known tome or who have produced F/o,.: j0 A as identification. (Not BEN C SALTZ Notary Public - State o1 f]2017 My Comm. Expires Jul 9,Commission EE 883Bonded Though National Nota Notary Public My Commission Expires: 7-9_x a )'j ATTACMIW-ENT 2 P41 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELEASING CERTAIN EASEMENTS IN SEARS COVE SUBDIVISION WHEREAS, Indian River County has an interest in a private road and utility easement, and a walkway easement, in Sears Cove Subdivision; and WHEREAS, retention of those easements, as described below, serves no public purpose; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County, Florida that: INDIAN RIVER COUNTY DOES HEREBY RELEASE and abandon all right, title, and interest that it may have in the following described easements: the north thirty (30) foot private road and utility easement, together with the north five (S) foot walkway easement, as depicted on the plat of Sears Cove, recorded in Plat Book 9, Page 8, of the Public Records oflndian River County, Florida. This release of easements is executed by Indian River County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, whose mailing address is 1801 27th Street, Vero Beach, Florida 32960. THIS RESOLUTION was moved for adoption by Commissioner , seconded by Commissioner , and adopted on the day of 2017, by the following vote: Chairman Joseph E. Flescher Vice -Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan Commissioner Susan Adams Commissioner Bob Solari Commissioner Tim Zorc The Chairman declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day of , 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court and Comptroller Deputy Clerk P42 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM: County Attorney ease.bccdoc proj/apl. no. 2016120098/78414 Cc: Applicant: MANELSKI, DENIS & JENNIFER 1804 OCEAN DR VERO BEACH, FL 32963 P43 h 1 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA MEMORANDUM TO: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator THROUGH: Richard B. Szpyrka, P.E., Public Works Director FROM: James W. Ennis, P.E., PMP, County Engineer SUBJECT: Work Order No. 1 to Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc., 66th Avenue Right-of-way Mapping & Surveying (57th Street — 85th Street) Indian River County Project No. 1505 DATE: February 27, 2017 DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS On October 4th, 2016, the Board of County Commissioners approved the Continuing Contract for Professional Survey & Mapping Services with Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. In December 2015, the Board of County Commissioners approved the 5 -year Schedule of Capital Improvements that split the 66th Avenue widening project into two segments—the first segment is 49th Street to 65th Street and the second segment is 65th Street to 83rd Street. On May 24, 2016, the Board of County Commissioners approved Amendment No. 16 with Arcadis US, Inc. to finalize construction plans for the widening of 66th Avenue from north of 49th Street to north of 57th Street which was part of the original 66th Avenue design contract with Arcadis US, Inc. (Phase 1). Work Order No. 1 with Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. is for finalizing the right-of-way mapping and survey controls verification, commenced in 2007, for right-of-way acquisition for the widening of 66th Avenue from 57th Street to 811 Street (Phase II) and the remaining right-of-way mapping between 81St Street and 85th Street (CR -510) for a lump sum total amount of $98,600. FUNDING Funding for Work Order No. 1 is budgeted and available from the following: Optional Sales Tax Account No. 31521441-066510-16009 66th Avenue (65th Street — 83rd Street) ($70,499.00) Optional Sales Tax Account No. 31521441-066510-07806 661h Avenue (49th Street — 65th Street) ($28,101.00) F:\Public Works\ENGINEERING DIVISION PROJECTS\1605 IRC Annual 2016 Professional Survey Services Contract\Admin\agcnda items\Work Orders-KH\WO-01—PCC Agenda_KHA_20170227.doc P44 PAGE TWO Work Order No. 1— KHA, Inc. For March 141h, 2017 BCC Meeting RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends the Board of County Commissioners approve Work Order No. 1 with Kimiey- Horn Associates, Inc. for a lump sum amount of $98,600.00 and authorize the Chairman to execute Work Order No. 1. ATTACHMENTS Work Order No. 1 with Kimley-Horn Associates, Inc. DISTRIBUTION Brian Good, P.E., Kimley-Horn Associates, Inc. APPROVED AGENDA ITEM FOR MARCH 14.2017 F:\Public Works\ENGINEERING DIVISION PROJECTS\1605 IRC Annual 2016 Professional Survey Services Contract\Admin\agenda items\Work Orders-KH\WO-01_13CC Agenda KHA_20170227.doc P45 IRC/Kimley-Horn Work Order#1 66th Avenue Right -of -Way Mapping Page 1 of 3 F7 R Board of County Commissioners Administration - Building A (South) 1801 27th Street Vero Beach, Florida 32960 Telephone: (772) 567-8000 FAX: 772-778-9391 Project: 66th Avenue Right -of -Way Mapping Indian River County Project # 1505 WORK ORDER NO. 1 (Engineering/Surveying) FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT ANNUAL SURVEYING and MAPPING/SERVICES WITH Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. In accordance with Contract No. 1605 This Work Order No. 1 is in accordance with the existing AGREEMENT dated October 4th, 2016 between Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. (SURVEYOR) and Indian River County (COUNTY). SECTION I — PROJECT LIMITS This Work Order No. 1 is for the SURVEYOR to perform surveying services to prepare a Right - of -Way map for 6611 Avenue totaling approximately 3.5 miles in length. The mapping limits shall begin at 57th Street and run northerly to 85th Street (CR 510). SECTION II - SCOPE OF SERVICES As agreed upon between Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. and Indian River County, the SURVEYOR shall provide Professional Land Surveying services to complete all tasks as outlined in this Work Order No. 1; specifically detailed in the attached proposal Exhibit A. SECTION III — TIME FOR COMPLETION & DELIVERABLESIWORK PRODUCT 1. Project shall be completed as follows: a. 100 % "Paper" review submittal (final review prior to final deliverables) shall be made within 120 calendar days of receipt of Notice to Proceed for review by County Staff prior to preparing final submittal package. b. Time of Final project completion shall be within 10 calendar days of receipt of the County's review comments from the 100% paper submittal. P46 IRC/Kimley-Horn Work Order #1 661" Avenue. Right -of -Way Mapping Page 2 of 3 2. Deliverables -The SURVEYOR shall provide the COUNTY: a. 100% Phase Submittal for County review and comment. All submittals shall include one (1) paper "hardcopy" along with Autocad files and an ASCII file for all survey points. County shall strive to provide review comments within 10 calendar days of the preliminary submittal. b. FINAL Deliverables, Two (2) paper "hardcopy" signed and sealed sets and one (1) signed and sealed MYLAR set in adequate recording fashion (I.E. Borders). One (1) Sheeted and model space (as applicable) AutoCAD drawing file in release 2013 or later, and one (1) PDF, all electronic files to be on CD. c. Survey set/sheets shall include a cover sheet with location sketch, survey certifications, and related title and project number; survey notes, legend and abbreviations and plan view sheets. d. Work product and digital versions are to be prepared and submitted so that the County or other consultants can readily use it for design and analysis of the area, as defined. It shall contain all information necessary for a third party surveyor to independently recreate or utilize the survey work. It is acknowledged all final products become property of Indian River County and will be available for use by the public at large. e. The SURVEYOR's work product shall meet or exceed the minimum standards defined by Sections II, III and IV or the COUNTY will not approve the SURVEYOR's request for payment. SECTION IV — COMPENSATION The COUNTY agrees to pay, and the SURVEYOR agrees to accept, for the above described services rendered as identified in Sections I, Il, and III of this Work Order No. 1 for a total lump sum fee of $98,600.00 All and/or any additional services not described hereon shall be pre -approved by the COUNTY. Approved additional services shall be invoiced at the rates disclosed in the approved fee schedule with the SURVEYOR for the contract year(s) of October 1, 2016 through September 30, 2018. All invoicing shall include Project Number 1505, Work Order No. 1 (WO 1), Contract Number 1605, itemize man-hours and materials expended to complete the scope of services. Payments shall be in accordance with the original Professional Surveying and Mapping/GIS Services Agreement, contract No: 1605 with the COUNTY and as stated in Section II, III and IV hereon. Remainder of page left blank intentionally P47 IRC/Kimley-Horn Work Order #1 66th Avenue. Right -of -Way Mapping Page 3 of 3 The AGREEMENT is hereby amended as specifically set forth herein. All remaining sections of the AGREEMENT shall remain in full force and effect, and are incorporated herein. IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties hereto have executed these presents this day of 2017. OWNER KIMLEY-HORN & ASSOCIATES, INC. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA —t --- Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman Approved by BCC, ATTEST: Jeffrey K. Smith, Clerk of Circuit Court and Comptroller Deputy Clerk Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency: Dylan Reingold, COUNTY Attorney Jason E. Brown, COUNTY Administrator Brid,n /� Gid; P.4, Sr. Vice President Witnessed by: (Signature) Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. cA40S -T (Printed -name) P48 Kimley»>Horn EXHIBIT A February 24, 2017 David W. Schryver, PSM Indian River County Surveyor Survey Section — Engineering Division 1801 27th Street, Vero Beach, F132960-3388 772-226-1386 Re: Professional Services Agreement Contract 1605 66te Avenue - Right of Way Mapping Dear Mr. Schryver, Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. ("Kimley-Horn" or "Consultant") is pleased to submit this letter agreement (the "Agreement") to Indian River County ("Client") for providing professional Survey and Mapping services. Our project understanding, scope of services, schedule, and fee are below. Project Understanding It is our understanding that Indian River County is requesting survey and mapping services for the preparation of a Right of Way Map for 661 Avenue totaling approximately 3.5 miles in length. SCOPE OF SERVICES Kimley-Horn will provide the services specifically set forth below. Task I — RiQht of Way Survey and Preparation of the Richt of Way Map This scope of services is for the preparation of a Right -of -Way Map for that portion of 6P Avenue lying between 57th Street and 851h Street (CR 510). (approximately 18,500'). This task will include and generally follow the items listed below: Order +- 55 Ownership and Encumbrance reports from the title company Research +- 55 parcels, plats, 20 Section Corners Recover Horizontal Control +-7 NGS/County monuments Establish Primary Control Recover and field locate Right of Way/Property Corners +-100 corners Review the Ownership and Encumbrance Reports P49 Kimley>»Horn February 24, 2017 Page 2 of 3 Calculate ROW lines for +-18,500' of 66" Avenue., including ties to 576, Street and 851h Street, and 13 Side Streets Monument and reference the baseline of survey Prepare certified corner records and set reference points for the section corners references Draft the Right of Way Map The survey and mapping services will be performed in accordance with Chapter 177 and Chapter 472 Florida Statutes and Chapter 5J-17 Standards of Practice as set forth for these types of surveys and the Indian River County Right of Way Map Checklist, attached hereto. This task also includes the cost of recording the Right of Way Map in the Public Records of Indian River County, Florida. SCHEDULE We will provide our services in an expeditious and orderly manner to meet the schedule mutually developed by the Client and Consultant for the various elements of the project. DELIVERABLES 2 signed and sealed copies of the Right of Way Map on 24" by 36" sheets. 1 signed and sealed mylar of the Right of Way Map suitable for recording. 1 digital AutoCad file and 1 PDF of the Right of Way Map. FEE KHA will perform the Scope of Services for a lump sum fee of $98,600 CLOSURE In addition to the matters set forth herein, our Agreement shall include and be subject to, and only to, the terms and conditions in the existing AGREEMENT dated October 4, 2016, between Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc., (SURVEYOR) and Indian River County (COUNTY) under the Continuing Services Contract No. 1605. P50 Kimley>»Horn February 24, 2017 Page 3 d3 We appreciate the opportunity to provide these services to you. Please contact me at 772- 794-4050 or cliris.demeter@kimley-horn.com should you have any questions. Very truly yours, KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES, IT, Chris Demeter, PSM Vice President Indian -River County Agreed to this day of , 2017. RI Witness: P51 0C— • �� INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA BOARD MEMORANDUM TO: Jason E. Brown County Administrator THROUGH: Richard B. Szpyrka, P.E. Public Works Director FROM: James D. Gray, Jr. Coastal Engineer SUBJECT: Work Order No. 15 CB&I Coastal Planning and Engineering, Inc. Sector 3 Beach Restoration Project 2017 Post Construction Physical Monitoring Services DATE: March 1, 2017 DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS On March 19, 2013 the Board approved a contract with CB&I Coastal Planning and Engineering, Inc. (CB&I) for professional coastal engineering services in Indian River County for a two-year term, 2013-2015. On March 17, 2015 the Board renewed the contract until March 19, 2017. CB&I is the selected County consultant for professional physical monitoring services related to the Sector 3 Beach Restoration Project and Sector 3 Dune Repair Project. The proposed Work Order No. 15 provides year 2017 post construction physical monitoring services to document the fill performance of the Sector 3 Beach Restoration Project Area. By Permit, annual Post Construction Physical monitoring is required following a large scale beach restoration project. The 2017 monitoring entails the following: • "Year 5" annual post construction physical monitoring of the Phase 2b project area • "Year 2" annual post construction physical monitoring for the Sector 3 Dune Repair project area Work Order No. 15 totals a lump sum amount of $43,977.80. All subsequent annual physical monitoring of the Sector 3 Project area will be addressed through future work orders. C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@28054043\@BCL@28054043.docx P52 Page 2 BCC Agenda Item Sector 3 Beach Restoration March 14, 2017 FUNDING Local funding of Beach Restoration includes a portion of Local Option Tourist Tax Revenue as well as allocation of the One Cent Sales Tax. Funding is budgeted and available for monitoring and for the Sector 3 Beach Restoration project in the Beach Restoration Fund, Sector 3 Post Construction Monitoring Account No.12814472-033490-05054. Additionally, this work order is eligible for 50% state cost through the Florida Department of Environmental Protection Beach Management Funding Assistance Program. RECOMMENDATION The recommendation of staff is for the Board to approve Work Order No. 15 to the contract with CB&I Coastal Planning and Engineering Inc. and authorize the Chairman to sign on behalf of the County. ATTACHMENT CB&I Coastal Planning and Engineering, Inc. Work Order No. 15 (1 original copy) APPROVED AGENDA ITEM FOR: MARCH 14, 2017 C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@28054043\@BCL@28054043.docx P53 WORK ORDER NUMBER 15 SECTOR 3 BEACH RESTORATION PROJECT 2017 PHYSCIAL MONITORING SERVICES This Work Order Number 15 is entered into as of this day of , 2017 pursuant to that certain Continuing Contract Agreement for Professional Services entered into as of March 19, 2013 ("Agreement"), and amended March 17, 2015, by and between Indian River County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida ("COUNTY") and CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. f/k/a Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. ("CONSULTANT"). The COUNTY has selected the Consultant to perform the professional services set forth on Exhibit 1, attached to this Work Order and made part hereof by this reference. The professional services will be performed by the Consultant for the fee schedule set forth in Exhibit 2, attached to this Work Order and made a part hereof by this reference. The Consultant will perform the professional services within the timeframe more particularly set forth in Exhibit 2, attached to this Work Order and made a part hereof by this reference all in accordance with the terms and provisions set forth in the Agreement. Pursuant to paragraph 1.4 of the Agreement, nothing contained in any Work Order shall conflict with the terms of the Agreement and the terms of the Agreement shall be deemed to be incorporated in each individual Work Order as if fully set forth herein. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Work Order as of the date first written above. CONSULTANT BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY By: Thomas P. Pierro, P.E., D.CE Title: Director Date: 3 1 1 1 Z V III By: Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court and Comptroller By: (Seal) Deputy Clerk Approved: By: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney P54 EXHIBIT 1 CBS February 17, 2017 James Gray Indian River County Public Works - Coastal Engineering Division 1801 27th St, Building A Vero Beach, FL 32960 CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. 2481 NW Boca Raton Blvd. Boca Raton, FL 33431 Tel: +1 561 391 8102 Fax: +1561 3919116 www.CBI.com Subject: Work Order #15 Indian River County Sector 3 Beach Restoration Project and Dune Repair Project Post Construction Physical Monitoring Services - 2017 Dear James: This proposal outlines a scope of work for CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. (CB&I), f/k/a Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. to provide services in support of one year of annual physical monitoring to fulfill FDEP and USACE permit requirements of the Sector 3 Beach and Dune Restoration Project constructed between 2010 and 2012 and the Sector 3 Dune Repair Project constructed 2014/2015. The 2017 Physical Monitoring Services entails the following: • "Year 5" annual post construction physical monitoring of the Phase 2b project area (R-20 — R-26+500), "Year 2" annual post -construction physical monitoring for the Sector 3 Dune Repair Project Area (R-24 — R-55). Physical Monitoring Report The Indian River County Sector 3 Beach Restoration Project and Dune Repair Project were constructed under permitting authority of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) and United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). These permits (FDEP permit No. 0285993 -001 -JC, FDEP permit modification No. 0285993 -008 -JN, USACE permit SAJ-2007-01645, and USACE permit modification SAJ-2007-01645(MOD- AWP)) contain permit conditions pertaining to construction and post -construction periods. FDEP permit condition 56 (d) requires an engineering report be submitted to the FDEP within 90 days following completion of each post - construction survey. We understand that the County's surveyor (or in collaboration with Sebastian Inlet District' surveyor) will perform the beach profile physical monitoring from R-15 to R-60, and be responsible for certifying the survey data and submitting a survey report to the FDEP. CB&I will review the data to ensure that it conforms to the standards required by the FDEP physical monitoring plan. CB&I will notify the County of any issues with the survey data and will coordinate through the County or directly with the surveyor to resolve any issues. CB&I will develop an engineering report that discusses the performance of the beach fill project. We will analyze shoreline and volumetric changes throughout the project area, identifying erosion and accretion patterns. The results will be analyzed for patterns, trends or changes between annual surveys and for cumulative changes over time. The project was constructed in three phases and the analysis will account for the phased construction. Furthermore, the report will compare the project performance to the stated design. Plots of the survey profiles, and graphical P55 .rCg representations of shoreline (contour) and volumetric changes for the monitoring area will be presented. Summary tables of the shoreline and volumetric changes will be presented. CB&I will collect aerials of the project area as discussed more fully later in this scope of work. The aerials will be collected from R-15 through R-60. Plots of relevant hardbottom and shoreline positions will be overlaid on the aerials and included in the report appendix. Considering biological monitoring is no longer required for this project, delineation of the edge of hardbottom is not required for the aerial photography. Deliverables CB&I will submit a draft of the report of the County for review and comment. This will be submitted electronically (PDF and/or MS Word formats). CB&1 will incorporate comments from the County and revise the report accordingly. CB&I will then submit an electronic copy to the FDEP. CB&I will submit one hard copy and an electronic copy (PDF) to the County. Required Data To perform the physical monitoring evaluation, CB&I will need the following data: Survey data in x,y,z format collected in summer of 2017. Schedule The draft monitoring report will be completed within 60 days of receipt of the survey data. We estimate that the County will review and provide comments on the document within 2 weeks. CB&I will revise the report, incorporate the County's comments, and submit a final report to the County and FDEP within 2 weeks of receipt of the County's comments. The goal is to submit the final report to the FDEP within 90 days of receipt of the required data. Assuming that data is provided by August 31, we estimate submittal of a final report by November 30, 2017. Cost The cost of the monitoring report, excluding the aerial collection is $27,642.00. A breakdown of the hours and expenses to develop these costs is attached and follow the provisions of the Professional Coastal Engineering Services Agreement (dated March 19, 2013) and Contract Renewal (dated March 17, 2015), between Indian River County and CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. Rectified Aerial Photographs Aerial photographs are required per FDEP special permit condition 56(c). CB&I will have aerials collected that follow BBCS Monitoring Standards for Beach Erosion Control Projects, Section 02100 — Environmental Aerial Photography Acquisition. Controlled, flight -dated, color vertical aerial photographs will be taken from Indian River County FDEP range monuments R-15 through R-60, inclusive. Collection of the aerial photography will be timed so as to collect the aerials concurrently with the surveys. CB&I will rely on Indian River County to notify us as to when these surveys are being performed. P56 The flight will be conducted on an incoming tide and when there is sufficient visibility in coastal waters to capture nearshore hardbottom. Film will be selected to provide the best possible images in the greatest possible water depths. Photography will be obtained during morning hours with cloud cover at less than 10%, and in order to minimize glint, the flight window shall occur when the sun angle is between 15 to 30 degrees to the horizon. If, during the flight, weather conditions deteriorate to the point that the purposes of the flight cannot be met, or the five flight conditions are not satisfied, the flight will be aborted and flown at a later date when conditions are satisfactory. The photography will employ the use of an aerial camera approved by the US Geological Survey. The camera will be equipped with a data block, which will record the lens number, calibration, focal length of the lens, altitude, date, and time. The photographs will be color aerial photography and geo-referenced digital imagery with the following specifications: 1. A minimum 60% overlap with each adjacent photograph and a ratio of 50% land and 50% ocean (2000' and 2000') on the horizontal. 2. The image will be clear and sharp in detail, free from clouds, shadows or any other blemishes that would render the image as uncertain for mapping rock and reef features as far offshore as possible and no less than -15 feet, NAVD. 3. Each frame will contain: i. time of day clock in standard time, ii. altimeter reading, iii. exposure counter, iv. camera identification number, V. lens focal length in mm, and vi. the plate ID number. Necessary ground control will be extracted from existing imagery sources and used in combination with collected ABGPS to rectify this imagery. It is assumed that previous control points can be used and have been previously surveyed. No additional field work is included in this proposal. Deliverables CB&I will provide the following deliverables to the County and FDEP: 1. Camera Calibration Report. 2. Flight Report — includes Flight Log, Weather Log, and Tide Log. 3. Individual geo-referenced image frames in uncompressed TIFF format and associated world files stored on DVD. 4. Mosaicked geo-referenced files in JPEG format on DVD. 5. MetaData - Complete federally compliant metadata file in ASCII or HTML format for the flight and image processing. P57 B Required Data CB&I may require additional survey points to rectify the images. We are proposing to sub -contract Aerial Cartographics of America (ACA), who previously performed the work, and they should have sufficient historic survey points to rectify the images. However, additional survey points may be required. Typically, the Public Works Department will have surveys that can be used to rectify aerial images avoiding additional field work. Schedule We will attempt to schedule collection of the aerials to coincide with collection ofthe survey data. Final deliverables related to the aerials will be submitted within 60 days of collection of the aerials. Cost The cost to collect the aerials and rectify the images is $16,335.80. A breakdown of the hours and expenses to develop these costs is attached and follow the provisions of the Professional Coastal Engineering Services Agreement (dated March 19, 2013) and Contract Renewal (dated March 17, 2015), between Indian River County and CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. Summary The total lump sum cost of this proposal for Work Order # 15 is $43,977.80. We appreciate the opportunity to work with Indian River County on this effort. Please call me if you have any questions. Sincerely, Michelle R. Pfeiffer, P.E. Senior Project Engineer CB&I Coastal Planning gineering, Inc. Authorized Corporate Signature �lhootas Printed Name Di recites of c7�o tY'vnS Title Please Reply To: Michelle Pfeiffer Phone: 561.361.3177 E -Mail Address: Micllelle.Pfeiffer(@cbi.com cc: Thomas Pierro, P.E. D.CE, CB&I William Reilly, P.E., CB&I P58 mOW0a151017 EXHIBIT 2 6TO RATES Am SPM ftEVlefON: 1017 -REV 171 ReMe, 0,tr. 4/7/17 ..._ PROJECT NUMBER:.ao00r PROPOSAL NUMBER: slentfla _ Ort.$-Mnp Modelo Prepared: IMMI7 Project Estimate Sumfty By Task IAC, WO'15 201TP steal Monitoring 02117M7 Taak Number Teak Name labor Sub• tora Conhac EqulpmerN Materials Otbef CDC'• Travel Total ASjustmenle Total Project 7311.001 SurAY0.1klb9eaond i 2,2110.00 i - i i - i i f 2211111.00 - i 1.290.00 Tak•002 ShorellmChanp.AftIfft 1 $405,00 f f - i • i i i 1,495.00 1 moon Tak-OW Voklmetm.opeAnMyd. S 9,570.00 f ! f f If • i 9,570.00 1 2,470A0 Tek -004 Report Deralopmam f 19,157.00 f f i i i i 10,157.00 f 1!,107.00 Tek 005 D....bren.ad Aylen f 1,202.00 i 15,199A0 i - i i - I - 1 15,996.50 f t9,975A0 TaMMS TnkName 0 Tak-M T..kN.ma7 4 • / i - i f TaW0o5 TOk MMO 1 - i f - f - f • . • f Te1o009 TnkN.na0 i - ! i Tak•010 Took Name 10 f 1 i Totals 15,193.110 f i • i 9; Itl77.10 4 f 47,977.50 SetankMd or. MW IMUS Pfeiffer euk'elmelr IRC Wb 152017 Phveiml Moneoml0 41dMb4en l.K D4n7117 F— eemk.c ee9.110a1.11@.00 I.— far Uv DD MMM YYYY Page 1 of 1 P59 PUBLIC HEARING INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA MEMORANDUM TO: Jason E. Brown; County Administrator THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP; Community Development Director Phil Matson, AICP; MPO Staff Director FROM: Brian Freeman, AICP; Senior Transportation Planner DATE: March 6, 2017 SUBJECT: Proposed GoLine route changes associated with the opening of the new Main Transit Hub It is requested that the information herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of County Commissioners at its regular meeting of March 14, 2017. DESCRIPTION & CONDITIONS The GoLine is Indian River County's fixed -route public transportation system and is operated by the Senior Resource Association (SRA). The GoLine's Main Transit Hub is served by seven routes, which connect at the Main Transit Hub each hour. For the past several years, the Main Transit Hub has been located at a temporary facility near the Vero Beach Regional Airport. A permanent Main Transit Hub facility is currentlyunder construction on property owned by the City of Vero Beach located at 1225 16th Street. Construction of the new hub is anticipated to be complete by the end of this month. The new transit hub will consist of a 1,732 sq. ft. structure with restrooms and open air waiting areas, 3,410 sq. ft. of pre -manufactured aluminum structures that will provide covered walkways and shelters for riders, and 1.6 acres of site improvements that include parking, lighting, landscaping, and stormwater treatment. The primary funding source for the project are grants from the Federal Transit Administration and the Florida Department of Transportation. The transit hub facility will be used by approximately 800 passengers each day. The new hub facility is expected to begin service on Monday, April 3, 2017. Because the new hub is located approximately two miles from the current hub, a major reconfiguration of all transit routes accessing the facility is necessary. While the transit routes have undergone major changes, nearly all existing bus stops will continue to be served. In some cases, bus stops have been moved to a nearby location in order to accommodate the reconfigured routes. No changes are being proposed to any bus stops or current routes located north of 49th Street. C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@1C05DCFO\@BCL@1C05DCFO.docx P60 In advance of the implementation of the new routes, SRA is posting notices about the route changes on all buses and at all major stops. In addition, a full page ad featuring the new route map will be published in the March 20 edition of the Press -Journal. At that time, the new route brochure will be released to the public and available on the GoLine website (golineirt.com). At the March 14th public hearing, SRA and County staff will make a presentation on the proposed changes to the GoLine routes. RECOMMENDATION The purpose of the public hearing is to provide an opportunity for public comment on the proposed route changes. No action is required at this time. C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@ I C05DCFO\@BCL@ 1 C05DCFO.doex 2 P61 i _ --47- .i ^''.":,'.'' •,J6ihA� ii �s:Y, ...:ni:?cii: i = "Cen wui. _ .y �lr' :* `•�:i:t:� �©•�< iiYC6a..,':;,;. ;�;;ie:•:: ..,i6c.,.( r:Mn ,�>'. r>p�.:'," ,. •-_.:',. ,� s i.-• ,,e,tla.�r,wvats:::.: ?:.��€:�: � i`r ",see `,:�F`3.'^ -,�'. .V F�:is+i?i�ii� iNFHPRi ie3 i •��,''�'>� S�\, MAIN � <;., e.- _ � 8]Jid S��m• - � i:?� ii ;x, ..��.' w�„i;p;, �. ;4:•3;1` F..: _ :.x:°; ii' _ l!'M°"d�3Ce+�lro",a: . • :tiw' ivr ::: € !; titi i �.`. , °FIUIE115TON. PARK- HUB�x:: ic.s A ?eotrtE a` . ?�°ic " 5'daetts +r!'�.�4• �� "gJ`,ytiy}'�; �. �f. �:.�y F. .SC �{. � .:.'. y,'�1�. .. - M1dri:��. .: "y`.:}_.r.•,C'r"�. ,�.::.:. .tAC•',s•:i��_g Y: Y. - •i�FAOi�il7H iF`:.'ft 1,{ "[a _ ^..q.. .'# a•Y„ ';J;`.":. _ �OEk1RiM8i,,l a1147V11 HtJCRi$ - _ - •,{bt.Jd 't` :.::�'. ;:i•€-,�i�•---: €o- .� = h����N' fir:; �p�:J ;,� ' • {�na�arRmior,., t •. �iasdst�; `�i%?Yi"�'' ''.rYr _ �.: canaEx' JIM iL ,' .:4••�'�• E#�+t� y4 - i ar'L .;g'.: �[�€i 'i1i9h�A.. :.r.:.r(�'��... .t�..��'p�•€�.:i, i�.. Ad1•_18��Y..ri:k9F,i't°' �:tf,V°'..�d?'o!"d('14^y'-r!•qt•:6�r']':�•. t. x 1 , ry� fiVI ia:fGs :_ d{t +'y t+j `=�:}'ir!�� •.ry•�'.•�•....: �-€P• [/'.Z-.> +mak i:�'�+'44+�'a'-�. L ?d„'a�C'.:: , i� '.' k. �, '�• iii;7 ROU1F 14 ! � • � Fl 't'� ' +�� �,t.�r. �•r'§i� �_. � _::;::i" 'iAlw'ST/EyWKE�'/AY6LW , 1] s ROUTE4 ')•. 'gH�1\�y'�y J+:h x _ �:i : ..... ....:.. .i y�'�i?%: QQ �*,g7 ham'} h*s�.� fix. ',"''• t ........—..::::-cn-1:-.—s.— r...r..r..r.,........,----»y N•ya ;......y...i. ME • ---- RY�., ._ -- •[:::::, •' .,.. _.::Kria'rx"ih � mCoeVA:r yp S r .• . :, 1 c 4R"',�,'.•',.", �.P�.RiNNRNHR ftp?i:na�iee�:i. ;.r - S /�" - y ,3JhY .i iiii•%�i"� ���'-`i FE2Eisir,: ,�...�::. E:. �� .:C+�' ::':i. , _ -------- ?ii: • ��' i.• r .ii.�'•-'�S: ' .::'..i3?'E?'[€3iii�� i'.iE� is €i g:i: � �.�` CiY Noto �t .... .� i ` .6 Y .✓.�' _ _ r ::?r g ..zy�,. .. , W. i0. eCi ? e?iRi?€ii€-�eo�h;, sa..: .�' - _y� `a� .�:. _ :."Y:^�_ �c"I r,:'.•.i2?ri;iiE iiei -�' .rte^:^ 1..:::,. - la'�M y L.. �.��;.,°�:; cu,.; Ia€i `r, ; ��•'•, .....,.i€"l c?r�tii2::: .si - - -[',:` : Mgio• Fl 15'- `�. =.t' ..:�•.x � 4tig`:� r - :IdM�$... ` i PARK• .P _ ° 3 Yi�•'ii'�ie:.:e:V ���V?�!�"'ua. V 'Mer;•�I�i:' P�PC;.�r,_•:.. i::>: r , . '$.- i-, n-,, Y: ��•••�••'.�'•'�.'•�:�� L1� �y L; vyxx::i: :.. •�9.1',}�' .4z,,," `. 6SC I+EAtiRomytNprp,gfg,. ti, .Y!�'x''_ (•iac 2e,5; 'r r:Cg :y:. �'•�'.. '.J1+OOlAlIY•:. •-_ a •L t_'F�S.rY?! - _. i:.' x. T & f, a� 'OaVmIDI.:>y�. .h ��'^"y''r^���"#:�"�• - �>,'�.:. F_ta .., �f:1 •.��+[c z xta9; v"�r•ed>ylul'�4 ::;\ T - :�` .'Fast:��' ; :�•,r�..,.� ��i ~ t�.ii:!� r^r�sLmwmCona�y-`.!.:'�t� � _.���' - ::::;��•..:= �: �sa�.,..,�,,,�i�aab,. •' VEf20';BEACFI ' �f ,`,, }.r} _� .. Mii i '� '.n:: ��. ' •�' • iii• i E7� ' • - :� "�'-i 3. f eeEi' •�''i "� i,J:'. Sv.L�z}[+rrn�,,.,M9,�. •1•)iMSL .- sA�' .. �3. •: `�' 3/16/2017 61-4 . . . . q/ -- 17 ( -'-L��- � . | ' , ^ ' . . ' .' . . . � � ^ 1 ^ ` . � ^ � | � . ` ....L....,...:;:.�Y::::::::.:� :,a : ............::.. .....• Y.:::_ssY•::::. , "r� siEiei: F�k�. • [. u: :F'. :w_'si Dde -.1., (°%i�E�i, r a,,....:.:i:d: ^^''' - •�IS,.�fi, __ Liii�:#is�;:�.:i ' - 3-:r',',':•.l':°'•''•'YMV? "A' E�y qri.. ;• n�'::i � ��iei��2: � ,�:z Ei ............ L.:.: • •:,Yi:'.:"4 >_..•:: ." ..¢3.��ri %::r.:ee sem-.' � $f� -: {- , ; ', ?', ,i '+�-'`'-;P: " R . ri'e EFFSirt°.a...::: ." _ � � i� 's'r;�e�'�;e e;;"�,r�ey:. ..r:�`;, •�„'r'.... :.:: un it - ••old - +1 .� lil.'L'iM35#[ai5' �t ':E;, �_ V•' i\. .: S.." :•:: ::. 1.�: �i«;......... S..E:;:l�Ftih1. ^L,L:::.N....:::.�L....[. .:�:Y ........_ .. <:.%:::::::;Y;'.::.i:::::::::.: .. p.__ Dom'' " fie• kp giE2i2EEii c ..... Y. LT.. E,!�t.:...'A:Sa; :'•:•' .�.' f,r x-. 3'�1D51%dYD50d9 � �e�r$';. •.is"'�l li,�'���•�{t�'f ��....". �, •._ � o•. r f .......•-a:.. .7'?„a�n�",.••',•',�,^.'..'•.:°'.EiE fir ::k :iE E::iS:s:;r^ .� :x E ::::Ecp„-::::� ::^L:?: �EE::x:e ::::;:;r'„ :: ;. ..... .::•::: LaY•rr,.Y::e;.;..:: ....:a ,•h x:iY�.:rS:..;a ::.:^::h. -r r :":%c:FiE .%:: i .........G:C:::::: � '..: ":Y... C. % ............ d:.....,a..b...;::::::}I . k ......................... ! ' "• � � fEL EitEElEa�iL':E� x:Y'u'p::i � EiiEiii _aie:'?,:::> ` • ;+.. .. •La.;a.: � .�.....r. "'�"...............R•a:: ....,.. •. '� •�.. EiEie:::::::� ?' � seYi� EeF:eie::: - it ,........ L.....r ... «e as ,, :::: ._...... .. q .� �x«•:::: ••r:Ea::::Y::: °::: �. �::::::: �::: ....5:::••� .x :'', 5:.' .. .......... ....... k ...�;.%. .:. - °iE+�eiE;%:FSS: n;;.. .:S` _ '�ia'yle.,•--EEEEE�:E'::d ........... ?i .:............."..,....... .�s �: •�• � Sig iDSSF:Ei..'K!ii � � r.i:a::::%ESFi� FE:E; ;. i�#� _ ::.<i. �s :,,;_ _._ru f.;:..... •. iRi•• ............yY....• :r.: ...... sq r., a:%ai:::::� :X:: �:::%:::, a . ' ... , �� rw"y,, a - - - Dp, :%•.. iS .... ..... ..•„s::; S:::L:.':: :07s+k '•r,,�;.rY :i: • .::g::,:r.::::r::Y:a #.: ::x .. s ;;;;.Y:` .'0,., :e :.:... hx;.; i. s:i{;x'°i• ^ tir.'eiEs aG• Na ::i€;ud •r3�,....:r "xEE 's ...u:� 2� EiiS'rii:iiE::eS= •: :%IiiitiF.iiii': � EE:':... f� `tea, s';�2::i:.. x .-se: iX:: .ke: 'r:':i ..' •:F.L:.; ifisu?',, �.. s:.:::, �: :: "i; ii•;. 'i d^.a. + _-""�'7;` �'-zj. '-"'k :::' iuiE:: .,,.%::::c E� is2i, 't.c:Y•.•Sit L TU it '; - 1} •• uS 1 % if3=KMN7+Clti• �.� ' :E':Ei .. _.h-`.•".•. ......,.�, :Y .:E:::!: :::::::- �.:` �...... 5 ....,.. .......... i:jE, it .....:..%YY.j._..:::...%: _ �t�,'L:q._:�::::>a•:i?::::::::: iii ia'':Sa:E: I ri::S:E:..SiS::::e:.;�c::... :%zi: �. ..,C7i R71NSiT��_. 'w.; ' MADJ:iF.' _�,.:.� .? J,?w:•ihi�rFei�mf �, xe.::: L _'FNDIANIRFVER'N1Illl,�Eiiii - y NU6}- $•-i ,< �yp� �J aY+ `"` s_ - '�EBFa4 some L pi aeTr51.h...yS''°•� ;3: t fv J• �Dt. �:e.F �n,.....taS3; :2r •iE•:ir-^ SSiES9€ `:F.o �9.•'kA c<.:c :a�ya""•,•, 'ZEe ? v .••.xa }:'®e'Fn ,[Ya :: ___ _ �f... _ �sA^:3�F_•.� DIY✓ •��i-•..” � � �-r-,-;<yi^'• ... �• a y! �pq� > .�, ,�.y.� - 1 Fit:::�• �:: ii`P. If i.1:..' ..j:::.::%.:•`,ji' ::: - �+'>��,'.'y dt7O.MY:-¢v: y is -, : ••�.•'�, :s ni::,: PIP, ••L:Lt••!�Ei,EEi !r.Zip la,$)�v 3/1+��/2017 61-6 a =m '::S: U=;Mzt� ............. ............... . ...... -_n 'N ic;im :t; t� u I . ........... . I V mm:m, W=N M4=== zx4, ... . ...... ..MW. ;rM;1 A . ;- u .!: . z�...............16...ilk_ Q1 �;m p ,4 IN $TRANSIT, :;ftT ns�tMtjbr�t­ . ..... ..... .Y K!j7 i 4", q IMF; 'TNI -i Mi. UT, 7 sEEE lw-uc - ?a ST/o5caF<MXA 01 -.0 4®r.21"" IME lit, ic. F .. ........... . .... . ......... 0 3/1,x/2017 x,1-7 3/1,L/2017 ME Important Dates -Ribbon cutting at New Hub • Monday, April 24 -New Hub Begins Service -Tuesday, April 25 3/1y�/,2017 CJ_ 9 ♦ r r � t, 1 '' '' y � � � iO_ 0 r�a IT T• •t"tY � --;i � �` �"'tflca'`,Yay'�i � + ,•o _ .'i �.:."^ �:•,� 3 - o, - s ^E� Lr •��;t'�� ,..'' t`:.�' ,fit � �l T," _ ' AU �� `�✓t o.� -�• ®� $ • � i � s. Ham.NZ ♦ . s .Ir 'V + ue,1..,c5 GoogieJ 6 �'Gi.-S`•S i 9a0 ■ .AVE .. i Key Points • Nearly all current stops will continue to.be served • Some stops will now be served by a different route • New service areas added • Royal Palm Pointe, Old Dixie Hwy, US 1 @a 12th Street i • No changes to any routes or stops north of 49th Street • Improved service offerings to Mall/SR 6o commercial area j from Gifford (Route 14) and South County (Route 7) {� • Secondary hubs: f • IG Center, Gifford Health Center, Indian River Mall - _ ;_f�; - 'r.lit:iiee� iii eii�Girf}"', Ylt r'• f - ., 3, . - OWN . '" �+�� •},ri•'t-: :- L� sc: � Via: :F �:: '-i?�vtr,!;�y� ew• ,j— :iii-� ,y, `'t �* X X1 .•7:� i^iiia:: �i: ...... - 11��...- r. .... r •f� ". LOW'ir: . . o v� i� _ �e�t. r� ........ ::}' :tr::: w «ww i i` 4, "r - I ? x�. :tJ •> s���t = t: e•�^'Pii J: ~"Y,r :iii' a r;;. °7!' •� - _ ": fr k. M mai, -ling Us `::tt:::. ^••moo.:::.:::::: ........�:i�iiiii ...._,.. .: : ': :: i... �. -i� ' �� .w t.L'ii ' � �•! , '4- X - ST! 1 .t. :viwbr�'S� . � y. -R"'^'^"• :^:t:l.........:... � ^seYiii aae i ,.E3 l ��°i .• ::a1a:::a:: :;: • [: it .: --,, vy � Y: ......:tiii, �................._ WIN �:.............. �:: is #::;...... :'tlri• ....... L... ,e . •• E::: ..:, i5 !S':w"e;aoe ............. a:::::::::::d..xe ....... ....... ... ra11: x:;aL.. L:i21ii. . ............. :::•::ilia:. :::::::: :': ..........................aai °iii.:a• e'a°err....,' a ;�i... � ..: � :'� " . 9A ?:. ' '"}!0x[ - : :.;•...tat .,. I:.:u ...:: '. .'.•� ^.-. -.":.." 1...:,� r.:•" -. :lea :- �'...., • xJL'.:::.��t ... ............... . '. Yom- AW `• nil '::: Leo:.' i'y'rL liu ...� . 1•:r'::::: bE'PeiEt L, ✓ • ter ..........., y ''?eaa?ie (P •'r E ............ z 3/1/2017 '61. 3 I Treasure Coast Newspapers I TCPAJLM Indian River Press Journal 1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32960 AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER Before the undersigned authority personally appeared, Sherri Cipriani, who on oath says that she is Classified Inside Sales Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida: that the attached copy of advertisement was published in the Indian River Press Journal in the following issues below. Affiant further says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published in Vero Beach in said Indian River County, Florida, and that said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, daily and distributed in Indian River County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that she has neither paid or promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. The Indian River Press Journal has been entered as Periodical Matter at the Post Offices in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement. Customer Ad Number Coovline PO # 463755 - INDIAN RIVER CO PLANNING DEPT 1506840 Meeting: 3/14/17• GoLine Meeting: 3/14/17 Pub Dates March 3, 2017 Sworn to ands cr aefore me this d of, March 02, 2017, by who is Sherri Cipriani (X) personally known to me or ( ) who has produced as identification. Sandra Coldren Notary Public ;�.•••••m�-,, SANDRAGOI.DREN =* * MY COMMISSION # FF 004035 a= EXPIRES: April 1, 2017 Bonded Thru Notary Public Underw here GR -10 F O N CO) LL ' oticeTO Creditors th"sMrney are set form All creditors of the decedenyt and almother or demands ag est odeC enesfe Sthataa <hom a paa is ired to be served toast file their )aims '!h this court ON OR BEFORE THE TER OF 3 MONTHS AFTER THE TIME OF THE FIRST PUB- LICATION OF THIS NOTICE OR 30 DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF SERVICE OF A COPY OF THIS NOTICEO HEM. other titer creditors of the decedent another PIKS'"' having claims or demands agSlnst docedenrs errata t foe Nets claims with this Court WITHIN 3 MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF THE FIRST PUBUCATION OF THIS NOTICE ALL CLAIMS NOT FILED wl - IN THE TIME PERIODS SET FORTH IN FLORIDA STATUTES SECTION 733.702 WILL BE FOREVER BARRED. NOTWITHSTANDING THE TIME PERIOD SET FORTH ABOVE, ANY CLAIM FILED TWO Q) YEARS OR MORE AFTER THE DECEDENTS DATE OF DEATH IS BARRED. The dateat first publicadon mt this notice is: M_1,3.201L Shim d this 8th day of Febm- Y.2017. Personal ReGresentaWe: VIRGINIA t. STARR 8569 5w Sea Capptain Drive Att me yfor Personzt99T-9323 ReBI Ga Doane, Es Florida Bar N. 062163a Doane A Doane, P. A. 2000 PGA Boulevard, Sai te443o Floripda 33408 Tole Emlailhone:(561) 65fi-0200 9tlone@do aanelaw.com Secondary EmaR: g orrigan _ doanelaw.com: dwiR9m scdoanelaw.cOm Pub: March 3. IS / TCN 1508993 Names) I. which assessed: """""' SHEILA CUETO AKA SHELIA pub: February 10, 17, N,March CUETO 3, 3011 TCN 1504950 Jzuto,.Dea)er DlrecE27 W_uta Dealer pireCtory f 'iAUtODealer Directory_ pq O^Q WALLA ECHRYSLER VEROBEACH CHRYSLER WAl1ACE HYUNDAI WALLACE GRIECO NISSAN -:----.--�- 23555E Fedeal 8555 US` 30015E Fe0eral LINCOLN MERCURY Sales/Service High y, Stuart 800-335-2966 Hwy., SNart 5555 South US 1 FL Pierce 4815 S US 1 �UCO DCeIC CIHCLLO 132-230-3600 verobeachcd.cem Tit-1&3-6PP0 1.800-329-6060 3-088-328J235 f r ry GriecmNissan.com D GAToo Cx rslcx j WALLACE DODGE WALLACE JEEP nz 64x645. WALLACE CHD Stuar DDaGEI 1 Highwa, Stuart 23555EFedeal HigOway, WALLACE MAZDA fid 3555 SE Fetl rel Hwy.,SNart Drive Atittle•SareA Lot Highway, SNart Stuart Tn-3263600 33255E Federal WALLACE VOLI(SWAGEN bTl-60fi-0562 DS -S, M-Iboume 732-2263fi00 Hwy., Stuart 28055E F¢deal Highway, WLortLrwys1 Mt VEIMBEACHIEEP 806335-1999 SNart WALLACE CHEVROLET , - - (32UT249611, _ _ VUDEnP 865 S. US ONE Tlb2t9-0GOT 2111S111,111 velde-fae,Pm� 806315-2966 WALLACENISSAN Hwy Stuart rXRBaIfll (IBC 488 USH 1 vemleach d.com 4313 SE Federal Hwy., WALLACE YOLYO TTb28T-3E32 o' 1a��� u VERO BEA Studrt 3801 SE Federal Hwy., Stuart 172.569.3/aD, 772 -286 -BOOR 666-x63-4201 IC H I Treawre Coast Newspapers Friday, March 3, 2017 SE Cq� Wiest fpreldS equRst f9r Bids NON SEQUITUR INVITATION TO BID NOTICE OF PROCUREMENT NO slCE ESYGIVENewed FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES ` `Ds R'S ZTuplpl SITE 1T 6XPLARJ6 ed bids will be by �i0 MIKH_. the City of Felismere `mfl 2:OOPM (time) on March 31, REpU- FOR QUADFlCATONS (0.FQ) bidsof beaopIn'dtifar the foBOwmR or"— CONSTRUCTION MANAGER Pursuant to Section 297.055, OLD SCHOOL CULTURAL Florida Statutes, the State Fl. ridaeCgom.1t.tl Com- --' (NFOZt MAT(DN _- on is, als, pfe mU,tkmX Act and the State Requirements for _� mate ,chi,e7ry equipment, labor and ub'li- ties re construct a_ storm. Educational Facihties(SREF), the DISTRICT BOARD OF E L e b water treatment famlity and ted inlets TRUSTEES OF INDIAN RIVER STATECOLUIEwiliconsider azs and ovens, manh0les; t lawns: an the trading of a CON - yw••- t plaza; an event Stage; STRUCTION MANAGER (CM) for -� parking: "'Caltile- o E landscaping, eroviding professional for the following IntiIks: dig butnotlimitedse' be base, construction pro)ecC _ - rad¢, 'since urs. stormwa- Surface Surface cos 'Pro1'Rdl man gement building dllar- Renovation of Radio Station WpCS pu - onstm<nan and nededtocompletethe specified canshuctI'" Its (Building Lacat<datmelRSCfrt Pierce Main Campus Uaee specitiwlly In the Bid uments. 3209VIr91nia Avenue, Fort Pierce, Florida 34981 Bids may be sent by mail to be t hand IiYcmd '•Prolec[11 peed App lCatlM ITdX Deed ApplitailOn to 22o South Oan Street, Felismere, Florida 32948. Replacement of thelndurtdal Bulding(Building 0) Bens will be publiclyy opened Located at the 5554 within 2 workin days of Yourr¢c_Ipt of this [ice I—the oroperty at chcer- atlreadaloudatth have trice 1, mediate) follow- y (RSC Maintampus 111209 Yr ginia Avenue. f ApPhca4on tar Tax Oeem If you are hearing or voice IN. shall bewld to the MAR - highest bitltler at me MAR- Ingtheaove-stated dosing Hme. Fort Pierce, Florida 34981 paired, call ill. TIN COUNTY COURTHOUSE COMPLEX, 1ST FLOOR Bids received after the time euslness entitles interested in Pub:February24,March 3. 10. OF THE CONSTITUTION- setforlhe0penin [the bid: std<red providing construction man- 17, 2017 TLN 148708] AL OFFICE BUILDINGJUAY will net be 'a rind will be returned '"Opened gement SB a for the Indian River State Collegge MANAGEMENT ROOM,100 5E OCEAN BLVD, SMART FLOR- bj-ct to the provisions of Subject Instructions to Bidders. (RSC) projects are hemby ratified rthat Nair 'State. NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR IDA 36991 at `0:00 A.M., on the l6m day of March, z017. gad CCPtionsLf ifi- b^ TA%DEED tog plans sp ations and other Wddllog a tialsritfmustt" m.dimiived the IRSC Purchasing Depart- NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that an, ddiflorid i utIminfi toes. o documents am a0n file in the above office andpen for meet a[ ]209 Virginia Ave- nu Bu00iig 9, Room 229. HMF FL E LLC the holder of the following certificate has public Insgee¢fan. Complete any and Fort Pierce, Florida 14981- 24. p.m. fled said certitIbe Imeds) to a WxdThe corofinee n,mb,r CAROLYN TIMMANN, &COMPTROLLERT COURT PI... nnectfinetlos ther bid Ing documents an maneayerMa'h Submittals rete d after and year of uance, the Marim County. Florida may be obtained by apply- that date/time will of be ties description of the proper{{7vY7 andna laws[ Sue Konney Deputy Clerk Inc,[[7008 list Street. Vero Beach. FL "so al a cost Pi interested bulur-an may submit for ane or beth stho az aszesse Depelaz fn with a diiabilita a ho ne"'Iran' ds a ' to 555.00 oar each sd of Plans a tl Contract Documents pro)ectz. Instructions for ca ple- Carhic.-He: 1231 Year Of Issuance: June -01-2014 ac mm dation in Order in this proceed- hich non -r fundable. Additional complete sets of bidding documents will be Uon and submission of the Lortstrudion Manhaement Statement of p life.- Description of Property: TWIN LAKES SOUTH CONO BID. L UNIT IS participate 9. You are entiUed, at no c t t0 yo', to the provision of certain assistance. Please available at acpit of $55 A0, ......fundable. [Ions' y be obtalnetl M me INC Office of Facilities 3638.41 -POS -013-01020.40000 Said praDerry being [he contact Sue Konney - 100 East Ocean Boulevard Stu - A n -mandatory, Pre -Bid Fting III be Aeld t Lity S. b Sustainability, 3209 n- ginia Avenue, Building S. County Of Martlm State of Florida rt, FL 34994. (Po Box 9016, Stuart. FL 34995) at 772-26B- elismere Hall 21 Cypress Street, Felismere, Room 233. fort Pierce Flori- da 34981-5596 or pre{ rably Nome(s) in which ass¢sse0: lOAN D. BURNS 5559 within 2 worMn9 days of Your receipt of this NofK FL 32948 on March 34, 2011 by e -mailing Your request to Unless aid rtificate shall f Application for Tax Deem Bt IX00AM. All eotential idders. pOten[ial 0 -con- dynchicim edu calling the Office of Facihlies E be redeemed occur in to law, Mepro�arty tin wch ter- if yno are hearing or Yalta impaired. call 711. Vactora suppliers, eft. are to attend, Sustainability tit 712-962- 1360. IRSCreservesthedght tlficate shNl be sold t0 the highest bidder at the MAR- Pu b: February 10, 1T. 24, March 3,2 17 All burged ids shall be submitted on Me Bid Proposal farms pro- m waive any informality in the selection process and In TIN COUNTY COURTHOUSE COMPLEX.1ST FLOOR TCN 1469907 BI dsyecAds urityenthecamtount of pual'di ationso05[atement of Rl OFFICE HE CONSTITUTION. NOTICE OF APPLICATION fmuSt eCCOnmpany)thet5ea<he Id PZpyj <bruary 24,MarcD ], 1P, OCEAN BMANAOELIVDSTUARTENT IOG FLORE FOR TAX DEED roposal ofeach builder will be Ouired follows: TCN (491247 IDA 34994 at 10:00 A.M., on the 30th day of March -2011. NOTICE IS HEI(E8Y GWEN that EVERGREEN ASSURDY COM - c zhher's check, a certified Icbeckorasuretyhondpay- Property is wed bjed to PANY the holder of the fol- bee to the City t Felismere. aX Deed Appli[at(on Y dgi[is _Sodnding taxes. I�in9 rtificate has fled dcertifw[eW tarot' Deposits will be tum ed to fulbidders. If the NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR TAX DEED CARDIN TI."A1FN, Eeed to be d there- Thlcortificatenumber and Cam act is awarded to a Bid- der, that Bidder shall enter NOTICE IS HEREBY GNEN that CLERKOFCIRCUIT COUpT &COMPTROLLER year of i uance, the tl... th on of tM1e property, into a Contact with the City furnish the CAIENOVin CREEK FUNDING Martin County. Flonda Sue Konney and me nasi In which k waz assessed are as follows: Pntl paired erforma nee d payment ^LC the balder pi the follow- i rtificate haz tiled said Deputy Clerk Bonds nil Certificates f Insurance of fprteit the Bid adjN,Rhd,) for a taxdeed to be issued thereon. The )f you ,are a person with a disabilito ho Beds any Certificate No: 1256 Year of Issuanc June -01-2009 iBOnd r security as lip's Eamages. c rtificate and year c mm dation in order to l dated A Contract I be executed within tom number f iss a the descry- [ion the rty, d participate in this proceed are -'I". atn0 0¢xription t Property: MONTEREY, LOT I8 BLKa �(30) days fPllowingthe and 0} pro me ria<me(s) in wb"ch it was 5.yo t t t0 you, to the provision Please 0?38-U-006-006-00280.70000 Haid property being in the of the successful bitltler T C City reserves the 0Pght tp asses dareazfo8ows: of certain assistance. tact Sue Konney - 100 County of Martin, State of delay Ne awarding f the Contact for up [o sixryP(60) Certificate No: toil Yearof Issuance: June -01-3914 East Ocean Boulevard Stu- rt, FL 34994. (PO Box 9016, Florida tl ys atter the bid 0 Ing. t i f ItBe DescriyyHon of Property: 9 Stuart. FL 36 995) at 7192.288- 5551 Names) In width assessed: COBRA INVESTMENTS INC. Y b d y PALL CAtitTTY AMENDED LOT fthm.2 of [his Ntaive of all bidsVinrwhole or Innpart with or without cause xS to 1T-3 8-11-0 01-013-0 0 0 9 010 0 0 0 9 id aroeerty Dein9 the Application for Tax Deed; H You a hearing or voice Unless said certificate shall to redeemed cording to besrst Egm tte bid IS in j°u,diy f Martin, State of pati Feb u�aryll24� March 3,10, th If he shz11-b soo1E to the erests Pf the City. February 28, 2011 Name(sj in whitli azsessetl: 1i, 2011 TCN 1481102 MShestbiddttatmeMAR- TIN COUNTY COURTHOUSE _Dphd: 1EKYLL & HYDE PROPERTIES COMPLEX, IST FLOOR Mark D. Mathes. CommunityDevelOpment Unle s said certificate shall be deemed according to OF THE CONSTITUTION- AL OFFICE BUILDING,IURY Director Pub: March 3,2017 law,r[he propertymsuch ter- tifcate shall be sold to me MANAGEMENT ROOM, 00 SE OCEAN BLVD, STUART FLOR- TCN L907597 highest bidder at the MAR- IDA 34994 at 1000 AN, on REQUEST FOR SEALED E -BID TIN COUNTY COUPTHOUSE COMPLEX, ]ST FLOOR the `6m day of Mardi, 200.. is Sald ubject 10 Req j.% for Sealed Electronic eT .-IF CO NSnIxUT'OPN- NOTICE OF APPLICATION FORTA%DEED Property =I C5 tltlibonal outstanding Names) I. which assessed: """""' SHEILA CUETO AKA SHELIA pub: February 10, 17, N,March CUETO 3, 3011 TCN 1504950 Jzuto,.Dea)er DlrecE27 W_uta Dealer pireCtory f 'iAUtODealer Directory_ pq O^Q WALLA ECHRYSLER VEROBEACH CHRYSLER WAl1ACE HYUNDAI WALLACE GRIECO NISSAN -:----.--�- 23555E Fedeal 8555 US` 30015E Fe0eral LINCOLN MERCURY Sales/Service High y, Stuart 800-335-2966 Hwy., SNart 5555 South US 1 FL Pierce 4815 S US 1 �UCO DCeIC CIHCLLO 132-230-3600 verobeachcd.cem Tit-1&3-6PP0 1.800-329-6060 3-088-328J235 f r ry GriecmNissan.com D GAToo Cx rslcx j WALLACE DODGE WALLACE JEEP nz 64x645. WALLACE CHD Stuar DDaGEI 1 Highwa, Stuart 23555EFedeal HigOway, WALLACE MAZDA fid 3555 SE Fetl rel Hwy.,SNart Drive Atittle•SareA Lot Highway, SNart Stuart Tn-3263600 33255E Federal WALLACE VOLI(SWAGEN bTl-60fi-0562 DS -S, M-Iboume 732-2263fi00 Hwy., Stuart 28055E F¢deal Highway, WLortLrwys1 Mt VEIMBEACHIEEP 806335-1999 SNart WALLACE CHEVROLET , - - (32UT249611, _ _ VUDEnP 865 S. US ONE Tlb2t9-0GOT 2111S111,111 velde-fae,Pm� 806315-2966 WALLACENISSAN Hwy Stuart rXRBaIfll (IBC 488 USH 1 vemleach d.com 4313 SE Federal Hwy., WALLACE YOLYO TTb28T-3E32 o' 1a��� u VERO BEA Studrt 3801 SE Federal Hwy., Stuart 172.569.3/aD, 772 -286 -BOOR 666-x63-4201 IC H I Public Hearings INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES Date: March 7, 2017 To: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator From: Vincent Burke, P.E., Director of Utility Services Prepared By: Arjuna Weragoda, P.E., Capital Projects Manager Subject: Collier Creek Estates Subdivision Petition Water Assessment Project Utility Phases 1, 1A and 1B (UCP 4125), Public Hearing and the Adoption of Resolution No. III BACKGROUND On January 24, 2017, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners (BCC) approved the adoption of Resolution 1(2017-004) and Resolution II (2017-005) forthe Collier Creek Estates Subdivision Petition Water Assessment Project Utility Phases 1,1A and 16, located along Easy Street between South Wimbrow Drive and Englar Drive in Sebastian. Since the adoption of Resolution I and 11, staff mailed out letters to the one hundred and forty one (141) property owners notifying them of the preliminary assessment roll and the subject public hearing. Included in the letter was an invitation to an informal meeting held on March 7, 2017, at the Sebastian Yacht Club, 820 Indian River Drive, where project details and financing options were discussed. ANALYSIS The Collier Creek Estates Subdivision has 141 parcels benefitting from the water -main. The parcels vary in size. The average parcel size is 0.66 of an acre. Staff received signed petitions from 100 of the 141 residential parcels, or 70.92% of the property owners in favor of the project. The 141 parcels according to tax records are zoned as follows: • 21 Vacant lots • 120 Single Family Residential parcels The BCC, in its capacity to oversee the assessment process, shall meet as the equalizing board to hear and consider any and all support for, or complaints against, the proposed special assessments, and it shall adjust and equalize the special assessments on the basis of justice and right according to Indian River County Ordinance Chapter 206 (Special Assessments). The City of Sebastian was notified January 24, 2017, and at the February 8, 2017, City Council Meeting of the subject proposed water assessment project in accordance with the 1995 Interlocal Agreement. No objections from the City have been received. The subject assessment portion of the project will consist of installing approximately 9,600 linear feet of 8 - inch and 6 -inch PVC water main, with ten (10) fire hydrants as well as water services to each parcel. The proposed 8 -inch water main will connect to the existing 16 -inch main on S. Wimbrow Drive to the north and the existing 8 -inch main on Englar Drive to the south. The total project cost is estimated at $881,250, which includes construction, surveying, engineering, administration and inspection. Therefore, an equal per parcel cost of $6,250.00 will be levied against all 141 benefitting parcels once Resolution No. III is adopted. C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Tech nologies\easyP D F 7\@BCL@00065F03\@BCL@00065F03.docx P62 Staff will apply for the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) permit depending on the outcome of the adoption of Resolution III. The right-of-way permit for the City of Sebastian has already been submitted. If the BCC authorizes staff to move forward with the project after the Public Hearing, then staff anticipates the following schedule (please note that these dates are estimations and could be subject to change): ➢ Advertise for bids —June, 2017 ➢ Award Contract —August, 2017 ➢ Notice to Proceed (NTP) — September, 2017 ➢ Substantial Completion — March 2018, or 180 calendar days from NTP ➢ Final Completion — April, 2018, or 210 calendar days from NTP ➢ Final As -Built Resolution (Resolution IV) to BCC —June, 2018 FUNDING: Funds forthis project are derived from the Assessment Fund. Assessment Fund revenues are generated from connection fees paid by the benefitting property owners. DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT NUMBER AMOUNT Collier Creek Estates Water Assessment 473-169000-16515 $ 881,250.00 RECOMMENDATION Open the public hearing and after receiving input, consider adopting Resolution No. III with any revisions based on that public input. Staff recommends that the BCC consider the following options: 1) Adopt Resolution No. III with the following items: a. Cost per parcel of $6,250.00 b. One hundred and forty one (141) benefitting parcels as part of the special assessment lien C. For benefitting parcels above in point b, allow property owners to finance the capital cost of $6,250.00 for up to 10 years, payable in ten equal yearly installments at an annual interest rate of 5.00% (set by the BCC each January). LIST OF ATTACHMENTS: 1. Confirming Resolution (Resolution No. 111) 2. Assessment Roll C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@00065F03\@BCL@00065F03.docx P63 Public Hearing (Third Reso.) RESOLUTION NO. 2017- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONFIRMING THE SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS IN CONNECTION WITH A WATER MAIN EXTENSION FROM 699 S. EASY STREET TO AND INCLUDING 774 S. EASY STREET; 193 CHELLO AVENUE TO AND INCLUDING 209 CHELLO AVENUE; 100 BECKER AVENUE TO AND INCLUDING 109 BECKER AVENUE; 100 CHARLES AVENUE TO AND INCLUDING 108 CHARLES AVENUE; 738 HOLDEN AVENUE TO AND INCLUDING 786 HOLDEN AVENUE; AND 800 HOLDEN COURT TO AND INCLUDING 807 HOLDEN COURT, WITHIN THE SUBDIVISION OF COLLIER CREEK ESTATES, PHASES 1, 3, 4, 5 AND PORTIONS OF PHASES 2 AND 6, LOCATED WITHIN THE CITY OF SEBASTIAN, IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA; AND PROVIDING FOR SPECIAL ASSESSMENT LIENS TO BE MADE OF RECORD. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County ("Board") has, by Resolution No. 2017-004 adopted on January 24, 2017, determined to make special assessments against certain properties to be specially benefited and serviced by a water main extension ("Assessment Project") from from 699 S. Easy Street to and including 774 S. Easy Street; 193 Chello Avenue to and including 209 Chello Avenue, 100 Becker Avenue to and including 109 Becker Avenue; 100 Charles Avenue to and including 108 Charles Avenue; 738 Holden Avenue to and including 786 Holden Avenue; and 800 Holden Court to and including 807 Holden Court, within the subdivision of Collier Creek Estates, Phases 1, 3, 4, 5 and portions of Phases 2 and 6, located within the City of Sebastian, in Indian River County, Florida ("the Assessment Area"); and WHEREAS, Resolution No. 2017-004 described the method of assessing the cost of the Assessment Project against the specially benefited properties in the Assessment Area and how the special assessments imposed on the specially benefited properties in the Assessment Area are to be paid; and WHEREAS, Resolution No. 2017-004 was published in the Indian River Press Journal on February 7, 2017, as required by Section 206.04, Indian River County Code; and WHEREAS, Resolution No. 2017-005, adopted by the Board on January 24, 2017, set a time and place for a public hearing at which the owners of the specially benefited properties in the Assessment Area to be assessed for the Assessment Project and other interested persons would have the chance to be heard as to any and all complaints as to the Assessment Project and the special assessments imposed on the specially benefited properties in the Assessment Area, and for the Board to act as required by Section 206.07, Indian River County Code; and WHEREAS, notice of the time and place of the public hearing was published in the Indian River Press Journal on February 28, 2017 and on March 7, 2017 (at least twice, one week apart; the last being at least one week prior to the hearing), as required by Section 206.06, Indian River County Code; and WHEREAS, the land owners of record were mailed notices on January 25, 2017 (at least ten days prior to the hearing), as required by Section 206.06, Indian River County Code; and P64 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - WHEREAS, the Board, on Tuesday, March 14, 2017, at 9:05 a.m. (or as soon thereafter as the public hearing was heard) conducted the public hearing with regard to the special assessments; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows: 1. The foregoing recitals are affirmed and ratified in their entirety. 2. The special assessments imposed for the Assessment Project against the specially benefited properties in the Assessment Area shown on the assessment roll attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by this reference are hereby confirmed and approved, and shall remain legal, valid, and binding first liens upon and against the specially benefited properties shown on attached Exhibit "A" until paid in full. The special assessments for the Assessment Project shall constitute a lien .against the specially assessed property in the Assessment Area equal in rank and dignity with the liens of all state, county, district or municipal taxes, and other non -ad valorem assessments. Except as otherwise provided by 'law, such special assessment lien shall be superior in dignity to all other liens, titles and claims, until paid. The special assessment lien shall be deemed perfected upon adoption by the Board of this Resolution and recordation of this Resolution in the Official Records of the County maintained by .the Clerk of Indian River County. Such recordation shall constitute prima facie evidence of the validity of the special assessments imposed for the Assessment Project in the Assessment Area. 3. The special assessment imposed per parcel is in the amount of $6,250.00, and shall .be due and payable and may be paid in full without interest within 90 days after the date of the passage of the as -built resolution by the Board. The as -built resolution occurs after completion of the improvements. If not paid in full within the 90 -day period from the passage of the as -built resolution, then the special assessment may be paid in ten equal yearly installments of principal plus interest; said interest rate to be determined by the Board when the improvements are completed. 4. The Board hereby finds and determines that the special assessments imposed in accordance with this Resolution and Resolution Nos. 2017-004 and 2017-005 provide an equitable method of funding the construction of the Assessment Project based upon the current uses, sizes, zoning and development potential of the parcels which are equally benefited by the provision of water, and thus the allocation of the assessment will be equal per parcel as described in Resolution No. 2017-004. The Board hereby finds and determines that the properties assessed by this Resolution will receive special benefits equal to or greater than the cost of the special assessment. The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner , and the motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: P65 RESOLUTION NO: 2017 - Chairman Joseph E. Flesch:er Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan Commissioner Susan Adams Commissioner Tim Zorc CommissionerBob Solari The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day of March,, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS INDIAN RIVER .COUNTY, FLORIDA Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court and Comptroller By: By Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman Deputy Clerk Approved as to 711!z� By Dyla ' gold, County Attorney Attachment: Exhibit "A" - Assessment Roll (to be recorded on Public Records) P66 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •"" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE lA & PHASE 1B r PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BORTOLI-FERGUSON, WENDY Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 699 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT: LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 699 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner EDWARDS, JOSHUA B & VIVIAN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 703 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 196 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner EBERLE, RICHARD WAYNE & DEANN MARIE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 194 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 194 CHELLO AV F-\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessment s_2014_Proposed\ColIierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\Word Doc uments\Ol_A_Prel iminaryAssessmentRol l_RESO LUT ION_3_Phase_1_]A_1Q FI NAL_MERG E 03_06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P67 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES plol<� COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 �QR • Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LIVINGSTON, MARK A & ALLISON L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 193 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT: LOT PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 193 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner COLOMBINO FAMILY TRUST Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 1313 PALERMO WAY LANTANA FL 33462 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 5 PBI%OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 195 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LACHOWICZ, GARY A & NICKI LYNN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 197 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 197 CHELLO AV F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTI0N_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_FI N A L_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P68 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES"''" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B ��ID PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL —RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FJ WEBB FAMILY LP (1/2) & Secondary Owner #1 WEBB, FRANCIS (TR) )1/2) Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 1744 SOUTH BOWERS RD MILFORD DE 19963 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 701 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner EDWARDS, JOSHUA B & VIVIAN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 703 EASY ST S SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT: LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 703 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0001-00009.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner VERNON, CAROLYN J & Secondary Owner #1 VERON, GARY L Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 705 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 9 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 705 S EASY ST P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineenng\Projects -Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\ColIlerCreekSubd ivisionPhase_1 \WordDoc uments\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_i B_FI NAL_MERGE_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P69 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICESIR COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 113 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 tM.—W Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WOLZ, MICHAEL E & SUSAN F Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 200 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 200 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ALTVATER, HENRY L & EDITH E Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 202 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 202 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HARRINGTON, ROGER S (LE) & RANNELL L (LE) Secondary Owner #1 HARRINGTON, CHRISTOPHER R Secondary Owner #2 HARRINGTON, ROGER S 1R Mailing Address 204 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958-4595 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address I 204 CHELLO AV F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\Coll ierCree kSubd ivisionPhase_1 \W ordDocument s\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_7 B_FI NAL_MERG E 03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P70 yprrx. RIVERINDIAN COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 �NIiP� PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FORGATCH, JOHN D Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 640 KINGFISH RD NORTH PALM BEACH FL 33408 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT: LOT PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 206 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CRONIN, BRADFORD F & PAULINE T Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 208 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 5 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 208 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HEINZ, H DENNIS & GAIL Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address LAKESIDE DR BLOCK ISLAND RI 02827 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 209 CHELLO AV -- - ., -- ----. - -'• - - — - o z ." -s.. �: r.��r.a ; ,gam. _...- - F•\Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_201.4_Proposed \CoIIierCreekSUbd ivisionPhase_1 \Word Documents\Ol_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_IA_1 B—FI NAL_MERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P71 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES•- COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B � ." PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CHIECA, ROBERT & MARIE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 207 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 207 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DRESCHER, RICHARD B & ELSE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 205 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 205 CHELLO AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00009.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HOFFMAN, BRUCE M & NAHIR Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 203 CHELLO AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 9 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 203 CHELLO AV F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionP hase_1\WordDocuments\Ol_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTI ON_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_FI NAL_M E RG E_03_06_2017.d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P72 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES �;'. COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE IA & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 �n.�°r�' Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00010.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MCDERMOTT, THOMAS M (LE) & JOYCE R (LE) Secondary Owner #1 MCDERMOTT, JOHN J (1/2) Secondary Owner #2 MCDERMOTT, THOMAS M JR (1/2) Mailing Address 700 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 10 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 700 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00011.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SANDS, MARSHALL B & JUDITH L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 702 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 11 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 702 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00012.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GRACE, PETER T & KATHLEEN M Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 704 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 12 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 704 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_P roposed\Coll ierCree kSu bd ivision Phase -1 \WordDoc u ments\01_A_P rel i mi na ryAssessmentRoI IR ESOLUTIO N_3_Phase_i_IA_i B_FI NA LM ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P73 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00005-0002-00013.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CONLON, JOHN M & BETTY M Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 706 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5023 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE I BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT: LOT 13 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-11 Site Address 706 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0001-00010.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FORSTE, ROBERT & NANCY Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 707 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 10 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 707 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0001-00011.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CANNEY, JOHN & CAROLE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 709 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT: LOT 11 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 709 S EASY ST F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\Coll ierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1 \WordDocuments\01_A_PreIimina ryAssessmentRoIl_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P74 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0001-00012.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MCCARTHY, SUSAN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 711 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT: LOT 12 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 711 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0001-00013.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ALESSO, BRUCE & MARGARET Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 713 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 13 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 713 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0001-00014.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GEARY, JOHN E & NANCY R Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 715 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT : LOT 14 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 715 S EASY ST F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_P roposed\Coll ierCree kSu hd ivision 13hase_1\Word Docu ment s\O 1_A_P rel i m i na ryAssessmentRol I_RESO LUTIO N_3_P hase_i_1A_1B_P I N AL_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P75 cm INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0001-00015.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KINDLER, KENNETH LEIGH & CHERYL LYNNE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 717 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK A LOT/UNIT: LOT 15 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 717 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0002-00014.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LEEDHAM, R W (LE) & MARY (LE) Secondary Owner #1 LEEDHAM, MARY (TR) Secondary Owner #2 LEEDHAM, R W (TR) Mailing Address 708 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 14 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 708 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0002-00015.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HOLMES, CALVIN TRUMAN JR & TAMMY Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 710 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT: LOT 15 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 710 S EASY ST F \Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\Coll ierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1 \Word Doc uiiients\01—A—PreliniiiiaryAssesstiie tit Rol l_RES0LUT10N_3_Phase_1_1A_3 B_FI NAL_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P76 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A &PHASE 16 .�. PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0002-00016.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WILLIAMS, JACKIE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 712 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT : LOT 16 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 712 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0002-00017.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner NAGY, BELA G JR & ELISSA R Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 714 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK B ' LOT/UNIT : LOT 17 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 714 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00006-0002-00018.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ELFORD, JAMES R III & MARY JANE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 716 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5023 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE TWO BLK/BLDG : BLK B LOT/UNIT: LOT 18 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-39 Site Address 716 S EASY ST P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDOQl ments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI N AL_M ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P77 �IYi k„ INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES ;�� . .COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B �. ,;� PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 �"°�'` Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0005-00019.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FLEMING, BRUCE W Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 720 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT: LOT 19 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 720 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00023.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GALLAGHER, JAMES J & JUDITH EVANS Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 766 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 23 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 766 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00024.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner Confidential Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 24 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSAbd ivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_I B_FI NA L_M ERG E_03_06_2017.d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P78 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 -O'Dv, Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00025.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GABOR, MICHAEL & DIANA C Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 770 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 25 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 770 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00026.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CLINTON, BRIAN J (TRS)(TOK) & JOAN M (TRS)(TOK) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 772 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 26 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 772 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00027.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HALL, PATRICK & SHARON Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 774 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 27 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 774 HOLDEN AV F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\Word Documents\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1 A_1B_F I NAL M ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P79 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A &PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00028.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BLOCK, ALFRED L (COTR)(TOK)& JUDITH A (COTR)(TOK) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 776 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 28 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 776 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00029.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KETCHAM, DENNIS TYLER & CYNTHIA LEA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 778 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 29 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 778 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00030.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KULLY, JOHN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 780 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 30 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 780 HOLDEN AV F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_i\Word Documents\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_i_] A_SB_FI NAL_MERGE 03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P80 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES cv., COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00031.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SPIVAK, MERRILL M (TR) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 782 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 31 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 782 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00032.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BUCHHEIT, GEORGE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 784 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 32 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 784 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0006-00033.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WALKER, JARROD & Secondary Owner #1 WALKER, FRANCES Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 786 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 33 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 786 HOLDEN AV F,\Utilities\UTILITY- Enginee ring\Projects -Assessment Project s\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\ColIierCreekSubd ivisionPhase_1\Word Documents\01 _A_PreIimi na ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_18_FI N A L_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P81 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 •'�"' Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00010.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner THEIMER, HANSJUERGEN & Secondary Owner #1 THEIMER, LISA A (KING) Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 767 HOLDEN AV SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 10 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 767 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00011.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CLARK, GERALD E (LE) & ELEANORE L (LE) Secondary Owner #1 CLARK, ELEANORE L (COTRS) Secondary Owner #2 CLARK, GERALD E (COTRS) Mailing Address 769 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 11 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 769 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00012.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BRITTON, LON G & PAMELA S Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 750 CONCHA DR SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT: LOT 12 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 771 HOLDEN AV P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDocumenls\01_A_PreliminaryAssessinentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Pliase_3_1A_113_FI NAL_MERGE 03 06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P82 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00013.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KRUPA, STEPHEN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 773 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 13 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 773 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00014.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ALDRICH, JANICE LEE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address PO BOX 533 VERO BEACH FL 32960-0533 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 14 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 775 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00015.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WELLMAN, JAMES E & CONNIE S Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 783 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5048 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 15 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 783 HOLDEN AV F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment Project s\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\CoIIierCreekSUbdivisionPhase_1\WordDOCUments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmetit RoII_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_3_1A_] BF] NA L_M E R G E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P83 .. INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE IA & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00016.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ST ANGELO, EDWARD JR (TR) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 1 FESSENDEN RD BARRINGTON RI 02806 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 16 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 785 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00017.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GHIGLIOTTY, HENRY (COTRS)(TOK)& AUDREE S (COTRS)(TOK) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address774 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 17 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 774 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00018.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner STANILKA, TONY & JOYCE L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 772 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 18 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 772 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessm e nt s_2014_P roposed\Col I ierC ree kS ubd iv ision Pha se_l \Word Doc u me n t s\Ol_A_P rel i m i na ryAssessme ntRol I_RESOLU TION_3_Phase_1 _l A_1 B_F I NAL_MERG E_03_0 62017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P84 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES r ,r eVx' COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 113 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3+ Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0008-00019.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HARTMAN, ROBERT E & Secondary Owner #1 HARTMAN, ROBIN A Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 770 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 19 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 770 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0009-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SUNNYCALB, JAMES & OLIVIA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 721 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 721 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0009-00022.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner EPISCOPO, ANTHONY & Secondary Owner #1 SILVA, VICTORIA S Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 40875 N ELIME RD ANTIOCH IL 60002 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 22 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 771 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Project s\000Assessments_201 4_Proposed\Coll ierCree kS ubd ivisio n Pha se_1\Word Doc uments\01 _A_P re Ii in na ryAssessment Rol I_RESOLUTIO N_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_MERGE 03 06_2017 docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P85 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0009-00023.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LELEKIS, JOHN & PAULA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 773 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LCT/UNIT: LOT 23 PBI/OR BK: 13131 15-66 Site Address 773 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner TERRA FRIMA LAMININ LLC Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 630 NEWPORT DR INDIALANTIC FL 32903-4029 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT: LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: 13131 15-66 Site Address 801 HOLDEN CT Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner TICE, CHARLES G Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 803 HOLDEN CT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 803 HOLDEN CT F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\Word Documents\Ol_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION 3 Phase 1 1A 1B FI NAL_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P86 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES "' COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 11B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ANDERSON, WILLIAM P Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 805 HOLDEN CT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 805 HOLDEN CT Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CALVERT, WILLIAM DEAN &JENNIFER MARIE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 807 HOLDEN CT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT: LOT PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 807 HOLDEN CT Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MCEWEN, MITCH & ROBIN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 806 HOLDEN CT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT : LOT 5 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 806 HOLDEN CT F'\Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\Word Documents\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_FI NAL_MERGE_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P87 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 ,�'�""11 . Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ROSS, SCOTT & DONNA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 804 HOLDEN COURT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK 1 LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 804 HOLDEN CT Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GIRAN, KAREN MARIE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 802 HOLDEN CT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT : LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 802 HOLDEN CT Parcel # 31-39-18-00007-0010-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner PACOWSKI, ANNE Y & ROSTISLAW Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 800 HOLDEN CT SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE THREE BLK/BLDG : BLK J LOT/UNIT : LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: PBI 15-66 Site Address 800 HOLDEN CT F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubd ivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NA L_M ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P88 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL —RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0006-00017.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HAWS, FRANKLIN & ANITA V Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 754 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 17 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 754 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0006-00018.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner PASLEY, MICHEAL CHRISTOPHER Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 756 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 18 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 756 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0006-00019.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SHARLAND, JOSEPH T & DEANA M Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 758 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 19 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 758 HOLDEN AV F \Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CoIIierCreekSubdivisionPh ase_1 \Word DOC uments\Ol_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoI l_RES0LUTI0N_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_FI NAL_MERG E 0306_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P89 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 co PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0006-00020.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BRUNELLE, DAVID P & SANDRA M Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 762 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 21 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 762 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0006-00022.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CARROLL, TERRI Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 764 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 22 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 764 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0007-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WALDRON, MEGAN & Secondary Owner #1 DALLY, PATRICIA Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 100 CHARLES AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5042 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 100 CHARLES AV P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment P roj ect s\OOOAssessm ents_2014_13 ro posed\Col I ie rCree kS u bd iv i sio n P ha se_i \Word Doc u ment s\O S_A_P rel i m i na ryAssess meet Rol 111 ESO LUTI O N_3_13 hase_1_1A_3 B_F I NAL_MERGE 03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P90 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0007-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BALDASSANO, PAUL A JR (TR)(TOK) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 102 CHARLES AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 102 CHARLES AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0007-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ODEA, MICHAEL D & MARGARET P Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 104 CHARLES AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 104 CHARLES AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0007-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FOY, ANDREW J (LE) Secondary Owner #1 FOY, ANDREW J Secondary Owner #2 GUILIANO, ANN MARIE Mailing Address 106 CHARLES AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 4 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 106 CHARLES AV I° P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\Ol_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_7 A_1 B_FI NAL_M ERG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P91 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •"� r �!. COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0007-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner QIZILBASH, ALI A & ZAHIDA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 108 CHARLES AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOTS PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 108 CHARLES AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner PAPARIAN, RAYMOND P JR & Secondary Owner #1 FIORE, JEAN M Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 123 INDIAN TR WAKEFIELD RI 02879 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT: LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 101 CHARLES AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HUDON, ROBERT & GINETTE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 103 CHARLES AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 103 CHARLES AV F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\000Assessmen1s_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPKase_1\WordDOCllments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessment Rol l_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1 A_18_FI NAL_MERG E_03_0 62017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P92 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •"`" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B , PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BUCKINGHAM, DONALD C & KYONG C Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 105 CHARLES AV SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 105 CHARLES AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner RIZWI, TABASSUM Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 8540 SEACREST VERO BEACH FL 32963 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT: LOT 4 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 107 CHARLES AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LEWIN, GILBERT (LE) & LEIGH C (LE) Secondary Owner #1 LEWIN, GILBERT R (TRS) & LEIGH C(TRS) Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 757 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 5 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 757 HOLDEN AV P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment 11rojects\000Assessments_2034_Proposed\CollierCreekSUbdivisionPhase_1\Word Doc uments\01_A_Prel iminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_MERGE_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P93 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ROMANO, THOMAS G & Secondary Owner #1 CAMPBELL-ROMANO, CORINNE Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 4989 SE DEVENWOOD WAY STUART FL 34997 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 759 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MATHISEN, NORMAN A (TRS)(TOK) & CHRISTINE (TRS)(TOK) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 761 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5048 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT: LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 761 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner EDWARDS, RICHARD H & Secondary Owner #1 EDWARDS, PATRICIA L Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 763 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LCT/UNIT: LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: 13131 16-26 Site Address 763 HOLDEN AV F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\COIIIerCreekSubd ivisionPhase_1\WordDoc uments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_S_1A_1 B_FI NA L_M ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P94 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES"`�"�� COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B �. PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00009.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CUMMINGS, CAROL A Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 765 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 - Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 9 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 765 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00020.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CLUTTS, MELVIN E & NANCY B Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 768 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 20 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 768 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00021.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SIMCHICK, EDWARD M & DALE IRENE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 766 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 21 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 766 S EASY ST F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCree 1,SubdivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_MERGE 03_06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P95 prLkn INDIAN VER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 ; h,N,lrt PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00022.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BROWN, ROBERT & DORIS L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 764 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5032 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 22 PBI/OR BK: 13131 16-26 Site Address 764 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00023.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WHITMORE, HOWARD & BARBARA E Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 762 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 23 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 762 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0008-00024.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HUMPHREY, MICHELLE DAWSON & DAVID STANLEY III Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 6240 E MIRROR LAKE DR #207 SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK H LOT/UNIT : LOT 24 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 760 S EASY ST F \Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\ColIierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1.\WordDoc u ments\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_MERG E_03_06_203 7.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P96 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •"'>~ COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 �'""' 1 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00013.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner VANCE, STEPHEN & CINDY Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 753 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 13 PBI/OR BK: 13131 16-26 Site Address 753 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00014.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CANNON, MARK B & LISA ANNE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 755 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 14 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 755 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00015.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DIVERS, PAUL SR Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 3851 CARAMBOLA CIR N COCONUT CREEK FL 33066 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 15 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 757 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed \CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_ 1 \WordDOCU ments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoIl_RESOLUTI0N_3_Phase_i_lA_1B_FI N A L_M ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P97 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES wwCOLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00016.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner COHN, ROBERT D (LE) & SHIRLEYJ (LE) Secondary Owner #1 COHN, ROBERT Secondary Owner #2 COHN, SHIRLEY JEAN Mailing Address 759 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 16 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 759 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00017.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DANGER, BRUNO P & LISA M Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 761 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 17 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 761 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00018.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SERVICE, PAUL Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address PO BOX 94 PORTJERVIS NY 12771 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 18 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 763 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Propose d\CoIIierCreekSubdivisionPhas e_1\W ordDoc uments\O1_A_Prel iminaryAssessmentRol l_RESO LUTI0N_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_MERG E 03_06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P98 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY - DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICEScv.-'-vt COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL -RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00019.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BUNNELL, JAMES R & TINA K Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 765 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 19 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 765 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00020.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KORONA, ALFRED & GRACE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 767 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 20 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 767 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00008-0009-00021.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner JOHNSON, NANCY C (TR) Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 917 FRANCISCAN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FOUR BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 21 PBI/OR BK: PBI 16-26 Site Address 769 S EASY ST F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3 Phase_1_1A_1D_FI NAL_M ERG E_03_06_2017. docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P99 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES 0%. COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00020.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LAMACCHIA, FRANK R & DOREEN I Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 722 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 20 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 722 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00021.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MARTIN, JAMES S & CANDACE A Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 10730 SW VISCONTI WAY PORT ST LUCIE FL 34986 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 21 PBI/OR BK: 13131 17-28 Site Address 724 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00022.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MCCOLLUM, DANIEL & JUDITH CAROL Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 726 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 22 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 726 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1 \WordDocuments\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessrnentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_S_9 A_1B_FI NAL_MERG E 03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P100 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES CN. COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE lA & PHASE 16PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00023.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner ABRAHAM, ANTHONY M & JENNIFER BOLSTER Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 121 AMHERST LN SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LCT/UNIT: LOT 23 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 728 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00024.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DAVENPORT, MICHELE SULLIVAN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 556 SOUTH WATERLOO RD DEVON PA 19333 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 24 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 730 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00025.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FAGNANT, ALDA P & JAMES Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 592 BISCAYNE LN SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT: LOT 25 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 732 S EASY ST F-\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_7 \Word Docu ments\01_A_Prelim i na ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTl0N_3_Phase_1_1A_l B_FI NAL_MERGE_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P101 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES -•"" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 �. PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00026.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner RUNYON, JAMES A& MIRIAM C Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 734 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT: LOT 26 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 734 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00027.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HOWARD, NORMAN J III & Secondary Owner #1 HOWARD, NORMAN J JR Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 738 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 27 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 736 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00028.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HOWARD, NORMAN & LINDA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 738 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 28 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 738 S EASY ST F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAsse ssment s_2014_P ro posed\Col I ie rC ree ICS ubd ivi sio n P Iia se_ 1 \Word Documents\01_A_P rel i m i na ryAssess ment Rol I_RESOLU T IO N_3_P hase_1_1 A_1 B_F I NAL_MERG E_03_06_201 7.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P102 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES • °F COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL —RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00029.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner O'KEEFE, WILLIAM E & BARBARA J Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 740 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 29 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 740 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0005-00030.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GILL, WALTER D & GAIL M Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 742 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK E LOT/UNIT : LOT 30 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 742 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00001.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DESAI, SURESH R (TR)(TOK) & Secondary Owner #1 DESAI, MINAXI 5 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 100 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 1 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 100 BECKER AV FUtilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed \CoIIierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDoc uments\Q1_A_Prel imina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL_MERGE_03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P103 kk INDIAN RIVER COUNTY —DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES �" a' " �,R COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 18 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 �'`"'°�✓ Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner THIESSEN, LEONARD J JR & SHIZUKO Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 102 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 102 BECKER AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MARCELLINO, PAUL & JESSIE ANN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 104 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 104 BECKER AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DURING, DONALD G & PATRICIA A Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 15 JAMES LN LEVITTOWN NY 11756 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 4 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 106 BECKER AV F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\Word Documents\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1 _1A_1B_FI NAL_MERGE_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P104 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •""�^ COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner FORSTER, ALAN J & Secondary Owner #1 FORSTER, CHRISTINA L Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 745 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958-5043 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 5 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 745 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner RHEIN, JEFFREY M & SUSAN L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 743 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 743 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DODD, VALERIE Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 14015 N INDIAN RIVER DR SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 741 HOLDEN AV P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\ColIierCreekSubdivisionPhase_3\WordDoc uments\01_A_Prel iininaryAssessmentRoII_RESO LUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1B FI NAL_MERG E 03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P105 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BLECKER, EDGAR & ELVA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 739 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 739 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00009.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner JOHNSTON, GARY WAYNE & SALLY ANITA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 738 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 9 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 738 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00010.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner HEISS, JOHN M JR & Secondary Owner #1 HOLSTEIN, DEBRA L Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 740 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 10 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 740 HOLDEN AV F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivision Phase_1\WordDoc uments\01 A_PreIiminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_FI NAL_MERG E 03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P106 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES cov-1. COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00011.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MANZI, AL & PHYLLIS Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 742 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958-0724 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 11 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 742 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00012.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MARTIN, ROBERT E (LE &) KEMBERLY A (LE) Secondary Owner #1 MARTIN, KEMBERLY A (TRS) Secondary Owner #2 MARTIN, ROBERT E (TRS) Mailing Address 744 HOLDEN AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOTS 12 & 13 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 744 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00014.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner NIELSEN-CITO, DIANE R & Secondary Owner #1 CITO, GARY J Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 748 HOLDEN AV SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 14 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 748 HOLDEN AV F-\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubd ivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RES0LUTI0N_3 Phase_1_1A_1B_FI NAL_M ERG E03062017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P107 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES gl§ COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B � �.� PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 `� 150/ Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00015.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KINKAID, ROGER ALAN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 2751 AINA LANI DR PAKALNI HI 96768 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 15 PBI/OR BK: 13131 17-28 Site Address 750 HOLDEN AV Assessment= Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0006-00016.0 $6,250.00 Owner LAROCHE, GLORIA L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 19930 BARLETTA LN UNIT 1322 ESTERO FL 33928-5613 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK F LOT/UNIT : LOT 16 PBI/OR BK: 13131 17-28 Site Address 752 HOLDEN AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0007-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MYERS, RICHARD L & Secondary Owner #1 CATON, JENNIFER A Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 109 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 109 BECKER AV F \Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_9 \WordDOCUments\01_A_Prelimi na ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_7 A_1B_FI NA L_M E RG E_03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P108 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES ,,��,.�s, COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 18 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0007-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner LEIPERT, GABRIELE A Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 107 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 107 BECKER AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0007-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner CLEAVER, JERRY A & WILMA C Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address PO BOX 781288 SEBASTIAN FL 32978-1288 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 105 BECKER AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0007-00009.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner PARKER, GREGORY J & ERLINDA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 103 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 9 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 103 BECKER AV P\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDocuments\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_r-I NAL_M ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P109 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •"" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1 PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B SSESSMENT ROLL —RESOLUTION 3 PRELIMINARY I ,�Y Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0007-00010.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner KEEPING, KAREN J Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 101 BECKER AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK G LOT/UNIT : LOT 10 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 101 BECKER AV Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00006.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner BARONE, LOUIS & KAREN Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 739 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 6 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 739 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00007.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner JOHNSON, ROBERT F & LYNN DAVIS Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 741 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 7 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 741 S EASY ST F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1 \WordDocuments\01_A_Prelimina ryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTI0N_3_Phase_1_1A_18_FI NAL_MERG E 03 06 2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 Pilo INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES cNe""; COL LIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE lA &PHASE 1BPRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3I Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00008.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner STEINGOLD, JEFFREY Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 10 CLEARYVIEW CT S PALM COAST FL 32137-8344 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 8 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 743 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00009.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner MCCORMICK, MICHAEL A& DIANE E Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 745 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 9 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 745 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00010.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner JOHNSTON, JOHN T & MARCIA L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 747 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 10 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 747 S EASY ST l"Wtilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\000Assessment s_2014_P roposed\ColIierCree kSUhdivisi6nPhase_1 \Word Docu ment s\0I_A_Prelim ina ryAssessmentRol l_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1B_FI NAL_MERG E 03_06_2017.docx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P111 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 16 • �Ary10�, PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 3 Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00011.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner WOJCIKIEWICZ, TOMASZ & BARBARA Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 749 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT 11 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 749 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00009-0009-00012.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner GARA, JUNE S Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 955 BEAR ISLAND CIR WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE FIVE BLK/BLDG : BLK 1 LOT/UNIT : LOT 12 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-28 Site Address 751 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00011-0009-00002.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner NILSEN, KENNETH & KIMBERLY Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 972 TARPON AVE SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE SIX BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 2 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-76 Site Address 729 S EASY ST F•\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\CollierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\\Nord Doc uments\Ol_A_PrehminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_3_Phase_1_1A_1 B_FI NAL ME RG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P112 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES •"`" COLLIER CREEK WATER ASSESSMENT PROJECT PHASE 1, PHASE 1A & PHASE 1B % PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL— RESOLUTION 1 �'5-- Parcel # 31-39-18-00011-0009-00003.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SPILLIS, LAURA ANN & Secondary Owner #1 SPILLIS, ABIGAIL BALDWIN Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 733 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE SIX BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 3 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-76 Site Address 733 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00011-0009-00004.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner DISCENZA, TRAVIS E & SUSAN K Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 149 STONEY POINT DR SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE SIX BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT: LOT PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-76 Site Address 735 S EASY ST Parcel # 31-39-18-00011-0009-00005.0 Assessment= $6,250.00 Owner SIWICKI, DAVID J & SANDRA L Secondary Owner #1 Secondary Owner #2 Mailing Address 737 S EASY ST SEBASTIAN FL 32958 Legal COLLIER CREEK ESTATES PHASE SIX BLK/BLDG : BLK I LOT/UNIT : LOT 5 PBI/OR BK: PBI 17-76 Site Address 737 S EASY ST F'\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment Projects\OOOAssessments_2014_Proposed\Coll ierCreekSubdivisionPhase_1\WordDoc unnents\01_A_Prel iminaryAssessmetit Roll_RESO LUTI0N_3_Phase_1_1A_IBF I NALM ERG E_03_06_2017. d ocx Tuesday, March 07, 2017 P113 Collier Creep Estates Watermain Assessment Project Res Ill' Public Hearing 03%1412017 How We Got Here lo- Initial Request to evaluate the feasibility of County water received August, 2014. lo -Received valid petition March, 2015. lo -BCC approved to secure Carter & Associates and start design April, 2016. ►BCC approved amending the original assessment area August, 2016. I1, -BCC adopted Res I & Res II January 24, 2017. No -Staff presented project at City Council Meeting February 8, 2017. lo -Staff presented project to the residents of Collier Creek March 7, 2017. Moving Forward Res III — March 14, 2017 (Pending BCC Approval) FDEP Permit — March, 2017 COS ROW Permit - March, 2017 Advertise for bids —June, 2017 Final Completion — May, 2018 1\3}- 2 11 MON =NEW I long I im mop I II I wn W WE 1111111M V 1111111Z1111111 Vj Moving Forward Res III — March 14, 2017 (Pending BCC Approval) FDEP Permit — March, 2017 COS ROW Permit - March, 2017 Advertise for bids —June, 2017 Final Completion — May, 2018 1\3}- 2 Indian River Press Journal 1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32960 AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER Before the undersigned authority personally appeared, Sherri Cipriani, who on oath says that she is Classified Inside Sales Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida: that the attached copy of advertisement was published in the Indian River Press Journal in the following issues below. Affiant further says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published in Vero Beach in said Indian River County, Florida, and that said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, daily and distributed in Indian River County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that she has neither paid or promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. The Indian River Press journal has been entered as Periodical Matter at the Post Offices in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement. Customer Ad Number Cooviine PO # 461741- INDIAN RIVER CO ATTORNEYS OFC 1471107 Resolution: 2017-004: Collier Creek RES 2017-004 Pub Dates February 7, 2017 Sworn to and subscribed this day of, F bruary 06, 2017, by who is Sherri Cipriani (X) personally known to me or ( ) who has produced Sandra Coldren Notary Public as identification. rrrr SANDRA COLDREN MY COMMISSION # FF 004035 EXPIRES: April 1, 2017 •a Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters 1 13p\ O p) V L d OI 3 ti 0 � 0 N Q) C > C � _3 Q O Rf son a 5 z 0 W 0 N N �c @ L: o a . CIO �. C Q C U p 'C CU > d U N Q Q fn 0 X r T- Z co Z �C C Q) z W Q 0 z a) i6 0 -p co N_ p Q C (n Q THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows: 2. As access to water provides an equal benefit to each property served, the assersmwt MR be equal per parcel. Me asue,wowt, shell bear Interest unaR paid ata rah to be determined by in, Board of County C—onissiunws when Me lmprawmedta are completed. of Ln¢proposetl ImDrovemerdz. tAll of1Mse are open tloi^rpeclion Oy ltle¢pAENaICILPttatie Departme^t of Ut0ity eervicesd'plans and :paainaaHoesfor M<impravements and as esdmat¢ofH ]. A proposed preliminary assessment roll with respect to Me special assessments Is on file with the Clerk to Me Roab and Department of Utility Services, S. URivet Pressloptl befine16 ruspublk heerina asami,=of byl9ectlon206.04 of Tcause hu Co de of sol,lilondian Rlyelon uwiit Amap zhowing Me areas M be served) to be published at least one Ume in the The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner Solari, and the motion was seconded by Commissioner Flescher, and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: Chairman Jeseph E Flesrner AYE Cammisssiionet5usan Ada Bs AYE Commissioner Tim tom AYE Commissioner Bob Solari AYE The Chalrinan thereupon declared the resolution duty passed and adopted this 24th day of January, 2DIT. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Attest Jeffrey RSmiM, Clerk of INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA Br Lu Aad C"Nloo,eputy Clerk BY )—phEFlescher, Chairman approved az he form and Intl sufficiency By: Dylan Reingdd County Attorney COWER [REEK ESTATESTPhii iii 1-i:) fvuimiR'dN'FaMaf2q WmexiMa �aurtr'/ ivai0 a2E^SA1tirt',nblheTlGtTCIID 4Y erMDtD Jday r.NtgNC4MYJt ta1tX[afaT[[ PYAtf61t,,. Treasure Coast Newspapers Tuesday, February 7, 2017 SO �enweelNDeedAPPlicatldd. ax Deed Apply' APPI�ic:rtlan -eX De• eO_ Catlan Deed A0lms De App plru NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR at na mf ccrtdn xssstancc rtY e¢scribed In such Ger- C3009-0462Number. sched- Wee the timebefore Bless Man and aR'rvelm"Unty.FL India. TAX DEED Pleasecontact CourtAdmim tMcah arttrtificates win be sold h the Highest Bidder Year of Issuance: 2089 ]tlays: N yoaare M1eannp aJ NOTICE TO PERSONS WITH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN isMa[lon, 250 NW Country Club Drive Suite 217, Fort SL Online at —led 1- Fne Number. 2036-Op6]TD Oesr+i0tlon of Pr rty: v Ice Impaired, call ]ll. Pub: February ], ]I, 31, 28, DISABIIfDES: If y a with a disability h0 THAT CB INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENTS DEPT 1500, at IeestLT d Itaxtleed.wm on the 14th ay of March. 2017 at 11:00 do. S SUB person on oaEertO an holder of the followlnaa Cer- o before Your A UNIT 11 BLK 110 LIT 57 BI i-57 TCN 3462790 In participate MIs ere enbded, tlficate haz filed sa1U Tax Certlfeate for a Tax Deed scheduled rt ppear- a or Immediately upon thio notification JEFFREY R. SMITH Probe Atldress: 3095E STMN BLVD proccedmgg. You tno wzl to you, to Me pro. vision of cerhln assistance. to be Issued thereon. the Ca a thane . the ad appearance park ofthe Cirwlt Court oCounty. NT0.YOEED APPLICATION FOR ISltration,easo n250 my 45ueose. t^e CesWpp[Ion antl Names) In i^less Man i days: if you are headn0 or IrldianoRlve FL NOTICE TO �ERSOyyNSttyyWITH Assessed To:��958 INDIAN RIVER INV�E�S,,T,,MENTS NW Countrrt Club Ddve Suite Port SL of pro43 perty H rs assessed are as Fuabl'-I�W3W�dy, 19llil, 28, persneebeon Atltiy of the � N .MCI 'I HERE Y GIVEN 12 fw1U1p CertlRcah Number. arty ecommllh a be n order h in M s ns tMnf�lor!dwy."' HTHAI ST TH PPA PARTNERS #620 holder of the following Cery ect'¢tl I d ca- � pe"reao a. Png 2009-0460 Year of issuance: 2009 NOTICE OF ABIICADON FOR participate HroceedInDe uare ¢ended, tnocoat°ro ypu, to the pro- Unl' s such certificate or cer- LMcahs span be redwmed titicate has filed said Tax Certificate far a Tax Deed this notincation HMe timbeounorM! srne0uletl Flee Number. 2016-0065T0 TAX DEED onof certain assistance, rtlinq la Law, the Prep- atifl�cnte to be Issued Merron. The appearanceIs less Man T or dalcne d Oescrtption of Pro arty: SEBASTIAN NTHATE Pleaze contact Court Admirny- 250 or�certifcates witbe Certificate Number and�year of IpsroDertY pe,rea nail ]Il�g N 2 BK 490 LOTO 55 BI CS INTERNATIONAL Club ONre Suite ]1T, PortdSt. orJln a Cbewsvnwi9ln?an nver� > d Na e(s) in is Pj1 21, 201] 31, February T. FroOerty Address: 317 SEBASTIAN BLVD holder fo°owing cer- tlficate has filed said Tax ai Ileist 144 y before youl acheeulee rt appear- l Weedcom On th lath Eay Df March, ZOIT at 11:00 �ows,T I assessed are as A 1449512 SEBASTIAN, 832958 Certificate for a Tax Deed enc Or adial¢ly upon AM Certlfcah Number: 2014-153 Assessed To: to be iswetl thereon. The caWlnq this notificaflon H H1e IEFFREY R. SMITH Yew fl—arms: 2014 INDIAN RIVER INVESTMENTS OFCENTRAL FLORIDA INC All Of the above yy Is Certificate Number and year Of isuance, the dozcrl flan o t and Name s) In tlme before the ached. led appearance is less than days: If are headn9 or Clerk of Me Circuft Court tl LomDboller Pndia^ File Number: 2016.006BTO Oescripbanof Property: CANNON SUEIM'FLGT2] NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR TAX DEED party IocS�LIntFlIa7eRiver Loum properly feh00W5it is assessed are as you S, River County, R NOISA&LRIES:ER iOyNoSU WRN pmBpl�2 ](]Aedr NOTICE ST WEALTH HEREBY U"'ENT pub: Februaary 14121, 18. who -R #6200. c t.1to raeheD Number: TCN 1462692 person .1M a disability ea am a D.C,_ fen A331 N,R3296T TNERS IfiuLP h rhatsefJedo zI Tu rdin9 arty desvibed In such Ger- 20D9icatte Vearll of Issuance: 2009 no." [�ogDarticipate In this f ALFRED DAVIS, MIRIAM Cc 1111, for A Tax Decd soldtoaNe Highest Biddber .old OesMpUohb�ro6De0rr[6[yy6�T0 NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR at neo Gust to jroµ to If A�Aat the above property is filo*, Certo tificahN mbar antl online et www.lndienriver. SEBASTIAN HIGNIANDS SUB TAX DEED f certain assistance. Please contact Court Admlm IOca ed' d' RIver Cour- itlCa. of issuance. Me ties f Itaxtleed=m an the lath daY of MarcR 2017 et 11:00 UNIT 12 SLK 490 LOT 56 PSI ]-5] NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN ist.61n, 250 NW Country ry SdMefFl U less such certlfcate or cer- I. racwty and Names) in .°YnPrn It Is Lase:sed are az AM. Propp rty Atltlress THAT CB INTERNATIONAL Club DHve Suite 211. Port SC FL34986, 772 SO 437D tifcates shall be redeemed follows: JEFFREY R. SMITH 3135EeA5NAN BLVD SEBASTIAN, 832958 INVESTMENTS DEPT 2500, holder the following Cery Lucie, L least 1 days before your rdin9toLaw,theProp- a described In such. cery Certlfcate Number. 2014-1931 Clark of the Circuit Court Assessed To: Of bleat has Flied said Tax s h,d oft ppear- m olahly upon tlficate orcertificates w^0 be Year of Issuance: 2014 d Comptrdler Indian Rlver County, FL INDIAN RIVER INVESTMENTS OF CENTRAL FLORIDA INC Certificate for a Tax Deed to be Issued thereon. The tecel1%this Ufcanon I said Lo the Highest Bidder online at www.indianHwr. FRe Number. 2016.006WO Description of Property: NOTICE TO PERSONS WITH All of the above Groperty is Certificate Number and year Itexcil a com oa MQ TM STONEY BROOK FARM SUB D16ABILITIES: If V. r0 a on wiMadlsaUllittys. ho Weston! in Indian River GOua- tyy, SMM of Florida. Of isauanCl, the deacripDRon fp party antl Name(S)in ahPh 1h¢tESIpPG�h¢[d ul da Of March, 2011 at 11:00 Ant. LOT 72 FBI 19.41 Property Address: no nee yeteammOddHOn Inrto in this order Unless such certiflcate Or dery tificAtes shall be redeemed ltNassessed are as farrows: T�ALM LIJtalfiCdi JEFFREY R. SMITH 570 STONEY BROOK FARM CT VERO BEACH, FL 32968 participate proceeding. You are entitled according to Law, the Prop- Clerk Of the Cirwlt Court Assessed To: THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows: 2. As access to water provides an equal benefit to each property served, the assersmwt MR be equal per parcel. Me asue,wowt, shell bear Interest unaR paid ata rah to be determined by in, Board of County C—onissiunws when Me lmprawmedta are completed. of Ln¢proposetl ImDrovemerdz. tAll of1Mse are open tloi^rpeclion Oy ltle¢pAENaICILPttatie Departme^t of Ut0ity eervicesd'plans and :paainaaHoesfor M<impravements and as esdmat¢ofH ]. A proposed preliminary assessment roll with respect to Me special assessments Is on file with the Clerk to Me Roab and Department of Utility Services, S. URivet Pressloptl befine16 ruspublk heerina asami,=of byl9ectlon206.04 of Tcause hu Co de of sol,lilondian Rlyelon uwiit Amap zhowing Me areas M be served) to be published at least one Ume in the The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner Solari, and the motion was seconded by Commissioner Flescher, and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: Chairman Jeseph E Flesrner AYE Cammisssiionet5usan Ada Bs AYE Commissioner Tim tom AYE Commissioner Bob Solari AYE The Chalrinan thereupon declared the resolution duty passed and adopted this 24th day of January, 2DIT. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Attest Jeffrey RSmiM, Clerk of INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA Br Lu Aad C"Nloo,eputy Clerk BY )—phEFlescher, Chairman approved az he form and Intl sufficiency By: Dylan Reingdd County Attorney COWER [REEK ESTATESTPhii iii 1-i:) fvuimiR'dN'FaMaf2q WmexiMa �aurtr'/ ivai0 a2E^SA1tirt',nblheTlGtTCIID 4Y erMDtD Jday r.NtgNC4MYJt ta1tX[afaT[[ PYAtf61t,,. Treasure Coast Newspapers 1 CLQUNTYATTORNEY"S TREASURE COAST NEWSPAPERS OFFIcLc INDIAN RIVER PRESS JOURNAL 1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32960 AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER Before the undersigned authority personally appeared Linda Klein, who on oath says that she is Classified Sales Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida, that the attached copy of advertisement was published in the Vero Beach Press Journal in the following issues below Affiant further says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published at Vero Beach in said Indian River County, Florida and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida daily and distributed in Indian River County, Florida for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that she has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper The Indian River Press Journal has been entered as Periodical matter at the Post Office in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement. Pub Customer Name Ad # qqt9(§1 Copyline Po # INDIAN RIVER 1485435 February 28, Meeting: 3/14/17 Meeting* 3/14/17 COUNTY 2017 Water Main ATTORNEY'S March 7, 2017 Extension OFFICE Sworn to a/Subscribed before me this March 15, 2017, by [ X ] personally known to me or [ who has produced who is as identification Sherri Cipriani ( N.�tary Public "S `e SHERRI CIPRIANI My COMMISSION #FF154095 :!eorF,o? EXPIRES August 25, 2018 (407)3 98-0153 FlnririaNrn�...c�....:.... ....... NEWSPAPER E -Sheet® LEGAL NOTICE ATTACHED DO NOT SEPARATE PAGES 113A-5 O N 4D Tuesday, March T. 2017 Treessno Coast Newspapers Notice ro eredimrs tl'Y'�Votice Ta Creditors The comas and addrossef of INTHEGRCIIITCOURT OF THE 9M Bedford Road Crossword Puzzle Not ce TaC editors gush. Nonce6 K -77= -,BMs below. MI Millions of the decadent PROBATEDIVISION R tatlw: cASENO.:"I6CPW1335 EA RABOURNE BUPKHAITER no other «rsom ^oHnpp "Al" or demands epahtrt opal t desedem's estate and Includin 71A S Eery MAINTENANCEOFMEDIAxS ACROSS 39 Garden tools Answer to Prevlpua Pu3Z1< tAiit0lIVirt WRxnmd7 MOHTNS m an I19ne in 209A0^tll0 in eccONanx with dehBCd 1 ODE'e 40 FoIUm hello a""— AFTER THE DATE OF THE FIRC°E`IBUGnoN of nils Avenue 100 Besktt Averme Be on, .liable 4 teak slowly 41 Sane site D E EIS OLE $ L A D No Amba Ci 10 �� ge- `°t t^erOhee°Vtt`ctol of`I'wrcnaa 8 Forbidding 43 VICE — A CRE POKE U M A All CIAIMS NOT RLED WITH• IN THE TIME PERI DOS BET m and In cd ]08 CMNes AwmC 738 HMd¢n Avenue m0. eih Nall 100 N. 11.5. 1. Nercb 12 SUM, For ae CerredY'e ro PC S HATTER E D S I R FLORIDA STATIfTES m eM mcm0'np T86 Hold- ' Fort fmrlda. Copies of the d«tmmes arc avaB depart 13 Food a -did— 50 On me HOG IRE A S HEN sECnON 711.702 WILL BE SECTION Avenue: a00 Heiden court a n°eou�rtl Indus a" ins de deetronic,By I=, thre Pf0e0 14 Entiu[ summit 51 Had ANA $ T A NOTWITHSTANDING°THE TIME PERIOD SET FORTN ABOVE OdM[bn Oi tolikr G<ek rcauez° ie maaeko® Gttyy--1 on the 15 Pie topping enOUgh TOt1°y J I M M Y Q U E L L S ANY CIAIM FlLED TWO i2i YEARS OR MORE AFTER 411E EStamf, TNNils 43, 4,5 Ne ppr(iom M Pest, 2 and! yy w¢C f(II OI Be.nnd$[ar10m (www.demanestacenml and 17 Apartment 1B Healthy 64 Reputation 65 Dog A H A T FUN I I I OECEOENi'S DATE OF OEATH IS BARRED. located within me G((yy of SebastMn, In Indbn Rver Ne Gty of Fart Pierto Pun l,nahpa she( ww.dty- 19 Voo makers ancestor A D LAG J A B S tTInbd°I ;u�e�c n�°irlW^i`io1� C°u°`y'R°rlda' �O A°Ma anW7Ni-tue M¢eF 20 Tight din. i9 Calttomia ion DEP L O Y BURST Toe Publk Header MObe ntle kq wl0 b<r^NdettOSOAM, 22 SSNS, 0.9• "o S7 Atli ca LEE LEG Personal Remt—tellve. =LYN TAGGE ne[d, Marty 11, 20DM 9:05 mere mursdaayy MartD 16, 2017, in Noor 23 SSNS' �• 26 Forest portion channel se Time peiods BUOYS FAD ICE 3290 Gimmr Paint Drive GnnmiDo. cA 30041 a.m. « as soon Iter of it 4Am1 meYY De heard, m me cov CouF the Enalirminp Flit Gnflmnc! Room, Uty Na0 growth 28 59 Female nib I R A S N O SHOED Nc`yOiezentative°eff•. °N1 nt eiMrt o 100 NorN US. Al. Port p 31Fl3, es npsuek ASK EARN ETON Erk R. Seversen from InAlti e m the county .emmis• naiufsTreli oM:mess me M Order for thele Md. 32 "Nature" DOWN SAS NETS NASA Emalk rf®numsanasevercon<om WLN& 1801 37th avast unto aceto. nodes m be e—Idered Anyone Mrlp channel 7 Teeth holders Secondary FinaB: 33960, at whkh tlme IMtt- ever loos aM. wit hot be.11—amp-let,em 3, C"N" telt 34 Thal, In Bala 2 Layered cockle 6 Perfume label 9 Viking letter word 10 Rainbow IvswMersQbumsalMsever ser emd aN<s mm, be here m the del y q pets ofe[�p`I[Y/women 35 DcbtDe. Date 3 lama's lanai 7 Opp- goddess Flmlda No. 23313 BURNS A SEVERSON. M Droll�c°!°"°m°°r°°°[M ownea eusmess Fntemdsc 36 Fro ble 4 Tfemts an Icy of pact- 11 Ration Dot PD. Be. 349 Arty Dropottd documents, portklpaUon. 37 Dade mtl road B Sticks 18 DIUCkbS u� D.(85e6dU 6'87300It 303 Intludlno pro eta ibe °easasch 38 Coat rock 5 ryes! (tern together 19 Melba. Fac (S6U Bel B1DI ede ed eIM Ph! °mwm to CfiY OF FORT PIERCE edelxla tarter, 21 22 23 mistiine Pum March?.14.2017 b< assasr m ea m Drop• Pumhasirl➢Mvuyytt y.,ww TCN 1515116 a be escertalned Dub: Flmuary 2A March 7. 24 As well ea 25 Speckled 27 Bend am 28 MoMlle title 29 DamI011C 30 Klubi minter 36 Dinette place 38 water -power 40 Rockies resort 42 Campus figures 43 Bam per top 44 LGA postings 45 Frisk about 47 Commotion, 48 Gem of "T - tole" 49 States further 51 Blow away 52 Not against 53 Gulf st r oUGe7o creditors vry Notice ro eredimrs tl'Y'�Votice Ta Creditors The comas and addrossef of INTHEGRCIIITCOURT OF THE 9M Bedford Road the nal rcprcze Uve y 1STHRIDIg4l gRgIR, IN M asst` mini A, d led personal rcpreiaent<- five's atterney me ad norm AND FOR ST.WGECOUNFY. Atmmey }Or O=A, FLORIDA e+co below. MI Millions of the decadent PROBATEDIVISION R tatlw: cASENO.:"I6CPW1335 EA RABOURNE BUPKHAITER no other «rsom ^oHnpp "Al" or demands epahtrt ESQUIRE INRE:THEESTATEOF FLORIDA DAR NQ: 410929 dec¢denri estat._rI pr }this Otke IF YAWAMPDOY, Laura 201, R°urmtiurldl.,rh. PA Dettasl0. Street t° be served mart fIC Ncir dalmi Mm cols VE Miami mass ibdda 0139 Miami hone NOTICE TO CR EDITORS Tel O 157.3307 3 Mrt MTHIN THE LATER OF ONTHS AFTER THE TIME The Administnstlon of the Fa[a 0e: (IIs 757.33% Estate f WILLIAM ADDY ID FmeD: OF or THE IT RST PUBDDATION NOTICE OR 30 Ia f BL0rr0yyPa•mt des«sed, whoa data oTHIS it Ymea®IODOa.rlet AFTER THE DATE OF SERWCE OF A COPY OF THIS NOTICE pdclaElnp in tl°0i!°ClfWIt CIWrt for GoZ1, nor Tcrtla rr� nen a""— SL Wcic Ida, Probate DMslon, Fd< NarWlbbpbmt All Ntt T.M.. of Me �ewMenMe omtt persons Num0er 2016.Cp-001335. me Pum Pobruary 20. March 7, addrc sof Nb llpSouM Tan ON ISOMIl IN THECH" Un COURT FOR MARTIN MU—. FLORIDA PROBATE DIVISION File Number IN RE ESTATE OF 0000 S Ccele OAU H1-5IS MCCMALL, OALL, ny�0 s'n�urs (°ds�°Q ra.m`9Y1. to flldarl[ .11.dllxe ulgl ticrt to the Board of County commtsMo«n, locamd on the sea of n°«m OUBemyy t Of me Gun Admin Street Vo�e � gs & Street Anyone who mays�M.Men, p«m to aal aectl IrI➢r bla and I. Olsof Nte Peaa Ihn, Is mad h toed wMm meiaxnd .Neal �rryom sNrO needs A spedM as. tin emust °cormeest the abet, ties Americans « (ADR) romm- dinster at 772-u6-1223 t �st44BU�rf In advance b INDIAN RIVER COUNTY NW OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS JOSEPH E FLESON CHAIRMAN Ptb11 16-20. March 7• TCN 1485435 Pusuc noTlcE 201, TCN 1500165 �R E51ate �O�', �5des h omen For Sale Indian River Shores ABSOLUTE AUCTION! Beachside Home 140 Amy Ann lane 3 Bedrooms & 3 Baths 2.206 p. ft. living space 4 St.. bbl " placed balconies Views of treetops from every room of this detnc7ied Townhome community pool Sat, Mar 11th 011 AM A¢Ncw ®10 AM RennkkAocSam 772.561-5015 Uta DeelCr Dlrettory (wto Dealer D'IFeelOry oDeder Dlroclory ate Dealer, Directory (_wto DCeler DirOttory_ WAILICECHRYSILER VER°Rualc R—r-- WAL3ACE HYUNDAI WAWICE "'a He _ 277S5SEFedew rc Es55 ust SSE Foderel tINCOW MERCURY Sales/service 772- ro00-3752966 H 4BISS 051 M ^way, Stuart wy.Smart SSSS SouN 051 Ft Pierce oto '0,NM Dincctory 72b3600 dente m-24Ii0a0 1.6M329-6060 rlacol72&/33S DATOR CHRrSIFa G(7n)Afian.com WALLACE CADILIAC 000cEJ® WALLACE DODGE WALLACE LEEP WALLICE MAZDA 741 �-�5 2155 sE iedercl 3155 SE FederclH r. 35555E fceeN Odw Allltle•SaveA lot N'gmvay, seuart Stuart"E"I'd -230.600 37255E red WpLLACE y0ilL9WAGEN aR-6RD.0 US -L M66rrtlyyboaeur.m< m-220.360" Hwr„scan 2gp55EfJiNla^way, ..ton, 1.661.Of` VERO BEACN I[V a0bT51999 WAl1ACE Covent Ef E RDI Id5SU5 OxE Stuart 772 2650 CHEV al p. wmttanicOm” aoo-)T53966 WALIACE NISSAN Hwy y'Wart Q„''d�pl Mpl�tl$1 6R USH I wroRcac d U13SEFedend Hwy., WALLACEVOLVO 772-382-3233 I VERG au 29-38015E federcl .Stuart nr569;3600 722-186-6000 dwx63-s2f ii3A-G Office of the 11A INDIAN RIVER COUNTY Jason E. Brown, County Administrator Michael C. Zito, Assistant County Administrator ADMINISTRATOR MEMORANDUM TO: Members of the Board of County Commissioners FROM: Jason E. Brown County Administrator r BY: William K. DeBraal, Deputy County.Attorney J(J DATE: March 8, 2017 ���""" SUBJECT: Offer to Purchase 16th Street Ballfields At its meeting of February 7, 2017, the Board of County Commissioners (Board) discussed the current status of the 16th Street Ballfield parcel. The 11.57 acre parcel is located north of 16th Street between 20th Avenue and 17th Avenue within the city limits of Vero Beach. Improvements to the property consist of three softball/little league/baseball diamonds with lights, fencing, parking, concession, press boxes and announcers' booths. An aerial photo of the Property is attached as Exhibit A. The property is currently being maintained by the County and rented out to groups for baseball practices. On December 20, 2016, the Board voted to obtain an appraisal of the Ballfield property in its current state and its value in a multifamily condition similar to neighboring property. The appraisal valued the Ballfield property in the "as is" condition at $5.00,000 and, if rezoned and the underlying land use is changed, the appraisal offered a value of $725,000. A copy of the appraisal is available for review in the County Attorney's Office. At the February 7`h Board meeting, staff was directed to contact the School District and the School Board members to determine if there was any interest in exchanging the Ballfield property for the District's "South County High School" property on the northwest corner of Oslo Road and 20th Street. A letter was drafted and sent to the School Board members. The proposed exchange was discussed by the School Board and the proposed exchange was rejected, as evidenced by the letter from the Superintendent, attached as Exhibit `B". P114 Offer to Purchase 16th Street Ballfields March 8, 2017 Page 12 At the same time as staff was inquiring if the School Board was interested in the property, staff was directed to draft the documents necessary to sell the property via the sealed bid process. The Board directed staff to initiate the process of selling the property effective March 14, 2017. Drafts of those documents are ready to be distributed via Demandstar and the required public notice and advertising if the Board decides to sell the property on the open market. After the February 7'' Commission meeting, staff was contacted by Joseph and Carole Graves about purchasing the 16th Street Ballfield property. Their 15 -year old son Jimmy died in a boating accident and a foundation has been established in Jimmy's name. Jimmy Graves was an accomplished multi -sport athlete and his family and friends wish to honor his life through his love for sports and fellowship. Staff met with the Graves family and has recently received an offer to purchase the 16th Street Ballfield property for $250,000. The terms of the proposed purchase are set forth in a letter from Rebecca Emmons, attorney for the Jimmy Graves Foundation, attached as Exhibit "C". The Foundation seeks to keep the recreational nature of the property, focusing on fun and enjoyment for youth. Emerging trends in youth sports such as 3 -on -3 soccer and 7 -on -7 flag football were two ideas discussed at the recent meeting. Given the not-for-profit nature of the Foundation and the new sporting and fellowship ideas offered, staff supports the sale of the property at the proposed price. Since the Fourldation is a not-for-profit organization, §125.38 Fla. Stat. (2016) allows the County to sell the Ballfield property to the Foundation without the need for the public bidding process at a price deemed acceptable to the Board, without regard for the actual value of the property. As was discussed at the February 7th Board meeting, a group led by Gene Waddell expressed interest in purchasing the Ballfield property. After learning of the Foundation's interest in the property, Mr. Waddell's group has decided not to go forward with their discussions and has expressed support for the Foundation's proposal. Fundine. There are no County funds impacted by this matter, however, if the sale is completed, staff wishes to earmark proceeds from the sale for recreational purposes. Recommendation. Staff recommends the Board approve the terms of the proposed purchase of the 16th Street Ballfield property by the Jimmy Graves Foundation at a price of $250,000 and authorize the Chairman to sign the attached letter and all other documents necessary to effectuate the sale. It is further recommended that the Board direct staff to negotiate the final terms of the Purchase Agreement and cooperate with the Foundation during the due diligence period. Copies to: Rebecca F. Emmons, Esq. Attachments: Aerial photograph Letter from Superintendent Proposed purchase letter Resolution P115 �I •�-` 4. ±:,�i.� ,:.---- 1 � n —�-- � i� � _ __ � yet ,•f {. `L �1 � tl � k1 , I.� .1 •'r �-V, �, +t 'f/ 1 •F ''ll � ,� �1�� 'i a i� - • A t �' � y t J� �' � 7 �[!`� 1 I • -•I � _/'-tet, ,� — �.� y: � +'circ+ 'A ,o ;! � + N + I, � 1-,`. '1 5�...,r".`.`� •Y.�.-�. ��_ ,,.�..,.. t -_ E X H T R.., School District of Indian River county 6500 57t' Street • Vero Beach, Florida, 32967 • Telephone: 772-564-3000 + Fax: 772-564-3054 Mark J. Rendell, .Ed.D. - Superintendent RE: 16th Street Ballflelds — Offer to Exchange Real Property Dear Mr. Brown: Recently we received a letter, dated February 9, 2017, from Mr. William K. DeBraal, .Deputy County Attorney, outlining a proposal from the Board of County Commissioners to exchange various parcels of 'land, or properties. The letter was sent directly to each member of the School Hoard. At our Business Meeting held on Tuesday, February 14" 2017, the School Board members reviewed the proposal outlined in that letter. The majority of the Board did not indicate any interest in accepting the offer to exchange properties as presented. I .ask that you share this Information with the Board of County Commissioners, Mr. DeBraal, and any other staff you deem appropriate.. Thank you for your time, Sincerely, i Mark 1. Rendell { Superintendent i I c School Board of Indian River County Judy Stang, executive Assistant to the School Board 1 "Educate and inspire every student to be successful" Shawn R. Frost • Dale Simchick • Laura Zorc s Charles G. Searcy • 'tiffany M. Justice 6 District 1 District 2 District 3 District 4 District 5 ? A "To serve all students with excellence - Equal Opportunity Educator and Employer t P117 Indian River County February 15, 2017 FEB 2 3 2017 Jason Brown, County Administrator of(tceofthe Indian River County CountyAdininistWOr 1801— 271h Street, Building A Vero Beach, FL 32960 RE: 16th Street Ballflelds — Offer to Exchange Real Property Dear Mr. Brown: Recently we received a letter, dated February 9, 2017, from Mr. William K. DeBraal, .Deputy County Attorney, outlining a proposal from the Board of County Commissioners to exchange various parcels of 'land, or properties. The letter was sent directly to each member of the School Hoard. At our Business Meeting held on Tuesday, February 14" 2017, the School Board members reviewed the proposal outlined in that letter. The majority of the Board did not indicate any interest in accepting the offer to exchange properties as presented. I .ask that you share this Information with the Board of County Commissioners, Mr. DeBraal, and any other staff you deem appropriate.. Thank you for your time, Sincerely, i Mark 1. Rendell { Superintendent i I c School Board of Indian River County Judy Stang, executive Assistant to the School Board 1 "Educate and inspire every student to be successful" Shawn R. Frost • Dale Simchick • Laura Zorc s Charles G. Searcy • 'tiffany M. Justice 6 District 1 District 2 District 3 District 4 District 5 ? A "To serve all students with excellence - Equal Opportunity Educator and Employer t P117 EXHISIT 11011 Kevin M. Barry •' Brooke M. Benzio Rebecca F Emmons Stephen J. Lacey 1. 3.9 Aaron D. Lyons 1.6 Justin W. McConnell Chelsea A. Miller J. Cole Oliver Tiffany S. Padgett Patricia L. Reid Bradley W Rossway Gregory J. Schwendeman Helen E. Scott Jason D Sister 2 R. Blake Smith John M. Stewart Michael J. Swan Thomas W. Tierney 2 Timothy M. Williams Clifton A. McClelland, Jr. Of Counsel William J. Stewart Of Counsel Edward P Swan (1927-2012) ' LLM - Taxation 2 Also admitted in CA ' Also admitted in GA 'Also admitted in MA 'Also admitted in NY Also admitted in OH 'Also admitted in PA 'Also admitted in TN 'Also admitted in VA LOCATIONS VERO BEACH The Modern One Building 2101 Indian River Blvd. Suite 200 Vero Beach, FL 32960 772.231 4440 MELBOURNE One Harbor Place 1901 S. Harbor City Blvd. Suite 500 Melbourne, FL 32901 321 984.2700 CORAL GABLES - Gables International Plaza 2655 LeJeune Rd. Penthouse 1-C Coral Gables, FL 33134 305.443.5020 Vydpp i; f.- I �i�i ROSSWAY SWAN ROSSWAY SWAN TIERNEY BARRY LAGEY & OLIVER, P.L. WWW.ROSSWAYSWAN.COM March 7, 2017 , VIA EMAIL TO: ibrown(a�ircl:ov Com Jason E. Brown County Administrator Indian River County 1801 2T" Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 RE: Jimmy Graves Foundation, Ina ("Buyer") proposed purchase from Indian River County {"Seller') of "I7rh Street BaUjklds" Dear Mr. Brown: This firm has the pleasure of representing the Jimmy Graves Foundation, Inc. in connection with the above -captioned matter. This letter represents a formal declaration of the Foundation's intent to purchase the property general identified as the "17i1' Street Balifrelds" which consist of approximately 11.76 acres on the north side of 16' Street between 171 and 20r' Avenue in the City of Vero Beach, Florida on the following terms and conditions: Properly: FROM SW COR OF SE 1/4 RUN N 80 FT TO N R/W OF 16TH ST & POB, TH E 943.19 FT TO W R/W OF 17TH AVE, TH N 463.5 FT, RUNT W 250 FT, RUN N 245 FT, RUN W 233.74 FT, RUN S 108.5 FT, RUN W 447 FT, TH S 600 FT TO POB LESS W 8 0 FT (RILEY FIELD BASE BALL DIAMONDS) Price: $250,000.00 (Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars). Purchase price is based, in part, upon existence of restrictive easements on the property and Purchaser's anticipated expenses associated with property improvement and need to change the future land use of the property to construct such improvements. Purchaser: Jimmy Graves Foundation, Inc. a Florida not for profit corporation (or its to be formed tax exempt whole owned LLC) Earnest Money: $10,000.00 to be deposited into an escrow account held by Rossway Swan Tierney Bang Lacey & Oliver, P.L. within five (5) days of the effective date of a formal Purchase and Sale Agreement (the "Effective Date"). Deposit to be fully refundable at any time during the Due Diligence period, upon notice. P118 Due Diligence: Purchaser shall have a 10 business days due diligence period from the Effective Date and receipt of all relevant documents and records from County. Contract: Purchaser shall provide a draft purchase and sale agreement to seller within 5 business days of the execution of this letter. Closing. Expenses: Each party shall be responsible for their own closing expenses traditionally paid for on transactions of this nature in Indian River County, Florida. Closing Date: Within 30 calendar days after the expiration of the Due Diligence Period. Contingency: Due diligence acceptable to Purchaser in its sole and absolute discretion, which includes without limitation: appraisal, environmental matters, physical inspection, title, zoning and financing. This letter of intent is not intended to create a binding agreement on the Seller to sell or the Purchaser to buy. The purpose of this letter is to set forth the primary terms and conditions upon which to execute a formal Purchase and Sale Agreement. All other terms and conditions shall be negotiated in the formal Purchase and Sale Agreement. This letter of intent is open for acceptance through March 21, 2017. Agreed and accepted: By: APPROVED AS TO FORM AN * L MNC 8Y 'WILUALSX.OEBRMI DEPUTY COUNTY ATTORNEY Sincerely, Rec F. Emmons, Esq. for the Foundation Date: P119 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, FINDING THAT THE SALE OF THE 16TH STREET BALLFIELD PROPERTY IS IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE CITIZENS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA WHEREAS, the County owns a parcel of property located north of 16th Street between 20th Avenue and 17th Avenue .in Vero Beach, Indian River County; and WHEREAS, the property is known as the 16th Street Ballfields and contains improvements consisting of three softball/little league/baseball diamonds with lights, fencing, parking, concession, press boxes and announcers' booths; and WHEREAS, the County no longer desires to maintain the property and has declared the Ballfield property to be surplus; and WHEREAS, the Jimmy Graves Foundation was organized by Carole and Joseph Graves, whose son, Jimmy Graves died in a boating accident; and WHEREAS, the family and friends of Jimmy Graves wish to carry on the spirit and memory of this accomplished multi -sport athlete by purchasing the Ballfield property in order to honor the life of Jimmy Graves. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: 1. It is in the best interest of the health, safety and welfare of citizens of Indian River County to sell this property to the Jimmy Graves Foundation for the sum of $250,000. 2. Staff is hereby directed to take the steps necessary to prepare the documents necessary to effectuate the sale of the Ballfield property to the Jimmy Graves Foundation. 3. . This Resolution is being made pursuant to Florida Statute 125.38. P120 RESOLUTION NO. 2017 - This resolution was moved for -adoption by Commissioner , and the, motion was seconded by Commissioner , and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: Chairman Joseph E. Flescher Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan Commissioner Susan Adams Commissioner Bob Solari Commissioner Tim Zorc The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and :adopted this 14th day of March, 2017. Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: illiam K. De raal Deputy County Attorney INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA by its Board of County Commissioners By Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of the Court and Comptroller By Deputy Clerk 2 P121 DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS Indian River County Inter -Office Memorandum Office of Management and Budget Date: March 1, 2017 To: Members of the Board of County Commissioners Through: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator From: Michael Smykowski - Director, Office of Management & Budget Subject: Children's Services Funding Allocation for Fiscal Year 2017/2018 Description and Conditions Each year, the Board of County Commissioners approves a funding allocation for Children's Services. This amount is then allocated to the applicants based upon recommendations of the Children's Services Advisory Committee. The County historically changed the funding allocation based upon the previous fiscal year's taxroll change with exceptions during the economic downturn. Funding during the downturn reached a low point of $623,890 and was held constant at that level during FY2012/2013, FY2013/2014, and FY2014/2015. For fiscal year 2015/16, the Board of County Commissioners approved a matching program where each dollar raised by the community would be matched dollar for dollar up to $200,000 in addition to the based funding amount of $651,965. It should be noted that the base funding amount was based upon the prior year's allocation ($623,890), plus the change in the taxroll for the prior year (4.5%). This resulted in total county funding of $851,965, plus $200,000 raised from the community (for a total of $1,051,965) allocated through the process. In the current fiscal year, (FY 2016/2017), the Board of County Commissioners provided funding for the entire allocation from the previous year ($1,051,965), which resulted in a $200,000, or 23.5% increase from the prior year. The $1,051,965 in FY 2016/2017 approved funding represents an increase of $428,075 or 68.6% from the low point of $623,890 approved in FY2014/2015. Staff is requesting that the Board set a funding allocation for Children's Services for FY 2017/18 at this time. The funding level in accordance with the prior policy for Children's Services (based upon the previous fiscal year's tax roll change) would generate $1,117,397 which is an increase of $65,432 or 6.22% over the base funding amount for the current year. Staff anticipates a moderate increase in the tax roll for next fiscal year. Staff also anticipates several other funding request increases due to deferred capital purchases and continued constrained funding levels for various agencies. It is anticipated that these requests will continue to strain the County's resources, even with the benefit of a rising tax roll. P122 Board of County Commissioners Page 2 of 2 March 1, 2017 It should be noted that interested parties in the community have suggested increasing the Children's Services funding to the 0.1250 millage cap. Assuming a 3% growth in taxable value, the 0.1250 millage would yield $1,857,000 in FY 2017/2018 based on appropriating only 95% of estimated revenues, in accordance with Florida Statutes. If the Board wants to consider funding Children's Services at the millage cap, staff would recommend that this be phased in over a six year period, as this would lessen the financial pressure on the General Fund in FY2017/2018 and still provide an average annual increase of $186,468 in funding each year. (See table below). Assumption re Taxable Value Taxable Value Milla a Rate Revenue Generated at Milla a Cap 950/0 Incremental Revenue Millage Increment FY2017 Taxable Value $16,182,423,493 0.1250 $1,897,803 $1,802,913 FY2108 Taxable Value @ 3% Increase $15,637,896,198 0.1250 $1,954,737 $1,857,000 FY2017 Taxable Value $15,182,423,493 0.072935 $1,107,332 $1,051,965 FY2108 Taxable Value @ 3% Increase $15,637,896,198 0.0800 $1,251,032 $1,188,480 $136,615 0.0071 FY2019 Taxable Value @ 39/6 Increase FY2020 Taxable Value @ 3% Increase $16,107,033,084 $16,590,244,076 0.0900 0.1000 $1,449,633 $1,659,024 $1,377,151 $1,676,073 $188,671 $198,922 0.0100 0.0100 FY2021 Taxable Value @ No Increase FY2022 Taxable Value @ 39/6 Increase FY2023 Taxable Value @ 39/6 Increase $17,087,951,399 $17,600,589,940 $18,128,607,639 0.1100 0.1200 0.12601 $1,879,675 $2,112,071 $2,266,0761 $1,785,691 $2,006,467 $2, 52.7721 $209,618 $220,776 $146,3051 0.0100 0.0100 0.0050 Recommendation Staff recommends that the Board of Commissioners approve funding for Children's Services agencies in the amount of $1,117,397 for fiscal year 2017/2018, which is an increase of 6.22% or $65,432 from the current year base funding level. This recommendation is based on efforts to avoid a General Fund millage increase in the upcoming fiscal year. Attachment Children's Services Funding History APPROVED AGENDA ITEM: FOR: March 14, 2017 P123 Children's Services Council Advisory Committee Funding History (FY1997/98 through FY2016/17) Fiscal Year Total Approved Fundis % Increase 1997/1998 $81,370 n/a 1998/1999 $293,835 261.1% 1999/2000 $414,072 40.9% 2000/2001 $750,000 81.1% 2001/2002 $900,000 200% 2002/2003 $900,000 0.0% 2003/2004 $1,147,750 27.5% 2004/2005 $1,223,000 6.6% 2005/2006 $1,173,000 -4.1% 2006/2007 $1,208,100 3.0% 2007/2008 $1,100,000 -8.9% 2008/2009 $882,700 -19.8% 2009/2010 $768,100 -13.0% 2010/2011 $691,290 -10.0% 2011/2012 $656,726 -5.0% 2012/2013 $623,890 -5.0% 2013/2014 $623,890 0.0% 2014/2015 $623,890 0.0% 2015/2016 $851,965 36.6% 2016/2017 $1,051,965 23.5% Children's Services Council Funding History $1,400,000 $1,200,000 $1,000,000 H C $800,000 C $600,000 G $400,000 $200,000 $0 p0� 000 Op0 00'Y 001 003 OOb p0y Opo Opt p0`b p0°� O,yO Oy'y OyL 0,� 0�a0,h O 0,1 �OyD�'L Oy�� �Oy�O\'L Fiscal Year P124 $200/child $175/child $150/child $125/child $100/child $75/child $ 50/child $ 40/child Taxpayer Expenses For Children's Services -2016 (Excludes in school K-12 Expenses) Martin County Children's. Council Children- 25,890 Direct Spend- $5,580,231 St. Lucie County* Children's Council Children- 60,946 Direct Spend- $7,134,865 CJ 0 • O �lJ y�� $200/Shooting Range Card Shooting Range ($56 Per Visit) �$94/Licensed Animal . Animal Control r' $41/Child Children's Services (CSAC)' Indian River County Children's Services (CSAC) Children- 25,550 Direct Spend- $1,051,965 ilk � i I I I SPENDING DATA. * MARTIN COUNTY AUDIT, SEPTEMBER 2016 1 * ST LUCIE BUDGET I * IRC 2016-2017 BUDGET BOOK CHILDREN <18 DATA. CENSUS AMERICAN COMMUNITY SURVEY #DP05 THE 19, AIR, IN 1999: In lieu of creating an independent special taxing district (Children's Council), Indian River County Commisssioners agreed to take a portion of their existing real estate revenues in the General Account and allocate them to the newly created Children's Services Advisory Committee (CSAC) to fund local nonprofits serving at risk children. Under Ordinance No 99-1., Section 103.26, the Board of County Commissioners agreed to provide an assigned millage up to .125. While this allocation was intended to be scaled in, it never was. In fact, in the recession, when services were most needed, it was cut. GM BOD R M WOW9 3 FALL BEHIND? 2,500,000. 2,250,000. 2,000.000 1,750,000. 1,500,000 1,250,000. 1,000 000. 750,000 500,000. 250,000 0 CSAC HISTORY 1999 -Present TRUE L TAXALLOCATIONLLOCAT N ACTUAL FUNDS ALLOCATED 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 111* 1 $31 MILLION PROMISED Im *SPENDING DATA. IRC 1999-2016 BUDGET BOOKS Don't Undercut IRC Children! Allocating the proposed $1,051,798 for 2017 falls $848,035 dollars below codified commitment at $74/Child, and positions IRC Children to FALL BEHIND. `g Vote the Full .125:$1,900,000 for IRC Children. L s . �, -, I�,yA1