HomeMy WebLinkAbout06/20/2017d%
",ORP
7
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DISTRICT
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
District 2
Peter D. O'Bryan, Vice Chairman
District 4
Susan Adams
District 1
Bob Solari
District 5
Tim Zorc
District 3
1.
2.
3.
4.
CALL TO ORDER 9:00 A.M.
BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
COMMISSION AGENDA
TUESDAY, JUNE 20, 2017 - 9:00 A.M.
Commission Chambers
Indian River County Administration Complex
180127 th Street, Building A
Vero Beach, Florida, 32960-3388
www.ircgov.com
Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of the Circuit
Court and Comptroller
A MOMENT OF SILENT REFLECTION FOR FIRST RESPONDERS
GRANICUS #
INVOCATION Detective Teddy Floyd, Indian River County Sheriff's Office
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
ADDITIONS/DELETIONS TO THE AGENDA / EMERGENCY ITEMS
5. PROCLAMATIONS and PRESENTATIONS
A. Presentation of Proclamation Designating the Day of July 1, 2017 as
Honor Guards Day
June 20, 2017
17-0494
Page 1 of 7
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Regular Meeting of May 16, 2017 17-0625
B. Regular Meeting of May 23, 2017 17-0637
7. INFORMATION ITEMS FROM STAFF OR COMMISSIONERS NOT
REOUIRING BOARD ACTION
A. Preliminary Update on the County's Short Term Vacation Rental 17-0603
Regulations and Implementation
B. Proclamation and Retirement Award Honoring Randy Baker on His
Retirement From Indian River County Board of County Commissioners 17-0621
Department of Public Works/Fleet Management Division with Thirty -
Five Years of Service
C. Notice of Hazard Mitigation Grant Program Application for Elevation of 17-0636
the Main House at the Jones's Pier Conservation Area
D. Landfill Closure and Collection Service Changes for the July 4th Holiday 17-0643
E. Update regarding Indian River Lagoon Council Board of Directors 17-0653
Meeting on June 9, 2017
8. CONSENT AGENDA
A. Checks and Electronic Payments June 2, 2017 to June 8, 2017 17-0629
B. Memorandum of Agreement with Florida Department of Children and 17-0639
Families for Limited County Access to FLORIDA System Data
C. Resolutions Delegating the Authority to the County Administrator or his
Designee to Call Letters of Credit and to Act on Behalf of Indian River
County during the time frames of June 21, 2017, through and including 17-0649
July 10, 2017; July 19, 2017, through and including August 14, 2017; and
August 16, 2017, through and including September 11, 2017
D. Approval of Sublease with the Senior Resource Association for the Main 17-0620
Transit Hub
E. Approval of 2018 Holiday Schedule 17-0623
June 20, 2017 Page 2 of 7
F. Approval of Work Authorization No. 2017-007 to Replace Water 17-0638
Services in "Oaks of Vero" Subdivision
G. Approval of Children's Service Advisory Committee's Funding 17-0640
Allocations for FY2017-2018
H. Miscellaneous Budget Amendment 18 17-0644
I. Approval of Sealed Bid Sale of 2625 54th Avenue - Bid 2017059 17-0645
J. Approval of Sealed Bid Sale of 2605 52nd Avenue - Bid 2017058 17-0646
K. Property Damage Release Concerning Intergenerational Center for Ocean 17-0654
Doors and Windows, Inc.
9. CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS and GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES
None
10. PUBLIC ITEMS
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. Indian River County's Request for Special Exception Use
Approval for the Osprey Acres Floway and Nature Preserve 17-0592
(Public Limited Utility) [SP -SE -17-06-09 / 2005060500-78909]
(Quasi -Judicial)
2. Indian River County's Request for Abandonment of a Portion of
12th Avenue SW from 5th Street SW to a Point 165 Feet North
of 7th Street SW as shown on the Last General Plat of The Indian 17-0595
River Farms Company Subdivision [ROWA-17-03-02 /
2005060500-78340] (Legislative)
3. Right -Of -Way Ordinance and Rate Resolution (Legislative) 17-0648
4. Ordinance Concerning Medical Cannabis (Continued from June
13, 2017) (Legislative)
17-0655
June 20, 2017 Page 3 of 7
B. PUBLIC DISCUSSION ITEMS
1. Request to Speak from Michael Marsh Regarding Bodycams for 17-0650
Indian River County Sheriffs Office (IRCSO)
C. PUBLIC NOTICE ITEMS
1. Notice of Scheduled Public Hearing for July 11, 2017: FINAL
HEARING: County Initiated Request to Amend (Update) Mixed 17-0631
Use Policy 5.6 of the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the
County's Comprehensive Plan (Legislative)
2. Notice of Scheduled Public Hearing for July 11, 2017: Indian
River County's Request for Amendments to its Land
Development Regulations (LDRs); Providing for Amendment to
Chapter 915, Planned Development (P.D.) Process and Standards 17-0633
for Development; by Amending Section 915.20 Mixed Use
Standards to be consistent with proposed Future Land Use
Element Policy 5.6 changes requiring mixed use in the
IRSC/SR60 preferred location area. (Legislative)
3. Notice of Scheduled Public Hearing for July 11, 2017: Indian
River County's Request for Amendments to its Land
Development Regulations (LDRs); Providing for Amendment to
Chapter 926, Landscape and Buffer Regulations, by Amending 17-0634
Section 926.05 General Requirements to establish provision for
reducing certain landscaping requirements for projects located in
remote agricultural areas. (Legislative)
11. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR MATTERS
None
12. DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS
A. Community Development
1. Follow-up on Development Review Tasks Resulting from April 17-0602
Workshop
B. Emergency Services
None
C. General Services
None
1. Human Services
None
June 20, 2017 Page 4 of 7
2. Sandridge Golf Club
None
3. Recreation
None
D. Human Resources
1. Health Insurance Recommendations for Plan Year 2017/2018
E. Office of Management and Budget
None
F. Public Works
None
17-0624
G. Utilities Services
1. North Sebastian Septic to Sewer (S2S) Phase 1, Resolution I
(Preliminary Assessment Roll) and Resolution II (Public Hearing 17-0652
Date)
13. COUNTY ATTORNEY MATTERS
A. A Resolution Directing Staff to Work With the Members of the Treasure
Coast Council of Local Governments to Promote and Defend Home Rule 17-0641
Authority
B. A Resolution Authorizing Participation in a Joint Meeting With The
Board of County Commissioners for St. Lucie County and The Board of 17-0642
County Commissioners for Martin County to Discuss Joint Legislative
Priorities
C. 2017 - Special Session A 17-0656
D. Florida Department of Environmental Protection Domestic Wastewater 17-0647
Facility Permit for Sunbreak Farms
E. Code Enforcement Board Appointment 17-0651
14. COMMISSIONERS MATTERS
June 20, 2017 Page 5 of 7
A. Commissioner Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
None
B. Commissioner Peter D. O'Bryan, Vice Chairman
None
C. Commissioner Susan Adams
None
D. Commissioner Bob Solari
None
E. Commissioner Tim Zorc
None
15. SPECIAL DISTRICTS AND BOARDS
A. Emergency Services District
1. Approval of Minutes Meeting of April 4, 2017 17-0514
2. Approval of Minutes Meeting of May 2, 2017 17-0577
3. Approval of Minutes Meeting of May 9, 2017 17-0576
4. Approval of Property Lease Extension for Temporary Location 17-0613
of Fire -Rescue Station No. 7
B. Solid Waste Disposal District
None
C. Environmental Control Board
None
16. ADJOURNMENT
Except for those matters specifically exempted under the State Statute and Local Ordinance, the Board
shall provide an opportunity for public comment prior to the undertaking by the Board of any action on
the agenda, including those matters on the Consent Agenda. Public comment shall also be heard on any
proposition which the Board is to take action which was either not on the Board agenda or distributed to
June 20, 2017 Page 6 of 7
the public prior to the commencement of the meeting.
Anyone who may wish to appeal any decision which may be made at this meeting will need to ensure
that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and evidence upon
which the appeal will be based.
Anyone who needs a special accommodation for this meeting may contact the County's Americans with
Disabilities Act (ADA) Coordinator at (772) 226-1223 at least 48 hours in advance of meeting.
Anyone who needs special accommodation with a hearing aid for this meeting may contact the Board of
County Commission Office at 772-226-1490 at least 20 hours in advance of the meeting.
The full agenda is available on line at the Indian River County Website at www.ircgov.com The full
agenda is also available for review in the Board of County Commission Office, the Indian River County
Main Library, and the North County Library.
Commission Meeting may be broadcast live by Comcast Cable Channel 27
Rebroadcasts continuously with the following proposed schedule:
Tuesday at 6.00 p.m. until Wednesday at 6: 00 a. m.,
Wednesday at 9:00 a.m. until 5:00 p.m.,
Thursday at 1: 00 p.m. through Friday Morning,
and Saturday at 12: 00 Noon to 5: 00 p. m.
June 20, 2017 Page 7 of 7
sA
PROCLAMATION
DESIGNATING THE DAY OF JULY 1, 2017, AS HONOR GUARDS DAY
WHEREAS, Honor Guards and their families and communities face an increasingly difficult
role as they protect and serve the nation and public; Honor Guards of America consist of
former and retired military, US Coast Guards, Police, Fire Fighters, Emergency Medical
Service (EMS) responders, Chefs and other agency personnel; and,
WHEREAS, in 2016, 16 Military, 140 Law Enforcement Officers, 68 Fire Fighters and 15 EMS
responders across the nation lost their lives in the line of duty, representing the highest Line Of
Duty Deaths in years; and,
WHEREAS, the men and women who wear these uniforms understand the dangers of their
job, but they heed the call to serve and willingly face those risks every day, in order to create a
safe nation and communities for all Americans; and,
WHEREAS, Indian River County recognizes and appreciates the sacrifices of Honor Guards
and their families and support their efforts to keep Indian River County a safe place to work,
live and visit.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that the day of July 1, 2017, be
designated as Honor Guards Day in Indian River County and the Board encourages all citizens
to acknowledge and value the service provided by Honor Guards.
Adopted this 20th day of June, 2017. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
Peter D. O'Bryan, Vice Chairman
Susan Adams
Bob Solari
Tim Zorc
P1
7A
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
TO: Jason E. Brown; County Administrator
FROM: Stan Boling, AICP; Community Development Director
DATE: June 6, 2016
SUBJECT: Preliminary Update on the County's Short Term Vacation Rental Regulations and
Vacation Rental Permit Implementation
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
BACKGROUND
At its meeting of June 21, 2016, the Board of County Commissioners (Board) concluded a
comprehensive effort to develop regulations for short-term vacation rentals. At that meeting, the
Board adopted special vacation rental regulations, established significant fines for vacation -rental
violations, and adopted an application fee for a County vacation rental permit process that
implements the vacation rental regulations. As part of its action at the June 21, 2016 meeting, the
Board directed staff to provide a "progress report" a year after adoption of the new regulations (see
Attachment 1).
Staff herein provides a preliminary update to the Board on implementation of the vacation rental
regulations. In October 2017, one year after full implementation of the County's vacation rental
permitting program, staff will present a full evaluation in a format that will allow public discussion.
ANALYSIS
Although the Board adopted short-term vacation rental regulations on June 21, 2016, it took some
months after adoption to fully implement the County's vacation rental permitting program and to
begin formally contacting owners/operators of suspected vacation rental units. After adoption ofthe
regulations, staff worked to secure a contract with an outside service provider to identify and track
internet advertisements for vacation rental units located in the unincorporated area of the county.
After securing the contract, it took additional time to obtain and refine data on suspected units, to
train code enforcement staff on inspection duties, and to develop listings and to begin mailing out
letters to owners/operators of suspected units. Mail -out notices began in October 2016.
C1Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Loca1\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@0006F8FE\@BCL@0006F8FE.docx
P2
Based on refined data provided by the County's service provider (iCompass/Host Compliance), staff
broke -down suspected vacation rental units into three sub -geographic areas of the county: the south
barrier island, the north barrier island, and the mainland. Staff then contacted each unit
owner/operator to confirm the use of the unit and to prompt initiation of the permit process when
applicable. To date, staff has found that, after staff contact, a significant number of owners/operators
ceased advertising for short term rental periods (less than 30 days). As previously reported to the
Board, the County's service provider continuously tracks all internet advertisements, enabling easy
monitoring of any advertisement changes. Also, to date a number of unit owners/operators have
obtained or submitted for a County permit while others have been unresponsive and have been sent a
notice of violation.
Since adoption of the commercial event prohibition in 2015 and the vacation rental regulations in
2016, complaints received by Code Enforcement for vacation -rental nuisances declined significantly.
Staff's focus now is on getting all short-term vacation rental units properly permitted. As of June 1,
2017, vacation rental unit statistics are as follows:
Total
Suspected Pulled/ Obtained Permit Notice of
Units Changed Ads Permit Pendin Violation
South Barrier
Island 41 18 7 10 6
North Barrier
Island 31 19 2 6 4
Mainland 67 48 3 10 6
Total
Unincorporated
Area Total 139 85 12 26 16
By October 2017, staff will have a full year of experience implementing the ordinance and will be in
a better position to fully evaluate the effectiveness of the vacation rental regulations and
implementation. Until then, staff will continue implementing the County's vacation rental permit
program and enforcing the short-term vacation rental regulations.
RECOMMENDATION
This is an informational item only; no Board action is required.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Minutes from June 21, 2016 Board of County Commissioners Meeting
2. County Vacation Rental Permit Application (Includes Vacation Rental Regulations)
3. Vacation Rental Inspection Checklist
4. Spreadsheets for South Barrier Island, North Barrier Island, and Mainland Units
CAUsers\GRANIC-1 \AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@0006F8FE\@BCL@0006F8FE.docx
2
P3
9.
E. Change Order No. 1, Final Payment and Release of Retainage County
Road 512 Resurfacing from 125`}' Avenue to I-95, IRC Project No. 1304
_(memorandum dated June 102 20161 69-86
- - -------------------
Approved Change Order No. 1 and payment of Ranger Cons ction
Industries, Inc. Pay Application No. 4 (Final) for final ment and
release of retainage in the amount of $133,167.14.
F. Change Order No. 1 and Release of Retainage ation Boulevard / 20`h
Avenue Intersection Improvements
_(memorandum dated June 8, 2016) ____ 87-120
Approved Change Order No. 1 payment of Guettler Brothers
Construction, LLC Contract s Pay Application No. 6 (Final) for
release of retainage in the punt of $26,505.47.
G. Approval of Chi d en's Services Advisory Committee's Funding
allocations for F' cal Year 2016-17
__(memdated June 142 2016) 121-122
-------------------------------------------------------
AppLizendiations
he Children's Services Advisory Committee's funding
rec for Fiscal Year 2016-2017.
one
10. PUBLIC ITEMS
11:31 A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
a.m.
1. Consideration of Proposed Vacation Rental Ordinance Establishing
a Local License Requirement and Vacation Rental Regulations
(memorandum dated June 6, 20161 123-233
Legislative
Proof of Publication of Advertisement for Hearing is on file in the
Office of the Clerk to the Board
Community Development Director Stan Boling, in his
PowerPoint Presentation, gave a comprehensive review of short-
term vacation rentals (rentals) in the County. He discussed the
need to establish regulations to address unlicensed units, noise,
excess parking, and other issues that have been brought to the
County's attention by nearby residents. He spoke about
Ordinance 201.5-013, prohibiting commercial events in
residential areas, and Ordinance 2015-014, regulating parking
at residences, and stated that the Short Terre Vacation Rental
Advisory Committee (STVRAC) was established (with a sunset
provision) to consider additional regulations. Director Boling
thereafter summarized the proposed Ordinance, as
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 4
Attachment 1
P4
recommended by staff and the Planning & Zoning Commission
(P&Z).
Discussion ensued, and the Board received input from
Emergency Services Director John King and Fire Marshal John
Duran, regarding the proposed fire safety regulations.
Director Boling spoke on two clauses, a Compliance Timeframe
Provision, and a No Impairment of Contracts Provision, that
were included in the proposed Ordinance.
Discussion ensued about identifying rentals to make sure owners
are complying with the appropriate regulations.
Director Boling informed the Board that staff is considering
hiring a consultant who would provide specific addresses of
short-term rental units.
The :Board CONSENSUS was that it would be worthwhile to
hire the consultant discussed by Director Boling.
Director Boling replied that staff would report back to the
Board regarding the consultant.
In response to questions posed by the Board and a citizen, Clerk
of Circuit Court and Comptroller Jeffrey R. Smith discussed the
collection of the Tourist Development Tax on the rental units.
Deliberations ensued regarding the proposed local license fee,
frequency of inspections, and various other aspects of the local
license.
Commissioner O'Bryan elaborated on his suggestions to have a
three-year- local license and inspection; require an updated State
rental license annually; set a maximum cap of ten people per
vacation rental; to grandfather in any rental home that is
currently licensed based upon the number of bedrooms listed
today for two occupants per bedroom, plus two additional
persons; and rewrite the entire noise regulation section.
County Attorney Dylan Reingold asserted that the idea of
grandfathering the existing larger -capacity units to a two plus
two occupancy cap would be beneficial for assisting the County
in terms of potential liability.
The Chairman called a recess at 12:37 p.m., and reconvened the
meeting at 1:08 p.m., with all members present.
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 5
Attachment 1
P5
The Chairman opened the Public Hearing
George Lamborn, Vice President, South Beach Property
Owners Association (SBPOA), read a statement (copy on file)
urging the Board to pass regulations to restore peace and order
to residential neighborhoods.
Joseph Paladin, 6454 Tropical Way, President of Black Swan
Consulting, and a member of the Short Term Vacation Rental
Advisory Committee, supported a one -,year local license; a
triennial inspection; a maximum cap of ten individuals per unit;
and a dedicated section on noise regulations in the final
Ordinance. He also advocated a ban on outside amplification of
speakers.
Glen Powell, 12845 Bay Street, STVRAC Member and Vacation
Rental Owner, talked about having stronger noise regulations
for all residences. He also advocated for owners of existing
licensed rentals to have the use of their - rental unit
grandfathered and portable.
Commissioner Davis stressed that there is a huge difference
between a home and a short term vacation rental, and that he
was not in favor of a blanket prohibition of amplified devices.
Vice Chairman Flescher preferred to leave the noise regulations
broad -scale and applicable to all residences.
Carter Taylor, 2235 Silver Sands Court, advocated for an
annual County license and a three-year inspection; a temporary
ban on outdoor amplified sound; and a maximum of two
persons per bedroom, with a cap of ten occupants per unit.
A brief discussion ensued regarding the possibility of a Bert J.
Hari -is claim from licensed owners who are marketing their
units as having a large number of bedrooms.
Mark Mendelsohn, 665 Reef .Road, commented on collecting
taxes from the rental unit owners. He also expressed concerns
about the Code Enforcement Division's ability to address code
infractions, which often occur at night or on weekends.
Staff provided detailed information on code violation
procedures and policies of the Code Enforcement Division and
the Sheriffs Office.
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 6
Attachment 1
P6
Bill Walker, St. Christopher Lane, commented on County Code
Chapter 912, Single Family Development, and stated that lie
would support the maximum cap of ten persons per unit.
Bronica Jenkins, 1017 Casseekey Lane, expressed concerns
about the potential impact of' a ten -cap occupancy limit on
licensed owners who have customarily accommodated over ten
persons in their rental units. She wanted to make sure that as a
licensed owner, the usage of her rental units would be
grandfathered.
Colleen Rosenbaum, 1005 River Wind Circle, owner of a
vacation rental, spoke on her positive experiences with the
persons who have rented her unit, and the economic benefits of
tourist dollars.
Tuck Ferrell, 12546 North Highway AIA, representing the
North Beach Civic Association, stated that there have been
detrimental impacts on his neighborhood due to renters
overdoing activities or having targe groups of people. He asked
the Board to help create a situation where individuals can have
quiet enjoyment of their homes and neighborhood.
Barry Siegel, Esquire, 3096 Cardinal 'Drive, stated that his
client, Mitchell Dudek, would agree to the cap of two persons
plus two additional persons, as long as his property is given
grandfather status with portability. Attorney Siegel cautioned
that the County might be exposing itself to Bert Harris claims if
a cap is imposed without the grandfather provision.
Commissioner Zorc stressed the need to establish a fixed cap of
ten in order to send a clear message to developers who are
building "mega -mansions."
The Chairman called a recess at 2:56 p.m., and reconvened the
meeting at 3:04 p.m., with all members present.
Miles Conway, 2340 South Highway AIA, President South
Beach Property Owners Association (SBPOA), gave a slide
presentation (copy on file), in which he referred to County
Ordinances 2015-013 and 2015-014; Chapter 974 of the County
Code -Noise Ordinance Requirements; Ordinances adopted by
the City of Anna Maria in Manatee County, and Monroe
County; Florida Statute 509.032 (Public Lodging); proximity
restrictions established in San Luis Obispo County, California;
and other data to stress the need for stringent rental
regulations. He stressed that a short-term rental which
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 7
Attachment 1
P7
operates as a business, is very different than a traditional
residence, and that any more than ten persons constitutes an
event. Mr. Conway also noted that it would be unlikely for a
rental owner to file a Bert Harris claim.
Mr. Conway read into the record remarks from homeowners
Walter H. Forman, M.D., Thomas P. Gillman, DDS, and Dr.
Leigh Hoppe, M.D. who have experienced the short term renter
and noise issues, and he played a short audio clip of music
blaring from a nearby vacation rental at 9:21 a.m. on a Sunday
morning. He urged the Board to pass regulations that would
restore peace, tranquility, and harmony to residential
neighborhoods, through adoption of an occupancy cap of ten
persons, no grandfather clause, and a prohibition on outdoor
speakers. Mr. Conway also suggested that the Board consider,
in the future, making a tangible personal property, tax
certificate part of the local license requirement.
MOTION WAS MADE by Vice Chairman Flescher to direct the
County Attorney's office to meet with the Sheriffs Department
about how best to enforce the current noise violation standards
as written in Chapter 974 of County Code, and report back to
the Board. Motion DIED for lack of a second.
Additional discussion ensued on what standards might be added
to the proposed Ordinance to deal with noise violations at the
rentals.
ON MOTION by Commissioner O'Bryan, SECONDED by
Commissioner 'Davis, the Board unanimously approved to add
to the proposed Ordinance, language banning the amplification
of audio or visual sound devices (outdoors or directed outdoors)
in rental units; and for staff to return with an update on the
noise regulations governing rentals.
MOTION WAS MADE by Commissioner O'Bryan,
SECONDED by Commissioner Davis, to adopt Ordinance 201.6-
006, concerning amendments to its Land Development
Regulations (LDRS); establishing requireinents for a County
Vacation Rental License and other Vacation Rental Regulations
by creating Zoning Code Section 911.15(9); and providing for
repeal of conflicting provisions; codification; severability; and
effective date, with the following amendments:
.EST,4BLISH an occupancy cap, for units served by public
sewer, of two occupants per bedroom, plus two additional
persons for a maximum limit of ten people per vacation rental;
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 8
Attachment 1
P8
ESTABLISH an occupancy cap, for units served by a septic
system, of two occupants per bedroom plus two additional
persons, or the number of persons accommodated by the
system as determined by the health department, whichever
number of persons is less, with the maximum limit of ten people
per vacation rental;
GRANDFATHER the use of any existing State licensed vacation
rental home, based upon the number of bedrooms as listed in
the Property Appraiser's office, allowing two occupants per
bedroom, plus two additional persons with no cap, (or the
number of persons accommodated by the septic system as
determined by the Health Department), with that use being
transferrable with the house; the grandfather clause would
dissolve after one ,year, if a new owner does not utilize the
property as a rental.
Director Boling advised that an approved building permit plan
is the most accurate means to determine the number of
bedrooms.
It was clarified that any rentals which are grandfathered must
have a State license as of today's date (June 21, 2016), and their
occupancy cap will be based on the number of bedrooms on the
building plan.
MOTION WAS AAIENDED by Commissioner O'Bryan,
SECONDED by Commissioner Davis, to require that any owner
who seeks the grandfather provision must hold a State rental
license as of June 21, 2016, the occupancy limits will be based on
the number of bedrooms depicted in the unit's approved
building permit plan as of June 21., 2016 (unless the septic
capacity is less).
Attorney Reingold recapped the changes requested thus far to
the draft rental Ordinance.
Mr. Conway suggested that for the grandfathered units, the
Board freeze the septic tank capacity as it currently stands with
the unit.
AMENDED MOTION WAS REVISED by Commissioner
O'Bryan, SECONDED by Commissioner Davis, to freeze the
capacity (the number of persons that the septic tank will
accommodate as determined by the Health Department) of the
septic tanks for the vacation rental units that will be
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 9
Attachment 1
P9
grandfathered in.
Commissioners Davis and Solari stressed that the intention is
not to impact any single family home or longer term rental; the
regulations are targeted to the homes that are being operated as
businesses.
Commissioner O'Bryan wanted a cut-off date added to the
Claim of Contract clause, stating that an owner who asserts
impairment of his or her rental unit must have a contract
effective on or before the date the Ordinance is adopted.
A. brief discussion ensued with Attorney DeBraal, after which
the Board CONSENSUS was to direct staff to add language in
the Claim of Contract Impairment Clause in the proposed
Ordinance for "...an owner who asserts the enacted ordinance
amendment impairs an existing short term vacation rental
contract in existence as of the date of this Ordinance, June 21,
2016..."
The Chairman CALLED THE QUESTION, and the Amended
Motions carried unanimously. The Board adopted Ordinance
2016-006 as amended.
ON MOTION by Vice Chairman Flescher, SECONDED by
Commissioner O'Bryan, the Board unanimously approved,
Resolution 2016-056, amending the schedule of penalties and
notification time frames for code violations set forth in
Resolution No. 92-59, as amended by Resolution Nos. 95-62 and
2013-089, to include the enforcement of vacation rental and
commercial event at residence regulations.
ON MOTION by Vice Chairman Flescher, SECONDED by
Commissioner O'Bryan, the Board unanimously directed staff
to prepare and present a "progress report" on the vacation
rental ordinance one ,year after adoption of the vacation rental
ordinance.
ON MOTION by Vice Chairman Flescher, SECONDED by
Commissioner O'Bryan, the Board unanimously approved
Resolution 2016-057, establishing an application fee for a
County Vacation Rental License.
Board of County Commission Minutes
June 21, 2016 Page 10
Attachment 1
P10
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
VACATION RENTAL LICENSE APPLICATION
CODE ENFORCEMENT SECTION
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
180127 TH STREET (BUILDING A)
VERO BEACH, FLORIDA 32960
(772)226-1249
DATE RECEIVED
Note: Required acknowledgment form attached
Applicant name
Applicant mailing address,
City, State, ZIP
Applicant phone number
Applicant email address
Vacation Rent Unit address
City, State, ZIP
1. Rental unit manager contact information:
Manager name:
Cell phone number:
Email address:
Mailing address:
2. Attach the following:
Attached Not Attached
a. State license for vacation rental unit
b. Local business tax receipt from the Tax Collector
c. Local tourist tax account # from the Clerk of the Circuit Court
3. Parking information:
Total number of garage and/or carport parking spaces:
Location and number of parking spaces accommodated on improved or stabilized driveway (attach
sketch or aerial):
4. Verification that state license fire protection items are provided Provided in Not Provided in
in the vacation rental unit: smoke alarms, emergency lighting rental unit rental unit
(wired), fire extinguisher (Class 2-A 10 -BC w/ current tag).
Verification of carbon monoxide (CO) alarm, when required.
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC I
P11
5. Unit is served by (check one): Public sewer: On-site septic/drainfield system:
Note: If served by an on-site sewage treatment and disposal system, the applicant is required to
provide an existing system evaluation approved by the Health Department if the Health Department
has no record of the system size permitted by the department. Code Enforcement will contact you if the
Health Department has no record of the system size.
6. Total Number of bedrooms:
Square footage of each bedroom:,
Execute and attach the vacation rental regulations acknowledgement AttachedI Not Attached
form.
8. Application fee submitted: $250.00
THE ABOVE INFORMATION AND STATEMENTS ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY
KNOWLEDGE AND I WILL COMPLY WITH CHAPTER 911.15(9), LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
APPLICANT NAME (PRINT):
APPLICANT SIGNATURE
TE
STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED TO BEFORE
ME THIS DAY OF , 20 , WHO IS/ARE PERSONALLY
KNOW TO ME OR HAVE PRODUCED THEIR,
AND WHO DID NOT TAKE OATH:
NOTARY PUBLIC
STATE OF FLORIDA AT LARGE
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES:
_________FOR OFFICE USE ONLY========___________________
DATE RECEIVED: DATE ACCEPTED:
PROJECT/APP REQ #: STVRL #:
REVIEWER: APPROVED: DENIED: BY:
EXPIRATION DATE:
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENIWPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 2
P12
Vacation Rental Fire Extinguisher
Aire,
' / ♦ %
a:s»� n�sc e,r+ Cyt j
..-M 'MI -_ - y
RD
-MMiEit
814
• Required classification of fire extinguisher: Class 2-A 10- BC, minimum 5 lbs.
• At least .one"fire extinguisher is required; located in kitchen area.
•
Pressuregaugc on fire extinguisher must indicate a proper charge.(needle pointing to green).
+► Fire extinguisher must have a current inspection and certification tag from a qualified fire
equipment inspection/certification company.
a W,
tr ,r FIREPROTECf10.k59QY[S+E°u
�-88&«57-0515 ,
j;M '172.2193405
Vacation Rental Emergency Lighting
r
�1 �}X,,
!,I �
........`" --
Examples
(Note: "Exit" sign in addition to lighting is optional)
Battery [back-up] powered emergency lighting shall be provided for a period of not less than
one (1) hour to illuminate the primary exit. The emergency lighting shall provide illumination in
the event of any interruption of normal lighting [F.A.C. 69A-43.018(6)]
The emergency lighting is required to be:
• Hardwired (not plug-in)
• Interior lighting of the primary exit (exterior lighting not required)
• Elevated lighting to illuminate the exit from a downward direction
• Permitted: a county building permit is required for the installation
MACode Enforcement\Vacation rentals\Emergency lighting flyer.dou
Attachment 2
P14
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
VACATION RENTAL REGULATIONS
ACKNOWLEDGMENT FORM
1. I have reviewed and understand the following vacation rental regulations:
a. Prohibition on commercial events at residence (e.g. weddings and celebrations).
b. Special parking regulations.
c. Sea turtle protection lighting regulations and dune protection regulations (for rental units located east of
SR A -1-A).
d. Noise regulations: Chapter 974 noise regulations which include day and night decibel level limitations,
more stringent "no disturbance" requirements from 10 pm to 6 am, and no excessive noise that would
cause annoyance to any reasonable person of normal sensitivity.
e. Limitations on dock/boat use: (for waterfront rental units): no more than 2 boats moored per dock, dock
used by unit owner or renter only, no live -aboard use; (all rental units): no more than 2 boats stored or
parked per unit.
f. Fire safety requirements and maximum sleeping occupancy limitations.
g. Fines and citation penalties for violations.
2. The following information has been posted or displayed inside the vacation rental unit:
a. Manager contact information.
b. Maximum number limit of parked automobiles and boats, and approved parking locations.
c. Trash and recycling pick-up days and protocol for placing and retrieving/storing containers.
d. Noise regulations: day and night decibel level limitations, more stringent "no disturbance" requirements
from 10 pm — 6 am, and no excessive noise that would cause annoyance to any reasonable person of
normal sensitivity.
e. Location of smoke alarms, emergency lighting, and fire extinguisher.
f. Emergency room information.
g. Sea turtle protection lighting information and dune protection information (for rental units located east
of SR A -1-A).
h. Maximum sleeping occupancy (number of persons).
3. I have contact any applicable property owners association or homeowners association and am aware
of any applicable private restrictions.
4. I will ensure that any advertisement and any rental offering associated with the vacation rental unit
will contain the following information:
a. Local license number.
b. Occupancy limit confirmed by the County Code Enforcement Officer.
c. Maximum number of vehicles allowed to be parked outside a carport or garage.
d. Noise regulation summary (see item Id. above).
e. Commercial event at residence prohibition.
f. [For any unit located east of SR A -1-A] Requirements of 932.09(1), 932.09(4), and 932.06(1)-(4).
I hereby acknowledge that I fully understanding and have provide the propriate information noted above:
Applicant Name (print): Date:
Applicant Signature:
Attached for applicant's reference:
1. Prohibition on commercial events at residence 911.15(8)
2. Special parking regulations 911.15(4)(b)
3. Vacation rental regulations 911.15(9)
4. Noise Regulations Chapter 974
5. Limitations on dock boat use 917.06(6) & 932.07(1)
6. Sea Turtle protection regulations 932.09(1) and 932.09(4) and dune protection 932.06(1)-(4)
7. Fines and citations Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 3
P15
DEFINITION
Commercial event at residence a gathering of people for a celebration that may include but not
be limited to a: birthday, anniversary, wedding, reunion or sporting event characterized by music (live
or recorded), dancing, catered food, tents, outdoor tables, alcohol or use of shuttles or valet for guests.
1. Held or occurring at single-family residence.
2. Leased by the owner or the owner's agent for consideration in exchange for holding the
event at the residence.
911.15(8)
(8) Prohibition of commercial event at residence.
(a)As defined in Section 901.03, it shall be a violation of this Code for any owner to lease a single-
family residence as a location for a commercial event at residence to be held. It shall be prima
facie evidence of a violation of this code for an owner to advertise or hold out the property to be
used as a location for a commercial event at residence.
(b)A commercial event at residence held at a site that is:
1. Four (4) acres or greater in area; and
2. At a site that is zoned agricultural; or
3. At a site used for agricultural purposes
must first apply for and receive a temporary use permit as prescribed by IRC Code Chapter 972
prior to conducting the commercial event at residence.
(c) If the owner of the property is not on the premises at the time of a commercial event at residence, it
shall be a rebuttable presumption of a violation of this section.
(d)Notwithstanding the prohibitions contained in paragraph (a) above, should this ordinance impair an
existing contract for a commercial event at residence that is scheduled to be performed prior to
September 30, 2016, holding the commercial event at residence shall not be a violation of this
Code, so long as the contract documents are provided to the community development director by
October 31, 2015.
911.15(4)(b)
(4) Parking or storage of vehicles.
(b) Parking or storage of automobiles. Except as provided in subsections 1-3 below, a
maximum of three (3) automobiles (not including recreational vehicles) may be parked outside of
a carport or garage on a single-family zoned lot. However, one (1) additional vehicle for each
licensed driver permanently residing at the premises may be parked on the lot. No automobile
may be parked or stored in any required yard area except in a designated and improved or
stabilized driveway. The limitations on the number of automobiles parked outside of a carport or
garage shall not preclude the parking of automobiles by persons visiting a single-family home.
1. For a vacation rental that has a carport or garage, the number of automobiles that may be
parked outside of a carport or garage shall be limited to one automobile per bedroom not to
exceed a total of five (5) automobiles parked outside the carport or garage. Automobiles
parked outside of a carport or garage shall be parked within a designated and improved or
stabilized driveway and not within any required yard area.
2. For a vacation rental that has no carport or garage, the total number of automobiles parked
shall be limited to two automobiles plus one automobile per bedroom not to exceed a total of
five (5) automobiles parked on site. Automobiles parked outside of a carport or garage shall
be parked within a designated and improved or stabilized driveway and not within any
required yard area.
3. For all vacation rentals, all automobiles except for service and delivery vehicles shall be
parked on-site and shall not be parked within a road right-of-way except within a designated
and improved or stabilized driveway.
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENnAPPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 4
P16
911.15(9)
(9) Vacation rental local license and regulations.
(a) For purposes of vacation rental local regulations, "bedroom" is defined as follows: any room
used principally for sleeping purposes and meeting applicable building code requirements for a
bedroom.
(b) The owner of a vacation rental unit shall obtain from the community development department a
vacation rental license. A separate license shall be required for each vacation rental unit. Each
license shall be valid for a period of three (3) years from the date of issuance unless terminated by
the owner or found by the county to be in violation of license conditions, and each license may be
renewed every three (3) years upon approval by the community development department. A
license may be transferred to a new owner upon submission of updated license information and
execution of and assumption of license obligations and conditions on a form provided by the
community development department.
1. A license application shall be submitted to the community development department on a
form provided by the department.
2. License application review shall be managed by the community development department in
coordination with other county departments, local agencies, and state agencies.
3. Prior to issuance of a license or a license renewal, a county code enforcement officer shall
conduct an inspection of the vacation rental unit for compliance with the requirements of
this section of the zoning code [section 911.15(9)].
(c)License application submittal requirements are as follows:
1. Rental unit manager contact information (cell phone number, email address, mailing
address).
2. Documentation that the applicant has obtained the following:
a. State license for vacation rental unit.
b. Local business tax receipt from the tax collector.
C. Local tourist tax account from the clerk of the circuit court.
3. Parking compliance information: number of garage and/or carport spaces, number of rental
unit bedrooms, maximum number of automobiles allowed outside of garage/carport,
location of spaces accommodated on improved or stabilized driveway.
4. Verification that carbon monoxide alarms, if required by code, and state license fire
protection items have been provided in the vacation rental unit: smoke alarms, emergency
lighting, fire extinguisher.
Unit interior under air information: square footage and number of bedrooms.
6. Verification of whether the unit is served by public sewer service or an on-site sewage
treatment and disposal system (septic/drainfield system). If served by an on-site sewage
treatment and disposal system, the applicant will be required to provide an existing system
evaluation approved by the health department if the health department has no record of the
system size permitted by the department.
7. Acknowledgment form provided by the community development department, executed and
dated by the rental unit owner and manager. The acknowledgment form shall provide
information regarding the following county requirements for vacation rentals.
a. Prohibition on commercial events at residence (e.g., weddings).
b. Special parking regulations.
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 5
P17
C. Sea turtle protection and dune protection regulations (for rental units located east of
SR A -1-A).
d. Noise regulations: Chapter 974 noise regulations which include day and night
decibel level limitations, more stringent "no disturbance" requirements from 10:00
p.m. to 6:00 a.m., and no excessive noise that would cause annoyance to any
reasonable person of normal sensitivity.
e. Limitations on dock/boat use: (for waterfront rental units): no more than two (2)
boats moored per dock, dock used by unit owner or renter only, no live -aboard use;
(all rental units): no more than two (2) boats stored or parked per unit.
f. Fire safety requirements and maximum sleeping occupancy limitations.
g. Fines and citation penalties for violations.
8. Acknowledgment that the following information will be posted or displayed inside the
vacation rental unit prior to inspection of the unit by the county code enforcement officer
and shall thereafter be continuously posted or displayed inside the vacation rental unit:
a. Manager contact information.
b. Maximum number of parked automobiles and boats, and approved parking
locations.
C. Trash and recycling pick-up days and protocol for placing and retrieving/storing
containers.
d. Noise regulations: day and night decibel level limitations, more stringent "no
disturbance" requirements from 10:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m., and no excessive noise that
would cause annoyance to any reasonable person of normal sensitivity.
e. Location of smoke alarms, emergency lighting, and fire extinguisher.
f. Emergency room information.
g. Sea turtle protection and dune protection information (for rental units located east
of SR A -1-A.
h. Maximum sleeping occupancy (number of persons).
9. Acknowledgement that the applicant has contacted any applicable property owners
association or homeowners association and is aware of private restrictions, if any, that may
affect operation of a vacation rental at the subject residence.
10. Application fee established by resolution of the board of county commissioners.
(d)Vacation rental local regulations are as follows:
1. To the extent that there is no conflict with these vacation rental regulations of section
911.15(9), all county regulations applicable to a residential unit that is not operated or used
as a vacation rental unit shall also apply to a vacation rental unit.
2. Parking and storage of vehicles shall conform to the requirements of zoning code section
911.15(4)(b).
3. Commercial events shall be prohibited in accordance with zoning code section 911.15(8).
4. The overnight maximum sleeping occupancy of a vacation rental unit shall not exceed the
following:
a. For a unit served by public sewer service, two (2) persons per bedroom plus two (2)
additional persons.
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT�APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 6
P18
b. For a unit served by an on-site sewage treatment and disposal system
(septic/drainfield system), two (2) persons per bedroom plus two (2) additional
persons or the number of persons accommodated by the system as determined by
the health department, whichever number of persons is less.
C. Notwithstanding paragraphs 4.a. and 4.b. above, a maximum (cap) of ten (10)
persons shall apply to each unit whether the unit is served by public sewer service
or by an on-site sewage treatment and disposal system (septic/drainfield system).
The unit occupancy limit confirmed by the county code enforcement officer shall
be stated on the local license.
5. Fire protection items required for a state vacation rental license shall be provided in the
vacation rental unit.
a. In addition, a carbon monoxide (CO) alarm, when required under Section R315,
Carbon Monoxide Alarms of the Florida Building Code—Residential, shall be
provided.
6. Changes in the vacation rental manager and/or changes in the manager contact information
shall be provided to the community development department within ten (10) days of the
change.
7. The local license number, the occupancy limit confirmed by the county code enforcement
officer, the maximum number of vehicles allowed to be parked on site outside any garage
or carport, the noise regulations statement contained in subsection (9)(c)7.d. of these
regulations, and a statement that there are special sea turtle protection and dune protection
regulations for units located east of SR A-lA, shall appear or be stated in any vacation
rental unit advertisement or any rental offering associated with a vacation rental unit.
8. Each year, the applicant shall submit to the community development department a copy of
a valid current state license for the vacation rental unit.
9. No amplification system, device, or sound system speakers, shall be used outdoors or
directed outdoors in a manner that is audible from an adjacent residential property.
(e) Interim operation of vacation rental unit:
1. Because of the length of time it may take to comply with all of the new requirements on
this section, all short term vacation rental owners may lawfully operate but shall have until
December 1, 2016, to obtain a license from the county and come into full compliance with
the new standards and requirements imposed by this section [911.15(9)].
(f) Claim of contract impairment:
1. It is not the intent of this ordinance [section 911.15(9)] to impair any existing contracts,
leases, or reservations, that are evidenced by writing. An owner who asserts the enacted
ordinance amendment impairs a short term vacation rental contract in effect on or before
June 21, 2016, shall submit the contract lease or reservation, evidenced in writing, to the
community development director for review and consideration. An owner shall have until
December 1, 2016, to submit the claim of impairment to the community development
director for determination. Appeal of the decision of the community development director
shall follow the appeal procedure set forth in land development regulation section 902.07.
(g)Units grandfathered -in for a higher occupancy cap.
1. A vacation rental unit in existence with a valid state license and operating with more than
four (4) bedrooms on June 21, 2016, shall be considered grandfathered -in as a legal
nonconformity and not subject to the occupancy limit maximum (cap) of ten (10) persons
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 7
P19
as stated in [subsection] (9)(d)4.c. so long as grandfathering is maintained in accordance
with section 904.08(1) for legal nonconformities. Overnight maximum sleeping occupancy
for grandfathered -in units shall be determined using the criteria of subsections (9)(d)4.a.
and (9)(d)4.b. For purposes of determining the number of bedrooms in operation for a
grandfathered -in unit on June 21, 2016, and for calculating the unit's maximum sleeping
occupancy the number of bedrooms shown on the unit's approved building permit drawings
of record as of June 21, 2016, shall be used..
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC S
P20
Chapter 974
Section 974.01. Short title and purpose.
Section 974.02. Definitions referenced.
Section 974.03. Noise and vibration restrictions, in general.
Section 974.04. Specific noise and vibration prohibitions.
Section 974.05. Additional noise control standards by zoning district.
Section 974.06. Exemptions.
Section 974.07. Opportunity for administrative approval.
Section 974.01. Short title and purpose.
This chapter shall be known and may be cited as the "Indian River County Noise and Vibration
Control Ordinance."
It is the purpose and intent of this chapter to regulate uses and activities in such a manner as to prevent
excessive noises and vibrations which degrade the quality of life, disturb the public peace, and jeopardize
the health, safety and welfare of the citizens of Indian River County. It is further the intent of this chapter
to recognize that factors such as the time of day, location (e.g., proximity to residences), and necessity of
sounds incidental to allowed uses and activities must be considered in balancing the protection of public
peace, individual freedoms and private property rights.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90)
Section 974.02. Definitions referenced.
The definitions of certain terms used in this chapter are set forth in Chapter 901, Definitions, of the
Indian River County Land Development Code.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90)
Section 974.03. Noise and vibration restrictions, in general.
It shall be unlawful for any person to make, continue, or cause to be made or continued any excessive,
unnecessary, or unreasonably loud noise or vibration which disturbs the peace or quiet of any
neighborhood or which would cause discomfort or annoyance to any reasonable person of normal
sensitivity. Moreover, it shall be prohibited for any person to engage in any use or activity that creates any
such noise or vibration contrary to the specific provisions of this chapter.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90)
Section 974.04. Specific noise and vibration prohibitions.
The following standards and restrictions shall apply to uses and/or activities in unincorporated Indian
River County, except as may conflict with the provisions of section 974.06, Exemptions, of this chapter.
Uses and/or activities in compliance with the standards and restrictions of this section shall not be subject
to the noise control standards set forth in section 974.05.
(1)Radios, television sets, musical instruments, and similar devices. It shall be unlawful to use,
operate, or permit to be played, used, or operated, any radio receiving set, musical instrument,
phonograph, television set, or other machine or device for the production or reproduction of
sound between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. in such manner as to create a noise or
vibration disturbance to neighboring premises.
Pertaining to radios, cassette players, disk players and similar devices associated with motor
vehicles, no such device shall be operated in such a manner as to create a noise or vibration
disturbance at one hundred (100) feet or more from such device, when operated on a public right-
of-way or public space.
(2) Construction equipment and activity. It shall be unlawful to operate any equipment or perform any
outside construction or repair work on buildings, structures, roads, or projects within the county
between the hours of 8:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. unless an administrative approval as set forth in
section 974.07 for such construction or repair work between such hours has been obtained from
Indian River County on the basis of good cause shown.
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 9
P21
(3)Engine mufflers. It shall be unlawful to operate any internal combustion engine, including such an
engine associated with a motor boat, or motor vehicle without a muffler or other device which
will effectively prevent loud or explosive noises therefrom.
(4)Animal noises. It shall be unlawful to keep or maintain any animal (including birds) without
providing and maintaining adequate sound -control techniques to eliminate any excessive,
offensive, and unnecessary noise. This provision shall not apply to property within an agricultural
zoning district.
(5) Vehicle repair in residential areas. It shall be unlawful to repair, rebuild, or test any motor vehicle
between the hours of 8:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. on property within or abutting any residential
zoning district in such a manner as to disturb the peace, quiet, and comfort of the residents of the
area.
(6)Activities in the vicinity of schools, courts, churches, and hospitals. It shall be unlawful to create
any excessive noise on any street adjacent to any school, court, church, or hospital which
unreasonably interferes with the workings of such institution, or which disturbs or unduly annoys
patients in a hospital.
(7)Loading or unloading of vehicles, opening bales, and boxes. It shall be unlawful to make, create, or
maintain any loud or excessive noise within the county that would result in a disturbance to
neighboring properties in connection with the loading or unloading of any vehicle or the opening
or destruction of bales, boxes, crates, or containers.
(8)Peddlers, hawkers, or vendors. It shall be unlawful for peddlers, hawkers, or vendors to shout or
cry along or on a roadway to the disturbance of the peace or quiet of a neighborhood.
(9)Drums, cymbals, and loudspeakers. It shall be unlawful to create, make, or maintain any noise by
the use of any drum, cymbals, loudspeaker, or other similar instruments in the county for the
purpose of attracting attention to any performance, show, sale, or display of merchandise, or
place of business. This provision shall not apply to ice-cream trucks or approval public events.
(IO)Bells or sirens on vehicles. It shall be unlawful for any person to use in conjunction with any
unauthorized vehicle any bell or siren similar to that used on ambulances or vehicles of the
sheriff, fire departments, and other public safety agencies.
(II)Skateboard ramps. It shall be unlawful to use any skateboard ramp or similar configuration
between 8:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. in a residential zoning district in such a manner that would
result in a disturbance to neighboring properties.,
(12)Air-blow cleaners. It shall be unlawful for any person to operate any air -blow cleaning equipment
or similar devices for the cleaning of parking lots, walkways, driveways, or similar areas between
the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. that would result in a disturbance to neighboring properties.
(I 3)Places ofpublic entertainment. It shall be unlawful for any public entertainment establishment or
person associated with or working for said establishment to operate, play or permit the operation
or playing of any radio, television, phonograph, drum, musical instrument, sound amplifier, or
similar device between the hours of 9:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. in such a manner as to create noise or
vibration that is a disturbance to neighboring premises.
(I4)Sounding of train horns or whistles. It shall be unlawful for any engineer, conductor, fireman or
other person in charge of or in control of any locomotive or railroad train of any railroad
company operating wholly within this state to sound any railroad train horn, whistle or other
audible warning signal between 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. in advance of or at any rail highway
crossing located within Indian River County, providing that the crossing is equipped with train -
activated automatic traffic -control devices, which shall include, flashing lights, bells and crossing
gates.
(I 5)Landscape maintenance. It shall be unlawful for any person to undertake landscape maintenance
activities in such a manner as to create a noise or vibration disturbance to neighboring premises
between the hours of 8:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m.
(I6)Power generators. It shall be unlawful for any person to manually or automatically exercise or
test a power generator 'in such a manner as to create a noise or vibration disturbance to
neighboring premises between the hours of 6:00 p.m. and 8:00 a.m. Marhgr&tic
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENAAPPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 10
P22
exercising or testing of power generators shall be for the minimum duration necessary to meet
manufacturer's specifications.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90; Ord. No. 2009-016, § 1, 10-13-09)
Section 974.05. Additional noise control standards by zoning district.
Except as may conflict with the specific noise and vibration provisions of section 974.04, it shall be
unlawful to project a sound or noise from one property into another property within the boundary of the
zoning district which exceeds the limiting noise spectra set forth in Table I below.
(I)Sound or noise projecting from one district into another zoning district with a different noise level
shall not exceed the limits of the district into which the noise is projected.
(2)The limits hereinabove referred to shall be in accordance with the following table:
TABLE I. APPLICABLE NOISE LIMITS
Measurement period one-quarter hour (continuous), as measured at the property boundary of the
receiving parcel. In multifamily developments (including duplex developments), the
measurement shall be taken from the receiving premises.
Level L(1). That noise (A -weighted sound level) exceeding one percent of a measurement time
equivalent to at least fifteen (15) minutes.
Level L(10). That noise (A -weighted sound level) exceeding ten (10) percent of a measurement
time equivalent to at least fifteen (15) minutes.
Level L(50). That noise (A -weighted sound level) exceeding fifty (50) percent of a measurement
time equivalent to at least fifteen (15) minutes.
*Residential developments within Agricultural Zoning Districts shall be subject to the decibel
level thresholds for the "Residential" Zoning Districts.
(3)If the noise occurs at any time on Sunday or holidays, the decibel level applicable between 10:00
p.m. and 6:00 a.m. shall prevail.
(4)Noise levels shall not exceed the peak noise levels, independent of time duration, set out in Table
II below:
TABLE 11. PEAK NOISE
Sound Level in Decibels A -Scale (DBA)
Zoning District
Day
6:00 a.m.-10.00 p.m.
Night
10:00 p.m. -6:00 a.m.
in Decibels
L
1
L
10
L
50
L
1
L
10
L
50
Conservation
65
60
55
60
55
55
Residential
70
65
60
65
60
55
Commercial
75
70
65
70
65
60
Industrial
75
70
65
75
70
65
Agricultural*
75
70
65
75
70
65
Level L(1). That noise (A -weighted sound level) exceeding one percent of a measurement time
equivalent to at least fifteen (15) minutes.
Level L(10). That noise (A -weighted sound level) exceeding ten (10) percent of a measurement
time equivalent to at least fifteen (15) minutes.
Level L(50). That noise (A -weighted sound level) exceeding fifty (50) percent of a measurement
time equivalent to at least fifteen (15) minutes.
*Residential developments within Agricultural Zoning Districts shall be subject to the decibel
level thresholds for the "Residential" Zoning Districts.
(3)If the noise occurs at any time on Sunday or holidays, the decibel level applicable between 10:00
p.m. and 6:00 a.m. shall prevail.
(4)Noise levels shall not exceed the peak noise levels, independent of time duration, set out in Table
II below:
TABLE 11. PEAK NOISE
LEVELS
Zoning District
Sound Level
(dBA)
in Decibels
A -Scale
Conservation
75
Residential
80
Commercial
85
Industrial
85
r►uacnrnUnL c
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENI�APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 11
P23
Agricultural 85
(5)For noise of impulsive character (hammering, etc.), the permissible decibel levels set out in Table I
shall be corrected by subtracting five (5) decibels. Impulsive sound is any sound of short
duration, usually less than one second with an abrupt onset and rapid decay, e.g. explosions and
blasting.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90; Ord. No. 2011-008, § 2, 9-13-11)
Section 974.06. Exemptions.
The following noises or vibrations shall be exempt from the restrictions set forth in the other sections
of this chapter.
(1)Noises of authorized safety signals and warning devices;
(2)Noises resulting from any authorized emergency vehicle, when responding to an emergency call or
acting in time of emergency or any other public safety operation;
(3)Noises resulting from emergency work, which is to be construed as work made necessary to restore
property to a safe condition following a public calamity, or work required to protect persons or
property from any imminent exposure to danger;
(4)Noises incidental to mosquito control activities by the Indian River County Mosquito Control
Board;
(5)Noises incidental to the activities of bona fide agricultural operations;
(6)Noises resulting from use of an emergency power generator during a power outage, provided that
the generator is operated in accordance with manufacturer's specifications, with all standard
equipment, and is in proper operating condition. Notwithstanding, noises resulting from use or
testing of a generator by a utility company to support installation, repair, maintenance, or
restoration of service operations are exempt from the restrictions set forth in this chapter;
(7)Noises resulting from an air conditioner, pool heater, and similar outdoor mechanical equipment
that is properly located, or county -approved as a "quiet" low decibel model unit, or installed with
a county -approved sound barrier or other county -approved noise -mitigating improvement as set
forth in section 911.15(2)(c) of Chapter 911, Zoning, and section 912.07(1)(b)6. of Chapter 912,
Single -Family Development.
(8)Noises or vibrations associated with uses or activities whereby an administrative approval to
produce such noises or vibrations contrary to the restrictions of this chapter has been obtained
from the community development director, as set forth in section 974.07 of this chapter.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90; Ord. No. 2009-016, §'2, 10-13-09; Ord. No. 2013-022, § 3, 12-10-13)
Section 974.07. Opportunity for administrative approval.
A deviation from the provisions of this chapter may be granted via an administrative approval from
the community development director. In reviewing a request for an exemption from the noise and vibration
restrictions of this chapter, the community development director shall consider the following factors:
Whether or not the proposed use or activity necessarily warrants a deviation from the noise and
vibration restrictions of this chapter;
Whether or not the noise and/or vibration associated with the proposed use or activity is compatible
with surrounding land uses so as not to create a disturbance to adjacent properties;
Whether or not the applicant has taken or will take all effort to limit excessive noises or vibrations
associated with the proposed use or activity to meet the intent of this chapter; and
In cases where the use or activity is proposed between 8:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m., whether or not such
hours of operation are necessary, and if so, are noises and vibrations associated with the use or activity
minimized.
(Ord. No. 90-16, § 1, 9-11-90)
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENI�APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 12
P24
Section 917.06. - Specific accessory uses and structures.
(6)Piers, docks, boatslips and waterfront structures. No dock, pier, boatslip, or waterfront structure
accessory to a single-family residence shall be rented, leased or sold to a party unless said party rents,
leases, or buys the associated single-family residence. See Chapter 932, Coastal Management, for more
information relating to piers, docks, boatslips and waterfront structures.
Section 932.07. - Piers, docks and boatslips.
(1)Restrictions upon regularly moored watercraft; maintenance. Watercraft shall not be regularly
moored along any shore without consent of the riparian land owner. Regularly moored watercraft shall
not be used as live -aboard vessels, offices or commercial enterprises except in commercial marinas
with approval and facilities for that purpose. Regularly moored watercraft shall be kept in seaworthy
condition when not in a permitted repair area. The mooring of live -aboard vessels (as defined in
Chapter 901) in commercial marinas shall be limited to those boat slips designated for live -aboard
vessels use on an approved site plan meeting the provisions described in section 971.35(3).
Section 932.09. Sea turtle protection.
(1)Purpose. The purpose of this section is to protect threatened and endangered sea turtles which nest
along the beaches of Indian River County, Florida, by safeguarding adult and hatchling sea turtles
from the impacts of light. The regulations of this section also serve as a light management mechanism
in furtherance of Indian River County's Sea Turtle Habitat Conservation Plan.
(4)Existing development. To meet the intent of this section, lighting of existing structures which can be
seen from the beach shall be in compliance with the following:
(a) Lights illuminating buildings or associated grounds for decorative or recreational purposes shall be
shielded or screened such that they do not directly or indirectly illuminate the beach, or turned off
after 9:00 p.m. during the period from March 1 to October 31 of each year.
(b)Lights illuminating dune crosswalks or any areas oceanward of the landward side of the dune line
shall be turned off after 9:00 p.m. during the period from March 1 to October 31 of each year and
shall not directly or indirectly illuminate the beach.
(c) Security lighting shall be permitted throughout the night so long as low -profile luminaries are used
and screened in such a way that those lights do not directly or indirectly illuminate the beach.
Motion detector switches may be used.
(d) Window treatments in windows within line -of -sight of an observer standing anywhere on the beach
on single and multistory structures are required so that interior lights do not illuminate the beach.
The use of non -reflective tint or film on windows or awnings is preferred; however, the use of
black -out draperies or shade screens will suffice.
(e)All exterior light fixtures on the seaward or shore -perpendicular sides of buildings, or on the
landward side of buildings if the fixtures are visible from the beach, shall be lamped with a long
wavelength light source, such as amber or red light emitting diodes (LED), low pressure sodium,
or true red neon. It has been recommended by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission that no such light source emit light below five hundred sixty (560) nanometers (nm).
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT\APPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 13
P25
Section 932.06. - Dune and shoreline protection.
In order to protect the natural vegetation and the main dune bluff fronting on the Atlantic Ocean, the
following restrictions shall be observed:
(])County dune stabilization setback line. The county hereby adopts the 1978 FDNR Coastal
Construction Control Line (C.C.C.L) as the County Dune Stabilization Setback Line (D.S.S.L.),
as recorded on June 10, 1981 in county Plat Book 10, Pages 93-93H.
(2)Encroachment, ingress, disturbance. Except as provided herein, encroachment or ingress onto or
any disturbance of the main dune or natural vegetation seaward of the county dune stabilization
setback line is prohibited, including encroachment or disturbance caused by individuals upon foot
or by vehicle of any kind. Ingress by foot seaward of the county dune stabilization setback line
must be associated with an approved dune crossover structure.
(3)New construction; disturbance of dunes, vegetation. The land between the coastal construction
control line and the county dune stabilization setback line is established as a zone of regulation,
whereby the Bureau of Beaches and Shores of the Florida Department of Natural Resources and
Indian River County may permit construction activity and construction related dune alteration.
Except as provided herein, new construction and/or disturbance of the dune and associated native
vegetation is not permitted seaward of the county dune stabilization setback line.
(4) Vehicles prohibited seaward of dune stabilization line; exception. Except as expressly provided in
subsection (5), it shall be unlawful for any person to operate, drive or propel any truck, tractor,
bulldozer, grader, crane, automobile, motorcycle, dune buggy, moped, minibike, all -terrain cycle,
or any other vehicle seaward of the county dune stabilization setback line excluding, however,
any of the aforementioned vehicles when operated by an officer of any agency of the state or of a
political subdivision of the state in the furtherance of official duties, or those operations which
have received the express authorization of the board of county commissioners. The parking or
storage of automobiles, trailers, motor homes, recreation and like vehicles is prohibited seaward
of the dune stabilization setback line (DSSL). Boats may be stored seaward of the dune
stabilization setback line if stored, located and moved in a manner that does not disturb, damage
or destroy the existing dune or associated dune vegetation, and in a manner that does not interfere
with the natural reestablishment of the dune or associated dune vegetation. Storage of boats is
also subject to the requirements of section 911.15(7). However, boats stored in accordance with
the requirements of this section by or with the permission of the abutting upland land owner, shall
be exempt from the requirements of section 911.15(7)(b)l. and 912.17(3)(b)l.
Attachment 2
FACOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENTIAPPLICATIONS\CODE ENFORCEMENT APPLICATIONS\VACATIONRENTALLICENSE.DOC 14
P26
RESOLUTION NO. 2016-_06
AMENDMENT TO RESOLUTION NOS. 92-59,95-62 and 201.3-089
Attachment A
CITATION ORDINANCE
SCHEDULE OF PENALTIES & NOTIFICATION TIME FRAMES
VIOLATION TYPE
SECTION
FINE'
NOTICE
TIME FRAMEEx
Stormwater violation
930
$100
48 hrs.
Vehicle parking & storage
911.15(4)
.$50
48 hrs.
Sea turtle li&ing violation
932.09
$50
24 hrs.
Fertilizer and Landscape
Management violations:
Timing of fert. app. vio.
Fertilizer -free zone vio.
Fertilizer content/app. vio.
Application practices vio.
Grass clippings/debris vio.
Comm. license/cert. vio.
316.3
316.4
316.6, 316.7
316.8
316.9
316.13
$503
$503
$503
$503
$503
$500
N/A
N/A
N/A
24 hrs.
24 hrs.
N/A
Vacation Rental
hi Ie narkitt vi ation
21L .M
$50 per vehicle per
occurrence per day
24 ktrs:"
fbr firsl violation:
$100 per vehicle tier
occurrence ler day
f e eatiol t' n
,failure to obtain or mainiain a valid
911,E
$100 per day ner
it
30 business days*
omp-tyYacatio-n-=ntal licenseio
Violafion of license condilipan1
da
24 ha,
C-QnkcA infonnalion update vtt
per v a
4
NWse yiplafiffl
911.15(9) and
.$100 per da�for
first violation; $300
W day for reheat
mme cr ial Event
�'rorntnercial event at reser
ante: due to Florida lawmt
IXCWAing $5 Qare asS���Qd_ t�-uAft
Q�,�-15181
$,i p�.r�vent�'�r
24jjrs,*
violrtttiQtt
$5-000-Dgtryent for
�o.%s�melit_
Board and not iy m s o citation
ret�eat�is�.lations
.eT
• J. / 1 1• _ .t 1 09-0-41111_
'Each day the violation exists represents a separate violation.
zThe notification time frame established herein may be waived if the violation presents a serious threat to the public
health, safety, or welfare, or if the violation is irreparable or irreversible.
'The fine shall be $100 for those violations by a person who has previously been found through the Code Enforcement
Board or any other quasi-judicial or judicial process to have violated, or who has admitted violating, the same section,
notwithstanding that the violations occur at different locations.
PACommunity DevelopmenAShort Term Vacation RcntalsNCitationFecSehedule.rtf
3
Attachment 2
im
PROJECT NAME:
LOCATION:
CD -PLUS Proj/Appl. #:
PERMIT #:
VACATION RENTAL LICENSE SITE INSPECTION CHECKLIST
Inspection requested by applicant: Date:
Inspection made: Date:
Re -inspections: Date:
GO OVER WITII PLANNER PRIOR TO SITE INSPECTION
[ ] Number of bedrooms per approved building plan?
[ ] Is property on public sewer or does it have an on-site septic system?
[) If on-site septic system, what is the occupancy capacity (per Health Depart.)?
[ ] Is the site grandfathered /exempt from the 10 maximum cap occupancy limit?
[ ] Is there a guest house on-site?
[ ] Is the site east of SR AIA?
[ ] Garage/carport or no garage/carport?
[ J Carbon monoxide alarm required/applicable?
(i.e., gas appliances or fire place inside, attached garage)
INSPECTION
Parking:
a) Total number of garage and/or carport parking spaces Actual:
b) Number of parking spaces on paved or stabilized driveway: Actual:
Occupancy / Bedrooms:
a) Number of bedrooms Actual:
b) Number of beds Actual:
Fire/Life Safety: Yes No
a) Smoke alarms (I perJloor, ],per bedroom area [within 10feet], 1 per bedroom, all interconnected, .
maybe 10 -year battery type) [ ] [ ]
b) Emergency lighting (at primary exit, wired) [ ] [ ]
C) Fire extinguisher (I in kitchen areu, Class 2 -sl 10 -BC 5 lbs min. with current tag, use 5 -point
checklist from Fire Prevention) [) [
d) Carbon monoxide (CO) alarm (if required, within 10 feel of bedroom ureas, may be combo
with smoke alarm) [) [ )
Posted or Displayed Information Inside Rental Unit:
a) Manager contact infonnation [ ] [ ]
b) Maximum number limit of parked vehicles, boats, and approved parking location [ ] [ ]
C) Trash and recycling pick-up days and protocol for placing/retrieving receptacles [ ] [ ]
d) Noise regulations: no excessive noise disturbance to neighbors; more stringent [ ] [ ]
requirements 10 p.m - G a.m.; no excessive noise that would cause annoyance to any
reasonable person of normal sensitivity; no outdoor amplification devises audible from
adjacent residential property at any time
e) Location of smoke alarms, emergency lighting, and fire extinguisher [ ] [ ]
f) Emergency room information [ ] [ ]
g) Sea turtle protection lighting and dune protection requirements (east of SR A IA) [ J [ ]
h) Maximum sleeping occupancy (number of persons) [ ] [ ]
Comments/Problems _
Date problems communicated to applicant:.
Planner Concurrence: _
Inspector: _
Stvc.chklst.sheet
Date:
Date:
Attachment 3
P28
South Barrier Island List
Attachment 4
I
LISTING
UNIT
MIN.
SITE
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL ADDRESS
NO.
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
NIGHT
STAY
COMMENTS
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
1331 White Heron Lane, Vero
1
hma
rental/p779708vb
Beach, FL
DAVIS, JAMES D & KIM
9108 E 25TH DR, DENVER, CO 80238
7
submitted application on 11/2/2016 -
PERMIT ISSUED 5/38/17
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
940 Crescent Beach Road, Vero
940 CRESCENT BEACH RD, VERO BEACH, FL
2
hma
I rental/p758603vb
https:l/www.homeaway.com/vacation-
Beach, FL
ZAMBELLI, PATRICIA R
32963
7
confirmed no longer listed as vacation rental
3
hma
1060 Clipper Road, Vero Beach, FL
OCNEANU, ILEANA ELENA
90 BERLIOZ ST APT PH3, VERDUN, QUEBEC
CANADA, H3E 1N3
Verified not a rental - website states 30 day
rental/p851982vb
4
'hma
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
407 LAURIER AVE, OTTAWA ONT CANADA, KIR
16
minimum stay
owner rents for 30 days or more. Owner
rental/p606630vb
1065 Clipper Road, Vero Beach, FL
VALIHORA, TIMOTHY
7Z1
28
updated the website
5
air
htt2s://www.airbnb.com/rooms/10225620
1436 Wyn Cove Dr, Vero Beach, FL
CARLON, GERARD A &
JACQUELINE G
1436 WYN COVE DR, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
17
owner only rents 3x a year for no more than
2 weeks at a time - no permit needed
1425 Treasure Cove Lane, Vero
GURDA, MICHAEL A IV &
6
air
lhtti2s://www.airbnb,com/rogms/14070631
Beach, FL
KIMBERLY A
360 BOWSER RD, MIDDLETOWN, NY 10940
1
Removed from list - not a rental
lhttps://www.homeaway.com/yacation.
rentaUD3653582
7
hma
220 Riverway Dr, Vero Beach, FL
GUANCI, JOSEPH W & ANN R
28 CASS ST, MELROSE, MA 02176
14
Removed from list - not -a rental
1580 Gracewood Lane, Vero
GROFCSIK, JOHN S &
8
air
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/6208536
Beath, FL
MARIANNE 1
1580 GRACEWOOD LN, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
7
Verified not a rental
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
1590 Gracewood Lane, Vero
9
hma
rental/p483640vb
https://www,homeaway.com/vacation-
Beach, FL
CARTER, DAVID M & JULIA S
1575 GRACEWOOD LANE, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
7
Permit issued 3/14/2017
88 Crooked Tree Lane, Vero
rental/D779996vb
10
hma
Beach, FL
107
MIAM INC
15 ROYAL PALM POINTE, VERO BEACH, FL 32960
verified not a rental
https://www.homeaway.com/yacation-
rental/P3565525
11
hma
95 Spring Lake Dr, Vero Beach, FL
101
KATES 95-101 LLC
1901 BAY RD APT 103, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
28
Not a rental
12
hma
https://www,homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p889183vb
146 RIDLEY BLVD, TORONTO, ONTARIO CANADA,
Submitted application on 10/18/2016 -
1976 Anglers Cove, Vero Beach, FL
CRANSTON, ROBERT R &
MSM 3M1
7
Permit issued 11/21/2016
https://www.flipkev.com/vero-beach-villa-
MACKENSEN, WOLFGANG
rentals/p1443535/
13
fli
1995 Anglers Cove, Vero Beach, FL
HEINRICH WILHELM * & NADJA
AMSELWEG 7,65719 HOFHEIM, GERMANY,
Notice of Code Violation sent on 5/17/17
14
air
htt s: www.airbnb.com roams 13787703
580 Reef Road, Vero Beach, FL
CACHAEDORA, CARMEN VARA
58p REEF RD, VERO BEACH, F! 32963
1
Notice of Code Violation sent on 5/17/17
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p737488vb
15
hma
695 Reef Road, Vero Beach, FL
ROMOLO, RICK & MARIA
325 NORTH END AVE, NEW YORK, NY 10282
6 1
Notice of Code Violation sent on 5/18/17
MAYO, BRIAN T (TR) &
FBO MAYO FAMILY REV TR 7/13/00,620 REEF -
16
air
https://www.ai bbnb.com/rooms/14354435
620 Reef Road, Vero Beach, Fl.
IELIZABETH
A (TR)
RD, VERO BEACH, FL 32963-2803
7
Notice of Code Violation sent on 5/18/17
httos://www.homeaway.com/yacation-
197 VILLA D'E5TES TER STE 205, LAKE MARY, FL
rental/D666862vb
17
hma
855 Reef Road, Vero Beach, FL
SCHAEFFER, KEITH W
32746
7
Notice of Code Violation sent on 5/18/17
ice of Cl
18
hma
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
www.homeawa .com vacation-
1496 Highway AlA, Vero Beach,
ROE FAMILY BEACH
not -property in process of being
rental/D7056299
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
FL
1005 Treasure Lane, Vero Beach,
PARTNERSHIP
ROSENBAUM, COLLEEN
PO BOX 1498, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
6
sold/Property sold
rental/D178662
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
19
hma
FL
SCHAFER & HARVEY A 11005
RIVERWIND CIR, VERO BEACH, FL 32967
7
submitted application on 11/30/16
120
hma
rental/p311687vb
1025 Reef Road, Vero Beach, FL
1025 REEF ROAD LLC
12715 SW 62ND AVE, PINECREST, FL 33156
7
sumbitted application on 12/2/16
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
1 21
hma
rental/p784997vb
925 Treasure Lane, Vero Beach, FL
DUFFY, MICHAEL P
925 TREASURE LN, VERO BEACH, FL 32963 17
issued
Submitted application on 11/7/2016 -Permit
11/21/2016
Attachment 4
I
South Barrier Island List
Attachment 4
LISTING
UNIT
MIN.
SITE
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL ADDRESS
NO.
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
NIGHT
STAY
COMMENTS
httos://www.homeiway.com/vacation-
2200 St Christopher Ln, Vero
rental/x7025885
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
22
hma
Beach, FL
COCONUT COTTAGE LLC *
17199 GULF PINE CIR, WELLINGTON, FL 33414
7
Notice of Cade Violation sent on 5/18/17 -
Submitted application on 5/31/2017
2155 Seminole Shores Lane, Vero
ABBATE, JOSEPH MICHAEL &
16526 BROOKLAN£ BLVD, NORTHVILLE, MI
rentallo319749vb
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
23
hma
Beach, FL
2165 Seminole Shores Lane, Vero
SYLVIA
48167
7
not a rental not rented for Tess than 30 days
24
hma
rental/p106831vb
Beach, FL
*
2165 SEMINOLE SHORES LN, VERO BEACH, FL
submitted application on 11/28/2016 -
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
1776 Mooringline Dr, Vero Beach,
WATSON, CRAIG & THERESA
32963
CROWN LODGE - CROWN ROAD, COLD NORTON,
7
Permit issued 3/14/17
Confirmed that owner rents no less than 2
25
hma
rental/p290865vb
FL
208
BIBBY, PAUL V & *
ESSEX ENGLAND CM34PO,
months at a time
26
hma
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p28144vb
LANGER, PEARL ELIZABETH
269 SHAKESPEARE DR, WATERLOO, ONTARIO
confirmed that owner rents no less than 1-2
1155 Reef Road, Vero Beach, FL
C-1
(1/2) &
CANADA, N2L 2T8
months at a time
https://www. ho meawa y.co m/va ca ti on -
rental/p773975vb
27
hma
2165 Galleon Dr, Vero Beach, FL
12
BENSON, KEVIN T &
2165 GALLEON OR #I-2, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
28
not a rental
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
2285 Genesea Lane, Vero Beach,
2770 INDIAN RIVER BLVD STE 201, VERO BEACH,
Submitted application on 10/31/2016 -
28
hma
rental/p684614vb
FL
CORAL GARDENS LLC
FL 32960
7
Permit issued 11/21/16
https:/Iwww.hameaway.comJvacation-
i-rental/p580566vb
2260 Magans Ocean Walk, Vero
2260 MAGANS OCEAN WALK, VERO BEACH, FL
Owner states they do not rent for less than
30 days/vertified owner does not
29
hma
Beach, FL
MITCHELL, EUGENE & ANGELIA
32963
7
need
1permit
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
2285 Silver Sands Court, Vero
30
hma
rentaljpSS7106vb
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
Beach, FL
DECKER, JANET A (TR)(TOK)(H) *
208 WILEY BOTTOM RD, SAVANNAH, GA 31411
7
submitted application on 12/7/16
2135 Windward Way, Vero Beach,
2135 WINDWARD WAY #206, VERO BEACH, FL
rental/p878262vb
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
31
hma
FL
2135 Windward Way, Vero Beach,
206
DYE, WENDY (TRS)
HYDE, DOUGLAS W & BRENDA
32963
7
Notice of Code Violation sent on 5/19/17
32
hma
rental/p645361vb
FL
210
M
781 TUXEDO TERRACE, SEBASTIAN, FL 32958
verified not a rental
1640 Hidden Pearl Place, Vero
33
air
httos:/J ..Rirbnb,com/room3 14522127
Beach, FL
HIDDEN PEARL PLACE LLC
2203 E OCEAN OAKS, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
5
not a rental - removed all listings
135 12th Place Southeast, Vero
34
air
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/"10562870
Beach, FL
1860 Highway
KELLY, CYNTHIA ANN &
135 12TH PL SE, VERO BEACH, FL 32962
1
Submitted application on 10/12/2016
https:%/www.homeaway.com/vacation-
35
hma
rental/p3897947
AIA, Vero Beach,
FL
Sent application packeYto owner on
NTIC-VERO BEACH LLC
1860 S HIGHWAY AlA, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
7
9/28/2016
36
air
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/14296723
1880 S Highway AIA, Vero Beach,
FL
*
Submitted application on 10/28/2016 -
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
2400 23rd St Southeast, Vero
JENKINS, SIMON & BRONIA
1017 CASSEEKEY LN, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
1
Permit issued 12/9/2016
37
hma
rentaVP496214vb
Beach, FL
DUDEK, MITCHELL D *
3 ROYAL PALM POINTE PE;VERO BEACH, FL
32960
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-beach-villa-
2125 West Beachside Lane, Vero
4
Submitted application on 11/14/2016
rentals/p141$323/
38
fli
Beach, FL
VANDER STRATEN, ROBERT C &
2125 W BEACH5IDE LN, VERO BEACH, FL 32963
Verified not arental - website states 30 day
minimum stay
d40
https://www,homeaway.com/vacation-
2281 West Ocean Oaks Circle,
39
hma
rental/p285760
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
Vero Beach, FL
2273 West Ocean Oaks Circle,
MOORE, DAVID J JR
2A BAKER AVE, WESTPORT, CT 06880
3
owner submitted application on 1/3/17
hma
rental/p860049vb
Vero Beach, FL
WALT N, MICHAEL K& LAURA
Submitted applicaton 9/12/2016 - Permit
https:f jwww.homeaway.com/vacation-
2277 West Ocean Oaks Circle,
M
19830 NE 42ND ST, SAMMARNISH, WA 98074
5
issued 12/7/2016
41
hrna
rental/p459962vb
Vero Beach, FL
CLARK, GARNETT Y & ALISON P
528 4TH ST SE, WASHINGTON, DC 20003
7
sumbitted application on 12/15/16
Attachment 4
North Barrier Island List
Attachment 4
LISTING
SITE
RENTAL DESCRIPTION
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL
ADDRESS
OWNER NAME
OWNERADDRESS
MIN.
NIGHT
STAY
COMMENTS
1
hma
Olde Florida Style Beach House
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
1830 East Sandpiper
Road, Vero Beach, FL
BARNHILL, JOHN H & MCMAHON,
MARGARET K
305 LITTLE FRESH POND RD,
SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968
property is listed for sale - not rented less
than 30 days
tion-rental/pl54979vb
2
hma
New to Market - Key -West Style
Cottage, walking distance to beach
Fn Summerplace
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
tion-rental/p908196vb
1951 West Sandpiper
Road, Vero Beach, FL
WILLIAMS, ANDREW K & LAURA G
22 MYRTLE AVE, GREENWOOD LAKE, NY
10925
2
submitted application on 12/19/16- Permit
issued 3/14/17
3
hma
Beautiful New 4BR Home - Access
Ito Beach - Large Pool & Spa
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
2281 West Ocean Oaks
Circle, Vero Beach, FL
MORRE, DAVID J JR
2A BAKER AVE, WESTPORT, CT 06880
3
this is a duplicate address - its in South
Barrier Island
tion-rental/p194213vb
4
air
Direct Ocean Front, Pet Friendly,
Sleeps 8
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1
2855512
12576 Florida AlA,
Vero Beach, FL
DAISY MAE PROPERTY LLC
151 MARINER BEACH LN, VERO BEACH,
FL 32963
1
submitted application on 10/24/2016 -
Permit issued 11/21/2016
5
air
Direct Ocean Front, Pet Friendly,
Sleeps 10
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1
2835837
12890 Florida AlA,
Vero Beach, FL
CRAWFORD, DEBBIE A &
151 MARINER BEACH LN, VERO BEACH,
FL 32963
1
submitted application on 12/1/16
6
hma
Beachfront/Riverfront Best Sunsets
And Sunrises
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
tion-rental/p757038vb
12740 Florida AIA,
Vero Beach, FL
LIEBLER, JAMES RANDOLPH
2500 COURTHOUSE TOWER, 44 W
FLAGLER ST, MIAMI, FL 33130
4
submitted application on 12/29/16 - posted
on 1/17/17 needed correct check
7
hma
Oceanfront And Riverfront Cottage
With Boat Dock And Kayaks
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
12840 Florida AlA,
Vero Beach, FL
GOFYS LLC
1600 NW CHRISTMAS RD, CHRISTMAS,
FL 32709
5
property not being rented - verified on
website
tion-rental/p514605vb
8
hma
Oceanfront Villa -3 level villa with
rooftop terrace that sleeps twelve.
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
12510 Florida AlA,
Vero Beach, FL
BALDWIN, FRED V • & DEBORAH T
397 SWEET BAY AVE, PLANTATION, FL
33324-8227
7
property has been sold - verified on
property app.
tion-rental/p4025814
9
hma
Ambersand Beach "respite By The
Sea" Oceanfront With Dock On
Intercoastal
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
tion-rental/p882371vb
12830 Florida AM
Vero Beach, FL
MORSE, BEVERLY A (TR)(TOK)
12830 N HIGHWAY AlA, VERO BEACH,
FL 32963-9417
7
Notice of Code Violation sent 5/19/17
10
fli
White Orchid Beach House Vero
Beach, FL
https://www.flipkey.corri/vero-
beach-vacation-rentals/pl74505/
12800 Florida AlA,
Vero Beach, FL
ROTCHFORD, GEORGE D & MARILYN
I&
2746 HOLLY POINT RD W, ORANGE
PARK, FL 32073
sumbitted application on 12/2/2016
11
hma
Oceanfront, Private Beach, Dock,
Vero Beach Florida
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
tion-rental/2102209
12928 Florida AlA,
Vero Beach, FL
BRADLEY, RONALD D 11 & `
3021 NE 48TH ST, LIGHTHOUSE POINT,
FL 33064
7
email from owner that they are not renting
at this time.
12 ihma
Beachfront/Riverfront - Boat Dock -
2 living areas, Flexible 3 Bedroom 3
lBath
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
13060 Highway AIA,
Vero Beach, FL
KORNFELD, HARVEY
13920 SW 107TH AVE, MIAMI, FL 33176
7
submitted application on 12/13/16
tion-rental/p828221vb
13
hma
Near The Beach, Intercostal
Waterway, And Much More!
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
tion-rental/p704183vb
8065 101st Ave, Vero
Beach, FL
ORNELAS, JUAN
8065101ST AVE, VERO BEACH, FL
32976
7
changed from 101st ct to 101st ave - sent
new Itr to correct add.
14
air
Ocean Front Estate in Vero Beach
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/9
12440 Florida AM
Vero Beach, FL
HAPPY SUNRISES LLC
PO BOX 190480, MIAMI BEACH, FL
33119
7
Notice of Code Violation sent 5/19/17 - no
longer being advertised as a rental
230331
15
fli
Elegant Ocean Front Estate
https://www.fliokey.com/vero-
beach-vacation-rentals/p683633/
2260 Sanderling Lane,
Vero Beach, FL
THOMAS, GRACE
3455 BELMONT TERRACE, DAVIE, FL
33328
verified not a rental - minimum 30 day stay
16
fli
4 Bedroom House with Pool Steps
from the Ocean
https://www.flipkev.com/vero-
beach-vacation-rentals/2312813/
2305 Sanderling Lane,
Vero Beach, FL
KASBAR, JOHN A &
3880 SHERIDAN ST, HOLLYWOOD, FL
33021
per letter from owner - not rented for less
than 30 days (not allowed by HOA)
Attachment 4
North Barrier Island List
Attachment 4
MIN.
LISTING
VACATION RENTAL
NIGHT
SITE
RENTAL DESCRIPTION
LISTING WEBLINK
ADDRESS
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
STAY
COMMENTS
FBO GENEVIEVE CALDWELL REV TR,
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-
9481 Frangipani Dr,
CALDWELL, DANIEL SCOTT (COTRS) &
1220 N RIO VISTA BLVD, FT
emailed information to owner on 10/21/16
17
fli
Fun Vacation home / Pet Frendly
beach-vacation-rentals/pl737416/
Vero Beach, FL
*
LAUDERDALE, FL 33301
submitted app on 10/26/16
Immaculately Maintained Beach
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-
9485 Frangipani Dr,
C/O 772 RIDGEWOOD RD, KEY
18
fli
House
beach-vacation-rentals/pl544611/
Vero Beach, FL
WARD, JEFFREY C & MARY E
BISCAYNE, FL 33149
letter returned - unable to forward
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-
9436 Sea Grape Dr,
19
fli
Beach Area Duplex
beach-condo-rentals/p684643/
Vero Beach, FL
WATTS, ANN MICHELLE
404 BISON CIR, APOPKA, FL 32712
verified not a vacation rental
Beachside Efficiency Adjacent to
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
9300 Highway AlA,
8860 E ORCHID ISLAND CIR, VERO
This is a commerical location with a long
20
hma
Disney Resort at Vero Beach
tion-rental/p4086551
Vero Beach, FL
FROST, ANNE (TR)*
BEACH, FL 32963-4183
7
term rental upstairs
Oceanside cottage in Summer
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-
1880 East Shell Lane,
21
fli
Place, Vero Beach
beach-cottage-rentals/pl415843/
Vero Beach, FL
GEIER, GEORGE D & ROBERTA G
121A FRONT ST, LEWES, DE 19958
not a rental - removed from advertising
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1
1890 E Sandpiper
22
air
Beautiful cottage, east of AlA
2125301
Road, Vero Beach, FL
1890 EAST SANDPIPER ROAD LLC
465 SPINNAKER, WESTON, FL 33326
14
Notice of Code Violation sent 5/19/17
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
1871 East Sandlewood
307 MAPLE ST, WEST HAMSTEAD, NY
23
hma
The Perfect Beachside Getaway,
tion-rental/pl48156vb
Road, Vero Beach, FL
DIGIOVANNA, LEONARD & DENISE
11552
7
not a rental - not rented less than 30 days
1891 a Sandalwood
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
Road West, Wabasso
1891 E SANDALWOOD RD, VERO
verified not a vacation rental - not
24
hma
Spectacular Custom Beach House
tion-rental/p7057497
Beach, FL
CARINCI, JOHN *
BEACH, FL 32963
adveristed
A friendly unique beachfront
community, private beach bicycles +
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
9475 Periwinkle Dr,
30 MAIN ST APT 8H, BROOKLYN, NY
tion-rental/o844098vb
25
hma
big golf cart
Vero Beach, FL
HOFFMAN, STEVEN &
11201
7
verified not a vacation rental
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
9485 Periwinkle Dr,
9485 PERIWINKLE DR, VERO BEACH, FL
verified not a vacation rental - no longer
tion-rental/0058268
26
hma
Private Beach Access
Vero Beach, FL
DOMKE, CHARLES A & DEBRA A
32963
7
listed and don't plan on renting
Charming Key West Style Home Plus
https:/Iwww.homeaway.com/vaca
1980 Coco Plum Lane,
PO BOX 701476, WABASSO, FL 32970-
verified not a vacation rental - no rented
tion-rental/p276228
27
hma
Guest Apartment - Near Beach
Vero Beach, FL
COURAGE, DAVID S (TRS)
1476
7
less than 30 days
Ultra Modern Totally Updated
https:/Iwww.flipkey.com/vero-
1990 West Cayman
21 WILDWOOD BLVD, DARTMOUTH,
verified not a vacation rental - not rented
beach-vacation-rentals/pl725855/
28
fli
Island beach Home
Road, Vero Beach, FL
KEATING, PATRICK A & SUZANNE N
NOVA SCOTIA CANADA, B2W 21-7
1
less than 30 days
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
9555 Periwinkle Dr,
9555 PERIWINKLE DR, VERO BEACH, FL
29
hma
ONE OF A KIND BEACH HOUSE
tion-rental/p305402vb
Vero Beach, FL
FOX, TIMOTHY A * & MAUREEN K
32963
3
Notice of Code Violation sent 5/19/17
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-
801 Island Club Square,
beach-vacation-rentals/x2055632/
30
fli
Walk To Beach
Vero Beach, FL
GALIK, HENRY K &
7355 W GREENLEAF ST, NILES, IL 60714
Notice of Code Violation sent 5/19/17
9536 Doubloon Dr,
131
Relaxing, Beautiful, Oceanfront
https://www.homeaway.com/vaca
Vero Beach, FL, United
hma
Home
tion-rental/p3S20821
States
SCHMIDT, SUZANNE CLAUGHTON *
7939 16TH PL, VERO BEACH, FL 32966
2
submitted application on 11/28/2016
Attachment 4
Main I and I ict
Attachment 4
W
co
MIN.
LISTING
UNIT
NIGHT
SITE
RENTAL DESCRIPTION
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL ADDRESS
NO.
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
STAY
COMMENTS
2 ACRE CUSTOM HOME UNIQUE
12525 Roseland Road,
12525 ROSELAND RD, SEBASTIAN, FL
not a vacation rental - rents for 1
1
air
SETTING
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/9423866
Sebastian, FL
KLEIN, JEFF & PATRICIA
32958
1
year at at time
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
8315135th Lane, Sebastian,
TREASURE COAST
951 N LAKE SYBELIA DR, MAITLAND, FL
rental/p876022vb
2
ihma
On The San Sebastian River
FL
GETAWAYS INC
32751
2
Iverified not a rental
Riverside Florida Cottage that
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
12880 83rd Avenue,
rental/p41391vb
3
hma
Time Forgot... Private Pool
Sebastian, FL
POWELL, GLENN E &
PO BOX 450, ROSELAND, FL 32957-0450
2
submitted application on 11/3/16
1924 Guest House with Boat Dock
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
4
hma
Access to the Sebastian River
rental/p225943vb
12830 Bay St, Sebastian, FL
POWELL, GLENN E &
PO BOX 450, ROSELAND, FL 32957-0450
2
submitted application on 11/3/16
Historic Poolside Riverfront
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5
ihma
Cabana with Boat Dock
rental/p33100vb
12845 Bay St, Sebastian, FL
fPOWELL, GLENN E &
PO BOX 450, ROSELAND, FL 32957
1
submitted application on 11/3/16
Serenety and Romance.... The
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
C/O MARIA JOVANOVICH, PO BOX 1374,
rental/p436966vb
6
hma
Lagoon House.
12825 Bay St, Sebastian, FL
LAGOON HOUSE LLC •
ROSELAND, FL 32957
28
not a rental
COBBLESTONE AT
Notice of Code Violation sent on
7
air
Cobblestone at Sebastian
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/14293560
8160 126 Place, Sebastian, FL
SEBASTIAN LLC
PO BOX 1783, MANDEVILLE, LA 70470
5
5/19/17
Million Dollar Viewsl I Direct
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
13750 Old Dixie Highway,
MCCOLLOM, BRAD : &
1950 SPOTTED OWL DR SW, VERO
verified not a rental - minimum 30
rental/p383931vb
8
hma
Intracoastal Home Private Dock
Sebastian, FL
HEATHER
BEACH, FL 32962-8627
7
days
Sebastian Waterfront Paradise
https:/Iwww.homeaway.com/vacation-
13580 North Indian River Dr,
642 EAST RIDGEWOOD ST, ORLANDO, FL
Notice of Code Violation sent on
rental&7104640
9
hma
W/Dock
Sebastian, FL
COALBY ARMS LLC
32803
5
5/19/17
Paradise Near the River-
https://www.flipkey.com/sebastian-condo-
13330 Old Dixie Highway,
WASSERMAN, HARVEY LEE
13330 OLD DIXIE HWY, SEBASTIAN, FL
rentals/R467178L
10
fli
Apartment
Sebastian, FL
&
32958
verified not a rental
Secluded Guesthouse in FL
11375 Kashi Court,
not a vacation rental - only renting
11
air
Paradisel
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1929910
Sebastian, FL
ASHTON, MICHAL &
11375 KASHI CT, SEBASTIAN, FL 32958
2
a room in the home
this address is not a rental per
Near The Beach, Intercostal
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
8065 101st Court, Vero
house -house does not match
12
ihma
lWaterway, And Much More!
rental/p704183vb
Beach, FL
HAYHURST, ANGELA L &
8065 101 ST CT, VERO BEACH, FL 32976
7
what is advertised
Notice of Code Violation sent on
11656 South Indian River Dr,
OVERSTAKE, MATTHEW &
28 TRUMMEL CT, THE WOODLANDS, TX
5/19/17 - submitted application
13
air
Indian River Vacation -Waterfront
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/12769663
Sebastian, FL
MEGHAN
77380
3
on 6/2/17
11110 Us Highway 1,
9611 N US HIGHWAY 1 PMB 213,
14
air
Spectacular water front studio apt
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/688886
Sebastian, FL
KURLAND, DAVID A
SEBASTIAN, FL 32958
2
not a rental
https://www.flipkev'com/sebastian-vacation-
11190 US HIGHWAY 1, SEBASTIAN, FL
Notice of Code Violation sent on
rentals/p863047/
15 Ifli
A New Spring Osprey Nest
11190 U.S. 1, Sebastian, FL
OWN TIME LLC
32958
5/19/17
submitted application on
iFeet-From
Charming 3 Bed/3Bath Home 300
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
12/19/16 - PERMIT ISSUED
16
hma
The Indian River
rental/p863178vb
6645110th St, Sebastian, FL
ECCHER, CRAIG & BRENDA L
120 WEST AVE, WELLSBORO, PA 16901
4
5/18/17
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-beach-
17
fli
Always Summertime
vacation-rentals/p1980418/
6645 110th St, Sebastian, FL
ECCHER, CRAIG & BRENDA L
120 WEST AVE, WELLSBORO, PA 16901
duplicate
5 bedroom 3 bath home on the
315 Cathedral Oaks Dr, Vero
40 DUNMINNING RD, NEWTON SQUARE,
18
air
river
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/2297412
Beach, FL
CASSIDY, TODD & ANNA M
PA 19073
3
not a rental
CHARMING VINTAGE -RETRO
FLORIDA COTTAGE... CAREFREE
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
19
hma
'BEACH BLANKET BUNGALOW'
rental/p71907vb
4695 85th St, Vero Beach, FL
POWELL, GLENN E IPO
BOX 450, ROSELAND, FL 32957-0450 12
submitted application on 11/3/16
Attachment 4
W
co
Amain 1 end l i«
Attachment 4
LISTING
SITE
RENTAL DESCRIPTION
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL ADDRESS
UNIT
NO.
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
MIN.
NIGHT
STAY
COMMENTS
20
hma
Upscale Waterfront Home with
Manatees in Your Back Yard
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
3555 Lucia Dr, Vero Beach,
FL
WAGNER, ERIC S &
GABRIELLE L
1820 47TH AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32966
not a rental
rental/p437650vb
21
air
Blackwater Creek
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/13504439
24300 State Road 60, Vero
Beach, FL
FIELDS, ROBERT E & SUSAN
A
24300 STATE ROAD 60, VERO BEACH, FL
32966
1
not a rental
22
hma
Bellewood Plantation - Venue,
Retreats, Reunions, etc
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
6070 69th St, Vero Beach, FL
BELLEWOOD PLANTATION
LLC
24300 STATE ROAD 60, VERO BEACH, FL
32966
not being advertised as vacation
rental
rental/p782531vb
23
air
Relaxing Home with Pool
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/13340123
6436 51st Avenue, Vero
Beach, FL
5 & G PROPERTY
INVESTMENTS, CORP
6436 51ST AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32967
1
submitted application on
11/15/16
24
hma
Tropical Breeze Vero Beach FL -
Heated Pool, Kayak, Bikes, WiR
Sept -Oct Special
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p3552350
6475 51st Avenue, Vero
Beach, FL
PHILLIPS, KANDI &
6475 51ST AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32967-
5314
3
submitted application on
11/18/16 - Permit issued3/16/17
25
hma
Relaxing Home With Pool
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p878596vb
6436 51st Avenue, Vero
Beach, FL
5 & G PROPERTY
INVESTMENTS, CORP
6436 51ST AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32967
duplicate
26
hma
Grand Harbor - Vero Beach,
Florida Waterfront Condo
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p161299vb
5520 North Harbor Village
Dr, Vero Beach, FL
104
MARCOUNA, AMELIA G &
718 RADCLIFF CT, LANDSDALE, PA 19446
verified not a rental
27
hma
Vero Beach Harbor Front Villa -
Private Dock, Beach Club & Golf
Membership
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5540 North Harbor Village
Dr, Vero Beach, FL
302
UGALE, MARK (2/3) &
5606 E CRESTLINE AVE, GREENWOOD
VILLAGE, CO 80111-1407
2
verified not a rental
rental/p36516vb
28
hma
Beautiful Waterfront Condo in
Grand Harbor
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5540 North Harbor Village
Dr, Vero Beach, FL
102
ICHAIKIN, KIMBERLEE A
948 GENTLEWOOD ST, GAITHERSBURG,
MD 20878
28
not a rental - not rented less than
130 days
rental/p429848vb
29
hma
WATERFRONT VILLA WITH DOCK,
COURTYARD POOL. GOLF, TENNIS,
BEACH MEMBERSHIP
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p4263412
5495 East Harbor Village Dr,
Vero Beach, FL
WALMSLEY, DONALD E (TR)
2724 PEACHTREE RD NW #403, ATLANTA,
GA 30305
7
not a rental - not rented less than
30 days
30
fli
Waterfront Harbor Home
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-beach-
5604 North Harbor Village
Dr, Vero Beach, FL
EMMONS, LAWRENCE L &
KATHLEEN E
5606 E CRESTLINE AVE, GREENWOOD
VILLAGE, CO 80111-1407
Notice of Code Violation sent on
5/18/17
vacation-rentals/063282L
31
hma
Family and Pet Friendly Home - 30
Minutes from the Beach
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p718914vb
4498 56th Lane, Vero Beach,
FL
RICHMART PROPERTIES LLC
(TRS)
PO BOX 291753, DAVIE, FL 33329
8
verified not a rental
32
ihma
Turnkey 2/2 overlooking 17th
fairway. Fully furnished top floor
unit.
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5080 Harmony Circle, Vero
Beach, FL
202
ARE -JAY INVESTMENTS OF
IRC INC
PO BOX 0, VERO BEACH, FL 32961
28
verified not a rental - 30 day
minimum stay
rental/p588676vb
33
hma
Pet friendly. First floor one
bedroom condo in gated
community. Sleeps 4.
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5025 Harmony Circle, Vero
Beach, FL
102
KEESEY, PEGGY E &
MICHAEL H
1255 WEST COLLEGE AVE, YORK, PA
17404
27
verified not a rental
rental/p3522926
34
fli
Newly Renovated 2 Bedroom, 2
Bathroom Condo
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-beach-condo-
rentals/p2082561/
5035 Harmony Circle, Vero
Beach, FL
303
APGAR, SALLY &
193 OCEAN KEY WAY, JUPITER, FL 33477
verified not a rental
35 lhma
Our Piece Of Paradise In Grand
Harbor
https://v4ww.homeaway.com/vacation-
5156 Saint Davids Dr, Vero
Beach, FL
WALSH, JAMES E
2059 LIMBER PINE CIR, MANLIUS, NYverified
13104
29
not a rental - no longer
adveristed
rental/p903536vb
36
hma
A Tropical Paradise for Fun/Sun-
loving Snowbirds & Tennis
Enthusiasts I
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p423057vb
4370 Doubles Alley Dr, Vero
Beach, FL
102
DEACON, OREN K JR &
CHERYL A •
5680 HIGHWAY AIA #206, VERO BEACH,
FL 32963
6
verified not a rental
37
hma
Beaches, Tennis, Golf, Quaint
Shopping, Cultural Arts, &
Community Events
ps://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
brentalp772423via
1641 Baseline Lane, Vero
Beach, FL I
BAYSURA, KELLY JO 132967
1641 BASELINE LN, VERO BEACH, FL
7
verified not a rental
Attachment 4
Main I and I kt
LISTING
SITE
RENTAL DESCRIPTION
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL ADDRESS
UNIT
NO.
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
MIN.
NIGHT
STAY
COMMENTS
38
hma
Eco Friendly Indian River Cabin,
Secluded yet convenient to
various activities.
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5425 43rd St, Vero Beach, FL
ZOOK, CARYL
5425 43RD ST, VERO BEACH, FL 32967
7
Iverified not a rental
rental/p644328vb
39
air
3 Bdr. 2 Bath Home in Upscale
Area
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/4204846
3936 58th Circle, Vero Beach,
FL
SMITH, DANIELS
3936 58TH CIRCLE, VERO BEACH, FL
32966
2
verified not a rental
40
air
Beautiful Central Vero Beach
House
https://www.airbnb.comLrooms/6143159
4636 26th St, Vero Beach, FL
COONEY, DEBORAH
4636 26TH ST, VERO BEACH, FL 32966
1
verified not a rental
41
hma
Vero -our little town that has it all.
FLY DIRECT NEWARK NJ TO VERO
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
renta1/p166737
1924 77th Dr, Vero Beach, FL
TAGGART, THOMAS M &
CARYN L
13870 COLUMBINE AVE, WELLINGTON,
FL 33414
verified not a vacation rental
42
hma
Treat Yourself to a Suite Vacation
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
8797 20th St, Vero Beach, FL
THE VERO BEACH INN LLC
308 NW 1ST AVE, DELRAY BEACH, FL
33444
not vacation rental - hotel
rental/p651448vb
43
Ifli
Luxury Patio Home in beautiful,
gated community 1
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-beach-villa-
1917 Sixty Oaks Lane, Vero
Beach, FL
OAKES, LARRY W *
38 HARBOUR ISLE DR E UNIT 104, FT
PIERCE, FL 34949
verified not a rental -1 year leases
only
rentals/p2032894/
44
air
Private Room with own Bath,
Kitchen, and Entrance
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/9051417
1125 36th Court Southwest,
Vero Beach, FL
SELWYN, JULIE MARGARET
PO BOX 650025, VERO BEACH, FL 32965
7
verified not a rental - minimum 30
night stay
45
hma
1.5 MILES FROM BEACH
htti3s://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
1451 3rd Court, Vero Beach,
FL
MCENERNEY, JANET D &
JOHN E
4510 6TH LN SW, VERO BEACH, FL 32968
5
verified not a rental - yearly rental
rental/p436513vb
46
jhma
Jill's home from home
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
400 E Waverly PI, Vero
Beach, FL
2B
PHILLIPS, JILL DIANE
121 FERRY RD, MARSTON, OXFORD, 0X3
OEX ENGLAND,
verified not a rental - no longer
adveristed
rental/p7035932
47
fli
Beautiful home close to beach
and town)
https://www.flipkey.com/vero-beach-
443 10th Place, Vero Beach,
FL
CARTER, SCOTT P &
PERNILLE L
406 MILL NECK RD, WILLIAMSBURG, VA
23185
verified not a rental - 30 days or
longer rentals
vacation-rentals/p1878124/
48
hma
Annabelle's Cottage guest house
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
655 Old Dixie Highway, Vero
Beach, FL
CLARK HOFFSTAEDT LLC
PO BOX 1586, VERO BEACH, FL 32961-
1586
verified not a rental -1 year
1 leases only
rental&7064642
49
air
Charming Vero Beach House
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/13352990
2165 8th St, Vero Beach, FL
NARDONE, KIMBERLY ANNE
2165 8TH ST, VERO BEACH, FL 32962
1
Submitted application on
11/22/16
50
air
Upscale on a Budget 1/1
Apartment
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/4342377
655 26th Avenue, Vero
Beach, FL
PIERCE, SETH
655 26TH AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32962
1
Notice of Code Violation sent
5/17/17
51
hma
Modern home with pool
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p688549vb
155 25th Avenue, Vero
Beach, FL
LARSEN, JANE
155 25TH AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32962
7
submitted application 12/6/16
52
hma
NEW I Breezy 3BR Vero Beach
House w/Private Pool
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/p4253269
516 20th Court, Vero Beach,
FL
CARP, SONYA C
137 39TH DR, VERO BEACH, FL 32968
3
submitted application 12/9/16 -
Permit issued 3/14/17
53
air
Comfortable Beach Resort Home
httgE//www.airbnb.com/rooms/68645
460 36th Avenue, Vero
Beach, FL
SULTZMAN, CHARLES W
(CO -TRS) & SHARRON L (CO-
TRS)
FBO SULTZMAN FAMILY REV TRUST, 460
36TH AVE, VERO BEACH, FL 32968-1935
7
Notice of Code Violation senton
5/19/17 - listing now shows
minimum 31 nights
54
air
Spacious beach getaway 3131)
w/pool
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/10683710
415 29th Court Southwest,
Vero Beach, FL
YOZZO, JOSEPH & ROSA
2213 PROCTORVIEW DR, UTICA, NY
13501
2
verified not a rental
55
hma
Seasonal Rentals 2 - 4 months
preferred /send email inquiry for
other options
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
rental/P169738
2607 Stockbridge Square
Southwest, Vero Beach, FL
GIARDINA, JOHN V &
LAUREN
21 W BARRETT HILL RD, HOPEWELL
JUNCTION, NY 125337
verified not a rental - ad was
removed 10/24/16
56
hma
LAKE FRONT HOME WITH
BILLIARDS & INDOOR
SHUFFLEBOARD CLOSE TO VERO
BEACHES
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
1035 Amethyst Dr
Southwest, Vero Beach, FL
MULHEARN, WILLIAM * &
PAMELA
1025 AMETHYST DR SW, VERO BEACH, FL
32968
21
verified not a rental - minimum 30-
60 nights stay___,
rental/p574536vb
Main Land List
Attachment 4
MIN.
LISTING
UNIT
NIGHT
SITE
RENTAL DESCRIPTION
LISTING WEBLINK
VACATION RENTAL ADDRESS
NO.
OWNER NAME
OWNER ADDRESS
STAY
COMMENTS
Beautiful Lake View Home In Vero
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
5045 Topaz Lane Southwest,
840 SARINA TER SW, VERO BEACH, FL
verified not a rental - ad was
57
hma
Beach
rental/p3809117
Vero Beach, FL
DIAZ, RODOLFO & VIVIAN
32968
21
removed
STYLISH HOME JUST 15 MINS TO
1825 19th Avenue
EIERS, ROGER L * & CORAL
1825 19TH AVE SW, VERO BEACH, FL
owner brought in proof no longer
58
air
BEACH
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/248782
Southwest, Vero Beach, FL
P
32962
3
listed for rental
Beautiful Condol - Nice
https://www.fliokey.com/vero-beach-condo-
1130 3rd Avenue, Vero
STOUTE, JAMES R & PENNY
1252 LEATHERWOOD DR, ALTAMONTE
verified not a rental - not rented
59
fli
Amenities!
rentals/p230930/
Beach, FL
204
F
SPRINGS, FL 32714
less than 30 days
Golfcourse View On The
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
88 Crooked Tree Lane, Vero
15 ROYAL PALM POINTE, VERO BEACH, FL
60
hma
Groundfloor In Vista Royale
rental/p779996vb
Beach, FL
107
MIAM INC
32960
duplicate not a rental
* SENIOR DISCOUNT -VISTA
ROYALE - GOLF, 4 CLUB HOUSES,
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
95 Spring Lake Dr, Vero
1901 BAY RD APT 103, VERO BEACH, FL
verified not a vacation rental -
61
hma
POOLS, NEAR BEACH
rental/p3565525
Beach, FL
101
KATES 95-101 LLC
32963
28
lyearly lease
STUDIO APT 732 SO FT
135 12th Place Southeast,
62
air
w/Music/Game Room, Pool & Spa
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/10562870
Vero Beach, FL
KELLY, CYNTHIA ANN &
135 12TH PL SE, VERO BEACH, FL 32962
1
not a rental
2244 5th Court Southeast,
GORDON, BRETT &
2244 STH CT SE, VERO BEACH, FL 32962-
63
air
Fisherman's Paradise
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/2637358
Vero Beach, FL
CATHLEEN M
8327
7
verified not a rental
2234 5th Court Southeast,
Notice of Code Violation sent on
64
air
Waterfront Getaway
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/10069237
Vero Beach, FL
IMINICH, WENDY W
2234 5TH CT SE, VERO BEACH, FL 32962
14
5/18/17
Lovely Poolvilla incl. Whirlpool &
Boat dock/lift at the canal,
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
2223 6th Avenue Southeast,
C/O SUSAN POOLER, 1835 14TH AVE SW,
submitted application on
rental&550916
65
hma
Atlantic access
Vero Beach, FL
BESTAENDIG, CONNY *
VERO BEACH, FL 32962
3
11/23/2017
Exclusive Pool -Villa with whirlpool
and boat dock at the canal,
https://www.homeaway.com/vacation-
2243 6th Avenue Southeast,
1835 14TH AVE SW, VERO BEACH, FL
submitted application on
rentalbS13449
66
hma
atlantic access
Vero Beach, FL
BESTAENDIG, DANIEL & *
32962
3
11/23/2016
Beautiful Home on Deepwater
irentajlp274127vb
https:/Iwww.homeaway.com/vacation-
2214 6th Avenue Southeast,
MULLER, MAX &
227 NE 23RD AVE, FT LAUDERDALE, FL
67
hma
Canal Close to Beach and Town
Vero Beach, FL
CONCEPCION
33301
5
verified not a rental
Attachment 4
PROCLAMATION
HONORING RANDY D. BAKER ON HIS RETIREMENT FROM
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DEPARTMENT OF. PUBLIC WORKS/FLEET MANAGEMENT DIVISION
WHEREAS, Randy D. Baker retired from Indian River County Fleet Management
Division effective June 30, 2017, and
WHEREAS, Randy D. Baker began his career with Indian River County on July 2,
1982, as a General Equipment Mechanic L In September of 1988, his position was
reclassified to an Equipment Mechanic II. He continued in this capacity until his
retirement; and
WHEREAS, Randy D. Baker has served this County and the Public with distinction
and selflessness. During his thirty-five years of service, he was dedicated, and his work
was greatly appreciated by the employer, citizens, and co-workers alike; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board
applauds Randy D. Baker's efforts on behalf of the County, and the Board wishes to
express their appreciation for the dedicated service he has given to Indian River
County for the last thirty-five years; and
BE IT FURTHER PROCLAIMED that the Board of County Commissioners and staff
extend heartfelt wishes for success in his future endeavors!
Adopted this 2e day of June 2017.
r� BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
t C = �t1VER CO _1 INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
-41
* * sept: E. Flescher, Chairman
�LORI44' _
P37
2his is to certify that
&ndy 0. Baker
is hereby presented this
Tstirement Award
for outstanding Perf°r►nance and
faithfulservice to
Indian Vver County
Board of County Commissioners
For tFrirty-five years of service
On this 30th Day of.7une 2017
VciiardB. Szpyrkg los fi �E Flescfier
Director of �cc6Cu 4Nor�,� Board of County Commissioner, Clraihmn
38
INFORMATION
ITEM
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
MEMORANDUM
TO: Jason E. Brown
County Administrator
THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP
Community Development Director
FROM: Roland M. DeBlois, AICP
Chief, Environmental Planning
DATE: June 12, 2017
RE: Notice of Hazard Mitigation Grant Program Application for Elevation of the Main
House at the Jones's Pier Conservation Area
It is requested that the Board of County Commissioners formally consider the following information at the
Board's regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
On February 8, 2017, the Florida Division of Emergency Management (FDEM) announced the availability
of Hazard Mitigation Grant Program (HMGP) funds resulting from the Presidential Disaster Declaration
for Hurricane Matthew. The purpose of the HMGP is to assist communities in implementing hazard
mitigation measures. The program is federally funded, but is allocated and distributed by the State through
the FDEM. The estimated funding availability for hazard mitigation projects in Indian River County under
the current HMGP funding cycle is $437,839.
Indian River County is an eligible HMGP applicant in that the County has a FEMA -approved local
mitigation plan and has a formally adopted Local Mitigation Strategy (LMS). This past January, the
County's LMS Working Group created a prioritized list of potential HMGP projects. That list was
subsequently narrowed down to 12 eligible county -wide projects, including a proposal to elevate the historic
main house at the Jones's Pier Conservation Area, which was flooded during Hurricane Matthew. Attached
is a copy of the refined LMS list of eligible projects, with the Jones's Pier project ranked 12th on the list.
The deadline for submittal of HMGP proposals under the current cycle was June 9, 2017. Staff submitted
an HMGP application for the Jones's Pier project prior to the June 9 deadline, with the understanding that
if the project is selected for funding, a formal agreement will be subject to County Commission approval at
a future date before the grant is accepted and finalized, or otherwise declined by the Board at that time.
Project Description
The historic Jones's Pier bungalow/ main house, original built circa 1921, lies approximately 80 feet from
the Indian River Lagoon and currently has a finished floor elevation (FFE) of 3.27 feet (NAVD 88), which
is 3.73 feet below the FEMA Base Flood Elevation (BFE) of 7 feet (NAVD 88). During Hurricane Matthew,
P39
the bungalow structure, which has an approximate l 1/2 foot underbuilding crawl space, was inundated
with approximately 7-9 inches of water in the interior for several days, resulting in damage.
The HMGP application to elevate the main Jones's Pier house is based on a proposal obtained by staff from
Brownie Companies, which specializes in the elevation of existing structures. Based on the Brownie
proposal, the estimated cost of the HMGP project is $69,356 (see Attachment 2).
Funding
The HMGP is a cost -reimbursement grant program and will fund up to 75% for eligible projects. The 25%
match may be a combination of cash and in-kind sources. Under this proposed project, the 75% grant
funding is estimated at $52,017, with the County's match share (25%) estimated at $17,339. If the project
is selected for funding, staff will recommend a budget amendment from Acquisition Bonds/Cash Forward
to fund the 25% match.
RECOMMENDATION
This is an informational item only; no Board action is requested at this time.
ATTACHMENTS
1. LMS HMGP projects priority list (April 2017).
2. Project cost estimate.
C:\Users\GRANIC-1 WppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@D805A637\@BCL@D805A637.docx
P40
Indian River County LMS
`Indicates jurisdiction interest in this project
and support wherever necessary.
Updated April 5, 2017
Possible Funding Sources
Date Confirmed/
Added
WS/DEP
Eligible
HMGP
1113117
(Beth Powell)
MGP, CDBG, Pre-disaster
Eligible
litigation Program
HMGP
1/10117
(Don Dexter)
DBG, HMGP, DRI, USDA,
Eligible
DA
HMGP
1/6117
(Jason Nunemaker)
MGP, FWC/DEP, FIND, DOT,
Eligible
oater Improvement Fund
HMGP
1/13/17
(James Gray)
MGP
Eligible
HMGP
1/6/17
(Freddie Woolfork)
MGP
Eligible
HMGP
116117
(Beth Powell)
DBG, HMGP, EDA
Eligible
HMGP
116/17
(Wayne Eseltine
MGP, FDEP
Eligible
HMGP
116/17
(Monte Falls)
MGP, FMA, SJRWMD, FPMS
Eligible
HMGP
1/6/17
(Wayne Esletqnel
MGP
Eligible
HMGP
1110/17
(Don Dexter)
ATTACHMENT 1
1 of 2
Indian River County
Local Mitigation Strategy
Project Prioritization List
For HMGP Applications related to Hurricane Matthew (FEMA -4283 -DR)
CL a
40
a N
Project Description
Estimated Project
Cost&
Estimated Time ol
Completion
Applicant/Responsible
Pally
Mitigation to be Accomplished
Hazards
Mitigated
Jurisdiction(s)
Involved'
Possible Funding Sources
Date Confirmed/
Added
64
Culvert replacement for ditch/street
$1 million
City of Sebastian
Replace all ditch culverts that
Flood
Sebastian
CDBG, Emergency Relief,
Eligible
crossings
>12 months
Joe Griffin
intersect streets to promote better
FMAP, HMGP
HMGP
11
drainage.
116/17
(Wayne Esletine)
61
Jones' Pier floodproofinglelevation
$800,000
Indian River County
Elevating/floodproofing historic
Flooding,
All Jurisdictions
HMGP, DHR
Eligible
<12 months
Community Development
structures to above base flood
Hurricane/tropical
HMGP
12
elevation (BFE); storm shutters;
storm
1/10/2017
drainage improvements
(Roland DeBlois)
Indian River County LMS
"Indicates jurisdiction interest in this project
and support wherever necessary. Updated April 5, 2017
v
A
N
2of2
Section M. Budget/Costs
In this section, provide details of all the estimated costs of the project. As this information is used for the Benefit -Cost Analysis,
reasonable cost estimates are essential. Do not include contingency costs in the budget. Avoid the use of lump sum costs.
Note: To be eligible for HMA funding, pre -award costs must be identified as separate line items in the cost estimate of the application.
This must be done in addition to filling out the HMGP Pre -Award Cost Request Form. Please mark each pre -award cost with an asterisk
CL
A. Materials
Hem Dimension Livantity cost per Unit Gost
fracture Elevation -See attached Brownie Companies Estimate I I I V3,850.00
Foundation Option -See attached Brownie Companies Estimate I I I 118,685.00 1
Townie Companies estimate addendum items (see attachment) 112,950.00
B. Labor (Include equipment costs. Please indicate all "soft" or in-ldnd matches. All in-kind match
must be identified in the Section IIL Budget/Costs of this application.)
Description Hours Rate Cost
General Contractor (See Brownie Companies estimate addendum items) 5% of total 13,871
C. Fees Paid (Include any other costs associated with the project.)
Attach any continuations or additional items to this page
Rate
Total Estimated Project Cost $ 69.356
ATTACHMENT 2
Form No. HMGP 001, Eff. 06/2012
P43
D. Funding Sources (Round figures to the nearest dollar.)
The maximum FEMA share forRMGPprojects is 75%. The other 25% can be made up of State and Local funds as well as
in-kind services. The FMA program requires that the maximum in-kind match be no more than 12.5% of the total project
costs. HMGP/FMA funds may be packaged with other Federal funds, but other Federal funds (except for Federal funds that
lose their Federal identity at the State level such as CDBG and certain tribal funds) may not be used for the non -Federal share
of the costs.
Estimated FEMA Share $ 52,017 75 % of Total (maximum of 75%)
Non -Federal Share
Estimated Local Share $ 17,339 25 % of Total (Cash)
$ % of Total (In-kind*)
$ % of Total (Project Global Match**)
Global Match Project Title:
Other Agency Share $ % of Total'
(Identify Other Non -Federal Agency and availability date: )
Total Funding sources from above $ 69,356 100 Total % (should equal 100%)
*identify proposed eligible activities directly related to project to be considered for In-kind services. (Note on Section B)
**Separate project application must be submitted for each project (Global) Match project
E. Project Milestones/Schedule of Work
List the major milestones in this project by providing an estimated time -line for the critical activities not to exceed a period of
3 years for performance, e.g. Designing, Engineering, Permitting, etc. These milestones should correspond with the scope of
work and budget.
Milestone
Mumher nfDays to Camnlete
[Example: Demolition of 6 structures and removal of debris
14 days]
County Advertisement, Selection and Award of Contract Bids
90 days
Engineering/Design of Structure Foundation
60 days
btain Building Permits
90 days
roject Mobilizati
30 days
tility Disconnects/Demolition of Existing Structure Foundation
30 days
xcavation of fill/ Installation of Lifting System/Elevation of Structure
60 days
oan/Inspect/Pour Concrete Pad Footings
30 days
Form/Inspect/Pour Tapered Concrete Piers
30 days
Lower Structure onto Foundation and Secure with Hurricane Tie -down Straps
30 days
Remove structure lifting system
30 days
Utility Re -connects
0 days
Clean, rough grade site, and demobilize
0 days
Surveys and Final Elevation Certificate
0 days
Final Inspections/Closeout
0 days
Bather Delays
0 days
Attach any continuations or additional items to this page
Form No. HMGP 001, Eff. 06/2012
P44
Est. 1922
385 NE Baker Road, Stuart, Florida 34994
Telephone: (772) 460-5660 Fax: (772) 460-5650
Website: www.BrownfeCompanies.com
Email: iamison@browniewmpanies.com
CGC 1519113
PROPOSAL
Submittal Date: April 22, 2017
Proposal Submitted To: Indian River County Community Development
Address: 180127th St., Vero Beach, FL 32960
Telephone Number: 772-226-1240
Contact: Steven Hitt
lite Location: 7770 lungle Trail. Vero Beach. FL 3
We hereby submit specifications and estimates for:
The elevation of an existing 1,400 sq. ft. wood frame residential structure.
Our work will include tate following:
■ Mobilization of machinery, equipment, and personnel to jobsite location.
■ Excavate fill material from around and underneath existing structure.
■ Provide and install temporary shoring equipment.
N Installation of temporary steel lifting sub -frame and hydraulic jacks.
■ Provide Unified Hydraulic jacking System.
■ Elevate structure approximately T above new proposed F.F.E. of 7.5' NAVD to allow for the installation of a new
foundation.
■ Lower structure onto new foundation.
■ Remove temporary steel lifting sub -frame and hydraulic lifting equipment.
■ Clean, rough grade site, and demobilize completely from job-slte location.
Foundation Option:
• Provide signed and sealed engineered foundation plans.
• Provide labor and material to form thirty-six (36) new concrete pad footings 24"x 24"x 12".
■ Place concrete in new pad footings.
• Form twenty-four (24) new perimeter tapered concrete piers approximately four feet (4') in height.
■ . Erect twelve (12) new CMU interior piers approximately four feet (41 In height
■ Place concrete in all new foundation piers.
■ Install new hurricane tie -down straps from.new piers to sill beam.
■ Nail new hurricane straps to existing sill beams.
Add $18.685.00 to Total Dollar Amount Below for FoUndation Option
Exclusions: Permit fees, termite treatment, densitytests, de -watering, demoUtion, construction, sill beam repairs, site prep, pilings,
dumpsters, utility disconnects/ reconnects, and surveys.
Twenty -Three Thousand Eight Hundred Fifty Dollars and 00/100
TOTAL DOLLAR AMOUNT OF THE ABOVE SPECIFIED WORK _ _ $23.850.00
We propose to hereby furnish material and labor -complete in accordance with the above specifications. All material is guaranteed to be as specified.
All work to be completed in a workman like manner according to standard practices. Any alterations or deviations from the above specifications
involving extra costs will be executed only upon written orders, and will become and extra charge over and above the estimate. All agreements
contingent upon strikes, accidents, acts of God or other delays beyond our control. Owner to carry fire, wind damage and other necessary insurance.
ACCEPTANCE OF PROPOSAL
The above prices, specifications and conditions are satisfactory and are hereby accepted. This Proposal may be withdrawn by us if not accepted
within (30) thirty days of the above submittal date. Upon acceptance of this proposal, you are authorizing us to do the work as specified above. We
will return an authorized, signed copy of this proposal to you upon your returned acceptance of this proposal to Brownie Companies, LLC. Payment is
expected after Service is Completed, unless prior arvungements have been made (subject to Management approval).
Signature/Authorized Acceptance Date
Signature/Brownie Co. Acceptance Date
P45
Steven Hitt
From: Jamison Brownie <jamison@browniecompanies.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 18, 2017 8:49 AM
To: Steven Hitt
Subject: Re: Emailing - Indian River County.7770 Jungle Trail.pdf
Steven,
I apologize for not getting this to you sooner. The figures I am associating with what I have in my proposal as
exclusions are only budget numbers they are not hard numbers. I would also add around 25% to these numbers
to allow for a general contractor to manage and coordinate the project. I hope this helps, please let me know if I
can be of further assistance.
Add 12 tapered concrete columns- $2,800.00
Termite treatment -$750.00
Density Tests -$350.00
De -Watering- Time and material and only if it is needed.
Demolition (removal and haul away existing concrete foundation only) -$2,600.00
Sill Beam Repairs -Unknown at this time. Can not determine until structure is elevated and might not be needed
at all.
Pilings- Unknown at this time. Need a soil investigative report/ soils report to determine if the existing
subsurface ground conditions are suitable to support the existing structure.
Site Prep -Unknown without fiuther information of final site plan.
Dumpsters- $450.00 per dumpster.
Utility Disconnects and Re -connects -$3,500.00
Surveys and Final Elevation Certificate -$2,500.00
Thank You,
Jamison Brownie
Cell -772-260-3799
Office -772-460-5660
Fax -772-460-5650
j amison&browniecompanies. com
www.browniecompanies.com
On May 2, 2017, at 12:05 PM, Steven Hitt <shitt(a,irc og v.com> wrote:
Good Afternoon Jamison,
Sorry it has taken so long for me to get back with you to thank you for the estimate. I have passed this
along to other departments and actually wanted to know if it would be possible to update the estimate
to include the foundation option with all 36 piers being tapered piers instead having any CMU piers.
Also, our public works department wanted to see the estimate include the costs for those things that
were listed as exclusions. Please let me know if you have any questions.
1
P46
Regards,
Steven Hitt
Senior Environmental Planner
180127th Street, Bldg. A
Vero Beach, FL 32960-3365
Phone: 772-226-1240
From: Jamison Brownie(mai Ito: iamiso n0brown iecomoanies.coml
Sent: Sunday, April 23, 2017 9:19 AM
To: Steven Hitt <shitt@kceov.com>
Subject: Emailiing Indian River County:7770 Jungle Trail.pdf
_Steven,
Attached is the proposal for elevating the residence on Jungle Trail. Once you have reviewed
please contact me with any questions or concerns you may have. Thank you for the opportunity,
to present you with this proposal and we look, forward to working with you and your team.
Regards,
Jamison Brownie,
C611-772-260-3799
Office -772-460-5660
Fax -772-460-5650
j amisontbrowniecompanies. com
www.browniccomRanies. com
2
P47
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL DISTRICT
BOARD MEMORANDUM
Informational I�g
Date: June 13, 2017
To: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator -
From: Vincent Burke, P.E., Director of Utility Services
Thru: Himanshu H. Mehta, P.E., Managing Director, Solid Waste Disposal District
Prepared By: Stephanie C. Fonvielle, Recycling Education and Marketing Coordinator, Solid Waste
Disposal District
Subject: Landfill Closure and Collection Service Changes for the July 4t' Holiday
In observance of Independence Day, the main county landfill and the five (S) customer convenience centers will
be closed on Tuesday, July 4, 2017. In addition, there will be no residential curbside services for recycling, garbage
or yard waste on July 4t''. The chart below provides information regarding collection services in unincorporated
county and the municipalities. Residents may visit the Solid Waste Disposal District (SWDD) website at
ircrecycles.corri for more information.
Beginning the week of June 10, 2017, the normal service schedule will resume.
Landfill Closure and Collection Service Changes for July 4t" Holiday
Page —1 —
P48
GarbageLocation
- -
Unincorporated IRC
Garbage services will be shifted by one day.
For example, if you are a Tuesday customer
City of Fellsmere
you will be serviced on Wednesday. If you
are a Friday customer, you will be serviced
Recycling will be shifted by one day.
on Saturday.
For example, if you are a Tuesday
City of Sebastian
Customers scheduled for Tuesday, July 4 will
customer you will be serviced on
be serviced Wednesday, July S.
Wednesday. If you are a Friday
(There will be No yard waste pick up for
customer, you will be serviced on
Tuesday customers).
Saturday.
The Town of Orchid
Garbage will be serviced on your next
City of Vero Beach
scheduled service day.
Indian River Shores
No changes
Beginning the week of June 10, 2017, the normal service schedule will resume.
Landfill Closure and Collection Service Changes for July 4t" Holiday
Page —1 —
P48
7E
INFORMATIONAL ITEM
JUNE 2% 2017
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: Members of the Board of County Commissioners
DATE: June 14, 2017
SUBJECT: Update regarding Indian River Lagoon Council Board of Directors Meeting
on June 9, 2017
FROM: Susan Adams, Commissioner
District 1
As an update on the Indian River Lagoon Council Board of Directors (IRLC) meeting of Friday, June
9, 2017, 1 wish to advise of the following:
• The Board of Directors approved our member addition to the Board. The
paperwork should be completed by the next meeting date (August 11, 2017),
making Indian River County an official voting member.
• While the IRLC spoke about several matters, one of the most interesting was a
presentation entitled "IRL Stormwater Capture and Treatment Feasibility Analysis
Final Report" by St. John's Water Management District. Due to the document is
too large to send over email; the full report is available at this link:
http://www.irlcouncil.com/uploads/7/9/2/7/79276172/16. irl finalswfeasibility 2017 02 01.pdf
• As a matter of information and to keep everyone informed, attached are the
minutes from the previous meeting, April 14, 2017.
• The Board of Directors approved the prioritized FY 2017-2018 RFP Project list,
attached.
C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF
7\@BCL@B805B5BC\@BCL@B805B5BC.doc
P49
\I /� 1
I �
ONE LAGOON"
ONE COMMUNITY . ONE VOICE
IRL COUNCIL
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
FRIDAY APRIL 14, , 2017
SEBASTIAN CITY HALL, SEBASTIANJL
Attendance:
Dick Winger, Drew Bartlett, Ed Fielding, Curt Smiths, -Doug Bournique, Deb Denys:
Agenda Item 1. For Information: Call to order and Pledge of Allegiance
Curt Smith, Chair, called the IRL Council Board of Directors meeting to order, welcomed all in
attendance, and led the attendees in the Pledge of Allegiance.
w
Agenda Item 2. For Consideration: Agenda revisions .
No revisions were offered.
Agenda Item 3. For Information: Resolutions, Recognition, Letters and Awards
IRLNEP Chairman's Award for Leadership presented to Former Chair, Ed Fielding, Martin County
Commission.
Agenda Item 4. For Information: Public Comment
Public comment was offered by Gary Ritter, Bob Stephen, Kelli McGee, Arthur Litowitz, and Carter
Taylor.
Agenda Item 5. For Consideration: Consent Agenda
a. Approval of IRL Council Board of Directors meeting minutes from February 10, 2017
b. Monthly Financial Statements'— Provided for information were a summary page, detail report,
and monthly balance sheet.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY ED FIELDING TO APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA, SECONDED
BY DOUG BOURNIQUE, MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Agenda Item 6. For Information: Water Quality Update.
Dr. Chuck Jacoby from SJRWMD, and Deb Drum from Martin County gave water quality updates from
the north/central and south IRL.
Azenda Item 7. For Information: Management Conference Reports
a. Citizens' Advisory Committee: Duane De Freese briefed the Board on the recent Citizens'
Advisory Committee meeting held at the Environmental Learning Center.
P50
b. STEM Advisory Committee — No report
c. Management Board — Martin Smithson, Co -Chair of the Management Board, gave an update
from the Management Board meeting conducted on April 11. The Management Board
recommended approval of the final Orientation and Policy Document, acceptance of the
Audit Report, and the appointment of 2 new members of the Board from the Space Coast and
Treasure Coast Leagues of Cities, Stu Glass from Indialantic Town Council and Tom
Campenni, Mayor of Stuart.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY ED FIELDING, SECONDED BY CURT SMITH, TO APPROVE
APPOINTMENT OF STU GLASS AND TOM CAMPENNI TO TIME. -MANAGEMENT BOARD.
Agenda Item 8. For Information: Legislative Update
a. State Legislative Update.
Drew Bartlett briefed the members on the st
stand between the Hose and Senate budge
b. Congressional Update. t,,
David Jackson, Congressman Posey's ano
Federal budget and legislation affecting the
IRI. Council thanking the 0$figressman for
IRLNEP. k
�u of legisl'a ive appropriations and where they
briefed members regarding _the status of the
2I,. Dr."/
requested. a, letter from the
isiattention and advocacy for the Lagoon and
Agenda Item 9. For Information: IRLNEP'Project Highlight.
Mike Middlebrook, Natural Resources Managei, St. Lucie County, gave -;.a presentation to the Board on
the Status of restoration efforts at Wesley's Island.
Agenda Item 10. For'Consideration .Old Busint'ess
a. Audit Report-, �
Frank. Sakuma introduced James Hallorarrtfrom James Moore & Co. to present the findings
:Morri the° FY 201 S 2416 audit: -
A MOTION WAS MADE -BY ED FIE DING, SECONDED BY DEB DENYS, TO ACCEPT THE FY
2015-20i`6;.AUDIT REPORT..MOTION,i,ASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
b. Brand Roll-out and Well Development Update
Duane pe Freese introduced Bob Allen of Ideas, Orlando to unveil the new logo for the
IRLNEP and discuss development of the new IRLNEP website.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY ED FIELDING, SECONDED BY DOUG BOURNIQUE, TO ENDORSE
THE NEW LOGO FOR THE IRLNEP. MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
c. Approval of Management Conference Policy Document
Duane De Freese briefly reviewed the final Orientation and Policy document for the
Management Conference.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY DICK WINGER, SECONDED BY KATHY LAMARTINA TO ACCEPT
THE FINALIZED ORIENTATION AND POLICY DOCUMENT. MOTION PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Agenda Item 11. For Consideration: New Business
P51
a. Resolution 2017-03 adopting the FY 2017-2018 IRLNEP Budget
Frank Sakuma reviewed the Final Budget for FY 2017-2018, which requires approval prior to
June 1, 2017.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY DOUG BOURNIQUE, SECONDED BY KATHY LAM.ARTINA, TO
ADOPT THE FINAL FY 2017-2018 BUDGET BY RESOLUTION 2017-03. NO PUBLIC COMMENT
WAS OFFERRED. MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Agenda Item 12: IRLNEP Executive Director's Report
Duane De Freese updated members regarding release of the 2016 IRLNEP Annual Report, the pending
release of 4 RFPs and I RFQ, The annual workplan under development, and the EPA Program
Evaluation.
Agenda Item 13: IRL Council Member Reports
Deb Denys: described a $1.5 Million project in Oak Hill to convert septic to sewer and provide economic
development opportunities.
Ed Fielding: Wishes the Board to focus on the need to stop pollution closer to its source(s) and to do this
more inexpensively than is currently done. ;
Drew Bartlett: Reiterated the need for DEP's $250,000 to be included in the final State budget. He also
noted the previsios for septic bills are different in the House and Senate versions of the bill.
Curt Smith requested the Ideas, Orlando presentation, and mentioned a meeting with space industry
representatives in which he asked them to consider providing volunteer efforts to work on lagoon issues.
Agenda Item 14: Next Meeting '
a. There is an IRL'Council Board of Directors meeting scheduled for .May 12, 2017, which requires
cancellation ifit is not needed.
A MOTION WAS MADE BY DEB DENYS, SECONDED BY DREW BARTLETT, TO CANCEL THE
SCHEDULED MAY 12, 201TMEETING. MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
b. The next IRL Council Board of Directors meeting will be held on Friday, June 9, 2017 at 9:30
a:m. in Sebastian City Hall, 1225, Main Street, Sebastian, FL.
Agenda Item 15, Adjourn
Meeting Adjourned.
P52
Category
Category
County
Applicant
Project
Requested
Running Total
Cost Share
Match as
%of Total
Total Project
Comments
AVG
SD
Ranking
Funding
Match
Cost
Project
Engagement
1
IR
ORCA
The Living lagoon
$ 37,434.00
$ 37,434.00
$ 166,203.00
82%
$ 203,637.00
87.60
6.0
Building Capacity for
Engagement
2
LW
Marine Resources
Council
Citizen Engagement
with the Indian River
$ 28,788.00
$ 66,222.O0
$ 50,388.00
64%
$ 79,176.00
Implementation MUST demonstrate lagoon wide coverage
86.40
7.2
LagoonWatch Network
1. Great Idea to try and quantify the value to Converting yard to Florida
Source and
fdendly Landscaping. 10 yards doesn't seem to be a targe enough sample to
.
Concentration
be significant. Also concerned that the results should dearly measure the
Surface at r
Surface Water
difference between weVdry season n noff AND vlaue of FFY/Lawn. Also
Engagement
3
B
University of Florida
Nutrients from
E 27,401.00
$ 93,623.00
$ 11.668.00
30%
$ 39,069.00
concerned that septic or legacy septic could skew results in such a small
8000
6.9
Residential Waterfront
sample. 2. should have been submitted under the Science and Innovative
Homes in Brevard
Technologies category and not the Citizen Engagement and Education
County, Florida
category. I believe It's a strong proposal but the ultimate goal for the project
is to answer a research question and the proposal does not directly engage
many ci8zens.
Audubon Advocates
Pelican Island
and Lagoon Gardens:
Engagement
4
IR
Audubon Society Inc.
Changing behavior to
S 25.000.00
$ 118,623.00
$ 98,354.00
80%
$ 123.354.00
79.00
5.1
(PIAS)
Improve Lagoon
habitat
Shelfth Harvests in
the Indian River
Engagement
5
V. 8
University of Central
Lagoon: Restoring
$ 9.891.00
$ 128.514.00
E 11,409.00
54%
$ 21.300.00
1. This is an extremely unique proposal, but I'm not certain that IRLNEP Is
75.50
13.5
Florida
Biodiversity through
the right fit. 2. interesting project, but is it important for lagoon restoration?
Capturing Historical
Reflections
Martne Discovery
Center, Marine
This project with Lagoon Watch seems like a lot of money for water
Resources Council,
monitoring that does not include any nutrient data. As a lagoon volunteer for
Volusia County
Project H2O Phase III:
many years and a water monitor for a couple of years. I have never seen any
Engagement
6
V
Environmental
Citizen Science
$ 31,950.00
S 160,484.00
$ 41,350.00
56%
$ 73,300.00
results or comments about trend from the existing water monitoring program
74.40
12.6
Management, Florida
Engagement
that has been going on for 25 years. If the quality control and better reporting
Fish and Wildlife
can significantly Improve the usefulness of the data, there consider funding
Conservation
that portion only for this year.
Commission
COLVI
Category
Category
Ranking
Rank
Applicant
Project
Requested
Funding
Running Total
Coat Share
Match as
l
xProject
70ffi1 Project
CornmeMs
AVG
SD
Match
Cost
Surfrider Foundation in
partnership with
1. 1 think this proposers strongest components are the demonstration
Breverd County's
sitestbuffers andf the proposed workshops. But, I don't see a strong effort
Engagement
7
B
Environmentally
Endangered Lands
Its Your Lagoon!
S 11,750.00
$ 172,214.00
$ 4,762.00
29%
S 16,512.00
made to enable actual behavior change. Brochures 8 posters aren't very
meaningful. Moreover, materefl distdution is not a meaningful outcome. 2.
72.67
10.6
(EEL) Program and the
There Is a desperate need to demonstrate to homeowners that their yards
Town of Melbourne
can look beatiful withoul sod to the waterilne. Public parks are the right
Beach
location where it will be maintained and observed.
Brevard minty
1. This could be an excellentro
p prri, but (here needs to be an actual plan for
Natural Resources
Countywide Rain
education. Simply installing benches doesn't constitute education nor
Engagement
8
g
Management Department and
ConstructionBench Construction
Installation
$ 5.000.00
$ 177,214.00
$ 5,000.00
50%
S 10,000.00
behavior change. I would really like to see this project with a more robust
proposal, (possibly using the evaluation criteria to rethink the 2. Good
65.50
7.0
Brevard
Brevard County
and
project.
hands on education but not much actual water retention. Perhaps fund
. Schools
through license plate hmdtng??
Engagement
9
LW
Blue Tube, Inc.
Blue Tube Installation
S 10,000.00
$ 187.214.00
$ 23,026.00
70%
$ 33,026.00
Corporate sponsorship Is $1501tube. Fund at 53,000 for 20 tubes. License
62.67
17.3
tag funding??
Engagement Total
$ 187,214.00
$ 412,180.00
$ 599,374.00
Category
Category
Ranking
Applicant
Project
Requested
Running Total
Coat Share
Match asTotal
of Total
Project
Comments
AVG
SD
Ranking
Funding
Match
Project
Cost
Living Shoreline and
Oyster Reef
Restoration In
Restoration
1
V
UCF
Mosquito Lagoon:
$E
62,770.00
E 87,055.00
51%
E 169,825.00
Fund. Strong history of excellence in IRL restoration research. Clear
812
3.8
Continuation of
restoration outcomes and high education component.
Successful Models
and Successful
Partnerships
Restore Our Shores:
Restoration
2
B
Brevard Zoo
Engaging Brevard
$ 81,280.00
S 164,050.00
S 166,024,60
67%
$ 247,304.60
1. Fund. Strang match, marry partners, high value and visibility, Rotary and
85.60
13.2
Public Schools to
school connection make this project unique.
Restore Our Shoreline
Restoration
3
LW
Indian River Lagoon
Indian River Lagoon
ShorelineRestoration
$ 52,425.00
$ 218,475.00
S 63.469.00
50%
$ 105,894.00
1. Fund. Strong ongoing work with FDEP - important to continue. Oyster
82.67
9.3
Aquatic Preserves
Project
mapping essential for restoration.
Enhancing seagrass
restoration success M
the Indian River
1. More of a research project 2. Fund. Interesting approach with highly
Restoration
4
M
Florida Oceanographic
Lagoon by
$ 43,048.00
$ 259,523.00
$ 43,154.00
50%
$ 86,202.00
qualified team. Understanding genetic diversity S resilience w10 be Important.
82.87
8.8
Society
Incorporating geneft
IRLNEP needs to help coordinate seagress and fitter feeder network.
diversity from an
established nursery
source.
.
Desoto Parkway
Restoration
5
B
City of Satellite Beach
Drainage Basin
$ 33,000.00
S 292,523.00
$ 35,000.00
51%
S 88.000.00
11,000 linear feet of highway. Not Geer on nutrient reduction benefits. May
82.3
9.2
Stomnvater
Enhancement Project
be able to obtain plants with FWC assistance.
Ocean Breeze
Restoration
6
M
Town of Ocean Breeze
Treatment Train
$ 180,000.00
$ 472,523.00
S 1,090,981.00
86%
S 1,270,981.00
Great project. High value, funding not fully secured. Confirm fundinng gap?
82.0
10.2
Retrofit
Reed Canal Basin
Stormwater
Restoration
7
V
Bethune-Cookman
Improvement through
E 181,148.00
S 853,871.00
$ 183,095.00
50%
$ 384 243.00
1. Fund. Strong proposal, high value, ready to go, small, underserved
81.80
11.8
Unwershy
Treatment Wetland
community, many partners.
Construction in South
Daytona, FL
Mandalay Marguerite
Restoration
8
M
Town of Sawairs Point
Stormurdter
$ 180,000.00
$ 833,671.00
$ 1,823,361.00
90%
$ 1,803,361.00At
M SLRIT. Strong value to IRL. Funding not fully secured.
79.2
9.4
Improvements
to
0)
Total Project
Cost
Comments
AVG
SD
168.222.00
Strong partners, unique school location on IRL. May need some permit and
'76.8
6.8
technical assltantoe. Really strong education component.
1. More of a research project. 2. Fund. Valuable pilot project. Novel
163,061.00
approach to septic repurposing. Economic analysis could help Incentivize
74.0
12.4
septic to sewer conversions. ID of sites and selection criteria vague. Permits
and variances may be required. Strong partners.
1,341,505.25
Fund. Ready to move, 76 acres, good water quality benefits.
72.0
9.8
Fund. Very Interesting, high value restoration with many unique feature. High
24,400.00
visibility. Restoration value, water quality improvement. Historic and cultural
70.0
18.6
value. Wetland creation, invasive. exotic removal.
Weak proposal but concept is sound. Great to see commercial shellfish
61,864.48
Industry participation. Proposal lacks detail but IRLNEP should work with
63.8
16.5
proposer to advance the idea. Not clear how project will define success.
High value restoration project. High visibility with multiple benefits. Low score
150,000.00
reflects lack of detail In proposal not restoration value. Evidence that area
61.5
12.8
has strong oyster recruitment. No educational component hurts proposal.
Interesting appracch to use oyster restoration on shoreline of outfalis. Would
40,000.00
provide polishing of water. Some conoems about salinity range and
60 7
12 3
survivability. This project might need more work, or, if funded, utilize IRLNEP
partners to help.
1. This is really a research project. 2. This project should be deferred until
100,000.00
after Dr. Trefry completes study with Satellite Beach (if funded). Weak
57.8
12.0
support on science side, monitoring and how to quantify success.
Category
Category
Ranking
Ranking
Applicant
Project
Requested
Funding
Running Total
Cost Share
Match
Match asTotal
% To l
project
Project
Cost
Comments
AVG
SO
Hubbs SeaWond
Replenishment of
Fund. Sea and Shoreline has long history of success in seagrass culture and
Restoration
17
8
Research Institute and
Sesgrasses in the
$ 161,701.00
b 1,543,687.48
$ 85,910.00
35%
$ 247,611.00
restoration. Hubbs is a new player in this arena. Primary focus is hatchery
57.50
10.0
Sea and Sh oreliine
Indian River Lagoon
development and capacity building. High likelihood of success through
restoration details are lacking.
Restoration Total
b 1,543;687.48
S 4,868,788.86
5 6,412,474.33
to
V
Category
Category
Ranking
Applicant
Project
Requested
CostTotal Cost Share
Match as
% of Total
Total Project
Comments
AVG
SD
Ranking
Funding
Match
Project
Cost
Developing a
Shoreline Restoration
Suitability Model,
-
1. Good student Involvement. 2. Fund - existing, ongoing project with high
Science &
1
V
UCF
Phase 1: Evaluation of
$ 41,454.00
$ 41,454.00
$ 22.489.00
35%
S 83,943.00
ROI: restoartion suitability has broad IRL application. 3. The information Is
90.0
7.7
Technology
shoreline
of value, and the appioad has been standardized. The results should prove
charactedst cs In the
useful In the future.
northern Indian River
and Mosquito Lagoon
1. Is it amiable? If not, benefd is limited. Beret' makes mlmimum match. 2.
The Efftcacy
Fundl High priority question. Strong experimental design, team with proven
Sediment Aeration as
rtis
expertise; Aeration as a'Compiemenr to dredging must be explored. 3.
Spence &
2
B
Florida Institute of
a Complement to
$ 120,000.00
$ 161,454.00
S 42.000.00
26%
$ 162,000.00
This work is psaudkxepnwted analysis of data and Interpretation of results
88.2
5.6
Technology
Technology
Mupkmust
Dredging in the
be done carefully, i.e.,thie is not a valid test of the nun hypothesis that
Indian River Lagoon
aeration has no snacks). It can be a valid way to look for patterns In states
and rates that appear to be related to aeration, but those results should not
be considered rigorous evidence of causation.
1. Many have tried to do this and IF successful win be useful. What does
NTP mean? 2. Lagconwide value. Innovative visual zatlon tool, open
Development of the
access, needs to align with IRL Health Assessment. 3. Attempts to hold ell
State of the Indian
necessary data In one database have failed multiple times in the past, with
Science &
3
LW
Applied Ecology Inc.
River lagoon Web
S 42.590.00
$ 204.044.00
$ 26,372.00
38%
$ 68,962.00
even an effort to centralize one type of data (water quality in STORET) being
87.0
8.1
Technology
Application (SIRLAP)
rldhwled. Even if the data can be assembled in a useable format, overly
and Ecological Health
simplistic evaluations of their Import win substantially decrease the uUny of
Gap Analyses
the app. It is true that data collection has not been massaged to support the
proposed use In large part because the proposed use is too simplistic, but
the cordention that data exist without a purpose Is dose to baseless.
1. There are a lot of unknowns with otters. Do they move around a krt? Does
Uniting Wildlife Health
diet reflect feeding sites? Does a sick animal eat the same as a healthy
Science &
HubbsesWodd
SResearch
to Ecological Factors
animare
l? 2. UMES demonstrate ed to bettor understand IRL Wildlife
4
LW
in the Heavily
$ 66,000.00
$ 270,044.00
$ 28,513.00
30%
S 94.513.00
health. New work on IRL otters Is valuable. Dolphin health high value as top
81.5
6.9
Technology
Institute
Impacted Indian River
tevef predators. Hubbs and team highly experienced to do this work. 3. The
Lagoon
health of wildlife Is Important, but documenting the problem without a clearer
plan for ddenttfying causes and solutions is probably not a high priority.
Leveraging natural
selection in bivalves of
1. This scored high but I'm not totally convinced. Studies have shown that
the northern Indian
hard clams 'clam up" so finding ones that do not. or do so less often may be
Science &
5
V
OF
River Lagoon to
$ 62.200.00
$ 332,244.00
$ 77,146.00
55%
$ 139,346.00
an impossible task. 2. Clam are emerging as an Important issue that must
81.0
3.8
Technology
enhance water quality
be addressed: would like to see date that states clams are available and that
and accelerate
experimental design Is light. If funded, IRLNEP needs to brig FDACS. Sea
ecosystem recovery
Grant, Industry and universities together to work on this problem.
(n
OD
h as
total
Total Project
Comments
AVG
SD
eat
Cost
1. This should be turned into a collaborative effort with UCF - shared
funding. 2. In part, this project is redundant to ongoing efforts at Sebastian
Inlet although it greatly expands those long-term efforts. 3. Low match and
K
$ 128.831.00
could improve the cost-sharing by partnering with other turtle study. 4. 2
80.8
3.0
different proposals differ in location only; experimental design needs mom
detail; sea turtle research groups need to get together on IRL focused
research. 5. A single project combining both proposed efforts would be a
better approach.
1. Doable but salinity regime could change over time, or change oyster
natural distribution. 2. Important role for fisheries and aquaculture folk; info
Yo
$ 99,317.00
could inform management decisions; Interesting appraoch worth exploring.
80.3
4.5
3. The approach Is somewhat risky, and the outcomes did not seem dearly
defined.
1. Valuable new technology application with example from coral research.
+e
$ 69.479.00
Should be explored and funded? High value, strong proposal. 2. Potentially
80.2
8.5
useful project, but nut a very high priority need.
1. Planning tool. Does not account for southern IRL. Minimum match. 2.
Important planning tool for CCMP. If funded, needs to include entire IRL;
'
$ 125,000.00
outward look to 2025 Important to decislon-making; Team has strong
00.2
7.9
credentials and experience. Recommend fund) 3. It would be better to link
this modeling with ongoing efforts mom explicitly.
1. Expensive. 2. This would be an enhancement for tracking HABs but may
not be a critical need. Barely above the minimum match. 3. Smart drifter
network; need to look at big picture: does system integrate with and
6
$ 191,739.00
complement existing sampling and monitoring efforts; love intelligent
79.0
6.7
monitoring capacity. Match?? 4. Uncertain about the utility of this work
given the relatively limited number of parameters that will be measured well.
A clearer definition of the outcomes would be useful.
1. This should be fumed into a collaborative effort with Loggerhead Marine
Life Cerner - shared funding. 2. Great match. Would benefit from partnering
with other turtle group. 3. Similar to the other sea turtle project proposed;
$ 83.222.77
team has strong experience and 36 jeers of long term research on IRL;
79.0
7.3
cutting edge skin mierobiome work. Worthy of funding and contributes to long
term date. 4. A single project combining both proposed efforts would be a
batter approach.
Category
Category
Ranking
Ranking
Applicant
Protect
Requested
Funding
Running Total
Cost Share
h as
MatcProjectTotal
% of Total
Project
Comments
AVG
SD
Match
Project
host
1. ID of phytoplankton is needed but I think it may be a stretch to say it will
Developing novel DNA
1 tmpmve WD. It may only Improve our response to problems. 2. High value,
Science b
Smithsonian Marine
sequencing
high risk proposal; success of novel approach could advance algal bloom
Technology
12
SL
Station
plications to identity
$ 45,807.00
$ 882,213.32
$ 26,675.00
37%
$ 72,482.00
research; addresses major technical challenges facing algal bloom research,78.8
di
downside:
4.7
harmful algae in the
Needs longtime frame for validalon. 3. The proposed approach'
th
IRL
holds considerable promise for accelerating the identification of key
phytoptankton, but the speed of our response is not as big an issue as the
shortage of resource to sample rigorously.
1. Values for %N removed are for rain events in mid-Atlantic unlike what are
experienced in Florida. May not work well under heavy summer rains or only
work as well as passive systems. I like this project but would be more
confortable seeing this In with other slormwater projects. 2. Valuable proof
of concept broad lagoon efficiency value and Increased ociency for nutrient
Brevard County
ContinFAoniti
Continuous arng
reduction In existing systems. Strong proposal, high value. 3. The suite of
Science&
Natural Resources
and Adaptive Control
parameters being measured Is limited, with other forms of nitrogen and some
Technology
13
B
Management
(CMAC) Retrofits for
$ 128,732.00
$ 1,010,945.32
$ 181,474.00
59%
$ 310206.00
measure of phosphorus being recommended. This project also would benefit
78.8
8.6
Department
Water Quality m
from explicit before -after sampling or an attempt to sample a reference
Brevard County
system. In either case, the project would remain pseudoreplicated, which
means analysis of data and interpretation of results must be done carefully,
i.e., this Is not a valid test of the null hypothesis that the automated system
has no effect(s). It can be a valid way to look for patterns In states and rates
that appear to be related to the system, but those results should not be
considered rigorous evidence of causation.
1. Interesting study. A lot of collaboration. Great benefit to understanding
Using acoustic
grouper fishery but this should stay in FWC's court. Not much benefit to IRL
Florida Fish and
telemetry 16 assess
ecosystem issues. 2. Love this project bud not sure based on
Science &
Wildlife Conservation
habitat use of juvenile
nuldent/habital focus. Critically endangered species and should be looked at
Technology
14
14
M
Commission, Fish and
Goliath Grouper in
$ 58,214.91
$ 1,069,160.23
$ 19,539.12
25%
$ 77.754.03
M the IRL. Habitat connection could have been a
78.5
3.0
Research
mangrove nursery
Although an Important species, work on grouper doe not match the highhest
Institute
habitats of the Indian
priority issue facing the lagoon at this time. For example, If poor water quality
River Lagoon
degrades habitats juvenile grouper will not have a home. Perhaps, funds
from FFWCC could be allocated to offset costs.
Predicting the filtering
1. Is it scalable? Would have to be stated up to have significant impact. 2.
Science 8
Florida Institute of
capacity of benthic
Ten Shells? Is this enough? Question about rigor of experimental design. 3.
Technology
15
B
Technology
communities as part o
$ 58,760.00
$ 1,127,920.23
$ 26,061.00
31%
S 84,821.00
Similar work in the past has failed to live up to the promised delivery. We
75.0
6.2
a'Uving Dock" in the
have some Information on gra" by fouling communities, so this project
Indian River Lagoon
does not meet a high priority need.
CD
Category
Ranking
Ranking
Applicant
Project
Requested
Funding
Running Total
Cost Share
Match
Match as
�6pro� l
Total Project
Comments
AVG
SD
Coat
Verification and
validation of high-
1. [Stated under both technical merit and benefits to IRL) Relative to other
resolution numerical
knowledge gaps, how critical is a wave model? 2. Wind, wave and
Science &
16
LW
Florida Institute of
wave model
$ 54,079.00
$ 1.181,999.23
$ 18,897.00
24%
$ 70.776.00
decisions.
circulation model for entire IRL will be important74.8
Technology
Technology
predictions in the IRL
Need to discuss with SJRWMD to see if their odelers anndwn
4.2
for planning of coastal
communicating?? Check match. 3. it would be better to link this modeling
restoration / costal
with ongoing efforts more explicitly.
development
1. Concerned about the cost-effectiveness. I liked this project much better
then the score reflects. If they were requesting funds for validation of an
Harbor Branch
The use of community-
already -proven technology. I would have scored H higher. 2. Biological
Science &
17
SL
Oceanographic
based Indicators In
indicators for sediment contaminants; novel survey technique; might take
Technology
Institute, Florida
determining
$ 180,075.00
$ 1,362,07423
$ 60,000.00
25%
$ 240.075.00
some time to validate methodology for application and management
73.8
11.5
Atlantic University
environmental health
guidance. Cost? 3. Bacterial community composition may be a very
sensitive Indicator ofpollution," but it Is unlikely to be an Indicator of a
spedfic type of pollution and the relevance of any differences is not clearly
demonstrated.
Modeling ecosystem
Harbor Branch
dynamics in the Indian
1. This Is a continuationproject anti regardless of score Unless the first
Science 6
16
SL
Oceanographic
River Lagoon and
$
year product was a total disaster) I believe H should be supported. 2. 2nd
Technology
Institute, Florida
assessing the
48,317.00
$ 1,410,391.23
$ 21,958.00
31%
$ 70.273.00
phase ongoing work; model has broad applications; must integrate with other
73.7
5.0
Atlantic University
potential impacts of
models like SJRWMDs; should be refunded despite low score. 3. It would
'
climate change
be better to Ink this modeling with ongoing efforts more explicitly.
1. Important in that proposal looks at pharna and personal care products;
Monitoring Pollutants
human health issues should be elevated as funding priorities; concern about
'
Science S
19
SL
ORCA
of Concern for Human
$ 64,010.00
$ 1,474,401.23
$ 50.000.00
44%
$ 114,010.00
M
experimental design ails; strong team; questions about how this "act
73.2
Technology
Health In the Indian
would inform management decisions. 2. The lade of understanding
7.0
River Lagoon
regarding the limitations of Microlox tests raise concerns. Past experience
With similar date indicated a problem with interpretation of results.
Copepod grazinggrazing on
Science 6
Florida Institute of'
harm
armfulla
algal blooms
1. Minimum matc h. 2. Important consideration fora I bloom science.
Technology
20
B
Technology
and the effect of
$ 55,284.00
$ 1,529,68523
S 18,615.00
25%
$ 73,ggg,00
Bask scientific research. not clear how it would advise resource
72,0
7.0
salinity on grazing
management and restoration. 3. This work will expand on existing
rates
information. Perhaps, not a tremendously thigh priority.
Biogeochemical model
1. Not sure what to make of this project match. Regardless of score, I do
Science 8
Sunergy Power
of St. Lurie West's
not support this project in the research category. I would feel more
Technology
21
SL
Systems, Inc
attainment of on -she
$ 50,000.00
$ 1,579,685.23
$ 353.107,00
88%
$ 403,107.00
comfortable if it were in with other stromwater projects. 2. Not clear how
62.8
12A
TMDL for Total
this provides broad/new guidance for other locations or how robust the model
Phosphorus.
might be. 3. The proposed work was not presented In a way that allowed for
rigorous evaluation of its utility.
Sclence Total:
$ 1,579,685.23
$ 1,164,070.57
$ 2,743,755.60
CD
Category
Category
Ranking
Applicant
jest
Requested
Running Total
Cost Share
Match as
% fTaal
Total Project
.
Comment*
AVG
SD
Ranking
Funding
Match
ProjecRiSc-based
Cost
Comnmunity
RWPerkiraon
vulnerability
assessment the
t. Fund. Strong, qualified team. Slrict adherance to EPA guldotlnea No
1
LW
Consu", Inc and
$ 24,700.00
$ 24,700.00
$
0%
$ 24,700.00
nu teh7 2. Not a very dgorously designed effort to gether'expeW ophlom
82.5
7.8
Resilience
The Belmoral Group
g
Indian River Lagoon M dhnate change and
The pmponoMs offer little in the way of specialized analysis.
seaaeval rise
Community
$ 24,700.00
$
S 24,700.00
Resilience Total:
Grand Total:
S 3,335,288.71
$ 8,44S,017.42
$ 9,780,304.13
.0
N
JEFFREY R SMITH, CPA, CGFO, CGMA
Clerk of Circuit Court & Comptroller
Finance Department
180127" Street
Vero Beach, FL 32960
TO: HONORABLE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
FROM: DIANE BERNARDO, FINANCE DIRECTOR
THRU: . JEFFREY R. SMITH, COMPTROLLER
♦I
t
DATE: June 8, 2017.
SUBJECT: APPROVAL OF CHECKS AND ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS
June 2, 2017 to June 8, 2017
In compliance with Chapter 136.06, Florida Statutes, all checks and electronic payments issued
by the Board of County Commissioners are to be recorded in the Board minutes.
Approval is requested for the attached lists of checks and electronic payments, issued by the
Comptroller's office,.for the time period of June 2, 2017 to June 8, 2017.
Attachment:
i
a
63
CHECKS WRITTEN
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR
AMOUNT
354170
06/02/2017
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY SHERIFF
90.00
354171
06/08/2017
PORT CONSOLIDATED INC
34,537.44
354172
06/08/2017
FIRE EQUIPMENT SVC OF ST LUCIE INC
195.00
354173
06/08/2017
JORDAN MOWER INC
178.86
354174
06/08/2017
SUNCOAST WELDING SUPPLIES INC
138.92
354175
06/08/2017
COMMUNICATIONS INTERNATIONAL
520,710.08
354176
06/08/2017
RANGER CONSTRUCTION IND INC
615.40
354177
06/08/2017
VERO CHEMICAL DISTRIBUTORS INC
230.60
354178
06/08/2017
RICOH USA INC
62.22
354179
06/08/2017
CHISHOLM CORP OF VERO
6,480.75
354180
06/08/2017
KIM'LEY HORN & ASSOC INC
1,326.00
354181
06/08/2017
VELDE FORD INC
. 92.61
354182
06/08/2017
SAFETY PRODUCTS INC
1,842.26
354183
06/08/2017
AT&T WIRELESS
571.18
354184
06/08/2017
DATA FLOW SYSTEMS INC
6,739.80
354185
06/08/2017
E -Z BREW COFFEE & BOTTLE WATER SVC
99.41
354186
06/08/2017
KELLY TRACTOR CO
3,392.08
354187
06/08/2017
GENES AUTO GLASS INC
460.00
354188
06/08/2017
SAFETY KLEEN SYSTEMS INC
351.09
354189
06/08/2017
GRAYBAR ELECTRIC
1,030.81
354190
06/08/2017
REPUBLIC SERVICES INC
490,356.33
354191
06/08/2017
MY RECEPTIONIST INC
266.34
354192
06/08/2017
AMERIGAS EAGLE PROPANE LP
29.63
354193
06/08/2017
AMERIGAS EAGLE PROPANE LP
1,199.23
354194
06/08/2017
GAYLORD BROTHERS INC
912.70
354195
06/08/2017
LFI FORT PIERCE INC
4,210.52
354196
06/08/2017
LFI FORT PIERCE INC
1,249.97
354197
06/08/2017
CLIFF BERRY INC
1,940.50
354198
06/08/2017
DEEP SIX DIVE SHOP INC
35.00
354199
06/08/2017
SCHULKE BITTLE & STODDARD LLC
34,520.00
354200
06/08/2017
PETES CONCRETE
3,750.00
354201
06/08/2017
ECOTECH CONSULTANTS INC
2,454.00
354202
06/08/2017
VERO INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY INC
441.38
354203
06/08/2017
TIRESOLES OF BROWARD INC
6,001.85
354204
06/08/2017
CARTER ASSOCIATES INC
11,895.00
354205
06/08/2017
DELL MARKETING LP
867.29
354206
06/08/2017
THE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY
2,211.98
354207
06/08/2017
BLAKESLEE SERVICES INC
65.00
354208
06/08/2017
BAKER & TAYLOR INC
4,382.74
354209
06/08/2017
MIDWEST TAPE LLC
1,144.43
354210
06/08/2017
MWI CORP
2,956.41
354211
06/08/2017
PRECISION CONTRACTING SERVICES INC
1,495.00
354212
06/08/2017
MICROMARKETING LLC
355.94
354213
06/08/2017
BAKER DISTRIBUTING CO LLC
55.12
354214
06/08/2017
CENGAGE LEARNING INC
178.50
354215
06/08/2017
GO COASTAL INC
129.50
354216
06/08/2017
CITY OF VERO BEACH
56,004.05
354217
06/08/2017
LANDIAINC
36,388.45
354218
06/08/2017
COMPBENEFITS COMPANY
80.16
354219
06/08/2017
FERGUSON ENTERPRISES INC
1,189.50
354220
06/08/2017
LIVINGSTON PAGE
180.00
354221
06/08/2017
JANITORIAL DEPOT OF AMERICA INC
837.22
354222
06/08/2017
PUBLIX SUPERMARKETS
14.95
354223
06/08/2017
ACUSHNET COMPANY
11,993.42
354224
06/08/2017
CULTURAL COUNCIL OF IRC
2,684.39
354225
06/08/2017
FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL
225.00
354226
06/08/2017
FLORIDA WATER & POLLUTION CONTROL
255.00
354227
06/08/2017
GEOSYNTEC CONSULTANTS INC
837.75
64
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR
AMOUNT
354228
06/08/2017
FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP
22.36
354229
06/08/2017
TIMOTHY ROSE CONTRACTING INC
1,110.00
354230
06/08/2017
JOHN KING
15.00
354231
06/08/2017
CALLAWAY GOLF SALES COMPANY
746.58
354232
06/08/2017
FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT
13,498.86
354233
06/08/2017
FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT
1,875.42
354234
06/08/2017
FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT
1,816.50
354235
06/08/2017
TAYLOR MADE GOLF CO INC
857.93
354236
06/08/2017
STRUNK FUNERAL HOMES & CREMATORY
425.00
354237
06/08/2017
JASON E BROWN
1,067.98
354238
06/08/2017
FLORIDA DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
75.00
354239
06/08/2017
FLORIDA DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
25.00
354240
06/08/2017
FLORIDA DEPT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
525.00
354241
06/08/2017
IRC HEALTHY START COALITION INC
500.00
354242
06/08/2017
IRC HEALTHY START COALITION INC
2,500.00
354243
06/08/2017
IRC HEALTHY START COALITION INC
1,000.00
354244
06/08/2017
IRC HEALTHY START COALITION INC
1,666.66
354245
06/08/2017
UNITED HEALTH CARE INS COMPANY
146.58
354246
06/08/2017
MYLES BROWN
160.00
354247
06/08/2017
GREY HOUSE PUBLISHING
345.00
354248
06/08/2017
HENRY SMITH
380.00
354249
06/08/2017
NEXTRAN CORPORATION
266.67
354250
06/08/2017
G K ENVIRONMENTAL INC
3,900.00
354251
06/08/2017
JOHN BROWN & SONS INC
3,900.00
354252
06/08/2017
WESTSIDE REPROGRAPHICS OF VERO BEACH INC
40.92
354253
06/08/2017
KEEP INDIAN RIVER BEAUTIFUL INC
474.50
354254
06/08/2017
THE PROFESSIONAL GOLFERS
510.00
354255
06/08/2017
HAMPTON INN
417.00
354256
06/08/2017
HAMPTON INN
417.00
354257
06/08/2017
MIKE DALTON
89.70
354258
06/08/2017
HUMANA
441.07
354259
06/08/2017
LELCO FB TALLAHASSEE LLL
204.00
354260
06/08/2017
HOMETOWN NEWS
739.00
354261
06/08/2017
RUSSELL PAYNE INC
730.38
354262
06/08/2017
TRANE US INC
60,888.00
354263
06/08/2017
RACHEL IVEY
57.00
354264
06/08/2017
INDIAN RIVER DOG TRAINING CLUB INC
203.50
354265
06/08/2017
VAN WAL INC
1,058.00
354266
06/08/2017
JOSEPH W VASQUEZ
100.00
354267
06/08/2017
NATIONAL NOTARY ASSOCIATION
130.00
354268
06/08/2017
SHELLEY NOWLIN
93.00
354269
06/08/2017
QUALITY INN
284.40
354270
06/08/2017
SANIBEL HARBOUR RESORT & SPA
298.00
354271
06/08/2017
OLDCASTLE PRECAST INC
2,740.00
354272
06/08/2017
MICHAEL ZITO
79.29
354273
06/08/2017
MASTELLER & MOLER INC
2,149.25
354274
06/08/2017
STAPLES CONTRACT & COMMERCIAL INC
969.18
354275
06/08/2017
PETER & LORRAINE SUTHERLAND
41.23
354276
06/08/2017
PELICAN ISLES LP
297.00
354277
06/08/2017
GARY L EMBREY
25.00
354278
06/08/2017
DEBORAH PHAIL
93.00
354279
06/08/2017
LARRY STEPHENS
340.00
354280
06/08/2017
AMERICAN WATER WORKS ASSOCIATION
224.00
354281
06/08/2017
D&,S ENTERPRISES OF VERO BCH LLC
.11.39
354282
06/08/2017
JOHNNY B SMITH
75.00
354283
06/08/2017
MENTAL HEALTH ASSOCIATION IRC INC
7,500.00
354284
06/08/2017
FISHER & PHILLIPS LLP
2,782.50
354285
06/08/2017
CHARLENE BRENNAN
125.00
354286
06/08/2017
AMERIMARK INC
5,599.12
354287
06/08/2017
MADESSIA FLOWERS
64.00
-- - - ---- P65
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR
AMOUNT
354288
06/08/2017
TERRI COLLINS LISTER
93.00
354289
06/08/2017
BILLYS AUTO SERVICE
24.16
354290
06/08/2017
FLUID CONTROL SPECIALTIES INC
3,135.01
354291
06/08/2017
NICOLACE MARKETING INC
100.00
354292
06/08/2017
THE SPIVEY GROUP INC
5,092.50
354293
06/08/2017
TERESA PULIDO
270.00
354294
06/08/2017
EXPRESS SUPPLY INC
3,733.84
354295
06/08/2017
WINSUPPLY OF VERO BEACH
45.94
354296
06/08/2017
HMA-SOLANTIC JOINT VENTURE LLC DBA
75.00
354297
06/08/2017
'FLORIDA MEDICAID
90.49
354298
06/08/2017
LARIAT ENTERPRISES INC
99.01
354299
06/08/2017
VERA SMITH
136.00
354300
06/08/2017
GARRETI' SMITH
280.00
354301
06/08/2017
KNAPHEIDE TRUCK EQUIPMENT SOUTHEAST
440.38
354302
06/08/2017
GUARDIAN FUELING TECHNOLOGIES
1,064.56
354303
06/08/2017
WOERNER DEVELOPMENT INC
1,520.00
354304
06/08/2017
VITTORIOS PIZZA
2,338.00
354305
06/08/2017
YOUR AQUA INSTRUCTOR LLC
150.00
354306
06/08/2017
FLORIDA ARMATURE WORKS INC
6,885.00
354307
06/08/2017
MARIA RESTO
368.49
354308
06/08/2017
CIT FINANCE LLC
186.21
354309
06/08/2017
NATIONAL CINEMEDIA LLC
325.00
354310
06/08/2017
PROMATIC INC
1,760.24
354311
06/08/2017
HEATHER HATTON
20.00
354312
06/08/2017
MOORS MOTORS INC
714.68
354313
06/08/2017
FREEDOM HEALTH
294.64
354314
06/08/2017
JENKINS TRUCKING INC
1,250.00
354315
06/08/2017
NEWSOM OIL COMPANY
617.72
354316
06/08/2017
LOWES HOME CENTERS INC
583.89
354317
06/08/2017
CB&I COASTAL PLANNING & ENGINEERING INC
10,869.92
354318
06/08/2017
MUNICIPAL EMERGENCY SERVICES INC
1,747.00
354319
06/08/2017
ADAMS FENCE 2 LLC
15,900.00
354320
06/08/2017
STEVEN G HANSEN
120.00
354321
06/08/2017
BURNETT LIME CO INC
9,580.20
354322
06/08/2017
SOUTHWIDE INDUSTRIES INC
180.00
354323
06/08/2017
IMPECCABLE SIGNS INC
936.00
354324
06/08/2017
LEARNING ALLIANCE
4,066.62
354325
06/08/2017
CARMEN LEWIS
172.00
354326
06/08/2017
STRAIGHT OAK LLC
20.95
354327
06/08/2017
CALDWELLPACETTI EDWARDS
3,197.01
354328
06/08/2017
CHARLOTTE CLAAR
546.36
354329
06/08/2017
KANSAS STATE BANK OF MANHATTAN
890.57
354330
06/08/2017
DUININCK INC
544,500.00
354331
06/08/2017
COAST TO COAST COMPUTER PRODUCTS
275.97
354332
06/08/2017
KESSLER CONSULTING INC
9,422.50
354333
06/08/2017
TRINOVA-FLORIDAINC
3,040.00
354334
06/08/2017
THE LAW OFFICES OF
656.00
354335
06/08/2017
TREASURE COAST CONSULTING INC
178.50
354336
06/08/2017
BERNARD EGAN & COMPANY
6,164.90
354337
06/08/2017
AMERITAS
26,828.17
354338
06/08/2017
FOUNDATION FOR AFFORDABLE RENTAL
409.00
354339
06/08/2017
RELIANT FIRE SYSTEMS INC
1,682.10
354340
06/08/2017
COBRA GOLF INCORPORATED
88.88
354341
06/08/2017
HAWKINS INC
1,435.50
354342
06/08/2017
ANFIELD CONSULTING GROUP INC
10,000.00
354343
06/08/2017
PRESTIGE 14EALTH CHOICE
102.06
354344
06/08/2017
ENCORE ONE LLC
1,580.18
354345
06/08/2017
RANDY KING
1,307.50
354346
06/08/2017
ESI ACQUISITION INC
28,113.85
354347
06/08/2017
KAMAN INDUSTRIAL TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION
9,172.14
- --- -- - ---VP6.6
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR
AMOUNT
354348
06/08/2017
SCRIPPS NP OPERATING LLC
1,662.00
354349
06/08/2017
JOSEPH DIZONNO
25.00
354350
06/08/2017
DIPLOMAT RESORT & SPA
597.00
354351
06/08/2017
CATHEDRAL CORPORATION
25,029.58
354352
06/08/2017
JENNIFER HYDE
203.71
354353
06/08/2017
UNIFIRST CORPORATION
1,233.78
354354
06/08/2017
TAMI GAY
1,625.00
354355
06/08/2017
WILSON SPORTING GOODS CO
828.20
354356
06/08/2017
SCHUMACHER AUTOMOTIVE DELRAY LLC
100.50
354357
06/08/2017
SITEONE LANDSCAPE SUPPLY LLC
750.10
354358
06/08/2017
CSMA SFR HOLDINGS H -LLC
414.00
354359
06/08/2017
ADVANCE STORES COMPANY INCORPORATED
224.55
354360
06/08/2017
PATRIOT PRODUCTIONS LLC
250.00
354361
06/08/2017
DENISE GILLESPIE
140.00
354362
06/08/2017
EGP DOCUMENT SOLUTIONS LLC
1,394.01
354363
06/08/2017
RUSSELL L OWEN III
75.00
354364
06/08/2017
NWI RECYCLING INC
7,228.00
354365
06/08/2017
DAVID CHECCHI
49.00
354366
06/08/2017
OKLAHOMA'SIMMS
280.00
354367
06/08/2017
DALE R BINTZ
84.85
354368
06/08/2017
COVERALL NORTH AMERICA INC
2,015.00
354369
06/08/2017
KELSIES BLINDS
1,330.00
354370
06/08/2017
PEOPLE READY INC
12,525.45
354371
06/08/2017
RAUL E VIVANCO
192.00
354372
06/08/2017
WILLIS SPORTS ASSOCIATION INC
410.59
354373
06/08/2017
MARY C OAKLEY
2,500.00
354374
06/08/2017
COLE AUTO SUPPLY INC
1,447.46
354375
06/08/2017
ASBRO LLC
2,020.00
354376
06/08/2017
MARISAALEXANDER
390.00
354377
06/08/2017
CANON FINANCIAL SERVICES INC
256.99
354378
06/08/2017
PROCTOR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LLC
96,829.83
354379
06/08/2017
KONICA MINOLTA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS
320.06
354380
06/08/2017
KIMBERLY RICCIARDONE
70.00
354381
06/08/2017
THOMAS LNOLAN
88.81
354382
06/08/2017
PAUL E THOMPSON
20.00
354383
06/08/2017
KENNETH JOHNSON
49.00
354384
06/08/2017
PUMPBIZ INC
1,757.00
354385
06/08/2017
OZARK MARTERIALS LLC
25,872.00
354386
06/08/2017
BETH NOLAN
50.00
354387
06/08/2017
LAUREN LOBDELL
93.00
354388
06/08/2017
SHELBY BALL
93.00
354389
06/08/2017
CAROL BERGERON
93.00
354390
06/08/2017
LISA HILL
93.00
354391
06/08/2017
GEORGE PEREZ
93.00
354392
06/08/2017
DARLENE COLLIA
93.00
354393
06/08/2017
DIANE FESHOH
93.00
354394
06/08/2017
JESSICA MENDOZA
93.00
354395
06/08/2017
FLORENCE PRICE
107.00
354396
06/08/2017
TRALISIA CURRY
53.50
354397
06/08/2017
THOMAS R PILIERO
16.00
354398
06/08/2017
HOTEL COLONNADE CORAL GABLES
357.00
354399
06/08/2017
PHOENIX REALTY HOMES INC
9,686.96
354400
06/08/2017
SHAMEKAAUBRY
53.50
354401
06/08/2017
ALEXANDRA APOSTOLIDES
32.00
354402
06/08/2017
ERIC GAYETSKY
75.00
354403
06/08/2017
JOAN NOTARO
90.11
354404
06/08/2017
JANE R OLSEN
73.85
354405
06/08/2017
BETTIE OSBORNE
74.72
354406
06/08/2017
MARABETH PEPINO
275.00
354407
06/08/2017
MARY E PETERSON
93.01
67
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR
AMOUNT
354408
06/08/2017
LISA RUSSELL
59.77
354409
06/08/2017
CYNTHIA SCHWARZ
27.37
354410
06/08/2017
JEAN W SERPA
74.02
354411
06/08/2017
ROGER TUCKERMAN
96.63
354412
06/08/2017
ALICE M VEM SISTER
78.14
354413
06/08/2017
DAVID VINCENT
95.16
354414
06/08/2017
INGER C WHITE
515.20
354415
06/08/2017
MARGARET WHITE
50.00
354416
06/08/2017
JOHN W ZILG
189.96
354417
06/08/2017
JUSTIN BECHTOLD
100.00
354418
06/08/2017
NAOMI BINTZ
97.79
354419
06/08/2017
PHYLLIS JENNINGS
15.80
354420
06/08/2017
LORRAINE LARUSSO
20.00
354421
06/08/2017
ELEANOR LYNCH
89.32
354422
06/08/2017
MAY E MICHALKO
300.00
354423
06/08/2017
AGATHE MOODY
81.81
354424
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
42.19
354425
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
41.86
354426
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
27.44
354427
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
68.36
354428
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
96.64
354429
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
341.71
354430
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
79.11
354431
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
12.47
354432
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
65.07
354433
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
100.00
354434
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
46.02
354435
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
61.73
354436
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
57.49
354437
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
96:64
354438
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
70.44
354439
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
38.49
354440
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
39.90
354441
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
78.90
354442
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
49.16
354443
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
34.20
354444
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
80.86
354445
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
77.10
354446
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
67.71
354447
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
103.82
354448
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
320.82
354449
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
40.76
354450
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
19.29
354451
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
46.44
354452
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
59.07
354453
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
64.28
354454
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
61.28
354455
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
40.19
354456
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
19.51
354457
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
19.57
354458
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
27.28
354459
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
43.58
354460
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
69.64
354461
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
29.23
354462.
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
2.40
354463
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
43.69
354464
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
45.45
354465
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
16.23
354466
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
85.85
354467
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
44.11
P68
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR_
354468
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
354469
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
354470
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
354471
06/08%2017
UTIL REFUNDS
354472
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
354473
06/08/2017
UTIL REFUNDS
Grand Total:
AMOUNT
91.61
46.16
30.37
23.15
70.62
130.95
2,322,162:30
P69
ELECTRONIC PAYMENTS - WIRE & ACH
TRANS NBR
DATE
VENDOR
5173
06/02/2017
KIMLEY HORN & ASSOC INC
5174
06/02/2017
NACO/SOUTHEAST
5175
06/02/2017
NACO/SOUTHEAST
5176
06/02/2017
IRC FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOC
5177
06/02/2017
ICMA RETIREMENT CORPORATION
5178
06/02/2017
ICMA RETIREMENT CORPORATION
5179
06/02/2017
FLORIDA LEAGUE OF CITIES, INC
5180
06/02/2017
BENEFITS WORKSHOP
5181
06/05/2017
FL SDU
5182
06/05/2017
IRS -PAYROLL TAXES
5183
06/05/2017
FL RETIREMENT SYSTEM
5184
06/06/2017
MUTUAL OF OMAHA
5185
06/06/2017
ALLSTATE
5186
06/06/2017
COLONIAL LIFE & ACCIDENT .INS CO
5187
06/07/2017
AMERICAN FAMILY LIFE ASSURANCE CO
P -CARD
06/08/2017
WELLS FA.RGO BANK, N.A.
Grand Total:
AMOUNT
43,259.60
27,520.82
1,324.64
6,840.00
2,410.00
13,097.80
4,234.83
6,216.61
6,067.41
445,407.05
527,221.62
7,157.30
292.22
21.24
18,387.04
29,749.60
1,139,207.78
P70
ELECTRONIC PAYMENT - VISA CARD
TRANS. NBR
DATE
VENDOR
AMOUNT
1011465
06/02/2017
EVERGLADES FARM EQUIPMENT CO INC
32.16
1011466
06/02/2017
HELENA CHEMICAL
1,053.45
1011467
06/02/2017
COLD AIR DISTRIBUTORS WAREHOUSE
442.88
1011468
06/02/2017
INDIAN RIVER BATTERY
168.00
1011469
06/02/2017
INDIAN RIVER OXYGEN INC
4,079.50
1011470
06/02/2017
DAVES SPORTING GOODS & TROPHIES
134.00
1011471
06/02/2017
GROVE WELDERS INC
259.90
1011472
06/02/2017
DEERE & COMPANY
289.10
1011473
06/02/2017
ROGER CLEVELAND GOLF INC
446.95
1011474
06/02/2017
COMPLETE ELECTRIC INC
2,950.00
1011475
06/02/2017
BENNETTAUTO SUPPLY INC
443.74
1011476
06/02/2017
L&L DISTRIBUTORS
123.19
1011477
06/02/2017
STAT MEDICAL DISPOSAL INC
495.00
1011478
06/02/2017
HORIZON DISTRIBUTORS INC
6,090.00
1011479
06/02/2017
ALLIED DIVERSIFIED OF VERO BEACH LLC
225.00
1011480
06/02/2017
OFFICE DEPOT BSD CUSTOMER SVC
108.36
1011481
06/02/2017
WASTE MANAGEMENT INC
2,000.70
1011482
06/02/2017
WHEELABRATOR RIDGE ENERGY INC
7,525.90
1011483
06/06/2017
SSES INC
863.55
1011484
06/06/2017
COPYCOINC
119.36
1011485
06/06/2017
NORTH SOUTH SUPPLY INC
247.95
1011486
06/06/2017
RING POWER CORPORATION
7,002.55
1011487
06/06/2017
MIKES GARAGE & WRECKER SERVICE INC
110.00
1011488
06/06/2017
GALLS LLC
62.25
1011489
06/06/2017
IRRIGATION CONSULTANTS UNLIMITED INC
137.76
1011490
06/06/2017
COMO OIL COMPANY OF FLORIDA
569.90
1011491
06/06%2017
COMPLETE ELECTRIC INC
127.50
1011492
06/06/2017
SHRIEVE CHEMICAL CO
2,308.03
1011493
06/06/2017
MIDWEST MOTOR SUPPLY CO
911.52
1011494
06/06/2017
SYNAGRO-WWT INC
70,587.86
1011495
06/06/2017
SOUTHERN JANITOR SUPPLY INC
1,590.92
1011496
06/06/2017
METRO FIRE PROTECTION SERVICES INC
90.00
1011497.
06/06/2017
CONSOLIDATED ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTORS INC
13.78
1011498
06/06/2017
BENNETT.AUTO SUPPLY INC .
41.57
1011499
06/06/2017
L&L DISTRIBUTORS
699.55
1011500
06/06/2017
PACE ANALYTICAL SERVICES INC
3,159.00
1011501
06/06/2017
NEXAIR LLC
185.91
1011502
.06/08/2017
EVERGLADES FARM EQUIPMENT CO INC
281.31
1011503
06/08/2017
COLKITT SHEET METAL & A/C INC
579.00
1011504
06/08/2017
ROBINSON EQUIPMENT COMPANY .INC
126.16
1011505
06/08/2017
HENRY SCHEIN INC
1,411.80
1011506
06/08/2017
DEMCOINC
123.14
1011507
06/08/2017
MIKES GARAGE & WRECKER SERVICE INC
65.00
1011508
06/08/2017
DAVES SPORTING GOODS & TROPHIES
1,702.04
1011509
06/08/2017
ALLIED UNIVERSAL CORP
12,764.28
1011510
06/08/2017
GROVE WELDERS INC
113.93
1011511
06/08/2017
SOUTHERN COMPUTER WAREHOUSE
792.46
1011512
06/08/2017
DEERE & COMPANY
423.68
1011513
06/08/2017
STRYKER SALES CORP
1,036.80
1011514
06/08/2017
SOUTHERN JANITOR SUPPLY INC
2,491.74
1011515
06/082017
CONSOLIDATED ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTORS INC
173.50
1011516
06/08/2017
BENNETT AUTO SUPPLY INC
15.33
1011517
06/08/2017
AUTO PARTNERS LLC
211.81
1011518
06/082017
L&L DISTRIBUTORS
286.19
1011519
06/08/2017
STAT MEDICAL DISPOSAL INC
330.00
1011520
06/0820.17
ALLIED DIVERSIFIED OF VERO BEACH LLC
225.00
Grand Total:
138,849.96
P71
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
Wiilliarn K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
1
Consent Agenda - B. C. C. 6.20.17
Ofce of
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
DATE: June 12, 2017
ATTORNEY
SUBJECT: Memorandum of Agreement with Florida Department of Children and Families for Limited
County Access to FLORIDA System Data.
BACKGROUND.
The Florida Department of Children and Families ("DCF") maintains certain information in the Florida
Online Recipient Integrated Data Access ("Florida") System regarding applicants for and recipients of
Medicaid services. There may be times that Indian River County staff may need to have access to the
FLORIDA System data. In order to have such access, DCF will require Indian River County to execute
the attached Memorandum of Agreement for Limited County Access to FLORIDA System Data (the
"MOA"). Under the MOA, the County employees who have access to the information will need to
comply with certain security and confidentiality protocols.
FUNDING.
There is no funding associated with this matter.
RECOMMENDATION.
The County Attorney's Office recommends that the Board vote to approve the Memorandum of
Agreement for Limited County Access to FLORIDA System Data with the Florida Department of
Children and Families and authorize the Chair to execute the Memorandum of Agreement for Limited
County Access to FLORIDA System Data.
ATTACHMENT(S).
Proposed Memorandum of Agreement for Limited County Access to FLORIDA System Data
F-141.. yWnda1GEWSPULIB C CNg—&)4,-1F1.,fd. System Dw.&,
P72
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT FOR
LIMITED COUNTY ACCESS TO FLORIDA SYSTEM DATA
This Memorandum of Agreement for Limited County Access to Florida Online Recipient
Integrated Data Access (FLORIDA) System data (hereinafter "MOA") is entered into between the
Florida Department of Children and Families, Office of Economic Self -Sufficiency (the
Department) and County (the County).
WHEREAS, the Department maintains certain information in the FLORIDA System regarding
applicants for and recipients of Medicaid Services;
WHEREAS, in 2012, House Bill 5301 mandated that the Department and the Agency for Health
Care Administration (ARCA) work together to assist counties in processing Medicaid invoices
sent to the counties for payment of the county share as required, by section 409.915, Florida
Statute, which states that Florida counties will pay a portion of the state Medicaid expenditures;
WHEREAS, the County needs ,to access limited data on the FLORIDA System to confirm
recipients of Medicaid Services were residents of the County when services were rendered for
payment purposes; and
WHEREAS, as part of the effort to assist counties with this issue, the Department is willing to
provide designated County employees limited access to the address data in the FLORIDA
System for such purposes, provided that the County complies with certain security and
confidentiality requirements.
NOW THEREFORE, IT 1S AGREED AS FOLLOWS:
The foregoing recitations are true and incorporated into the terms of this MOA by reference.
2. Conditioned on the County's compliance with the terms of the "County Use and Security
Requirements" ("Exhibit A") to this MOA and the terms below, the Department will grant
authorized County employee's limited access to the FLORIDA System to verify Medicaid
recipient addresses. Authorized County employees will be. provided "view only" access to
the screens shown in "Exhibit B" to this MOA (hereinafter the "limited FLORIDA data"). The
Department will have sole discretion to determine the means of access and the manner of
display of the limited FLORIDA data.
3. The County. hereby agrees to comply with the terms of Exhibit A and will access the limited
FLORIDA data exclusively for purposes of verifying Medicaid recipient addresses for
payment of the County's portion of state Medicaid expenditures and will not utilize nor
permit any person to utilize the limited FLORIDA data for any other purpose. Any County
record of the limited FLORIDA data shall be maintained and used only in accordance with
the terms of this MOA; however, the foregoing does not limit the right of the parties to enter
into subsequent agreements or seek court or administrative orders authorizing the use of
these records in judicial or administrative proceedings.
4. The Department will provide appropriate and timely training and support to the County,
including its employees, with regard to FLORIDA System access.
5. Prior to granting access to the FLORIDA System to individual users at the County level, the
following must be accomplished:
I I P a g e
P73
a. The Department must be in receipt of a signed MOA with the appropriate County entity.
b. The Department must be in receipt of a "FLORIDA Individual Security Information Form"
("Exhibit C") for each user requesting access to the FLORIDA System.
c. The Department must be in receipt of a signed CF 114 "Security Agreement Form"
(Exhibit D). This form should accompany Exhibit C.
d. Individual users must have received confirmation from the Department's FLORIDA
Application Data Security Administrator that access has been granted and received a
user ID and an initial password.
e. Individual users must have completed FLORIDA System access training.
f. Individual users must have completed the required initial Department online security
training, and have printed out their completion certificate for their local personnel file. A
copy of the security -training certificate should accompany Exhibit C. This training is
required annually after completion of the initial training, maintained in the personnel file
and provided to the Department upon request.
6. The County shall safeguard and maintain the confidentiality of all information provided to or
accessed by the County employees pursuant to this MOA in accordance with applicable
Florida and federal laws, rules, and regulations, the Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act (HIPAA) and information security and privacy laws regarding Personal
Identifiable Information including section 501.171, Florida Statutes.
7. The County agrees to provide a signed "Department of Children and Families Annual
Affirmation Statement" ("Exhibit E") to the Department on or before the anniversary date of
this MOA. The initial signed Exhibit E must be submitted to the Department with the County
signed MOA.
8. To the extent permitted by law, including section 768.28, Florida Statutes, and without
waiving the limits of sovereign immunity, the County shall indemnify the Department, its
officers, employees and agents from any,suits, actions, damages, claims and costs of every
name and description, including attorneys' fees, relating to access to or use of the limited
FLORIDA data by the County, its officers, employees or agents; provided, however, that this
indemnity shall not include that portion of any loss or damages proximately caused by an
act or omission of the Department, its officers, employees or agents.
9. This MOA executed and entered into in the State of Florida, shall be construed, performed
and enforced in all respects in accordance with Florida law and venue shall be in Leon
County, Florida.
10. There are no provisions, terms, conditions, or obligations other than those contained herein,
and this MOA shall supersede all previous communications, representations, or
agreements, either verbal or written between the parties.
11. If any term or provision of this MOA is legally determined unlawful or unenforceable, the
remainder of the MOA shall remain in full force and effect and such term or provision shall
be stricken.
12. Modifications of provisions of this MOA shall be valid only when they have been reduced to
writing and duly executed by the duly authorized officials of both parties. Changes to the
Agreement Coordinators may be completed by written notification that is acknowledged by
the other Party.
2 1 P a g e
P74
13. To the extent that the County Clerk of the Circuit Court acts as the
County's agent or administrator for purpose of Medicaid payments to recipients, the term
"County" as used in this MOA shall include the Clerk of the Circuit Court, provided that this
MOA is also executed by the Clerk of the Circuit Court as provided below.
14. This MOA shall commence the last day executed by all parties and shall continue until June
30, 2023, provided, however, that the confidentiality requirements regarding the limited
FLORIDA data shall survive the expiration or termination of this MOA. This MOA may be
terminated by either party without cause upon 30 days written notice. This MOA may be
terminated by either party for cause upon no less than 24 hours written notice. The
Department may administratively suspend access to the FLORIDA System at any time the
Department has reason to believe that the County is not in full compliance with the
provisions of this MOA.
15, This MOA may be renewed once for a period not to exceed three (3) years or for the term of
the original contract, whichever period is longer. To be eligible for renewal, the Exhibit E,
Annual Affirmation Statement, must be completed and signed. Such renewal shall be made
by mutual agreement and shall be contingent upon satisfactory contract monitoring as
determined by the Department. Any renewal shall be in writing and shall be subject to the
same terms and conditions as set forth in the initial Agreement including any amendments.
16. Designation of Agreement Coordinators:
County contact/coordinator:
Name —
Title -
Organization
Mailing Address (city, state, ZIP)
Phone -
Email -
Department contact/coordinator:
Janice D. Johnson
Contract Manager
Florida Department of Children and Families
Economic Self -Sufficiency Program Office
1317 Winewood Blvd., Bldg. 3, Room 461
Tallahassee, FL 32399-0700
(850) 717-4110
JD.JohnsonO-mvflfamilies.com
Clerk of Circuit Court contact/coordinator (of applicable):
Name -
Title -
Organization
Mailing Address (city, state, ZIP)
Phone -
Email -
17. Attachments:
Exhibit A — County Use and Security Requirements
Exhibit B — FLORIDA System screen shots
Exhibit C — FLORIDA Individual Security Information Form
Exhibit D — CF 114 Security Agreement Form
Exhibit E — Department of Children and Families Annual Affirmation Statement
3.I P.a_ge..
P75
IN WITNESS THEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Memorandum of Agreement to be
executed by their undersigned officials as duly authorized.
COUNTY BOARD
OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILIES
Chairman's Signature Date Director's Signature Date
Economic Self -Sufficiency
COUNTY CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT (as needed)
Signature Date
4 1 P a g e
P76
EXHIBIT A - COUNTY USE AND SECURITY REQUIREMENTS
The County agrees to comply with the following use and security requirements:
That the information obtained from the Department's system pursuant to the MOA (hereinafter
"the limited FLORIDA data") is confidential in nature and protected from disclosure by State and
Federal Law.
2. To restrict the transmission of the limited FLORIDA data using secure file transfer protocols to
County personnel who have a verifiable need to know in the performance of their official duties
for the purposes stated in Section 3. of the MOA and that the limited FLORIDA data will be used
and disclosed only for such purposes.
3. To maintain a listing of County personnel granted on-line access privileges to the Department's
system pursuant to this MOA and, upon request, make such information available to the
Department. At a minimum, the list will include the user's first and last name, User Identification
(USERID), date access was granted/changed/deleted, dates of initial security training and
annual awareness training. This information will be maintained for a period of five (5) years after
access has been terminated or until administrative purposes have been served, whichever is
longer.
4. To abide by IT Security Awareness training provided by the Department at
http://www.m)dlfamilies.com/about-us/dcf-training or an equivalent security training
provided to County employees. Initial and annual refresher IT Security Awareness training shall
be documented. The Department reserves the right to review the County training for required
elements.
5. To comply with State of Florida network security requirements specified in Chapter 74-2 of the
Florida Administrative Code.
6. That the limited FLORIDA data may not be re -disclosed by the County or its personnel verbally,
electronically or in any other form except as specifically authorized by law or regulation.
7. That the limited FLORIDA data shall be stored in a place physically secure from access by
unauthorized persons and to safeguard access to the limited FLORIDA data in such a way that
unauthorized persons cannot view, print, copy or retrieve the information by any means.
8. To instruct all personnel granted on-line access privileges to the Department's system or
granted access to the limited FLORIDA data in the County's possession regarding- the
confidential nature' of the information, the safeguards and requirements of this MOA and the
provisions specified in Chapters 74-2 of the Florida Administrative Code, as well as Chapters
39, 119, 282.318, 501, 812, 815, 839 or 877, Florida Statutes, and all applicable federal
requirements. .
To adhere to the confidentiality requirements stated herein, and to fully and promptly report any
infraction of these requirements to the respective contacts specified in #16 of the MOA.
10. To promptly notify the Department of any breach of security related to the limited FLORIDA data
in its possession and to be responsible for full compliance with section 501.171, F.S., if
applicable, in the event of a breach of security concerning confidential personal information in its
possession received from one another, including but not limited to, providing notification to
affected persons and to provide any such breach notification, if applicable, to the Department for
prior review and approval of the contents of the notice.
5 1 P a g e
P77
C. T V f :-)f E
IS
3 F H
c MN i.Ifli._. Elf--��R-'3R NPON� F N U
F, f
P I
1-1 tT i 'i U U' i !3t
STFiTf P
E, 5
I D D,
74 E
R E ID L
X lu F P
Exhibit C: FLORIDA Individual Security Form
0 FLORIDA INDIVIDUAL SECURITY iNFC3RMATION FORM
idenl:itying Infonnation:
1 • 2. 3. 4. Mr. MS. MRS.
Last Name First Name MI. (Circle One)
5. Social Security Number. 6. Position Title: 7. UCB: Yes No
S. A'gencyJBusiness: _ 9. Contracted with: 10. Access to Federal Tax InformationYES_NC
10a.,Access to SAVE YES NO 10b. Access to AMS YES -NO 10c. AMS ROLE
rrae:ex+-rr,�.a-ver,eirxxxexxrxxexx�a�••erax.xexxteyx:rarrxe+,exx rx•�exx••x+reerxx�rx•�•�xearxaren•ei-rsxar+,ea,�•xx•xx,.,,e+,r.,�•axw•exwrsiw rya++••ea,.e,�,>axezxax�••xs,�eexsx,rxra:a,.xraa-..:krr:exx•x,re,e+ax•x�crxew,r:
User:ID(st updates: Action Requited: A = ADD C = CHANGE S = SUSPEND D e DELETE R e RESTORE
Action R►orker Security. Security Profile Profile,
11. Required 12.: User ID 13. _Type 14. Profile Name„ 15. Level 16. Begin Date 17. End Date
Site Information:.
18. DidtrictJCSE Region: 19. Service -Site County No.: 20. Service -Site Location No.:
21.:5uncom # 22., Area CodeA Phone #•, 23: User E -Mail address
'z� a ' ` :sem
Z4 ; Ar1m>3aistratt�ie>Uiiit Asstgtied;.
ab -!i6. 26.:Primary_ Unit Supervisor's ID
.<�upieYvisoi's<%�fs�tr►e:`:.'a::,.,.::::>:.- .: -
*'P U,
30.. Justification? Comments
The employee has completed the DCF Security Amareness Training (1'0OV4 and the DCF Security A%mreness Recertification Training (SOOBVu)
The employee hasgiewed UMAX
31. 32,
Signature of Requester, DATE Signature of Administretor or Next Level Supervisor DATE
33. 34.
Signature ofDisfrict/Region Security Officer DATE
35.
Signature of OPA/Program Administrator DATE
Latt Updated; AtgtstiT.2010
9
Signature of HQTR Security Officer
DATE
CF M. MayM a)btokles CF113 of OOM(bj 110 may rotbe tied) *tDON Nrmbe r: 5T{o-DDB-0113-p
7 1 P a g e
V
CO
Exhibit D: Security Agreement Form
Onp4 tAA�hr
• ~a
O O
SECURITY AGREEMENT FORM
Mrruwiuuoou
The Department of Children and Families has authorized you:
Employee's or Other System User's Name/Organization
to have access to sensitive data using computer-related media (e.g., printed reports, microfiche, system
inquiry, on-line update, or any magnetic media).
Computer crimes are a violation of the department's Standards of Conduct. In addition to departmental
discipline, committing computer crimes may result in Federal or State felony criminal charges.
I understand that a security violation may result in criminal prosecution according to the provisions of
Federal and State statutes and may also result in disciplinary action against me according to the
departments Standards;of Conduct in the Employee Handbook.
By my signature below, I acknowledge that I have received, read, understand and agree to be bound by
the following:
6 The Computer Related Crimes Act, Chapter 815, F.S.
6 Sections 7213, 7213A, and 7431 of the Internal Revenue Code, which provide civil and criminal
penalties for unauthorized inspection or disclosure of Federal tax data.
• 6i 030)(7) of the Internal Revenue Code, which provides confidentiality and disclosure of returns
and return information.
• CFOP 50-2.
6 It is ;the policy of the: Department of Children and Families that no contract employee shall have.
access to IRS tax information or FDLE Information, unless approved in writing, by name and
position to. access.specffied information, as authorized by regulation and/or statute.
• It is the. policy of the Department of Children and Families that I do not disclose personal passwords.
• It is the policy of the Department, of Children and Families that I do not obtain information for my oven
or another person's personal use.
• 1.will'only access or view information or data for which I am authorized and have a legitimate
business reason,to see when performing my duties. I shall maintain the integrity of all confidential
and sensitive information accessed.
•. "Casual viewing" of employee or client data, even data that is not confidential orotherwise exempt
from disclosure as a public record, constitutes misuse of access and is not,acceptable,
The Department.of Children and Families will perform regular database queues to ider*misuseof
access.
s Chapter 119.0712, Florida Statutes, and the Driver Privacy Protection Act (DPPA).
.PRIVACY :ACT 'STATEMENT: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary, but.must be provided
in order to gain access to department systems. It is requested, however, pursuant to Section, 282.318,
Florida Statutes, the Security .of Data and information Technology Resources Act. The .Department
requests -social security numbers to ensure secure access to data systems, prevent unauthorized access to
confidential and sensitive information collected and stored by the Department; and provide a unique
identifier in our systems.
Print Employee or Other System User Name
Signature of Employee or Other System User Date
PrintSuperv'rsor Name Signature of Supervisor Date.
CF 1:14. PDF 03/2013 Distribution of Copies: Original —Personnel: File/011ier Svstem'User File: Coov — Emolrnee/Other systeni User
8 1 P a a e
P80
Exhibit E: Annual Affirmation Statement
Department of Children and Families
Annual Affirmation Statement
Date:
0. pEPApT1�F
o-
W0®
a T
n
Atin c*��
AWFIfAMILIFS.COA:
In accordance with Section.7, of the Memorandum of Agreement between the
Department of Children and Families and County (County), the
County hereby affirms that the County has evaluated and has adequate controls in place
to protect the data from unauthorized access, distribution, use and modification or
disclosure and is in full compliance as required in the Memorandum .of Agreement.
Signature
Printed Name
Title
Date
Name of County / Agency
P81
CONSENT: 6/20/17 FC,
OfIce Of
COUNTYINDIAN RIVER
ATTORNEY
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Dylan Reingold - County Attorney
DATE: June 12, 2017
RE: Resolutions Delegating the Authority to the County Administrator or his Designee
to Call Letters of Credit and to Act on Behalf of Indian River County during the
time frames of June 21, 2017, through and including July 10, 2017; July 19, 2017,
through and including August 14, 2017; and August 16, 2017, through and
including September 11; 2017
The Indian River County Board of County Commissioners has canceled regularly scheduled
meetings during the three time frames of June 21, 2017, through and including July 10, 2017;
July 19, 2017, through and including August 14, 2017; and August 16, 2017, through and
including September 11, 2017. During these three intervals, it is necessary and desirable that the
Board delegate to the County Administrator, or his designee, the authority to call Letters of
Credit that may expire during these three time intervals. Further, it is necessary and desirable
that the Board delegate to the County Administrator, or his designee the authority to execute all
other documents necessary for the proper functioning of the County. In Resolution No. 2016-
120, the Board delegated the authority to sign any resolution or proclamation of local emergency
or state-wide emergency that affects Indian River County, together with any and all emergency
orders and other acts required in connection therewith, to the County Administrator, or his
designee. Resolution No. 2016-120 remains in full force and effect through December 31, 2017.
Additionally, in Resolution No. 2016-121, the Board delegated to the County Administrator or
his designee, the authority to sign resolutions on behalf of the Board to call letters of credit
which may expire or otherwise require action to be taken during the period of a declared state of
local emergency or declared State of Florida emergency affecting Indian River County.
Resolution No. 2016-121 also remains in full force and effect through the calendar year 2017.
Funding:
There is no expense associated with this item.
P82
Requested. Action:
Authorize the Chairman to sign the three Resolutions as presented, delegating the authority to
call Letters of Credit and delegating full signing authority during the periods commencing June
21., 2017, through and including July 10, 2017; July 19, 2017, through and including August 14,
2017; and August 16, 2017, through and including September 11, 2017, respectively.
/nhM
Attachments
2
083
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, DELEGATING AUTHORITY TO THE
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE, TO EXECUTE
RESOLUTIONS CALLING LETTERS OF CREDIT AS NECESSARY
DURING THE PERIOD COMMENCING JUNE 21, 2017, THROUGH AND
INCLUDING JULY 10, 2017, AND FURTHER DELEGATING TO THE
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE, THE AUTHORITY TO
EXECUTE ALL DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO THE PROPER
FUNCTIONING OF THE COUNTY DURING THE PERIOD COMMENCING
JUNE 21, 2017, THROUGH AND INCLUDING JULY 10, 2017.
WHEREAS, at the October 4, 2016 Board of County Commissioners meeting, the Board
canceled regularly scheduled Board meetings during the period commencing June 21, 2017, through
and including July 10, 2017;
WHEREAS, Section 101.05.1.q of The Code of Indian River County allows the Board to
authorize the County Administrator, or his designee, to perform other duties on behalf of the Board of
County Commissioners;
WHEREAS, various letters of credit are posted with the County to, among other things,
guaranty performance or warranty as well as compliance and restoration of sand mines, and many
letters of credit have certain call language requiring a resolution of the Board of County
Commissioners declaring default or failure to post alternate security;
WHEREAS, it is necessary to delegate specific authority to execute resolutions on behalf of
the Board of County Commissioners to call letters of credit;
WHEREAS, it is necessary to delegate additional signing authority, not previously delegated
by Florida Statutes, The Code of Indian River County, and Indian River County resolutions, to each
of the County Administrator or his designee; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2016-120 and section 101.10(1) of The Code of
Indian River County, the Board of County Commissioners previously delegated to the Indian River
County Administrator acting as Indian River County Emergency Services District Director, or his
designee, the authority: (i) to declare a state of local emergency for Indian River County pursuant to
Florida Statutes section 252.38(3)(a)(5); and (ii) pursuant to any duly issued Executive Order
concerning Emergency Management issued by the Governor of the State of Florida declaring that a
disaster and/or emergency [as such terms are defined in Florida Statutes section 252.34 (2) and (4)
P84
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
respectively] exists in Indian River County, to issue orders and rules, including, without limitation,
the ability to .issue Emergency Orders for Indian River County, during the period of the declared
emergency, and such delegation in Resolution No. 2016-120 remains in full force and effect; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2016-121, the Board of County Commissioners
previously delegated to the Indian River County Administrator or his designee, the authority to
execute resolutions on behalf of the Board to call letters of credit which might expire or otherwise
require action to be taken during the period of a declared state of local emergency or declared State of
Florida emergency affecting Indian River County, and .such delegation in Resolution No. 2016-121
remains in full force and effect.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The County Administrator, or his designee, is hereby delegated the authority to execute resolutions
on behalf of the Board of County Commissioners to call letters of credit which might expire or
otherwise require action to be taken during the period commencing June 21, 2017, through and
including July 10, 2017. Any resolutions executed by the County Administrator or his designee, to
call letters of credit during the period commencing June 21, 2017, through and including July 10,
2017, are to be accompanied by a copy of this Resolution.
2. The County Administrator, or his designee, is hereby authorized to execute all documents
necessary to the proper functioning of the County, which may arise during the period commencing
June 21, 2017, through and including July 10, 2017, provided that all such documents signed during
such interval are brought to the Board of County Commissioners for ratification.
3. The Effective Date of this Resolution is June 21, 2017, and this Resolution shall expire
without further action of this Board at the close of business on July 10, 2017.
This Resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote
was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
2
P85
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
The Chairman thereupon declared this Resolution duly passed and adopted this 20th day of
June, 2017:
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court
and Comptroller
M.
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
.legal sufficiency
By
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
3
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
P86
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, DELEGATING AUTHORITY TO THE
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE, TO EXECUTE
RESOLUTIONS CALLING LETTERS OF CREDIT AS NECESSARY
DURING THE PERIOD COMMENCING JULY 19, 2017, THROUGH AND
INCLUDING AUGUST 14, 2017, AND FURTHER DELEGATING TO THE
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE, THE AUTHORITY TO
EXECUTE ALL DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO THE PROPER
FUNCTIONING OF THE COUNTY DURING THE PERIOD COMMENCING
JULY 19, 2017, THROUGH AND INCLUDING AUGUST 14, 2017.
WHEREAS, at the October 4, 2016 Board of County Commissioners meeting, the Board
canceled regularly scheduled Board meetings during the period commencing July 19, 2017, through
and including August 14, 2017;
. WHEREAS, Section 101.05.1.q of The Code of Indian River County allows the Board to
authorize the County Administrator, or his designee, to perform other duties on behalf of the Board of
County Commissioners;
WHEREAS, various letters of credit are posted with the County to, among other things,
guaranty performance or warranty as well as compliance and restoration of sand mines, and many
letters of credit have certain call language requiring a resolution of the Board of County
Commissioners declaring default or failure to post alternate security;
WHEREAS, it is necessary to delegate .specific authority to execute resolutions on behalf of
the Board of County Commissioners to call letters of credit;
WHEREAS, it is necessary to delegate additional signing authority, not previously delegated
by Florida Statutes, The Code of Indian River County, and Indian River County resolutions, to each
of the County Administrator or his designee; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2016-120 and section 101.10(1) of The Code of
Indian River County, the Board of County Commissioners previously delegated to the Indian River
County Administrator acting as Indian River County Emergency Services District Director, or his
designee, the authority: (i) to declare a state of local emergency for Indian River County pursuant to
Florida Statutes section 252.38(3)(a)(5); and (ii) pursuant to any duly issued Executive Order
concerning Emergency Management issued by the Governor of the State of Florida declaring that a
disaster and/or emergency [as such terms are defined in Florida Statutes section 252.34 (2) and (4)
P87
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
respectively] exists in Indian River County, to issue orders and rules, including, without limitation,
the ability to issue Emergency Orders for Indian River County, during the period of the declared
emergency, and such delegation in Resolution No. 2016-120 remains in full force and effect; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2016-121, the Board of County Commissioners
previously delegated to the Indian River County Administrator or his designee, the authority to
execute resolutions on behalf of the Board to call letters of credit which might expire or otherwise
require action to be taken during the period of a declared state of local emergency or declared State of
Florida emergency affecting Indian River County, and such delegation in Resolution No. 2016-121
remains in full force and effect.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The County Administrator, or his designee, is hereby delegated the authority to execute resolutions
on behalf of the Board of County Commissioners to call letters of credit which might expire or
otherwise require action to be taken during the period commencing July 19, 2017, through and
including August 14, 2017. Any resolutions executed by the County Administrator or his designee, to
call letters of credit during the period commencing July 19, 2017, through and including August 14,
2017, are to be accompanied by a copy of this Resolution.
2. The County Administrator, or his designee, is hereby authorized to execute all documents
necessary to the proper functioning of the County, which may arise during the period commencing
July 19, 2017, through and including August 14, 2017, provided that all such documents signed
during such interval are brought to the Board of County Commissioners for ratification.
3. The Effective Date of this Resolution is July 19, 2017, and this Resolution shall expire
without further action.of this Board at the close of business on August 14, 2017.
This Resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote
was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
2
P88
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
The Chairman thereupon declared this Resolution duly passed and adopted this 20th day of
June, 2017.
Attest:. Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court
and Comptroller
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency
By
Dyl eingold, County Attorney
0
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
P89
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, DELEGATING AUTHORITY TO THE
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE, TO EXECUTE
RESOLUTIONS CALLING LETTERS OF CREDIT AS NECESSARY
DURING THE PERIOD COMMENCING AUGUST 16, 2017, THROUGH AND
INCLUDING SEPTEMBER 11, 2017, AND FURTHER DELEGATING TO
THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE, THE AUTHORITY
TO EXECUTE ALL DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO THE PROPER
FUNCTIONING OF THE COUNTY DURING THE PERIOD COMMENCING
AUGUST 16, 2017, THROUGH AND INCLUDING SEPTEMBER 11, 2017.
WHEREAS, at the October 4, 2016 Board of County Commissioners meeting, the Board
canceled regularly scheduled Board meetings during the period commencing August 16, 2017,
through and including September 11, 2017;
WHEREAS, Section 101.05.1.q of The Code of Indian River County allows the Board to
authorize the County Administrator, or his designee, to perform other duties on behalf of the Board of
County Commissioners;
WHEREAS, various letters of credit are posted with the County to, among other things,
guaranty performance or warranty as well as compliance and restoration of sand mines, and many
letters of credit have certain call language requiring a resolution of the Board of County
Commissioners declaring default or failure to post alternate security;
WHEREAS, it is necessary to delegate specific authority to execute resolutions on behalf of
the Board of County Commissioners to call letters of credit;
WHEREAS, it is necessary to delegate additional signing authority, not previously delegated
by Florida Statutes, The Code of Indian River County, and Indian River County resolutions, to each
of the County Administrator or his designee; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2016-120 and section 101.10(1) of The Code of
Indian River County, the Board of County Commissioners previously delegated to the Indian River
County Administrator acting as Indian River County Emergency Services District Director, or his
designee, the authority: (i) to declare a state of local emergency for Indian River County pursuant to
Florida Statutes section 252.38(3)(a)(5); and (ii) pursuant to any duly issued Executive Order
concerning Emergency Management issued by the Governor of the State of Florida declaring that a
disaster and/or emergency [as such terms are defined in Florida Statutes section 252.34 (2) and (4)
P90
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
respectively] exists in Indian River County, to issue orders and rules, including, without limitation,
the ability to issue Emergency Orders for Indian River County, during the period of the declared
emergency, and such delegation in Resolution No. 2016-120 remains in full force and effect; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2016-121, the Board of County Commissioners
previously delegated to the Indian River County Administrator or his designee, the authority to
execute resolutions on behalf of the Board to call letters of credit which might expire or otherwise
require action to be taken during the period of a declared state of local emergency or declared State of
Florida emergency affecting Indian River County, and such delegation in Resolution No. 2016-121
remains in full force and effect.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The County Administrator, or his designee, is hereby delegated the authority to execute resolutions
on behalf of the Board of County Commissioners to call letters of credit which might expire or
otherwise require action to be taken during the period commencing August 16, 2017, through and
including September 11, 2017. Any resolutions executed by the County Administrator or his
designee, to call letters of credit during the period commencing August 16, 2017, through and
including September 11, 2017, are to be accompanied by a copy of this Resolution.
2. The County Administrator, or his designee, is hereby authorized to execute all documents
necessary to the proper functioning of the County, which may arise during the period commencing
August 16, 2017, through and including September 11, 2017, provided that all such documents signed
during such interval are brought to the Board of County Commissioners for ratification.
3. The Effective Date of this Resolution is August 16, 2017, and this Resolution shall expire
without further action of this Board at the close of business on September 11, 2017.
This Resolution was moved for adoption, by Commissioner , and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote
was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
K
P91
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
The Chairman thereupon declared this Resolution duly passed and adopted this 20th day of
June, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court
and Comptroller
2
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency
By
Reingold, County Attorney
3
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
P92
ON
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
TO: Jason E. Brown; County Administrator
THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP; Community Development Director
Phil Matson, AICP; MPO Staff Director
FROM: Brian Freeman, AICP; Senior Transportation Planner
DATE: June 7, 2017
SUBJECT: Approval of Sublease with the Senior Resource Association for the Main Transit
Hub
It is requested that the information herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of
County Commissioners at its regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
DESCRIPTION & CONDITIONS
The Senior Resource Association (SRA) is Indian River County's Community Transportation
Coordinator (CTC) and public transportation operator. SRA operates the GoLine fixed -route
system which uses as its main transit hub the recently constructed facility located at 1225 16t'
Street, Vero Beach. That facility, which was built by the County on land that is leased from the
City of Vero Beach, was constructed with grant funding from the Federal Transit Administration
(FTA).
Because Indian River County is the recipient of federal grant funding for public transportation,
and because the facility is located on land owned by the City of Vero Beach and leased to the
County, the County is seeking at this time to enter into a formal sublease agreement with SRA for
the use of the Main Transit Hub (Attachment 1). In addition to clarifying roles and responsibilities
with respect to the use and operation of the Main Transit Hub, the attached sublease enables the
SRA to enter into agreements for necessary utility services, such as water and sewer, as the legal
tenant of the premises.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve the attached sublease and
authorize the Chairman to execute the lease.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Sublease with the Senior Resource Association for the Main Transit Hub
C.\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@30055684\@BCL@30055684.do"
P93
SUBLEASE AGREEMENT
THIS SUBLEASE AGREEMENT ("Sublease") by and between Indian River County,
Florida, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, whose address is 1800 27th Street,
Vero Beach, Florida ("County"), and Senior Resource Association, Inc., a Florida non-profit
corporation, formerly known as Council on Aging, Inc., whose address is 694 14th Street,
Vero Beach, FL 32960 ("SRA"), shall take effect as of July 1, 2017 ("Effective Date").
BACKGROUND RECITALS:
A. The Senior Resource Association is the Community Transportation Coordinator
(CTC) and Transit Service Provider for Indian River County. The SRA operates a fixed
route bus system serving the citizens of Indian River County utilizing over 50 buses. Most
of the buses operated by the SRA are titled to Indian River County as the owner of the
vehicles. The operation of the buses for the citizens of Indian River County serves a
valuable public purpose; and
B. The SRA's transit system, the GoLine, has steadily increased in ridership,
popularity and size, necessitating construction of a main transit hub facility to
accommodate passengers and the buses for the various routes; and
C. Effective April 16, 2013, the City of Vero Beach and the County entered into a
ground Lease Agreement ("Ground Lease") to provide for a site for the construction of a
main transit hub facility on 1.6 acres of City owned land located at1225 16th Street, Vera
Beach, FL whose legal description is attached as Exhibit A, and incorporated by reference
herein.
. D. Construction of the Indian River Transit Main Hub ("Main Hub") is now complete.
The Main Hub includes a 1,000 square foot building, parking lot, covered walk ways,
covered waiting area and restrooms. The Main Hub was built using grant funds and will
continue to be considered a County owned improvement on City owned property.
E. The County and SRA now desire to enter into a Sublease Agreement with a five
year term that will allow the SRA to utilize the Main Hub for passenger operations; and
F. Pursuant to Florida Statues Section 125.38, the County has the ability to set a
nominal rent regardless of the actual value of the property so long as the price of the rent
shall be set forth in a resolution of the Board of County Commissioners.
NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and
sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, and intending to be legally bound hereby, the
parties hereby agree as follows:
1. Recitals. The above recitals are true and incorporated as a part of this document
by reference herein.
2. Property, Rent and Term. The County hereby Subleases to the SRA, and the
SRA hereby Subleases from County, the property and any improvements thereon
P94
including the Main Hub, located at the 1225 16th Street, Vero Beach, FL and more
specifically described on Exhibit "A", attached hereto and made a part hereof. The
Sublease shall be for a term of five (5) years commencing June 1, 2017 and terminating on
May 31, 2022. The rent payable by the SRA during the term shall be five dollars ($5.00).
Said amounts shall be payable annually, in advance, in the amount of one dollar ($1.00)
per year. The SRA shall be responsible for any sales tax, use tax, ad valorem tax, non -ad
valorem taxes, tangible property tax, and intangibles sales tax that may arise from this
Sublease or the Main Hub.
3.1 Review of Sublease. Approximately ninety (90) days prior to the expiration of
this Sublease, the parties shall meet to discuss extension of this Sublease and any other
changes deemed necessary by either party.
4. Property Subleased "AS IS". The SRA agrees that the Main Hub is being
Subleased "as is" and that the County makes no representation, warranty or guarantee of
the condition of the Main Hub or any of the improvements thereon. The SRA has
examined the Main Hub and has determined that it is suitable for the SRA's purposes.
SRA may use the Main Hub for the purposes relating to operation of the bus service.
5. Maintenance and Repairs. The SRA shall repair and maintain the Main Hub and
keep the area, including the interior and outdoor waiting areas, in a safe, clean and
attractive condition. The County shall mow the lawns and maintain the landscaping, trees
and shrubbery at the Main Hub. The County shall maintain the automobile and bus
parking areas, driveways and the exterior of the building in a safe, clean and attractive
condition. The County shall maintain the generator at the Main Hub through its existing
generator maintenance/service contractor. Upon expiration of the Sublease, the SRA shall
surrender the Main Hub quietly and peaceably in substantially the same condition as it was
in at the start of the Sublease, reasonable wear and tear excepted. SRA shall notify
County of any structural or non-structural repairs, or alterations made to the Main Hub so
County may keep an accurate history concerning the building.
6. Installation and Removal of Equipment and Personal Property. The SRA shall
have the right to install such equipment, fixtures and other items necessary or convenient
for its use of the Main Hub. All equipment and personal property purchased by the SRA
and placed in, on, or about the Main Hub, including equipment not affixed to the realty,
shall remain the property of the SRA. The SRA may remove such equipment and personal
property on or before the termination of the Sublease, provided that if such removal results
in damage to any part of the Main Hub, the SRA shall repair such damage prior to
termination of the Sublease. Any of the SRA's equipment or personal property not
attached or installed in any building or structure shall remain the SRA's property and may
be removed on or prior to termination of the Sublease.
7. Public Utilities. The SRA will pay, within time allowed for payment without
penalties, all charges for water, sewer, electricity and garbage collection and all other
public utilities which may arise from the SRA's use of the Main Hub. SRA shall also be
responsible for payment of any pest control expenses.
P95
8. , Improvements or Alterations to the Main Hub. SRA shall make any
necessary improvements or alterations to the Main Hub in order to accommodate the safe
operation of the system at SRA's sole expense. Any such improvements or alterations
shall be subject to County's prior written approval. County expressly reserves the right to
review and approve or disapprove of any construction plans prior to application for any
building permit. All such improvements or alterations shall comply with any and all
applicable governmental laws, regulations, rules, and orders, shall follow standard
construction methods and shall be constructed in accordance with the plans and
specifications approved by the County. County, at County's sole discretion, may require
SRA to have any alteration, improvement or construction secured with surety bonds or
such other security approved by County. SRA shall maintain such improvements or
alteration as may be required by County. Any and all improvements or alterations made
by the SRA to the Main Hub shall become the property of the County at the time of
expiration or sooner termination of this Sublease.
9. Use in Declared Emergency. During any federally, State of Florida, or locally
declared disaster or other emergency, the County reserves the right to have the full and
exclusive use of the Main Hub for as long as reasonably necessary as the County, in its
sole discretion, acting as the Indian River County Emergency Services District, shall
determine, for any and all appropriate governmental purposes in connection with such
declared disaster or other emergency.
10. Insurance. During the term of this Sublease the Main Hub shall be insured by
the County. The insurance required is commercial general liability insurance with a
reputable insurance company authorized to issue insurance policies in the State of Florida,
subject to approval by the County's Risk Manager, in an amount not less than $1,000,000
combined single limit for bodily injury and property damage, including coverage for
premises/operations, products/completed operations, contractual liability, and independent
contractors, in accordance with County's Administrative Policy Manual. The commercial
general liability policy shall name Indian River County, a political subdivision of the State of
Florida as the insured party and the Senior Resource Association, Inc., shall be named as
an additional insured. County shall calculate the cost of the insurance on an annual basis
and bill SRA monthly for one twelfth of the cost of the annual insurance coverage. SRA
shall remit payment within 15 days of receipt. Failure to pay County for insurance
coverage shall be deemed a default of this Sublease.
11. Indemnity SRA shall indemnify and hold harmless the County, and its
commissioners, officers, employees and agents, from and against any and all claims,
damages, liabilities, costs (including attorney's fees), third party claims, judgments, and
expenses to persons or property that may arise, directly or indirectly, from any negligent,
reckless, or intentional act or omission of SRA, or of SRA's officers, employees or agents,
in the operation of the Main Hub, or otherwise in connection with this Sublease.
12. Repair for Damage. SRA shall repair, cause the repair, or reimburse the County
for the repair of, any damage to County's property caused by SRA or SRA's employees,
guests, invitees, licensees, or permittees.
P96
13. Compliance with Laws. SRA shall comply with all of the laws, rules, ordinances,
and regulations of the County, State and Federal Governments, and agencies regarding
the use of the Main Hub. Violation of any law, rule, ordinance or regulation may result in
immediate termination of this Sublease.
14. Default. In addition to the rights granted under paragraph 13 of this Sublease,
County shall have the right to terminate this Sublease upon the occurrence of any of the
following (each an "Event of Default"): 1) Loss of non-profit corporation status by SRA; 2)
Abandonment by SRA of the Main Hub; 3) Default of, non-performance of, or other non-
compliance with, any term, covenant or condition of any nature whatsoever under this
Sublease to be performed by SRA; or 4) Failure to pay when due any rent, insurance cost
reimbursement, or any other expense which could result in a lien being placed upon the
Main Hub. Upon the occurrence of an Event of Default, the County shall send a written
notice to SRA, in the manner set forth in this Sublease, setting forth the Event of Default in
specific detail and the date this Sublease shall terminate in the event SRA does not cure
the default. Within thirty (30) days following receipt of a default notice, SRA shall have
cured the default to the reasonable satisfaction of County. In the event SRA fails to cure
the Event of Default within thirty (30) days, this Sublease shall be deemed to be terminated
with no further action by the County, other than providing final written notice to the
defaulting party that the Event of Default has not been cured and that the Sublease is
terminated.
15. Vacatinq Main Hub. The SRA is the Transit Service Provider ("TSP") for Indian
River County. Should the SRA cease acting as the TSP for the County, then this Sublease
shall terminate. In the event of this Sublease terminating due to the SRA ceasing to act as
the TSP for Indian River County, SRA shall have 90 days to vacate the Main Hub. During
this period, SRA understands that another community transportation coordinator may have
to use the Main Hub and SRA agrees not to interfere with the new TSP's activities.
16. Assignments or Encumbrances. SRA shall not, in any manner, assign, transfer,
mortgage, pledge, encumber, or otherwise convey an interest in this Sublease, or sublet
the Main Hub or any part thereof (any one of the foregoing events hereinafter referenced
as an "Assignment"), without the prior written consent of County which consent may be
granted, conditioned, or withheld at County's sole discretion for any reason. Any such
attempted Assignment without County approval shall be null and void.
17. Attorney's Fees and Costs. In the event there arises any dispute or litigation over
the terms and conditions of this Sublease, each party shall bear its own attorney's fees,
costs, and expenses to resolve that dispute.
18. Notices. Any notices which are required, or which either party may desire to serve
upon the other parties, shall be in writing and shall be deemed served when hand
delivered, or when actually received via U.S. Mail, postage prepaid, return receipt
requested, addressed to the parties at:
SRA: Senior Resource Association, Inc. County: Indian River County
Attn: Karen Deigl Attn: County Administrator
694 14th Street 1801 27th Street
P97
Vero Beach, FL 32960
Vero Beach, FL 32960
These addresses may be changed by any party by providing written notification to the
other parties.
19. Right of Quiet Enioyment. If and so long as SRA performs all of its obligations
under this Sublease, County covenants that SRA shall and may quietly hold and enjoy the
Main Hub, subject to any provisions of this Sublease, applicable laws, ordinances, and
governmental regulations, and to any governmental actions, and to any taking under the
power of eminent domain.
20. Inspection. The County may enter and inspect the Main Hub with reasonable
notice at all reasonable hours to insure the Main Hub is being properly maintained and
kept in good condition.
21. Jurisdiction. This Sublease shall be governed by the laws of the State of Florida
and any and all legal action instituted because of this Sublease shall be instituted in Indian
River County.
22. Waiver of Strict Compliance. Each right, power and remedy of the County and
SRA provided for in this Sublease shall be cumulative and concurrent and shall be in
addition to every other right, power or remedy provided for in this Sublease or now or
hereafter existing at law or in equity or by statute or otherwise. The failure of either party
to insist upon compliance by the other party with any obligation, or exercise any remedy,
does not waive the right to so in the event of a continuing or subsequent delinquency or
default. A party's waiver of one or more defaults does not constitute a waiver of any other
delinquency or default. County's acceptance of rent does not waive any uncured
delinquency or default by SRA.
23. Prior Agreements. This Sublease incorporates and includes all prior and
contemporaneous negotiations, correspondence, conversations, agreements or
understandings applicable to the matters contained herein and the parties agree that there
are no commitments, agreements, or understandings of any nature whatsoever concerning
the subject matter of the Sublease that are not contained in this document. Accordingly, it
is agreed that no deviation from the terms hereof shall be predicated upon any prior or
contemporaneous representations or agreements, whether oral or written.
24. Severability. If any term, covenant or provision of this Sublease, or the application
thereof to any person or circumstances shall, to any extent, be held invalid or
unenforceable for the remainder of this Sublease, then the application of such terms or
provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid or
unenforceable shall not be affected, and each and every other term and provision of this
Sublease shall be deemed valid and enforceable to the fullest extent permitted by law.
25. Execution. This Sublease may be executed in one or more counterparts, each of
which shall be deemed to be an original copy and all of which shall constitute but one and
the same instrument.
P98
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Sublease to be
executed by their respective duly authorized representatives as of the date first set forth
above.
SENIOR RESOURCE ASSOCIATION, INC
By:
Karen Deigl, President/CEO of the
Senior Resource Association, Inc.
Date Approved:
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
William K. DeBraal
Deputy County Attorney
6
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Board of County Commissioners
By:
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman,
Board of County Commissioners
Date Approved:
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith
Clerk of Court and Comptroller
By:
Deputy Clerk
Approved:
By
Jason E. Brown
County Administrator
P99
8F
CONSENT
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO:
Jason Brown
Holiday
County Administrator
FROM:
Suzanne Boyll
Martin Luther King Jr. Day
Human Resources Director
DATE:
June 12, 2017
SUBJECT:
2018 Holiday Schedule
For consideration by the Board of County Commissioners, the following is the proposed
schedule of holidays for Indian River County employees for 2018:
Holiday
County Observance
New Year's Day
Monday, January 1, 2018
Martin Luther King Jr. Day
Monday, January 15, 2018
Good Friday
Friday, March 30, 2018
Memorial Day
Monday, May 28, 2018
Independence Day
Wednesday, July 4, 2018
Labor Day
Monday, September 3, 2018
Veterans Day
Monday, November 12, 2018
Thanksgiving Day
Thursday, November 22, 2018
Day after Thanksgiving
Friday, November 23, 2018
Christmas Eve
Monday, December 24, 2018
Christmas Day
Tuesday, December 25, 2018
New Year's Day
Tuesday, January 1, 2019
P100
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
Date: June 6, 2017
To: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
From: Vincent Burke, P.E., Director of Utility Services
Prepared By: John M. Boyer, P.E., Utilities Engineer
Subject: Approval of Work Authorization No. 2017-007 to Replace Water Services in "Oaks
of Vero" Subdivision
DESCRIPTIONS AND CONDITIONS:
The water distribution system in the "Oaks of Vero" community was constructed with the subdivision's land
development improvements during year 2006 and turned over to the Indian River County Department of
Utilities Services (IRCDUS). The construction of residential homes in the subject community stalled during
the recession; however, development is once again progressing as the economy recovers. As a result, IRCDUS
staff have been responding to requests for water meters and are finding some meter boxes to be missing
and the related service pipe to be unserviceable. In order to support the development of the community,
IRCDUS will need to replace the missing meter boxes and unserviceable piping.
ANALYSIS:
The most efficient and timely method to replace the water services in the subject community is to utilize the
IRCDUS labor contractor, Blue Goose Construction. A list of the anticipated labor and material quantities was
prepared and bid prices from the labor contract was used to calculate the labor expense. The total cost of
material was based on unit prices derived from the Annual Contract for Utility Warehouse Stock.
Construction cost breaks down as follows (see Attachment 1):
1. Labor Expense: $ 14,157.00
2. Materials: $ 10,342.20
Total Construction Cost: $ 24,499.20
FUNDING:
Funding for this project is derived from the R&R budget in the Operating fund. The Operating fund budget is
derived from water and sewer sales.
ACCOUNT NAME ==ACCOUNT NUMBER AMOUNT
Oaks of Vero Water Service Replacement 1 47123536-044699-17528 $ 24,499.20
P101
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) approve Work Authorization No. 2017-
007 authorizing Blue Goose Construction to replace the water services in the Oaks of Vero community for
the labor amount of $14,157.00, and also requests that the BCC authorize the direct purchase of.materials
totaling $10,342.20.
ATTACH M ENT(s):
1. Cost Estimate— Labor & Material
2. Work Authorization No. 2017-007
C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Tech nologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@500545C2\@BCL@500545C2.docx
P102
Indian River County Department of Utilities Services
ATTACHMENT 1- LABOR AND MATERIAL COST
Project: Oaks at Vero - WATER SERVICE INSTALLATION
Date: June 6, 2017
TOTAL PROJECT COST $24,499.20
P103
LABOR COSTS
MATERIAL COSTS (IRC Direct
Purchase)
Bid
Bid Item
Estimated
Unit of
Labor Unit
Total Labor
Material Unit
Total Material
Item No.
Description
Quantity
Measure
Price
Price
Price
Price
18g
Install Water Service Single Long (Close Corp, and Set &
Connect Meter Box Only)
11
EA.
$425.00
$4,675.00
$228.00
$2,508.00
18)
Install Water Service Double Long (Close Corp, Install 1"
PE, Set & Conned Meter Boxes Only)
12
EA.
$425.00
$5,100.00
$487.00
$5,844.00
23
Test Holes / Potholes
5
EA.
$250.00
$1,250.00
$0.00
80a
Install 4" Sidewalk
300
SF
$2.25
$675.00
$3.50
$1,050.00
91
Mobilization, Demobilization, MOT (based on 10% of
Labor):
1
LS
$1,170.00
$1,170.00
Subtotals:
Labor:
$12,870.00
Material:
$9,402.00
Contingency:
10%
$1,287.00
10%
$940.20
Totals:
Labor Cost $14,157.00
Materials $10,342.20
TOTAL PROJECT COST $24,499.20
P103
WORK AUTHORIZATION DIRECTIVE
No. 2017-007
Pelican Pointe Water Service Lateral Replacement
BLUE GOOSE CONSTRUCTION
DATE OF ISSUANCE: June 6, 2017
ATTACHMENT 2
EFFECTIVE DATE: June 20, 2017
OWNER: Indian River County
CONTRACTOR: Blue Goose Construction
CONTRACT: WATER, SEWER AND RECLAIM WATER LINE.REPLACEMENT / EXTENSIONS
AND MISCELLANEOUS LABOR CONTRACT, BID NO. 2015001, AWARDED September 9, 2014
PROJECT: Oaks of Vero Water Service Replacement
COUNTY UTILITY PROJECT NO.: UCP #NIA CONTRACTOR'S PROJECT NO.: N/A
COUNTY WIP. No. 47123536-044699-017528
You are directed to proceed promptly with the following work:
Description: Replace water meter boxes and service lateral piping.
Attachments: Attachment 1
Method of determining Contract Price:
❑ Unit Prices: Bid Items as established pursuant to Bid No. 2015001, and awarded by the Board of
County Commissioners on September 9, 2014 to Blue Goose Construction, Inc.
❑ Lump Sum
0 Cost of the Work
The Cost of Labor, Contingency and Contract Time is summarized below:
Labor Cost (rounded) _
$14;_581.71
Estimated
90 days from NTP
Contract Time:
ACCE
By:
Blue Goose Construction
Labor Con acto/
Date: l
RECOMMENDED:
By: / �.�
John M. Boy, , P.E.
Utilitties Engineer
Date:
APPROVED:
By:
COUNTY, CHAIRMAN
Joseph E. Flescher
Date:
F:Wtlllties\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects -Utility Construction Permlts\IRC - Oaks of Vero WS Replacement\Admin\Agenda Item\Work
Authorization No. 2017-007.doc
P104
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
AGENDA ITEM
Assistant County Administrator /
Department of General Services
yal
CONSENT AGENDA
Date: June 12, 2017
To: The Honorable Board of County Commissioners
Thru: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
Thru: Michael C. Zito, Assistant County Administrator
From: Brad Bernauer, Director Human Services
Subject: Approval of Children's Service Advisory Committee's Funding Allocations for
FY 2017-2018
It is requested that the information herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of
County Commission at its regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
DESCRIPTIONS AND CONDITIONS:
The Children Services Advisory Committee (CSAC) received 38 program responses to RFP
#2017044. The total amount originally requested by the agencies applying was $2,244,368. The
CSAC Grant Review Committee met for three days, June 8th , 9th. and on June 10th they determined
a final recommendation for funding for the 2017-18 fiscal year.
The Children's Service Advisory Committee met on June 12th and voted to approve the attached
funding recommendations totaling $1,607,965 to those agencies listed.
FUNDING:
Account Description Account Number Budget Amount
Children's Services — Outside Agencies 00112869-088*** 1$1,607,965
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff respectfully recommends approval of the CSAC's funding recommendation for 2017-2018.
ATTACHMENT(s):
Children's Service Advisory Allocation Spreadsheet
CAUsers\GRANIC-1 \AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@B8059EF ] \@13CL@138059EF1.doc
P105
Total Available Budgeted Fundin 1,051,965 $7,607,665.00 44.8% 15.5%f 27 5M 124%
Over (under) CSAC Funded $0.00 1,607,985
Priorities $636,403.00
Early Childhood Development
Build Parent Capacity
Out of School Recreational Activities and Enrichment Programs
Middle and High School Programs That Address Risky Behavior
N
• •- ••^••• ••�•••_
201
,vwaroeA
2013.14
roved
2014-15
Awarded
Match
Total
Awarded
Re uested
Recommended
Priorities
Bi Bro 8 BI Sis of IRC
Pass ort to Litarac
2015.16
2015-2016
2015 2016
2016.17
21117-18
2017-18
1
2
3
COP Children of Promise
15,000.00
15,000.00
24,994.00
15,000.00
25,000.00
49,894.00
50,000
85 T55
585,000.80
85,000
4
Bo & Gids Club of IRC
Sebastian Branch
10,080.00
10,000.00
30,000.00
15,000.00
15,000
2 380
515,000.00
0g ppp
Castle
H' h H s
-
30.000.40
30,OOtl
30,000
530,000.00
30,000
Safe Families
Strep thenin Families
56,402.00
50,000.00
35,000.00
35,000.00
7tl,000,00
70,000
80000
520,000.00
$Sq 000.00
80,000
20,000
20000
30,000.00
Catholic Charities -Samaritan Samarlan Center 30.000.00 49,065 28,008 520000.00
26,000.00 26,000.00
Child Care Resources of IRC
Conscious Disc) line
27,700.08
27,700.00
29,008
29 000
529 000.00
52960
24,300
6600
190,000
29.000
Professional Develo merit -Educators 52868 552960.00
Ps 5
jai Services ,925. 5,516.00 21,150.00 21150.00 24,300 42828 524300.00
00 5,V25.00
5,925.00 5925.00
nt600 6600 $6,600.00
Children in Ceers 170,000.00 170,000.00 17
6, 170000.00 170,000 200,000
Children's Home SociMt Teen Life Chokes 5790,00.00
15, 000.00 15,000.00 30.000.00
Crossover Mission Crossover Mission - 30,000 50.00
$
Dasie Ho a Cerner
Dais H Ce
Center Tutorial Pro ram
25,000.00
20,440.00
19,000.08
30,000.00
25,000.00
44,000,00
45,000
65 800
550 000.00
50 000
Education FoundationSte
frdo Ki Or anon
107,534.00
30060.00
35,008
45,000
Edo 000.00
40,000
Economic O ortundiesCou
Ear Bird - Dotl ertown
_
15,8511,00
123,384.00
130,000
160,000
5156655.00
156,655
EaBird - Indian River Adadem
TS.p�
510,000.00
10,000
Feed The Lambs
FTLABerschool & Summer
20,000
$20,000.00
20000
GMAC
Fam i Guidance/After Schoot Pro ram
28,150.00
28,158.00
30,000.0010,000
47,004
$10'000.06
10,000
Health Start of IRC
PaMers in Pre pan /Bel Beatifu!
5.000.00
6,000.00
30,000.00
6,040.00
35,000
6,000
37,450
$37 450. 00
37 450
Babies and B And $0.00
Doula Services
50,000
530 Ann A.
30,000
30,000
Parents As Teachers 87,064 530 800.00
Givin Kiz A Chance Health Families 30,000.00 10,000.00 40 000.00 30,000 30 000 530 000.00
TLC
-
10.000.00
00,000.00
20,tltl0.40
15,400.00
35,000.00
28.000
30,004
$30 arm tin
30 800
30,000
Hibiscus Children's Cemar
Career Pathwa s to Inds endence
10,000 00
10,000.00
12,000.00
12,000.00
12,000
-
50.00
Thr He a for families Canter
Life St P ram
20,500.00
19,500,00
20600
x-00
The Leami Alliance
Moonshot Academ
67 822
$4,00
ORCA
Moons hot Moment ReadiA Rocket
Livin
20,000.00
15,000,00
21,596.00
23,000.40
44,596.00
40,000
I'm Ann
5100800.00
100,000
La oon
540000.00
40000
Pekcan Island Audubon Soc,
Overcomi Natuna -Deficit Disorder
Al 570
E3o 000.00
30,000
R.C.M.A
Childcare Infant/Toddler
24,689 00
20,000.00
20,000.00
20,000.00
20,000
24,303
520 000.00
20 000
CCEP Match
TS,SpO
;39,000.00
39,000
Strivin 4 Success
STEM Club
75,500
$40000.00
40,000
Substance Abuse Council
Lite Skiffs-
67.216.00
67,216.00
67,206.00
5.000.00
72216.00
10,000
zu.Vou
;15 000.00
1 S 004
Sunshine Ph 'cal Ther
Retlired Pro ram ht Choice
Ea Tnera
080,008.00
100 000.00
100,000,00
100 00000
80,000
100,000
100,000
130,000
5100 000.00
100 000
T kes and Teens
en
imervemion
Infant Mental Hearth
38,000
5100,800.00
530,000.00
30,000
100 000
Wd6s ort Assoc.
Dod er's Baseba9 Pr ram
62,000
;62,000.00
62,000
Youth Guidance
Mentoring&Activtties
7,500.00
61000.00
15,000.0010.0
29.000
315000.00
15000
15000.00
15,000
30,980
.520,000.00
20,000
Gifford Youth Orchestra
Gifford Youth Omhestm
10,000.00
10 000.00
10,000
TOTAL
586,390.00
586390.00
841,965.00
190,000.00
7,031965.00
1,051,965
2244,368
$1,607,965.00
716,515
249,000
442,450
200.000
Total Available Budgeted Fundin 1,051,965 $7,607,665.00 44.8% 15.5%f 27 5M 124%
Over (under) CSAC Funded $0.00 1,607,985
Priorities $636,403.00
Early Childhood Development
Build Parent Capacity
Out of School Recreational Activities and Enrichment Programs
Middle and High School Programs That Address Risky Behavior
N
Consent Agenda
Indian River County
Interoffice Memorandum
Office of Management & Budget
To: Members of the Board of County Commissioners
From: Michael Smykowski
Director, Office of Management & Budget
Date: June 13, 2017
Subject: Miscellaneous Budget Amendment 018
Description and Conditions
1. On June 13, 2017, the Board of County Commissioners approved a building analysis of the
Roseland Community Building. Exhibit "A" appropriates $8,300 from General Fund/Reserve
for Contingency.
P107
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE FISCAL YEAR 2016-2017 BUDGET.
WHEREAS, certain appropriation and expenditure amendments to the
adopted Fiscal Year 2016-2017 Budget are to be made by resolution pursuant to
section 129.06(2), Florida Statutes; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County
desires to amend the fiscal year 2016-2017 budget, as more specifically set forth
in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and by this reference made a part hereof,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Fiscal Year
2016-2017 Budget be and hereby is amended as set forth in Exhibit "A" upon
adoption of this Resolution.
This Resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner
, and the motion was seconded by Commissioner ,
and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Chairman, Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman, Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner, Susan Adams
Commissioner, Bob Solari
Commissioner, Tim Zorc
The Chairman thereupon declared this Resolution duly passed and adopted
this day of , 2017.
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith
Clerk of Court and Comptroller
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Board of County Commissioners
By
Deputy Clerk Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
BY
APPROVED AS TO FORM
AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY
COUNTY ATTORNEY
P108
Resolution No. 2017 -
Budget Office Approval:
Exhibit "A"
Michael Smykowski, Budget Director
Budget Amendment: 018
Entry
Number
Fund/ Department/Account Name
Account Number
Increase
Decrease
1.
Expense
General Fund/Facilities Maintenance/Other Professional
Services
00122019-033190
$8,300
$0
General Fund/Reserves/Reserve for Contingency
00119981-099910
$0
$8,300
1 of 1
P109
CONSENT
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
PURCHASING DIVISION
DATE: June 13, 2017
TO: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
THROUGH: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
Mike Smykowski, Director, Office of Management and Budget
FROM: Jennifer Hyde, Purchasing Manager
SUBJECT: . Approval of Sealed Bid Sale of 2625 54th Avenue — Bid 2017059
BACKGROUND:
November 10, 2015, the Board authorized the purchase of. 2625 54th Avenue to acquire right-of-way
necessary for planned widening of 26th Street, as well as the subsequent sealed bid sale of the remaining
parcel, including a single family residence, once the right-of-way take was completed.
In accordance with F.S. 125.35, advertisements announcing the sale appeared on May 25 and June 1, 2017.
An open house was held to enable prospective buyers to examine the house. Six sealed bids were received
and publicly opened on June 13, 2017 at 2:00 P.M. in the amounts of $155,750.00, 150,100.00, 145,000.00,
125,000.00, 124,300.00 and $85,000.00.
Funds in the amount of $233,000.00 were deducted from Traffic Impact Fees/District II/ROW 26th
Street, 43rd Ave to 66th Ave account #10215241-066120-06011 to acquire the parcel, and proceeds
from this sale will be returned to the Traffic Impact Fees/District II Fund.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners ratify and accept the high bid of $155,750.00
submitted by the Carlson Family LLC and Michael Peters. Staff further recommends the Board approve the
Agreement to Purchase and Sell Real Estate and authorize the Chairman to execute the agreement. Finally,
staff recommends the Board authorize the County Attorney's staff to prepare and execute any other
necessary documents to complete the sale.
ATTACHMENTS:
Agreement to Purchase and Sell Real Estate
Pilo
AGREEMENT TO PURCHASE AND SELL REAL'ESTATE
THIS AGREEMENT TO PURCHASE AND SELL REAL ESTATE ("Agreement") is
made and entered into as of June 12 , 2017, by and between Indian River County,
("County"), a political subdivision of the State of Florida, whose address is 1801 271' Street,
Vero Beach, FL 32960; and r\sc,n ii:4"zI . LLG � M. J14 c -S
(b yer's full name)
2tc3 st,.�n�_se b\�a, F'�.P,:�ct.P C= L-
(buyer's address) (city) (state)
("Buyers"), who agree as follows:
1. Agreement to Purchase -and Sell. The County hereby agrees to sell to the Buyers,
and the Buyers hereby agrees to purchase from County, upon the terms and conditions set
forth in this Agreement, that certain parcel of real property located at 2625 54th Avenue
Vero.Beach, FL 32966 and more specifically described on Exhibit "A" attached hereto and
incorporated by reference, containing approximately 0.42 acres, and all improvements
thereon, together with all easements, rights and uses now or hereafter belonging thereto
(collectively, the "Property').
2. Purchase Price, Effective Date. The purchase price (the "Purchase Price") for the
Property shall be ! -#A M&a tF. . _.1','ti . j ?A,. -reve.,:,,,,(,,,�. ,, 00/00 Dollars
(written purchase pri )
($1550 75o .00). The Buyer has paid and the County acknowledges receipt of a
cashier's ch ck in the amount of ten perc nt (10%) of the purchase price or
0/00 Dollars($ 155.'75L) .00).
(written purchase price)
that is currently being held in escrow by the County (Escrowed Funds). The balance of the
Purchase Price shall be paid on the Closing Date. The Effective Date of this Agreement
shall be the date upon which the County approves the execution of this Agreement, either
by approval by the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners at a formal
meeting of such Board or by the County Administrator pursuant to his delegated authority.
3. Title. County shall convey marketable title to the Property by County Deed free of
claims, liens, easements and encumbrances of record or known to County; but subject to
property taxes for the year of Closing and covenants, restrictions and public utility
easements of record provided (a) there exists at Closing no violation of any of the
foregoing; and (b) none of the foregoing prevents Buyer's intended use and development
of the Property ("Permitted Exceptions").
4. Representations of the County.
4.1 County is indefeasibly seized of marketable, fee simple title to the Property, and is
the sole owner of and has good right, title, and authority to convey and transfer the
Property which is the subject matter of this Agreement, free and clear of all liens and
encumbrances.
P111
4.2 From and after the Effective Date of this Agreement, County shall take no action
which would impair or otherwise affect title to any portion of the Property, and shall record
no documents in the Public Records which would affect title to the Property, without the
prior written consent of the Buyers.
4.3 There are no existing or pending special assessments affecting the Property, which
are or may be assessed by any governmental authority, water or sewer authority, school
district, drainage district or any other special taxing district.
5. Default.
5.1 In the event the Buyers shall fail to perform any of its obligations hereunder, the
County shall, at its sole option, be entitled to: (i) terminate this Agreement by written notice
delivered to the Buyers at or prior to the Closing Date and thereupon retain the Escrowed
Funds as liquidated damages. Neither the County nor any other person or party shall have
any claim for specific performance, damages, or otherwise against the Buyers; or (ii) waive
the Buyer's default and proceed to Closing.
5.2 In the event the County shall fail to perform any of its obligations hereunder, the
Buyers shall, at its sole option, be entitled to terminate this Agreement by written notice
delivered to the County at or prior to the Closing Date and thereupon neither the Buyers
nor any other person or party shall have any claim for specific performance, damages or
otherwise against the County; or (ii) waive the County's default and proceed to Closing.
6. Closing.
6.1 The closing of the transaction contemplated herein ("Closing" and "Closing Date")
shall take place within 30 days following the Effective Date of this Agreement. The parties
agree that the Closing shall be as follows:
(a) The County shall execute and deliver to the Buyers a County Deed conveying
marketable title to the Property, free and clear of all liens and encumbrances and in the
condition required by paragraph 3.
(b) The County shall have removed all of its personal property and equipmentfrom the
Property and the County shall deliver possession of the Property to Buyers vacant and in
the same or better condition that existed at the Effective Date hereof.
(c) If County is obligated to discharge any encumbrances at or prior to Closing and fails
to do so, Buyers may use a portion of Purchase Price funds to satisfy the encumbrances.
(d) The County and the Buyers shall each deliver to the other such other documents or
instruments as may reasonably be required to close this transaction.
•z -
P112
7. Closing Costs: Expenses. Buyers shall be responsible for preparation of all Closing
documents.
7.1 Buyers shall pay the following expenses at Closing:
7.1.1 The cost of recording the warranty deed and any release or satisfaction
obtained by County pursuant to this Agreement.
7.1.2 Documentary Stamps required to be affixed to the warranty deed.
7.1.3 All costs and premiums for the owners marketability title insurance
commitment and policy, if any.
7.1.4 Current taxes which are not yet due and payable
7.2 County shall pay the following expenses at or prior to Closing:
7.2.1 All costs necessary to cure title defect(s) or encumbrances, other than the
Permitted Exceptions, and to satisfy or release of record all existing mortgages, liens or
encumbrances upon the Property.
8. Miscellaneous.
8.1 Controlling Law. This Agreement shall be construed and enforced in accordance
with the laws of the State of Florida. Venue shall be in Indian River Buyers for all state
court matters, and in the Southern District of Florida for all federal court matters.
8.2 Entire Agreement, This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the
parties with respect to this transaction and supersedes all prior agreements, written or
oral, between the County and the Buyers relating to the subject matter hereof. Any
modification or amendment to this Agreement shall be effective only if in writing and
executed by each of the parties.
8.3 Assignment and Binding Effect. Neither Buyers nor County may assign its rights
and obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other party.
The terms hereof shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the parties hereto
and their successors and assigns.
8.4 Notices. Any notice shall be deemed duly served if personally served or if mailed by
certified mail, return receipt requested, or if sent via "overnight" courier service or facsimile
transmission, as follows:
If to Buyers: buyer's full name: Carle tcl,. I pKe's
.,vo m & m - 14 h -
Address: -2tca 5e, UJ.
City, State, Zip: VMA.,Ne rr, rL J�ft 50
-3 -
P113
Phone: —772-575-SOM9
Email: yhav►a.�c-�cp�lsb►. w.�1..2�t..C.corv,
If to County: Indian River County Attorney's Office
1801 27th Street
Vero Beach, FL. 32960
Phone: 772-226-1426
bdebraal@ircgov.com
Either party may change the information above by giving written notice of such change as
provided in this paragraph.
8.5 Survival and Benefit. Except as otherwise expressly provided herein, each
agreement, representation or warranty made in this Agreement by or on behalf of either
party, or in any instruments delivered pursuant hereto or in connection herewith, shall
survive the Closing Date and the consummation of the transaction provided for herein.
The covenants, agreements and undertakings of each of the parties hereto are made
solely for the benefit of, and may be relied on only by the other party hereto, its successors
and assigns, and are not made for the benefit of, nor may they be relied upon, by any other
person whatsoever.
8.6 Attorney's Fees and Costs. In any claim or controversy arising out of or relating to
this Agreement, -each party shall bear its own attorney's fees, costs, and expenses.
8.7. .Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in two or more counterparts, each
one of which shall constitute an original.
8.8. County Approval Required: This Agreement is subject to approval by the Indian
River County Board of County Commissioners as set forth in paragraph 2.
9.0 Property is Being sold "Where Is, As Is" The County makes no guaranty or
warranty as to the Property or any of its structures or their contents. The sale is not
contingent upon buyer obtaining financing. Th'spale is not contingent upon a satisfactory
inspection report. Buyer's Initials Buyer's initials MP
-a-
P114
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have executed this Agreement as of
the date first set forth above.
Buyer:
By: C-"
lnt N e:
P&A I ,, m bar ter<<oa nilyLLC
Print Name:
Date Signed by Buyer:
Approved as to form and legal
sufficiency.
William K. DeBraal
Deputy County Attorney
-5-
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY,, FLORIDA
BOARD'OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
By:
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
Date BCC Approved:
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court
and Comptroller
0
Deputy Clerk
13115
EXHIBIT A
LEGAL ,,DESCRIPTION -
P116
Sketch arra'Legal Descripfron far• INDIA NRlVER COUNTY
II,—S89'41'34"E �- 171.32' --.�_ 1
H'?
(J
Q
9
' i . i ,•- "WEST 171.31'.. , - �t:-=- - •'r'- �t
co1r
• r•t . :i f '•, f. .J •,. .: .: (�./ ; fry - Iri
�GONfAINING'i8436` SQ; F7.t
(0.42 ACRES*)
trr .i ; � ' / . � tV. � , ' .;t-/!�' %o � � , /,'t:,. .,� ; ,,'.. •_-r,"'`.", f��' '�, till
0.119. 2867, F"AGE
`r4;'`fi° Jy 262554th AVENUE / . stn
`�•�} 1.7 , . /!r i •�' r/. jf /, •'. ' •'' pry v 4. i5!
Oi.i', r r /, /,r "y/'i f % r� f Off.
,� �. �'t ,tt}.�,+ // .• ..r �.: � � r: .. 'fir :/ ♦ L?e ♦ G7 �
Iz
' �' � /';.r/ � r.t/f `fes" i .. /.•y f.• f.•' �`"' - .` -,. ' n� Q t? _� `t
. r. l`./, t ',. ,ter .!,•,." �`%: % ,/. r/, r j:'. ',. yr'. - ..'. • Y ;k 4'! O�
,/ .,?, .{.. iter.•i Zr.%,.rr.�.'l%y.rr,•rt', /-�'. r::_ ,�.
�S89.41 13411E . ,'.46.32' 20' a a
mb ; I LESS AND EXCEPT
CONTAINING 6460 SO. FT.* b cn
4 ; ; (0.15 ACRES±)ul
4 1 t
t ' '
s ; i NORTH LINE OF PARCEL "A'
t ��•
01
N89'41'34'W -- 171.32' NORTH LINEi
In -c'
I W
26th STREET (WALKER A VE)
•
o
pd+
14.0'
Z s M S 0
PARCEL "A'
I ri t
!
,
TOWNSHIP32 SOUTH P.e.14, PGE 18
;
&DLITH LINE TRACT 14
,
FOUND 1"IRON PIPE,
589'41'347E - 1327.07'(M)(UN
+ P
S.W. CORNER ACT
S.W. CORNER
t4
TOWNSHIP 33 SOUTH
FOUND 1-1/4' IRON PIPE ✓
POINT OF
I.R.F.W.C.D. SUB-LATERAL'A-3' CANAL
(UNNUMBERED)
S.E. COR. TRACT 14
r"l�MMENCEMENT (30' RIW PER P.B.S. 2, PG 25)
LESS AND EXCEPT Legend and AbbreviaGans
SGWN11fSr CORNER TRACT 14 I.R•F.W.C.D. = INDIAN RIVER FARMS PBS - PLAT BOOK ST. LUCIE
5EG77ON39. T32S R�9E GRAPHIC SCALE WATER CONTROL DISTRICT prDELTA ANGLE
L = LENGTH OF ARC SQ. FT. = SQUARE FEET
30 a 30 O.R:B.= OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK R- RADIUS
. (P)= PLAT RAN = RIGHT-OF-WAY
P.B.= PLAT BOOK
PGE = PAGE
( IN FEET ) �SHEETI BEING THE SKDFD IN ITS ENTIRETY ETCH OF DESCRIPTION SHEETS
1 inch - 30 It. This is not a Boundary Survev
AULNCY: INDIAN RIVER C0111M. FL
PU6LIC WORKS DEPT./ENC/NEER1NG MY.
u
I' -3o'
2 OF 2
Sketch and L egal Descrlptlon
fvr."
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
(2625 54117AVENUE)
P117
LegaiDescription for /ND/ANRIVER COUNTY
Legal Description (ar.b. 2967. >aaae 962 Remainder
THE NORTH 160 FEET OF THE SOUTH 189.43 FEET OF THE WEST 171.31 FEET OF TRACT 14, SECTION 33, TOWNSHIP 32 SOUTH,
RANGE 39 EAST, ACCORDING TO THE LAST GENERAL PLAT OF THE LANDS OF THE INDIAN RIVER FARMS COMPANY
SUBDIVISION, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 25, PUBLIC RECORDS OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA; SAID LAND NOW LYING
AND BEING IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA. LESS THAT PORTION FOR ADDITIONAL RIGHT-OF-WAY AS SET FORTH IN PLAT
BOOK 14, PAGE 18, PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
Less and Except the Following
BEING PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION 33, TOWNSHIP 32 SOUTH, RANGE 39 EAST, INDIAN RIVER COUNTY FLORIDA, SAID
PARCEL ALSO BEING A PORTION OF TRACT 14, ACCORDING TO THE LAST GENERAL PLAT OF LANDS OF THE INDIAN RIVER FARMS
COMPANY SUBDIVISION, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 25, ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID LAND NOW LYING AND
BEING IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID PARCEL ALSO BEING A PORTION OF A TRACT OF LAND AS DESCRIBED IN
OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 2967, PAGE 162, PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA. SAID PARCEL. BEING MORE
PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
COMMENCING AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SAID TRACT 14; THENCE NORTH 00'26'65" EAST, ALONG THE WEST LINE OF SAID
TRACT 14, A DISTANCE OF 44.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PARCEL; THENCE CONTINUE
ALONG SAID WEST LINE, NORTH 00.26'W EAST, A DISTANCE OF 36.00 FEET; THENCE DEPARTING SAID .WEST LINE, SOUTH
89'41'34" EAST, ALONG A LINE THAT IS 80.00 FEET NORTH OF AND PARALLEL WITH, AS MEASURED AT RIGHT ANGLES TO, THE
SOUTH LINE OF SAID TRACT 14, A DISTANCE OF 146.32 FEET; THENCE NORTH 4522'41" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 35AO FEET TO THE
EAST LINE OF SAID TRACT OF LAND AS RECORDED IN OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 2967, PAGE 162, OF SAID PUBLIC RECORDS, SAID
LINE ALSO BEING THE WEST LINE OF A 20.00 FOOT WIDE RIGHT-OF-WAY AS DESCRIBED IN OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 194, PAGE 682.
OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA; THENCE SOUTH 00'28'55' WEST, ALONG SAID LINE A DISTANCE OF
61.00 FEET TO THE NORTH LINE OF PARCEL "A , BEING A 14.00 FOOT WIDE STRIP OF LAND AS SHOWN IN PLAT BOOK 14, PAGE 18,
OF SAID PUBLIC RECORDS AND THE NORTH RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF 261h STREET (WALKER AVENUE); THENCE NORTH 89'41'34"
WEST, ALONG SAID NORTH LINE, SAID LINE BEING 44.00 FEET NORTH OF AND PARALLEL WITH, AS MEASURED AT RIGHT ANGLES
TO, THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID TRACT 14, A DISTANCE OF 171.32 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
CONTAINING 18,436 SQUARE FEET, (0.42 ACRES) MORE OR LESS
Surveyor's Notes
1), THIS SKETCH AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION WAS PREPARED WITH THE BENEFIT OFA BOUNDARY SURVEY PREPARED BY
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT, JOB NO, 1045, DATED DECEMBER 8, 2016. TOGETHER WITH THE LAST
GENERAL PLAT OF LANDS OF THE INDIAN RIVER FARMS COMPANY SUBDIVISION, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 25,
PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
2).THIS LEGAL DESCRIPTION SHALL NOT BE VALID UNLESS:
(A) PROVIDED IN ITS ENTIRETY CONSISTING OF 2 SHEETS, WITH SHEET 2 SHOWING THE SKETCH AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION.
(B) REPRODUCTIONS OF THE DESCRIPTION AND SKETCH ARE SIGNED AND SEALED WITH AN EMBOSSED SURVEYOR'S SEAL.
3). THE BEARINGS SHOWN HEREON ARE REFERENCED TO THE SOUTH LINE OF TRACT 14 AS SHOWN ON THE LAST GENERAL
PLAT OF INDIAN RIVER FARMS COMPANY SUBDIVISION, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 25, ST LUCIE, NOW INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID LINE BEARS NORTH 89'41'34" WEST AND ALL OTHERS ARE RELATIVE THERETO.
Looend and Abbreviations
I.R.F,W.C,D. = INDIAN RIVER FARMS
WATER CONTROL DISTRICT
L = LENGTH OF ARC
O,R.B! OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK
(P) - PLAT
P.B.- PLAT BOOK
PGE'- PAGE
PBS a PLAT BOOK ST. LUCIE
A=DELTA ANGLE
SQ. FT. = SQUARE FEET
R - RADIUS
RAN = RIGHT-OF-WAY
PROVIDED IN ITS ENTIRETY CONSISTING OF
WITH SHEET 2 SEINO THE SKETCH OF OESM
Certification
(NOT VALID WITHOUT THE SIGNATURE AND ORIGINAL
RAISED SEAL OF A FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR AND MAPPER)
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE SKETCH AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPERTY
SHOWN AND DESCRIBED HEREON WAS COMPLETED UNDER MY DIRECTION AND SAID
SKETCH AND LEGAL IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND
BELIEF.
1 FURTHER CERTIFY THAT THIS SKETCH AND DESCRIPTION MEETS THE STANDARDS OF
PRACTICE FOR SURVEYS SET FORTH BY THE FLORIDA PROFESSIONAL BOARD OF
SURVEYORS AND MAPPERS IN CHAPTER -5J-17.032 FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE,
PURSUANT TO SECTION 472.027 FLORIDA STATE STA TES
I - N - 1-7 &�Za
DATE OF SIGNATURE DAVID M, SILON
PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR AND MAPPER
This IS not a Boundary Survey FLORIDA CERTIFICATE NO. 6139
AUkNL T: /ND/AN R/li£R COUNTY, FL
PURLIC WORKS DEPT./£NG/NEER/NG DIV
7
1 of 2
,ketch and L ega/ Description
far'
INDIA /V RI VER COUNTY
(2625 54117 AVENUE)
P118
g
CONSENT
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
PURCHASING DIVISION
DATE: June 13, 2017
TO: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
THROUGH: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
Mike Smykowski, Director, Office of Management and Budget
FROM: Jennifer Hyde, Purchasing Manager
SUBJECT: Approval of Sealed Bid Sale of 2605 52nd Avenue — Bid 2017058
BACKGROUND:
On September 13, 2016, the Board authorized the purchase of 2605 52nd Avenue to acquire right-of-way
necessary for planned widening of 26th Street. The necessary right-of-way was extracted from the parcel and
the remaining property, including a single family dwelling was advertised for sealed bid sale.
In accordance with F.S. 125.35, advertisements announcing the sale appeared on May 25 and June1, 2017.
An open house was held to enable prospective buyers to examine the house. Two sealed bids were received
and publicly opened on June 13, 2017 at 2:00 P.M. in the amounts of $71,100.00, and $55,000.00.
Funds in the amount of $167,000.00 were deducted from Traffic Impact Fees/District II/ROW 26th
Street, 43rd Ave to 66th Ave account #10215241-066120-06011 to acquire the parcel, and proceeds
from this sale will be returned to the Traffic Impact Fees/District II Fund.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners ratify and accept the high bid of $71,100.00
submitted by the Carlson Family LLC and Michael Peters. Staff further recommends the Board approve the
Agreement to Purchase and Sell Real Estate and authorize the Chairman to execute the agreement. Finally,
staff recommends the Board authorize the County Attorney's staff to prepare and execute any other
necessary documents to complete the sale.
ATTACHMENTS:
Agreement to Purchase and Sell Real Estate
P119
AGREEMENT TO PURCHASE AND SELL REAL ESTATE
THIS AGREEMENT TO PURCHASE AND SELL REAL ESTATE ("Agreement") is
made and entered into as of June -12- , 2017, by and between Indian River County,
("County"), a political subdivision of the State of Florida, whose addrem is 1801 27th Street,
Vero Beach, FL 32960; and Car -1-&,,,2
perce (buyer's full name)
210-3 $4m.-,�se bld i rL lql5o
(buyer's address) (city) (state) (zip)
("Buyers"), who agree as follows:
1. Agreement to Purchase and Sell. The County hereby agrees to sell to the Buyers,
and the Buyers hereby agrees to purchase from County, upon the terms and conditions set
forth in this Agreement, that certain parcel "of real property located at 2605 52nd Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32966 and more specifically described on Exhibit W attached hereto and
incorporated by reference, containing approximately 0.28 acres, and all improvements
thereon, together with all easements, rights and uses now or hereafter belonging thereto
(collectively, the "Property").
2. Purchase Price, Effective Date. Thep rdiase price (the "Purchase Price") for the
Property shall be 5eyeA4--,&a -- 7h—cxs,- 40 - i 00/00 Dollars
.w
(written pbrchase price)
($ -71, /oo .00). The Buyer has paid and the County acknowledges receipt of a
cashier's check in the amount of len percent (10%) of the purchase price or
.Seven&-jone Aydr-ed 00/00 Dollars f$ -71f, JoQ .00).
(written purchase price)
that is currently being held in escrow by the County (Escrowed Funds). The balance of the
Purchase Price shall be paid on the Closing Date. The Effective Date of this Agreement
shall be the date upon which the County approves the execution of this Agreement, either
by approval by the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners at a formal
meeting of such Board or by the County Administrator pursuant to his delegated authority.
3. Title. County shall convey marketable title to the Property by County Deed free of
claims, liens, easements and encumbrances of record or known to County; but subject to
property taxes for the year of Closing and covenants, restrictions and public utility
easements of record provided (a) there exists at Closing no violation of any of the
foregoing; and (b) none of the foregoing prevents Buyer's intended use and development
of the Property ("Permitted Exceptions").
4. Representations of the County.
4.1 County is indefeasibly seized of marketable, fee simple title to the Property, and is
the sole owner of and has good right, title, and authority to convey and transfer the
Property which is the subject matter of this Agreement, free and clear of all liens and
encumbrances.
vin
4.2 From and after the Effective Date of this Agreement, County shall take no action
which would impair or otherwise affect title to any portion of the Property, and shall record
no documents in the Public Records which would affect title to the Property, without the
prior written consent of the Buyers.
4.3 There are no existing or pending special assessments affecting the Property, which
are or may be assessed by any governmental authority, water or sewer authority, school
district, drainage district or any other special taxing district.
5. Default.
5.1 In the event the Buyers shall fail to perform any of its obligations hereunder, the
County shall, at its sole option, be entitled to: (i) terminate this Agreement by written notice
delivered to the Buyers at or prior to the Closing Date and thereupon retain the Escrowed
Funds as liquidated damages. Neither the County nor any other person or party shall have
any claim for specific performance, damages, or otherwise against the Buyers, or (ii) waive
the Buyer's default and proceed to Closing.
5.2 In the event the County shall fail to perform any of its obligations hereunder, the
Buyers shall, at its sole option, be entitled to terminate this Agreement by written notice
delivered to the County at or prior to the Closing Date and thereupon neither the Buyers
nor any other person or party shall have any claim for specific performance, damages or
otherwise against the County; or (ii) waive the County's default and proceed to Closing.
6. Closing.
6.1 The closing of the transaction contemplated herein ("Closing" and "Closing Date")
shall take place within 30 days following the Effective Date of this Agreement. The parties
agree that the Closing shall be as follows:
(a) The County shall execute and deliver to the Buyers a County Deed conveying
marketable title to the Property, free and clear of all liens and encumbrances and in the
condition required by paragraph 3.
(b) The County shall have removed all of its personal property and equipment from the
Property and the County shall deliver possession of the Property to Buyers vacant and in
the same or better condition that existed at the Effective Date hereof.
(c) _ If County is obligated to discharge any encumbrances at or prior to Closing and fails
to do so, Buyers may use a portion of Purchase Price funds to, satisfy the encumbrances.
(e) The County and the Buyers shall each deliver to the other such other documents or
instruments as may reasonably be required to close this transaction.
zkrAj
7. Closing Costs; Expenses. Buyers shall be responsible for preparation of all Closing
documents.
7.1 Buyers shall pay the following expenses at Closing:
7.1.1 The cost of recording the warranty deed and any release or satisfaction
obtained by County pursuant to this Agreement.
7.1.2 Documentary Stamps required to be affixed to the warranty deed.
7.1.3 All costs and premiums for the owner's marketability title insurance
commitment and policy, if any.
7.1.4 Current taxes which are not yet due and payable
7.2 County shall pay the following expenses at or prior to Closing:
7.2.1 All costs necessary to cure title defect(s) or encumbrances, other than the
Permitted Exceptions, and to satisfy or release of record all existing mortgages, liens or
encumbrances upon the Property.
8. Miscellaneous.
8.1 Controlling Law. This Agreement shall be construed and enforced in accordance
with the laws of the State of Florida. Venue shall be in Indian River Buyers for all state
court matters, and in the Southern District of Florida for all federal court matters.
8.2 Entire Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the
parties with respect to this transaction and supersedes all prior agreements, written or
oral, between the County and the Buyers relating to the subject matter hereof. Any
modification or amendment to this Agreement shall be effective only if in writing and
executed by each of the parties.
8_3 Assignment and Binding Effect. Neither Buyers not County may assign its rights
and obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other party.
The terms hereof shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the parties hereto
and their successors and assigns.
8.4 Notices. Any notice shall be deemed duly served if personally served or if mailed by
certified mail, return receipt requested, or if sent via "overnight" courier service or facsimile
transmission, as follows:
If to Buyers: buyer's full name:,,. 4,te-el e
Address: 2
City, State, Zip:
-3-
P122
Phone: -772-57q-807"
Email: I cavv%
If to County: Indian River County Attorney's Office
1801 271h Street
-Vero Beach, FL. 32960
Phone: 772-226-1426
bdebraal@ircgov.com
Either party may change the information above by giving written notice of such change as
provided in this paragraph.
8.5 Survival and Benefit., Except as otherwise expressly provided herein, each
agreement, representation or warranty made in this Agreement by or on behalf of either
party, or in any instruments delivered pursuant hereto or in connection herewith, shall
survive the Closing Date and the consummation of the transaction provided for herein.
The covenants, agreements and undertakings of each- of the parties hereto are made
solely for the benefit of, and may be relied on only by the other party hereto, its successors
and assigns, and are not made for the benefit of, nor may they be relied upon, by any other
person whatsoever.
8.6 Attorney's Fees and Costs. In any claim or controversy arising out of or relating to
this Agreement, each party shall bear its own attorney's fees, posts, and expenses.
8.7. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in two or more counterparts; each
one of which shall constitute an original.
8.8. County Approval Required: This Agreement is subject to approval by the Indian
River County Board of County Commissioners as set forth in paragraph 2.
9.0 Property is Being sold "Where Is, As Is" The County makes no guaranty or
warranty as to the Property or any of its structures or their contents. The sale is not
contingent upon buyer obtaining financing. This sp le is not coritingentUpon a satisfactory
inspection report. Buyer's Initials . . / Buyer's initials MP
ELIE
P123
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have executed this Agreement as of
the date first set forth above.
Buyer:
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
� A
By: By:
rint Name: ift�1. �.a Pe'}�e
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
Date BCC Approved:
By: U - -
Pri t Name:_ t}c Aec,issn N 1
Ga�h�ino` vgeoo v- C4.CiSCw% .%w.`y LLC.
Date Signed by Buyer: ;6 M V7 1 Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court
and Comptroller
Approved as to form and legal
sufficiency.
William 'K. DeBraal
Deputy County Attorney
-s-
By
Deputy Clerk
P124
EXHIBIT A
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
INDIAN RIVER FARMS COMPANY SUBDIVISION
PLAT BOOK OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY 2-25, PART OF THE EAST 10.47 ACRES OF THE
WEST 20.47 ACRES OF TRACT 16 BEING A LOT 137 FEET BY 225 FEET AS IN
RECORD BOOK 14, PAGE 130, LESS RIGHT-OF-WAY AS IN OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK
1093 PAGE 910; LESS THAT ADDITIONAL ROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY AS DESCRIBED IN
THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER'S RESOLUTION NO. 2015-038 AS MORE
PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 2831, PAGE 1101
G -
P125
X: 3000116, 2495
45/(-OtOh 817d L &7RI Desai-ptlon fol:
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
Legal Description (1ot 1, Block "C" Remainder
BEING ALL OF LOT 1, BLOCK *C'. ACCORDING TO THE PLAT OF DODGERTOWN SUBDIVISION, AS RECORDED
IN PLAT BOOK 3, PAGE 49, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
Less and Except the Following Described Parcel:
BEGINNING AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SAID LOT 1; THENCE NORTH 00"38'58" EAST, ALONG THE WEST
LINE OF SAID LOT 1, A DISTANCE OF 25.00 FEET: THENCE DEPARTING SAID WEST LINE, SOUTH 89141'34"
EAST. A DISTANCE OF 104.96 FEET: THENCE NORTH 45'29'14* EAST, A DISTANCE OF 35,47 FEET TO A POINT
ON THE THE EAST LINE OF SAID LOT 1. (SAID LINE ALSO BEING THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF 52ND
AVENUE, BEING A 70 FOOT WIDE RIGHT-OF-WAY) THENCE SOUTH 00-40-01- WEST. ALONG THE SAID EAST.
LINE AND SAID WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE, A DISTANCE OF 35.09 FEET TO THE BEGINNING OF A
TANGENT CURVE, CONCAVE TO THE NORTHWEST, HAVING A RADIUS OF 15,00 FEET; THENCE
SOUTHWESTERLY AND WESTERLY ALONG THE ARC OF SAID CURVE THROUGH A CENTRAL ANGLE OF
69-38-24-, A DISTANCE OF 23.47 FEET TO THE CURVES END AND A POINT ON THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID LOT 1
AND THE NORTH RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF 26TH STREET (WALKER AVENUE); THENCE NORTH 89,41*34* WEST,
ALONG SAID SOUTH LINE AND SAID NORTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE (SAID LINE BEING 65.00 FEET NORTH
OF AND PARALLEL WITH, AS MEASURED AT RIGHT ANGLES TO, THE SOUTH LINE OF TRACT 14, SECTION 33,
TOWNSHIP 32 SOUTH, RANGE 39 EAST, AS SHOWN ON THE LAsrGENERAL PLAT OF LANbS OF THE INDIAN
RIVER FARMS COMPANY, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 25, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA) A DISTANCE OF 115.05 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING,
CONTAINING 12,082 SQUARE FEET, (0.26 ACRES) MORE OR LESS
Surveyor's Notes
1). THIS SKETCH AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION WAS PREPARED WITH THE BENEFIT OF A BOUNDARY SURVEY PREPARED BY
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT, JOB NO. 1632, DATED DECEMBER S. 2016. TOGETHER WITH THE PLAT OF
DODGERTOWN SUBDIVISION, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3, PAGE 49, PUBLIC RECORDS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
2).THIS LEGAL DESCRIPTION SHALL NOT BE VALID UNLESS:
(A) PROVIDED IN ITS ENTIRETY CONSISTING OF 2 SHEETS, WITH SHEET 2 SHOWING THE
SKETCH AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION.
(B) REPRODUCTIONS OF THE DESCRIPTION AND SKETCH ARE SIGNED AND SEALED WITH
AN EMBOSSED SURVEYORS SEAL.
3). THE BEARINGS SHOWN HEREON ARE REFERENCED TO THE SOUTH LINE OF TRACT 14 AS SHOWN ON THE LAST GENERAL
PLAT OF INDIAN RIVER FARMS COMPANY SUBDIVISION, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK Z PAGE 25, ST LUCIE, NOW INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID LINE SEARS NORTH 89.41'34' WEST AND ALL OTHERS ARE RELATIVE THERETO.
Leoend and Abbreviations
I.R.F.W.0,I). u INDIAN RIVER FARMS
WATER CONTROL DISTRICT
L - LENGTH OF ARC
(P) = PLAT
PB$ - PLAT BOOK ST. LUCIE
&-DELTA ANGLE
SO. FT. - SOUARE FEET
R a RADIUS
RNV = RIGHT-OF-WAY
PROVIDED IN ITS ENTIRETY CONSISTING OF 2
SHEETS WITH SHEET 2 BEING THE SKETCH OF
DESCRIPTION
This Is not a
Certification
(NOT VALID WITHOUT THE SIGNATURE AND ORIGINAL
RAISED SEAL OF A FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR AND MAPPER)
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE SKETCH AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPERTY
SHOWN AND DESCRIBED HEREON WAS'COMIPLETED UNDER MY DIRECTION AND SAID
SKETCH AND LEGAL IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND
BELIEF.
I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT THIS SKETCH AND DESCRIPTiookqT��'#ANI'DARDSOF
PRACTICE FOR SURVEYS SET FORTH BY THE FLORIDA, Op q "
OOF
SURVEYORS AND MAPPERS IN CHAPTER 63-17.052 FL IDA CODE,
PURSUANT TO SECTION 472.027 FLORIDA STATE STATUTES,
i2-12" Z01(0
DATV OF SIGNATUR
AULNUY: INDIAN OVER COUNTY, I a
AVA91-1c WORKS Dn"IrlmawrimIN49 Dly.
21
f Or 2
UAVIU M. blLVN
L6 'ilb"
l) CER I
- TE -.-. 0a.
fo,5Xrelc17,917o(L09c41-
X-.-"
r.
INDIAN 1"i'MER COUNTY
(2609 92170A VENUE)
EXHIBIT "B"
Nm
X. 300011G: 2496
LOT 11
LOT 12
0
cv
w
t ketcI7 end L &gal Doscrlption for
INDIAN RIMER COUNTY
LOT 2
S6 '39 29"E - 129.96'
N� BASEMENT
Iv LOT 3
DODGERTOWN SUBDIVISION
t BLOCK "C"
w P.B. 3, PG. 49
rriirrrrrrQ.F`Tt /
� CONTAINING 12,082 SQ. FT,3
(0,28 ACRESt)
M
V uytu EA uENT h ga
r'r/89'41'34"E. - 104.96/'
LESS AND EXCEPT 6-89-382a"
'39'58"E CONTAINING 3514 SO. FT.3 R=15.0'
25.00' (0,08ACRESt) 1 L=23.47'
i
SOUTH UNE OF LOT 1
N89'41'34"W - 115.05'
70' R(W
a
w
yi
`C
aF
3 ry
!
o h
i
o �
(h A K
O
-------•---T-R
---------------
�r
r•-
,
POINT OF,
LESS AND EXCEPT ;
ri SWTHWEST CORNER Lor 1. BLOCK 0* ;
K ; DOOCERTONN suBOJWSION,
PLAT BOOK 3, PACE 49
26th STREET (WA LKERAVE.) �
TOWNSHIP 32 SOUTH !
,
1 SOUTH LINE TRACT 14 1 . 1 N89.41'34"W
I.R.F.W.C.O, SUES-IATERAL'A-3' CANAL
-- WNSHIP 33 SOUTH (30• RM PER P.6,6. 2, PG 25)
GRAPHIC SCALE
0 30
IN FEET
I inch = 30 ft_
PROVIDED IN ITS ENTIRETY CONSISTING
OF 2 SHEETS WITH SHEET'2 BEING THE
This Is not a Boundary Surrey SKETCH OF DESCRIPTIOP
AGENCY: INQIAN RIVER COZINTY, FL
PUBLIC WORKS DEPT.IENOVEERING DIV,
U
I "=30'
2 OF 2
Legend and Abbreviations
I.R.F.W.C.D. = INDIAN RIVER FARMS
WATER CONTROL DISTRICT
L = LENGTH OF ARC
(P) a PLAT
PBS = PLAT BOOK ST. LUCIE
A -DELTA ANGLE
$Q. FT. - SQUARE FEET
R - RADIUS
RAN s RIGHT-OF-WAY
Sketch and Legal Deserlplron
for.•
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
(260552ndAVEM/,E)
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingoh Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
2 /<.
Office of Consent Agenda 6120117
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
MEMORANDUM
ATTORNEY
TO: Board of County Commissioners
THROUGH: Richard B. Szpyrka, P. E., Public Works Director'
FROM: William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
DATE: June 14, 2017
SUBJECT: Property Damage Release Concerning Intergenerational Center for
Ocean Doors and Windows, Inc.
On, October 13, 2016 Hurricane Matthew impacted Indian River County. After the storm
passed, the Intergenerational Center was inspected and it was found that some of the
windows leaked causing water to enter the building. The leaking windows caused
damage to some flooring in one of the Intergenerational Center's rooms. The County's
contractor, Kast Construction, Inc., contacted the window subcontractor, Ocean Doors
and Windows, Inc., to assess the damage. After investigation by Arch Specialty
Insurance Company, the insurance company for Ocean Doors and Windows, it was
determined that the windows were defective and the cause of the leak and ensuing floor
damage. Arch Insurance has reached a settlement with Kast Construction for
replacement of the damaged flooring in the amount of $23,411.28. As the County is the
owner of the building, Arch Insurance has requested the County to sign the attached
Property Damage Release. By executing the document, the County will release Ocean
Doors and Windows and Arch Insurance only from damages sustained on.October 13,
2016. Excepted from the release is any claim for warranty or guarantee from Ocean
Doors and Windows or Kast Construction in favor of the County concerning the
Intergenerational Center.
Funding: There is no County funding impacted by this matter.
P128
Ocean Doors and Windows Release
June 14, 2017
Page 12
Ocean Windows and Doors has replaced the faulty windows and staff has not
observed any leaks with the replacement windows.
Recommendation: Staff recommends that the Board approve the release and
authorize the Chairman to execute the release on behalf of the Board of County
Commissioners.
Attachment: Property Damage Release
Copies to: Richard B. Szpyrka, Public Works Director
Caroline Johnson, Esq., Attorney for Arch Insurance
P129
Claim #: OQ0013005740 File #: PRWP00482
PROPERTY DAMAGE RELEASE
KNOWN ALL BY THESE PRESENTS:
That the Undersigned, being of lawful age, for sole consideration of Twen -three thousand four hundred eleven
dollars and twenty-eight cents ($23.411.28) to be paid to Kast Construction. Kast Construction and Indian River
County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida do/does hereby and for my/our/its, heirs, executors,
administrators, successors and assigns release, acquit and forever discharge Ocean Doors and Windows Inc. and
Arch Specialty Insurance Company -and his, her, their, or .its agents, servants, successors, heirs, executors,
administrators and all other persons, firms, corporations, associations or partnerships of and from any and all claims,
actions, causes of action, demands, rights, damages, costs, loss of service, expenses and compensation whatsoever,
which the undersigned now has/have or which may hereafter accrue on account of or in any way growing out of any
and all known and unknown, foreseen property damage and the consequences thereof resulting or to result from the
occurrence on or about the .131 day of October 2016, at or near 1590 SW 9th Street Vero Beach, FL 32962.
Excepted from this release is any claim for warranty or guarantee from Ocean Doors and Windows, Inc. or Kast
Construction, Inc. in favor of Indian River County concerning the intergenerational Center.
It is understood and agreed that this settlement is the compromise of a doubtful and disputed claim, and that the
payment is not to be construed as an admission of liability on the part of the party or parties hereby released, and
that said released parties deny liability and intend merely to avoid litigation and buy their peace. The undersigned
further declare(s) and represents(s) that no promise, inducement or agreement not herein expressed has been made to
the undersigned, and that this Release contains the entire agreement between the parties hereto, and that the terms of
this Release are contractual and not a mere recital.
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court
and Comptroller
By:
Deputy Clerk
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
Board of County Commissioners
BCC approved:
On this — day of June, 2017, before me appeared Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman of the Board of County
Commissioners of Indian River County, Florida who is personally known to me and who executed this
release with full authority of the Board of County Commissioners.
NOTARY
printed name:
Commission No.:
Commission Expiration:
F.S. 817.234 (1) (b) Any person who knowingly and with intent to injure, defraud, or deceive and insurer
files a statement of claim or an application containing and false, incomplete, or misleading information is
guilty of a felony of the third degree.
APPROVED AS'TO FORM
AN . L GAL OF 1 iyCY
WIL'LIAM'K. DEBRAA
DEPUTY COUNTY ATTORNEY
WM
/OA I
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
TO: Jason E. Brown; County Administrator
THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP; Community Development Director
THROUGH: John W. McCoy, AICP; Chief, Current Development
FROM: Ryan Sweeney; Senior Planner, Current Development
DATE: June 9, 2017
SUBJECT: Indian River County's Request for Special Exception Use Approval for the Osprey
Acres Floway and Nature Preserve (Public Limited Utility) [SP -SE -17-06-09 /
2005060500-78909]
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
DESCRIPTION & CONDITIONS
The Indian River County Public Works Department has submitted an application for major site plan and
special exception use approval to construct a stormwater floway system and nature preserve. The subject
site is 83.7 acres in size and is located on the south side of 5th Street SW, immediately east of the
County's Osprey Marsh Nutrient Removal Facility (aka Algal Turf Scrubber). Please see attachment 3.
The proposed facility will accept pre-treated stormwater from the Osprey Marsh facility, as well as
untreated water from the Indian River Farms Water Control District (IRFWCD) canal system, treat that
water through shallow marshes/settling ponds and the floway system, and discharge the treated water
back into the IRFWCD canal system. Approximately 95% of the site is zoned RS -6, Residential Single -
Family (up to 6 units/acre), while two smaller t2.3 acre portions are zoned RM -6, Residential Multiple -
Family (up to 6 units/acre) and CL, Limited Commercial, respectively (see attachment 3). All of the
floway improvements are located north of 7th Street SW in the RS -6 zoned portion ofthe site, while two
nature trails extend south of 7th Street SW (see attachment 5). Under the County's land development
regulations (LDRs), the proposed facility constitutes a "public limited utility" use. As a public limited
utility, the proposed stormwater floway system requires special exception use approval on the RS -6
zoned portion of the subject property. Therefore, special exception approval is required for the proposed
facility.
In this case, the applicant has applied for concurrent major site plan and special exception use approval.
Consistent with the County LDRs, staff has approved the major site plan application subject to the
Board of County Commissioner's (BCC) approval of the special exception use request.
The BCC now needs to consider the special exception use request for the proposed public limited utility
(stormwater floway system), conduct a public hearing, and approve, approve with conditions, or deny
the request. Pursuant to Section 971.05 of the County LDRs, the BCC is to consider the appropriateness
P131
of the requested use for the subject site and compatibility of the use with the surrounding area. The BCC
may impose reasonable conditions and safeguards necessary to mitigate impacts and to ensure
compatibility of the use with the surrounding area.
Planning and Zoning Commission (PZC) Recommendation:
At its meeting of June 8, 2017, the PZC voted 7-0 to recommend that the BCC grant special exception
use approval with the conditions recommended by staff (see attachment 2). During the public hearing
several members of the public spoke with a common theme of support for increased public access to the
facility, especially the proposed trails. The PZC supported the public comment by providing an
additional recommendation (not tied to the development application) that the BCC consider
increased/enhanced public access to the site for passive recreation purposes. County Stormwater
Division staff has indicated that they will accommodate any public access schedule the BCC deems
appropriate.
ANALYSIS
1. Size of Site: 83.70 acres
Note: The "developed" area, which includes the floway system, shallow marshes/settling ponds,
access roads and parking area, structures, trails, and other impervious areas will be a total of
18.03 acres. The remainder of the site (65.67 acres) will remain as an undeveloped nature
preserve, with limited removal of nuisance exotic vegetation.
2. Zoning Classification: RS -6, Residential Single -Family (up to 6 units/acre) / RM -6,
Residential Multiple -Family (up to 6 units/acre) / CL, Limited
Commercial
3. Land Use Designation: L-2, Low -Density Residential -2 (up to 6 units/acre) / C/I,
Commercial/Industrial
4. Building Area: 1,200 square feet (operations building)
186 square feet (restroom building)
1,056 square feet (meeting pavilion/picnic shelter)
2,442 square feet (total)
Note: The restroom building and meeting pavilion/picnic shelter will be provided in Phase 2.
5. Impervious Area: 54,014 square feet or 1.24 acres
Note: The impervious area consists of the access roads and parking area, concrete work slabs,
and structures.
6. Open Space: Required: 40%
Proposed: 98.5%
Note: The entire site, except for the above -referenced impervious area calculation, is considered
open space.
2
P132
7. Traffic Circulation: Primary access to the project site will be provided via a gated, full -
movement driveway connection to 5th Street SW. A secondary gated, stabilized driveway
connection to 7' Street SW will also be provided. The proposed traffic circulation plan consists
of a paved two-way main driveway off 5th Street SW with 90 -degree parking spaces located at
the south end of the driveway. In addition, an asphalt millings service driveway will connect the
proposed maintenance building to the main driveway (see attachment 5). The proposed site
layout provides a modified type "T" turnaround area as required by Fire Prevention.
Due to the low trip generation associated with the proposed project, a traffic impact study was
not required. No off-site traffic -related improvements are required or proposed, and Traffic
Engineering has approved the proposed plans.
8. Off -Street Parking: The proposed project is a unique use that does not have a specific parking
requirement identified in the County LDRs. The proposed site layout provides a total of 10
parking spaces that will be available to the public during specified times and events (e.g. school
field trips) and also provides a concrete parking area for County maintenance vehicles to
maneuver and park near the proposed operations building. The Community Development
Director has determined that the project site plan provides sufficient on-site parking for the
proposed use.
9. Landscape Requirements: The landscape plan is in conformance with Chapter 926
requirements, including perimeter buffering. A Type "B" buffer with a 6' opaque feature is
required along the north, east, and south property lines, and the portion of the west property line
that is not adjacent to the Osprey Marsh facility. The proposed project design provides a 100'
wide buffer of preserved native plant material that will satisfy the Type `B" buffer and the 6'
opaque feature requirement (see attachment 5). Perimeter buffering is not required or proposed
between the proposed project site and the Osprey Marsh facility. In addition,, the proposed
project site will be secured by a 6' tall black vinyl -clad chain-link fence provided along the
north, east, and south property lines.
10. Phasing: The project is proposed to be constructed in two phases. Phase 1 will consist of the
floway system and shallow marshes/settling ponds, the operations building, and the 5th Street
SW main driveway and parking area. Phase 2 will add an open air meeting pavilion/picnic
shelter and a public restroom building.
11. Environmental Issues:
a. Wetlands: There is a.28 acre area of isolated, low -quality wetlands located in the southwest
corner of the project site (see attachment 5). Those wetlands will not be impacted, and the
proposed site layout provides a significant wetland buffer/setback from the proposed project
improvements to the wetland. Therefore, a County wetlands resource permit will not be
required.
b. Uplands: Since the subject site exceeds 5 acres, the County's native upland set aside criteria
apply to the project. Approximately 80 acres of intact native upland plant communities exist
on the project site, and the project's set aside requirement is 12 acres (15% of 80 acres). The
project site plan identifies a specific 12.5 acre upland preserve area located along the eastern
edge of the project site. However, the overall project will preserve a total of approximately
65 acres of native uplands, and the proposed floway and shallow marshes will compliment
and/or enhance the overall environmental quality of the site.
P133
c. Tree Preservation: The site is heavily wooded with mostly non -hardwood tree species (e.g.
pine trees). However, there are several existing hardwood trees that will be preserved in
place, and the final design of the noway path will be adjusted as needed to avoid most of
those existing hardwood trees. Very few existing hardwood trees, if any, will be removed
from the site. The applicant must obtain Environmental Planning staff approval of the
project's final tree protection plan, and tree mitigation plan (if applicable), prior to issuance
of land clearing and tree removal permits for the project.
d. Listed Species: The applicant provided an environmental assessment that indicated a total of
nine gopher tortoise burrows on the project site. The project will be designed to avoid the
existing gopher tortoise burrows to the maximum extent possible. However, if an existing
burrow cannot be reasonably avoided, then the subject gopher tortoise will be relocated to a
different area on site. If a gopher tortoise needs to be relocated, the applicant must obtain a
gopher tortoise permit from the Florida Fish & Wildlife Commission (FWC) prior to
issuance of land clearing and tree removal pen -nits. No other listed species were observed on
the project site.
12. Stormwater Management: The Public Works Department has reviewed and approved the
proposed project plans. A County stormwater permit will not be required.
13. Utilities: The project will be served by public water and sewer service provided by County
Utility Services. The County Department of Utility Services and the Department of Health have
approved these project utility provisions.
14. Abandonment of 12th Avenue SW Right -of -Way: The Public Works Department has
submitted a separate right-of-way abandonment application requesting abandonment of the 30 -
foot wide unimproved 12th Avenue SW "paper street" right-of-way that runs from 5th Street SW
to a point approximately 165 feet north of 7th Street SW (i.e. along the subject site's western
perimeter). That application has been reviewed and conceptually approved by the Technical
Review Committee (TRC), and the right-of-way abandonment public hearing will be held
immediately following the public hearing for the subject special exception application.
The proposed project design integrates the Osprey Marsh facility with the noway system,
providing a stormwater (force main) pipe connection that crosses 12th Avenue SW from the
Osprey Marsh facility to the proposed project site. Therefore, if the subject segment of 12th
Avenue SW right-of-way is not abandoned, then the applicant will be required to obtain a
County right-of-way permit for that stormwater pipe connection. If the subject segment of 12th
Avenue SW is abandoned as proposed, then a right-of-way permit for the stormwater pipe
connection will not be required for the force main.
15. Specific Land Use Criteria: Pursuant to LDR section 971.44(3), the following criteria for
public limited utilities apply to this project:
1. Per Chapter 901, the definition of utilities, public and private — limited includes
"electrical substations, package treatment plants, water purification, storage and
pumping facilities, sewage pumping facilities, and similar utility uses;"
4
P134
Note: The proposed use (stormwater floway system) meets the definition of a
public limited utility.
2. Between all above -ground facilities (except distribution and collection facilities) and
adjacent property having a residential land use designation a Type 'B"buffer (reduce to
Type "C" where abutting a local or thoroughfare plan roadway) with six-foot opaque
screening as specified in Chapter 926, Landscaping, shall be provided;
Note: As noted in section 9 of this report, the proposed project design provides a
100' wide buffer of preserved native plant material that will satisfy the
Type "B" buffer and the 6' opaque feature requirement along the north,
east, and south property lines, and the portion of the west property line that
is not adjacent to the Osprey Marsh facility. Perimeter buffering is not
required or proposed between the proposed project site and the Osprey
Marsh facility since that facility is under the same ownership and is being
integrated into the floway system.
3. All below -ground high voltage cables within a utility right-of-way shall be made known
to the public through the use of signs posted therein;
Note: There are no proposed below -ground high voltage cables within a utility
right-of-way. Therefore, the above -referenced signage criterion does not
apply to the subject project.
4. In all zoning districts except the industrial districts, all equipment, machinery and
facilities which cannot by their size or nature be located within an enclosed building
shall be separated from adjacentproperties having a residential land use designation by
a Type "C" buffer (with six-foot opaque screening) as specified in Chapter 926,
Landscaping;
Note: As noted in section 9 of this report, the proposed project design provides a
100' wide buffer of preserved native plant material that will satisfy the
Type "B" buffer and the 6' opaque feature requirement along the north,
east, and south property lines, and the portion of the west property line that
is not adjacent to the Osprey Marsh facility. That perimeter buffer is
provided between all project facilities and adjacent residential property.
5. Driveways located inclose proximity to adjacent properties having a residential land
use designation shall provide a six-foot opaque screening between the driveway and
adjacent property. An eight foot opaque screen may be required if deemed necessary to
mitigate noise and visual impacts.
Note: There are no driveways located in close proximity to any adjacent
properties. Therefore, the above -referenced driveway criterion does not
apply to the subject project.
P135
16. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning:
North: IRFWCD Ditch, 5th Street SW, Serenoa Subdivision / RS -6
East: IRFWCD Lateral "J" Canal, Fox Ridge Subdivision (aka Timber Ridge Phase V) / RS -6
South: 7th Street SW, Oslo Park Subdivision / RS -6
West: 12th Avenue SW (to be abandoned), Osprey Marsh Nutrient Removal Facility / RS -6
All conditions recommended by staff have been accepted by the applicant.
RECOMMENDATION
Based on the analysis above, staff recommends that the BCC grant special exception use approval for a
public limited utility facility to be known as the Osprey Acres Floway and Nature Preserve with the
following conditions:
1. Prior to issuance of land clearing and tree removal permits, the applicant shall:
a. Obtain Environmental Planning staff approval of the project's final tree protection plan,
and tree mitigation plan (if applicable).
b. Provide a copy of the project's gopher tortoise permit from the Florida Fish & Wildlife
Commission (if applicable).
2. Prior to site plan release, the applicant shall obtain approval of the requested right-of-way
abandonment of 12th Avenue SW or obtain a County right-of-way permit for the proposed
stormwater (force main) pipe connection between the Osprey Marsh Nutrient Removal Facility
and the subject project site.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Application
2. Excerpt from Draft June 8, 2017 PZC Minutes
3. Location and Zoning Map
4. Aerial
5. Site Plan
rol
P136
SPECIAL EXCEPTION SITE PLAN (SPSE) APPLICATION7
PROJECT NAME {Please Print): Qspm�j Aerej4Poujak d.,jd Nnc�f'I
ILSO�l♦
NAME AND
PROJECTM. zlbosocoosoo SP -SE ---1
OWNER: (PLEASE PRINT)
T14J,06--s p -we -f Cofjm
NAME
1%ot 2l4im 'S+ree+
ADDRESS
VeXo toaC11, FL 32.Q6t)
CITY, STATE, ZIP
AGENT (PLEASE PRDM
saue- a,p owme4-
NAME
CITY, STATE, ZIP
-772.-22-4 —1!5SID ?-
PHONENUMBER PHONE KAMER
1',AAC,C-Ulll 4D-
EMAILADDRESS EMAIL ADDRESS
CONTACT PERSON CONTACT PERSON
SIGNATURE
PROJECT ENGINEER: (PLEASE PRINT)
OWNER OR AGENT
PROJECT SURVEYOR,, (PLEASE PRINT)
lw_ p4hp— If,,>C- Ulm Wofts EA)w.,bi v
NAME NAME w
l8r-n I V
ADDRESS
VC4-0 &C,l /0 -
CITY, STATE, ZIP
=-& — 15 6 ?-
PHONE NUMBER(s)
/*=> ( 2 77q- 51 --me 4 -
Vero $e1, VL 32
CITY, STATE, ZIP
22z,-1226
PHONE NUMBER(s)
KAAC,C-U // q rC 46 V. CQ M11D IrC-�VCiOAA
EMAIL ADDRESS' EMAIL, ADDREW
1,- bq\jtd_S,dotj,
/se/ -f ccd�/� 4 P,E*
CONTACT PERSON CONTACT PERSON
Atow% i2t 27orn Attachment I
OF
P137
• DOES THE REQUEST INCLUDE A CONCEPTUAL PLAN ONLY OR A CONCEPTUAL AND
"FINAL" SITE PLAN?: *' r/mgj "I Sr-feDla.-j
• AMOUNT OF NEW IMPERVIOUS SURFACE: (SO.FT.) �4-, 014 S-0
• SITE ADDRESS: 925 5 S-ree4. gull VO -0 &-4-C A .FL 3Zg6 Z.
• SITE TAX PARCEL ID#(s): 33 - 319 - 2-4 - acx=y=�b'" S cx=) o
• IS ALL OR A PORTION OF PROJECT IN ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE AREA AS
DESIGNATED IN THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OR ADDRESSED IN A PRE -APP CONFERENCE?
YES t/� NO
c a4s ode. !0o - ('
• FLOOD ZONE;Fk J ZONIN �ZS-619 FLUES L•-�
,moo pp -
*
e• TOTAL (GROSS) ACREAGE OF PARCEL: S` 3.7
• AREA OF DEVELOPMENT (NET) ACREAGE:
• PROPOSED CHANGES TO EXISTING DEVELOPMENT (IF APPLICABLE): N�A
A. NUMBER OF UNITS: FROM TO
B. DENSITY: FROM UNITS PER ACRE TO -UNITS PER ACRE
• CHANGE IN USES BY SQUARE FEET GROSS BUILDING AREA
USE: FROM SO.FT.OF (USE)
TO SO. FT. OF _(USE)
COMMENTS:
"PLEASE PLEASE COMPLETE APPLICATION CHECKLIST ON NEXT PAGE**
I 01n1 "dl ll— O---1. VT MAGA Attachment 1
P138
SPECIAL EXCEPTION SITE PLAN APPLICATION SUBMISSION CHECKLIST
MATERIAL (note N/A where applicable) YES NO
1. EVIDENCE OF PRE APP CONFERENCE IF PROJECT OVER V
20 UNITS OR 40,000 SQ. FT. NEW IMPERVIOUS SURFACE ap'Pile W/ Co v4A . b"
2. Fee: Administrative Approval $200.00
Minor $650.00
Major
<or = 5 acres: $1000.00
> 5 but < 10 acres: $.1200.00
= or > 10 acres: $1400.00
V'ee L x t( be- (e+rVJ
Frov, 05ppaLi
4XXOwa+ 'to ca*"•004•
Special Exception Use fees required in addition to above site plan fees:
$975.00 less than 40 acres
$1075.00 40 -100 acres
$1275.00 over 100 acres
+$ 50.00 for each additional 25 acres over 100 acres
3. Completed Application Form, and if pre -app conference already -held, then
a pre -application conference discrepancy letter response or summary of
plan revisions
4.
S.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Ten (10) Copies of the Site Plan
Two (2) Sealed Site Surveys
Two (2) aerials of site with project overlaid, showing surrounding 200 feet
One (1) Copies of the Owner's Deed
Letter of Authorization (if applicant is not owner)
One (1) Copy of the Drainage Report
Completed Tree Removal Permit Application OR Signed Exemption Form
Completed Land Clearing Permit Application OR Signed Exemption Form
We p,Z)WAJy 50bAaW
V
ye w .Sr -10, pt" sv6A4i
y' tau scf a Flaw sCZM,ffi
NSA►
N iA
a/A
12. Three (3) sets signed, conceptual floor plans and elevations prepared by architect
or engineer (when project is required by Florida law to have such architectural or N %A
engineering drawings)
13. Environmental Survey if all or portion of project in environmentally sensitive are V
14. Concurrency Application or Acknowledgement Form NIA,
15. Written statement and photograph of posted sign
(Needed if Planning & Zoning approval required)
co Is f '+l`Q,J<-, ar +1> aDrfZulm -Kt"e
T RAI 77A gtmwt VPM RParh RT.'A7Q(,n Attachment 1
P139
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
There was a meeting of the Indian River County (IRC) Planning and
Zoning Commission (PZC) on Thursday, June 8, 2017 at 7:00 p.m. in the
Commission Chambers of the County Administration Building, 1801 27th Street,
Vero Beach, Florida. You may hear an audio of the meeting; review the meeting
agenda, backup material and the minutes on the Indian River County website
www.ircqov.com/Boards/PZC/2015.
Present were members: Chairman Alan Polackwich Sr., District 2
Appointee; Vice Chairman Todd Brognano, Member -at -Large; Patrick Grall,
District 1 Appointee; Chip Landers, District 3 Appointee; Dr. Jonathan Day,
District 4 Appointee; Angela Waldrop, District 5 Appointee; and Jordan Stewart,
Member -at -Large.
Shawn Frost, non-voting School Board Liaison, was absent.
Also present was IRC staff: Bill DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney; John
McCoy, Chief of Current Development; Ryan Sweeney, Senior Planner of
Current Development; and Lisa Carlson, Recording Secretary.
Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance
The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. and all stood for the Pledge
of Allegiance.
Additions and Deletions to the Agenda
There were none
Approval of Minutes
ON MOTION BY Mr. Brognano, SECONDED BY Ms.
Waldrop, the members voted unanimously (7-0) to
approve the minutes of the May 25, 2017 meeting as
presented.
Public Hearing
Chairman Polackwich read the following into the record:
A. Osprey Acres Floway and Nature Preserve: Indian River County's
request for special exception use approval for the Osprey Acres Floway
and Nature Preserve (Public Limited Utility). Indian . River County,
Owner & Agent. Located on the south side of 5th Street SW,
Attachment 2
P140
immediately east of the County's Osprey Marsh Nutrient Removal
Facility (aka Algal Turf Scrubber). Zoning Districts: RS -6 (Residential
Single -Family up to 6 units/acre), RM -6 (Residential Multiple -Family up
to 6 units/acre), and CL (Limited Commercial). Land Use Designations
L-2 (Low Density 2 up to 6 units/acre) and C/I (Commercial/Industrial).
[SP -SE -17-06-09 / 2005060500-78909] [Quasi -Judicial]
Chairman Polackwich asked the Commissioners to reveal any ex -parte
communication with the applicant or any conflict that would not allow them to
make an unbiased decision. The members stated that they had not had any ex -
parte communication.
The secretary administered the testimonial oath to those present who
wished to speak at tonight's meeting on this matter.
Mr. Ryan Sweeney, Senior Planner of Current Development, reviewed
information regarding the request for special exception use approval for the
Osprey Acres Floway and Nature Preserve and gave a PowerPoint presentation,
copies of which are on file in the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) Office.
He recommended that the Commission recommend that the BCC grant the
special exception use approval for the public limited utility facility with conditions
stated in the staff report.
Mr. John McCoy, Chief of Current Development; Mr. Keith McCully,
Stormwater Engineer, IRC Public Works; and Mr. Sweeny proceeded to clarify
several inquiries from the commissioners regarding operational details, safety
concerns and public access to the proposed facility.
Mr. Mark Manera was sworn in by the secretary as he failed to do so
earlier in the meeting. He explained that he owns land adjacent to the proposed
facility and voiced his approval for the project with the hope for substantial public
access.
Ms. Ruby Jenkins was sworn in by the secretary as she failed to do so
earlier in the meeting. She stated that her family owns land adjacent to the
proposed facility and spoke in support of the project. She reiterated Mr. Manera's
suggestion for increased community access to the facility.
ON MOTION BY Mr. Landers, SECONDED BY Dr.
Day, the members voted unanimously (7-0) to
accept staff recommendations with the suggestion
for enhanced community access on this Quasi -
Judicial matter.
Attachment 2
P141
1 ITH SO S4V . vsi N
33392400022000000000.2
4
�CS-T.0-1Y
5TH ST SW (REBEL-RD)
5th Street SW 5rH 'ETo Svu.(RFs
"S{.BL4 iE7�AL'E-r` r - .. ttl - - -
LP iATE RAL-J-1 £ -
5TH PL S .
�oap,pyMa sh Th =
3923000010090b0001.0 Subject Site FO
5 1�
Zoned RS-610 rn
1F.
- o -
.a
U)
o,
3
8TH WST.SYV > F ;c 8TH
•RM-6 � �:
O U Cj
Q
CL UR
.
FgrrH-Sr-SWt,VSL-0 RD)
9th Street SW (Oslo Rd) 5 -
y�SM-LATEPAUJ-z--fn l
8P80fl001001000001A.�
IF I I 1h qIETYLLL
Attachment 3
N
07 76 w j
M,
=2j
'"=CrA=
-__- -
�----�
| | | |
« o o o
| | | | | | | | | |
| �----� �-_--� L----� L ----J L -_--J
| M SIREET�
/ �----1 �---� F----� F----� F----�
' ' ' '/ / / / / /
| | | | | |
| �o-------------------------------
u --°--�n�=MM
PEPM NOOK
TCPALNIi, N, a�
Indian River Press Journal
1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32964
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared, Sherri Cipriani, who on oath says that she is Classified inside Sales
Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida: that the
attach ad copy of advertisement was published in the Indian River Press Journal in the following Issues below. Affiant further
says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published in Vero Beach In said Indian River County, Florida, and
that said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, daily and distributed in
Indian'River County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement;
and affiant further says.that she has neither paid or, promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission
or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. The Indian River Press Journal
has been entered as Periodical Matter at the Post Offices in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period
of one year next,preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement.
Customer Ad Number Conviine Pf%#
463755 - INDIAN RIVER CO PLANNING DEPT 1631052 Hearing: 6/20/17: Osprey Acres Floway hearing: 6/20/17
Pub Dotes
June 5, 2017
.Sworn to And sub$crl0ed beforayne thisl0ay of June 02, 2017, by
Sherri Cipriani
(X) personally known to me or
( ( who has pr000ted __
who is
as identification,
sR.M
LINDA JOYCEKLEINN:tary%blit-St tedrf0r'daCommission li GG 0g} 422N; Conmi. Expires Mar 4, 2021ilo dtd through NaBoral Notary Assn." .
1OAI
P 144- 1
4CWinf.yI... 5, 7&17 Trreafura Coast Newspapers `
NON SEQUITUR
f,eg$1'NOIIG@S A CtlOp
• Ole(, DIRbT TklfN64 E)RhT . rr(.?i' '� .`y'', :x'."U , '2007 NESE UEST
( NfiEb Tb 4E5,f A IAVALT`{, N' 'PINS 5NI8Y]BU47NI117/9
QATtt iRckA G.W.Et`TON6 f ' 7000 NISSAN KTERRA
'"S' 1�'•� VIN. SNIED28TOYC52285B'
_tA �,r±0"r •'sf.l'F'Fy, 2002 FORD EI(Fl0i1ER
(Js�%" VINBIMCV1aEl7VB1T7n6
,1I +: 2000 HYUN0A1 -
'• _' 7 YIND KMHJF35F,AYL 15323
^af M1
Nun's INC
a00155E,uaCo-,,.AVP
1({LiT„7]2220.1151.OFox
,�C,1]3.130-ISTb fad
��r` , `t. TS nrb:luae S.loIT
(V r ' y!r /-%.fy) TCN /6126]0'
•.�`e, ;(C.F�•.,z,:-.= GIVE.li_'"^; tf PUBEICN NOTICETNATTRI•IS'HEREBYCOUNTY
�c
AUTOMOTIVE ti •' TOWING
W41F.14 11 REAl1.Y( eis .,4Ii TO Cs 4,,pIYTN _ WILL SELL, AF PUBLIC AUC-
_ TION, PURSUANT•TO FLORIDA_
STATUTES.SECTION 713,78,
TRI -COUNTY RESERVES
THE RIGHT 'TO ACCEPT
a "^�xhrc ..? r.2) ' gt4•+ ,W -O °."e r"'� wa d OR 110115 ANY ANDTOR
EhA(7�DT(C5 "<.:'ysyE1 Q8lNM'iGE'Sdg'"a'.✓tf ALL. NTY0 AUfosELLO AT
�.../
Mmr¢d DlItMWnt(3) who. Ue SCNPdukd apple Cl i3 AT lids DKE£tH.REE ROAD.
ans 1 klwwn to be load ar Ipfs then i day5; H yW are
FORT ' PIERCE. FL' X907 AT
ailve,ed, ",alO Unimuwn hearingy sUIC<Imyaire0.' E:DOA M.
aa(UA3me. coils aninlerasl utsma.Zor-
"5ntygasc.H-Other pjdd. Pule MaYY 29, June 5. 1017' AUC TION DATE:JOfi-163017
T%,xi"'e O Fix !Wim•. TCN 1626020 VI: )14G254S65C771107
"T%
Dan 2. Part is Id
Fassession 01. N IhinO and,
'all Unknorm-PUUo3 calm• Pub: 163 5:2617
Ina. bY. through: under and' TCH,16TAI
aDalnN .tRa. above named NOTICE 6GBLTi-SAI:,_
I"'-'"' wnR are. ry7t
N other sabidd Unknuwn¢pai TCARE ADP OF PARENTAL
USUcuyyiees. 1xrg by SIn that
'ties oras' ikkh a interest RIGHTS, OYoochobae Poad,Ft PI<rce:
s 800usC,'Neks ape Cl i.- (1.34947 i}! soil MS•C..-
G"tots, or Otter Claim- $UMMpNS OY PU6LItATK)N leOl -uf Use 11 -In F Hells,
DMendanifs). (UNKNOWN PMENT/S)). IHtod below n[ a yyuxbe auo-
DOCKET NUMBER: tion to sadslY a p Placed
NOTICE OF ACT ION- I6C10066NA. '' thentents (Purxudnk
FORECLDIJPE COMMONWEALTH Of to ChaOlvr 83 of Tisa fluHd
DROCELbINGi-p ROPFRTY AIASSALNUSETTS. Statutest,i he sok wi& take
Berkshire County,luveNiO Ciace'M lh..webUte'Slora
T0: Vatter LORRIanm LAST Ceurl. Skaif3Jd oA1- 14.20?
KNOWN ADDRESS. R46 18th- 390 awtn Stre¢t, fit 9:00 y2). The tole will Dr-
Avenue,VeroBCae F172960 PN lsfeld:,MAIIIII Cr7nduneO,unUerModlrec-
R Tien Of'Christapho, Rasa
and Mnendd lYdM lohntana: ,TO:. Jason George d any (nU4167) and Shuef Ste
N.'
.LAST KNOWN AppRtS3940: unknOWn,UMamPd /dDuraf in
(AB3182)arbanal7 lot the
lath Averee. Vere Beach: ft KV, Michel. laneron, DOD facil y's m beh,l tthe
3n�o, � 030/2o[55.aburn Lo Karl
sSn 11 be avalWh tan viowin0'
Reskgn<e k�uwn, 1 Gv lean. Arkr In PanhiNt pp wMesaltonSDxaae-
,Ing:InGWIny Y,unWWwn NtA:-Stufl.81d: .
,Spouse of ine sand •Defeo- CMtenu,wlN bR sold for cash
rLdd and if enhor of bothoof: A p.tb has tieen Prqunied Ny.tp the nrpnest nMder
gad Oeleatlent3. are dad. to ltus courtny.DCF se CkinO, A'10% huyCYS premium
meinr rive"unknown >t. the fdlowlnp drib: Na will D8 thoraco di we8'ar
het 9,.'dcvisea3 prantoes, IYn M.lanQran.UN((s.ticnlid a $100 Cleaning deposit yy
asfigMeo, d)torf. Uan. bUCloundmnacd of care and no LAll,alts 2)e neat Segr
end_trvsNM, and all pr lection and LdmnlR3ed til ¢strvei Mt yht a IN=
Mer Bond, ClUnaln by, Lha Oapartm<nl of Chddr.n - draw the property at' arty
v• d(k Fa RinCA Th. LO Wt dWY hrtw b0bre the S5alt Or l0
Ih.mun untler 9unst dislith •Me itpoMs f Lisa IuSe ahry Ultla. llle proper.
Com! ¢d 'De].ndani(1)' por-R.) r+dlrWtl hernia N tYN,b<SOit IS dPs'"b" aM
d 'IM aninenti.rod CPlvp,nOU<!.1 or T..COA• yarw Yat nouSeMltl t.thS"
rix nen . De tentlahl(3/ d sent lu anyy ftp I prncnMl7ry Nat• olhonxne nofod.
is'uch UI Uni afurynivnUuneO fleehnD.lhe tldltibn, hH; R035 Ell,aptM Ybevl9, 5031
ncMW.1 Def. -In and lud Y•sK glmNl¢gshrD era PalrlCla Sand-, 8101 Pster,
Such d.the alpremPnflOrle<I 'her
d)spoMdn of the chill C Bakrr Jr. R076 OuNeria
blown Defentlu+ksaimay ed Rertb. if It finds that iMrnlon,SOLODCrWislre-
xC be ".4p o. sw Cis. or the cbld,D, in need of Diner, Jr, 0053 Mebssa Sum-
otnerwisuMlSWluris. yid ;xotactlon, and that the dlin. P 19 Ltnlsho talk.
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED be,
f into<sts.1 the thNd son, Vol, David Petra: 009]
that An action hes Dead cpnl• Id be no -d by said d;t- 'Claude Wella. RValB. DAvW
d<td N foretbs. a mmt- Da51Hup, Pevo: Go72 Latonya Brown.
gage'On iho•tolWwl real You ora hereby ORDERED 'Fl010 CdrPllne Bowan
proyyPf lY. jidd OI I` no (o,appear•hh this Court, at Pub; Mayy l9.lwra S.lOIT,
aM'Sltuet'd IA IrWlan River 11, court adtlrtas set, forth; TtN 1639530
COen{y HOIWd.'Yor rtlC• dGOver un llx Fol lowing ddle ("'xr,w •=•'TrN +,rry.,•'L�
MrN desvlben as roYews: d I'n+a,'06/17aa17 09:00 gJ6t5--_.F,prRt
107-1 .'BLOCK I: BEI -FORTE AM Other HCarbhO
PARK:,A000ROMO TO THE Ypu may. orin9 ,an attorney IN THECIRCUITCOURTOFTHE
PUT THEREOF AS PECORO- ill' ye"' You ha q right NINETE[NTH )UOK:IAI
ED IN KAT BOOK S, PACE 21. to b2) altOrnoy end 1 rho CIRCUITR ANU ICl ST. LUCIE
PUOUC RECORDS OF'INDUN COUR tlCtermine[ that you COUNTY; fLOR9DA
TWWYERCWNTY.ilOR1pA.., are IMlq¢n14 N._Cowl wt 1, Carp Na: 662.10 CA 0p19UY,
VL been Nkd aQ Dointy an al[.rney to re0• �G.narollud>dt<lion Division
."nit en;,.M Va.'A'a Ij ynu/xllttRpmNr.M.CWrt LANDS pOWNE MOATGAGC.
, Ittl ea T. - .'e Y .1 aayy proceed .d that date. LLC... Floud.IDniled liability
You r Wijtan deflnie, iv y. a d any dee thereafter with 2)y.
upOn'SI41CIR0,•F15NMAN A Pa
OACNEE. CLP: ,AHornOyc tar aniriai an the merits of Mo PWiAy/l,
AT I. whole addres I$ ppldh on and an adjudication s.
I4T4 North FCd,r11 Hall all), matte. PATRICIA L. DUNNING. THE
ay. Suke, 760. Beta Baron, Far further Inturm¢tWn. w11, UNKNOWN. SPOVS[ . OF
FL"1X)2, within thirlY {7W to 0"Ics, of the Clark-MAg. PATRICIA L. TURNING;
day, aK,, the Ibst pubRCa- IslEateHail-6642700. 'FIELDSTONE
VILLAGE NONE.
Ildl of IMS none. aAd
NM OWNtRS A$$OCNTtON, INC.
the art at with the Clerk' of WITNESS: ANO, ALLOTHEWPERSONS
WsCourt either hetero hint side loan M, MCMahonry, CLAIMING AN INTEREST
7tl, 2017 SMvfce-en PWIM1 FIRST RISIICE IN THE REAL PROPERTY
[ItYs 'attorney or' midi. Lou,. Been. WHICH IS THE SUBJECT
[tIy tR¢re filter; Oih<rWiie C,LERK-MAG5TRATE MATTER OF THIS ACTION
a dolault wdl ba pntwatl DATE ISSUED: 05/77/2017 BY AND INROUGII UNDER
pains you fur the Gnf peb:Jwm 2, 5.12,:2017 OR' AGAINST THL NAMhD
EPdwnd<d In Me C'hoPICnt TCN 1630504 DEFENDANTS HEROIN: JOHN
WITNESS my hath And seal of .:1:C"c';a+'^.'-^YAW^:vly(j, , DOEand1ANE 001, Unknown
IMS Co.. ad Ma 24th. of � r,rSBj ((,,rte Ito pRrtles in vii-sid-fay.
MaY.2017.=SSr....•r"'3'i-+ .Otfenaani(s).
�FW
ripal, {IfF{tLY $' a aseus1••; d(fdtalalSSt4s YERa.IUiix �1
1�utfeyQf;Ftir`BD1a3ure' filr)31.TPCrpghOYH'. ;'. "OtlietPOlitiGi'iNCea;r.�•,
DY AND THROUGHUNDER;
of
late f LAMES O. BEN,
Nuusly to UNctl and saltl taxi
OR AGAINST THE'NAMED
DEFENDANTS HEREIN: JOHN
SDN JAAILS OSCAR
BENSON, deceasid.'whose
0113 or li¢d lo.1Ae
Saint LUCIo'County Tax Col
•DOE find 1ANE DOE Unknown
Qurllni In pp e inn. IE m
List DeferrGants,the Clerk
Ml! Of UCalh'was Apra ]0,
TOI7, H p<nCDR` in the
OWI DPUFL for Martin"'.',
kLLo, dl MSY 30, 2D17.,
Michalle Frank Rd, CFA
W U+a CouR.lasPPh E.Smk1ry,
"a, CVLVrobat¢ nUn. Lisa
- 'oparty Appp_C,
bill 5011 to Use 111,11 m
Mt Wddarrofcasll. by lice•
.... of which is 100'casl
ocean Boulevard, Stuart,
•Saint Wei CWniy
Pub: June S, 2011
'tuAL;'Into at' w.;Z1`cle:
ciOrXae.ti0n.cam, l 8:00
florid 34994. Tht Mmes
and adNl52.5' e! In¢ p¢r-
TCN 1671722
NOTICE, OF ABANDONA/FN7
:AM. 42) JBLT,la, Zan J,the
IOlfewirtq daxcrih<d^prO[er.
SOnal rtprpsemalive andtM1e
Fvnunol r0prC6enlaliv!'s
_ E.
NOdc! i3 herEDY given that
ly'ai Sui lorlhin the Final
JUd9mnnh,
attorney aro 5etbrd below.
All cr.tlllor{.1 rho dett0ent
R<[nlutien 103I.OS1,was
daDted by the. Board .t
10711, OLOCK 11, TRADITION
'PIAT NO. 19,E TOWNPARK=
a d o1Mr-PCfsOn3 havinginlyan
laimA ¢r demands upalnSt
coup ort.stat.
Rlver,C lSvtgn�lUiide
•PHASE ONE. A SUIMMSION
ACCORDING TO THE PLAT
onw ortla
opvl.Mr n0Uee is reOWrCtl
pP,ep Il, 2017. PocCono..
bad'=',II:IITOnti1Wb1D:
THEREOF RECORDED AT
to be serve0 must lite. Meir
Clafmp with this cOUrt ON
dOsing. renountM9: A7W QfY'
KAT'SOOK 47, PAGE'32, IN
THE PUBLIC RECORDS Of ST.
OR BEFORE THE LATER OF
claime,P anY.iipnt 2)r inter.
sl'in a. Nghtof-way. bT,a
LUCIE COUNTY, FLOP IDA,
3 KSONTHS AFTER TH E•TIME
OF TINE FIRST PUBLICATION
16 toot wide aIIOY runnr�7WW
Street d ret$:- Ila84, SW
ri<Idstodn Way. Port St
',ucle,FbrldaX9a7'
OF THIS NOTICE OR 30 DAYS
AF TER THE DATE OF SERVICE
ham 129M.Court h, 129th
SDoa{{ and=lYtns Linh ndMte-
ANY PERSON CLAIMING AN
OF A COPY OF THIS NOTICE
ly ad)nG<nt' and; c.ntigund,
Is bis 3.10, ObIX t8 Cf rile
INTEREST Iw' THE SURPLUS
FROM THE SALE.' IF ANY,
ON'THEM.
All ,uthor ttedlrors of Ino
Townsite Piet f'Rp..1 2)9
SuM(visrnn'as described IO
OTHER THAN THE PR
dettdent and OIdOr persens
11 ahova•rlfduncd <
TOWNER AS OF THE DATE OF
THE US PENDENS MUST FILE
;awing CWIm$ Or demand
9alnit. decedent'[,lStalt
oluUod, tservinV cerinin
A CLAIM WITHIN SIXTY (6W
e[ -hie their ckim5 wxth
ngnts totlro County..
,
DAYS AFTER THE SALE.
this court WITHIN 3 MONTHS
'THE -.TRE
INDUN RIPER COUNTVp
NOTEIO PERSONS
WITH DISABILITIES:
AFTER OAT' OF
FIRST "DUCAT Ra" ONTHIS
BOARD Of COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS
Hay rt a perp on with a
- tl1I""'y
NOTICE:
A!1 CLAIMS NOT FILED WITH-
BY'los<ph C. flesch.r;,
who CCAS any
LCd_ed,h.n In order to
IN THE TIME' PERIODS;
Chtlfman'
Feb: June 5: 7017
ParliclpatA in, this proceed-
q• You are entitled„ of de
FO ATHINFLORIDASTATJ 5
SECTION 733.712 WILL BE
FORTVERDARREU. _
TCN163104!'-
" D 'A. •."'. -"'
<ASLN rotnc provision
.f urtain ai Mstance. Plea Se
NOTWNHSTANpING THE TIME
PuliGO NN"watiC85 •.'.s.'. •"._'/`
ton[act Corrie lohnso7I AUA
PERI ODS SET FORTH ABOVE.
NOTICE OF PUBLIC NEAPINO
t'd-o"UH 25DHW Country
Club Dr.... Suite !17„Nott
ANY CLAIM FILED TWO (2)
YEAR$ OR MORE'AFTER•TNE
_
Nnticn O(a Iieerin0 t0
St. Lucia. il' 14996: (77]1
DECEDENT'S DAIaE Of DEATH
IS BARRED.
yUbi(c,
cgnsidar. a pttihon for Lha
807.4170 at .least i Da Ys
h<forA your sche.ukd court
The data of !list pubDdaliun
piosbs9, abandonment .Sud
pPnarnntY, imm¢dute.
WMIs MdCe)SMAvn,Iune
ata Hod nfaponinn Ot. t7tn
'Avonul,SW from Sth Street
I upon reCPiYfA this Mtl:
Y U
5,1027.
sw to a paint a •yrozhMte-
In,Ich.ii Na tune bCb is
M<Sthvdul<d,ueD?arance is
PenoneI inn,ICsentadva:
11 L'S" Mol. -itis $Uxi
let, Mui 1 dais; A, yea, are
579 South Gard Be LL rRotor,
Rlvaryft C dip""'t [-
hearin dvD to imDyrptl,
ca1171Y
,Hohn Sound. Florida 3)655
.t lands and Plan rely L
DATED: May 31. EDIT
AllpmeY IYT P<fSOMI
Dmin.9a and Noatl RapPrYa.
U.M. A Dubl1. hearbr9, at
Byy. Vlvlari P.Jdlnus ESV
P""-.ta-a
LY... W, SproYe. fsR.
hick penial. mt<resl and
,6 [do Baf N0..7{al1!'
Attorney
,�l(jypnS 3tWDiWv0 an6 PYd'
NndY to ha heard., wd be
AITTE0. ZAPE7SKLot B[A
Florida Bar Numbeii OBGS6Y9
SPRAKER A PRINZ
hold by the Board•of Cbyn-
B 1AIM�; LI P.,
29l5BiscayneBOulEvud,
P.O. BOX H38- -
Stuart FloHda X995
1Y Cammissidrpn=ol Inman
RrvCr County, Fbritle_in. the
Suite 300
Miami, Florida 33130_
Tel (173)22.-0217
GOUntY sain 310A am-
T.A6562.61,
L (3651372.091)-
Far: (3p5)7D4-0173
Far: (7 721 2 20-0417
E -Meth l$�rak<r4ya.I.cOm
ben of Mt Countyy'Adminit•
•Dation BWidihat be led t
t8o12'f Strett,Vero Beach;
Prima im01
vivia ➢rr lin .c 72)
2nd E•MBI:
CarakeraneD Inx , mau.eam
,
Rorke. 02) 7ueptlnY: June To.
2a17at9:00 AM.
d [[
pub: May 29:Jw[.7oU'
TCN 1629171 -
d nneGralU .Com
lune6. LI,1017
AnYOne w110 Y '!In to•
Tfb116251a0
TCN
Soleal any deds)on; which
y,b< arAde dl. Ihk.m�ot•
'
MGeB'L-,
to Med t. ensure that.
er d of the
.moa- .R'e•ti;�F,
NOT)C@TQOiddli0r;
4bifCN 4+. y,
d1sirli, .
pr aNny<ip mne! rear
-Inichad. Me teStinwnyY mt
i :�
NOTICE
.Videnct Upon whleM .the,
1111111111 COURT FOR
pursuant to Seclian 290.127(1)5
aPpc'Iw,110t Das ed. -
PROBATEDVII ION LORIOA
florlda SLaNt<s, (Ice
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
File Na: 110DO)65CPA%MI(.
hereby given to all taxpayers
and mvn.n of both real and
OOAn. Of COLLNTY
IN RE: ESTATE OF
y al. VrOpe,TV that the
COMMIS510NCR5
BY, I.StPII E. fICStnlr.
LAMES O. BENSON
NRlIS Mve been', extended,to
Chairman =
JAMES Cta)R B[NSONsac
NewIhp tax .11rR u(.hle to
'TCN l6]O6Bd ti
vc-sed.
cable Properly riot Pro
-
NOtICETOCREOiTOAS^�
-
He admint,,tlallod .1 'the
Y7an'VhY x
p i44u�
WALLACE MAZDA
1 (772)464.4645. i
17I55EFeder.l
WALLACE VOLKSWAGEN
liWy„T5.5tuart1939
Baa3
2805 SE Federal NvIt-y,
Stuart
WALLACENISSAN-
mz191aoT
op SEru.dal Hwy.,^
WALLACE VOLVO
- Stuart•
772.286.8000
3801 SF. Fedral NsvYa Studrt
866-2631201•
p i44u�
Osprey Acres Floway & Nature Preserve
Special Exception Use
Board of County Commissioners
June 20, 2017
Special Exception Process
➢ Special Exception Use
• Appropriateness and compatibility of the requested use
• Specific Land Use criteria [971.44(3)]
• Two public hearings (1 PZC & 1 BCC)
➢ The BCC is to:
• Approve request
• Approve request with conditions
• Deny request
2
lo•�o 1,
Public Notice Procedures
➢ PZC Public Hearing
• Legal advertisement in the newspaper
• Notice of hearing mailed via USPS to surrounding property
owners within in 300' (including POAs)
• Posting of sign(s) on the property
➢ BCC Public Hearing
• Legal advertisement in the newspaper
• Notice of hearing mailed via USPS to surrounding property
owners within in 300' (including PDAs)
• Posting of sign(s) on the property
3
Location Map
H $f 5'H
ptEFEL'AO f
5th„ f •ect S\1`
� I i l
�*.W
—vnueac•e:
Oawy
0
Q t
Subject Site � `•O�
Zoned RS -6
T" Street SW jj i
'
i
riT rw4
�f
9th Sit eet SW(Oslo Rd) �Nsrsr,
li ylc. i `" rY
4
..
Aerial
Traffic Circulation_ Plan
Site Plan Detail
- - - --T5"'St,eet SW --
/w
UNDISTURBED `✓ TRAILHEAt} UNDISIURBED
AREA
AREA
,I
.. Parking area ,t
F O
LY.' UNDISTURBED
5
( ,-,: ;
'' ✓ ; AREA
E r2.; < Phase 2 Improvements
l I I� 1
JR,
(RESTROOM
UNpISTURBED
AREA
8
7
Traffic Circulation_ Plan
- - - --T5"'St,eet SW --
i
Gated driveway connection to 51h
.. Street SW & two-way drive aisle
.. Parking area ,t
--------------------------- :. Gated secondary (stabilized)
71h Street SW access to 7th Street SW
IAI •i iii
l I I� 1
II 1 �I
! FF
tt 1 ii
F.�.s L— j
LiIL.i
Oslo Road ---__- �__..� - ; --_
8
P, 14;
Landscape Plan
5-SteetSW
100' wide native
plant buffer
,
"T" Streel-��
,
slo Road
9
P-1444.71
ROW Abandonment
- —. 5'h Street SW _ 'i - - ---• _
I Proposed 12'hAvenue SW
i ("paper street") ROW ,
- abandonment area
r Th Street SW 7-1 F ---1
l
i' I i t I I 1 1 1 1 1 •�I� b^ { 1
�•I 1 I I 1 1 1 1 I
_== _ Oslo Road ----- -- -- - -
11
PZC Action
➢ On June 8, 2017, the PZC voted 7-0 to recommend
that the BCC grant special exception use approval
with the conditions recommended by staff.
➢ The PZC also provided an additional
recommendation (not tied to the development
application) that the BCC consider increased/
enhanced public access to the site for passive
recreation purposes.
➢ The applicant has agreed to all recommended
conditions, and has indicated that they will
accommodate any public access schedule the BCC
deems appropriate. 12
P 14-S
Staff Recommendation
That the BCC grant special exception approval for
a public limited utility facility with conditions
stated in the staff report, related to:
Tree protection/tree mitigation
• Gopher tortoise permit
12th Avenue SW ROW abandonment
13
PIN
10Ad
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
TO: Jason E. Brown; County Administrator
THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP; Community Development Director
THROUGH: John,W. McCoy, AICP; Chief, Current Development
FROM: Ryan Sweeney; Senior Planner, Current Development
DATE: June 9, 2017
SUBJECT: Indian River County's Request for Abandonment of a Portion of 12th Avenue SW
from 5th Street SW to a Point 165 Feet North of 7th Street SW as shown on the Last
General Plat of The Indian River Farms Company Subdivision [ROWA-17-03-02 /
2005060500-78340]
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS:
The Indian River County Public Works Department has submitted a petition to abandon a portion of
12th Avenue SW from 5th Street SW to a point 165 Feet north of 7th Street SW as shown on the Last
General Plat of The Indian River Farms Company Subdivision. The subject right-of-way was created
in 1913, has never been improved for vehicular use, and is essentially a "paper street." The subject
right-of-way abandonment request is directly related to and in support of the County's Osprey Acres
Floway and Nature Preserve project.
In 1913, the Last General Plat of The Indian River Farms Company Subdivision platted a total of 60
feet for canal and road right-of-way for 12th Avenue SW. Currently, it appears that the Indian River
Farms Water Control District (IRFWCD) owns the western 30 feet of right-of-way, and the County
owns the eastern 30 feet. It should be noted that Public Works Department staff is also in the process
of requesting formal abandonment of the IRFWCD right-of-way. It is County staff's intent to have
both of the 30 foot wide segments abandoned, and the entire 60 foot wide strip added to the adjacent
Osprey Acres project site to the east.
Prior to the Technical Review Committee (TRC) meeting at which the subject request was reviewed,
Planning staff notified each property owner adjacent to both sides of the subject right-of-way by
mail. To date, staff has not received any objections from any of the adjacent property owners.
At this time, the applicant requests that the subject right-of-way be abandoned.
P145
ANALYSIS:
Consistent with guidelines established by the Board of County Commissioners (BCC), this petition
was reviewed by all County divisions and utility providers having jurisdiction or potential interests
within the subject portion of right-of-way. Upon review, all reviewing departments and agencies
indicated that they reviewed and approved the request for abandonment without the need to retain a
drainage or utility easement over the area to be abandoned. Therefore, the proposed abandonment
resolution does not include a request to retain a drainage or utility easement over the area to be
abandoned.
As noted on the County Thoroughfare Plan, the subject portion of right-of-way is not part of the
County's major roadway system and is not needed for the thoroughfare system. It should be noted
that Planning staff has previously supported the idea of improving/constructing the segment of 12th
Avenue -SW between 5th Street SW and Oslo Road (9th Street SW). However, now that the County
has purchased the 83.7 acre Osprey Acres site to the east, and has effectively removed the possibility
of constructing ±300 additional homes in the area, Planning staff has determined that the subject
portion of 12th Avenue SW is no longer essential for traffic circulation in the surrounding
neighborhoods. Also, the subject right-of-way abandonment has been requested in order to support
the proposed design for the County's Osprey Acres Floway and Nature Preserve project. That project
will ensure that the Osprey Acres site will remain as a permanent open space, eliminating the need
for a 12th Avenue SW connection between 5th Street SW and Oslo Road.
The County Attorney's Office has reviewed and approved the attached abandonment resolution for
legal form and sufficiency.
RECOMMENDATION:
Based on the analysis, staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners abandon its rights
to the subject portions of rights-of-way and authorize the chairman to execute the attached
abandonment resolution.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Application
2. Location Map and Aerial
3. Abandonment Resolution
2
P146
y_.
Treasure Coast Newspapers I TCPALM,
Indian River Press Journal
1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32960
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared, Sherri Cipriani, who on oath says that she is Classified Inside Sales
Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida: that the
attached copy of advertisement was published in the Indian River Press Journal in the following issues below. Affiant further
says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published in Vero Beach in said Indian River County, Florida, and
that said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, daily and distributed in
Indian River County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement;
and affiant further says that she has neither paid or promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission
or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. The Indian River Press Journal
has been entered as Periodical Matter at the Post Offices in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period
of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement.
Customer Ad Number Coovline PO #
463755 - INDIAN RIVER CO PLANNING DEPT 1631042 Notice of Abandonment: Res 2017-051 RES 2017-051
Pub Dates
June 5, 2017
( ) who has produced
who is
as identification.
lo, ,4-,�
ti�µY',',;;H,,
LINDA JOYCE KLEIN
;'NctaryPublic-StateofFlorida
rnl\
' " -
Commission # GG 081422
°-
my Comm. Expires Mar 9, 2021
Bonded through National Notary Assn.
lo, ,4-,�
e-1�Vj
IOZYE9L•T9B
Lanli "FMNW Bpaf 35106[.
Dope-get-tu
�UtK
'•AMNIeAap =,I
a d Mp Ai,.Qa,n a1VP111 @elle
moos
Ba9P[AI tYDL !Vn{nq....gl
:.-'""'CP6tLb4st1Y:"% ;F,rt)I
4"2 AfAN 5011n4 f1^",
y ntt
'�jn�rJ,f'(P"0�,
'xExf-Lea:u,
IreniSFMN
OA1OA 3.3V.1NM
35 F[C9
. NVSSIN 3'JYPIvm
woa'pa4"—>.n
99sastE•oge'
inoa"pro1:ePlaA:y:
AINAOJ Y3hitl NVIONI ; aa11Uu,�salnl[iS tpt,%!
N,aDaA35059Z.•
1310sA3ND 33V11tlM
- 1o0P6Tx•x4
It'O3 LJODMJ 3M1 N1
314050'5556
;'ai�o�taQi3A;: -1
uro'>P 1yaCa4maA
66959PU unOwnNre uu%f:
'm xnitl
'bf3'Aa4e,ds'M avuFl
LnmS
'A¢MVOI13
H 34,@0@9 5062
N30tlM5NXIA aDYTitlM
.666,-SLtro04
M-15"AMN
Ipli 3SSLG[
'dllfNm60tl7h
009ffOtM[L UCNS
•APMVB)X
etB 'I !L(.
NenK'A y6M
1[!@44135 SSLZ
90Gt•SlCOOs.
ISn 5556
'n314A0MD IpY7flatl3h
.L950f09•!/6'.
gnnK "hmNlewpal3S593f
'S/4r¢ IL ..
Woa'u¢SS Noaa90`
VOv,a
ZVW 301111VM
tawWf 3555((
.d33f3�V17tlM
390003�tlllVM
'r.,---';y�jy:yt1mCf--'--;
I rmlW4a+D1a6,,3:
9V'IlI4V�3�VT1YM
N �n
SE2t•BZ[•8B8•I
..1 SO'S Slg1-
0909'6x[•00 1
>j,a d'1l15n tl1np955S5
000[•(iFtll
)n?n1S "AmN
009C•OZ2-Z 1
((III
';UPVpld3M46
oVfl+¢410atIY1i�•CtSA„'"°"'',
A!+OY
(@,3O)V �ditl
.UUj�01)
_ .;,"•-b'^„•'t d::.'••v .i:i
A—Um.
HYSSIN PON
AN11O113W'N100Nil
.30tl31tlM
- itwpoi 3S lost
ItlON -30tl11tlM
Iwzpad35552t
B3lSAtlND 3�1T7M
p” 10000
IOOOOY
$$ xDa0lYt)..•;..:
is
(S
T.00010aJhI1a100O'01
E— -lea(i p1n\t.
�,jy�A1^01!'10"+8!ea00j
�
O70A3J :,191£a0'Pj�V
4f3'lel2?OOV+;
6-4-15'.•
0 OIYiBn1d LSUI!
3141
1nb3 4,
• A1NnO3 MIAMI NvlONI
.'.�JG•a: ±3C:., _:tY':.'
!.Ca'i_ . T1Tr ' •
. = C�'_� ��..i :S'id1,..� i
.::Ala;".i .,
pu—S
tpu'wap sF— 6UTAt4
b:, w4M W¢luapaaaP
AUownsai sa0nlau! V>14+^
IIIM'OupnaW TIVI fe @pew
ju
r_a0t a-*T1F:$'#1
N1- 4,YOR¢ W.Pope aul
S'a
a d Mp Ai,.Qa,n a1VP111 @elle
moos
Ba9P[AI tYDL !Vn{nq....gl
,'PaTga�ao
14051430 tltl0S05)ntlf"
Lt01'4....i N 01, pOpuolxO uOAq Dont
AN
NOSN3I„0:38
'UJ a LAluno 1 1.1%e5 9T0((
9T
Va V: Ya y"3 Wasai'M )r41 �t., O,d IPUoswtl'
NI
J031tl1S3 :3tl NI
Ogg
Amno�i,TONV0a ,p 1¢.J 41aq l0 swum@Pue,
Andz01l r al uan!p Aga,ay
XWXtld059C00011 :'^Na0!
AINAOJ Y3hitl NVIONI ; aa11Uu,�salnl[iS tpt,%!
L'OItl07l A1NA0y 110”
V
'Oottq>q'TO. 1'.060 "4L)xITr6 l pWla>Sollunnv nd
It'O3 LJODMJ 3M1 N1
AVI 4aQgM Uodn as plAa 30Ii0N
t4u wnsa7 caPnlaul
'•.+"S[i%#!f!aNJL4`/ `M
,
1,.
.@alum apYw q,s� !Paaw+d ��'^"-�,**S�t�pA^-Fealnd17�
66959PU unOwnNre uu%f:
'm xnitl
'bf3'Aa4e,ds'M avuFl
' m 1p waaa, wplg,aAe' .p '?''�.t.<��;m•."w �.....�
-' .anlleluaxa,P TV,
nljvnosN
31:91---N PON flue. ul
N 6rnu
-I—S!w la ApelAaa
In>ed4
1 Vs!M -Rew 04M 8u'AUY
10191
Id
WY 00:1P[0
•pZ aunf'Fep'sa.I V..P
teNOT
LII!Nw,'AAMlM6pu1Ii _
wo s
o
1
V,
iiLO.Ot�
?Iq,R4� u�i spU 1aj11Altm'Oo9D
L([j'7711.
Pel u: ep!,g3 'A I— wn:SAstUiT
566b£-eOen;S.
'0'd
u �Pul lu srsuo!zs!wwo],Al
- o]f^,pnoA.>4t Ay'PIa4
-oso6
•ZNlUd 4f b31;Yntlz
0 IM'1p e
VANaV of ANunl
'.aor)rlou an:411Vs cu>:nP
'pue sawlv!w Yg4etl Vu!VM
66959PU unOwnNre uu%f:
'm xnitl
'bf3'Aa4e,ds'M avuFl
1n .uueay _apgntl a •tuun
-' .anlleluaxa,P TV,
nljvnosN
11411
41 peon Wv000ww0
Pull Iu%d Pia sapuea lP
jl t
55Kt vpl+ol3'Ou50
..p.,uedw00Altl-
Oul'W un .mow to •M
s; ,
DPotl4>1>841.05905 '
osu0ll "n CP+aO
lya1A15,YW 1'a'V1FOU 591.-
:dApt1LL0YA,tl.+nlVUnuDd
a lu!OQ a al MS
WWl anuaAY'
`WET
M5
i WS 00
41[1 D Uu!LC Jp yONU>Cn
--f -6E Atn t! Ou S!1V{42/o.,
»!I'1'
pue 'M .—Vi qV '6%sola
I"
aw ,% "DO, '"I"
.4,-lgnd ILII 10 OIVp 141
03bntle 51
Ogrva4 spgnd ¢Ice aa!lnN
.HiV30 AO 31Vd SUN303330
3141 V313Y 3UOW No So—
ONINV3NDI18M1030110N
(L) OM1Cl ANtl
y cep..-ry.•....¢e..a
3AOAV IiAbOJ 3S S001034
3nLL 3141 amaNY15N11MtON
--' �
3a IIIM'� ��1lltln NOIl]OI
35
lief
ilOtt91 N]l
LIOL'S auWf'9N
531n3Y1S baItla".Ni
LOS sacim, 3W11.d11 xl.'
-N11M 03111 LO1,SW!YID TItl
'iayiT31!'3 iloit0(A6
Stl3N01551nWaJ
D10N
-SL
Ab
LNnOJAOANOfl
0 OIYiBn1d LSUI!
3141
1nb3 4,
• A1NnO3 MIAMI NvlONI
SH1N10 C3 IG
'A)UMo, of"ino
O4M sw!ala I>ynl al!I lsnw
a11oPA p )w1YOt,
fICUa>-P—j.1. "in
a41
al paaYA iaTV
pu—S
tpu'wap sF— 6UTAt4
b:, w4M W¢luapaaaP
U. -A
.Qe.paquxaP q
u¢lat'vn lu t¢Id ob�liumol
^VI 10 s„upan ",aylvOv
nim{o 61 aggA'01 fl% ol.
011.0@puC lu»P!oMIs
3311ON SIM1 10 A O7 V !0
-.faw!DaWW!GulAi pU1 lParii
'W"SA031Y03H1tim.
SAVO O£ b03alION SIMI AO
W6ti of llnOD"VIAi[ wo,J
11ff p 1.01,91
NOiLvallum ISVIA 314110
�ojMR¢w%j!o•lyejiw'•ujjii
wet Ju•i4a1+ AUC Ou1wICl>
3ni1'3N1 tl310,5HANOW f
10 n31Y1 S 141 avom UO
�DP1re'6LL!aun0ua, •Bu•SOL
no .Lona, 4t V11M'surtep
ayl alN tfaw it>n,is ad al
'Ournnnuoagp,'0%UopdYgD,
'bully>'A A4ry.u'-
wormyy aF
slt
LIOZ'Cx
:PPiall R{urwJ"anln unrPul
Co)ej6a ,epaaup
10Puewop
10 :LPUOITgWWOJ
��t�Vuitav ,o swl%a.
Wrµ.N tUOLad w410,0—
MdVn
.IO 0+100 aw AV PoldoPn
'tM UOnnIOYatl'
1r aPa>aP aw {o's,01! C" fly
'^6-t1DE'
1-41 u G Aga,ay MON
Ion yUol IM W¢Row011a
a Im+ot,a0
1N3nN00NYAtl A03DLL.OH
y,Iel....+Ear
jeltl eLp-jo 1 -mol, pl.,
LZ1if91 N]1t
1[01:5 Ounf:Qnd
r 041 ;166@[ 1Pu01A
UCMS 'PMnalnOtl, u4aa0
At'urropp (ant lutes
iaTlC,eatl FLld"d
Nn3 ODT tl N%ym'M'ssuppn
al¢gD,d'PpP%1
tl3D'uS4+m,f >A>VMW
,•tVl'UOrfU40
A1uno]un,an,.j4—al!na
-J] ay1'131 Gul4uad II 'ifOt
'GIOL:Of RCPj un 4djail.
'•113 Pel Mu,w3 O!>nl 1.115
'021NOY .SVM wasp to alep
OBD4M 'post6a0p',t10S0
Net Piof Drcrt!pa! 1!1Na0M/ywaln
at138a0331YYIP)0 ,M'J'A
I�fi�, 114261@ a.,
',t".'_ s�ar11 p1J Gi a]pa�Jt
OK5291 14]1',
L�or'2l's aper Ana
.-111I1ew3 �1op�.iaS
>'mglL, u AM
[2141141 SOE3v!'
(Sot) Pil
1[IEf Pp1%f'Iw%W
Uelnl$
'Pmna1n1i01:1,Ts19 5162
611:3"TV( T
'tl3e1U11111 v3Nvttlipliloli
M3'wulM_a)iaNIM1' A
spaw"Ol
1S3tl3110NY ONIWIVIJ .APp. 3CJ'915V sa1111aN p� 1'x"4 a1 °cent.w urwll`
SNOS034 10410.11y, ONY 'Ysa ppo a.JOW11•lD '(102'91 L I
JNI NOUT'looSitl S4,0,o bun, uv •w'e0P:6 M 65[11 Un1JlJas I'll
By1,1! a%l2alJ
.'OMNNnati tl101tl1tld 10 A 3H 1- 'IS 1,
gn01.Fl.s 1 1''yi 141'6.µp»,.vaon Aj
'+iSAOdS; NMONNNn 311 ^q 4P> S>I1NJn 6ulmoaol ayl i%paWwl A0 'iwe,ead0e
ONIXNna .1 YIJICtld W Unoa pVaf +nOA a,oMq
-a.4At ''p„qo luno] MV13303alloN ACP l !se>I 1¢',OLEt-LO8
cell^l 15 iel oc W �N#>lp (LLL) '94b[C.V :Ppn1 .15
IV!kPnt inuaalal4N din -J. e099Z91 NOT Lod 'LIZ allnS VAl,p, qnl]
j—, JMa,QMp 1.'666100, LTOT•s Nnf'6Z Aan:gnQ A, -d it N05L'w1tUIp,00D
Y'J SID( IS ate! SAM ui•HDtO01180I ? ➢tl •uatuyof o!wn] 1>aluUt
.aceto@ pua;>I.S lasatl In 'Nldl3'Y:H0109 tYOLNIiI! %auPislt3e� elJaa to
PUW'ypP kCS a,niopa,of
44M. Tim 06619 P W o ie�,Detip4ua iT,P'nM l'bul
au4atA o) u%ton 'a!¢6 A'.5 /,CPA '60f5tL:Si-oi SUv^<-PamoJO 5!114 nl altap!LeU
aua,o! 01 uo!i.lalr4tpp Aauafl oM a8¢FOtf A{gns Ol yfia 1 ,ap,o .uI ua!*epowwo»a
•, r3 t,NNu!eI¢ OupuP,O yy D105 q pIM "no a, Rut, Tpa>P oy q!pgtfrp
+@4,0,1[14 YC k W N` Pue U bald to SUadold l --c! v 4gm'uog,O [' aJP no! II
9161 'P JHVWBada , 013[4 .Jo '1661[ J! '1,4nts 'Par,
luaWapnr IeuIL ow o3luens t, ppoMu%loD 3s iY$I,To 1I'N 1 S /0
N3M0AI3a3M T13J11ON-..Wb O.:Or 11"lot'if.-r, 1-0 Aluno] pu4 V-13
31Y9Nn01 4it-S'a A. waf
Ao.33113JIION RA31v5 403!11014
((n1u1Pw1a0 .Sf10 an 500 O **•�mss� Ac 11TOZ'A01Y
'Auv}I'aortsatsoE 15>N r1d •!,, tl" fl NIUpaT To P41tt NN
nNJI
U•aoUzun'3093Nvr P. 300 �u`'•='•'•*•••^'as:a LO 1Paf put PUPV Aw S53V11M,
'NNOL :013R)4 SINVON3110 OSDE9I NO!
PyVplwoJ o41 W pap4lvwP
03WVN- 3141 'ISNIVOV tlO LI01 "Ll 'S't auntAnd poiA Wa4up i0xujln[jaP GP
nail HOnovt- ONV A8' •ti0i/Et/5p:03n5St 31tl0 asp NIO :+a1'a a,aVl Alew
NOUN SIN1 10 wit", 31tla1SipVWA4313 :rp ww! m:RaU VLN 5,11!3
,103fnn5 3141 St' I131NM Oantl Pmtl •4I%d u0'aa!n,ui 1102 'A2
All13dOtld 1V9a 31Y1 NI 3JIISnflShl.4 I>+olaq wgpU Z SL
in
1S101N1 NY 'JNIWWIJ, 'Rw.H8M1JW'W Ueef'uOH ao A+%J syi wMt ltwO aVu%i
. SNOsu d `13H10ON
3H10 11V , V' :SS3NLM Ira pub:.anW s!yl,/O t
ONI,*31LYpOSSV SbINMO' q>II rM 3541 ay1 ,aJ11 cAtp
]"Oil 30VIIIA'2NO1SOl3N 'Ot119'699'Cla le a]erisl CalgFlry4l UN7!m 'll1EE 11
�NIN 3SlAi0dS 1 NMON4Mn'. IPi 'Uo11WA+unjual' a4)iry 043"S
gv6'09L a4nS 'Anm
3141 iONINROO '1 .VYJIn1id 11UN i to i4%N Ivapa3 yLON ILtL
ocimIPMp4 I¢a pov u%al.d I,cs ,pPe asaym Y}!7V!eld
'N tu!%a aW lD_tlww 0yl,u A RYI q DL ADwa11Y 5fil )3I4JY0
'RUe.wOa 'wlM,all'a,aV1 a]eD Rue Y NYWT 513 'OtlIdYNS Oa^
,Ri1119%I patP++n ¢PL%3 a•J11. 1tP 1C4i u0 Daaau,d Aew Au¢{ fualaPu>IIUMig.,
30YO1UOn 3NMOOSONVI Unp> M,',eodd¢ M nil nOAN aDv d > ¢ aa+as.ol Ca+l^DiJ
A was@, A pue no,'. tsurei C,
u0191Ma uopalPtimf 11—n •da, oI Aauw)l. ue Iulodd0 P-111 a 4 icy u00oe NL
660100 VJ910L
'IN
I'll Ilm )#loa ayl lVafii0ul,o+¢ 'YOIUDil'A1NO0]tl3Altl'
VOIUOIL -AIWW �M law tipwuilap LnoD NVI@1110 SOtlONtl 3I18AA
IIJnVis 601 ONY,NI lln]IM 141 H Pua AawoN4 u¢ Ol 't23DVd'S NOOK V. NI all
tYlJlanl H1N3313NIN aytl9 <:aAN nOF;ll •noA W!M •OtlDD>al-SV fO3b3H11Y1d
314110 SW llnu*31LLM Aau,%le. u¢ 6u!+q ACW 31101 ONIONDOI9't 1d
fiu!+aaN ,OI�10 Wit 31�tlrOnqd-�138.'['MJOIY "141101
'a.JvlKa60AfD130�L O 00:60 LtoE/lt/40 :P ,y o e ,jlyr0 aiow�ePN%! Ffv
-+!x42"- :, T,:•`: A19114]1 VV?J1 alb ,ili:uP� 1+ 0> 041' Ili UVlpw ul p>Itn11s
5102.>�o5ounf'62A WAN le•Iln^a sM %,road[ nl OutaY Pui au1Rl 'R{,aQOueJd
p auryn,e]OIDN' 03NI0n0 Aga,e,t •n0A
aq 1AT ubM%lot agl:uo a6t0
dMa8 CN1oN.1 [COD 'oJlOd `i,a!1K0o �i rea uaaiulaa,o/o7 Peaww
pNV0 ol0Atl fIIPM apnvlD 'IP pfM Aq"""I'>g VpWm gAS3113pae UllM
/6aD' 1>d prnn0 [OOA ;uus a44a.aw 10 ita+.lu1'lseq 031A110N A83U314 3tltl n0A
-41x1 1411.'1 61pd inti..! VI 11,11 Pue ual SaAlP,tl pue .tool rrrtlm: axlin,ayin
-luny mlm C50D,',Q ,vmo1 ¢a )C Pacer w 5'41!4>-o4t D.PIu>'iewn
>11 sl—O 0105 u ,o II 1 4110.117!N'dN%A4 paweu 1 >%'S1 ul Pq
'mJa41pn0 fro@ ,r, ,p,iTY •,1 pAN aW /o r+ol)podgp wyl0 euw se t)w•pia!ap umap4un
4dl bnZo tl's,apurS,%kriaA Au4 ao gySU4!prina,n'Apel LUQprsuawalolt a4. Wns
1105 '6 noA VIOg4n bm Voltoope oV TuOaaNe P. tu'Wala a' umou4un'
13 9f0U Pauo}iu.wawpr yt In 41nt
•PalOu>f!m,a470 T,,*.n auo'aaw,d,ea; Cw)uaY put,-(s)luepuPRO P.-
0 Wayasnoy. Itnu04 •u .140 To akl%r aa>aa+ �qualubwe,o/[' eyl put
,SP tMr4e,asaP sl Pouf aq MAI e1 WI iV go-- thuaT,ad ,It)]ua
J41••fPl9 Ade aSMa, 411 M 1469 141 ai 1110 PUOIa, pawtu W
al:,o.ii¢t e l 1011aq'�dun)
AT. 111-a41'fap, APU1 lsup!b¢ ,o :gpx^ yGmwil
yy '.1q. eUW ta> alJatl Wu
.Foe fa ALadn,d y{ PIP 'uUl>cai4]-+o Iuaan,eee0 e4 1!t, put a�sn+i Sue"LO
..aHnt nl
446V.-41 BiPuWda put VapNlT1.
ITS, 11.111.1 t Y'1P#1 D Ca P.Du u!purrp/a9 •Sajndilt+,6ll Baas usi�oP
a 1rooaP-Ilu e—IJ 001St F�WPIeaV41'Ue, un'niM 0 tun inq>adi+ ,1}41
sY O>M aP P�. 44a •a9 Iiim '� MapP>%lol.w ols. pvaD a,e slu¢ua)aa PIPs
wn!wa,tl J{,nq '9605 �tl "� Plans .6J0 q TIM a fn,wog w,pw1" L! Pue All
>app:Q nPytlY ay�ol'quo D )ws lacepoHna V ,two, -4 -n'- It slurpp
ysna ,%1911 aq p! lualuo] -u>{tp DICs ,>yI 10 aSnoEs
oe,nis mou4Uu ou fiu:p oiue aul
nlf alli 'PIn'{I
oyl of ,.Na pp!I LNW w ..Poet rrto( w4 it %ori p!sotl
Gwmaln 1 a ealu11U1tne aq'i16M PItPIA -1 --q'9TOZ10[MO
Sltun,luaWad fAllllael 000'ue,Pu[f al>VwW uN t'N 33 eaiA"%wMY 4181
"a41M11Pya9 VO LZSV[IV)P!n JO,ay141 Pbw8UWl +umlya,Un u�nOgY NANxx LSYt
-`loll@ e,OA Pua U91f11P) Auv 9'va,oa0 'uotef •Ol 401 C.", t""UPtm
.Dtl ,d.j,pga lc: -901
IP ,ayl ,a0un P>wppo'a (oZ10 tlIY'pla0flt!d Net T112•fe ySSIT M Nm HN
Pq 4Ve 11¢1 a41 — D0:61P '1.@145uWry 06, ISVJ ;uuawNOl +.11PA •Ol
I'nr N,nl uo p10wMSy 'NO3
-b¢'MS ep1 q.M Ow V!WISA al!uann� Alu'xq a,!yty,xe ALtl3a0nQ'SDNI033JOVd
e4¢I IIIm g_ oyl .lsalnln is Sll35nH]VSStln 3tlfISDTD3tlOf
apH%A aw Jo T4 w)O¢y] na 30 N11tl'VNmon N1 N011]Y l03DLLON
lutnuM) Siup— aln u • VN"DidJ91
pa^nId'u4ua0 a Aliues % uoP • :tl3011nll 131,1000 .R)HraPuaMO
P 106¢Misla.411. 11.111NOIIYJI18OdYAO SNUWWn5 tlua
>•>41 Iat Ila L1G1C 13 'sasnnaa 11aM'asnud5 to
@Did 1!'Pa01I >qoyy> JMS '.10 .0l Isa,alu! ut fu!nIa Aew sa!1
.Z66t lP Vs((11 bWV CJMS nP1Hatl4d0 NO11tlNMtl31 -,ed umou4un I'MI RING,
4141 ueera Fga'N s! OaNON 'Np17)lOnd ONV38VD 'PAST to P4ap N,M-umou4.
331ION 10u•are anoM M)W.pu.la0
31YS.JIIeljq W4U qe 4110MIa'
6O01E91 NN Dun ;ytliwuW 'Aq'6g
'tIO2'Satmf:gN •rulel> s¢rLVd mMoutlon ne,
Pu1.'Ou'>A IP --m
1OfLt1]S9SSSLOt(T:NIA - TT -4 u,4un siva
d 3315461 Ota9p41 NO1' - >'%] ,@410- SOa1rre.D,
LlAl'91-90:31VA NOLLDOY 12035 aUr4'62 W:gN 'e qA.O'atnoe5.so
rG+(iL 1114 um1 — u!ga Aew t>W"
- - ',te:6 aDu!pAtu! t>lon ,0 ul,vaV tnwl Dil, ,aVlaVM •anpa
lY Le61C 'IJ '31)lOP'W%WOf 1 no•O JI :sF.Cp:1 utN3101 l0 P¢ap aq o) UMou410u a,i
OYOtl'3300N]33V0 SYf.[ltl t!Baiw,aaMa na!npi41¢ a41 ym (z)IucnuOiaa Pawau
3M1DnOLnY AWO3-Itll
.lv- o13H 3e 01 'Sale IIIj�".^' •,i�'.;.'. ?'NpNtepa'6 e,*', s oN)aex!.
tlOGONtl ANV 1N13n UO- »aa�'•^='r'^'-•^-''"
1d3]JY Ol 1101tl 3111
. S.Mbllsu- A1Nn0a•Itl1
Na",35 S3lnitlt5
Ya1tl0'N 011 NYAStlnd;N011
-Orttl.]f1OnA 1V 1135 111M
ONIM01 Y 3AUTlim HV
'A1HnO3'lvI IV
141' WAW
AA3tl3H SI 301LO. ]Vend
31Y5 anand
0C92Z91 M31
L102'S au I!Pnd
'9G5f•OlVE11
.11i10,IStl-ozz-Z11
.AYLaysa, wop 3S ioo[
IN, ""I
1X51 035E1n1.1 CNIA
IY—N H POPE
9Y1GIBnZ13D[A]1111#NIA
tl3U01d[3 an03 ZOO(
PSVTC31X11NSSIN toolA
6LLL63 ASSIN loot lA
�' Sua(9atry'se�JpitiN,e~�`'aa f
I�91-
WIlInDaS NON
UadedtmaN>stoj Aif PWL Ltot'S Punt`AepUoly 3D
PETITION FOR UM
ABANDONMENT OF PUBLICLY DEDICATED
E
RIGHTS-0F-WAY, STREET, OR ALLEY�v,�
Coin t)b)Wg&S bf. . herebyp�ons ZOO
.
(Plifit mu
n - - 121-1-A AyEmyc sw .locates in
(MM4 alley, �, I
'rhe eas+ r c .
-o�-� o� /7?�-t�+ �e S
v�w lies caw -tile w&s4 !we o�
TracA- 12. Seg+004 Z OfAWSEV, 3 3 S aAft , starting at
none, parcel M or tract)
irkafingat
7+%+ S+ryu�e SW laying adjacent
to (or 12 ,-" �� Section ZQ' , Townswp�3$ - Range 31E , as recorded in
Plat Book t%/'A ,Page NOA , Public Records of Indian River County, Florida.
reason for this request is (should include mtended use of
Applicants Name
Address: 1901
— 15f.7-
rVrSto w
f
Date: 12- 7—ZOI (.w
List of property owners abutting the portion of the mad requested to be vacated (if any):
Name (Please
Telephone: E-mail:
Name (Please Print): K!e(� Wc-r �rSt�icf
E—
ae
Name (Plem
0
Telephone: I E-mail:
Name (Please Print):
Addrew:
Telephone: E-mail:
I M/ ft"& any � I_— "--.J.. M --
0
Attachment
Attachment 1
P147
RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR THE CLOSING,
ABANDONMENT, VACATION AND DISCONTINUANCE OF A PORTION OF
12TH AVENUE SW FROM 5TH STREET SW TO A POINT 165 FEET NORTH
OF 7TH STREET SW AS SHOWN ON THE LAST GENERAL PLAT OF THE
INDIAN RIVER FARMS COMPANY SUBDIVISION
WHEREAS, on December 13, 2016, the Indian River County Community Development
Department received a duly executed and documented petition from the Indian River County Public
Works Department requesting that the County close, vacate, abandon, discontinue, renounce and
disclaim any right, title and interest of the County and the public in and to a portion of 12th Avenue
SW from 5th Street SW to a point 165 feet north of 7th Street SW as shown on the Last General Plat
of The Indian River Farms Company Subdivision, as recorded in Plat Book 2, Page 25 of the Public
Records of St. Lucie (now Indian River) County, Florida; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with Florida Statutes 336.10, notice of a public hearing to
consider said petition was duly published; and
WHEREAS, after consideration of the petition, supporting documents, staff investigation and
report, and testimony of all those interested and present, the Board finds that the subject portion of
right-of-way is not a state or federal highway, not located within any municipality, not necessary for
continuity of the County's street and thoroughfare network, and does not provide exclusive access to
any private property.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that:
1. All right, title and interest of the County and the public in and to that certain right-of-way
segment more particularly described as follows:
Being a Portion of 12th Avenue Southwest Right -of -Way, Lying in Section 24, Township 33
South, Range 39 East, as shown on the Last General Plat of The Indian River Farms
Company Subdivision, as recorded in Plat Book 2, Page 25, of the Public Records of St.
Lucie (now Indian River) County, Florida. Said parcel being more particularly described as
follows:
Being the West 30.0 feet of the Northwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of said Section 24,
Township 33 South, Range 39 East lying adjacent and contiguous to the West line of Tract
12, according to said Last General Plat of The Indian River Farms Company Subdivision,
less the North 30.00 feet thereof for the Indian River Farms Water Control District Sub -
Lateral J-1 Canal Right-of-way and less the South 165.00 feet thereof.
Containing 34,211 square feet, (0.78Acres) more or less
Lying and being in Indian River County, Florida, is hereby forever closed, abandoned,
renounced, disclaimed, and vacated (see Exhibit A attached).
Attachment 3
P149
2. The closing, vacation, and abandonment of this portion of public right-of-way is in the best
interests of the public.
3. Notice of the adoption of this resolution shall be forthwith published once within thirty (30)
days from the date of adoption hereof.
4. The Clerk is hereby directed to record this resolution together with the proofs of publication
required by Florida Statutes 336.10 in the Official Record Books of Indian River County
without undue delay.
5. Ownership of the right-of-way shall revert entirely to the adjacent property to the east.
The foregoing resolution was offered by Commissioner
adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
a vote, the vote was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
who moved its
and upon being put to
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day of
, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court and Comptroller
:•
Deputy Clerk
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, and officer duly authorized in this State and
County to take acknowledgments, personally appeared , and
as Chairman of the Board of County Commissioners and Deputy Clerk,
respectively, to me known to be the persons described in and who executed the foregoing instrument
and they acknowledged before me that they executed the same.
Attachment 3
P150
WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State. last aforesaid this day of
.2017.
Notary Public
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
APPROVED AS TO PLANNING MATTERS
Stan Boling, AICP, Director
Community Development Department
Attachment 3
P151
9
0
0
D
Q
W
m
J
W
ketch and Description fora/ND/ANR/VER COUNTY
Exhibit A
Legal Description (12th Avenue SW Right -of-Way Abandonment)
Being a Portion of 12th Avenue Southwest Right -of -Way, Lying in Section 24, Township 33 South, Range 39 East, as shown
on the Last General Plat of The Indian River Farms Company Subdivision, as recorded in Plat Book 2, Page 25, of the Public
Records of St. Lucie (now Indian River) County, Florida. Said parcel being more particularly described as follows:
Being the West 30.0 feet of the Northwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of said Section 24, Township 33 South, Range 39 East.
lying adjacent and contiguous to the West line of Tract 12, according to said Last General Plat of The Indian River Farms
Company Subdivision, less the North 30.00 feet thereof for the Indian River Farms Water Control District Sub -Lateral J-1
Canal Right-of-way and less the South 165.00 feet thereof.
Containing 34;211 square feet, (0.78Acres) more or less
Surveyor's Notes
1) This sketch and Legal Description was prepared with the benefit of a Boundary Survey prepared by Indian River County
Survey Section, Job No. 1601, Dated June 23, 2016
2) This legal description .shall not be valid unless:
(A) Provided in its entirety consisting of 2 sheets , with sheet 2 showing the
sketch of the legal description.
(B) Reproductions of the description and sketch are not valid unless signed and sealed with
an embossed surveyor's seal.
Certification
(Not valid without the signature and original
raised seal of a Florida licensed Surveyor and Mapper)
I hereby certify that the Sketch and Legal Description of the property shown and
described hereon was completed under my direction and said Sketch and Legal
is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
I further certify that this Sketch and Description meets the St ancaru3 of Practine
for .surveys set forth by the Florida Professional Board of Survayon. and
Mappers in chapter 5J-17.052 Florida Administrative code, pursuant to seatbn
472.027 Florida State Statutes. ,
a' -?
Date of Signature David K Silon
Professional Surveyor and Mapper
This is not a Bounds SurveyFlorida Certificate, No. 6139
AGENCY: INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FL
PURL/C WORKS O£PTANG/NEER/NG 01Y. Sketch and L eqa/ Description
7 (DRAWN
SCALE:
N/A
EET:
> 01-2
R. /NOLETT for. -
BY: n c» /7A//ND/ANRIVER COUNTY
Attachment 3
P152
Sketch and L &ga/Description for.
INDIANRIVER COUNTY , Exhibit A
RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE I RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE
NORTHWEST CORNER OF
THE SOUTHWEST 1/4 5th STREET SW 0
SECTION 24-33-39
d- 1i
L
I.R.F.W.C.D. SUB -LATERAL E-7 CANAL N 1.R F. W.C.D. 5118-LA�AL J-1 CANAL
RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE
o, 301-----J WEST LINE OF TRACT 12 AND L SkS NORTH 30'
T CANAL R/W EAST RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE FOR `CANAL R/W
s OF 12th AVENUE SW
in I.R. F. W. C. D.
SEC. 23 LATERAL "E" CANAL--;C.._SEC. 24
T33S, R39E (30' CANAL R/W) T33S, R39E
m NORTHWEST 1/4 OF
a Z
J THE SOUTHWEST 1/4
TRACT 9 � TRACT 12
1.R.F C. S. Q 1.R. F. C.S.
(PBS 2, PGE 25) r'�.. r33'-39-24-00000-5000-00001.0
BS 2, PGE 25)
a EAST UNE OF TRACT 9 AND N
�a WEST RIGHT-OF-WAY UNE-- '� 2012 LT1-FL-PHP, LLC
LATERAL "E" CANAL
.R.B. 2663, PAGE 838)
0
KENNETH CHILDERS
33-39-23-00001-0090-00001.1
(O.R.B. 1492, PAGE 1058)
TRACT 16 NORTHWEST O1TH WES1 CORNER F THE
1. R. F. C. S. SOUTHWEST 1/4
(PBS 2, PGE 25) SEC. 24-MS-R39E
NOT TO SCALE
This is not a Boundary Survey
SOUTHWEST CORNER
SECTION 24-33-39---
23
26
A`'tNUY: IN 0/,4N R/V£R COUNTY, FL
PURL/C WORKS DEPT./£NG/N££R/NG MY.
DATE: 6/06/17 I DRAWN BY: R. /NGL£TT
A11A -
2 OF 2 OB N0:
-------T-- PARCEL 3
:s
0
= O,
(TRACT 12 LESS THE
wq
NORTHEAST 1/4)
J co
(O.R.B. 2663, PAGE 838)
7th STREET SW
M OSLO PARK
BLOCK "K"
(PB 3, PGE 96)
N
Legend and Abbreviations
DB = DEED BOOK
24
I.R.F.W.C.D. = INDIAN RIVER FARMS
WATER CONTROL DISTRICT
I—
I.R.F.C.S. = INDIAN RIVER FARMS
COMPANY SUBDIVISION
25
LLC = LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
O.R.B. = OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK
PB = PLAT BOOK
PBS = PLAT BOOK ST. LUCIE
PGE. = PAGE
R = RANGE
RNV = RIGHT-OF-WAY
SEC. = SECTION
SW = SOUTHWEST
T.I.I.F. = TRUSTEES OF THE INTERNAL
IMPROVEMENT FUND
T = TOWNSHIP
Slretch and L egal Description
for,-
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
Attachment 3
121h Avenue SW Right -of -Way
Abandonment
Board of County Commissioners
June 20, 2017
Location Map
6TH SVMZT S.
`t
Proposed 121h AvenueSW '�
("paper street") ROW
abandonment area
1; � E � � ��,�r•;"�� Lam...... �.,, ` � ,` 1
�o...�e....�—
----___----- _yr—�' --------- — ------- ---� 4
1,1 ,
1
I:� I'1 I'I ISI I'I ...... •�
11 1 1 I
r I 1 1
MW
lo.4-01.
,� � ,u r � � �", ,fig A,����^r `3• ,�_ � ,�'�•' "` �� �
v
V�, a 44
S
E 4,,x
Analysis
• Not formally improved
• Not needed for Thoroughfare Plan
• Requested in support of the County's
Osprey Acres Floway project
The Osprey Acres Floway project
eliminates the need for a 12th Avenue
SW connection between 5th Street
SW and Oslo Road
- 4
Staff Recommendation
➢ That the BCC abandon the subject portion of
right-of-way.
-3
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County .Attorney
01ce a, f
INDIAN
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners .
FROM: Dylan Reingold, County AttorneyV4-11~
DATE: June 13, 2017
SUBJECT: Right of Way Ordinance and Rate Resolution
BACKGROUND.
16JA3
Public Hearings - AC.C. 6.20.17
RIVER COUNTY
ATTORNEY
During the 2017 Florida Legislative Session, the Florida Legislature enacted the Advanced Wireless
Infrastructure Deployment Act, House Bill 687' (the "Act"). Although the Governor has not signed the
Act, the Act, if it becomes law, will become effective July 1, 2017.
Under the Act, local governments will have limited ability to prohibit, regulate, or charge for the
collocation of small wireless facilities in the public rights-of-way. The Act includes onerous permitting
requirements on local governments, including accelerated permitting timeframes, prohibition of permitting
fees for those noncharter counties, such as Indian River County (the "County"), already charging the local
communications services tax at a rate of 0.24 percent, and allowing applicants to combine 30 small
wireless facilities into one application. The Act limits the collocation fee for a small wireless facility on a
local government utility pole to no more than $150 per year.
The Act does allow local governments to adopt by ordinance provisions for insurance coverage,
indemnification, performance bonds, security funds, force majeure, abandonment, liability, or warranties.
On June 6, 2017, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners (the "Board") voted to
authorize the County Attorney's Office to draft an ordinance to ,address several of these issues. The
attached draft ordinance generally resembles the proposed language presented to the Board on June 6,
2017. There are two significant changes in the final draft. First, the proposed ordinance includes
performance security under section 312.11(D), for any free stranding poles in the right-of-way. Thus, in
the event a free standing pole is abandoned, the County will have funds to remove such pole. Second,
additional requirements for collocation have been included under section 312.14. Such additional
requirements include plaques for collocations so structures or objects can be properly identified,
concealment and design criteria for collocations and associated equipment and submission of structural
analysis and wind load calculations for collocations.
Also, the County Attorney's Office has prepared the attached rate resolution for annual user fees and
permit fees for collocations. The fee for an installation on County utility poles or other equipment or
F. L1m wyU,.dolG$NF.RALIBCC4dgeudaAfemorVttghr<FlPayrUrachmert prrihnnee Md -
P154
Board of County Commissioners
June 13, 2017
Page Two
structures in the County Right -of -Way will be $600.00 per location, with a re -inspection fee if necessary
of $300.00. The annual fee will be $150:00 per location.
FUNDING.
The cost of publication of the required public notice for this public hearing was $148.78. This cost was
funded from the County Attorney's Office budget within the General Fund (account number 00110214-
033190). Any annual fees obtained will be deposited into General Fund/Miscellaneous/Rents & Royalties
(001038-362010). Any permit fees will be deposited into Transportation Fund/Permit-Fee/Other Permits
(111032-329090).
RECOMMENDATION.
The County Attorney's Office recommends that the Chair open the public hearing and take public
comment and then have the Board vote to approve the proposed right-of-way ordinance and rate
resolution.
ATTACHMENT(S).
Proposed Right of Way Ordinance
Proposed Rate Resolution
F:Wttor -YD'U d-*DVFRIUB CCW9-d-,W—{Rlahtoj-1VayAU-h—t "bwnce(2). n
P155
t
[Treasure Coast Newspapers I TCPAIM'l
Indian River Press Journal
1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32960
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared, Sherri Cipriani, who on oath says that she is Classified Inside Sales
Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida: that the
attached copy of advertisement was published in the Indian River Press Journal in the following issues below. Affiant further
says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published in Vero Beach in said Indian River County, Florida, and
that said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, daily and distributed in
Indian River County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement;
and affiant further says that she has neither paid or promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission
or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. The Indian River Press Journal
has been entered as Periodical Matter at the Post Offices in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period
of one year next preceding the first pulahcatiun o9 the a, -,ached ccp^; of zdver!isement.
Customer Ad Number Copyline PO #
461741- INDIAN RIVER CO ATTORNEYS OFC 1640382 Hearing: 6/20/17 Hearing: 6/20/17
Pub Dates
June 10, 201W---,,
Sworn to'dgd suf <r?k)ed before me Vis daiy;of, June 09, 2017, by
Sherri Cipriani
(X) personally known to me or
( ) who has produced
Klein
who is
as identification.
Notary Public
I oAJ
P 155-1
;••'SeJa�'Ni;''
n �;'
LINDA JOYCE KLEIN
Notary Public - State of Florida
Commission H GG 081422
My Comm, Expires Mar 4, 2021
Ilnndedthr00 gh National Notary Assn,
I oAJ
P 155-1
1x'60 Saturday, June 10, 2017 Treasure Coast Newspapers
ACROSS
1 LOct as
45 Lose focus -
48 OUltter•s cry
Answer to pvl all'
5 Amiable
51 Carrion
leaders
T O T O C I
9 Social insect
12 Release
53 PrecNca
I R E N E A 11R L E I
money
56 Sou! singer
-demes
ABETS N I B B L E D
13 Countess's
husband
57 Neptune's
A P P T ORAL S
14 Sugarloaf
kingf corn
R E P R O S R I
locate
15 Notion
59 Compotes a
WOW I T C H EST A
t6 '•-Goes•'
60 Prince Val's
ROE TALE R E A M
18 Area
20 Leaks
IS
61 No and sic
AFRO BULK P R O
22ExplsiPSST
62 "What-
LE V I I RK
22 Explosive
15 new?"
TAE E S S A Y
23 Riggror. Ross
DOWN
F A K E D M D S E
26 Ogled
t Heron kin
g V A R ICE E A R T H
33 Cc obi ie
2 Consumer
advocate
ate
M I L OAS S L A K E
34 ZINerIIng
ap
ESE SPA S H O
35 Water, In Baja
37 Sheik
3 Reunion
attendee
8 ,john of 17 Mono l5 buy
f
colleague
4 Scheduled
"oh o 19 Garfield
39 Male doll
40 Trail
5 Approach
9 Grand Canyon canine pal
but
mjx
41 Yoga position
6 -Holm of
"Alien^
Inas
10 Number Unca d
43 Bedwear,
7 Get misty-
f muses 24 atln g
briefly
eyed
11 Duds amppss
25ictional
Cheek No
waoc mora Pa:slasa
"Just r411ht C....-
out
.1 cud11Driv.-ka.com 27 Hearty laugh
28 Parts season
2 329
s a
++ Lair
place, fenced yard, W/D;
Sec Dep 233-0262
Pool. a""`I7
from chapping mallli
30 Funny fellow
31 It may be
fragile
+s
+e
32 Plant prickle
36 Orchard
a
h aBenCH ue sC,0RES
3BR, Vero
Shores 5365,000.00 For Sale
product
21
;- WEB ID_16N342.
-
38 A gemstone
42 LP protector
23
4
44 Casualwear
21 ze 46 No later than
odes-UrIRJrn
-tr 6-17091
6
•= Www.We therbe
Townho r -P-
47 Evaluates
- WEB_101611819_•-"NJ
55+1 280/2BA Con00 FOr
Sale. upgraded ttlroughout -
48 Moons elle
6
37
39 111
river Jew tondo at Narbour
Isle. 2 SR house, 2
ahYhIXR/Be8L11. ,NOpGty/
50 "Rush Hour"
FORT PIERCE NORTH RUCNunfurnished
3/2, pool, 2 garage,
$2000. Call 772 -
4a tar
51 Cackler.
as
w 4s
47 52 Courtesy
sa s
s+encl.
54 Louis XIV, e.g.
-_
-. --
-- 55 Weep
o -to oa)+r UFS,oM.gAnamw Mdamtrlb5
' oti[e TO Greditdrs
DtIMTU Creditors �No Ce To rediYon s
representatives and the per-
.anal representatives' alter-
da 32961
ALL CLAIMS NOT FILFD WITH- Attamey foe ,.1,11 al
IN THE TIME PERIODS SET
ey are set forth below-
All cradfOrs of the decedent
Representative:
FORTH IN FLORIDA STAMES john Joseph McHugh, Jr.,
SECTION 733.702 WILL BE
and other Oersons having
Esgwre
FOREVER BARRED. Email:
clalrns Or demands against
decedent's estate an who
NOTWITHSTANDING THE TIME Iphn@a mchughlaw.e0m
PERIODS SET FORTH ABOVE, coo
a cap f this notice
Ontl Bar No
ANY CLAIM FILED TWO (2) john Joseph McHugh, Jr.,
qulred to be served must
file their claims ith this
YEARS OR MORE AFTER THE Esquire
DECEDENT'S DATE OF DEATH
court WITHIN THE LATER OF
p0 Box 280]
IS BARRED. Ver, Beach Florida 32961
Personal Representatives:
John 6. Hudson, Jr.
401512th Place SW
Vero Beach, Florida 3299688
And
Pamela H. Hendrix
62201st Street SW
Vero Beach, Imida 32968
Attorney for Personal
ReRra_rtaWa_
lust." K. Larson
Florida Bar No. lIU25
Gould Cooks¢yy Fennell, PA
Vero Beach nR 32963 arc
Telephone: (712)231.1100
jkl-eservice(L9ouldcaoksey.
coon
Pub: June 10,17, 2017
TCN 1643SU
ST,ILUGECOUN97. ran
FLORIDA
PROBATE DIVISION
File NO.:
562017CP000255FMXXXX
IN RE ESTATE OF
MARGGA ETAMES,
NOTICE TO CREDITORS
The administration of the
state of Margaret James.
death ecssewasd, wNovemberdate at
13.
2016, Is pending in the Circuit
Iloridat Probate Dfv(siConl.nthe'
address of.kh is 2185ou h
Second Street• Fort Pierces
Florida 34950. Then e
and ddr..... f the p
nal representative and Me
¢ars
enal representative's
ttom¢y are sN forth below.
All creditors of the decedent
and other or persoclans hemands aving
decede estate an whoinst
m a
copy i[Nisnoticeisrequired
to be served must file their
.alms with this court ON
OR BEFORE THE LATER OF
3 MONTHS AFTER THE TIME
OF THEFIRST PUBLICATION
OF THIS NOTICE OR 30 DAYS
AFTER THE DATE OF SERVICE
OF A COPY OF THIS NOTICE
Olml NpTHEM.
Adecedent and other persons
having claims or demands
against decedent's estate
ust file their claims with
this court WITHIN 3 MONTHS
AFTER THE DATE OF THE
FIRST PUBLICATION OF THIS
NOTICE
�PUbOC Notices.
NOTICE OF INTENT
PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that
misseo ers of Intl an River
Countyry. Florida, will conduct
a Pub Hearing to consider
adoption of a G oposed ordi-
nance entitled:
AND DINANCE OFTHE BOARD
OF COUNTY COMMISSION-
ERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUN-
TY, FLORIDA, AMENDING
SECT ON 312,11 (PERFOR-
MANCE SECURITY). SECTION
312.13 (TERMINATION OF USE
AND SECTION 31' 11(PU80R hOVAL OF C
PROTECTION AND LIABIOTY)
OFPTER 312 (RIGHTS-
OF-WAYjCHAOF THE CODE OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY,
FLORIDA IN ORDER TO PRO-
VIDE ADDITIONAL BE IRE'
MENTS FOR INSTALLATION
IN COUNTY RIGHTS-OF-WAY;
AND PROVIDING FOR COD-
IFICATION, SEVERABILITY,
REPEAL OF CONFLICTING
PROVISIONS, AND AN EFFEC-
TIVE DATE
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY BOARD
OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
JOSEPH E- FLESCHER,
CHAIRMAN
Pub: June 10, 2017
TCN IW0382
NOTICE PUBLIC HEARING
Thedate of first publication of Tel
ephone• 772-77&000 An Ordinance of the City of
Nis notice lsJune
3, 2017. Pub:lune 3, 10, 2017 Vero Beach, Florida, amend-
AnclllaryPersonai In Chapter 58 ofthe Code of
Representative:
STEPHEN P. JAMES
4350 B,Uer Road
Reisterstown
Ma land 21136
Attom¢ys for esente y
Personal RepresentaLve:
STEGER LAW
8y Sam T. ste9er,EsQQuire
Florida ear No.280496
603 S.W. Cleveland Avenue
Stuart, Florida 34994
(7721 287-88M
Fax: (772)220-3518
E -Service:
Primary Desiggnation: stsser-
lst ¢secondary: cam
m@ste-
Pub June 3. 10,2017
TCN 1635520
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR
NDIAN RIVER COUNTY,
FLORIDA
PROBATE DIVISION
File No.: 312017CP000469
IN RE: ESTATE OF
THERESA JOHNSTON
THERESA MHNSTON
�.IO
THERESA'. JOHNSTON,
Deceased
TCN 3635034
Vero
ence: PRE-BID MEETING: A
Sin pet Band Retirtr
e 1. too add°a new ArtiNe
III to be _UUed "Other
IN THE GIRCUITCOURTOFTHE
NINETEENTH IUDICIAL
Post -Employment Benefits'
(OPEB); Creating an OPER
CIRCUIT IN AND FOR MARTIN
Tnrst and Providing for Its
Administration; Providing
COUNTY, FLORIDA
for Confiktar Severability;
PROBATE DIVISION
NO.:
772338-1935 WEB
FILE
432017CP000324CPAXMX
andviPrloovviiding fordancEHec(
five Date.
IN RE: ESTATE OF
RENA
Deceased.,
Personal Rep men t,ti -
Up John JosepP 0. 6 ugh8,o
Personal Representative:
2713 Seashore Cove
Attamey for Pe..n.1 VA 23454
Representative:
Steven
H. Wlsaker
wi keriaw@ggmail.conn
Fisokeriaw@Ilotma0.com
lorida Bar No. 0110612
2725 Judge Fran Jamieson
Way, Bab• E
Viers, FL 32940
321-501.0221
Pub: June 3. 10, 2017
TCN 1632845
The City Council of the City 1
Ven. ulicahe'uieg concerning
the Adoption of an ON!nance
with
the tide asshown at
the Cltym Hall,lCoundl Chamn
bars. at la.2Mh P]ace, Vero
alas,. of Mas public hear ng
the Ordinance Into law. nact this
Interepsted pathNes m y obtain
nce at
the 'ce of the Gly Clerk
tt City Hall and are welcome
o attend the public hearing
concern,n V. Ordinante-
Anyane h m y viish to
a, any decision which
y De made at this hear
in It will
eed to ensure that
". record
of
erb.the
P udeii' itesta�onywhichd
evidence upon hien and
coca., o basehisd- Anyone who
S
a speclat accommo•
datiLa fthe City.
-AmeU.rrien5
with Disabilities Act (ADA)
Coordinator at at
least 48 hours In9ad ane a of
the meeting.
CITY OF VERO BEACH,
FLORIDA
BY: Tammy K. Vock, MMC
City Gerk
Pub: June 10, 2017
TCN 1c36M
�eiluestfor olds
SCHOOL DISTRICT OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
60556280 AVENUE
VERO BEACH, FL. 32967
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL
RFP FOR ATHLETIC
FIELD MANAGEMENT
RFP-15-0.2017/JC
The School District of Indian
River County repuests inter-
ested paled .bids/o o it kis
for the above referencedsa
Scope of Work: The p noose
d intens of this RFP is for
the outsourcin of all Ber-
SchooeDlstrlctisital Scope
Is W Include the anage-
ment of all Be 1' grass
fields, to Include atenag,
fertilizing, mowing, pest con-
t"''e Uoa, top dressing
sod repair, etc. as required
to keep the Dishlct's fields In
ezcellent playing condition
n A green manner and to
.,.,.'.a rthit. ImPRt to the
environmOrdering Instructions• This
peck.ga can be anEStardon
ff ow bsite at httpJ/www.
demaedstarcom. Or by con-
tacting Jeff Carver.
Pre/Bid Proposal Confer-
,egUestfor Bids
'Fogle By OWner
ence: PRE-BID MEETING: A
FORT PIERCE - HOME FOR
on -mandatory prebid meat•
Ing will be held on lune 14,
SALE No cred'd/bad credit
ok, Owner financing 3/35/2
2017 @ 10:00AM at [he OIs-
trlct'S Purchasing- DeOar"
corner lot golf community
low NOA'M0a n" can
menL Suppport Serntt Cam•
glex,605562nd Avenue.Vero
boon. GREAT BUYI Quick
Nos e. S700X. 10%down. Call
101636221
Beach, R 32967. Instructions
for scheduling site visits will
772338-1935 WEB
be provided at this meeting.
Due Date/Time: 6/29/2017
HOME FOR SALE Owner
financing o credit, bad
2:00 PM Eastern
School District of Indian River
credit ok 385 35th Ave, Vero
Beach 3/2/1 newer roof
Counttyh must receive bids no
laterrox
datr
bs large private
$165K down
B isrecelvedafteSaid
Such time
will be returned unopened.
lard
51,320/m5o call 772.5381935
NOTE: ALL PROSPECTIVE BID-
a4(772)538-1935
iC'OtSy/A[_�r0 efOf_Sa_le
•fig_.
DERS/RESPONDENTS ARE
HEREBY CAUTIONED NOT TO
CONTACT ANY MEMBER OF
- _ _. _
STUART - Rocky Polot 5416 SE
THE SCHOOL DISTRICT OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTYSTAFF
Orange SL 34997; 70' x 110'
lot has deeded access to a
OR OFFICIALS OTHER THAN
THE SPECIFIED CONTACT
PERSON.
private marina: clty water
15105,000;(772)186-0140
WEB 101633690
M/WBPs are encouraged to
participate in the bid pro-
cess.
ro- Real Eslate AUCNOn
Contact JeHCarver FT PIERCE/PORT ST. LUCIE
Director N dn"Ing
Phone; 7725645050
ON-SITE
Pub: lune 1'. 2017
TCN 1643821
AUCTIONS
'- - _ ---'
i`RealEstale
Saturday, June 10 -
10.00 AM'
969 & 979 SW McDevitt'
- Ave. Vacant
Open Houses
ntiPSL
Residential Lot%ats, BOx125ea.
I;;(•�m- vERo REACH ,.;
=IW. E
10:45 AM
16625WSylvester Lo PSL.
(SCh StSW between
ey
'[27th Ave& -Mrd Ave)�f..
Vacant Residential Lot
BO%125
OPEN SUNDAY, NOON-4PM
11:15 AM
701 Okracoke Sq SW$
.. - --
-
SW Aster Rd, PSL
- Great location wNh' I,,
fares(,
'�tAA.panoramicIn
can
yawntResjot90xI25. -
front Lot 90x125.
1.
82.`x'2 d+IOen/21,a/2c9 0lir`:5,
large screened lanN. paver
12. NOON
tlgeat I9hhwhood.
AH I fwjunI6279,9000-
s}o
TRIG 511th SL Ft Pierce.
' Vacant Residentail lot
i For more I or Appt.
-
70x135
WE81D 1fi34807 Y"
Jt070esFOTSaIe
- - -
1ENSEN BEACH
Forthh&atker auedons v6il:
...bse.aucti-as -
7ERM5: 10%yyBuyer's
PreBalldnceatlu /atle.
da
oPinecrest1 cent
Lakes. CBS 3/2/2 on I acre,
WESI 1 43o. (560324-0244
WEBID16434T5
PORT SL LOGE •Updated
4/2/L New A/C, StnlS Steel
allhaer rra ty,
30 cl:
Y 0-
Pm'ier tr New -
Priori Sok,
_ Call 'son ucti 79 ,
la AAAI Auction Co:
ABlll:' AU231 .
Wl w-
... rewan
Dears Driveway Move In
ready!$20 D 1620932
(77340-28]1
i
PORT ST: IVCIE'23tory
HOme,Water View Ibd/L51
bath- 25006y fL
gated comm
/resort r
parbllents-FUrnl9hedN
Oke Move cadY.olesj
Move In ReatdLy,ro
(
STUART • Downtown
pia
floor pan; 55, gran. ,0
"sORd 2 car Oar, home waN
eac
waterfront efnclenccyy,
$950/.0.+S=yIn. A/C
r ty,yt call s 772-475-9590
f271,990y WEB ID 16101a1J
& all ub1s. Geon; No Pets.
Minimum 6 months a.rpr .
ST. LUCIE WEST - Casscades
772-283-5677fOrmare Info
WEB ID 1611688
55+ Like naw. 3/2/2. 1876sf
/c open, airy wide lake, Ig
IGE MBD. Reduttd S15,aa
VERO BEACH - IBR, Modem;
t0 5259,900. Principals onl
%
2nd D with balcony. Laundry
room. 5600/mo. 1122 16th St
this low price. owner
772-577-6484. WEB 1630451
CMI nz-s3e-ap]5
STUART YACHT&CC
�r.1�
'�tpartrnen�_fU-.
3b02ba Fairway ham¢,
5299,900; 772-215-5284
T' --- FORTPIIERCE'
Karo!Grgiud l
Licensed RE Broker
WEB ID 1641864
1872/IBA 2BR/2.SBA
Certenilla9e.net
(772) 466-1505
MG BEACH" 2 bdrm, to Ilv-,1611869
I , room,TV room, at -In
. kitchn, 2 baths, walk -In
IEMSEN BEACH - 1/I small
house on ri erfront, f re -
Closets. Carage &fenced
In, Gated
place, fenced yard, W/D;
Sec Dep 233-0262
Pool. a""`I7
from chapping mallli
5900 plus
Harocs
wly renovates• $135,000
1,(917)974-7586 WEB 16140381
VER0 -BEACH--= IDd/lbs.
Mohdl1FPXa"karSnoors
VERO� 2313
I to ro ts;,kl0 min
h aBenCH ue sC,0RES
3BR, Vero
Shores 5365,000.00 For Sale
F85, Lease/Purchase OptaI
Aail, Cell Vicki 772JS1-9051
By Owner 3/2/1- Rec"'
updated with new cabinets,
;- WEB ID_16N342.
-
c pet and paint No a"".5%WNTTEdTVT'''"rh
or sidenelghb WEB ID
1612339 (40T)946-5716
Townhome community .a•�
2BeT72-dno4 POoI
odes-UrIRJrn
-tr 6-17091
6
•= Www.We therbe
Townho r -P-
FOpT PIERCE •High Point
- WEB_101611819_•-"NJ
55+1 280/2BA Con00 FOr
Sale. upgraded ttlroughout -
DRIPS FUrnWteil
55 apPla. q"He counters.
screened porch, Southern
blinds. 772-207-8629 or 772-
YERO BFACH-LU%URVRENT-
ALSFurnished Targe 2 BR
201.3559 WEB ID 1617393
river Jew tondo at Narbour
Isle. 2 SR house, 2
ahYhIXR/Be8L11. ,NOpGty/
ggFurnyiis�hed
for 51700/mlanN•nOr, Wge
FORT PIERCE NORTH RUCNunfurnished
3/2, pool, 2 garage,
$2000. Call 772 -
Oman Resort Paradise. 2bd/
lba.fumished.Ocean/ Iver/
633-1776
Marina. Pool & tennis. Rent-
Hd.,4reyl1,�,"ikr�nis_• wed
ed monthly for $1,200; seg
$139,000. Call Van 772-519•
'
0962 WEBJD1614190
PORT ST LUCIE - 3/2/2
Den, Large kitchen. Tile
HUTCHINSON 15 STUART
Dunes club, Directly an
floors, New InVEXt pain4
fentyced yy rd. lawn tare Inti.
beat Furn'/Super Geanl use,
FIS HH2 o pets.$ W 810
Faces pool. 5299.000 Owner.
1636104
grandemy4ent d-aom
105-692-9264 WEBIDEB ID 1615284
VERO BEACH PofnteWestLake
4 5/3/2+2. 2Lev¢Iz, 3900spH t
VerYDe9ant•neatYlle'grRlte
rA20U riJCS
GIIW/D•Den'Patlo'Pool'Prch
- 51805' FLS' 72-453-4842 t
PL Pierce Tanglewood
Golf+Pleygrnds, WEB 1611598
Moble Nom Sales ine
Brand New 20173/216'x66'.rpp
OS FU1615hhed
Newly Renov 19963/216'x6fi
Ca11772-682-0137forpricing-
Inhouse Fin, Avail n Qua,
DEWAR-272 DeIMaz Ocean
front Complex Great Om•
bu�ers;All ageamilytamm
.len to dMHP.com
pr get away Close to shops
Beautiful
NOB' SOUND- Beautiful, 2/2,
Pool & Beach Avail,
Move in Ready, new kit. WD,
Call 305-968-1994 101623277
srned poral, w 10x12
den singe shed new A/C,
ao _
walk in closets, water son-
nen, SESk call T72-546-6090
,Condos unfurnished
„ �,. ..�,yf
On 772-341-9011 Ip 1627459
STIART -2BR/28A, 2nd Floor.
laun-
1C_�eredp00e
PORT ST LUCIE • 55+,
Spanish Lakes Lg 3/1 2005,
mry klnoggli13N/
+ tris FLS Call (774)392-
56' dbl wide, jlrepla.. Car-
1007 WEB ID 1619077
high eiligs; Brand
part.con
SMART SOUTH• Mile, Grant
o dI$30K, Make Offerl
Lot rent $518. (772)341-2718
CC. . 55+, 2nd floor, pool,
WEB ID 1637932
dpatio,walktoInter-
c
coastal, amenities, available
_
VERO BEACH SS+, -Comm.
Lrg 26d/l.sba. Completelyy
Augus[ist. $875 FLS
alti72-286-3089 ID1643539
updated in Pristine Cantl!
Cent Air, Must See! Minutes
STUART• CONQUISTADOR
tram shoppingg &beach. Na
p t' $14,908 Av eX`ith
2brRba, 51100 annual. FLS,
Call John T72.283-]72]
772-217-1247- Weh Id 1644320
WEB ID 1643404
ORDINANCE NO. 2017 -
AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING SECTION 312.11
(PERFORMANCE SECURITY), SECTION 312.13 (TERMINATION OF USE OR
REMOVAL OF OBJECT) AND SECTION 312.14 (PUBLIC PROTECTION AND
LIABILITY) OF CHAPTER 312 (RIGHTS-OF-WAY) OF THE CODE OF INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA IN ORDER TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
REQUIREMENTS FOR INSTALLATION IN COUNTY RIGHTS-OF-WAY; AND
PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION, SEVERABILITY, REPEAL OF
CONFLICTING PROVISIONS, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, per House Bill 687 (2017), local governments are allowed to adopt by
ordinance provisions for insurance coverage, indemnification, performance bonds, security
funds, force majeure, abandonment, authority liability, or authority warranties under the
Advanced Wireless Infrastructure Deployment Act; and
WHEREAS, installations under the Advanced Wireless Infrastructure Deployment Act
must comply with applicable codes including objective design standards adopted by ordinance;
and
WHEREAS, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners desires through
this ordinance to adopt necessary ordinance provisions and objective design standards in order
to ensure the protection of the health, safety and welfare of the public;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA THAT;
Section 1. Enactment Authority.
Article VIII, section 1 of the Florida Constitution and chapter 125, Florida Statutes vest broad
home rule powers in counties to enact ordinances, not inconsistent with general or special law,
for the purpose of protecting the public health, safety and welfare of the residents of the county.
The Board specifically determines that the enactment of this ordinance is necessary to protect
the health, safety and welfare of the residents of Indian River County.
Section 2. Legislative Findings.
The Board finds that the "Whereas" clauses above are true and correct, and hereby
incorporates such clauses as the legislative findings of the Board.
1
P156
Section 3. Amendment of Section 312.11 (Performance Security), Section 31213
(Termination of Use or Removal of Object) and Section 312.14 (Public Protection and
Liability) of Chapter 312 (Rights -Of -Way).
New language indicated by underline, and deleted language indicated by E;tFikethrough.
Section 312.11 (Performance Security), Section 312.13 (Termination of Use and Removal of
Object) and Section 312.14 (Public Protection and Liability) of Chapter 312 (Rights -Of -Way) of
the Code of Indian River County, Florida is hereby amended to read as follows:
CHAPTER 312. RIGHTS -Of -WAY
Section 312.11. Performance Security.
A. Security bond shall be posted to secure completion of all construction or installation
commenced, pursuant to a permit under this chapter, except for construction of
driveways not requiring a roadway modification, for utility placement by utility companies
having a valid franchise to operate in Indian River County, for drainage structures
serving single family residences located in ditches parallel to the roadway, and
pedestrian bikepath facilities. Security bond shall be posted in the amount of one
hundred fifteen (115) percent of the estimated costs of the proposed improvements in
the right-of-way. The estimate shall be prepared by an engineer registered in the State
of Florida to practice professional engineering. Upon completion and approval by the
public works director of all required improvements, ninety (90) percent of the posted
security will be released by the public works director. A ten (10) percent warranty
security will be held for an additional twelve (12) months, following which time, if all
improvements are free of defects due to faulty field engineering, workmanship, or
materials, this ten (10) percent security will be released by the public works director.
B. In lieu of the above security, the permittee may post in an escrow account one
hundred fifteen (115) percent of the estimated cost of the improvements in the right-of-
way. Partial release may be authorized (up to ninety (90) percent of the posted security)
as work is approved. The remaining ten (10) percent will be held for an additional twelve
(12) months, following such time, if all improvements are .free of defects due to faulty
field engineering, workmanship or materials, this ten (10) percent of the security will be
released by the county public works director.
C. Any user placing or installing any structure or obiect on County utility poles or other
equipment or structures within the right-of-way shall ensure that at least thirty (30) days
prior to the commencement of any work on County utility poles or equipment or
structures, the user, provide the Public Works Director security, in the form of a letter of
2
P157
credit, in a form deemed legally sufficient by the County Attorney's Office, or cash,
posted in the amount of one hundred fifteen 0 15) percent of the estimated costs of all
required improvements for each location The estimate shall be prepared by an engineer
registered in the State of Florida to practice professional engineering. Upon completion
and approval by the Public Works Director of all required improvements, ninety (90)
percent of the posted security will be released by the Public Works Director. Ten (10)
Percent security funds shall remain in place at all times the structure or object remains
installed or placed on the County utility poles or other equipment or structures within the
right of way. If at any time, the security funds are not in place, the structure or object
shall be deemed abandoned and shall be subject. to immediate removal per section
312.13.
D. Any user placing or installing any free standing poles or other equipment or structures
within the right-of-way shall ensure that, at least thirty (30) days prior to 'the
commencement of any work, the user, provide the Public Works Director security, in the
form of a letter of credit, in a form deemed legally sufficient by the County Attorney's
Office, or cash, posted in the amount of one hundred fifteen (115) percent of the
estimated costs of all required improvements for each location The estimate shall be
prepared by an engineer registered in the State of Florida to practice professional
engineering. Upon completion and approval by the Public Works Director of all required
improvements, ninety (90) percent of the posted security will be released by the public
works director. Ten (10) percent security funds shall remain in place at all times the free
standing pole, structure or object remains installed or placed within the right of way. If
at any time, the security funds are not in place, the free standing pole, structure or object
shall be deemed abandoned and shall be subject to immediate removal per section
312.13.
Section 312.13. Termination of use or removal of object.
Notwithstanding any section of this chapter to the contrary, the county may terminate
any certain use allowable or under permit, or require the owner or permittee to remove
any object allowable or under permit, if it is determined that it is in the public interest to
have such use terminated or object removed. Such objects shall be removed as soon
as practicable with a time limit to be established by the director of public works. Failure
to comply will result in the permittee being subject to penalties as described in section
312.15. The County may immediately remove any free standing pole, structure or obiect
that is deemed abandoned per section 312.11 or 312.14 or for lack of payment of any
annual fee.
Section 312.14. Public protection and liability.
3
P158
1. Whenever any of the public rights-of-way are used under the terms of this chapter the
person so using them shall take necessary precautions, including illumination, for
protection of the public with particular emphasis on the period from sunset to sunrise.
The persons so using the public rights-of-way as a condition of that use agree to hold
and save the county harmless from any and all liability that may arise out of the use of
any public rights-of-way as provided in this chapter or by permit.
2. The user agrees and is bound to hold Indian River County whole and harmless against
any and all claims for damages, costs, and expenses to persons or property that may
arise out of, or be occasioned by the use, occupancy, and maintenance of the public
right-of-way, or from any act or omission of any representative, agent, customer, and/or
employee of the user. This user shall also be responsible for any claim for damage that
any utility, whether publicly or privately owned, may sustain or receive by reason of
user's use of the public right-of-way and improvements and equipment located thereon.
User shall not make any claim of any kind or character whatsoever against Indian River
County for damages that it may suffer by reason of installation, construction,
reconstruction, operation, and/or maintenance of any public improvement, or utility,
whether presently in place or which may in the future be constructed or installed,
including but not limited to, any water and/or sewer mains and/or storm sewer facilities
fiber optic cables, and whether such damage is due to flooding, infiltration, natural
causes, or from any other cause of whatsoever kind or nature. It is the intention of this
section, and a condition of any permit, that it shall be full and total indemnity against any
kind or character of claim whatsoever that may be asserted against Indian River County
by reason of, or as a consequence of having granted permission to a user to use and/or
maintain a public right-of-way. User is required to defend any and all suits, claims, or
causes of action brought against Indian River County on behalf of the county and pay
any judgment or judgments that may be rendered against county in connection
therewith.
3. Any user placing or installing any structure or object on County utility poles or other
equipment or structures within the right-of-way shall ensure that, at least thirty (30) days
prior to the commencement of any work on County utility poles or equipment or
structures, the user provides to the Indian River County Risk Management Division a
certificate or certificates issued by an insurer or insurers authorized to conduct business
in Florida that is rated not less than category A-: VII by A.M. Best, subject to approval
by Indian River County's Risk Manager, of Commercial general liability insurance with a
combined single limit of $1,000,000.00 per occurrence. The County shall be named as
an additional insured for each of these policies. The Indian River County Risk
Management Division has the authority to require additional insurance based upon the
structure or object to be installed or placed.
0
am
4. Any user placing or installing any structure or object on County utility poles or other
equipment or structures within the right-of-way shall ensure that such structure or obiect
has a plaque identifying the structure or obiect the owner and the owner's contact
information, and said plaque shall not exceed 0.25 square feet. No signage shall be
allowed.
5. All wiring and fiber for any structure or object on County utility poles or other
equipment or structures within the right-of-wav shall be concealed within the support
structure and all conduit, wiring and fiber shall be buried between structures and/or
structures and ground mounted cabinets. All service lines (e.g. electric lines) to the
support structure must also be buried unless service lines in the area of the support
structure are aerial. In that event, service lines to the structure or obiect may also be
aerial, except for any service drop crossing a street or roadway which would need to be
bored and placed under such street or roadway.
6. Structures or object on Coun utility poles or other equipment or structures within
the right-of-wav shall be designed to blend into the surrounding environment and
complement existing streetscape elements through the use of color, camouflaging and
architectural treatment.
7. Any user submitting documentation for placing or installing any structure or object on
County utility poles or other equipment or structures within the right-of-way must include
in the submitted documentation structural analysis and wind load calculations prepared
by an engineer registered in the State of Florida to practice professional structural
engineering.
8. If at any time, any user placing or installing any structure or obiect on County utility
poles or other equipment or structures within the right-of-way, or any structure or object
on County utility poles or other equipment or structures within the right-of-way, is not in
compliance with the provisions of this section the structure or obiect shall be deemed
abandoned and shall be subject to immediate removal per section 312.13.
Section 3. Codification. It is the intention of the Board of County Commissioners that the
provision of this ordinance shall become and be made part of the Indian River County Code,
and that the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered or re -lettered and the word
ordinance may be changed to section, article or such other appropriate word or phrase in order
to accomplish such intention.
Section 4. Severability. If any part of this ordinance is held to be invalid or unconstitutional
by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remainder of this ordinance shall not be affected by
such holding and shall remain in full force and effect.
5
P160
Section S. Conflict. All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are hereby
repealed.
Section 6. Effective Date. This ordinance shall become effective upon adoption by the Board
of County Commissioners and filing with the Department of State.
This ordinance was advertised in the Indian River Press Journal on the day of ,
2016, for a public hearing to be held on the _ day of June, 2017, at which time it was moved
for adoption by Commissioner , seconded by
Commissioner , and adopted by the following vote
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice -Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Bob Solari
Commissioner Tim Zorc
The Chairman thereupon declared the ordinance duly passed and adopted this day of
June, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
M
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk
and Comptroller
0
Deputy Clerk
EFFECTIVE DATE: This Ordinance was filed with the Department of State on the day of
June, 2017.
APPROVED AS TO FORM
AND LEGAL SUFFICIE •--�
BY
L N REINGOLD
COUNTY, ATTORNEY
P161
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
ESTABLISHING A FEE SCHEDULE FOR INSTALLATION
WITHIN COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
WHEREAS, there are instances in which applicants who do not remit taxes imposed by Indian
River County pursuant to chapter 202, Florida Statutes, seek to install wireless facilities in the County
right-of-way.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County wish to establish a
reasonable permit fee for such applicants; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that the following fees are hereby established:
Installation fee for structures/objects on County utility poles or other County equipment or
structures in County Right=of-Way (per location): $600.00
2. Re -inspection fee for structures/objects on County utility poles or other County equipment
or structures* in County Right -of -Way: $300.00
3. Annual fee for structureslobjects on County utility poles or other County equipment or
structures in County Right -of -Way per location: $150,00.
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner and seconded
by Commissioner and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as
follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adam's
CommissionerTim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
The Chairman thereupon declared the Resolution duly passed and adopted this _ day of
June, 2017.
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of
Court and Comptroller
By
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal
sufficiency:
'Dylan Reingold
I County Attorney
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
By
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
1Q4q
Public Hearings - B. CC 6.20.17
Office of
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Dylan Reingold, County Attorneyvp,
DATE: May 31, 2017
ATTORNEY
SUBJECT: Ordinance Concerning Medical Cannabis (Continued from June 13, 2017)
BACKGROUND.
On October 18, 20.16, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners (the "Board') enacted
land development regulations concerning medical marijuana treatments centers in advance of the vote on
Amendment 2. As part of the agenda item, the Community Development Department included a
memorandum. from the County Attorney's Office, which stated "[a]s section 381.986, Florida Statutes,
addresses low -THC and medical cannabis, I recommend that any potential regulations concerning such
uses be addressed under a separate discussion item."
Per section 381.986, Florida Statutes, medical cannabis includes all parts of any plant of the genus
Cannabis that is dispensed for medical use by an eligible patient as defined in section 499.0295, Florida
Statutes. Under the statute, an eligible patient is a person who has 1) a terminal condition that is attested
to by the patient's physician and confirmed by a second independent evaluation by a board-certified
physician in an appropriate specialty for that condition; 2) considered all other treatment options for the
terminal condition currently approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration; 3) given
written informed consent for the use of an investigational drug, biological product, or device; and
documentation from his or her treating physician that the patient meets the requirements for being an
eligible patient.
Under section 381.986, Florida Statutes, the State of Florida has preempted local governments from
regulating the cultivation and processing of medical cannabis or low -THC cannabis. However, under the
statute, a county may adopt an ordinance regulating the number, location, and some permitting
requirements for low -THC and medical cannabis dispensing facilities. On January 10, 2017, the Board
voted 4-1, with Vice -Chairman O'Bryan dissenting, to direct the County Attorney to: 1) draft an
ordinance which will incorporate into the current code, regulations concerning medical cannabis
dispensing facilities; and 2) ensure that the details are consistent and compliant with state law.
The County Attorney's Office has drafted the attached proposed ordinance. The proposed ordinance
incorporates the medical cannabis into the definition of marijuana and a dispensary under Section
381.986, Florida Statutes into the definition of a Medical Marijuana Treatment Center under Chapter 315
F. Ww.WWJ., affNZRAL1g C CWgadodfsm.W dlcd Ca b, Ordim Rd da
um
Board of County Commissioners
May 31, 2017
Page Two
of the Indian River County Code of Ordinances. The proposed ordinance also incorporates an exclusion of
regulations in the event of a preemption under section 381.986, Florida Statutes.
FUNDING.
The cost of publication of the required public notice for the public hearing was $136.67. This cost was
funded from the County Attorney's Office budget within the General Fund (account number 00110214-
033190).
RECOMMENDATION.
The County Attorney's Office recommends that the chair open the public hearing and after taking public
comment vote to approve the proposed ordinance.
ATTACHMENT.
Proposed Medical Cannabis Ordinance
F: tinarneyiUMctGEiVE77A118 [: Gl4gendoMmepsUledicot Gammbs G,atra =a).toc
P164
'Treasure Coast Newspapers I TC'!-)A,LM-
Indian
River Press Journal
1801 U.S. 1, Vero Beach, FL 32960
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared, Sherri Cipriani, who on oath says that she is Classified Inside Sales
Manager of the Indian River Press Journal, a daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County, Florida: that the
attached copy of advertisement was published in the Indian River Press Journal in the following issues below. Affiant further
says that the said Indian River Press Journal is a newspaper published in Vero Beach in said Indian River County, Florida, and
that said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Indian River County, Florida, daily and distributed in
Indian River County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement;
and affiant further says that she has neither paid or promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission
or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. The Indian River Press Journal
has been entered as Periodical Matter at the Post Offices in Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida and has been for a period
of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement.
Customer Ad Number Cooyline PO #
161741- INDIAN RIVER CO ATTORNEYS OFC 1630547 Hearing: 6/13/17: Controlled Substances Hearing: 6/13/17
me this day of, June 02, 2017, by
r . who is
Sherri Cipriani
(X) personally known to me or
( ) who has produced _ ID as identification.
(-CJCL��-
Notary Public
..........LINDAJGYCEKLEiN
li,tar, °uhlk. - Sate of Flor.:,a
•
Cu!nmriaon k 66081422
\v`.y��'
t:iyComm.EKoresMini9,2021
Borded through National Notary Pcr
P1(0q-I
V
C
t
(6 O
FW+ Q
� CL •
"O CA N 0
Q 4 CO o
.na. ti
g x
to Q i) Q
Z Z
(D
.0
E
(D Z (v
E o
-p m N_ p
c
<i Cn U
H
u
ot of Laa
Qy3+ar6
V/
405aDeday,lurre12017T ure Coast Nompapea
NotlreTo creditors-_.,� rvotia TO creditors
4th Finor _
?clam➢arybne: (i17a 296ll00
Sjm@MCCarihy5umm¢rs.cbm
Omd
dr2-Em
vrp
rpem
@Mrya.-?D:!uz0M1M"com
u
IN THECtRCUITCWRT FDR
MARHN CAUNTy, R41UPA
IT.PROBATE DIVISION
e No:
2R17CP000292CPAXMX
IN RE ESTATEOF
JOSEP DINEpC BERLANO.
Persorol Reprrsentafvts
Chrstne Onham
31709 N.W.4Ith Drive
Cord Springs.8330nd
Midreile HabmLaa d
13D East 52nd St.
�p lesiQapap �Gq 31405
RICH (a M4
RICHARD I. BARRON, ESO,
RICHARD J. GARRON, P.N.
Me SE Falrw E.
StuaK R 349l�
Richard J -Ba EsO.
F mida ear Na lou,
Pub:16331 t0, 2031
TCN 2639361
ININ THE CIRCUIT COURT FDR
RIVER COUNTY,
FLORIDA
PROBATE DIVISION
File NO.: 312017Cp000308
JN RE ESTATE OF
lENoewiuddE.
TheN admni cRE ITOR Ne
state f Jennie E Heine,
deceased, hose d3aa,t0 t
death
dln9Jaln ih 1CtKuii
Court (or Indian River COurl-
P-11Repres.1
1
a1
3IMa knpddn
65elleck5treet
Stamford
Conne<ticUt 06902
Attorray fm PersmurJ
Representhdvm
(frac. R Abernethy, lr.
ALtOrn.y
IOrida lar Numb- (GS7251
111 S INmAN RIVER DR STE 91
FORT PIERCE.R 34950.4353
TelepNone:(772)4834101
lrafc(TTI)d89A9o2
E -Ma l: jbr.cky3vbruceapasom
Rerondnry E -Mat
babemaMy@brace—Co.
Pah:Myi7Juhe3, 2037
TCN 1622899
INTHECIRLNTCOURT FOR
ST. LUCJE COUNTY,
FLORIDA
,Rte Np,E.VrB.N
562011C1,0002SSFMXXXX
IN RE ESTATE OF
MARGARETJAMES,
Deceased.
NOTICE TO CREDITORS
Th
e admini=1U,11n f Na
dslate of MargarN James
ectased, whose date {
death November 13,
2o16, ➢ dinggle the CUCvit
Court for St Wde County.
Ioritla,Probate M'.' ,Dm
s"it ofwhidr Is z18111C
erontl Stree4 Fort pierce
Florida 'of'u,eapmet
zonal of a and Ne
pzrzan[I presen.Asive's
Many are tK forty Dhow.
AMI
ai � apf Ure decadent
persons haven
C Ner aemanas a anti
a ace�earls.stateanw�mn
topY otthisnotke knquired
o be Swed must ll¢ ON
Balms RE HE wort ON
OR RETORE THE LATER OF
3 THEFT AFtFR THETIME
OF TNS. PUBLICATION
Oi THSNOTICE OR 30 DAYS
AFTER THE DATE OF SERVICE
OF A COPY OF THIS NOTfcE
All Other
creditors .t the
All
nother persons
baying chimt o demands
against decedenCs as at'
4ust foe their darts wdh
cnurttYttHJN 3 MONTHS
AFTER THE GATE OF THE
FIRST PUBLICATION OF THIS
NOTICE
(No13r:eTO.CreCitDrS.�
ALL CLAIMS NOT FILED W".
I'RINI
1]H-
INTHE TME PERIODS SET
FOR THJNFLOR(DASTATUTES
SECTION 733.7N WILL Be
FOREVER MRRE
NOTWITHSTANDING THE TIME
PERIODS SET FORTH Aso+{l2Ey,
YEARS OR MORE AF R THE
DECEDENTS OATI OF DEATH
S.I.
The date of Nrst pvbiicaffen el
this
noticei5lune 3, 2017.
Axillary P.raonai
Representative:
STEPHEN P. JAMES
4350 Butler Road
Rafstes—,
Attomeya for me
ta23138
Personal Rempsenta0ve:
Ssyorida LAW O.28,Esquire
oad5 W clevetand n ¢nue
StuaK FTOrido 34994
Phone: (TR7267-6885
EServ77 220-3518
Pri CO�5O$Y�s DosX.Un e stssery
.. da.......rY-so m@st4
Pub:JOne3,L.—T
TCN 3635520
fN a TiRCNTCOURTFOR
INDIAN RIVERCWNTY,
FLORIDA
PROS gTE DIVISION
FW Na: 312017CP000469
IN RE: ESTATE OF
THERES�IINSTON
THERESA M. /JOHNSTON
THERESAa/.JaOONNSTON,
�(4odfeTO Ctedi[bi5�
lahn@7mchughiawAom
FlondaBar Na 444626
J.Dn /aleph MCHv9h Jr,
Esquire
P.0.60%2807
V.ro Beach, F'ladda 32961
Tdeprone: TJ2-77&1100
Pub:June 3.10, 2011
TIL
FHTHE gRCUiiCWR OF TN
19THl RSTU CE IN
AND FORST WCIECOUNTY,
ROB T
PROBATE
File N4 20U-CP-0OIT ON
00400
IN RE ESTATE OF
ANTHONY PAUL
MiCHALAR05,
Deceased,
Personal Represen ati im
.I. John Josaph MrHugh,li
Vara Beach, Florida 3 951
Attamy for Parsona4
ReyreSentativC:
JlaShul proseph McHugh, Jn,
tNTHEL1RDViTCWR OF THE NINETEENTH IUptgAt CIRCUIT NAHD FOR
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
)AMES W. KARL, CATS NO.312017CA000Z1S
P'Isintiff
THE UNKNOWN HEIRS, SUCCESSORS, SENEICIARIES, DEVISEES, GRANTEES. ASSIGNEES LIEN-
ORS, CREOtTORS, EXE'yl
UTORS AND PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES, TRU5TEf5 ANO MAPS PARTIES CLAIMING ANY INTENEST BY THROUGH OR AGAINST MARY N. SATTERFIELD OR THE
mdf;Aants.MANY N SA7TERFlEt0, DE4IEASED; ET AL
NOTICEOFACTION
TO: THE UNKNOWN HEIRS, SUCCESSORS, BENEFICIARIES. DEVISEES, GRANTEES, ASSIGNEES,
LIENORS, CREMTORS. EXECDTORS AN p PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES, TRUSTEES ANO AEL
OTHER PARTIES CLaINC G ANY tNTER£ST BY, THROUGH OR AGAINST MARY N. SAtTER-
FlEW ORTHEESTATE pFMAPY N. SATfEBFlEL0,0ECEA5Ep; AND ANY OTHER HEIRS OFMAI7Y N.
SATTERFIELD IFALIVE, AND, IF DEAD, THEIR UNKNOWN SPOUSES HEIRS bEVI5EE5, GRANTEES,
SUCCESSORS AND A53N.NS,1U00MENi CREDITORS. ANO Atl ETHER PARTIES ClAiMlNG BY,
THROUGH, UNDER OR AGAINST THEM THE UNKNOWN SFOUSf, HEIRS DEVISEES, GRANTEES,
AND 1VOGMENT CREDITORS pF DECEASED DEFENDANTS, AND ALL OTA PARTIES CLAIMING
BY, THROUGH, UNpER.OR AGAIkST ANYOFTHEDEFEH HTS: ANDALLpNKNOWNNAiDRAI
PERSONS EF AtiVE, ANO, if DEAD 9A MOT KNOWN TO BE DEAD Oft ALIVE, THEIR SEVfRAL AND
RESPECTFVE UNKNOWN SPOUSE. HEIRS, NCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS. DEVISEES, GRANTEES.
AND JUDGMENT CREDITORS, OR OTHER PARTIES CLAIMING eY. THRGUGH, OR UNDEN THOSE
UNKNOWN NATURAL PERSON: pND THESE EVRAL AND RESPECTIVE UNKNOWN ASSIGNS SUC-
CESSORS IN INTEREST, 7RUS(EES. DR OM PERSONS CLAIMING BY. THROUGH. UNDER. OR
AGAINST ANY CORPORATION OR OTHER tEGA4 ENTRY NAMED ASA OEFENDA -ANO Alt
CLAIMANTS. PERSONS pq PARTIES, NATURAL OR CORPORATE, OR WHpSE EXACT LEGAL STA-
TU515 UNKNOWN, CLAIMING UNDER ANY OF THE ABOVE NAMED OR DESCRIBED DEFENDANTS
TTHLI MPGA Nit; UNXNOWN OCEST NO 3 ANO UNKT�NOWN OCCUPANT 'D2 CRIIBE'
BEINGFy U kuNS TO ACCOUNT FORPARTIES IN POSSESSION,
Addresses: Unknown
YaU ARE NOIT that an action to palet HU¢ based an aTax Oend has been filed ag 'nst n
d you are req ed [O Serve aAaPYpfy Iran tl¢fenses, deny, on Warren ad.
Dil(Esquire
lwho atltlress IsrOill M Evans, p.L.1565 US Highway L 5ebasUan, Iortda 3958 on m before
une 211 2037, Omt Less Nan 28 nor mme than 60 dayys akar the (first publication of this Notice)
anduo{Re NeprlgilulwiNthe(Jerk cfthiseomteitherbefore serviceoncation fsthisN .r
indn[ely thereafter, otherwlan.tl1 .11 wel be entered agains[yau forth¢ roiief demanaetl
tie ComGGTaint The real pro ¢rty at fssue in Nase
tlon to quiat a Tax bead ix in Indian River
COunty andmme particulaHY Bescribad of Into -
The SOON 1.74 acres of the following do¢cribed p Garty: The East t/2 of ,act 1333, IGAS Ne
East 20 feet 1UV
—. together D, NB East 12.50 (sett of the Wert IR of said Tract 3331, Plat
East, )n St Luda CountYt,—is off Iprifde acC6Mmg M I'm
2 mayor plat Nle eoTastreCC 1, P n
Plat Book 2. Pa 3. Pubbe Records of St Luci@ County, Fl. dda. Smd land .. ying and being
In Intllan River County, flortda.
thereinafter re oocal...-Real PraPeM1yry
Property Address: 10025138th Avenues F.11anu.m. Florida 32948
Dated this 23rd day of May, 2037,
IEFFREY R-SMITN
perk Ne C'ncuit Court
B .Acura waters
Deputy Clerk
REppUEESTS FOR ACCOMMODATIONS BY PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES. IP you aro a persgn wiN
tlpli I , Natrseads any amommodaGon, la miler W partidp.te to Ni Proceadutg• Y.0 aze
led, Ino C05tto you, to Ne prov$ion of.errainasiist . Pic
asacpptact Court Atlmim
isha[ion, 250 NW Countrryy dub Odve, Sh z27 POR SL W tie, R 34986, 772-8011.4370, at leas[ 7
tla sbefOre yOmi for thetl c.court appearance mimme0iatelYY pun receiving Nis iffication
if call 73L the scheduled appemance is less Nan l tlnys; if you aze hearing oY voice
In.
My 27 June 3,10,17 2037
TCN 162298
PersiASON ril kOCsroHAlARps
AtUmeyfm Personal
ReoresomMUTY.
SroN R Bugy-Esquire
C"111"
"111 rtSURe P600
290 NW TdAu Street
.1 3169
Ta7ephonc (305) 9569640
Fac (3057 94$•2905
Pilary E. a a
Secoul-rblawwyy .tom
Seconda+y EmaiC�
PTa@mblawyersrem
ub: May 2) lune 3, 9111
TCN.426.(
N THE CIRCUIT COURT OF TH
NIS91-T IHIUCICIAL
d RCVITIN AND FOR MARTN
COUNTY, FLORIDA
PROSATEDIV/SfON
FlLE NO
43t/77CP000324CPAXMX
IN RE ESTATE OF
RENATE Deceased KER.
I"....*--»;,•-,-'..•--._. }kimesFulsale"_.. ri
oUce7o Credltois
W<ra R3z94offVERFRONT
321.501-0211
Pub: June 3, 30, 2037
TL"8a5 MOORINGS
CONDO
ABSOLUTE
PNbilcNpgP_s .:__} AUCTION!
4 NOTICE OF INTENT
PUBUCHEARING 901 Bap Read
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that179
2 Be ICON i Bath
N¢ Board of County Com- 1,795 Sgft Of beingsppace
mssioner5 of Indian River GTODntl door Condtl
Caun{tyy Florida, MR conduct EnUgSed Dorch, Fireplace
atln b� n Hearing to consider QUditerly HOA
ha MdIded: oposed ortll- ICat �.g e
9 9
AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD
OF COUNTY COMMISSION- TO be AgucthmerIt0 the
TMS OF
LOR OA RAMEND N6 REGARiD1Fast5S pIFPRI0E2
CHAPTER 315 (PAIN MAN-
AGEMENT CLINICS, CON-
TROCCFO SU85TANCES AND Sat. Jdn.3rd @ 13 AM
MEDICAL MARIJUANA) pF Pttview @LOAM or by App
THE LODE OF INDIAN RIVER R(mniGldwcltOns.com
COUNTY TO REVISE REST
tACONA11 TICKS
OFCESN0TIRITIE
RELATING TO LOWTHC AND i
- IS
.
MEDICAL CANNABIS; AND
PROWLING FOR SEVERABIL-
ITY, LODIFlCATION AND AN 117 '5623015
EFFECTIVE DATE STUART 36drm/2ba'2car
The Public Hearing will be held ypazager possibl 4N Ddrtr4
Tuesday, lune 13, 201] at i J with 2,000 sp. It ca do -
995 a.m. or as Soon Nere• Near San Sprit Park.
akar as N¢ matter ma b¢ W B D LOU
(772)29.4411
maril, n Ne Count Com-
isSlon first
Hear of located ''4tRU."3 j'; GateE Gomm:
An 1 first Door of Building : 4br..Os ac t `otshbe: gran?
of the County AQm7n15- "Ptnen'caunters;_Iu4henS;opanS
3 960` �w faa. Issel 27th
li t ITR 56F9 0 W B,Ips 5aT
wted parties may be heard VERO BEmCN 2 Cdr
iN rester Ne proposed m, �9liw
rdioo co.
g ry roam, Hn
The proposed ordinance may kiosets. G bath's alk -In
bo icpegg<ted by Ne pub• d.sets. Garage }. feneed
InUrsu(8:30 Ya�mu[o business
Jnrppool. Gated. Mamnniy
s from shoppping mal
Montlay through Fdda»y9 t Nmvly reneyeted, M35,000
the O4 t f the Cleric to (937)974.7586 WEB_t63�038
the Board of County^ oni- VERO BEACH SHORES -2321
ZIssioners I ... led o ". 4th avenue se, 388 Vero
rol floor of BuildinggA of the shores $165,000.00 Far Sale
Count'
Aamin'atrat)ve C.M. uy owner 3R/t Recently
Bedchi FlUrldab Street V¢ro piloted wiN new cabinets,
Anyone he by wish to Carpet old pajnt No rear
appeal any ch—lon whir
0 side neighbors. WEB ID
maybe made at this mM,h 1612339 (4pT)g4&RY6
m9.,If need to ensure that
nbatt- c rd of the �Cp` nEuslln(uisst,: f
roceerzdings IS matlanwhkh
Uudestestimony d all- FORT PIERCE - High Point
d_b 2Onwhlch theappesl 55+, 2BDnBA Condo Fot
Anyone wno needs a s ectal Saye, up9r4dM Nrouthou, -
P 55 appls, granite —inrz,
aceemmpddsion }pr this d porch Southam
Com,7[y. Amercans[tWith 2ands'92WE9IP216or 1733R-
DisabllfNes Act (AOAy Com• _
¢)ason hours in2adven2ce DI ^�T J
WtltP it�fli
the neetmo. HUTCHINSON 0 STUART
INDIANRIVERCOIINTY BOARD 9-1,1
unes Curb, Directly on
1003EPHE FFI FSCHFRSI0NEg5 beat Fum er CIaGIhouse.
CHAIRMAN Faces Po0I, 5299,060Ownm.
Pub:lune 3, 2937 9 od[ rAt@ic( d.com
ICN 1630547 305-: 2.99 t* IU 1E15384
'Fa(ms&ACr"P,a`gE� tZ
l .14"
_ N md.714 Cry
Ma flap T3mberWnd; P(anF
j We., e.%mi%ed 70.. Hard)
Huntdln5@p:t500�4c�e elCall
-a
,�
lbabuf ctumd HDiP�`s�
HOSE SGVNO- Beautiful, 2R,
Move In Ready, new kit W/0,
vNod4 porch 30%32
e o stprg Shed, new A/C.
walk in do to water saft-
v 365k II )72.546-6p90
m 1}72-34t-4032 Ip 3627459
PORI ST k -I - 55+,
Spanish Lakes. LDl.. 2005,
56' Bbl wide flreplace,cm-
pp earlggn 1NIm , Brand
dJ S40K Make ONm1
Lot rent 5518.tF72)341-2]18
WEB ID 1603508
PORTST WCIE
2/2/t CBS..._.„., -5651000
Or¢at buy (nthe
Ss+comm.
SipCllit bedtooma, WASk In
osets. Nice patio /or
¢nt'es"g. Near shopping,
fa[i+amant5, meairal
lf0e5. Cal BMB Realty
IT2.070-0899
fiNOME FDR 561E Owner
re ncin9 edit. Dad
Ble ciho3 2/1loWnI 35N Ave, Ve f
kitchen Cbl large privhte
1rd5365K 1654tlown apmm
,32.9 c.7. .538.1035
772)53&]939
T`s/Aereage fforSafe !3
PORT ST. WCIE 2 WT5 (17
St James a (I7 Je L Decker
$UL,u 0esch. Princi"NAM;
lws oNy.
Cou Uau)741-2802 EB ID
YEARS OR MORE AfTFIt THE
SPac oscewarromCOppeenn 160783]
DECWENT'S GATED
IS BARRE0.
E'td'an VVLh' of ca6tnets$
breakfast Dat.2 boricle: ,
SMART - Rocky Potnt 5116 BE
prang¢ 5t. 34997;Th.
do
this undceis lune 3, 2pi7.
o
imrm shutter gWet roH
de-sacstreet. Tosacra))
IoI he deedaa access too
psnvai¢ marina; dH water
Personal Regrew advC:
BMB ReaNy 7IZ-878-8699
IID Ie 0? fTJ1)18E0146
WEB m 1633690
am
Taya un,C—
21, SeashoreCave
VA23454
vlV%
yy
ttt
`fiter0snU ic`w
A
-,-
ABeatn.
Attorney fo Personal
like.lierel
RSI ESId'blgys •
Represe1=1
S. 1. H.wtsa;.
iRenml9'{T.-i ,L,
..— �..
kedaw@ mdtcam
kml w@@Iobnaacom
T'vit BarNa033061z
♦
Real fttate---
'aitrn�ryts;�Wimistierl�
279 a dge flan Iamiason
way, Sldg.E
....
SMART - Da
tedront efRCi4nccyy
}f RtaiEstate
5950/ma+Seeurit.gii.A/C
Mall0 Clean•n ii.
yt'�1]ur�_�•t�._,-t __
Minimvm6m ttq or more
7R -Z WEE' 7 for more info
wEB 1p i6it668
••tiia0haeinNe
wlMban 7,,LaundYwy'
Cotl 71S655h6Dn 16N St
ORDINANCE NO. 2017 -
AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 315 (PAIN
MANAGEMENT CLINICS, CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES AND MEDICAL
MARIJUANA) OF THE CODE OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY TO REVISE
REGULATIONS AND PROHIBITIONS OF CERTAIN ACTIVITIES RELATING
TO LOW -THC AND MEDICAL CANNABIS; AND PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, in 2016, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners (the
"Board") amended Chapter 315 of the Code of Indian River County entitled "Indian River
County Pain Management Clinic and Controlled Substances Ordinance" addressing medical
marijuana under Amendment 2; and
WHEREAS, the Board wishes to regulate low -THC and medical cannabis, as set forth
in section 381.986, Florida Statutes, in a similar manner as medical marijuana under
Amendment 2;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA THAT:
Section 1. Enactment Authority.
Article VIII, section 1 of the Florida Constitution and chapter 125, Florida Statutes vest broad
home rule powers in counties to enact ordinances, not inconsistent with general or special law,
for the purpose of protecting the public health, safety and welfare of the residents of the county.
The Board specifically determines that the enactment of this ordinance is necessay to protect
the health, safety and welfare of the residents of Indian River County.
Section 2. Legislative Findings.
The Board finds that the "Whereas" clauses above are true and correct, and hereby
incorporates such clauses as the legislative findings of the Board.
Section 3. Amendment of Chapter 315 (Pain Management Clinics Controlled
Substances and Medical Marijuana).
Chapter 315 of the Code of Indian River County, Florida is hereby amended to read as follows
(added language is underlined, and deleted language noted by strikethrough):
FUaomry�lindnlGFNEFAyVterolulionr&Or 6nmlaer10rd1nmmerlPn»Cf�ni�dimlC na6isdars 1
P165
CHAPTER 315. PAIN MANAGEMENT CLINICS, CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES
AND MEDICAL MARIJUANA
Section.315.02. Definitions.
For the purposes of this chapter, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
(7) Marijuana shall mean cannabis as defined in Section 893.02(3), Florida
Statutes. The term shall include "low -THC cannabis," and "medical
cannabis" as defined in Section 381.98604M, Florida Statutes.
(8) Medical Marijuana Treatment Center shall mean an entity that acquires,
possesses, processes (including development of related products such as
food, tinctures, aerosols, oils, or ointments), transfers, transports, sells,
distributes or dispenses marijuana, products containing marijuana, related
supplies, or educational materials to qualifying patients or their caregivers
and is registered or approved by the department of health or its successor
agency, pursuant to Article X, Section 29 of the Florida Constitution or
Section 381.986, Florida Statutes.
Section 315.03. Prohibited Activities.
Each of following activities shall be prohibited and shall constitute a violation of this
Code:
(3) Operation of a pain management clinic without a valid and current
registration pursuant to sections 458.3265 or 459.0137, Florida Statutes, or
registered or approved by the Department of Health, pursuant to Article X,
Section 29 of the Florida Constitution or Section 381.986, Florida Statutes,
unless such clinic is exempt from registration or approval undeF SUGh StatUt8;
(14) Gultivation, administFati, Administration or consumption of marijuana at a
pain management clinic, unless otherwise allowed by state law.
F.Wt1—ylLi &QEWDMLUt—&f—&"'nmla 10h*—.MPaln pinf diem Cmm b d— 2
P166
Section 315.04. Permit Required for Operation of Pain Management Clinic.
(1) Permit Required. No pain management clinic shall operate by any means
in Indian River County without a valid and current pain management clinic
permit issued by the Department.
(2) Application. Any pain management clinic requesting issuance of a pain
management clinic permit shall complete and submit to the Department a
sworn application, on a form provided by the Department, containing, at a
minimum, the following information:
a. The name and address of the pain management clinic;
b. The name and address of each owner of the pain management clinic
(including, if the owner is a business entity such as a corporation, limited
liability company, etc, the name and address of each officer, manager or
managing member, general partner or other comparable person authorized
by state law to manage the affairs of the business entity), each person who
will be managing or supervising the activities of the pain management clinic,
and each person who will be prescribing or administering controlled
substances, and each person who will be acquiring, possessing,
processing, transferring, selling, distributing or dispensing marijuana at the
pain management clinic;
c. The name and address of the person who has been designated as the
responsible physician or osteopathic physician for the pain management
clinic, pursuant to sections 458.3265(1)(c) or 459.0137(1)(c), Florida
Statutes, if applicable;
d. The name and address of the person or entity which owns the real property
upon which the pain management clinic will be operated;
e. Proof that the applicant is currently registered as a pain management clinic
with the Florida Department of Health, pursuant to sections 458.3265 or
459.0137, Florida Statutes or registered or approved as a Medical Marijuana
Treatment Center, pursuant to Article X, Section 29 of the Florida
Constitution or section 381.986, Florida Statutes;
P167
f. Proof that any person who will be prescribing or administering controlled
substances at the pain management clinic has a valid and current controlled
substance registration number issued by the United States Department of
Justice, Drug Enforcement Administration, including the controlled
substance registration number for each such person;
g. Unless otherwise prohibited or preempted by state statute or Department of
Health rule, a A sworn statement certifying that within the ten (10) years
prior to submittal of the application, neither the pain management clinic, nor
any person identified pursuant to subsections b, c or d above, has been
found by any county or municipal board, commission or council, or by any
state or federal court, or by any state or federal regulatory body, to have
acted with respect to controlled substances or marijuana in violation of
applicable law; and
h. A sworn statement certifying that the pain management clinic, and every
other clinic owned or operated by any person identified pursuant to
subsections b, c or d above, will, during the term of the permit, be operated
in compliance with applicable law.
i. Unless otherwise prohibited or preempted by state statute or Department of
Health rule. proof Nee f that a Medical Marijuana Treatment Center is wholly
owned and operated by one or more
1. board-certified anesthesiologists, physiatrists, or
neurologists; or
2. board-certified medical specialists who have also completed
fellowships in pain medicine approved by the Accreditation
Council for Graduate Medical Education or the American
Osteopathic Association or who are also board-certified in
pain medicine by a board approved by the American Board
of Medical Specialties or the American Osteopathic
Association and perform interventional pain procedures of
the type routinely billed using surgical codes.
Section 4. Severability. If any part of this ordinance is held to be invalid or unconstitutional
by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remainder of this ordinance shall not be affected by
such holding and shall remain in full force and effect.
F. UtromrylGndnIGEVFRALUtrrolu7fmr&O,&.—,10r& ... W—pinla dieol Ca ,,,b A,. 4
P168
Section 5. Codification. It is the intention of the Board of County Commissioners that the
provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made part of the Indian River County Code,
and that the sections of this ordinance may be renumbered or, re -lettered and the word
ordinance may be changed to section, article or such other appropriate word or phrase in order
to accomplish such intention.
Section 6. Effective Date. This ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the Florida
Department of State.
This ordinance was advertised in the Indian River Press Journal on the day of ,
2017, for a public hearing to be held on the —day of , 2017, at which time it
was .moved for adoption by Commissioner , seconded by
Commissioner , and adopted by the following vote:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
The Chairman thereupon declared the ordinance duly passed and adopted this day of
, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
2
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
and Comptroller
By:
Deputy Clerk
Dy an Reingold, County Attorney
EFFECTIVE DATE: This ordinance was filed with the Florida Department of State on the
day of , 2017.
P169
1061
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION
REQUEST TO BE SCHEDULED FOR PUBLIC DISCUSSION
Any organization or individual wishing to address the Board of County Commission shall complete this
form and submit it to the Indian River County Administrator's Office.
PUBLIC DISCUSSION INFORMATION
Indian River County Code Section 102.04(10)(b): as a general rule, public discussion
items should be limited to matters on which the commission may take action
Indian River County Code Section 102.07(2): limit remarks to three minutes unless
additional time is granted by the commission
NAME OF INDIVIDUAL OR ORGANIZATION: oe
C, Ifs
ADDRESS: a� l) 06 1 f Q 1 PHONE: a� ~ 1/714
xq b i
SUBJECT MATTER FOR DISCUSSION:
SC
IS A DIGITAL/ELECTRONIC PRESENTATION PLANNED? YES a NO
IS THIS AN APPEAL OF A DECISION ❑ YES NO
WHAT RESOLUTION ARE YOU
REQUESTING OF THE COMMISSION?
D (,Gr)_S1jee 4�11S ,
Fr dfk)5(n5
ARE PUBLIC FUNDS OR ACTIVITIES REQUIRED? F-1 YES NO
WHAT FUNDS OR ACTIVITIES ARE
REQUIRED TO MEET THIS REQUEST? tj
Transmitted to Administrator Via:
Interactive Web Form
E -Mail
Hand Delivered
Phone
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR:
MEETING DATE:
Jason E. Brown
Doeumem4
P170
i0B1
Name
at Email Phone Number
2.
3.
5.
6.
8.-
9.T.
10.
-
12.t4C-r�G
13.
20
A
2
24.",-
25
26.
27.
29 A
�L 1
31.
33.
�-
34.
35. >
i r
37. k� Ann
38. `
39. '�
40. /
41. a t,
42.
43. t4 IFA' d
F
44. El tg, Q -KC
/?
45. j1L�r
�f.'i
LO
LN
Ny
M
Name
Signature
Email
Phone Number
0 14 6S
I. q4' -0j&4 4:11i:t1- i
---
W
J
KC,
go -
L
..'eat, M
72-
+ Le, (Lk—
T—
OAI'bh4vu
M5� QJ" 14
1
`AAr
tn.
_L6
144
WTIM
EM
_qj
"CfLI
OLL
W
J
KC,
go -
..'eat, M
VI
+ Le, (Lk—
T—
OAI'bh4vu
`AAr
tn.
144
914&.
P170 -A
m
P 1 '70-4
in ' _ I _
' 'A►
r l�ir�Rlit��
-_
liZ3+aT�L.1�i"L�If:H'►`�l.i�'�A�i����`ill%��i'►!�J.�����1
t� (� � :tet ��l
_ • 1�
MUM,
1 �
R&ff.fi
F ! / ZA
-
• , V
_ ....
2131 VLA'MI .��11WIf�I;�.
>
,
-11
11
� Htf �s ��� L. GJ
i I.1i1��
.BMW
- ..i
Irv_
1,WIFE IASSIIA05 FAMM .
-
AM
i MONO."ll �
_-
m
P 1 '70-4
J i_,--
52
P170-6,
WSM I WINI%
Name
Signature
Email
Phone Number
227.
228. 71e
229.IVti 14r_�
t
l
231
� W S311
:3_
S�
232. « ��
1. '
72- z� -
234. r
f
235 d
i
'1
236.
238. r,Vl�s
7, tgd E r'
239. c v- r\
240.
I;N `N L
241.
42.
242'-
24
24
2 lS
245. rNI i L1 -U jil
flot CA,
- ^ .Gt t 1t
�. - 71
246.71 d')
'I72 kC`310
247. ri'iL
-�'t_
7 `-105 '6"" i
__---
248. r 1�C' 1'. i
��
�e
r.
249.
250.
.• /
- i.
7
251.
252. e
\ 1'.
-7
253.
254,`'•, ,-r "
� 7J� /` S
255.
256.
257.
258. e S�
259.j,-..Mei
U
260. ' !! �-'' i ' 1�'
� � -•= �� � �
263.
264. Qi?t
266:
aj
268L-d--e-,�-
2691
27Q v 1I, f %� 1 .1/',
L 'I�Z�
iJ /
M
3;(
0/
P,170 -('e,
P. tqc). 7
Signatu(g.,.*
MPA
,fly
.e �Al*�Jgp,
'*'—Vr 7V" r,41W
Q
W)
9 F r5 rn � Mx R", -Mm
0 yj fff 3A UM
I W WE
I I W, , NAM A
W� ffA�_q'j NIS—MA4 �'j
WAR=
TAF
P�
AIWI
W
Wfi
Mod
affirm"
M 11"M
! AN ral 017 m "m a m
P. tqc). 7
�A
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
TO: Jason E. Brown; County Administrator
FROM: Stan Boling, AICP
Community Development Director
Richard B. Szpyrka, P.E.
Public Works Director
DATE: June 6, 2016
SUBJECT: Follow-up on Development Review Tasks Resulting from April Workshop
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of June 20, 2017.
BACKGROUND
At its meeting of May 2, 2017, Commissioner Zorc brought to the Board of County Commissioners
(Board) three items to move forward as a result of the.April 12, 2017 Development Review and
Permitting Process Workshop. The items are as follows:
1. Review of landscaping requirements
2. Use of Temporary Suspension of Compliance provisions
3. Review of Development Review fees for Community Development and
Public Works
The Board considered the items and directed the Community Development Department to move
them forward (see attachment #1).
Community Development has considered workshop input and.coordinated with other departments on
the three development review tasks and now proposes specific changes for the Board to consider.
Once the Board considers the proposed changes in concept and provides staff input, staff can obtain
public input and formally initiate processes for future Board adoption of the changes.
The Board is now to consider the proposed changes along with any public input and provide staff
direction.
C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@340595C8\@BCL@340595C8.docx
P171
ANALYSIS
Two of the three tasks assigned to Community Development involve land development regulations
(LDRs). LDR changes involve a formal process that requires a public hearing before the Planning
and Zoning Commission (PZC) and a public hearing before the Board. The third task involves
development review fees. Changing those fees requires only Board review and adoption of new fees
via a resolution.
• Landscape Regulation Changes
With respect to the first item regarding existing landscaping regulations (LDR Chapter 926) those
regulations were most recently revised in 2010 with input from the development industry, the
landscape industry, and the environmental community. The 2010 revisions included a number of
changes that added flexibility to the regulations such as allowing a range of planting heights that
average out overall to meet. plant height minimums. Recently, two additional landscaping
requirement "flexibility" items have been suggested. Those include codifying an allowance for
varying plant heights for littoral zone plantings along pond shorelines (a practice already used by
staff), and allowing a minor reduction in initial plant height for plants used to in -fill gaps in
preserved, native buffer areas. Staff has drafted landscape ordinance and littoral zone planting
regulation changes for those two concepts and supports moving forward with formal changes to
Chapter 926 and Chapter 934 (see attachment #2).
• Temporary Suspensions of Compliance
The second item deals with use of temporary suspensions at the end of project construction.
Although the existing temporary suspension of compliance provisions are popular and useful, staff
has identified a need to curtail requests to eliminate certain items that are causing an inordinate
amount of staff and applicant time spent resolving punch list items and follow-up after -the -fact. To
address that problem, staff proposes to amend the existing temporary suspension regulations
(Chapter 902) to provide more specificity that will guide staff and applicants, while adhering to the
temporary suspension's original purpose of allowing certificates of occupancy and certificates of
completion when a project has been inspected and deemed substantially complete with only "minor
deficiencies" remaining.
Staff's proposed changes to Chapter 902 will add to the temporary suspension regulations a list of
minor "suspend -able" items and a list of items not considered minor and not suspend -able. Although
the lists are not all-inclusive, adopting those lists into the code will provide specific guidance for
most end -of -project circumstances (see attachment 43). In addition to the proposed code changes,
staff is proposing a nominal fee for a temporary suspension request ($100). Such fee will cover only
a portion of staff costs for the extra administrative and inspection time devoted to servicing the
requests, but will provide developers a small incentive for following the normal process, 100%
completion of all required items, for obtaining a Certificate of Occupancy (C.O.) or Certificate of
Completion (C.C.).
CAUserAGRANIC-1 WppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@340595C8\@BCL@340595C8.docx 2
P172
• Development Review Fees
The third item involves development review fees. Indian River County's current development
application fees have not been updated since 2004 and are significantly lower than application fees
charged by other counties in the area (see attachment #4). Development review fees were updated in
1990 and 14 years later when they were next updated in 2004 the Board directed staff to update them
more often... every 4 years. The 2004 update included a development application schedule used by
Community Development and a separate fee schedule used by Public Works for stormwater permits,
right-of-way permits, and site inspections. However, when the 4 year update timeframe came around
in 2008, the county had entered what turned out to be a deep and long recession. Consequently, it
was decided to keep review fees low and "un -updated" at that time. Now, 13 years out, review fees
cover only a small portion of the staff time involved in reviewing, processing, inspecting, and
closing -out development review projects.
Staff has drafted a preliminary development application review fee update for current development
application types using the same methodology employed during the 1990 and 2004 fee updates. That
methodology calculates for each specific application type the labor cost (salary and benefits) of each
staff position involved based on the increment of time that staff position spends on the "average"
development project application from beginning to C.O. Staff positions from various departments
are used in the fee calculation; Fire Prevention reviews are not included in the calculated fees since
Fire Prevention charges separate fees for its development application reviews. Also calculated into
the preliminary fee schedule are the costs of advertising and mailed notice which applies to certain
application types, and the additional costs of certain application types that may require a special PZC
review. Staff's preliminary update indicates that development review fees need to increase
substantially from the current fees set in 2004. Even so, the preliminary updated fees for Indian
River County will still be generally lower than fees charged in nearby counties (see attachment #6).
If the preliminary updated fees (full calculated costs) had been charged for development applications
submitted in the last 12 months, staff estimates that an additional. $221,731.61 of revenue from
development review fees would have been received during that 12 month period (see attachment #5).
Such revenue increase would help financially sustain needed increases in development review
staffing levels to get faster development review turnaround times. The need for staffing increases,
quicker review times, and development review fee increases were discussed at the April 12"
workshop.
Staff proposes that, after public input, a finalized and updated Community Development fee schedule
be considered by the Board in September. That schedule will include an update of other application
types handled by Community Development such as comprehensive plan amendments, rezonings,
concurrency certificates, and environmental permits. In addition, Public Works has evaluated its
costs and fees as it relates to the building permit review and inspection process and the land
development review and inspection process and has found that there is a significant revenue
shortfall. That evaluation and preliminary fee information will be presented to the Board by the
Public Works Director at the June 20, 2017 meeting (see attachment #8). An updated, finalized and
updated Public Works fee schedule will need to be considered by the Board in September as well as
a complete and updated Community Development fee schedule.
C:\Users\GRANIC-1 WppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@340595C8\@BCL@340595C8.docx 3
P173
Related to fees is the issue of whether or not an application is required to be reviewed by the PZC.
When an application is required to be reviewed by the PZC, rather than staff -level approval, costs
increase for producing staff reports and for staff time at the PZC meeting. To reduce staff and PZC
time for certain routine projects which currently require PZC review, staff proposes code changes
that would allow staff approval. Such code changes would reduce certain application fees and would
save time for staff, the PZC, and the applicant. Such changes would also reduce approval time by 2
to 3 weeks for the affected projects. To that end, staff proposes that the Board authorize a code
change to allow staff level approval for certain "routine" uses that currently require PZC review and
approval. A draft list of those uses is attached (see attachment #7).
CONCLUSION
To address the three workshop items assigned to Community Development by the Board, the Board
needs to authorize staff to move forward with an LDR amendment for certain landscape code and
littoral zone planting regulation items (see attachment #2), an LDR amendment for temporary
suspension regulations (see attachment #3), and an LDR amendment to allow staff approval of
routine projects that currently require PZC approval (see attachment #7). In addition, the Board
needs to authorize an update of development application review fees charged by Community
Development and by Public Works. Those fee schedules will ultimately need to be adopted by a
Board resolution. If authorized to move forward with these items, staff will finalize drafts of the
three LDR amendments and the updated development application fee schedules, obtain public input,
and bring those items through the appropriate adoption processes.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Authorize staff to initiate the formal process to review and adopt LDR amendments for:
a. Chapters 926 and 934 to change certain landscape and littoral zone planting
requirements,
b. Chapter 902 to change certain temporary suspension regulations, and
c. Chapter 971 to allow staff level approval for certain uses
2. Direct staff to finalize an update of development review fees for Community Development
and for Public Works and to present final updated fee schedules with proposed effective date
for Board consideration and adoption.
ATTACHMENTS
1. Commissioner Zorc's May 2, 2017 Board Item and Meeting Minutes
2. Draft Changes to Landscaping Regulations (Chapter 926) and Littoral Zone Regulations
(Chapter 934)
3. Draft Changes to Temporary Suspension Regulations (Chapter 902)
4. Comparison of Application Fees in Other Jurisdictions
5. Draft Preliminary Fee Schedule Update (Community Development)
6. Indian River County Preliminary Fees Comparison to Other Counties
C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@340595C8\@BCL@340595C8.doex 4
P174
7. List of Uses Proposed for Staff Level Approval
8. Public Works Revenue and Fee Data
C:\Users\GRANIC—I\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Technologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@340595C8\@BCL@340595C8.docx
P175
Development Review
Items for Board of
County Commissioners
June 20,2017 Meeting
• April 12 Workshop (Commissioner Zorc &
Staff)
• May 2 Commissioner Zorc follow-up memo
and request to BCC to move forward with:
1. Review of landscape requirements
2. Use of Temporary Suspension provision
3. Review of Development Review Fees
—Community Development fee schedule
—Public Works fee schedule
1a.A. I.
1. LANDSCAPE REGULATION CHANGES
• Revised in 2010 with input from developer,
landscape contractor, environmental groups:
added flexibility
• Based on recent input changes are proposed
to Chapter 926 and 934 to:
— Reduce understory tree height at planting from
6' to 5' in buffer preserves
— Establish flexible planting standards for littoral
zone trees and codify practice of using littoral
zones to provide required irregular pond bank
contours
2. TEMPORARY SUSPENSIONS
• Intended for projects all complete except
for non -safety, minor deficiencies
• Problem identified by staff: long and
complicated punch lists; non -minor items;
inordinate amount of time to resolve
• Impacts Public Works and Utilities; also
Applicants; Planning/Code Enforcement,
Attorney's office
PI'7It-)" -2
• Proposed solution: change code to add list
of minor "suspend -able" items and non -
minor "not suspend -able items"
• Lists relate to Public Works and Utilities
items, not all inclusive but cover most
circumstances
Development Review Fees
• Community Development fees for
development project applications such as
site plans, plats, planned developments
(PDs)
• Updated in 1990 and 2004
• 2004 BCC directive: update every 4 years
• Update delayed due to recession
P. Irl - 3
Current fee schedules: one for Community
Development (site plans, plats) and one for
Public Works (stormwater, right-of-way
permits)
• Project application fees significantly lower
than area counties
• Preliminary calculation of staff costs
(includes advertising and notice costs)
shows significant increase needed to cover
costs but still at or lower than fees charged
by area counties
Fee -related change: streamline approvals for
certain uses that have become routine
• Administrative permit uses: allow for staff
level approval while still requiring special
conditions
• Reduces time and cost for approvals that
are now routine
Change to staff -level approval
• Miniature Golf Course in CH
• Building Material Sales in CG
• Outdoor Storage in CH
• Veterinary Clinic in CG and CH
• Child Care/Adult Care in RM -8, RM -10, PRO, OCR, CN
• Nursing Home in MED
• Accessory single family dwelling in agricultural and residential
districts
• Drug store in CN and OCR
• Used Vehicle Sales in CH
No development criteria or standards will be changed.
P 116-5
Staff Recommendation: authorize staff to
initiate:
1. Landscape code changes
2. Temporary suspension changes
3. Staff -level approval changes
4. Development review fee update:
a. Community Development Schedule
b. Public Works Schedule
Public Works
Building Permit Fee Anal,�sis
• Over the last three -years the following revenue was
generated for building permit review and inspection
services provided by Public Works Engineering staff.
The revenue is a combination of funds transferred
from Community Development and from the current
Public Works fee schedule for single family homes.
• Fiscal Year 14-15 $121,414
• Fiscal Year 15-16 $152,002
• Fiscal Year 16-17 $109,922 (YTD @ May)
P75 - 6
Public Works
Building Permit Fee Analysis
• Staff costs for Building Permit review and inspections
have averaged $264,796.00 per year. When comparing the
annual cost for staff and the revenue collected for
Building Permit review and inspections, there was a
revenue shortfall in the following amounts:
• Fiscal Year 14-15 $143,382
• Fiscal Year 15-16 $112,794
• Fiscal Year 16-17 $ 66,608 (YTD @ May)
• The total revenue shortfall for building permit review is
$322,784 over the last three years. The shortfall results in
a taxpayer subsidy to the fund the remainder of the
building permit review and inspection costs.
Public Works Building Permit
Fee Analysis
• To address the revenue shortfall for Public
Works Building Permit reviews it is
recommended that the current Public Works
Fees for Single Family ROW and Drainage
review be increased from $75.00 for public
r/w and $45.00 for private r/w to $180.00 for
both public and private r/w.
Public Works Building Permit
Fee Analysis
• Utilizing Single Family Residential (SFR) Building Permit
numbers for the last three years the proposed fee increase of
$135.00 for Private and $105 for Public Permits would
generate the following revenue to offset the current shortfall.
• Fiscal Year 14 —15
Private SFR Permits 490 x $135.00 = $66,150
Public SFR Permits 98 x $105.00 = $10,290
Total Additional Revenue $76,440
Shortfall = $143,382
Public Works Building Permit
Fee Analysis
• Fiscal Year 15 —16
Private SFR Permits 603 x $135.00 = $81,405
Public SFR Permits 232 x $105.00 = $24,360
Total Additional Revenue $105,765
Shortfall = $112,794
• Fiscal Year 16 —17 (YTD)
Private SFR Permits 461 x $135.00 = $62,235
Public SFR Permits 68 x $105.00 = $7,140
Total Additional Revenue $69,375
Shortfall = $66,608
Pr76_8
Public Works Building Permit
Fee Analysis
• The proposed fee increase does not take
into account the need for additional
staff to reduce the current review times
or backlog for single family residential
permit reviews, however the additional
fee collection could help fund the
needed staffing increases.
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
• For each of the last three years the following fees have
been collected for Public Works Land Development
and Right -of -Way permit reviews.
• Fiscal Year 14-15 $55,793
• Fiscal Year 15-16 $65,045
• Fiscal Year 16-17 $66,474 (YTD @ May)
• Staff costs for Public Works Land Development and
Right -of -Way permit reviews have averaged $548,650
per year.
P t-75 - 9
Public Works
Development Fee Analis
• When comparing the annual cost for staff and the
revenue collected for Public Works Land
Development and Right -of -Way permit review
process, there was a revenue shortfall in the
following amounts:
• Fiscal Year 14-15 $492,857
• Fiscal Year 15-16 $483,605
• Fiscal Year 16-17 $299,292 (YTD @ May)
• The total revenue shortfall for land development
review and inspection process is $1,275,754 over
the last three years. The shortfall results in a
taxpayer subsidy to the fund the remainder of the
Public Works Land Development Review and
Inspection process.
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
• In order to address the revenue
shortfall for Public Works Land
Development and Right -of -Way
Permit reviews and inspections the
following revisions to the current fee
schedule are proposed:
P. 115-10
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
Category
Current
Proposed
Stormwater Permit (A & B)
$450.00
$ 750.00
Stormwater Permit (C)
$100.00
$ 225.00
Single Family R/W Permit
$45/$75
$ 180.00
Utility R/W Permit
$350.00
$ 600.00
Land Dev. R/W Permit
$550.00
$ 900.00
Comm. R/W Permit
$300.00
$ 600.00
Re -inspection Fee
Hr. Rate
$ 300.00
After 2nd Re -inspection
Plan Review Fee
Hr. Rate
$ 300.00
After 3rd Resubmittal
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
• Fee Schedule Cateeory Additional Revenue FY 15-16
• Stormwater Permit (A & B)
= $ 8,400
• Stormwater Permit (C)
= $12,625
• Single Family R/W Permit
= $ 9,660
• Utility R/W Permit
= $ 1,000
• Land Dev. R/W Permit
= $ 1,050
• Comm. R/W Permit
= $ 3,600
• Re -inspection Fee
N/A
• After 2nd Re -inspection
• Plan Review Fee
N/A
• After 3rd Resubmittal
• Additional Revenue from Proposed
Fees = $36,355
P.1'75 -11
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
• Permit review fees do not cover staff costs after
permits are issued by the Public Works
Department. Once permits are issued, staff deals
with projects on a daily basis including
inspections for right-of-ways, site plans and
subdivisions, permit violations, drainage issues,
project changes, field issues, correspondence with
project engineers and developers, project
closeout documentation, as -built drawing
evaluation, bonding, etc.
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
• The following is proposed to cover staff costs of project
inspections after permit issuance.
• Inspection fees for the portion of construction costs
up to $500,000 will be 2% of Construction Costs.
• Inspection fees for the portion of the construction
costs between $500,001 and $1,000,000 will be 1.5%
of the Construction Cost.
• Inspection fees for the portion of the construction
costs above $1,000,000 will be 1.0% of the
Construction Costs.
The inspection fees will be cumulative to cover the entire
construction cost for the project.
R I75-12
Public Works
Development Fee Analysis
• For example:
• A project with a construction cost of
$1,289,000.00 will have a inspection fee
calculated as follows.
• $500,000 x 2.0% = $10,000
• $500,000 x 1.5% = $ 7,500
• $289,000 x 1.0% = $ 2,890
So, the inspection fee due before permit
issuance is $20,390.00.
Public Works Building Permit
Fee Analysis
• Harmony Reserve 1A
• Construction Cost $1,012,871
• Number of Lots 34 @ $29,790/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $17,628
• Additional Cost per Lot $518.47 or 1.7% of lot cost
• Willows
• Construction Cost $699,376
• Number of Lots 43 @ $16,264/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $12,990
• Additional Cost per Lot $302.10 or 1.85% of lot cost
P,17,5-13
Public Works Building Permit
Fee Analysis
• Millstone Landing— Phases 4-6
• Construction Cost $4,237,121
• Number of Lots 243 @ $17,436/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $49,871
• Additional Cost per Lot $205.23 or 1.17% of lot cost
• Waterway Village 2A-2
• Construction Cost $2,423,241,
• Number of Lots 68 @ $35,636/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $31,732.41
• Additional Cost per Lot $466.65 or 1.3% of lot cost
SUMMARY
• Building permit review fees for Public Works were
established in 2004 and have not been adjusted
since 2004.
• To maintain the current level of service for
development and building permit reviews by Public
Works Staff, a taxpayer subsidy is required to fund
the difference between staff costs and revenue
collected.
• Staff is proposing increases to review fees
established in 2004 and another method of
generating revenue to fund the Land Development
Review and Inspection process to offset the current
taxpayer subsidy required.
(D, Irl 14
Proposed Medical Plan Changes
FY2017/18
Q��VER
�G
\LOR19%
PROPOSED
• Increase employer premiums by $30 per month
• Single coverage $635 per month (currently $605)
• Family coverage $875 per month (currently $845)
• Increase employee premiums by $20 per month moving towards
90/10 and 75/25 premium share target for employer/employee
approved in 2016
• Single coverage $50 per month — 7.3% (currently $30)
• Family coverage $267.50 per month — 23.4% (currently $247.50)
PROPOSED
• Wellness and preventive benefits will be covered at 100% with no out
of pocket cost to the employee
• All deductibles, copayments, coinsurance, and Rx copayments will
count toward the annual out of pocket maximum. Currently, only
coinsurance counts toward the out of pocket maximum.
PROPOSED
•Increase the cost share for advanced imaging from $25 to $100
• Increase the out of network deductible from $400/$800 to
$800/$1600
• Increase the out of network out of pocket maximum from
$3,000/$6,,000 to $4.,000/$8,000
043
PROPOSED
• Eliminate the prepayment of insurance premiums one month in
advance. Payment would occur during the month of coverage. No
prepaid premiums would be collected in September.
s
Z
SUMMARY
• Recommended changes accomplish the following
✓Provides for reserve funding to maintain sustainable plan
✓Moves employee contribution toward target goal of 90/10 and 75/25
✓Eliminates premium prepayment
✓Maintains affordable and competitive plan
✓Removes financial barriers to wellness — integrating wellness with our health
plan design
✓Increases cost share for high cost advanced imaging
✓Provides a true catastrophic out of pocket maximum
✓Provides financial incentive for in -network utilization
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
June 16, 2017
Parcel #: 30382100001999900029.0
Owner Name: RIVERWALK VILLAGE, INC.
Site Address: 1614 US HIGHWAY 1
Mailing Address: 1616 N. US HWY 1
SEBASTIAN, FL 32958
The Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County will hold a P,UBLIC`HEARING on Tuesday, July 18, 2017, at 9:05
am in the County Commission Chambers located at 180127 1h Streee, Vero *Beach, Florida. This meeting is to hear from
benefitting property owners of the sewer project and adoption f
�o,an asses,�ment roll. If the project is approved, your
property will be assessed its fair share cost of the project. The`fair,share cost is based on a Hydraulic Fair Share (HFS)/ERU
allocation. An HFS/ERU is the amount of water used or wastewater produced by a typical residential unit, which water
use ranges from zero to three hundred (300) gallons per day on a maximum day basis or zero to two hundred fifty (250)
gallons per day on a maximum month basis. For example, a single family home is assigned one (1) ERU and
commercial/non-residential units are assigned ERU's based on County Code 201.07. .e potential consumption
calculations were based on the underlying future' an`'ruse designation; zoning, current ERU's on existing parcels with county
water, and the size of each "parent" parcel. This assessment will reside�with the property as a lien until such time as it is
paid in full inclusive of any interest on the original a.ssessed,amount.
The proposed assessment that benefits your property/unit is xxxxxxx which represents an HFS/ERU share of the total cost
of $1,137,519. Please note that the total,construction�cost �is/$2,977;93,1.58 of which the benefitting property owner's
portion is only 38% or $1,137,519.
If the project is approved, the assessed*cost can be -spread oversten (10) years at a special annual interest rate of 2.00%
(set by the BCC). If6austome decid s,t co onnect-to,the-sewer:service they would also incur the following fees.
Sewer Impact�Fee�Per Code 201:09 °� �.� 1-1-11 PERU @ $2,796.00 Each
$2,796.00
Sewer Deposit '\ 1 Deposit @ $50.00 per ERU
$50.00
New Service Fee if not'an existing utility customers'\ 1 New Service Fee @ $25.00
$25.00
Total $2,871.00*
*In addition to assessment fe_es,�
The sewer impact fee can be``ssppread,out over a 5 -year period at an interest rate of 2.00% per year. Details of all related
costs as well as a hypothetical monthly bill are depicted on the attached spreadsheets.
The County will not require payment of the assessment fees or impact fees until the project has been completed or
Resolution #4. At that time, details on payment plans will be provided. An informal INFORMATIONAL MEETING will be
held on Thursday, July 11, 2017 at Sebastian City Hall Chambers, 1225 Main Street, Sebastian, Florida 32958 at 6:00 p.m.
All interested property owners are encouraged to attend. Should you have any questions, please contact the Utilities
Department at (772) 226-1821.
Sincerely,
Arjuna Weragoda, P.E.
Capital Projects Manager
i'R.6. /.
CAPITAL COST BREAKDOWN -OPTION 11
Map ID
No.
Parcel ID
SITE ADDR
-
OWNER NAME
-
IRC
Estimated
ERU's
ERU (HFS) COST
DOR DESC
1
30382100001999900029.0
1614 US HIGHWAY 1
RIVERWALK VILLAGE INC
2
$9,978.24
Stores (1 Story)
2
30383000002001000004.1
1620 N CENTRAL AV
VAR[, ATTILA T AND HEATHER E
1
$4,989.12
Multi -Family (2-9 Unit Buildings)
3
30382100001999900028.0
US HIGHWAY 1
RIVERWALK VILLAGE INC
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
4
30383000002001000004.0
1624 N CENTRAL AV
JMH VENTURES CORPORATION
1
$4,989.12
Stores (1 Story)
5
30382100001999900027.0
US HIGHWAY 1
FISH, GLENN
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
6
30383000002001000002.0
1632 N CENTRAL AV
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
7
30382100001999900026.0
1640 US HIGHWAY 1
STRUNK, GLENN AND DOROTHY
2
$9,978.24
Vacant Commercial Land
8
30383000002001000011.0
1637 INDIAN RIVER DR
MC CANN, SANDRA CALVIN
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
9
30382100001999900025.0
US HIGHWAY 1
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
10
30382100001999900024.0
US HIGHWAY 1
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
it
30382100001999900014.0
1644 N CENTRAL AV
KELLY, RICHARD ARTHUR &
6
$29,934.71
Single Family -Improved
12
30382100001999900022.0
1623 N CENTRAL AV
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY H
1
$4.989.12
/
Mortuaries/ CemeteriesCrematoriums
13
30382100001999900013.0
1654 N CENTRAL AV
SWANIK, JAMES
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
14
30382100001999900012.0
1662 N CENTRAL AV
HALL, HAROLD AND CHRISTINE L
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
15
30382100001999900021.0
1676 US HIGHWAY 1
1676 DUCKS LLC
1
$4,989.12
Offices; Non -Professional, One Story
16
30382100001999900020.0
1683 N CENTRAL AV
SYPHER, RONALD
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
17
30382100001999900011.1
N CENTRAL AV
INDIAN RIVER RV INC
4
$19,956.47
Open Storage, Etc.
18
30382100001999900018.0
1697 N CENTRAL AV
VICTORIA -WILLIAM COMPANY
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
19
30382100001999900011.0
1698 N CENTRAL AV
INDIAN RIVER RV INC
2
$9,978.24
Auto Sales / Auto Service / Auto
Rental / Car Wash
20
30383000001004000011.0
DAVIS ST
SMITH, DALE 5 AND CYNTHIA A
2
$9,978.24
Vacant Commercial Land
21
30383000001004000014.0
DAVIS ST
SMITH, DALE S AND CYNTHIA A
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
22
30383000001003000001.0
1715 N CENTRAL AV
SEBASTIAN MASONIC LODGE NO 232
1
$4,989.12
Clubs / Lodges / Union Halls
23
30382100001999900010.0
616 DAVIS ST
MCBRIDE, HAROLD RJR (LE)
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
24
30393100001000000005.4
612 DAVIS ST
FAIRCHILD BRIAN 1
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
25
30393100001000000004.2
1727 N INDIAN RIVER DR
NILSSON ROBERT TERESA
2
$9,978.24
Single Family -Improved
26
30383000001004000002.0
1716 US HIGHWAY 1
KRASCO LESLIE'
1
$4,989.12
Stores (1 Story)
27
30383000001004000001.0
MADISON ST
KRASCO LESLIE'
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
28
30382100001999900009.0
608 DAVIS ST
NILSSON ROBERTTERESA
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
ri
29
30383000001005000011.0
704 MADISON ST
NEVAREZ PEDRO &
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
30
30383000001005000012.0
MADISON ST
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
2
$9,978.24
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
Hospitals
Q
"T'1
31
30383000001002000009.0
MADISON ST
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
1
$4,989.12
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
Hospitals
V1
M
D
32
30383000001005000003.0
711 JACKSON ST
NEVAREZ PEDRO &
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
(/)
33
30383000001005000001.0
707 JACKSON ST
MARSHALL HARRY J SARA
1
$4,989,12
Mixed Use; Store, Office with
Residential
D
34
30383000001002000001.0
1805 CENTRAL AV
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
1
$4,989.12
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
Hospitals
z
4 -
C
35
30393100001000000003.5
1724 N CENTRAL AV
HOCH REBECCA 5
1
$4,989.12
Mobile Homes
36
30383000001006000000.2
710 JACKSON ST
HART MARIA
1
$4,989.12
Laundries, Various Services, etc.
V)
37
30383000001006000000.1
708 JACKSON ST
HART MARIA
2
$9,978.24
Multi -Family (2-9 Unit Buildings)
38
30383000001001000001.0
698 JACKSON ST
HALL JERRY S' MARSHA
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -improved
42
30382100001000000025.1
12900 US HIGHWAY 1
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
2
$9,978.24
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
Hospitals
0
z
45
30383000010000000000.0
S
$24,945.59
Office Condominium
30383000010000000001.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000002.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000003.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000004.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000005.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000006.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000007.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000008.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000009.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000010.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000011.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000012.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000013.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000014.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000015.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000016.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000017.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000018.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000019.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000020.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
F:\Utilities\UTIL1TY-Engineering\Projects- Utgity Constmalon Permits\IPC-Sewer Feasibility Studies UCP#4101\3. North Sebastian jM&MI\Design Phase\Phase)-Data\S2S-Pha IA -Based Bid Prims.alsn P.
I �� ATTACHMENT 3.
CAPITAL COST BREAKDOWN -OPTION II
FAUtilltles\UnUTY - Engineering\Projects -Utility Construction Permits\IRC - Sewer Feasibility Studies UCP d 4101\3. North Sebastian (M&MJ\Design Phase\Phase 1-0ata\S25-Phase IA -Based Bid Price-lu ATTACHMENT 3.
P175-'nQ3
30383000010000000021.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
46
30382100001000000023.0
13020 US HIGHWAY 1
FAMILY CAR WASH CO INC
6
$29,934.71
Auto Sales / Auto Service / Auto
Rental / Car Wash
47
30382100001000000022.0
13050 US HIGHWAY 1
PTS OF BREVARD COUNTY INC
2
$9,978.24
Professional Services
48
30383000011000000000.0
2
$9,978.24
Office Condominium
30383000011000000001.0
13060 US HIGHWAY 1
ARID. H. OONWALA
1
$4,989.12
30383000011000000002.0
13060 US HIGHWAY 1
M. NASIR & TABASSUM RIZWI
1
$4,989.12
49
30382100001000000021.1
13070 US HIGHWAY 1
SEBASTIAN PARTNERS LLC
3
$14,967.35
Vacant Commercial Land
50
30382100001000000020.2
13090 US HIGHWAY 1
ZAIDI SYED IRFAN H (COTRS) MUNAWAF
2
$9,978.24
Professional Services
51
30382100001000000019.0
13100 US HIGHWAY 1
SHALHOUB HAIR
3
$14,967.35
Professional Services
78.00
$389,151.22
43
30382100001000000025.0
12920 US HIGHWAY 1
FOUNTAIN TOWERS LLC `
2
$9,978.24
Professional Services
44
30382100001000000024.0
12950 US HIGHWAY 1
IRIZWI LLC
3
$14,967.35
Vacant Commercial Land
52
30383600D04001000001.0
13230 US HIGHWAY 1
IGERISEB PL
1
$4,989.12
Professional Services
53
30383600D06000000000.0
91
$44,902.06
Office Condominium
30383600006000000001.0
13262 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
3038360000600D000002.0
13260 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
303836D0006000000003.0
13258 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000004.0
13256 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000005.0
13254 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000006.0
13252 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000007.0
13250 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000008.0
13248 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000009.0
13246 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000010.0
13244 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000011.0
13242 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000012.0
13240 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
54
30382500000004100002.0
13350 US HIGHWAY 1
ROYAL PALM CORPORATE CENTER ASS
75
$374,183.86
Vacant Commercial Land
55
30382500000005000005.0
13480 US HIGHWAY 1
QUALITY HEALTH CARE INC OF FLORIDAI
20
$99,782.36
Vacant Commercial Land
56
30382500000002000003.3
13700 US HIGHWAY 1
JUNO ROAD REALTY LLC
22
$109,760.60
lVacant Commercial Land
57
30382500000002000003.2
13800 US HIGHWAY 1
NATIONAL RETAIL PROPERTIES LP
2
$9,978.24
Banks/ Savings and Loan Assoc./
Mortgage Co. / Credit Services
58
30382500017000000000.0
4
$19,956.47
Office Condominium_
30382500017000000001.0
13830 US HIGHWAY 1
BRADY, VALERIE
0.33
$1,663.04
C
Z
30382500017000000002.0
13832 US HIGHWAY 1
PELICAN NEST LLC
0.33
$1,663.04
z
30382500017000000003.0
13834 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
n
O
30382500017000000004.0
13836 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017000000005.0
13838 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
O
30382500017000000006.0
13840 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
y
30382500017000000007.0
13842 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
m
30382500017000000008.0
13844 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
a
n
30382500017000000009.0
13846 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
O
30382500017000000010.0
13848 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
C
Z
30382500017000000011.0
13850 US HIGHWAY 1
DONOVAN, RICHARD) and PATRICIA W
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017000000012.0
13852 US HIGHWAY 1
DONOVAN, RICHARD and PATRICIA W
0.33
$1,663.04
59
30382500000002000003.1
14000 US HIGHWAY 1
BAY STREET SEBASTIAN LLC
4
$19,956.47
Stores (1 Story)
60
30382500012000000000.0
4
$19,956.47
Medical Condominium
30382500012000000001.0
7740 BAY ST
PETERSON, MARK A and MARY LOU
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000002.0
7744 BAY ST
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000004.0
7746 BAY ST
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000005.0
7750 BAY ST
j KHAWAJA, FARHAT J and MUSSARRAT
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000006.0
7752 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, FARHAN J and SABEEN 1
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000007.0
7754 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, SOBIA (1/3) &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000008.0
7760 BAY ST
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000009.0
7762 BAY ST
THEIS, ALFRED J
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000010.0
7764 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, MUSSARRAT 1(1/2) and
MAHMUDA
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000011.0
7766 BAY ST
BROOKS, HAROLD L JR & BARBARA R
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000012.0
7768 BAY ST
ALI, SABIR MD and ATTIYA
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000013.0
7770 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, MOHAMMAD NAIM and
SHAHIDA NAIM
0.33
$1,663.04
61
30382500000002000002.1
14410 US HIGHWAY 1
CLARITY MEDICAL PROPERTIES LLC
4
$19,956.47
Professional Services
150.00
$748,367.73
228.00
$1,137,519
FAUtilltles\UnUTY - Engineering\Projects -Utility Construction Permits\IRC - Sewer Feasibility Studies UCP d 4101\3. North Sebastian (M&MJ\Design Phase\Phase 1-0ata\S25-Phase IA -Based Bid Price-lu ATTACHMENT 3.
P175-'nQ3
Indian River County Utilities
North Sebastian Septic to Sewer (S2S) Adoption of Resolution I & II
Board of County Commissioners
June 20, 2017
Septic to Sewer (S2S) History
Description
8/8/2013 Board approved WO #6 - Feasibility Study
3/9/2017 Advertised for Bids
4/12/2017 Opened Bids
5/16/2017 BCC Approved Option II for the assessment portion
5/24/2017 Staff presented results at City of Sebastian City Council Meeting
Approved Allocations Based on $2.97M
FUNDING ALLOCATIONS APPROVED BASED ON LOWEST RESPONSIVE,
RESPOSIBL_E BID_ PRICE OF $2.97 M
Percentage
Amount
p�
21.80%
$649,240
20.00%
$595,586
OG�1 �. lOt \►l�: �� .
¢3�
20.00%
$595,586
°�' ' •
38.20%
$1,137,519
$4,989.12
,• � Ii
OG�1 �. lOt \►l�: �� .
I
PARCELS/ NIT COST BREAKDOWN
Tentative Schedule
tfor
jests
ite
P 17,5-6z
Board Consideration
1) Adopt the Providing Resolution (Resolution 1) for the installation of the
sewer main within the North Sebastian Septic to Sewer area, subject to
the terms outlined in the resolution, with a 2% interest rate as
approved by BCC.
2) Adopt the Setting Resolution (Resolution II) setting the time and place
of the Public Hearing—July 18, 2017, at 9:05 am.
Questions?
P t'l
June 16. 2017
Mr. Stan Boling, AICP
Community Development Director
Indian River County
180127 th Street
Vero Beach, FL 32960
RE: Sunbreak Farms
Proposed Compost/Farming Operation
Dear Mr. Boling:
Thank you for taking the time to meet with my client, Mr. Patrick Cheney, and myself. We have
received your request for additional information and have formulated the responses indicated
below. Please note, the ten questions/comments from your June 9, 2017 letter are in bold and our
responses are below in normal typeset. Sunbreak Farms is an active agricultural operation and
therefore is regulated under the "right to farm" legislation. However, in the interest of being a
good neighbor we are supplying this information and look forward to the opportunity to further
educate the county about the farm. Our response is as follows:
1. That the facility will be used solely to amend the soil on the 6,600 acre site in
support of actively and continuously farming feed corn or a similar crop over the
entire subject site except for the Minute Maid Road Reservoir area.
Yes. All production is to be used for amending the soil and supplementing nutrients for crops
grown on the Sunbreak Farms property.
2. That the overall site will continue to be managed for farming under the Florida
Department of Agricultural Services (FDACS) best management practices program,
including any FDACS best management practices and recommendations for
preventing leaching of run-off from biosolids into the soil.
Yes.
3. That the facility will cease accepting compost or biosolids on site if and when the
continuous farming of crops on-site ceases.
Yes. Further, if supplementing the soil results in residual nutrients which are available to the
crop, Sunbreak Farms has no intention of adding compost where none is needed.
10250 SW Village Parkway; Suite 201
Port St. Lucie, FL 34987
772-223-5200
13 D
E3(1A'
ENGNEERS Q SURVEYORS
Indian River County
Sunbreak Farms
RAI Response Letter
4. That mulch from vegetative debris and biosolids will be accepted on-site only twice a
year during fallow periods between crops (roughly June - August and November -
January).
No. Sunbreak Farms has no capability, and is in fact prohibited by the proposed FDEP permit,
from stockpiling biosolids. So biosolids will only be accepted when Sunbreak Farms can
immediately place them on a compost pile to begin composting. But Sunbreak Farms reserves
the right to receive vegetative matter at other times, as it is made available. Please note, the
acceptance and/or storage of vegetative matter is not part of the FDEP permit.
5. That no mulching will be conducted on site and compost will be tilled into the soil
within 90 days of receipt on site; compost will not be stored on site for more than 90
days.
Sunbreak Farms is not conducting a mulching operation on the site, nor is permitted to complete
mulching on the site. Sunbreak Farms IS permitted to receive mulch and FEMA certified
vegetative mulch. Compost will be tilled into the soil within less than 90 days of receipt of
biosolids on site. Composting of biosolids will be completed within 30 to 60 days, in accordance
with the permit conditions. The completed material will then be tilled into the fields within seven
(7) days.
6. That no water or compost will be marketed, sold, or exported from the site.
No compost will leave the site. We don't understand your question regarding marketing, sale and
export of water, however, water will not be sold off the site. Sunbreak Farms will comply with
its permits from the South Florida Water Management District. The marketing language in the
proposed FDEP permit is based in regulations relating to Class AA fertilizer, which in order to
be applied according to BMPs, must be "marketable." To be clear, Sunbreak Farms did not
request the ability to "market" or "sell" the Class AA fertilizer off the site. The marketing and
selling language is a legislative requirement of the FDEP permit. Sunbreak Farms will not sell or
market any compost material off the property.
7. That the 1,500 acre portion of the site lying within Indian River County drains into
the overall system of the 6,600 acre overall site and the 640 acre Minute Maid Road
Reservoir that lies within St. Lucie County.
The portion of the system in Indian River County does not drain in Indian River County, and is
not connected to the surrounding canal systems. The overall system is managed by pumps, not
simply drainage, but generally does drain to the south.
8. That the 6,600 acre facility is subject to South Florida Water Management District
(SFWMD) stormwater management permitting requirements and that compost
containment areas will be established and maintained so as to contain run-off from
a 100- year 3 -day storm.
The ERP for the Sunbreak Farms property must be modified to reflect the construction of the
containment areas, but Sunbreak Farms may not, and will not, proceed with operation under the
FDEP permit until such modification is approved by the SFWMD.
10250 SW Village Parkway; Suite 201
Port St. Lucie, FL 34987
772-223-5200
F0274995.vl
P► I., to
A**
E3[ 11
ENGINEERS 0 SURVEYORS
Indian River County
Sunbreak Farms
RAI Response Letter
9. That the facility will cease accepting compost or biosolids on site if and when the
facility stormwater management system fails to meet the 3 day 100 -year storm
design standard.
Yes.
10. That the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) permit holder
notify the Indian River County Administrator at the time any .permit extension or
modification request is made to the FDEP or its successor agency -
We have no objection and will comply.
Thank you for the opportunity to reply to your request for additional information and we
look forward to working with Indian River County.
Sincerely,
EDC, Inc.
Tobin R. Overdorf
Vice President
Cc: Patrick Cheney
Dennis Corrick
David Baggett
10250 SW Village Parkway; Suite 201
Port St. Lucie, FL 34987
772-223-5200
F0274995M
May 2, 2017
ITEM 14.E.1
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: Members of the Board of County Commissioners
DATE: April 26, 2017
SUBJECT: Follow-up on Development Review and Building Process Workshop
FROM: Tim Zorc
Commissioner, District 3
Discussion Item:
As was discussed at a previous Board of County Commissioner meeting, a workshop
was held to have an open discussion on Development Review and Permitting Process
on April 12, 2017. The workshop provided input from developers, citizens, and the
construction community.
In follow-up to the discussion at the workshop, there are three items which I would like
to move forward with as follows:
Review of the Landscaping requirements
Use of Temporary Suspension for Certificate of Completion Ordinance
• Review of Development Review Fees
- Community Development
- Public Works
Additionally, as a long term solution, it was determined that a new automated system
needs to be investigated to incorporate all review requirements and revenue.
The Utilities Department has provided draft changes to the utility construction standards
for review with a deadline of June 9th for comments to the development and permitting
community as well as the public at large.
These items could be further explored with interested parties, and staff could bring a
report back to the Board with specific recommendations.
Attachment 1
P176
Board of County Commissioners Meeting Minutes - Final May 2, 21
Senate could decide to go with the House version of the Bill, which he felt woul
not be good for Indian River County.
In reference to the additional Homestead Exemption, SB 1774 passed 2 10 to
move forward on the Senate side, and it is feared that the HB 7107 ' also pass.
He also conveyed that the The Florida Association of Counties : sued an alert,
identifying a rumor that the Speaker may introduce a bill red irmg the state to
approve any increase to the millage rate; therefore, giving'local government less
control.
Vice Chairman-O'Bryan suggested forming a caucus with Martin, St. Lucie, and
Okeechobee Counties along with local municipalities, building a bigger voice and
offering support to Legislators and Senaereasure
in the region. He would like the
authority from the Board to speak at V Coast Council of Local
Governments Meeting, bringing uvP e idea of forming a four (4) county caucus.
He also introduced the idea of providing education to local voters, in reference to
the additional Homestead Exerfiption, showing two different real-life scenarios, in
order to help people betternd erstand how the voting outcome would affect the
area.
Assistant County,. Kate Pingolt Cotner was thanked for her time and
efforts in Talla • ssee during the recent Legislative session. She acknowledged the
recognition vised that the Budget was not complete at this time, and supported
the forrnA(of a local coalition, as Vice Chairman O'Bryan had discussed.
i ensued between Commissioner Zorc, Chairman Flescher, and Vice
O' -Bryan, voicing frustrations of not being heard in Tallahassee.
/A motion was made by Vice .Chairman O'Bryan, seconded by Commissioner
Solari, to give authority to Vice Chairman O'Bryan to meet with other local
govemment officials for the purpose of forming a four (4) county caucus to
support Legislative Agendas. The motion carried by the following vote:
Aye: 5 - Chairman Flescher, Vice Chairman O'Bryan, Commissioner Adams,
Commissioner Solari, and Commissioner Zorc
E. Commissioner Tim Zorc
14.E.1. 17-0469 Follow-up on Development Review and Building Process Workshop
Recommended Action: Discussion Item
Attachments: Commissioners Memorandum
Indian River County Florida Page 18
Attachment 1
P177
Board of County Commissioners Meeting Minutes - Final May 2, 2417
Commissioner Zorc gave a brief summary regarding the Development Review and
Building Process Workshop, held on April 12, 2017.
Chairman Flescher suggested for Commissioner Zorc to bring the ideas that came
from the Workshop, to the Board.
Vice Chairman O'Bryan suggested giving staff more authority to make decisions,
as some projects require some creativity to come together in atimely fashion.
Commissioner Zorc agreed to share, with Community Development Director Stan
Boling, the ideas communicated to him at the Workshop; and have Community
Development return to the Board with their ideas and suggestions.
No Action Taken or Required
15. SPECIAL DISTRICTS AND BOARDS
The Board reconvened as the Board of Commissioners of the
District. The minutes will be approved at an upcoming Emer
meeting_ J
A. Emergencyices District
15.A.1. 17-0407 Approval of Minutes Meeting of March 7, 2017
Recommended Action: Approve
Attachments: 03072017 E S D
Approved
Aye: 5 - Chairman
15.A.2. 17-0422
Recommended Action:
Attachments:
Approval
Kncy Services
Services District
, Vice Chairman O'Bryan, Commissioner Adams,
ri, and'CommissionerZorc
utes Meeting of March 21, 2017
A motion was made by Vice Chairman O'Bryan, seconded by Commissioner
Solari, to approve the Meeting Minutes of March 7, 2017 and March 21, 2017,
as written. The motion carried by the following vote:
Aye: 5- Chairman Flescher, Vice Chairman O'Bryan, Commissioner Adams,
Commissioner Solari, and Commissioner Zorc
17-0431 Approval of Amended Property Lease for Temporary Location of Fire
Rescue Station No. 7 '
Indian River County Florida Page f9
Attachment 1
P178
LANDSCAPING AND
LITTORAL ZONES
ORDINANCE 2017 -
AN ORDINANCE OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONCERNING
AMENDMENTS TO ITS LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS (LDRS); PROVIDING
FOR AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 926, LANDSCAPE AND BUFFER REGULATIONS,
PROVIDING FOR AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 934, EXCAVATION AND MINING; BY
AMENDING SECTION 926.06, LANDSCAPE MATERIALS STANDARD, BY AMENDING
SECTION 926.08 PERIMETER BUFFER STANDARDS, BY AMENDING SECTION 926.10
NONVEHICULAR AREA LANDSCAPING STANDARDS, BY AMENDING SECTION
934.06(2) MINING STANDARDS; AND BY PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING
PROVISIONS; CODIFICATION; SEVERABILITY; AND EFFECTIVE DATE.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER
COUNTY, FLORIDA THAT THE INDIAN RIVER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS (LDRS) CHAPTER 926, LANDSCAPE AND BUFFER REGULATIONS,
AND CHAPTER 934, EXCAVATION AND MINING BE ZED AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION #1:
Amend LDR Section 926.06(3)(d) Tree sizes; as fol
I
(d) Tree sizes:
1. Required canopy trees shall b umelve (12) feet overall in height and
two (2) inch diameter at one- h ( a ove grade with a minimum crown
spread of four and one- (4.5) t the lme of planting, except as follows:
a. Unless othe a spe ed in ubsection] (3)(a) above, palms used toward
canopy tree c minimum clear trunk (ground to lowest frond,
measur nk) of ten (10) feet. Where an arrangement of such palms
with ing ht ween six (6) feet clear trunk and eighteen (18) feet clear
tr s propose nd t e average clear trunk of the arrangement is ten (10) feet,
each in the angement shall count as one (1) ten -foot clear trunk palm for
tree can re ement purposes.
b. Narrow, upright canopy tree species, such as varieties of cypress, holly, and
magnolia, shall have a minimum spread of three and one-half (3.5) feet at three
(3) feet above ground level.
c. Where a building between twelve (12) feet and twenty-five (25) feet in height is
proposed to be located within fifty (50) feet of a perimeter property line that
separates the development project from an abutting residential use located
outside the project, canopy trees within required buffers (Types A -C) located
between the building and a site perimeter shall be a minimum of fifteen (15) feet
in height with a three-inch diameter at 0.5 feet above grade at planting and a
minimum six-foot spread. Where a building between twelve (12) feet and
twenty-five (25) feet in height is proposed more than fifty (50) feet from a
perimeter, the canopy tree height requirements of [subsection] (d)1. above, shall
apply to canopy trees within the buffer.
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
94ike *Feugh-: Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017-_ 926 and 934.docx
I
Attachment 2
P179
LANDSCAPING AND
LITTORAL ZONES
ORDINANCE 2017-
d. Where a building over twenty-five (25) feet in height is proposed to be located
within seventy (70) feet of a perimeter property line that separates the
development from an abutting residential use located outside the project, all
canopy trees within required buffers (Types A -C) located between the building
and a site perimeter shall be a minimum of sixteen (16) feet in height with a
three-inch diameter at one-half (0.5) feet above grade and a minimum eight -foot
spread at planting. Where a building over twenty-five (25) feet in height is
proposed more than seventy (70) feet from a perimeter, the canopy tree height
requirements of [subsection] (d)1. above, shall apply to canopy trees within the
buffer.
2. Required understory trees shall be a minimum of six (6) feet overall in height and
one- and one-half (1.5) inches diameter at one-half ) feet above grade at the time
of planting.- exce t as twovided in section 926.0 a for understory trees used
as in -fill material within areas of existine INminiOverall
ti-trunk trees shall have
a combined one- and one -half-inch caliper f (6) inches above grade.
Palm trees used as understory trees shal vela height of six (6)
feet and shall not comprise more tha a-thi he total understory tree
requirement.
SECTION #2:
Amend LDR Section 926.08(4) Pery er b tan rds opaque features; as follows:
(4) Opaque features. Three-fgQ�and s' foot oue features may be required within buffers,
where specified in the land ations.
(a) A required si of op e e shall consist of a solid native plant buffer, a masonry
wall, an eaVrU
co ination berm/vegetation (berm must comprise at least
three (3) feaque feature; vegetation shall consist of shrubs planted in an
off -set douthe planning and zoning commission approves a substitute
material (sely opaque living landscape barrier) based upon the use and
conditions of the project site and adjacent site. Landscaping is required along both sides
of a wall unless otherwise approved by the planning and zoning commission. To
minimize the impact upon existing tree roots in cases where a wall is to be located among
existing trees, such wall shall should be a pre -cast concrete panel wall or other similar
system that minimizes footer impacts to root systems. Wherever a wall is used as the
opaque feature, required understory trees and shrubs shall be planted on the side of the
wall facing a public street or adjacent property, whichever is applicable.
(b) A required three-foot opaque feature may consist of a wall, berm, or a continuous screen
of shrubs. Shrubs planted to form this opaque feature shall be arranged in an off -set
double row.
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
Strike threes Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 926 and 934.docx
2
Attachment 2
P180
LANDSCAPING AND
LITTORAL ZONES
ORDINANCE 2017-
(c) Required three-foot and six-foot opaque features shall be measured from the finished
floor elevation of the proposed structure(s). This requirement may be modified by the
planning and zoning commission based upon grade differences and the relationship
between the height and mass of the proposed building and its setback from the property
line. The maximum required height of an opaque feature shall be eight (8) feet above the
finished site grade where the feature is located.
(d) In cases where an abutting use/district is separated from the project site by a thoroughfare
plan road, the height of a six-foot opaque feature shall be reduced to three -feet, except in
cases where the buffer is to be provided around the perimeter of a single-family or multi-
family residential development as required by subsection 911.07(8) or 911.08(8).
(e) Where understory trees are used as infill material within an area of existing
overall height of 5' or greater.
SECTION #3:
Amend LDR Section 926.10(3) Nonvehicular
required around lakes/ponds including stormw:
(3) Canopy trees required around lakes/pd
For proposed lakes/ponds or lake/pond
lake/pond bank must be designe nc
amenity. Providing an irre2dPXr-Jft4
three native, water tolerai
may be cluster<raise
maintenance. L
areas contig
requirements se
delineated by a
SECTION #4:
dards canopy trees
area; as follows:
%rinwater retention/detention areas.
one (1) acre in area or larger, the
irregular shape to provide an aesthetic
i
t s. Re"dless of size, all lakes/pond shall have at least
d 7one hundred (100) feet of shoreline. The trees
shoreline in a manner that facilitates access for lake
d as required in Section 934.05. The common
the >ttoral zones are subject to the non -vehicular landscaping
, and the landward edges of the littoral zone shall be clearly
Amend LDR Section 934.06(2)(c) Mining standards littoral zone design requirements; as
follows:
(c) Littoral zone design requirements:
1. The slope for the planted littoral zone shall be no steeper than one (1) foot vertical to
ten (10) feet horizontal to a distance of five (5) feet waterward of the designated
planted littoral zone area. Excluding the planted littoral zones, slopes shall not exceed
one (1) foot vertical to four (4) feet horizontal. Certified drawings of the littoral zone
slopes must be sent to the planning division within thirty (30) days of slope
construction.
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
StFike threagh- Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 926 and 934.docx
3
Attachment 2
P181
LANDSCAPING AND
LITTORAL ZONES
ORDINANCE 2017-
2. Littoral zones shall comprise at least thirty (30) percent of the waterbody surface
area, or twenty-one (21) square feet per lineal foot of shoreline, whichever is less.
Littoral zones must be located between one (1) foot above ordinary water level
(OWL) and two (2) feet below OWL, as determined by the applicant's engineer or
designee unless otherwise approved by the community development director or his
designee.
3. The littoral zone shall be provided with a minimum of six (6) inches of sand topsoil
mix, unless otherwise approved, and planted with at least five (5) species at an
average spacing of two (2) feet on center. Inter -plant spacing will vary with species,
and must be depicted on the littoral zone vegetation plan.
4. A minimum of one (1) tree shall be provided for every five hundred (500) square feet
of littoral zone coverage. The proposed trees must minimum of five (5) feet in
height at time of planting (measured at plant' depth) and consist of native,
freshwater wetland varieties (e.g. red bay, rejjoft, bald cypress, loblolly bay).
indicated in the following table:
i.
Littoral Zone 1W
Min. Caliper and
UdggizinaCredits
Nk Min. Hei ht
Tree Credits
0.5
5'
1
1 INd
6'
2
1.25 a
7'
4
2 anM
1 8' or above
6
V
5. Appropriat f oral zone plantings, including trees, are listed in Chapter
926, Ap ix E.
If any clause, section or proton of this Ordinance shall be declared by a court of competent
jurisdiction to be unconstitutional or invalid forany cause or reason, the same shall be eliminated
from this Ordinance and the remaining portion of this Ordinance shall be in full force and effect
and be as valid as if such invalid portion thereof had not been incorporated therein.
SECTION #6: REPEAL OF CONFLICTING ORDINANCES
The provisions of any other Indian River County ordinance that are inconsistent or in conflict with
the provisions of this Ordinance are repealed to the extent of such inconsistency or conflict.
SECTION #7: INCLUSION IN THE CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES
The provisions of this Ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Laws and
Ordinances of Indian River County, Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbered
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
StFike-tom Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 926 and 934.docx
4
Attachment 2
P182
LANDSCAPING AND
LITTORAL ZONES
ORDINANCE 2017 -
or relettered to accomplish such, and the word "ordinance" may be changed to "section", "article",
or any other appropriate word.
SECTION #8: EFFECTIVE DATE
This Ordinance shall take effect upon filing with the Department of State.
This ordinance was advertised in the Press -Journal on the day of , 2017, for a public
hearing to be held on the day of , 2017, at which time it was moved for adoption
by Commissioner , seconded by Commissioner , and adopted by
the following vote: ,
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Bob Solari
Commissioner Tim Zorc �
Commissioner
The Chairman there upon declar 'duly passed and adopted this day of
, 2016.
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court and Comptroller
Deputy Clerk
This ordinance was filed with the Department of State on the following date:
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance 5
StFike tgreu& Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance Attachment 2
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances120170rdinancesi2017-� 926 and 934.docx
W1cj
LANDSCAPING AND
LITTORAL ZONES
ORDINANCE 2017 -
APPROVED AS TO PLANNING MATTERS
Stan Boling, AICP; Community Development Director
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance 6
�� ' ough- Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 926 and 934.docx Attachment 2
P184
Temporary Suspensions
ORDINANCE 2017 -
AN ORDINANCE "bF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONCERNING
AMENDMENTS TO.4TS, LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS (LDRs); PROVIDING
FOR AMENDMENTS TO CHAPTER 902, ADMINISTRATIVE MECHANISMS; BY
AMENDING..SECTION 90204 ROLE OF BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND
SPECIFIC -ALLY REGULATIONS FOR TEMPORARY SUSPENSION OF COMPLIANCE;
AND, -BY PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS,; CODIFICATION;
-,SEVERABILITY; AND EFFECTIVE DATE.
BE,,IT,ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER
COUNTY, FLORIDA THAT THE INDIAN RIVER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS'`(LDRS) CHAPTER 902, ADMINISTRATIVE MECHANISMS, BE
AMENDED AS FOLLOWS:
.i J
SECTION #1:
Land development regulation (LDR),Section 902.04(14), regulations for temporary
suspensions of compliance, shall be ainended to read as follows:
(14)The board of county commissioners may, hear requests for temporary suspensions of
compliance, as provided below.
(A) Purpose and intent. This section is established to provide procedures for reviewing
temporary suspensions of compliance -(including appeals and referrals) by the board of
county commissioners 'and staff. -A temporary suspension of compliance is of limited
duration, pertains to regulations not directly related,,to: p6llic `safety, and is intended to
provide site plan, planned development, and subdivision project applicants an opportunity
to obtain a certificate of occupancy or certificate of completion with a condition that
minor deficiencies are corrected within a specified and limited timeframe. A list of minor
ttQed.'�
(B) Approving authority. The board of county commissioners is hereby authorized to grant
temporary suspensions of compliance in accoitdance with the provisions of this section
and may attach conditions to temporary suspensions .of compliance granted. In addition,
the county administrator or his designee is authorized to grant temporary suspensions of
compliance, in accordance with the provisions of this section.
1. Temporary suspension of compliance by the county administrator or his designee. A
temporary suspension of compliance with land development regulations not directly
related to public safety may be granted by the county administrator or his designee,
without board of county commissioners approval, under the following circumstances.
a. The development project is certified by the project design professional or
owner/designer to be complete and in substantial conformance with the
approved development plan in accordance with site plan ordinance sections
914.12(3)(a) and (b) or subdivision ordinance section 913.07(5)(I), whichever is
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance Attachment 3
F:1Community Development\CurDev\Ordinanees120170rdinances\2017- 902.04(14).docx
P185
Temporary Suspensions
ORDINANCE 2017-
applicable, and required landscaping is certified by a landscape architect or
landscape contractor as Florida No. one (1) or better in accordance with
,landscape ordinance section 926.12(1)(a).
mob. The.development project has been inspected by county staff, a "punchlist" of
" diserepancies has been issued, and the project developer has provided staff a
written request specifying the discrepancies he or she wishes to be temporarily
suspended. -,
C. The project deficiencies that are the subject of the suspension request are found
to be minor in nature and extent, and are found to be correctable within a
timeframe not to.exceed ninety (90) days.
J,
d. The suspension timeframe is specified in writing and does not exceed ninety
(90) days from the date of the suspension.
e. The corrective action(s).is specified in writing and found to be sufficient to bring
th&development project into compliance upon completion.
f. The project engineer, developer, or and owner agree to the specified suspension
timeframe and the obligation to) complete the specified corrective action(s)
within the specified timeframe.
(C) Procedures for approval.by the co u administrator or his designee. The applicant may
apply to the planning division for a_ temporary suspension by filing a temporary
suspension application form provided by the planniing division., The,county administrator
or his designee shall act on any temporary suspension requesv, Within two (2) business
days of receiving the request. For each temporary, suspension of compliance
determination, staff shall provide notice of the determination decision in writing to the
project owner, project developer, and board of county conirnissioners.-.Each suspension
determination granting approval sh'all'specify the maximta duration of the suspension,
required mitigation and/or corrective action(s), andrany conditions) attached to the
suspension. f
(D) Procedure for referral or appeal to the board Of county commissioners. The project
owner, or project developer, may appeal a decision_ of the county administrator or his
designee to the board of county commissioners within ten (10) days of the mailing of the
written determination referenced in subsection (C) above. Each appeal shall be
accompanied by a fee established by resolution of the board of county commissioners.
The county administrator or his designee may refer a request to the board of county
commissioners. Any referral or appeal shall be:
Made in writing to the chairman of the board of county commissioners with a copy
provided to the project developer, project owner, county administrator (if an appeal),
and board of county commissioners. Upon receipt of a referral or appeal, the
chairman shall call a meeting of the board of county commissioners as soon as
practicable to conduct a hearing on the suspension request, subject to the
requirements of subsections (D)2. and 3. below.
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
Str�#r: Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance
F:\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 902.04(14).docx
2
Attachment 3
P186
Temporary Suspensions
ORDINANCE 2017-
2. Noticed at�least seven (7) days prior to the hearing via written notice of the hearing
mailed-toeachiowner of property adjacent to the development project site. The notice
shall contain ,th'e name of the applicant, a description of the appeal/temporary
Z_suspension-requesi and the development project location, as well as the date, time,
�• " and place of the lie anng.
3._1. -Considered at a„eariiig held no more than twelve (12) business days after receipt of
the appeal or referral. At the hearing, the board of county commissioners may
approve a4 emporary suspension request if it finds that all temporary suspension
criteria of subsection (B)La.—f. above are satisfied.
l'
(E) Conditions authorized. Thi county administrator or his designee, or; upon referral or
appeal; the board of county commissioners, may impose conditions including, but not
limited to, a cash deposit which will be forfeited for non-compliance within a time
specified. -
(F) Consequence of non-compliance. In the event that the specified corrective action(s) is
not completed prior to the end of the specified suspension timeframe, the project owner
shall be deemed in violation W& land development regulations, shall forfeit any
required cash deposit for compliance., and'shall be subject to code enforcement action. In
addition, the county shall withhold issuance of any future development order, building
permit, certificate of completion, o'certificateof occupancy associated with the project
site unless and until the.,violation is -corrected, -Notwithstanding the above, a certificate of
occupancy may be issued-fe'r a- sidential unit wit,, ubdivision project site deemed
to be in violation if security(is posted,with the county that. guarantees correction of the
violation. For purposes of these regulations, the -subdivision. project, site shall mean the
development area that is the subject of the certificate of completion:
(G) Limitation. No temporary suspension of corhpjiance shall V6 -granted -for -building code or
fire code items, or other items directly,reiated to public safty.
that
1. Minor deficiencies that can be temporarily suspended:
• Utility Services
a. Engineer of Record's proiect certification, letter
b. Field Inspector's sign -off
c. 24/7 private lift station maintenance agreement
d. Private lift station acknowledgement letter from engineer.
e. If public lift station: set of O & M (Operations and Maintenance
manuals
f. I_f public lift station: transfer of lift station electric account to the County
g. Certified Cost Estimate (OPC; Opinion of Probable Cost)
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance 3
Strike-dweugh- Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance Attachment 3
F:\Community Development,Curl)ev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 902.04(14).docx
P187
ORDINANCE 2017-
h.
Temporary Suspensions
2.
y. As -built surveys r`
Z.
aa. Roadway or parking lot work
bb. Drainage, including soddinakomplete stabilization of all swale slopes
and stormwater tracts
CC. Perimeter grading
dd. Rough grading of lots
ee. Utilities not deemed fully accepted that could lead to open cutting of
roadways and parking lots
ff. Required sidewalks (required by code or approval condition)
gg. Required improvements necessary for traffic operations
Rold Underline: Additions to Ordinance 4
Strike 4hfough! Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance Attachment 3
BCommunity Development\CurDev\Ordinances\20170rdinances\2017- 902.04(14).docx
P188
Temporary Suspensions
ORDINANCE 2017-
If any clause, see- on or protZsion of this Ordinance shall be declared by a court of competent
jurisdiction,to be unconsdiud6nal or invalid for any cause or reason, the same shall be eliminated
from thW6rduiance-and the remaining portion of this Ordinance shall be in full force and effect
and l a as valid, as"if such invalid portion thereof had not been incorporated .therein.
The provisions of.any other Indian River County ordinance that are .inconsistent or in conflict with
the provisions of -this Ordinance are repealed to the extent of such inconsistency or conflict.
The provisions of this,Or'dnance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Laws and
Ordinances of Indiart River County, Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbered
or relettered to accomplishsuch, and th ,word ordinance may be changed to "section", "article",
or any other appropriate word.
SECTION #5: EFFECTIVE DATE
This Ordinance shall take effect upon filing Wphlthe Department of State.
This ordinance was advertised in the =Press Journal on the day .of- , 2017, for a public
hearing to be held on the day off , 2017, at`which time it -was moved for adoption
by Commissioner , seco_ nded by Commissioner ' . , and adopted_ by
the following vote:
Chairman Joseph`l. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Bob Solari
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Susan Adams
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
The Chairman there upon declared the ordinance duly passed and adopted this day of
22017.
BY:
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
)Bold Underline: Additions to ordinance 5
Strika-thteugl - Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance Attachment 3
F'\Community Development\CurDev\Ordinance s\20170rdinances\2017- 902.04(14).docx
P189
•Ct1 .Wow iin
Temporary Suspensions
:ST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of Court and Comptroller
Deputy Clerk
:nt of State on the following date:
SUFFICIENCY
-1
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
APPROVED AS TO PLANNING MATTERS
Stan Boling, AICP; Community, Developmen# Director'
Bold Underline: Additions to Ordinance
Stfike lhreugW Deleted Text from Existing Ordinance Attachment 3
F:1Community DevelopmentlCurDcvlOrdinaneesl20110rdinances12017- 402.04(34).docx
P190
APPLICATION FEE COMPARISON
Fee Category Indian River County St. Lucie County Brevard County Martin County Osceola County Sarasota County Volusia County
Effective 1-17-17 Effective 10-1-16 1 Effective 11-1-16 Effective 10-1-16_
Planned Development
Less than 20 acres $2,375
Less than 20 acres $5,400
$13,800
$2,456 + $30 per acre or any
Rezoning/Conceptual Plan
20-40 acres $2,775
20-49 $5,400 + $10 per
additional fraction thereof, +
Request
Over 40 acres $2,875 + $100.00 for
acre
$8 per dwelling unit for res
each additional 25 acres over 40
49.01+ $5,400 + $25 per
acres
acres over 50
Planned Development
Less than 20 acres $2,075
20 lots or less $91 per lot
Special Exception
2040 acres $2,475
21 lots or more $1,814+.$37
Request
Over 40 acres $2,575 + $100 for
per lot for every lot over 20
each additional 25 acres over 40
acres
Preliminary PD Plan
Less than 20 acres $1,150
$13,600 minor
$6,500
20 lots or less $1268 per lot
20-40 acres $1,250
$16,600 major
21 lots or more $2,524 + $37
Over 40 acres $1,300 + $50 for each
per lots over 20
additional 25 acres over 40 acres
Final PD Plan
$1,400
$2,400
$3,389 + $87 a lot
$9,127
20 lots or less $54 per lot
2I or more $1,078 + $37 per
lot over 20
PD Plan for Minor
Charge administrative approval or
$1,000
$259
Modification
minor site plan fee (Planning
Director to determine
PD Plan for Major
Charge same as for original plan
$2,000
$3,750
$821 for map amend add
Modification
review
$30 per acre or any fraction
thereof, + $8 per dwelling
unit for res
DRI Review Residential
Less than 40 acres $3,300
Up to 50 acres $3,000
$17,334 + $43 per
$24,000
$600
$8,014 + consulting fees
40 acres or more $3,300 + $150 for
50.01- 499.9 acres $5,000
acre
each additional 25 acres over 40
500+ acres $7,000
acres
$43,400
DRI Commercial/Mixed
Less than 500,000 sq. ft. $3,900
$8,014 + consulting fees
Use
500,000 sq. ft. or more $3,900 +
$300 for each additional 50,000 sq.
ft. over 500,000 sq. ft.
DSame
formula as oriinal fee
$43,335
$24,000
YffAmendinentJ
$1,500
$750
$3,800
$1,973 + consulting fees
DRI Annual Re
$500.00
$1,000
$500
FACommunity Development\CurDev\OtdinamesUO170rdinancesNppFces\Foe Comparisons.doc
19
Attachment 4
APPLICATION FEE COMPARISON
Fee Category Indian River County St. Lucie County Brevard County Martin County I Osceola County I Sarasota County Volusia County
Effective 1-17-17 1 Effective 10-1-16 1 Effective 11-1-16 Effective 10-1-16
Rezoning
Less than 5 acres $1,550
$2,250 less than 10 acres
$849 + $24 per acre
$1,000 mandatory
$1,665
$7,500
$957 + $30 per acre or any
540 acres $2,000
plus $10 per acre
over 5
$3,115 non-
additional fraction thereof
Over 40 up to 100 acres $2,300
10.01+ acres $2,500 plus
mandatory
Over 100 acres $2,500 + $200 for
$25 per acre
each additional 25 acres
Land Use Plan
Less than 5 acres $3,000
Less than 10 acres $1800
Amendment
5-40 acres $3,800
10.01- 20 acres $2,000 +
Over 40 up to 100 acres $4,400
$20 per acre
Over 100 acres $4,500 + $200 for
20.01+ acres $2,500+ $25
Small scale $1,471.00
each additional 25 acres
per acre over 20.01
Large scale $6,700
Large scale $2,406 + $50 per
Small scale $3,000
acre not to exceed $6,000 for
land use
Amendment to Text of
$2;600
$5,000
$1,785 + $43 per acre
$8,150
$5,000
Comprehensive Plan
Element Other than Land
Use
Amendment to Text of
$1,500
$2,550
1,733
$6,100
Do not have, LDR changes
Land Development
can only be initiated by
Rerulations
Board of staff.
Administrative Approval
$200
Major $625
$3,850
$500
AA for Fence
$75.00
Minor $400
Pre -Application
Site plans free
$250 credited to formal
$2,135 site plan
$580 non PUD
$350
$131
Subdivision $300
a
$2 755 subdivision
$1,100 PUD
Minor Site Plan
$650.00
Residential $1,000 plus
$3,145
$8,750
$1,314
$10 per acre
Non-residential $1,700
plus $10 per acre
Major Site Plan
Less than 5 acres $1,000
Less than 10 acres $2,000
$3,960 + $360 acre
$12,000
$4,000 + $600 per
50,000 sq ft or more but >
5-10 acres $1,200
10 - 49 acres $2,000
adjusted gross acre
200,000 sq. ft./50 or more,
10 acres or more $1,400
49.01+ acres $2,000 + $10
but > 150 dwelling units:
per acre over 50
$1,971
200,000 sq. ft. + / 150 or
more dwelling units: $2,760
Major Modification to SP
Same as original fee
$850 up to 49.01 acres
Y4 of original fee +
$12,000
$850 plus $10 per acre
2,000
over 50 acres
F:1Cammmdty Development\CurDL-AOrdinances\20170rdmances\AppFees\Fee Comperisons.doc
Attachment 4
APPLICATION FEE COMPARISON
Fee Category Indian River County St. Lucie County Brevard County Martin County Osceola County Sarasota County Volusia County
Effective 1-17-17 Effective 10-1-16 Effective 11-1-16 Effective 10-1-16
Appeal bApplicant
$400
$1,500
$1,200
$1,000
$500
Appeal by Affected P
$800
Preliminary Plat
10 acres or less $700
Up to 50 acres $3,735
$3,400
$3,750 + $337.50 per
20 lots or fewer $126 per lot
More than 10 acres $950
+ $36 per lot + $90
adjusted gross acre
21lots or more $2,524+ $37
per acre
per lot over 20
Over 50 acres $5,335
+ $36 per lot + $90
per acre
Final Plat
$1,400
$3,389 + $87 a lot
$2,700
$3,750
20 lots or fewer $50 per lot
21 lots or more $$1,008+
$34 per lot over 20
Plat Vacation
$800
$1,624
$1875
Variance (Board of
$800
$850
$598
$270 administrative
$1,000
$650
$600 (double ATF)
Adjustment approval)
$690 non-
administrative
Written Zoning
$50
$37.50
$158
$100
$100
$39
Confirmation
FACotmnunity Development\CurDev\Odinancest20170rdinenusWppFees\Fee Comparlsons.doc
Attachment 4
APPLICATION FEE COMPARISON
Fee Category Indian River County St. Lucie County Brevard County Martin County Osceola County Sarasota County Volusia County
Effective 1-17-17 1 1 Effective 10-1-16 Effective 11-1-16 Effective 10-1-16
Per lnhn'c rrnnr_ethe1nw are emmp. frr_c nther mimirinalitiec rharae that we, do not
Extension
$0
1 $1,500
1
$595
$500
$162
Resubmittal
$0
3"a and subsequent 30% of
3'" or subsequent fees
Varies by
20 or subsequent $225 3or subsequent
21 and subsequent 10% of
original fee
based on what
application type
$1,000
original fee
department reviews
still needed
FACommunity Developmrnt\CurDev\Ordinances\20170tdinances\AppFees\Fee ConVwlsons.doc
Attachment 4
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2017 PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR "AVERAGE" APPLICATION BY TYPE
• Only a portion of Administrative approvals (AAs) regfdre a Tragic review, only those AAs requiring aTraffic review witl be changed an additional fee
Only a Potion of Temparary Use Permits require a Traffic andftir PW (Public Works) review, Onty those TUP applications requirings Traffic andifor PW reviewwiii be changed en additional fee
•^ Temporary Suspension fee's nominal tee covering only a podion of staff time to process, inspect, and manage requests
NOTE:` eaw- -."d. maMed..k Mn Mb. H--dwMW ft e- RaMwheu�r IncM1k�t.N�w.-hNrr-M--aMtime,aM Wro0 WWnhir�tlm fMwAh o^^M^�tla,.
F:1Camunky omebpeMmh StlM *M=j 7,eNew,hhe8rt q FM S,ba" wa+ PUEBe Wake span ows
-$For application types showhi:
Last 12 months under current teas: - 5 10D.900.00
Last 12 -months under preliminary teas: S 322:630.61
AddBbnel i2 moW t6vrelaio una t proifiinary fans: S '221,730,87
Attachment 5
Calculated
current
Additional
PERMIT/REVIEW
intstratMe Approval (RA)"
IPZC r viewer-6dd $67A4
lPZCrevlew Bed add $300
encefWallAA ------------------
Site Plan ($PMN)#,
iPZCreview uied.edd:3300
aor aviewr (SPMJ)#
Re
1PZCreNew uBedadd3300
eda,121.3
lExceptlon
••-- ... '
dver6ah Gusts: 5575.00
OW-Aban4onmerrt•
............._ ___ _•,-__
tiver0ain Costs: 5482.00
nceptuaiPO
dver0£Bi Costs: $470.00
t5davttolExampttcn........
DRaxGn i!S................
dver6skr Costs; 51.130.00
IatVatatlon
ariance ejjW�gCosts: $324.00'--••
.............................
""""' ' ' ""
PPagi......................
!B E!PP....................
tmina PD orPiat
IrmIPlBtorPD -._.._..--•4:004
Sr. Env
Planner
kour)(Rato
$38A8
1.500
357,84
0.000
-------30.00
3.000
111538
5.004
3,182.50
5.000
11 -----
.1.000
-•---•-----•-
5.48
7.500
$288.45
t:OW
538' S
7S
4288:5
_ 0.500
559.82
0.0
f0:00
3.000
1 S5.
" "'
S38A6
GIS
Planning
Tech
wiltxilata
530.44
_0250
-• rl.fit
_ ...0.250
47.61
__.._..0.500
1,15.23
0.750
322:65
0.500
.---
555.22
- 0.250
" 57.61
5500
345.55`3236.78
-_ 0540
515.22
i 2404
...-_..__...
560.88
i 0250
) 5761
0.250
tl 57.61
(..:115
;15.22
4.000
`5307:
2.000
"""""""
$60.88
Section
_ Chief
ate
HourxRate
559,69
4250
5746 1
---...0.250
114.92
1.600
----•-584.54
25011
5,149.23
3.500
.....I.....i.
$208,92
'1.500
589.54
.._....x.000
2
`±159,58
4.000
_...._
52776
....,: 2000
19.38
57Kkq 2
10:38
3,
_... _...
5179,
.......1: ; ..
S 69
2604'
5149.23
._x!':1.500
' ' 389.54
0.250
474.92
Planning
Tech.
Hour
$3020
O51>D
15, 0
5 1
0500
415.,10
/500........1500
54584.
.1500
345.30
1500
_......••••-•
54534
4504
S154D
_..
545 0�1;500
1504:_...ca•S?00.
51530
j tAoO:
...
1 59020
f 000
...---
S902d
........0.500
i 415.70
aSOa
i 515nd
_.d.... 0500
/ 115.14
15041
14544.•
_•_.__,4•SD6:._.,r�_.�n.:A00......12A�Q.:
515.10
0250...•
5755'
Planning
Asst.
Hour
530,20
2)04
_..,.. OAD
56
'0.750
522.65
34580
.2.000
.......................................
S6dA0
3:000
.......--
194)0
1000
5 3020
-33)00
133020
i 3)40
--'
59460
- 5000
( .. _
143020
0.760
322)5
4004
20
53089
f.... L 0580
15.10
2)04
56040
560)0
0,750
32205
Senior
Planner
Hour
140,70
2.44
... rf8020
1:000
S40.t0
5.000
-$200,54
20.000
5802)0
27)00
5108270
10.000
5441 A0
13.000
80
t5.000
--$601:50
•11 7.000
$681.70
.. 400
S20A0
12:000
$48120
A. 10400
5101)0
.....} 5.00........Qil
520058
5 .0041
548120
$48110
'0.750
S3DA8
DIRECTOR UTILITIES
1404 It Rate .1101x.%Rate
534,34
0.250 Q.5QQ
42129 5 17.16
0350 0.500
$21.29 i17.f6
0,750
563.87 102 6
1.000 4000
........
S85.f8 413728
4500 2.500
538322 185.80
1:000 2,000
385.1fi $69:54
6.500 3:000
5363.22 3101595
I:� .. X250
.585.18 .58
_4540 _ .0:..._
^._ _..._... , 040
1 385.72 $0:00
1.004 0:400
�.
505,18 $0.00
'3.004 �r,.•,t0:0�
255)3 E $0,00
3 000 a 004
255.45' -``94'90
6 -_, 4;006
�I 588:&1
1,• 3.000
517.74/ 70296
....�i'_�.......2n
54258 f68.64
0250 O.5m ................,
$21.29 45578
Sr. Legal
ATTORNEY Assistant
kourxRate A06fRRat
$7951 147.38
0.254 025
69.89 Efi $
__ __ 4,000 0.
••-•••••• -
$OA0 $000
$3477 5478
0.300 „_,,,1000
...
$S9.TT 547.38
1.000 ... 0:000'__..._9
$7954 10.40
0.800 _ _. 0000
539.77 30.0
....0600 ....000
539.77 S0.
__. _?_000 �0-...
159:08 547980
E_.._ �_`'4Q 0.00
$119.31 $0.00
4.500 0040
$39J7 f0.00
�- 1.640 0000
__.. _
11981 50.00
0 750 ,.... :.
9.66 $0.00
AQO �# ...q
51.00 10)0
a.5po 4.400
6if. Su.00
....-.4:�....5t5:..
3S18.f6 S?,10.70
4.000 2
50.00 19476
TRAFFIC
HourXRate
AO
-
SOHO
- --•........
5a0a
1168.50
__•,.,6;000
5404.00
0...._....,.,4.750
330344.
............. 00..•...•
357)0
PW LAND
DEVELOPMENT
: Hourx'kete
158.50
.500
......... ,16625
0.750
34988
..................
536.000
„•_•.,. 8.400
5532)0
33!588
2.000
5133.00
SURVEYOR
HourxRate
(8001
0.000
10.00
----•.......
10.00
1..000
52000
$S21h50
......2.000
5121.50
_, 1.000
f50.
Current Fee
Schedule
------------
Calculated
Update Fee
-----------
Number
of Apps
las[ 52
months
-------•-
schedule
revenue
generated las
12months
Revenue last
12 months If
now fees
applied
-------
--•-----------
5200.
............
f75A
.......•--•,
5650,0
51000.4
-----"--_••
12475.0
3700.4
5532:04
...:.......
4,188.74
----..._...
21 9SA
52 39.
...........
$3 99.2
434
......:a
1?
3 25.800.00
. i....
S 2,475.00
..............
$ 7.150.04
544:493.70
---S3,T52.35
f8i78.t
17
........ 5...•_...._....
3 17.400.00
3 10.37 ,
S2T,f72.zT
_...00 $7,._..._.
41 488
090.1
...
$2,512.8
3
�
..............
$ 2,100.00
..............
$
5 4000.00
.... ........ _..
#1645)8
M 6)00
3404)0
_... :�0.....
587)0
6.000
539100
...�WQ
S665A0
It000
60.75
_ _ 5.000
4303.75
32.375,0
.........
f0A0
"- -'
3f 040.
56.051.3
!_9
$30340
.._......._:4.000
1286)0
....._.4 040
i6 ,75
I ....
12,475.
..........
f3A53a
.........
•-----•.......
$ 2,575.00
.........
t, 8.1
1- 11 4
1587)0
8.504
$58525
5.440
SB .75
5800.4
S1 85;7
......:....
it 165,8
Q
....... t
$
_......W66.6,
8 800.04
_»
$0.0
"4
533.70
5:500
/ 599.75
0. 00
f .04
...........
5800.0
_........__...
83.80
4500
$33.70
__
...._..._.. 0.250
(1888
....._ °• -
i .o0
•--::..:_.:
5400.0
......
3996,
.....................
S
.........._,_ .
0• 00
�._6?�
33.70
E 1,000.,
$1101.10
.._ 1:000
f2B8A0'60.00-11500
7:000
548550
0.
3.
516
) .........
...........
.........
...
..............
ii
S.
'f17012
6
,_._..4
........
S 5,750.00
;010.77
...... ..-..-.
55.3
_..:�.0°••+q6----.,,..
333.70
...................-,-_-.-,•
_..._ 110)0
T:S�S
f49&75
_--,-----_f0A0
-5384.50
...,., i10_.
.._• 10.00
�...........
S1 Ob
._.
- _175.0..._
...........
$2782.67
122583
.......
----• 90
S 5.600.00
$•-_6,750.00
55:530.4
3;555
am ore UseParmh'•
...................
0.250 0.250
0 ...
$4,52 $7.6f
!Tni treview-add'WAS:It PW
___
an Garttimatbn tatter
...-•..........
nttyofi46e
issofu0onofutltjoflitie
ani Suspension ......................50.00
,..D -
review -add 5332.50'56
.......
$2.88 12.28
x.500 0.000
............. ..........................
519.23 .00
9054 5500
51:02 $45.66
0.000 0.500
..... ...... ............
$15.22
- ...•• -.
"'
's4,0d ^" $0:00
$4A8
0.540
$29A5
4.760
$41:77
0.004
40,00
•...•••••50)0
-
SdAd
52,27
0004
.............
.50.00
0000
SOHO
. .• .•...0.000•.
_.._....
60.00
$684
0504
........•----
$55.10
OS4D
15.10
O.t)".----••0.OQO.......0,000.._...D:ti00,...._0;2
_
BdAU
$9.02
• S.ODO
540.14
,0.504
320)3
--•.•SOHO
116 bb
6.39 $5.15
'0,000 '0,000
50)0 .50.00
0.004 : 0:000
.........
$0.00 60.00
-50.00 SOHO
_..::'
.$4.00 50.00
$0.00 12849
0.000 OA00
S4A0 SO.00
6.250 4'
............ ...........
$5$89 57,1.07
7 ..
-659.88 571.07
...._..60.00 '--...
51885
:0:000
10.00
518.63
.----...._ 0.000
40.00
30.00
0.4
50.08
575.0
'5101,56
S 4.204.00
$i 55.23
5sb.o
............
30.0
5104.2
...........
4255)
......96
8 4.700.00
t^___'•----..
S
35.101.85
•_-•_•-0:?0..._.......
5111.00
4.040
90)0
...,..:0004
511.00
_.
,1408.
-$21,4
0•2W
69bu
ObO,.....,.--539
4.000
110)0
sd
O.OdO
_
0.00
...._ -5000
. _ 7§.D
if6A0
$106.1
..
$ 825.00
$54293
•,5700.0
24
.........
...........
6, -
....
�h4Gd:00
• Only a portion of Administrative approvals (AAs) regfdre a Tragic review, only those AAs requiring aTraffic review witl be changed an additional fee
Only a Potion of Temparary Use Permits require a Traffic andftir PW (Public Works) review, Onty those TUP applications requirings Traffic andifor PW reviewwiii be changed en additional fee
•^ Temporary Suspension fee's nominal tee covering only a podion of staff time to process, inspect, and manage requests
NOTE:` eaw- -."d. maMed..k Mn Mb. H--dwMW ft e- RaMwheu�r IncM1k�t.N�w.-hNrr-M--aMtime,aM Wro0 WWnhir�tlm fMwAh o^^M^�tla,.
F:1Camunky omebpeMmh StlM *M=j 7,eNew,hhe8rt q FM S,ba" wa+ PUEBe Wake span ows
-$For application types showhi:
Last 12 months under current teas: - 5 10D.900.00
Last 12 -months under preliminary teas: S 322:630.61
AddBbnel i2 moW t6vrelaio una t proifiinary fans: S '221,730,87
Attachment 5
Indian River County Preliminary Development Review Fees Comparison
Application Type St. Lucie Brevard Martin Sarasota Volusia IRC Current IRC Preliminary
Adminstrative Approval
$625.00
---
$3,850.00
$500.00
---
$200.00
$532.04
$1,010.00 * or
Minor Site Plan
$1,710.00 *
$3,145.00
$8,750.00
---
$1,314.00
$650.00
$1,393.47
Major Site Plan
(4 acre site)
$2,000.00
$5,400.00
$12,000.00
$6,400.00
$1,971.00
$1,000.00
$2,639.55
Preliminary Plat
(40 acres, 100 lots)
---
$10,935.00
---
$17,250.00
$5,484.00
$950.00
$1,901.27
Final Plat
---
$12,089.00
---
$3,750.00
$3,728.00
$1,400.00
$2,782.61
PD Rezoning/
Conceptual PD
(40 acres, 120 lots)
$5,800.00
---
$13,800.00
---
$4,616.00
$2,775.00
$3,653.17
* St. Lucie: for 1 acre site $1,010 residential; $1,710 non-residential
Attachment 6
STAFF LEVEL APPROVALS
USES THAT SHOULD HAVE STAFF LEVEL APPROVAL
The following administrative permit uses have specific land use criteria and are specially regulated
in LDR Chapter 971. Some administrative permit uses are allowed to be approved at a staff level,
but most require Planning and Zoning Commission (PZC) review and approval. Routine uses that
currently require PZC review and approval should be changed to staff level approval are listed
below:
• Miniature Golf Course in CH
• Building Material Sales in CG
• Outdoor Storage in CH
• Veterinary Clinic in CG and CH
• Child Care/Adult Care in RM -8, RM -10, PRO, OCR, CN
• Nursing Home in MED
• Accessory single family dwelling in agricultural and residential districts
• Drug store in CN and OCR
• Used Vehicle Sales in CH
No development criteria or standards will be changed.
Attachment 7
P197
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2017 PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR "AVERAGE" APPLICATION BY TYPE
Administrative Approval (AA)
Current Rates
$183.38
5au.zu
$10.50
,wu.iu
$52.50
?w.v;w
$3050
Number of
Revenue Revenue.'
134
$12,529.00
Staff time Planning Staff Time Current Applications
Generated for Curr Generated for Curr Current Fee
�-
$0.00
Current Cost Only- Current Fee Development - last 12
Dev, - Current Fee Dev - Proposed Fee Schedule
$15.25
PERMIT/REVIEW
Calculation Staff Assistant Sr. Planner Planning Chief Schedule* New Calculations* months
Schedule Schedule (minimum fees)
$1,716,00
$2,442.00
$2,563.19
$3,688.69
Old Rates $21.00 $35.00 $61.00
Minor Site Plan (SPMN)
$444.75
Administrative Approval (AA)
Current Rates
$183.38
5au.zu
$10.50
,wu.iu
$52.50
?w.v;w
$3050
$93.50
$215.21
134
$12,529.00
$28,838.48
$200.00
Fence/Wall AA
$0.00
$10.50
$26.25
$15.25
$52,00
$77.67
33
11
$1,716,00
$2,442.00
$2,563.19
$3,688.69
$75.00
$650.00
Minor Site Plan (SPMN)
$444.75
$21.00
$140.00
$61.00
$213.50
$222.00
$514.50
$335.34
$1,011.63
17
$8,746.50
$17,197.63
$1,000.00
Major Site Plan (SPMJ)
$884.44
$1,351.94
$21.00
$84.00
$280.00
$420.00
$366.00
$870.00
$1,382.22
5
$4,350.00
$6,911.08
$2,075.00
Special Exception
R Abandonment
$686.50
$42.00
$245.00
$183.00
$470.00
$520.74
3
$1,41090
$1,562.21
$700.00
-O -W-
Conceptual PD
$1,691.75
$84.00
$525.00
$427.00
$1,036.00
$850.66
0
4
$0.00
$1,930.00
$0.00
$3,004.32
$2,375.00
$1,000.00
Affidavit of Exemption
$2,161.25
$10.50
$35090
$665.00
$122.00
$427.00
$482.50
$1,176.00
$751.08
$1,011.06
1
$1,176.00
$1,011.06
$2,375.00
PD Rezoning
$1,838.25
$778.88
$84.00
$42,00
$245.00
$183.00
$470.00
$470.38
0
$0.00
$0.00.
$800.00
Plat Vacation
$803.56
$73.50
$350.00
$610.00
$1,033.50
$623.23
1
$1,033.50
$623.23
$800.00
Variance
Appeal
$799.69
$42.00
$210.00
$366.00
$618.00
$610.27
0
$0.00
$0.00
$400.00
Pre -Application Conference
$435.75
$21.00
$122.50
$91.50
$235.00
$275.29
89
5
$20,915,00
$2,170.00
$24,500.81
$3,454.13
$0.00
$1,150.00
Preliminary PD or Plat
$857.69
$10.50
$210.00
$213.50
$61.00
$434.00
$351.50
$690.83
$631.14
4
$1,406.00
$2,524.54
$1,400.00
Final Plat or PD
$1,364.00
$69.63
$10.50
$15.75
$280.00
$17.501
$15.25
$48.50
$67.65
90
$4,365.00
$6,088.28
$75.00
Temporary Use Permit
$77.75
$15.75
$26.25
30.501
$72.50
$85.05
94
$6,815.00
$7,994.23
$50.00
Zoning Confirmation Letter
$135.75
$5.25
$8.75
$15.25
$29.25
$79.92
98
$2,866.50
$7,831.92
$75.00
Unity of Title
Dissolution of Unity of Title
$0.00
$5.25
$8.75
$15.25
$29.25
$0.00
11
$321.75
$0.00
$0.00
* Current Fee Calculations includes Staff Assistant; Sr. Planner; Planning Chief
Current Development Staff Time 100% (1950 hrs/year) @ Current Rate
Current Development Staff Time 80% S.A.; 60% Sr. Planner; 50% Planning Chief
(1950 hrs/year) @ Current Rate
$253,480.50
$152,226.75
NOTE: staff ao,mm are averaged, rounded and mdude t enefft Hours rounded to quarter hours, Review hours induce rev time, meedag preparation and time, end project adminmtratioa through ooa,PleWn
C.tUamslsgagnonlDesktopiPrehmirmry Draft Fee Schedule v PVW. Worle: figures 061317
$74,192.25 $117,793.76
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2017 PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS&ABOR ESTIMATES FOR "AVERAGE"APPLiCATION BY TYPE
NOTE:stn!IukiVes aro --VC --,W - iI,WCa 8erwrds- -n .,- - Re - lnclWe - -, --tpp -and-,-OINK
COSTS u,8OR EST -ES WITHOUT HEALTH DEPT FIGURES REIS V1
Sr, Planner
Hour.x Rate
DIRECTOR
Hour x Rate
UTILITIES
Hour x Rate
-fi�v
ATTORNEY
Hour, x Rate
0.25
$119.8s
0 0015
-0 500
0500
$39.
-1 0-10
Sr.Legal
Assistant
HO ur x Rate
1.54 1;07�iy
$0.00
-1 000
000
0.006
. . ... ...... -
$0.00
TRAFFIC
Hour x Re
I.=
$ 7 0
$0.00
PW LAND
DEVELOPMENT
Hour x Rate
........... PW.�d -- -----
-
4WU
1
-----LM.2
1500
$99.76
$19..71
SURVEYOR
Hour x Rate
` 6
IMIJ
$0.00
Current Fee
Schedule
$200.00
$75.00
Proposed
Fee
Schedule
. . .....
$300.00
....... . ....... I . .......
$300.00
5675X0
Applications
last 12
months
. . ........... ...... . ........
134
33
..... .........
Additional
Revenue
PERwiftEvIEW
........ ... .. .. .......... -- ..... .. ........ ....
Sr. Env
Planner
Hour x Rate
... ........
----�xxtr
GIs
Planning
Tech
Hour x Rate
t-56:44 ..... .......
4
Section
Chief
Hour x Rate
W:65* ... ........
planning
Tech.
Hour XRato
m. . id ... ..
Planning
Asst,
HourxRate,
.....
dministrative Approval (AA)*
rf PZC review re uired add $300
enceNvalt.�� ... ..........
Minor S
............... q�Lnn-emn
]
K PZC review require d add $30 0
M�JRI:5,ite Plan kSPMj)
PZC review red add $30
recut
S ............
1.5 0
$57.69
-1291)
.. ...
$0. 3
.......... j-jj�-jj ........
0
$192,30
0,250
$7.61
0:1250
. ............ .. . ... ..........
$
. . -jiK22
-
0750
$2283
-
0,500
$1612
1250
0250
1500
...........
$89,54
-2500
$149,23
-3.500
$208.92
0.
0.
1,500
-
. ..... 1500
30
-1.500
545.
- 2,000
...... ....... 03F0
65
1.500 ............
............. . 2.000
j66,46
-3,000
0
2 000
. _.,,,_._$80.20 ......--
1000
$40.10
5000
20000
-27.000
$1,882.70
0.250
$21 .29
0150
$21.29
0.750
1.000
............ . jWj'.'fj
4.500
$383.22
0.500
WAS
0.500
3.000
$10
-4000
jfiF28
-
2.500
585.80
2, C�
8.60
6�000
6-000
$399.00
-6000
.. ........ . ......
$60.75
$660.0
11
� 7
........ ...... . ...
. .......... ..
1 '00G.00
........ ... ....... .....
4.500
530
4750
2000
- - - -----
'5'.00
1,000
$85.16
�4.500
�Sii.22
2�000
$68.64
05100
..... ..........
$39.77
3-009
..... ............ -
$0,00
1,-0'0'0 .
$67.40
.. ............... . 2000
5133.40
1,090
560.75
fia,00
. ....... .
$182.00
$470.00
....... . ............ ........ .
4
.........
Advertisin Costs
R -O -W -Abandonment bando!j!n2al .. .
..........
Advertisin Costs
2 131�1a!fq� ... . ............... ....
Costs
AffidAdvertisin oss
.......... �.RtEnnpina . . .. . ..........
1 Mo
. ........... . ....
$38.46
T500
5288.45
1000
-
0,250
. ... -------
$7.61
1.500
$45.56
0-500
..
$15.22
-
1.500
589,54 .
4.00�
$238.76
2.003
... . ...... iiii., --
.38
-1 500
iZ36
-1�
....... 500
------- ......
$46.30
-1 000
3000
- -----
1.000 .
$30.2 0
-10 000
......... .
13000
-15.00C)
...... I i
$60 so0.000
3 000
........... ..... .
S102.96
0500-
* 0 - O'e'
-
6 .
i�iai6
--10000
............ 6000
1.000
-1,000
$85.16
4.500
81--
38
1,000
............ ... L .........
$255.48
... ... .
.20
. .500
...........
$421i
............. 0.250
iiiai
0,075
-----
'
-0,250
. ... . ..... -
$8.58
0-000
-
2,000
**......
5159,08
1,500
10000
.... -i�i .60
-
.00
1000
$67.40
4.500
5303.30
-- ........ -
4�UUU
5,00
1,000
-........__60.7
$.6
.......... . .. . .....
sl,000.
ii,,3-7-5- -0-0,
.. . .... . . ..
. . . ..
............ ........ .........
1
.. ...... . .. .. ............ -
....... . . .... ..........
......... . ....
PD Rezoning ........... .... ..... .......
"""""'"""..--a
Advertisin Costs
Plat Vacation
Advertisin Costs
anance0.250
............. ... . ........................
$288.45
0,500
519,23
q!4.821
u.uuu
$0.00
................ MN
$60.88
......... ... 250
$7.51
0.250
$7.6115119.38
$7.61
...........
$238.76
20
5119,38
2,000
30.20
1000
534.24
0
515.10
........... -i==.
..... ....... 3WO
1,000
............... .
$30.20
522.65
it-, 00wo
-
................_8;000 --........
5481.20
$401.110
$0.00
$0.00
____3.000
............
2.000
iii * 64
U.buu
. . . .......
5139.31
$69,66
-0-000
0�500DCQ
4�000
S3`18.1675
0000
.....................
50.40
�00
$0.60
2
.................
$0%4 76
00
533.70
..... ..... ....
$33.70
499.76
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
$0.00
$800.
........ .. ... . .....
.53 . . ........... ... ......
89
5
4
. ...... .... .. ......... .
............. ee504
Prelimina PD ar Plat
Fi.n.alflal.o.r..P.D- ............
... . ... .. ...
..na�r
3.000
$115.38
$38.46
........... .
S9.6256
0
.22
1.006
.44
$60�88
0.2-50750
'*�'@I�����'2�"
2.500
1.560
1.500
0.540
2.0001
29.00
...............0.750......
5000
12.000
.
.i6
..........OOa
08
1.10
............. A.500
SKfi
0.250
$46641
..........
......... . .............
T500
11
V- .
.... . ........ . . ....
...... . .. . . ......
...... .........
..... .... ....
.. .......... .
$75.00
....... .......
90
...........
5
................ ............
Zoning Confirmation Letter
...... . � j.
$2.88
„•,_._„•,._0500
_$2.28
129.9
�6.00
S,L48
529.86
$2*27
50,00-
0,225'
56.80
500
S15,10
0225
S9,02
1.00C
.................... I
$40.14
nix of iIs
.--- ..L... .... .......... ..... ..........
iTitle
$1913
0.050
............ iTii............i.44.
0000
:. .-..
$om
TP,7
.....
i6.
eiM
..........-..............0...
$4
.
DGa
.,.-
0.000
..........--
�66
..... --
.6689
$19
. ........ ............
.............................
.......... CAA
0
NOTE:stn!IukiVes aro --VC --,W - iI,WCa 8erwrds- -n .,- - Re - lnclWe - -, --tpp -and-,-OINK
COSTS u,8OR EST -ES WITHOUT HEALTH DEPT FIGURES REIS V1
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2017 PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR "AVERAGE" APPLICATION BY TYPE
CO
Qr
17
GIS
Sr. Env
Planning
Section
Planning
Planning
Sr. Legal
PERMIT/REVIEW
Planner
Tech
Chief
Tech.
Asst.
Sr. Planner
DIRECTOR
UTILITIES
ATTORNEY
Assistant
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
--------------------------------
-- $38.46
----$30.44
----$59.69 --
-- $30.20---
----$36.20 ---
----$40.16
$85.16
$34.32
$79.54
$47.38
Administrative Approval (AA)* 1.500
0.250
1.250
0.500
2.000
2.000
0.250
0.500
0.250
0.250
$57.69
$7.61
$74.61
$15.10
$60.40
$80.20
$21.29
--------------
$17.16
--------------
$19.89
--------------
$11.85
--------------
--- -------
-revi--e- w---requireed---_ir-----add----$300 ----
if PZC
--------------
---------------
--------------
---------------
---------------
Fence/Wall AA
0.000
0.250
0.250
0.500
0.750
1.000
0.250
0.500
0.000
0.000
--------------------------
$0.00
--------------
$7.61
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$14.92
$15.10
$22.65
$40.10
$21.29
$17.16
$0.00
$0.00
Minor Site Plan (SPMN) # 3.000
0:500
1.5001
1:500
-
-------1.500
5.000
0.750
3.000
0.500
1.000
- ------------ ------------------- -------------
$115.38
$15.22
$89.54
$45.30
$45.30
$200.50
$63.87
$102.96
$39.77
$47.38
if PZC review required add $300
Major Site Plan (SPMJ # 5.000
--------
0.750
2.500
1.500
-
2.000
20.000
1000
4.000
---------
0.500
------ ----
--- -
1.000
-
$192.30
$22.83
$149.23
$45.30
$60.40
$802.00
$85.16
$137.28
$39.77
$47.38
if PZC review required add $300
Special
5.000
0.500
3.500
1.500
3.000
27.000
4.500
2.500
1.000
- 0.000
_Exception
$192.30
$15.22
$208.92
$45.30
$90.60
$1,082.70
$383.22
$85.80
$79.54
$0.00
Advertising Costs
R -O -W- Abandonment1.000
0.250
1.500
1.500
1.000
10.000
1.000
2.000
0.500
0.000
--------------------------------
-------------
$38.46
--------------
$7.61
---------------
$89.54
--------------
$45.30
---------------
$30.20
---------------
$401.00
--------------
$85.16
--------------
$68.64
--------------
$39.77
--------------
$0.00
Advertising Costs
Conceptual PD
7.500
1.500
4.000
1.500
3.000
13.000
4.500
3.000
0.500
0.000
$288.45
$45.66
$238.76
$45.30
$90.60
$521.30
$383.22
$102.96
$39.77
$0.00
Advertising Costs
Affidavit of Exemption
1.000
0.500
2.000
1.500
1.000
15 000
1.000
0.250
2.000
--------------
10.000
--------------
--------------
$38.46
$15.22
$119.38
$45.30
$30.20
$601.50
$85.16
$8.58
$159.08
$473.80
PD Rezoning
7.500
2.000
4.000
1.000
3.000
17.000
4.500
0.000
1.500
0,000
$288.45
$60.88
$238.76
$30.20
$90.60
$681.70
$383.22
$0.00
$119.31
$0.00
Advertising Costs
Plat Vacation
0.500
0.250
2.000
1.000
1.000
8.000
1.000
0.000
0.500
0.000
---------------------------------
$19.23
--------------
$7.61
---------------
$119.38
--------------
$30.20
---------------
$30.20
---------------
$320.80
--------------
$85.16
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$39.77
--------------
$0.00
Advertising Costs
Variance
0.250
0.250
2.000
0.500
0.750
12.000
3.000
0.000
1.500
0.000
--------------------------------
-------------
$9.62
--------- -----
$7.61
---------------
$119.38
--------------
$15.10
---------------
$22.65
---------------
$481.20
--------------
$255.48
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$119.31
--------------
$0.00
Appeal ----------------
0.000
0.250
3.000
-
0.500
1.000
-
10.000
-
3.000
-
0.000
- -
0.750
-
0.000
$0.00
$7.61
$179.07
$15.10
$30.20
$401.00
$255.48
$0.00
$59.66
$0.00
Pre -Application Conference
1.500
0.500
1.000
0.500
0.500
5.000
0.250
2.000
0.000
0.000
-
$57.69
$15.22
-
$59.69
$15.10
-
$15.10
-
$200.50
$21.29
$68.64
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$0.00
Preliminary PD or Plat
3.000
1.000
2.500
1.500
2000
12,000
1.500
3.000
0.500
0.000
---------- ---------
-------
$115.38
$30.44
$149.23
-
$45.30
$60.40
$481.20
$127.74
----- --------
$102.96
--------------
$39.77
--------------
$0.00
Final Plat or PD
1.000
2.000
1.500
0.500
2.000
12.000
0.500
2.000
4.000
15.000
- -------------- -----------------
------- -- ----
$38.46
$60.88
--------------1--rter
--------------
$89.54
--------------
$15.10
---------------
$60.40
---------------
$481.20
--------------
$42.58
--------------
$68.64
--------------
$318.16
--------------
$710.70
Te_ mporary Use Permit
0.250
0.250
0 250
0.250
0.750
0 750
0.250
0.500
0000
2.000NOTE:staffsalariesareaveraged,round
and includ � t
.Hours rou �dCID1
hour$14.92
$7.55
$22.65
$30.08
$21.29
$17.16
$0.00
$9
CO
Qr
17
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2017 PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR "AVERAGE" APPLICATION BY TYPE
NOTE: staff salaries are averaged, rounded and include benefits. Hours rounded to quarter hours.
C.\Users\sgagnon\Desktop\PERMIT COSTS LABOR ESTIMATES WITFfb"W1tAIJ H P FqggRpBie, meeting preparation and time, and project administration through completion.
Im
GIS
Sr. Env
Planning
Section
Planning Planning
Sr. Legal
PERMIT/REVIEW
Planner
Tech
Chief
Tech. Asst.
Sr. Planner
DIRECTOR
UTILITIES
ATTORNEY
Assistant
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour ur x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
--------------------------------
---$38.46---
- $30.44--
----$59.69---
-- $30.20 -- $30.20---------
$40.10--------
$85.16
$34:32 ---------
$79.5--------
$47:3$ ---
TUP Renewal
0.075
0.075
0.075
0:075
0.225
0.225
0.075
0.150
0.000
0.600
--------------------------------
$2.88
$2.28
$4.48
$2.27
-
$6.80
$9.02
$6.39
$5.15
$0.00
$28.43
Zoning Confirmation Letter
0.500
0.000
0.500
0.000
0.500
1.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
--------------------------------
-------------
$19.23
--------------
$0.00
---------------
$29.85
--------------
$0.00
---------------
$15.10
---------------
$40.10
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$0.00
Unity of Title
0.050
1.000
0.750
0.000
0.500
0.500
0.000
0.000
0.250
1.500
--------------------------------
- --------- ---
$1.92
--------------
$30.44
---------------
$44.77
--------------
$0.00
---------------
$15.10
---------------
$20.05
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$0.00
--------------
$19.89
-------------
$71.- 07
Dissolution of Unity of Title
0.000
0.500
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.250
1.500
--------------------------------
- $0.00
$15.22
$0.00
------ $0.00
- ---- $0.00
$0.00
- - $0.00
$0.00
---- $'19.89
- $71.07
Temp Suspension
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
-----------------------------
�d.d $0.00
" """" $o:oo
"""""""""$0.00
""""" $o.66
------ $o.00
$o.00
$o.00
$o.00
" - $o.00
""""""""$0.00
NOTE: staff salaries are averaged, rounded and include benefits. Hours rounded to quarter hours.
C.\Users\sgagnon\Desktop\PERMIT COSTS LABOR ESTIMATES WITFfb"W1tAIJ H P FqggRpBie, meeting preparation and time, and project administration through completion.
Im
NOTE: staff salaries are averaged, rounded =
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2O17PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR ^AVERAGE^APPLICATION BYTYPE
Proposed
Applications
PW LAND
Current Fee
Fee
last 12
Additional
TRAFFIC
DEVELOPMENT
SURVEYOR
Schedule
Schedule
months
Revenue
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
0.500
1,500
0.000
13�
33
1.250
2.500
1.000
11
4.500
4.750
2.000
17
4.500
4.750
2.000
r
5
1.000
2.000
1.000
3
1
$182.001
4.500
12.000
1.000
0
1.000
10.000
5.000
4
4.500
12,000
1.000
1
1.000
4.000
1.000
0
0.250
0.250
0,000
0.500
0.250
0.000
0
0.500
4.000
0.000
89
1.500
4.750
3.000
5
0.500
7.500
6.000
4
0.250
0.000
0.000
90
d include bei$Tts6l3c
urs rounded to quar$CbGa
so .00
-7
laration
i
and time alroiect
administration
throuah comoletion.
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2O17PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR 'AVERAGE^APPLICATION BYTYPE
NOTE, staff salaries are averaged, rounded and include benefits. Hours rounded to quarter hours.
o. snwIToomS LABOR ESTIMATES WITmmr*wLtAmT4,m&nftnqgn*m8i=meeting preparation and time, and project administration through completion.
Proposed
Applications
PW LAND
Current Fee
Fee
last 12
Additional
TRAFFIC
DEVELOPMENT
SURVEYOR
Schedule
Schedule
months
Revenue
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
Hour x Rate
0.250
0.000
0.000
56
0.000
0.000
0.000
94
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
t--
$0.001
i 16 0-- 0-0
NOTE, staff salaries are averaged, rounded and include benefits. Hours rounded to quarter hours.
o. snwIToomS LABOR ESTIMATES WITmmr*wLtAmT4,m&nftnqgn*m8i=meeting preparation and time, and project administration through completion.
PLANNING/CURRENT DEVELOPMENT SECTION: 2017 PRELIMINARY DRAFT
COSTS/LABOR ESTIMATES FOR "AVERAGE" APPLICATION BY TYPE
Current Fee
New Cost Old Cost Schedule
PERMIT/REVIEW Calculation* Calculation** (minimum fees)
Administrative Approval (AA)
$304.21
$183.38
$200.00
Fence/Wall AA
$160.12
$0.00
$75.00
Minor Site Plan (SPMN)
$829.58
$444.75
$650.00
Major Site Plan (SPMJ)
$1,514.93
$884.44
$1,000.00
Special Exception
$1,996.91
$1,351.94
$2,075.00
R -O -W- Abandonment
$840.72
$686.50
$700.00
Conceptual PD
$1,956.53
$1,691.75
$2,375.00
Affidavit of Exemption
$1,571.29
$2,161.25
$1,000.00
PD Rezoning
$2,054.19
$1,838.25
$2,375.00
Plat Vacation
$609.89
$778.88
$800.00
Variance
$909.69
$803.56
$800.00
Appeal
$888.46
$799.69
$400.00
Pre -Application Conference
$445.15
$435.75
$0.00
Preliminary PD or Plat
$1,096.48
$857.69
$1,150.00
Final Plat or PD
$1,913.34
$1,364.00
$1,400.00
Temporary Use Permit
$224.29
$69.63
$75.00
Zoning Confirmation Letter
$101.58
$77.75
$50.00
Unity of Title 1
$273.511
$135.751
$75.00
Dissolution of Unity of Title 1
$106.181
$0.001
$0.00
* "Planning" only (includes Utilities and Attorney Staff time)
** Includes ALL Departments
NOTE: staff salaries are averaged, rounded and include benefits. Hours rounded to quarter hours. �p
C:\Users\sgagnon\Desktop\PERMIT COST6@Y W@WD W0RseNgk w mppXr19-R3t"139l 9!§me, and project administration through completion. (�'
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
TO: Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
FROM: Richard B. Szpyrka, P.E., Public Works Director
SUBJECT: Public Works Analysis of Building and Development Permit Fees
DATE: June 9, 2017
On May 2, 2017 Commissioner Zorc brought to the Board of County Commissioners three items
to move forward as a result of the April 12, 2017 Development Review and Permitting Process
Workshop. One of the items was for staff to review Development Review fees for Community
Development and Public Works.
Review of the current Public Works Fee Schedule shows that the fees established by the Board
of County Commissioners in 2004 have remained current at 2004 levels.
Building Permit Fees
An analysis of Public Works Building Permit Revenue over the last three years has shown a
significant shortfall in revenue when compared to costs. Staff costs over the last three years for
the Building Permit Review and Inspection process have averaged $264,796 per year. However,
in this same time -period the following revenue shortfalls were noted:
• In Fiscal Year (FY) 14-15, the total revenue collected for the Building Permit and
Inspection process was $121,414. When compared to staff costs, the revenue shortfall
for FY 14-15 is $143,382 or 54% of the total cost for services.
In FY 15-16, the total revenue collected for the Building Permit and Inspection process
was $152,002. When compared to staff costs, the revenue shortfall for FY 15-16 is
$112,794 or 42.5% of the total cost for services.
In FY 16-17, through the end of May, the total revenue collected forthe Building Permit
and Inspection process was $109,922. When compared to staff costs of $176,530 for the
same time period, the revenue shortfall for FY 16-17, through May, is $66,608 or 38% of
the total cost for services.
Over the last three years, the revenue generated by the current fee schedule for Public Works
Engineering Building Permit Review and Inspection services has resulted in a shortfall in the
amount of $322,784. The shortfall results in a taxpayer subsidy to fund the remainder of the
building permit review and inspection costs.
Attachment 8
FAEngineering\RSzpyrka\ltem FoldeIsTY 17-18\Land Development FeesTublic Works Fee Memo for 062017 BCC Meeting 061317.doc
P198
Page 2 of 5
Public Works Analysis of Building and Development Permit Fees
June 9, 2017
To address the revenue shortfall for Public Works Building Permit Reviews and Inspections, it is
recommended that the current Public Works fees for single family residential (SFR) right-of-way
and drainage permits be increased from $45.00 for private roads and $75.00 for public roads to
a fee of $180.00 for public or private roads.
Increasing the current right-of-way SFR right-of-way and drainage permit fee to $180.00 will
address the current revenue shortfall. Applying the proposed fee to the past three years
resulted in the following additional revenue being generated:
• FY 14-15
Private SFR Permits — 490 SFR @ $135.00 ea = $66,150
Public SFR Permits — 98 SFR @ $105.00 ea = $10,290
Total Additional Revenue Based on Proposed Fee Increase = $76,440
Total Calculated Revenue Shortfall = $143,382
• FY 15-16
Private SFR Permits — 603 SFR @ $135.00 ea = $81,405
Public SFR Permits — 232 SFR @ $105.00 ea = $24,360
Total Additional Revenue Based on Proposed Fee Increase = $105,765
Total Calculated Revenue Shortfall = $112,794
• FY 16-17 (YTD)
Private SFR Permits — 461 SFR @ $135.00 ea = $62,235
Public SFR Permits — 68 SFR @ $105.00 ea = $7,140
Total Additional Revenue Based on Proposed Fee Increase = $69,375
Total Calculated Revenue Shortfall = $66,608
As shown above, the proposed fee schedule for SFR right-of-way and drainage permits is
anticipated to eliminate the current revenue shortfall. The proposed fee increase does not take
into account the need for additional staff to reduce the current review times or backlog for
single family residential permit reviews, however the additional fee collection could help fund
the needed staffing increases. The proposed fee increase will need to be considered by the
Board for final action in September.
Public Works Land Development and Right -of -Way Fees
An analysis of Public Works Land Development Revenue over the last three years has shown a
significant shortfall in revenue when compared to costs. Staff costs over the last three years for
the Land Development and Right -of -Way permit review and inspection process have averaged
$548,650 per year. However, in this same time -period the following revenue shortfalls were
noted:
F:\Engineering\RSzpyrka\1tem Folders\FY 17-18\Land Development FeesTublic Works Fee Memo for 062017 BCC Meeting 061317.doc Attachment 8
P199
Page 3 of 5
Public Works Analysis of Building and Development Permit Fees
June 9, 2017
In Fiscal Year (FY) 14-15, the total revenue collected for the Land Development and
Right -of -Way permit review and inspection process was $55,793. When compared to
staff costs, the revenue shortfall for FY 14-15 is $492,857 or 905o of the total cost for
services.
• In FY 15-16, the total revenue collected for the Land Development and Right -of -Way
permit review and inspection process was $65,045. When compared to staff costs, the
revenue shortfall for FY 15-16 is $483,605 or 88% of the total cost for services.
In FY 16-17, through the end of May, the total revenue collected for Land Development
and Right -of -Way permit review and inspection process was $66,474. When compared
to staff costs, $365,766 (YTD), the revenue shortfall for FY 16-17, through May is
$299,292 or 81% of the total cost for services.
Over the last three years, the revenue generated by the current fee schedule for Public Works
Engineering Land Development and Right -of -Way permit review and inspection services has
resulted in a shortfall in the amount of $1,275,754. The shortfall results in a taxpayer subsidy to
fund the remainder of the Land Development and Right -of -Way permit review and inspection
costs.
In order to address the significant revenue shortfall for Public Works Land Development and
Right -of -Way permit reviews and inspections, we have evaluated the issue and propose the
following changes:
2004 Public Works Fee Schedule
Fee Schedule Category
Current
Proposed
Additional Revenue FY 15-16
Stormwater Permit (A & B)
$450.00
$ 850.00
21 Apps @ $400 = $ 8,400
Stormwater Permit (C)
$100.00
$ 225.00
101 Apps @ $125 = $12,625
Single Family R/W Permit
$45/$75
$ 180.00
92 Apps @ $105 = $ 9,660
Utility R/W Permit
$350.00
$ 600.00
4 Apps @ $250 = $ 1,000
Land Dev. R/W Permit
$550.00
$ 900.00
3 Apps @ $350 = $ 1,050
Comm. R/W Permit
$300.00
$ 600.00
12 Apps @ $300 = $ 3,600
Re -inspection Fee
N/A
$ 300.00
N/A
After 2nd Re -inspection
Plan Review Fee
N/A
$ 300.00
N/A
After 3rd Resubmittal
The above proposed permit fees would have generated an additional $36,335 in FY 15-16.
It is not feasible to increase the above permit fees to compensate for the total shortfall of
revenue with respect to Public Works Land Development and Right -of -Way permit reviews and
inspections. So, the above proposed changes are to compensate for the review aspect of the
permitting process. The following is a proposed fee schedule to compensate for staff costs after
permit issuance by the Public Works Department.
F:\Engineering\RSzpyrka\ltem FoldersTY 17-18\Land Development Fees\Public Works Fee Memo for 062017 BCC Meeting 061317.doc Attachment 8
P200
Page 4 of 5
Public Works Analysis of Building and Development Permit Fees
June 9, 2017
Permit review fees do not cover staff costs after permits are issued by the Public Works
Department. Once permits are issued, staff deals with projects on a daily basis including
inspections for right-of-ways, site plans and subdivisions, permit violations, drainage issues,
project changes, field issues, correspondence with project engineers, project closeout
documentation, as -built drawing evaluation, bonding, etc.
To address the revenue shortfall after permit issuance, a step system for inspection fees is
proposed for all development projects, including site plans, subdivision, right-of-way
improvements, and administrative approvals. The proposed step system does not include the
on-site cost of water and sewer infrastructure improvements that are not inspected by Public
Works inspection staff. However, it does include these infrastructure improvements within the
County right-of-way. Calculating inspection fees is proposed using the following step system:
• Inspection fees for the portion of construction costs up to $500,000 will be 2% of
Construction Costs.
• Inspection fees for the portion of the construction costs between $500,001 and
$1,000,000 will be 1.5% of the Construction Cost.
• Inspection fees for the portion of the construction costs above $1,000,000 will be 1.0%
of the Construction Costs.
• The inspection fees will be cumulative to cover the entire construction cost for the
project.
The following is an example of how the inspection fee would be calculated:
• A project with a construction cost of $1,289,000.00 will have an inspection fee
calculated as follows.
• $500,000 x 2.0% _ $10,000
• $500,000 x 1.5% _ $ 7,500
• $289,000 x 1.0% _ $ 2,890
• The inspection fee due before permit issuance is $20,390.00.
The following is a sample of current development costs and the calculated fee based on the
proposed inspection fee schedule above.
Harmony Reserve 1A
• Construction Cost $1,012,871
• Number of Lots 34 @ $29,790/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $17,628
• Additional Cost per Lot $518.47 or 1.7% per lot
F:\Engineering\RSzpyrka\ltem Folders\FY 17-18\ and Development FeesTublic Works Fee Memo for 062017 BCC Meeting 061317.doc Attachment 8
P201
Page 5 of 5
Public Works Analysis of Building and Development Permit Fees
June 9, 2017
Willows
• Construction Cost $699,376
• Number of Lots 43 @ $16,264/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $12,990
• Additional Cost per Lot $302.10 or 1.85% per lot
Millstone Landing — Phases 4-6
• Construction Cost $4,237,121
• Number of Lots 243 @ $17,436/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $49,871
• Additional Cost per Lot $205.23 or 1.17% per lot
Waterway Village 2A-2
• Construction Cost $2,423,241
• Number of Lots 68 @ $35,636/lot
• Calculated Inspection Fee $31,732.41
• Additional Cost per Lot $466.65 or 1.3% per lot
Based on the above sampling of projects the overall cost to the developer is less than 2% per
lot.
As shown above, the proposed fee schedule for Public Works Land Development and Right -of -
Way permit reviews and inspections is anticipated to reduce the current revenue shortfall. The
proposed fee increase does not take into account the need for additional staff to reduce the
current review times or backlog for Land Development reviews and inspections, however the
additional fee collection could help fund the needed staffing increases. The proposed fee
increase will need to be considered by the Board for final action in September.
Recommendation
Staff recommends the Board of County Commissioners direct staff to finalize an update of
development review fees for Community Development and for Public Works, obtain public
input, and to present final updated fee schedules to the Board in September with a proposed
effective date for Board consideration and adoption.
F:\Engineering\RSzpyrka\ltem Folders\FY 17 -18M -and Development Fees\Public Works Fee Memo for 062017 BCC Meeting 061317.doc Attachment 8
P202
DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY'
MEMORANDUM
To: Jason Brown
County Administrator
4'
From: Suzanne Boyll"
Human Resources Director
Date: . June 12, 2017
Subiect: Health Insurance — Recommendations for Plan Year 2017/2018
Background
Indian River County utilizes a self-insured group health insurance program. Health insurance is
available to fulltime employees and retirees of the Board of County Commissioners and the
respective Constitutional Officers (Sheriff, Property Appraiser, Tax Collector, Clerk of Courts, and
the Supervisor of Elections) and their eligible dependents. Health insurance claims and program
administration expenses are paid from contributions from employer and employee/retiree
contributions. Under our program, stop loss insurance for extraordinary and aggregates claims
experience is obtained to protect against high cost claims.
The health insurance program is an integral part of the employee benefit package and important
to recruitment and retention efforts.
The health insurance program is evaluated throughout the year for plan performance and staff
makes recommendations to ensure the plan is:
✓ Affordable
✓ Competitive
✓ Sustainable
At the June 21, 2016 Board of County Commissioners meeting, the Board approved the following
cost saving measures to mitigate projected plan losses for FY2016/17 plan year:
• Transitioning from Blue Options to Blue Choice Health Plan
• Implementing Kannact Diabetes Management Program
• Offering a voluntary International Prescription Provider (CanaRx)
• Adjusting Employee Premiums towards a 90%/10% and 75%/25% target
At the December 20, 2016 Board of County Commissioners meeting, the Board also approved a
plan change to the acupuncture benefit in response to excessively high claims experience for this
P203
benefit over prior years. This benefit was capped at 26 visits per year and a maximum annual
benefit of $1,500 per year.
The changes have had a positive impact on the plan's performance for the current plan year.
Analysis of Plan Performance
The plan's performance since 2009 is reflected below.
$4,000,000
$3,000,000
$2,000,000
$1,000,000
$0
Health Program Net Revenues
FY09 - FY17 Projected
$3,032,903
$1,761,58 ` 0
$1250302 $933,336
-$1,000,000 FY09 FY10 FY11
-$2,000,000
-$3,000,000 -
-$4,000,000
$484,193
-0
-$1;375;479
-$2,763,29
5
FY12 FY13
$250,000
■ FY_17
_$1,093,073 (PROD)
To continue to maintain an affordable, competitive and sustainable health plan, the following
recommendations are made for the FY2017/18 plan year:
1. Increase the Employer contribution to the plan by $30 per month per covered emplovee to
provide a funding reserve. Current funding levels do not provide for a reserve. A reserve is
recommended to fund for unexpected plan performance that may not reach our stop loss
insurance levels and cover health cost increases above expected trends. The new employer
paid monthly premium would be $635 for single coverage and $875 for family coverage The
$30 increase per month in employer contributions will generate approximately $507,600 in
FY2017/18.
2. Increase the Emplovee contribution to the plan by $20 per month for both single and familv
coverage. This recommendation is associated with the second phase of the premium increase
approved by the Board in June 2016. The second phase was approved to be an additional
$30 per month. However, in order to maintain a competitive plan and affordable premiums
for our employees, it is recommended the increase be limited to $20 per month rather than
$30 per month. Under this increase, the plan would no longer qualify for "grandfather" plan
status. This adjustment will continue moving towards the funding target of 90%/10% and
75%/25%. If a similar adjustment is made for the 2018/2019 plan year, these targets will be
reached. The new employee paid monthly premium would be $50 per month for single
coverage and $267.50 for family coverage. The $20 increase per month in employee
contributions will generate approximately $338,400 in FY2017/18.
P204
3. Modify the plan design to provide 100% well ness/preventive benefit and include all employee
out of pocket costs in the out of pocket maximum. Due to the loss of "grandfather" status,
these plan design changes will be required. The benefit of these changes is they will allow
the County to promote employee wellness by removing financial barriers to seeking
preventive screenings and to visit the doctor annually for routine health exam at no cost to
the employee. This strategy promotes early detection of health issues so that chronic
conditions can be prevented or managed before they become serious. A wellness strategy
that supports the ongoing health of employees will have a positive impact on future plan
performance. Additionally, the inclusion of all employee out of pockets costs in the out of
pocket maximum will provide defined levels of protection to our employees if they
experience a catastrophic medical event. Currently, out of pocket costs related to office visit
co -pays, deductibles, and prescription co -pays are in addition to the out of pocket maximums
under the plan. Only the coinsurance paid by an employee is included in the out of pocket
maximum. Our current out of pocket maximums are $3,000 for single coverage and $6,000
for family coverage.
4. Increase the cost share for advanced imaging from $25 to $100. The cost to the plan for
advanced imaging (MRI, CT, etc.) is high and the current cost share of $25 is well below the
typical employee cost share for this type of imaging.
5. Increase the out of network deductible from $400/$800 to $800/$1600 and the out of
network out of pocket maximum from $3,000/$6,000 to $4,000/$8,000. The in network
deductible and out of pocket maximum would remain unchanged. The plan would continue
to offer out of network benefits that allow employees to choose medical care outside of the
expansive Florida Blue network. However, because the cost of obtaining medical care outside
of the network is typically more expensive for the plan, it is not uncommon to have a higher
deductible and out of pocket maximum for out of network care.
6. Eliminate the prepayment of insurance premiums one month in advance. Currently,
employees are required to prepay for their insurance one month in advance. This creates
administrative difficulties and often premiums have to be doubled up to capture the month
in advance. This is a negative experience for new hires or employees who add family coverage
who experience a deduction from the pay check before their insurance is effective.
Eliminating the prepayment a month in advance would improve the administration of the
benefits and eliminate the negative experience for new hires and employees adding family
coverage. September 2017 would be a premium free month for employee premiums that
are currently deducted a month in advance.
How Does Our Health Plan Compare?
Plan design and benefits offered vary significantly. Some offer multiple plans with employees
paying premiums based on the level of benefit provided. Deductibles range from $300 to $2,500;
out of pocket maximums range from $1,500 to $20,000; copays, coinsurance, and prescriptions
costs vary as well. Some employers offer financial incentives tied to wellness to assist with out of
pocket expenses. Our current health plan, while still competitive, is one of the few remaining
plans that does not provide 100% wellness and preventive screening benefits. In the long term,
P205
this can have a negative impact because our ability to encourage and incentivize employee
wellness is limited through plan design. Integrating a wellness strategy into our health plan will
assist us in meeting our goals of long term health plan affordability, competitiveness, and
sustainability. Additionally, we are one of the few health plans that does not include all out of
pocket costs in the out of pocket maximum under the plan. By including all of the out of pocket
costs in the out of pocket maximum, employees will have improved protection against financial
hardship resulting from medical bills.
How Do Our Premiums Compare?
The following two charts reflect the employee paid premiums for surrounding local government
employers for Single Coverage and Family Coverage. Indian River County's proposed employee
premium increase of $20 per month is reflected as well. Our premiums will remain competitive.
Single coverage will cost an employee $50 per month and family coverage will cost an employee
$267.50 per month. Premiums payments are made on a pre-tax basis.
Employee Monthly Premium Comparison - Single
Coverage
$250 -- — —
$212
$200 ----
$150 $319
$113
$100
$50 $30 $50 $35 $46 $53 $44
g
$-25—$-27--$-24
0 SO SO $0 $0 _ r
wJ ea ti ti 3 yJ cJ e J �e ti ti e ti ti
\ac o� o� J�o 0a �o° y�`a \ao Sao pec \ao \ao \ate
�-,A . ���o Qa\� `�� �,e6a e��y �a� cae cad
P�� ccJ°� Co� `°� \moo ari Qoc� o� mea lea o�F lt°a I°a I°a
a a a �` `� Jeno °\ °\
Jeno �'\� r°°\ coc°
e e e e � 5�
a\a Qac 0� 0� 0t `\J° 6\J° \�C \�C \R
As illustrated above, most local government employers in the surrounding area charge an
employee premium for single coverage. A few offer single coverage at no cost to the employee;
however, several of these plans have higher deductibles and out of pockets costs than our plan.
P206
Employee Monthly Premiums Comparison - Family
Coverage
$1,000
$900 $871
$800
$700 $688 r
$600 $547 $532
$500$-38.5 S445 $462 r,
$400 $-299—$-3-10—$350 _$33.4
$300 $248 $268 $233 —$228 _
$179 $'19fi
$200 _
$100 1
$0—-
a ti �
ti l e J --
J ti e J '
o Se o 0 0 0'` c'`
tLo° `oQ° �AQ�aLo�a �a ° moo° a�F �� e�ay r r e\\y� a0 a0 ale
�e Q `�e ao aL
P� � L°J L°J L°J �J al` Q° °� 0e Q,e o�
roo\ roo\ roo\
e e e e K K
Employee premiums for family coverage for most local government employers surveyed are
higher than the County's as shown in the table above. The recommended $20 increase per
month maintains a competitive and affordable plan for employees and their families. The
resulting monthly premiums are reflected below:
Fiscal Year 2017/18
Proposed Emolover & Emalovee Premiums
This premium relationship moves us closer to the target employer/employee split for single
coverage of 90%/10% and 759/o/25% for family coverage.
While the premiums are increasing for employees by $240 per year, they are gaining an increased
preventive and wellness benefit as well as increased out of pocket maximum protection as a
result of the recommended changes. Additionally, employees would not pay insurance
premiums in September 2017, if we eliminate the prepayment of insurance premiums.
Discussions with Constitutionals/Unions/Employees
Human Resource representatives held meeting with the Constitutionals, union representatives
and employees to explain the proposed changes and discuss any concerns. Representatives from
the Constitutionals and the unions are supportive of the recommended changes.
P207
MonthlmountM
rcentage Share
Tier of Coverage
Employee
--
Employer
Employee
Employer
- -
This premium relationship moves us closer to the target employer/employee split for single
coverage of 90%/10% and 759/o/25% for family coverage.
While the premiums are increasing for employees by $240 per year, they are gaining an increased
preventive and wellness benefit as well as increased out of pocket maximum protection as a
result of the recommended changes. Additionally, employees would not pay insurance
premiums in September 2017, if we eliminate the prepayment of insurance premiums.
Discussions with Constitutionals/Unions/Employees
Human Resource representatives held meeting with the Constitutionals, union representatives
and employees to explain the proposed changes and discuss any concerns. Representatives from
the Constitutionals and the unions are supportive of the recommended changes.
P207
Staff recommends and respectfully requests the Board QfCounty Commissioners approve the
proposed changes to the health plan as identified in Numbers 1 through 6 above and restated
• increase the Employer contribution to the plan by $30 per month for single and family
coverage hmprovide a funding reserve. �
• Increase the Employee contribution iothe plan by$2Oper month for both single and
family coverage.
m Modify the plan design to provide lOD%xveUnpsv/nreventive benefit and include all
employee out ofpocket costs inthe out mfpocket maximum.
• Increase the cost share for advanced imaging from $35tm$1OO.
• Increase the out of network deductible from $400/$800 to $000/$I600 and the out of
network out ofpocket maximum from $3,0OO/$G,8DOto $4'000/$8'000'
• Eliminate the prepayment ofinsurance premiums one month in advance and provide
employees premium free month inSeptember 2D17'
N
O
t0
GEHRING AGROUP
INSURANCE BROKERSID& CONSULTANTS
ALTERNATIVE #3
Nen-Grandfathprpd Plan
Scheduleof
Blue
•.
In Network Out of Network
Florida Blue
In Network Out of Network
Florida Blue
In Network Out of Network
Deductible
Single
$400
$400
$400
$800
Family
$800
$800
$800
$1,600
Out of Pocket Maximum
Coinsurance Only
Coinsurance Only
OED,_ Coinsurance, Copays & Rx
Single
$3,000
$3,000
$3,000
$4,000
Family
$6,000
$6,000
$6,000
$8,000
Coinsurance
20% 40%
20% 40%
20%
40%
Office Visits
Physician Office Visit
$25
40% after CYD
$25
40% after CYD
$25
403'. after CYD
Specialist Visit
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
Pre -Natal
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
Preventive Services
$25/$45
40%
$25/$45
40%
No Charge
40%
Independent Clinical Lab
$15
40% after CYD
$15
40%after-CYD
$15
409'o after CYD
Advanced Imaging
$25
40% after CYD
$25
40% after CYD
$100
409'. after CYD
Chiropractic
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
Urgent Care Center
$25
40% after CYD
$25
40% after CYD
$25
409'. after CYD
Hospital
$200 PAD +
$200 PAD +
$200 PAD +
Inpatient
$400 PAD +40% after CYD
$400 PAD + 40% after CYD
$400 PAD + 40% after CYD
20% after CYD
20% after CYD
20% after CYD
Outpatient
20% after CYD
40% after CYD
20% after CYD
40% after CYD
20% after CYD
40% after CYD
Emergency Room Visit
$100 Copay +
$100 Copay + 40% after CYD
$100 Copay +
$100 Copay + 40% after CYD
$100 Copay + '
$100 Copay + 20% after In -Net CYD
20% after CYD
20% after CYD
20% after CYD
Physician Services at Hospital
20% after CYD
40% after CYD
20% after CYD
40% after CYD
20% after CYD
2051. after In -Net CYD
Mental Health / Substance Abuse
Inpatient
$200 PAD +
$400 PAD + 40% after CYD
$200 PAD +
$400 PAD + 40% after CYD
$200 PAD +
$400 PAD +40% after CYD
20% after CYD
20% after CYD
20% after CYD
Outpatient
$45
40% after CYD
$45
40% after CYD
$45
409'. after CYD
Prescription Drugs (Retail)_
Generic
$10
$10
$10
Brand Name
$35
$35
$35
Non Preferred Brand
$50
50%
$50
503.
$S0
509.
Mail Order (90 day supply)
2 x Copay
2 x Copay
2 x Copay
Total Employer Employee
Total Employer Employee
Total Employer _ Employee
EE Only 697
$635.00
$605.00
$30.00
$665.00
$635.00
$30.00
$685.00 $635.00
$50.00
EE+Family 924
$1,092.50
$845.00
$247.50
$1,122.50
$875.00
$247.50
$1,142.50 $875.00
$267.50
Monthly Premium
$1,452,065.00
$1,500,695.00
$1,533,115.00
Annual Premium
$17,424,780.00
$18,008,340.00
$18,397,380.00
$Increase
N/A
$583,560.00
$972,600.00
% Increase I
N/A
3.3%
5.6%
/4/
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
Date:
June 12, 2017
To:
Jason E. Brown, County Administrator
From:
Vincent Burke, P.E., Director of Utility Services
Prepared By:
Arjuna Weragoda, P.E., Capital Projects Manager
Subject:
North Sebastian Septic to Sewer (S2S) Phase 1, Resolution I (Preliminary Assessment
30393100001000000002.3
Roll) and Resolution II (Public Hearing Date)
BACKGROUND
On May 16, 2017, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners (BCC) authorized staff to proceed
with the assessment procedures for notifying benefitting property owners, and preparation of assessment
roll based on an updated financial analysis (Option II). Those steps included preparation of the necessary
resolutions and scheduling of necessary public meetings for property owners and interested parties. Staff
presented the results of the May 16, 2017, BCC decision to the City of Sebastian City Council meeting on
May 24, 2017.
ANALYSIS
The North Sebastian Septic to Sewer (S2S) Phase I area has 61 "parent" parcels (Map ID No's) benefittingfrom
the sewer main. Please note that Map ID No's 45, 48, 53, 58 and 60 are office condominiums and, as such,
contain sub parcels with multiple owners (or 115 parcels/units). The parcels vary in size from the largest
parcel at approximately 17 -acres to the smallest parcel at 0.13 acres. See Attachment 5 for an area map.
Out of the 61 parent parcels, three (3) parcels were left out of the preliminary assessment roll (or 112
parcels/units) and also were excluded (not benefitting) from previous sewer assessment calculations for
the following reasons:
Map ID No.
Parcel ID.
Reason
39
30383000009000000000.1
City of Sebastian Cemetery
40
30393100001000000002.9
City of Sebastian Cemetery (TIITF/STATE OF FLORIDA)
41
30393100001000000002.3
Vacant Land, can conned to centralized sewer on Indian
River Drive
The project will consist of the construction of a new gravity sanitary sewer system. The system will serve
commercial areas along US Highway 1 in parts of the un -incorporated county and within the City of Sebastian.
The project will generally include approximately 2,700 LF of 8" sewer, 6,500 LF of 10" sewer, 37 manholes,
143 LF of 8" sewer jack and bore, 137 LF of 10" sewerjack and bore, 50 service laterals, county -specified lift
station, 850 LF of 4" force main, and all related and necessary appurtenances. The total construction cost is
estimated at $2,977,931.58 based on competitive bids.
The 2013 sewer feasibility study for the North Sebastian Septic to Sewer pricing was based on an Equivalent
Residential Units (ERU's) calculation. The ERU allocations were based on the potential consumption. The
C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Tech no logies\ea syPD F 7\@BCL@3C058CF5\@BCL@3C058CF5.docx
P210
potential consumption was based on the underlying future land use designation, zoning, current ERU's on
existing parcels with county water, and the size of each "parent" parcel. This method, labeled Hydraulic Fair
Share/ERU Allocation, is further described below.
Hydraulic Fair Share (HFS)/ ERU Allocation: This method is verysimilarto evaluatingthe numberof Equivalent
Residential Units (ERU's) required of a given property based on the underlying land use and zoning. An ERU
is the amount of water used or wastewater produced by a typical residential unit, which water use ranges
from zero to three hundred (300) gallons per day on a maximum day basis or zero to two hundred fifty (250)
gallons per day on a maximum month basis. For example, a single family home is assigned one (1) ERU and
commercial/non-residential units are assigned ERU's based on County Code 201.07. The vacant "parent"
parcels' HFS/ERU Allocation was evaluated based on the underlying future land use designation, zoning, and
size of the "parent" parcel. Staff feels that this method is fair and equitable to the smaller parcels and
especially for the parcels with existing businesses where the current water usage is known in the corridor.
Therefore, based on Option II of the funding allocations approved by BCC and utilizing the HFS/ERU Allocation
method, the capital cost ranges between $4,989.12 and $374,183.86 per "parent" parcel based on a single or
a multiple ERU allocation.
A Providing Resolution (Resolution I) Attachment 1 is presented for adoption by the BCC.
A separate resolution (Resolution II) Attachment 2 is presented for adoption to hold a Public Hearing to
discuss the advisability, project cost, and amount of the assessment for each property owner in the benefited
area. Pending BCC approval, a Public Hearing is tentatively scheduled for Tuesday, July 18, 2017 at 9:05 A.M.
in the Indian River County Commission Chambers. An assessment roll and assessment plat have been
prepared and is on file with the Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners.
FUNDING:
As approved on May 16, 2017, the funds for this project are to be derived as follows:
Description
Account Number
Amount
SJRWMD Cost Share Grant (21.80%)
N/A
$ 649,240
Utility Assessment Fund Reserves (473) (20.00%)
473-169000-15501
$ 595,586
Optional Sales Tax Contribution (20.00%)
31526836-066510-15501
$ 595,586
Property Owner Assessment (38.205,o)
473-169000-15501
$1,137,519
RECOMMENDATION ,
The staff of the Utilities Department recommends that the BCC consider the following recommendations:
1) Adopt the Providing Resolution (Resolution 1) for the installation of the sewer main within the
North Sebastian Septic to Sewer area, subject to the terms outlined in the resolution, with a 2%
interest rate as approved by BCC.
2) Adopt the Setting Resolution (Resolution II) setting the time and place of the Public Hearing —
July 18, 2017, at 9:05 am.
C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Tech nologies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@3C058CF5\@BCL@3C058CF5.docx
P211
LIST OF ATTACHMENTS:
1. Providing Resolution (Resolution No. 1)
2. Setting Resolution for Public Hearing (Resolution No. 11)
3. Capital Cost Breakdown
4. Assessment Roll
5. Assessment Area Map
C:\Users\GRANIC-1\AppData\Local\Temp\BCL Tech no logies\easyPDF 7\@BCL@3C058CF5\@BCL@3C058CF5.docx
P212
Providing (First Resolution)
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR A
SEWER MAIN TO BE EXTENDED TO SERVE CERTAIN
PROPERTIES LOCATED ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF U.S.
HIGHWAY 1 BETWEEN 13230 AND 14410 U.S. HIGHWAY 1, AND
INCLUDING 12920 AND 12950 U.S. HIGHWAY 1 WITHIN THE
UNINCORPORATED BOUNDARY OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY;
AND CERTAIN PROPERTIES ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF U.S.
HIGHWAY 1 WITHIN THE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY OF THE
CITY OF SEBASTIAN BETWEEN 13100 AND 1614 U.S. HIGHWAY
1, INCLUDING CERTAIN PROPERTIES ALONG JACKSON
STREET, MADISON STREET, DAVIS STREET, N. CENTRAL
AVENUE (SOUTH OF JACKSON STREET) AND INCLUDING 1637
AND 1727 N. INDIAN RIVER DRIVE (NORTH SEBASTIAN SEPTIC
TO SEWER [S2S] PHASE 1 PROJECT); PROVIDING THE TOTAL
ESTIMATED COST, METHOD OF PAYMENT OF ASSESSMENTS,
NUMBER OF ANNUAL INSTALLMENTS, AND DESCRIPTION OF
THE AREA TO BE SERVED.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County has
determined that the improvements herein described are necessary to promote the public welfare
of the county and has determined to defray the cost thereof by special assessments against certain
specially benefited properties to be serviced by a sewer main extension servicing certain
properties located along the east side of U.S. Highway 1 between 13230 and 14410 U.S.
Highway 1, and including 12920 and 12950 U.S. Highway 1 within the unincorporated
boundary of Indian River County; and certain properties along the east side of U.S. Highway 1
within the municipal boundary of the City of Sebastian between 13100 and 1614 U.S. Highway
1, including certain properties along Jackson Street, Madison Street, Davis Street, N. Central
Avenue (south of Jackson Street) and including 1637 and 1727 N. Indian River Drive (North
Sebastian Septic to Sewer [S2S] Phase 1 project),
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows:
The County does hereby determine that a sewer main shall be extended to benefit certain
properties located along the east side of U.S. Highway 1 between 13230 and 14410 U.S.
Highway 1,. and including 12920 and 12950 U.S. Highway 1 within the unincorporated
boundary of Indian River County; and certain properties along the east side of U.S. Highway
1 within the municipal boundary of the City of Sebastian between 13100 and 1614 U.S.
Highway 1, including certain properties along Jackson Street, Madison Street, Davis Street,
N. Central Avenue (south of Jackson Street) and including 1637 and 1727 N. Indian River
Drive (North Sebastian Septic to Sewer [S2S] Phase 1 project), to specially benefit 112
parcels/units located therein ("Improvements"), and that the cost thereof shall be specially
P213
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
assessed in accordance with the provisions of Section 206.01 through 206.09 of The Code
of Indian River County.
2. The assessment will be based on the number of existing Equivalent Residential Units (ERUs)
for developed property; and for vacant property, the number of ERUs will be conservatively
calculated based on existing land use designation, zoning and size.
3. The estimated cost for the Improvements is $2,977,931.58 and the specially benefiting
parcels/units will be assessed for 38.20% of the cost of the Improvements as shown on the
assessment plat on file with the Department of Utility Services and the Clerk to the Board,
with 21.80% being funded from a St. Johns River Water Management District Cost Share
Grant, 20.00% from the Utility Assessment Fund, and 20.00% from the Optional Sales Tax
Contribution. Assessments are to be levied against all lots and lands specially benefited
thereby and further designated by the assessment plat with respect to the special assessments.
4. A special assessment per ERU or in the case of vacant property, calculated future ERUs,
may be assessed against each of the specially benefited properties designated on the
assessment plat on file with the Clerk to the Board. This special assessment may be raised
or lowered by action of the Board of County Commissioners serving as the equalizing board
at the public hearing, as set forth in Section 206.07 of The Code of Indian River County.
5. The special assessments shall be due and payable and may be paid in full within 90 days
after the date of the as -built resolution of the Board with respect to credits against the special
assessments after completion of the Improvements (the "Credit Date") without interest. If
not paid in full, the special assessments may be paid in ten equal yearly installments of
principal plus interest. If not paid when due, there shall be added a penalty of 1-1/2% of
the principal not paid when due. The unpaid balance of the special assessments shall
bear interest until paid at a rate of two percent (2%) percent per annum.
6. There is presently on file with the Department of Utility Services and the Clerk to the Board
an assessment plat showing the area to be assessed, plans and specifications for the
Improvements and an estimate of the cost of the proposed Improvements. All of these are
open to inspection by the public at the Department of Utility Services and the Clerk to the
Board.
A proposed preliminary assessment roll with respect to the special assessments is on file
with the Department of Utility Services and the Clerk to the Board.
8. Upon the adoption of this resolution, the Department of Utility Services shall cause this
resolution (along with a map showing the areas to be served) to be published at least one
time in the Indian River Press Journal before the public hearing as required by Section
206.04 of The Code of Indian River County.
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner , and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the
vote was as follows:
2
P214
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this
day of June, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of
Court and Comptroller By:
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
LOW
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
By:
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
P215
Time and Place (Second Resolution)
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SETTING A TIME AND
PLACE AT WHICH THE OWNERS OF CERTAIN PROPERTIES
LOCATED ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF U.S. HIGHWAY 1 BETWEEN
13230 AND 14410 U.S. HIGHWAY 1, AND INCLUDING 12920 AND
12950 U.S. HIGHWAY 1 WITHIN THE UNINCORPORATED
BOUNDARY OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY; AND CERTAIN
PROPERTIES ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF U.S. HIGHWAY 1 WITHIN
THE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY OF THE CITY OF SEBASTIAN
BETWEEN 13100 AND 1614 U.S. HIGHWAY 1, INCLUDING CERTAIN
PROPERTIES ALONG JACKSON STREET, MADISON STREET,
DAVIS STREET, N. CENTRAL AVENUE (SOUTH OF JACKSON
STREET) AND INCLUDING 1637 AND 1727 N. INDIAN RIVER DRIVE
(NORTH SEBASTIAN SEPTIC TO SEWER [S2S] PHASE 1 PROJECT);
AND OTHER INTERESTED PERSONS, MAY APPEAR BEFORE THE
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER
COUNTY AND BE HEARD AS TO THE PROPRIETY AND
ADVISABILITY OF CONSTRUCTING A SEWER MAIN EXTENSION,
AS TO THE COST THEREOF, AS TO THE MANNER OF PAYMENT
THEREFOR, AND AS TO THE AMOUNT THEREOF TO BE
SPECIALLY ASSESSED AGAINST EACH PROPERTY BENEFITED
THEREBY.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County has, by
Resolution No. 2017- , determined that it is necessary for the public welfare of the citizens of
the County, and particularly as to those living, working, and owning property within the area
described hereinafter, that a sewer main extension ("Improvements") be installed to service certain
properties located along the east side of U.S. Highway 1 between 13230 and 14410 U.S. Highway
1, and including 12920 and 12950 U.S. Highway 1 within the unincorporated boundary of Indian
River County; and certain properties along the east side of U.S. Highway 1 within the municipal
boundary of the City of Sebastian between 13100 and 1614 U.S. Highway 1, including certain
properties along Jackson Street, Madison Street, Davis Street, N. Central Avenue (south of Jackson
Street) and including 1637 and 1727 N. Indian River Drive (North Sebastian Septic to Sewer [S2S]
Phase 1 project), and
WHEREAS, the benefit derived from sewer to each parcel/unit will be based on the number
of existing Equivalent Residential Units (ERUs) for developed property; and for vacant property,
the number of ERUs will be conservatively calculated based on existing land use designation,
zoning and size; and
P216
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
WHEREAS, it has been determined that the cost to be specially assessed with respect
thereto shall be $4,989.12 per ERU or a percentage of same in the case of condominiums where
units share ERUs; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has caused an assessment ' roll to be
completed and fled with the Clerk to the Board; and
WHEREAS, Section 206.06 of The Code of Indian River County provides that the Board
of County Commissioners shall fix a time and place at which the owners of the specially benefited
properties to be specially assessed or any other persons interested therein may appear before the
Board of County Commissioners and be heard as to the propriety and advisability of constructing
such sewer main extension, as to the cost thereof, as to the manner of payment therefor, and as
to the amount thereof to be assessed against each parcel/unit benefited thereby,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows:
1. The County Commission shall meet at the County Commission Chambers in the County
Administration Building at the hour of 9:05 a.m., or as soon thereafter as the matter may be
heard, on Tuesday, July 18, 2017, at which time the owners of the specially benefited
properties to be specially assessed and any other interested persons, may appear before
said Commission and be heard as to the propriety and advisability of making the
improvements, the cost thereof, the manner of payment therefor, and the amount to be assessed
against each parcel/unit. The area to be improved and the properties to be specially benefited
are more particularly described upon the assessment plat and the assessment roll with regard
to the special assessments.
2. All persons interested in the construction of said Improvements and the special assessments
against the properties to be specially benefited may review the assessment plat showing the
area to be assessed, the assessment roll, the plans and specifications for said Improvements,
and an estimate of the cost thereof at the office of the Department of Utility Services and the
Clerk to the Board any week day from 8:30 a.m. until 5:00 p.m., excluding holidays.
3. Notice of the time and place of this public hearing shall be given by two publications in the
Indian River Press Journal Newspaper one week apart. The last publication shall be at least
one week prior to the date of the hearing.
4. The Department of Utility Services shall give the owner of each parcel/unit to be specially
assessed at least ten days' notice in writing of such time and place, which shall be served by
mailing a copy of such notice to each of such parcel/unit owners at his last known address
obtained from the records of the property appraiser.
P217
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner , and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote,
the vote was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Tim Zorc
Commissioner Bob Solari
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day
of June, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Attest: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk of
Court and Comptroller By
ZZ
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
By:
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
3
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
P218
CAPITAL COST BREAKDOWN -OPTION 11
Map ID
IRC
No
Parcel ID
SITE
OWNER NAME
Estimated
ERU (HFS) COST DOR_DESC
ERU's
1
30382100001999900029.0
1614 US HIGHWAY 1
RIVERWALK VILLAGE INC
2
$9,978.24
Stores (1 Story)
2
30383000002001000004.1
1620 N CENTRAL AV
VARI, ATTILA T AND HEATHER E
1
$4,989.12
Multi -Family (2-9 Unit Buildings)
3
30382100001999900028.0
U5 HIGHWAY 1
RIVERWALK VILLAGE INC
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
4
30383000002001000004.0
ib24 N CENTRAL AV
JMH VENTURES CORPORATION
1
$4,989.12
Stores (1 Story)
5
30382100001999900027.0
US HIGHWAY 1
FISH, GLENN
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
6
30383000002001000002.0
1632 N CENTRAL AV
STRUNK, GLENN A A"HI
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
7
30382100001999900026.0
1640 US HIGHWAY 1
STRUNK, GLENN AN2
$9,978.24
Vacant Commercial Land
8
30383000002001000011.0
1637 INDIAN RIVER DR
MC CANN, SANDRA
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
9
30382100001999900025.0
US HIGHWAY 1
STRUNK, GLENN A A
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
10
30382100001999900024.0
L HIGHWAY 1
STRUNK, GLENN A A
i
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
11
30382100001999900014.0
1644 N CENTRAL AV
KELLY, RICHARD ART6
$29,934.71
Single Family -Improved
12
30382100001999900022.0
1623 N CENTRAL AV
STRUNK, GLENN A AH
1
$4,989.12
Mortuaries) Cemeteries J
Crematoriums
13
30382100001999900013.0
1654 N CENTRAL AV
SWANIK, JAMES
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
14
30382100001999900012.0
1662 N CENTRAL AV
HALL, HAROLD AND CHRISTINE L
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -improved
15
30382100001999900021.0
1676 US HIGHWAY 1
1676 DUCKS LLC
1
$4,989.12
16
30382100001999900020.0
1683 N -CENTRAL AV
SYPHER, RONALD
1
$4,989.12
Offices; Non -Professional, One Story
Single Family -Improved
17
30382100001999900011.1
N CENTRALAV
INDIAN RIVER RV INC
4
$19,956.47
Open Storage, Etc,
18
30382100001999900018.0
1697 N CENTRAL AV
VICTORWWIUJAM COMPANY
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
19
30382100001999900011.0
1698 N CENTRAL AV
INDIAN RIVER RV INC
2
$9,978.24
Auto Sales J Auto Service J Auto
20
30383000001004000011.0
DAVIS ST
SMITH, DALE SAND CYNTHIA A
2
$9,978.24
Rental J Car Wash
Vacant Commercial Land
21
30383000001004000014.0
DAVIS ST
SMITH, DALE SAND CYNTHIA A
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
22
30383000001003000001.0
1715 N CENTRAL AV
SEBASTIAN MASONIC LODGE NO 232
1
$4,989.12
Clubs J Lodges J Union Halls
23
30382100001999900010.0
616 DAVIS ST
MCBRIDE, HAROLD RJR (LE)
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
24
30393100001000000005.4
612 DAVIS ST
FAIRCHILD BRIAN J
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
25
30393100001000000004.2
1727 N INDIAN RIVER DR NILSSON ROBERT TERESA
2
$9,978.24
Single Family -Improved
26
30383000001004000002.0
1716 US HIGHWAY 1
KRASCO LESLIE •
1
$4,989.12
Stores (1 Story)
27
30383000001004000001.0
MADISON 5T
KRASCO LESLIE'
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
28
30382100001999900009.0
608 DAVIS ST
NILSSON ROBERT TERESA a
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
(7
29
30383000001005000011.0
704 MADISON ST
NEVAREZ PEDRO &
1
$4,989.12
Vacant Commercial Land
30
30383000001005000012.0
MADISON ST
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
2
$9,978.24
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
O
Hospitals
'Tl
31
30383000001002000009.0
MADISON ST
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
1
$4,989.12
Municipal, other than Parks, f
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
V1
m
32
30383000001005000003.0
711 JACKSON ST
NEVAREZ PEDRO &
1
$4,989.12
Hospitals
Single Family -Improved
00
N
33
30383000001005000001.0
707 JACKSON ST
MARSHALL HARRY J SARA
1
$4,989.12
Mixed Use; Store, Office with
--q
Residential
D
34
30383000001002000001.0
1805 CENTRAL AV
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
1
$4,989.12
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
z
i
35
30393100001000000003.5
1724 N CENTRAL AV
HOCH REBECCA S
1
$4,989.12
Hospitals
Mobile Homes
C
36
34383000001006000000.2
710 JACKSON ST
HART MARIA
1
$4,989.12
Laundries, Various Services, etc.
37
30383000001006000000.1
708 JACKSON ST
HART MARIA
2
$9,978.24
Multi -Family (2-9 Unit Buildings)
38
30383000001001000001.0
698 JACKSON ST
HALL JERRY S a MARSHA G
1
$4,989.12
Single Family -Improved
(7
42
30382100001000000025.1
12900 US HIGHWAY 1
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
2
$9,978.24
Municipal, other than Parks,
Recreational Area, Colleges, and
Q
45
30383000010000000000.0
5
$24,945.54
Hospitals
Office Condominium
z
30383000010000000001.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000002.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000003.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000004.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000005.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000006.0
13000 U5 HIGHWAY 1
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000007.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000008.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000009.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24"
$1,187.89
30383000010000000010.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000011.0
13000 U5 HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000012.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000013.0
13000 U5 HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000014.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
3038300001000000001S.0
13000 U5 HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000016.0
1300D US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000017.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000018.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000019.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
30383000010000000020.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187'.89
F:\Utilities\UTIUTY. Engineedng\Projects. Utility Construction Permits\IRC - Sewer Feasibility Studies UCP 0 4101\3. North Sebastian (M&M)\Design Phase\Phase I-Data\S2SPhase Wisased Bid Prlcn.zlsx ATTACH M ENT 3.
P219
CAPITAL COST BREAKDOWN -OPTION it
F:\U0011es\Ur1U7Y - Engineedng\Pro)ects - Udiity Construction Permits\IRC - Sewer FeesibilltyStudies UCP 114101\3. North Sebntlan (M&MI\Design Phase\Phase 1-0nt*\$2S-Phase IA -Based Bid Pric-%. ATTACHMENT 3.
P220
30383000010000000021.0
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
0.24
$1,187.89
46
30382100001000000023.0
13020 US HIGHWAY 1
6
$29,934.71
Auto Sales / Auto Service J Auto
FAMILY CAR WASH CO INC
Rental / Car Wash
47
30382100001000000022.0
13050 US HIGHWAY 1
PTS OF BREVARD COUNTY INC
2
$9,978.24
Professional Services
48
3038300D011000000000.0
2
$9978.24
Office Condominium
30383000011000000001.0
13060 US HIGHWAY 1
ABID. H. OONWALA
1
$4,989.12
30383000011000000002.0
13060 US HIGHWAY 1
M. NASIR & TABASSUM RIZWI
1
$4,989.12
49
30382100001000000021.1
13070 US HIGHWAY 1
SEBASTIAN PARTNERS ULC
3
$14,967.35
Vacant Commercial Land
50
30382100001000000020.2
13090 US HIGHWAY 1
ZAIDI SPED IRFAN H (COTRS) MUNAWA
2
$9,978.24
Professional Services
51
30382100001000000019.0
13100 US HIGHWAY 1
SHALHOUB HALA *
3
$14,967.35
Professional Services
18.00
$_389,151.22
43
30382100001000000025.0
12920 US HIGHWAY 1
FOUNTAIN TOWERS LLC "
2
$9,978.24
Professional Services
44
30382100001000000024.0
12950 US HIGHWAY 1
RIZWI LLC
3
$14,967.35
Vacant Commercial Land
52
30383600404001000001.0
13230 US HIGHWAY 1
GERISEB PL
1
$4,989.12
jProfessional Services
53
30383600006000000000.0
9
$44,902.06
Office Condominium
30383600006000000001.0
13262 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000002.0
13260 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000003.0
13258 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000004.0
13256 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000005.0
13254 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES ULC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000006.0
13252 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000007.0
13250 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006004p00008.0
13248 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
# -
30383600006000000009.0
13246 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000010.0
13244 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000011.0
13242 US HIGHWAY 1
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
30383600006000000012.0
13240
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
0.75
$3,741.84
54
30382500000004100002.0
133 1
ROYAL PALM CORPORATE CENTER ASS
7S
$374,183.86
Vacant Commercial Land
55
30382500000005000005.0
134 1
QUALITY HEALTH CARE INC OF FLORIDA
20
$99,782.36rcial
Land
56
30382500000002000003.3
"HIGHWAY
137 1
JUNO ROAD REALTY LLC
22
$109,760.60
Vacant Commercial Land
57
30382500000002000003.2
138 12
$9,978.24
Banks / Savings and Loan Assoc. /
NATIONAL RETAIL PROPERTIES LPMortgage
Co. / Credit Services
58
30382500017000000000.0
4
19,956.47
Office Condominium
i
30382500017000000001.0
13830 US HIGHWAY 1
BRADY, VALERIE
0.33
$1,663.04
;;., Z.
30382500017000000002.0
13832 US HIGHWAY 1
PELICAN NEST LLC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017400000003.0
13834 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS} &
0.33
$1,663.04
Z.
>" n
30382500017000000004.0
13836 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017000000005.0
13838 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017404000006.0
13840 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES {TRS} &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017000000007.0
13842 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500017000000008.0
13844 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
m.
0
30382500017000000009.0
13846 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
n:
30382500017000000410.0
13848 US HIGHWAY 1
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
0.33
$1,663.04
0
C
30382500017000000011.0
13850 US HIGHWAY 1
DONOVAN, RICHARD J and PATRICIA W
0.33
$1,663.04
Z
30382500017000000012.0
13852 US HIGHWAY 1
DONOVAN, RICHARD J and PATRICIA W
0.33
$1,663.04
59
30382500000002000003.1
14000 US HIGHWAY 1
BAY STREET SEBASTIAN LLC
4
$19,956.47
Stores (1 Story)
60
30382500012000000000.0
4
$19,956.47
Medical Condominium
30382500012000000001.0
7740 BAY ST
PETERSON, MARK A and MARY LOU
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000002.0
7744 BAY ST
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000004.0
7746 BAY ST
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000005.0
7750 BAY S7
KHAWAJA, FARHATJ and MUSSARRAT
0.33
$1,663.04
1
30382500012000000006.0
7752 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, FARHAN J and SABEEN J
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000007.0
7754 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, SOBIA (1/3) &
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000008.0
7760 BAY ST
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000009.0
7762 BAY ST
THEIS, ALFRED J
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000010.0
7764 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, MUSSARRAT 1(1/2) and
0.33
$1,66304
MAHMUDA
30382500012000000011.0
7766 BAY ST
0.33
$1,663.04
BROOKS, HAROLD LIR &BARBARA R
30382500012000000012.0
7768 BAY ST
AU, SABIR MD and ATTIYA
0.33
$1,663.04
30382500012000000013.0
7770 BAY ST
KHAWAJA, MOHAMMAD NAIM and
0.33
$1,663.04
SHAHIDA NAIM
jProfesslonLalSer-vices
61
30382500000002040402.1
1441D US HIGHWAY 1
CLARITY MEDICAL PROPERTIES LLC
4
$19,956.47
156 -AF -748,367.73
228.00
$1,137,519
F:\U0011es\Ur1U7Y - Engineedng\Pro)ects - Udiity Construction Permits\IRC - Sewer FeesibilltyStudies UCP 114101\3. North Sebntlan (M&MI\Design Phase\Phase 1-0nt*\$2S-Phase IA -Based Bid Pric-%. ATTACHMENT 3.
P220
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500012000000001.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
PETERSON, MARK A and MARY LOU
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
4280 BERRY RD
Total ERU's: 4
GRANT FL 32949
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 1 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7740 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000002.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 368
Number ERU's: 4
ROSELAND FL 32957
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNITS 2 & 3 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7744 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000004.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 368
Number ERU's: 4
ROSELAND FL 32957
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 4 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7746 BAY ST
6/7/2f'017
MD' i
ties\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
tAssessmentRoll_R ESO_1_2_No rthCou ntySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. doa
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P221
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500012000000005.0
Assessment=
$1,663.04
Owner
KHAWAJA, FARHATJ and MUSSARRATJ
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1860 BAYVIEW CT
Total ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 5 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7750 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000006.0
Assessment=
$1,663.04
Owner
KHAWAJA, FARHAN J and SABEEN 1
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1860 BAYVIEW CT
Number ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 6 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7752 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000007.0
Assessment=
$1,663.04
Owner
KHAWAJA, SOBIA (1/3) &
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1860 BAYVIEW CT
Number ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 7 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7754 BAY ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject 61_Parcels\Word Documents\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO_1_2_NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsst Projec t M ult i. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P222
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500012000000008.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
BAY STREET PHARMACY INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7746 BAY ST UNIT 4
Tota) ERU's: 4
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 8 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7760 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000009.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
THEIS, ALFRED J
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 2550
Number ERU's: 4
MELBOURNE FL 32902
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 9 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7762 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000010.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
KHAWAJA, MUSSARRATJ (1/2) and MAHMUDA
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1860 BAYVIEW CT
Number ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 10 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7764 BAY ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Pro pos ed\06_No rthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssess mentProject_61_Pa rcels \Word Docu me nts\01_Preli mi naryAssessme ntRo II_R ESO 1_2_NorthCou ntySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P223
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500012000000011.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
BROOKS, HAROLD L J R & BARBARA R
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
6855 1ST ST SW
Total ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32968
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 11 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7766 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000012.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
ALI, SABIR MD and ATTIYA
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
809 CHAMPION DR NE
Number ERU's: 4
PALM BAY FL 32905
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 12 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7768 BAY ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500012000000013.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
KHAWAJA, MOHAMMAD NAIM and SHAHIDA
NAIM
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 60
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7754 BAY ST
Number ERU's: 4
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
BAY STREET CENTER PHASE I
UNIT 13 OR BK 685 PP 566
Revision Date
Site Address
7770 BAY ST
6/7/2017
I
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessme nts_2017_Propos ed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssessm entProject_61_Pa rcels \Word Docu ments\O1_Preli mi naryAssess mentRoll_RESO_1_2_NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P224
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500017000000001.0 Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
BRADY, VALERIE
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13830 N US HWY 1 #1
Total ERU's: 4
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 1 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13830 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000002.0 Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
PELICAN NEST LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13832 US HWY 1
Number ERU's: 4
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 2 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13832 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000003.0 Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Number ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 3 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13834 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
- Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Roll_RESO_1_2_North Cou ntySe ptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P225
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500017000000004.0 Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID : 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Total ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 4 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13836 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000005.0 Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Number ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 5 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13838 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000006.0 Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Number EkU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 6 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13840 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Pro posed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssess mentP roject_61_Pa rcels \W ordDoc u ments\01_Preli mi naryAssess mentRoll_R ESO_1_2_No rthCo untySe ptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P226
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500017000000007.0
Assessment=
$1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address,
7 ORION
Total ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 7 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13842 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000008.0
Assessment=
$1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS)- &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID:, 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Number ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 8 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13844 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000009.0
Assessment=
$1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Number ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 9 OR 8K 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13846 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
7
F:\Uti1ities\UT1L1TY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCounty5eptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject 61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO_1_2_NorthCountySeptic
—SewerAsstProjectMulti.docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P227
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500017000000010.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
SPOTO, JAMES (TRS) &
Secondary Owners
SPOTO, CATHY
Map I D : 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7 ORION
Total ERU's: 4
IRVINE CA 92612
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 10 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13848 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000011.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
DONOVAN, RICHARD J and PATRICIA W
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1831 CAYMAN RD E
Number ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 11 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13850 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500017000000012.0
Assessment= $1,663.04
Owner
DONOVAN, RICHARD J and PATRICIA W
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 58
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1831 CAYMAN RD E
Number ERU's: 4
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
ZALES PLAZA
UNIT 12 OR BK 927 PP 419
Revision Date
Site Address
13852 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessme nts_2017_Pro pos ed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssess mentProject_61_Parcels \Word Docu ments\OI_Prel imi na ryAssessme nt Roll_R E50_1_2_NorthCou ntySeptic
_SewerAsst ProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P228
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000010000000001.0
Assessment=
$1,187.89
Owner
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3717 10TH CT
Total ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 1 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000002.0
Assessment=
$1,187.89
Owner
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3717 10TH CT
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 2 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000003.0
Assessment=
$1,187.89
Owner
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3717 10TH CT
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 3 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocu ments\Ol_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO 1 2 NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulU. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P229
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY —DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL—RESOLUTION 1
ap�r�y
Parcel #
30383000010000000004.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3717 10TH CT
Total ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 4 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000005.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 4S
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3717 10TH CT
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 5 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000006.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
SEA CREST OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3717 10TH CT
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 6 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
'F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017 Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\O1_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO 1 2 NorthCountySeptic
SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P230
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000010000000007.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 4
Total ERU's: 5
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 7 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
_
Parcel #
30383000010000000008.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 4
Number ERU's: 5
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 8 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000009.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 4
Number ERU's: 5
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 9 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCounty5eptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject 61_Parcels\WordDocuments\O1_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO_1_2_NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P231
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000010000000010.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 4
Total ERU's: 5
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 10 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000011.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 4
Number ERU's: 5
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 11 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000012.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
PRIMARY CARE OF SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 4
Number ERU's: 5
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 12 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Pro posed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssess mentProj ect_61_Parcels \Word Docu me nts\01_PreliminaryAssessment Roll_R ESO_ 1_2_NorthCountySeptic
SewerAsstProjectM ulti.docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P232
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL—RESOLUTION 1
CAP
Parcel #
30383000010000000013.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Total ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 13 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000014.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 14 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000015.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 15 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address,�t�
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Pa rcels \Word Docu ments\O1_Preli mi naryAssessmentRoll_RESO_S_2_NorthCou ntySeptic
SewerAsst ProjectM ulti. door
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P233
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000010000000016.0
Assessment=
$1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Total ERU's: 5
VEROBEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 16 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
•a aii.
Parcel #
30383000010000000017.0
Assessment=
$1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 17 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000018.0
Assessment=
$1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 18 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017I
1 - _.. �1
w4i
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects -Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017 Proposed\06 NorthCounty5eptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO 1_2_NorthCou n ty5e ptic
SewerAsstProjectM ulti.docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P234
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000010000000019.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Total ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 19 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000020.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 20 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000010000000021.0
Assessment= $1,187.89
Owner
KP MAES PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 45
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1351 INDIAN MOUND TRAIL
Number ERU's: 5
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
SEA CREST PROFESSIONAL BUILDING CONDO
UNIT 21 OR BK 1597 PP 2809
Revision Date
Site Address
13000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
aC .c
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessme nts_2017_Pro pos ed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssess mentP roject_61_Pa rcels \Word Docu me nts\O1_Preli mi naryAss ess mentRo11_RES0_1_2_NorthCou ntySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P235
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000011000000001.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
OONWALA, ABID H (TRS)
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 48
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
4854 S HARBOR DR #301
Total ERU's: 2
VERO BEACH FL 32967
Legal
MERCHANT-RIZWI CONDO
UNIT A OR BK 1689 PG 1942
Revision Date
Site Address
13060 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000011000000002.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
RIZWI, M NASIR AND TABASSUM
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 48
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
8540 SEACREST DR
Number ERU's: 2
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
MERCHANT-RIZWI CONDO
UNIT B OR BK 1689 PG 1942
Revision Date
Site Address
13060 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000001.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 1 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13262 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCounty5eptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RES0_1_2_NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM u Iti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P236
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383600006000000002.0
Assessment= $3;741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Total ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 2 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13260 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000003.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 3 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13258 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000004.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 4 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13256 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Pro posed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocu ments\Ol_Prelimi naryAssessmentRoll_R ESO_3_2_NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM utti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P237
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383600006000000005.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Total ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 5 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13254 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000006.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 6 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13252 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000007.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 7 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13250 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61 Parcels\WordOocuments\O1_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO_1_2_NorthCounty5eptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ult i. docx
Wednesday, lune 14,2017
P238
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383600006000000008.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Total ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 8 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13248 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000009.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 9 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13246 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000010.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 10 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13244 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Pro posed\06_NorthCou nty5eptic_to_SewerAssessmentProj ect_61_Parcels\WordDocu ments\Ol_Preli minaryAssessmentRoll_R ESO_3_2_NorthCou ntySeptic
SewerAsstProjectM ulti.docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P239
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383600006000000011.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Total ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 11 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13242 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600006000000012.0
Assessment= $3,741.84
Owner
FIREFOX PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 53
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 643661
Number ERU's: 9
VERO BEACH FL 32964
Legal
SAND RIDGE CENTRE CONDOMINIUM
UNIT 12 OR BK 805 PP 1379
Revision Date
Site Address
13240 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
FAUtilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocu ments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESO_1_2_NorthCountySeptic
_SewerAsstProjectM ulti. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P240
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROIL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001999900029.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
RIVERWALK VILLAGE INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 1
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1616 N US HIGHWAY 1
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 COM AT THE INT OF THE E
R/W LI - NE OF NEW US
HWY 1 AND THE S R/W LINE OF 9TH ST; RUN SLY ALONG THE E
R/W LINE OF, NEW
US HWY 1 A DIST OF 1185.13 FT TO PO - B: FROM SAID POB
RUN ELY ON A LINE P
ARA WITH THE S BDY OF 9TH STA
Revision Date
Site Address
1614 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000002001000004.1
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
VARI, ATTILA T AND HEATHER E
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 2
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
285 RAVENNA DR
Number ERU's: 1
LONG BEACH CA 90803
Legal
INDIAN RIVER HILLS SUB PBI 4-51 THE SLY 25.0 FT OF LOT 4
BEING - A STRIP
25.0 WIDE LYING NLY OF AND IMME DIATELY ADJACENT TO
SIDE LINE BETWEEN LO,
TS4&5
NLY 50.0 FT OF LOT 5
BEING A - STRIP 50 FT WIDE LYING S OF & IM
Revision Date
Site Address
1620 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900028.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
RIVERWALK VILLAGE INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 3
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1616 N US HIGHWAY 1
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 THAT PART OF
WAUREGAN LYING E - OF RY; S OF 9
TH ST & BETWEEN NEW US HWY 1 & N CENTRAL AVE DESC AS
FOLL; COM AT , SE COR
OF INTERSECTION OF NEW US HWY 1 & - 9TH ST
RUN S 9 DEG 57 MIN 30 SEC E AL
0 GN E R/W LINE OF NEW US HWY
Revision Date
Site Address
US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCoun tySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_Prelimin aryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION_1 2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P241
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
W,
Parcel #
30383000002001000004.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
JMH VENTURES CORPORATION
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 4
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 1014
Number ERU's: 1
ROSELAND FL 32957
Legal
INDIAN RIVER HILLS SUB PBI 4-51 NLY 75 FT OF LOT 4
SLY & IMMED - IATELY
ADJ TO SIDE LOT LINE BETWEEN LOTS 3 & 4
AS R BK 279 PP 420 BLK 1
Revision Date
Site Address
1624 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900027.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
FISH, GLENN
Secondary Owners
Map I D: 5
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
6007 INNES TRACE RD
Number ERU's: 1
LOUISVILLE KY 40222-6004
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 POR OF PART OF
WAUREGAN BETWEE - N RY & S OF
9TH ST; BEING A LOT LOCATED BETWEEN N CENTRAL AVE &
NEW US HWY 1 AS , R BK
51 PP 257
Revision Date
Site Address
US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000002001000002.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 6
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
2 SEA GULL AVE
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32960-5213
Legal
INDIAN RIVER HILLS SUB PBI 4-51 LOT 2 & SWLY 80 FT OF LOT
12AS-RBK64
PP 289 BLK 1
Revision Date
Site Address
1632 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments 2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\O1_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_R ES0LUTI0N_1_2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P242
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001999900026.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
STRUNK, GLENN AND DOROTHY
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 7
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
916 17TH ST
Number ERU's: 2
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 POR OF PART OF
WAUREGAN BETWEE - N RY & S OF
9TH ST; BEING A LOT LOCATED BETWEEN N CENTRAL AVE &
NEW US HWY 1 AS , R BK
51 PP 249
Revision Date
Site Address
1640 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000002001000011.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
MC CANN, SANDRA CALVIN
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 8
Secondary_ Owners
Mailing Address
1637 INDIAN RIVER DR
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958-3854
Legal
INDIAN RIVER HILLS SUB PBI 4-51 LOT it BLK 1 LOT 1
BLK 2 & ALS - O INCL
THAT POR OF ABAN R/W IND RIV DR P ER THE CITY OF SEB RES
#R-01-52 AS DESC
IN OR BK 1417 PG 2405; ALSO INCL LOT 1 B - LK 1
Revision Date
Site Address
1637 INDIAN RIVER DR
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900025.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 9
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
2 SEAGULL AVE
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 FROM THE SE COR OF US
#1 & 9TH - ST; RUN S9
DEG 57 MIN 30 SEC E 835.15 FT ALONG E R/W OF US #1 TO
POB; TH S 9 D, EG 57
MIN 30 SEC E 50 FT ALONG R/W
THS -88 DEG 06 MIN E 124.79 FT TO W R/W N
CE NTRAL AVE
TH N ALONG SAID
Revision Date
Site Address
US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01 PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION_1 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P243
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001999900024.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 10
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
2 SEAGULL AVE
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 FROM THE SE COR OF US
NO1&9-THST RUNS
9 DEG 06 MIN W 142.09 FT TO POB AS IN R BK 312 PP 456.
Revision Date
Site Address
US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900014.0
Assessment= $29,934.72
Owner
KELLY, RICHARD ARTHUR &
Secondary Owners
KELLY, BARBARA JEAN
Map ID: 11
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1644 N CENTRAL AVE
Number ERU's: 6
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 PART OF SEC 30; FLEMING
GRANT - AS OR BK 41 P
P 292 & PART E OF RY AS IN D BK 46 PP 110 AND ALSO INCL
PART OF LO, T 6 MO
RE PART DESC AS FOLL
FR INT OF N - LINE OF IR HILLS & FLEMING GRANT LINE F
OR POB
RUN N 45 DEG 09 MIN 00
Revision Date
Site Address
1644 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900022.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
STRUNK, GLENN A AND DOROTHY H
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 12
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
2 SEAGULL AVE
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32960-5213
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 COM AT SE COR OF US #1
& 9TH S=T; CITY OFS
EBASTIAN; RUN S 9 DEG 57 MIN 30 SEC E ALONG E R/W SAID
US#1;DIST OF, 300
FT TO POB
TH CONT ALONG SAID E R/W - 485.18 FT
TH RUN S 88 DEG 6 MIN E 0
N A LINE PARALELLTO 9TH ST 14
Revision Date
Site Address
1623 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
♦
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION 1 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P244
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001999900013.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
SWAN IK, JAMES
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 13
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1945 5TH CT
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32960
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 PART OF SEC 30 FLEMING
DR ASD - BK 12 PP 62
&DBK25;PP571&DBK30PP131&DBK31PP91,LESS
BERGBOM A, S R B
K 41 PP 292
LESS LOT 100 X 150 FT - AS DESC IN OR BK 366 PP 455 & LESS
TO
B ERGBOM AS IN OR BK 41 PP 292
Revision Date
Site Address
1654 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900012.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
HALL, HAROLD AND CHRISTINE L
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 14
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
8925 107TH AVE
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32967
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 PART OF SEC 30; FLEMING
GRANT; - BEING LOT 10
0 FT X 150 FT AS DESC IN OR BK 366 PP 455
Revision Date
Site Address
1662 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900021.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
1676 DUCKS LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 15
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
3155 62ND AVE
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32966
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 NLY 300 FT, MEASURED
ALONG E R -/W LINE OF N
EW US HWY 1 OF THAT PART OF WAUREGAN LYING E OF RY &
S OF 9TH ST; LY, ING
BETWEEN NEW US HWY 1 & N CENTRAL AVE -
LESS ELY 100 FT THEREOF AS R BK 36
PP 316, ALSO DESC AS FOLL; BE
Revision Date
Site Address
1676 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCounty5eptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_S 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P245
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL—RESOLUTION 1
r�I
Parcel #
30382100001999900020.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
SYPHER, RONALD
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 16
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1683 N CENTRAL AVE
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958-3807
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 BEG AT INTERSECTION OF
ER/WL- INEOFNEWU
S HWY 1 & S R/W LINE OF 9TH ST; TH RUN ELY ALONG S R/W
LINE OF 9TH S, T 29
3.59 FT TO THE INTERSECTION OF 9TH S - T & N CENTRAL AVE
TH RUN SLY ALONG
W LI NE OF N CENTRAL AVE 153.5
Revision Date
Site Address
1683 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900011.1
Assessment= $19,956.48
Owner
INDIAN RIVER RV INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 17
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1698 N CENTRAL AVE
Number ERU's: 4
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBBI-179 THAT PART OF WAUREGAN
LYING E 0 - F N CENTRAL
AVE & S OF 9TH ST DESC AS FO LL; BEG AT INT OF S R/W OF
9TH ST &WLY , LIN
E OF AUGUST PARK SUB (SAME BEING FLEM - ING GRANT
LINE) AS IN PBS 1-19
TH
RUN S WLY ALONG S R/W OF 9TH S
Revision Date
Site Address
N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900018.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
VICTORIA -WILLIAM COMPANY
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 18
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
6945 49TH ST
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32967
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 BEG ATTHE INT OF THE E
R/W LI - NE OF NEW US
HIGHWAY NO 1 & THE S R/W OF NINTH ST; TH RUN ELY
ALONG THE S R/W LI, NE 0
F NINTH ST A DIST OF 293.59 FT TO TH - E INT OF NINTH ST &
N CENTRAL AVE FO
RPOB
TH RUN SLY ALONG THE W
Revision Date
Site Address
1697 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments 2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic to SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\O1_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION_1_2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssess ment Project. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P246
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
MM.
Parcel #
30382100001999900011.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
INDIAN RIVER RV INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 19
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1698 N CENTRAL AVE
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 & PBI 1-19; COM INT OF S
R/W 0 - F DAVIS ST &
WLY LINE OF AUGUST PARK SUB (SAME BEING FLEMING
GRANT LINE); TH S 5, 6 DE
G 03 MIN 35 SEC W ALONG S R/W LINE 0 - F DAVIS ST A DIST
OF 16.30 FT TO POB
TH CONT S 56 DEG 03 MIN 35 S
Revision Date
Site Address
1698 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001004000011.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
SMITH, DALE S AND CYNTHIA A
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 20
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
197 FULLERTON RD
Number ERU's: 2
DERRICK CITY PA 16727-1213
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOT 11
LESS HWY R/W & LOTS 12 & -13 BL
K4
Revision Date
Site Address
DAVIS ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001004000014.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
SMITH, DALE S AND CYNTHIA A
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 21
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
197 FULLERTON RD
Number ERU's: 1
DERRICK CITY PA 16727-1213
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOT 14 BLK 4 TOGETHER
WITH WLY 1- /2 OF
ADJ ABND ALLEY PER CITY OF SEBASTI AN ORD # 0-83-16
Revision Date
Site Address
DAVIS ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessme nts_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Pa rcels \Word Docu ments\01_Preli min aryAssessmentRol I_R ESOLUTIO N_1_2_NorthCou n
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P247
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
+'
Parcel #
30383000001003000001.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
SEBASTIAN MASONIC LODGE NO 232
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 22
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
PO BOX 780193
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32978-0193
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 1 TO 10 INC BLK 3
TOGETHER - WITH E
LY 1/2 OF ADJ ABND ALLEY PER CITY OF SEBASTIAN
ORDINANCE # 0-83-16
Revision Date
Site Address
1715 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001999900010.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
MCBRIDE, HAROLD R JR (LE)
Secondary Owners
DELVIN, LINDA (1/4)
GIBLIN, LAURA (1/4)
Map ID: 23
Secondary Owners
MOBLEY, CRAIG (1/4)
MOBLEY, ERIC (1/4)
Mailing Address
616 DAVIS ST
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 COM AT A PT WHERE THE
FLEMING - GRANT LINE IN
TERSECTS CENTRAL AVE OR THE OLD DIXIE HWY; IN THE
TOWN OF SEBASTIAN , ; TH
GO S 338 FT
MORE OR LESS TO AN IRO - N POST WHERE CENTRAL AVE IS
INTERSECT
ED BY 9TH ST FOR THE POB
TH G
Revision. Date
Site Address
616 DAVIS ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30393100001000000005.4
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
FAIRCHILD, BRIAN J
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 24
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
86A CAMPVILLE RD
Number ERU's: 1
NORTHFIELD CT 6778
Legal
AUGUST PARK SUB ESTATE OF PBS 1-19 PART OF LOT 5 AS D
BK 26 PG 85
Revision Date
Site Address
612 DAVIS ST
6/7/2017
'4,±'x,7.., .'S�-_��1:•'•-T.
F:\Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessment Project_61_Parce1s\WordDocuments\01PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RES0LUTI0N_1 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P248
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30393100001000000004.2
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
NILSSON, ROBERT AND TERESA
Secondary Owners
Map I D : 25
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
608 DAVIS ST
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
AUGUST PARK SUB ESTATE OF PBS 1-19 A POR OF LOTS 4 & 5
BEING MORE - PART
DESC AS FOLL
COM AT INT OF WLY R/ W LINE OF OLD DIXIE HWY & NLY R/W
LINE
0, F 9TH ST; TH RUN N 26 DEG 44 MIN 00 SEC - W ALONG
SAID WLY R/W LINE 141
.21 FT
Revision Date
Site Address
1727 N INDIAN RIVER DR
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001004000002.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
KRASCO, LESLIE
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 26
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
5240 93RD LN
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 2,3 & LOT 4; LESS
HWY R/W & - LOT 5
LESS HWY R/W BLK 4
Revision Date
Site Address
1716 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001004000001.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
KRASCO, LESLIE
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 27
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
5240 93RD LN
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOT 1 BLK 4 TOGETHER
WITH WLY 1/ - 2 OF
ADJ ABND ALLEY PER CITY OF SEBASTIA N ORDINANCE # 0-83-
16
Revision Date
Site Address
MADISON ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments 2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION_3 2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAs s es s ment Proj ect. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P249
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001999900009.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
NILSSON, ROBERT AND TERESA
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 28
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
608 DAVIS ST
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-179 A POR OF FLEMING GRANT
SEC 30 - MORE PART DES
C AS FOLL; BEG AT A PT WHER E FLEMING GRANT LINE
INTERSECTS N CENTRA, LAV
E
TH S 22 DEG 16 MIN 05 SEC E ALONG - E R/W OF N CENT AVE
TO A PT WHICH IS
13 8 FT N OF INTERSECTION OF
Revision Date
Site Address
608 DAVIS ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001005000011.0
Assessment=
$4,989.12
Owner
NEVAREZ, PEDRO &
Secondary Owners
HUITRON, GLORIA
Map ID: 29
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7340 57TH ST
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32967
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB - BLK 5 LOT 11 PBI 2-7
Revision Date
Site Address
704 MADISON ST
6/7/2017 -
Parcel #
30383000001005000012.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 30
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1225 MAIN ST
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958-4165
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 12 & 13 BLK 5 &
INC A PORT - OF ABN
D ALLEY ABUTTING LOT 13 PER CITY 0 F SEBASTIAN ORD #0-
092-10
Revision Date
Site Address
MADISON ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY- Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments 2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySept is_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61 Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll 11ES0LUTI0N_1 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P250
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000001002000009.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 31
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1225 MAIN ST
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958-4165
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 9 & 10, BLK 2 &
INC A PORT - OF ABN
D ALLEY ABUTTING SAID LOTS PER CIT Y OF SEBASTIAN ORD
#0-92-10
Revision Date
Site Address
MADISON ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001005000003.0
Assessment=_ $4,989.12
Owner
NEVAREZ, PEDRO &
Secondary Owners
HUITRON, GLORIA
Map ID: 32
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7340 57TH ST
Number ERU's: 1
VERO BEACH FL 32967
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB - BLK 5 LOTS 3 & 4 PBI 2-7
Revision Date
Site Address
711 JACKSON ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001005000001.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
MARSHALL, HARRY AND SARA
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 33
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
707 JACKSON ST
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 1 & 2 BLK 5 & INC
A PORT OF - ABND
ALLEY ABUTTING LOT 1 PER CITY OF S EBASTIAN ORD #0-92-10
Revision Date
Site Address
707 JACKSON ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptit to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION 1_2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P251
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000001002000001.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 34
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1225 MAIN ST
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958-4165
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 1 TO 8 INC & INCA
PORT OF - ABN D A
LLEY ABUTTING SAID LOTS PER CITY 0 F SEBASTIAN ORD #0-
92-10
Revision Date
Site Address
1805 CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30393100001000000003.5
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
HOCH REBECCA S (LE)
Secondary Owners
HOSH RACHEL S
Map ID: 35
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
99 CARMEN ST
Number ERU's: 1
MELBOURNE FL 32951-3836
Legal
AUGUST PARK SUB ESTATE OF PBS 1-19 BEG AT CONCRETE
MARKER ON N LINE OF LOT
3
291.5 FT W OF NE COR OF LOT 3
TH RUN SON W BDY OF PROPERTY DESC IN D
BK 88 PG 88
A DIST 139.82 FT TO AN IRON PIPE FOR POB
Revision Date
Site Address
1724 N CENTRAL AV
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001006000000.2
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
HART, MARIA
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 36
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1546 N US HIGHWAY 1
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 PART OF TRACT A AS
FOLL: BEG AT - NW COR
OF LOT 5 BLK 6
RUN N 93.20 FT TO NW COR OF TRACT A
TH SELY ALONG N BDY 0
, F TRACT A TO PT DUE N OF NE COR OF LOT 5 ; TH S TO NE
COR OF LOT 5; W
50 FT TO PO B
Revision Date
Site Address
710 JACKSON ST
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RES0LUTI0N 1_2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P252
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30383000001006000000.1
Assessment= $9,978.24
Owner
HART, MARIA
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 37
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1546 N US HIGHWAY 1
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 BLK 6 LOTS 1, 2, 3, 4 &
TRACT A LESS THAT
DESC POR CONVEYED IN D BK 72 PG 351 BLK 6 & INCA POR OF
LOT 1 TOWN OF WAUR
EGAN IN PBS 6-32 BEING MORE PART DESC AS
COM AT CAPPED 4 INCH IRON PIPE LA
BELED AS PRM ON SAID PLAT OF 0
Revision Date
Site Address
708 JACKSON ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383000001001000001.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
HALL, JERRY S AND MARSHA G
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 38
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
7711 ROSELAND RD
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
OCEAN BREEZE HEIGHTS SUB PBI 2-7 LOTS 1-2 & 3 BLK 1 AS
PREV CONV - EYED I
N R BK 227 PP 440; TOG W TOWN OF WAUREGAN PBS 1-179
PART OF GRANT SEC 30 ,
AS IN R BK 227 PP 41 & ALSO INC ALL OF A - BND ALLEY PER
CITY OF SEB RES #
R -01-51D ESC IN OR BK 1417 PP
Revision Date
Site Address
698 JACKSON ST
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001000000025.1
Assessment= $9,978.24
Owner
CITY OF SEBASTIAN
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 42
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1225 MAIN ST
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178-179 PART OF LOT 25;
LYING E OF - US NO 1 DESC
AS FOLL; BEG ON NELY FLEMI NG GRANT LINE IN SEC 30 AT A
CONCRETE MO, NUME
NT MARKING BDRY BETWEEN LOTS 25 & 26 -
TH SWLY ALONG SAID BDRY BETWEEN SA
ID L OTS 322.38 FT TO ELY R/W
Revision Date
Site Address
12900 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOdAssessments 2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION_1_2_NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P253
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
00.0'11R
Parcel #
30382100001000000025.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
FOUNTAIN TOWERS LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 43
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
12920 US HIGHWAY I
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN PBB 1-178&179 THE NWLY 116.97 FT
OF LOT - 25 LYING NELY
OF US HW 1 (OR BK 457 PP 186)
Revision Date
Site Address
12920 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001000000024.0
Assessment=
$14,967.36
Owner
RIZWI LL
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 44
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
8540 SEACREST DR
Number ERU's: 3
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBS 1-178 PART OF LOT 24 LYING E
OF USN - 01 DESC AS
FOLL: FR A PT ON THE NELY FG LINE IN SEC 30 AT A CONCRETE
MON MARKIN, G BD
RY BETWEEN LOT 25 & 26
TH SELY ALON - G SAID BDRY 322.38 FT TO ELY R/W OF
US N 0 1
TH NWLY ALONG R/W OF
Revision Date
Site Address
12950 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382 1'00001000000023,0
Assessment=
$29,934.72
Owner
FAMILY CAR WASH CO INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 46
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
101 INNER HARBOUR WAY
Number ERU's: 6
JUPITER FL 33477
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-75 AND RE -FILED IN PBS 1-178
THE P - OB BEING THE
PT OF INT FORMED BY THE ELY R/W OF US HIGHWAY 41 WITH
THE NLY BDY L, INE
OF LOT 23 FROM SAID POS PROCEED NELY - ALONG THE NLY
BDY OF LOT 23 A DIST 0
F 2 07.03 FT TO THE INTERSECTI
Revision Date
Site Address
13020 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Uti1ities\UT1L1TY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments-2017_Proposed\06—NorthCountySeptic_to.sewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_1_2_NorthCoun
tySeptic—SewerAssessmentProject.docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P254
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001000000022.0
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
PTS OF BREVARD COUNTY INC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 47
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1430 S PINE ST
Number ERU's: 2
MELBOURNE FL 32901
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 & 179 ALL OF LOT 22
LYING EOFUSHWYI&WO
F FLEMING GRANT LINE AS I N OR BK 555 PG 1886
LESS PORT DESC AS F OLL: COM
AT INTERSECTION WITH SLY LINE LOT 22 & ELY R/W US HWY
#1 & RUN N 36 DEG 38
MIN 55 SEC W 166.59 FT FT TO
Revision Date
Site Address
13050 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001000000021.1
Assessment=
$14,967.36
Owner
SEBASTIAN PARTNERS LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 49
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
C/O WILLIAM NEUHAUS
Number ERU's: 3
PALM CITY FL 34990
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 & 179 THAT PART OF LOT
21 LYIN - G E OF PRESE
NT HIGHWAY #1
Revision Date
Site Address
13070 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382100001000000020.2
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
ZAIDI, SYED IRFAN H (COTRS) AND MUNAWAR
SULTANA (COTRS)
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 50
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
209 AREGA ST
Number ERU's: 2
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 & 179 THAT PART OF LOT
20; E 0 - F PRESENT US
HW #1
Revision Date
Site Address
13090 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\Word Documents\OS PreliminaryAssessmentRoll RESOLUTION_3 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P255
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382100001000000019.0
Assessment= $14,967.36
Owner
SHALHOUB, HALA
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 51
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1302 RIVER REACH DR
Number ERU's: 3
VERO BEACH FL 32967
Legal
TOWN OF WAUREGAN , PBB 1-178 & 179 THAT PART OF LOT
19 LYIN - G E OF PRESE
NT US HWY #1 & ALSO INC LOT 18 OF INDIAN RIVER TWIN
ESTATES ;JEANS U, NIT
PBI 8-31
Revision Date
Site Address
13100 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30383600004001000001.0
Assessment= $4,989.12
Owner
GERISEB PL
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 52
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1515 US HIGHWAY 1 STE 204
Number ERU's: 1
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
INDIAN RIVER TWIN ESTATES SUB PBI 8-31 LOT 1 JEANS UNIT
& TOWN OF WAUR -
EGAN PBS 1-178 & 179 LOT 18 LYING W OF F LEMING GRANT
LINE & E OF US HWY #1
Revision Date
Site Address
13230 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500000004100002.0
Assessment= $374,184.00
Owner
ROYAL PALM CORPORATE CENTER AS SOCIATES
LTD
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 54
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
101 PINEAPPLE GROVE WAY
Number ERU's: 75
DELRAY BEACH FL 33444
Legal
ALL THAT PART OF FOLL DESC LAND LYING E - OF US HWY 1
BEG AT SE COR OF INL
ET VIE SUB AS PER PLAT THEREOF; THENCE RUNS 74, DEG 07
MIN W ALONG SOUTH
ERN BDRY OF SAI - SUB & ACROSS R/W OF OLD D/H A DIST OF
656.34 FT
MORE OR
LESS; TO W R/W LINE , OF OLD
Revision Date
Site Address
13350 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessme nts_2017_Propos ed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\Word Docu ments\01_Preli minaryAssessmentRol I_R E S0LUTI0N_1_2_NorthCou n
tyS a ptic_Sewe rAssess me nt P roj ect. doc x
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P256
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
•n1
Parcel #
30382500000005000005.0
Assessment=
$99,782.40
Owner
SWEET FEELINGS LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID : 55
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1840 BAYVIEW CT
Number ERU's: 20
VERO BEACH FL 32963
Legal
BEG AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE S BDRY LI - NE OF VAN
BERGEN & HENDRYS ADD T
0 ROSELA ND; ACCORDING TO PLAT THEREOF IN PBI 3-3, 9,
WITH THE E BDRY LINE
OF STRD5
SEC - 8801/207 110 ACCORDING TO SURVEY THEREO F
RECORDED IN PL
AT BK 4 PP 63; TH RUN N , 41
Revision Date
Site Address
13480 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500000002000003.3
Assessment=
$109,760.64
Owner
JUNO ROAD REALTY LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 56
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
910 GILPIN AVE
Number ERU's: 22
WILMINGTON DE 19806
Legal
FOR A PT OF COMMENCE BEGIN AT INTERSECTI - ON OF THE
SLY R/W LINE OF BAY ST
(A/K/A 110TH ST) & TH ELY R/W LINE OF US, 1 (ST RD #5); TH
RUN S15DEG 1
5 MIN 59 - SEC E ALONG SAID R/W LINE OF US #1 A DIST OF
965.66 FT TO THE PO
B; THENCE RUN, N 43 DEG 36 MI
Revision Date
Site Address
13700 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500000002000003.2
Assessment=
$9,978.24
Owner
NATIONAL RETAIL PROPERTIES LP
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 57
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
450 S ORANGE AVE STE 900
Number ERU's: 2
ORLANDO FL 32801
Legal
A POR OF LAND LYING IN SEC 25 TWP 30 S R - GE 38 E BEING
MORE PART DESC AS
FOLL; FO R A PT OF COM BEGIN AT THE INT OF THE SL, Y R/W
LINE OF BAY ST (A
/K/A 110TH ST) & - THE ELY R/W LINE OF US HWY NO ONE (SR
NO 5)
THRUN S15
DEG 15 MIN 59 SEC E ALO, NG
Revision Date
Site Address
13800 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessments_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCountySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\WordDocuments\01_PreliminaryAssessmentRoll_RESOLUTION_1 2 NorthCoun
tySeptic_SewerAssessmentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P257
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY — DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
NORTH COUNTY SEPTIC TO SEWER PROPOSED SEWER ASSESSMENT
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL — RESOLUTION 1
Parcel #
30382500000002000003.1
Assessment= $19,956.48
Owner
BAY STREET SEBASTIAN LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 59
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
1579 ESTUARY TRAIL
Number ERU's: 4
DELRAY BEACH FL 33483
Legal
ALL THAT PART OF LOTS 2-3 & 4 LYING ELY - OF US HWY 1
MORE PART DESC AS FOL
L; COM AT A PT ON W BDY OF GOV LOT 2 & 617.80 , FT N OF
SW COR THEREOF; TH
N 35 DEG 10 - MIN 00 SEC E 778.47 FT
TH S 34 DEG 23 MIN 42 SEC E 37.35 FT
TO POB; TH CONT , S 34 DEG 2
Revision Date
Site Address
14000 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
Parcel #
30382500000002000002.1
Assessment= $19,956.48
Owner
CLARITY MEDICAL PROPERTIES LLC
Secondary Owners
Map ID: 61
Secondary Owners
Mailing Address
14410 US HIGHWAY 1
Number ERU's: 4
SEBASTIAN FL 32958
Legal
COM AT SE COR OF GOV LOT 1 SEC 25-30-38
- TH N ALONG E LINE OF GOV LOT 1
617.80 FT, TH N 35 DEG 10 MIN 00 SEC E 678.12 , FT TO INTER
PT OF ELY R/W
LINE OF US 1 & - NLY R/W LINE OF OLD ROSELAND RD, A/K/A
BAY ST; TH N 15 DEG
21 MIN 20 SEC W 445 , FT TO
Revision Date
.Site Address
14410 US HIGHWAY 1
6/7/2017
F:\Utilities\UTILITY - Engineering\Projects - Assessment
Projects\OOOAssessme nts_2017_Proposed\06_NorthCou ntySeptic_to_SewerAssessmentProject_61_Parcels\W ordDocu ments\01_Prel i mi naryAssess mentRol I_R ESOLUTION_1_2_NorthCou n
tySeptic_SewerAssess mentProject. docx
Wednesday, June 14, 2017
P258
110
2 yG
AA13
142ND
ST--,,/
141E ST -ST -
=140TH -ST
T STJ
F-: I-- - - - = - —i
°J = 140TH ST
s
NORTH SEBASTIAN SEPTIC TO SEWER
PHASE 1
59 ��Q /LSA
#7!38
36 o��� / 35
57 \ / 323 �L
30 31
L56)Ski \ \ 28 25 /
24
O :y3
�Q� > 6 2722
its
P 16)
�' 9�
IN
�F�92
UNINCORPORATED - IRC \ \
\ \T
�2
�l\�-
15,
S
9T�d' / �i
S
OZ
>c),
\his
'132ND_
131
o�
130TH.S
129TH L
ST CITY OF SEBASTIAN
0
A TACHMENT 5
ST
is
,J2
CITY OF SEBASTIAN I
CITY LIMITS
L
G
O�
Date: 6/14/2017
P259
/3A
County Attorneys Matters -B.C.C. 6.20.17
Office of
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney( Pc
DATE: June 12, 2017
ATTORNEY
SUBJECT: A Resolution Directing Staff to Work With the Members of the Treasure Coast Council of
Local Governments to Promote and Defend Home Rule Authority
BACKGROUND: In 1968, Florida voters amended the Constitution of the State of Florida to confer
broad home rule powers to counties and municipalities. Pursuant to the Constitution and Section 125.01,
Florida Statutes, Indian River County is authorized to pass local ordinances and exercise all powers not
specifically prohibited by law. This power is commonly referred to as home rule, and it is essential for the
Board of County Commissioner for Indian River County ("Board") to be able to establish local rules and
regulations that are in the best interest for the residents.
During Florida's 2017 legislative session, there were a significant number of bills filed that threatened to
preempt the home rule authority of local governments. While most of the referenced bills were
unsuccessful, we should anticipate future legislation that proposes to curtail, restrict and/or preempt the
Board's home rule authority.
This Board has expressed a desire to work with our sister communities along the Treasure Coast to form a
coalition to defend its home rule authority. Staff recommends this Board adopt the attached resolution and
authorize Indian River County staff to work with the members of the Treasure Coast Council of Local
Governments ("TCCLG"), a voluntary council created pursuant to Section 163.02, Florida Statutes, to
support and defend the home rule authority of local governments.
FUNDING:
There is -no funding associated with this item.
RECOMMENDATION:
The County Attorney's Office recommends that the Board of County Commissioners adopt the attached
resolution to direct staff to work with the members of the TCCLG to promote and defend the home rule
authority of local governments.
Attached: Proposed Resolution
P260
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DIRECTING
STAFF TO WORK WITH THE MEMBERS OF THE
TREASURE COAST COUNCIL OF LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS TO PROMOTE AND DEFEND HOME
RULE AUTHORITY; AND DIRECTING CERTIFIED
COPIES OF THIS RESOLUTION TO BE PROVIDED TO
VARIOUS OFFICIALS.
WHEREAS, in 1968, Florida voters amended the Constitution of the State of Florida to
confer broad powers to counties and municipalities; and
WHEREAS, Indian River County is a non -charter county that is authorized under the
Constitution of the State of Florida and pursuant to Section 125.0 1, Florida Statutes, to pass local
ordinances and exercise all powers not specifically prohibited by law, otherwise known as "Home
Rule"; and
WHEREAS, local governments are instrumental in improving the quality of life of their
citizens and use Home Rule authority to provide vital public services such as parks and recreation,
water, sewer, streets and public rights-of-way, drainage and storm water management, and police
and fire protection that are used and counted on by citizens, businesses and visitors every day; and
WHEREAS, Home Rule powers, both administrative and fiscal, allow local governments
to develop and implement community-based solutions to local problems without state interference;
and
WHEREAS, there were a significant number of legislative bills filed during the 2017 State
of Florida legislative session that proposed to preempt the Home Rule authority of local
governments thereby inhibiting the ability of local governments to respond to matters of local
importance; and
WHEREAS, Indian River County anticipates future legislative attempts to curtail, restrict
and/or preempt it from using its Home Rule authority; and
WHEREAS, it is imperative and critical that decisions and legislation regarding local
government services be left to the form of government closest to the citizens; and
WHEREAS, Indian River County is a member of the Treasure Coast Council of Local
Governments ("TCCLG") which was established in 1987 and incorporated in 2003 as a voluntary
council pursuant to Section 163.02, Florida Statutes, for the purpose of studying and addressing
area governmental problems as the TCCLG deems appropriate; and
WHEREAS, Indian River County believes working together with the members of the
TCCLG to support and promote its Home Rule authority is in the best interest of the County's
residents, businesses and visitors.
a0l
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS THAT:
Section 1. The above "WHEREAS: clauses are true and correct, and hereby adopted as
findings of this Board.
Section 2. The Board of Commissioners direct staff to work with the members of the
TCCLG to promote and defend the integrity of the Home Rule power of local governments.
Section 3. A certified copy of this resolution shall be provided to the TCCLG, Senator
Mayfield and Representative Grail.
Section 4. This resolution shall take effect on adoption.
The foregoing resolution was moved for adoption by , and seconded by
Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
Vice -Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Bob Solari
Commissioner Tim Zorc
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day of
.2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By,
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk
of Court and Comptroller
By:
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
By:
Kate Pingolt Cotner
Assistant County Attorney
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
2
P262
J3,8
County Attorney's Matters - B. C.C. 6.20.17 ir-
Ofice of
INDLAN RIVER COUNTY
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K DeBraaL Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County, Atto
DATE: June 12, 2017
ATTORNEY
SUBJECT: A Resolution Authorizing Participation in a Joint Meeting With The Board of County
Commissioners for St. Lucie County and The Board of County Commissioners for Martin
County to Discuss Joint Legislative Priorities.
BACKGROUND: The Board of County Commissioners for St. Lucie County and the Board of County
Commissioners for Martin County have expressed a desire to hold a joint board meeting with the Board of
County. Commissioners of Indian River County CBoard) to discuss joint legislative priorities in
anticipation of the State of Florida's 2018 legislative session.
In accordance with Section 125.001, Florida Statutes, the Board is permitted to participate in a joint
mecting with the governing bodies of one or more adjacent counties or municipalities to discuss matters
regarding land development, economic development, or any other matters of mutual interest. To do so, all
three referenced boards are required-, to: (1) adopt a resolution. authorizing the participation -in the joint
meeting; (2) publically notice the meeting within its jurisdiction; (3) and hold the meeting in an
appropriate public place. Pursuant to Section 125.001(2)(b), Florida Statutes, no official vote can be taken
at the meeting.
FUNDING:,
There is no funding associated with this item.
RECOMMENDATION: The County Attorney's Office recommends that the Board adopt the attached
resolution to hold a joint meeting with the Board of County Commissioners for St. Lucie County and the
Board of County Commissioners for Martin County to discuss joint legislative priorities in anticipation of
the State of Florida's 2018 legislative session. .
Attached: Proposed Resolution
RESOLUTION NO. 2017-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS FOR INDIAN RIVER COUNTY TO
PARTICIPATE IN A JOINT MEETING WITH THE ST.
LUCIE COUNTY COMMISSION AND MARTIN COUNTY
COMMISSION TO DISCUSS AND PLAN MATTERS OF
MUTUAL INTEREST; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners for Indian River County desires to
participate in a joint meeting with the Board of County Commissioners for St. Lucie County and
the Board of County Commissioners for Martin County to discuss legislative priorities that we
share prior to the State of Florida's 2018 legislative session; and
WHEREAS, Section 125.001, Florida Statutes, authorizes county boards to meet and
discuss matters of mutual interest with one or more adjacent counties or municipalities; and
WHEREAS, Section 125.001, Florida Statutes, further states that such meetings may be
held at any appropriate public place within the jurisdiction of any participating county or
municipality, and requires that due public notice be provided within the jurisdiction of all
participating municipalities and counties; and
WHEREAS, Section 125.001, Florida Statutes, further requires that the governing body
of a county or municipality must first adopt a resolution authorizing participation in the joint
meeting,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS THAT:
Section 1. The above "WHEREAS: clauses are true and correct, and hereby adopted as
findings of this Board.
Section 2. Pursuant to Section 125.001, Florida Statutes, the Board of County
Commissioners is hereby authorized to participate in a joint meeting with the St. Lucie County
Commissioners and Martin County Commissioners on a date that will be properly noticed within
the jurisdiction of all participating counties.
taken.
Section 3. Notice of this meeting shall be duly advertised and official minutes shall be
Section 4. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
The foregoing resolution was moved for adoption by , and seconded by
Commissioner , and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Chairman Joseph E. Flescher
P264
RESOLUTION NO. 2017 -
Vice -Chairman Peter D. O'Bryan
Commissioner Susan Adams
Commissioner Bob Solari
Commissioner Tim Zorc .
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this day of
, 2017.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith, Clerk
of Court and Comptroller
By:
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
By.
Kate Pingolt Cotner
Assistant County Attomey
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
P265
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
Wffiarn K DeBraaL Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
18C
Attorney's Matters - B. CC 6.2 0.17
Office Of
INDLkN RIVER COUNTY
I 13 I �,- - j�U
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorne
DATE: June 13, 2017
SUBJECT: 2017- Special Session A
ATTORNEY
BACKGROUND: The State of Florida's 2017 Special Session A was held from June 7, 2017, to June 9,
2017. During this time, the State Legislature passed legislation relating to medical marijuana, funding
towards repairing Lake Okeechobee's Herbert Hoover Dike, increased funding for higher education, state
funding for Visit Florida, the creation of the Florida Job Growth Grant Fund within the Department of
Economic Opportunity.
P266
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County .Attorney
WE
County Attorney's Matters - B.C.C. 6.20.17
Office 0, f
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
DATE: June 14, 2017
ATTORNEY
SUBJECT: Florida Department of Environmental Protection Domestic Wastewater Facility Permit for
Sunbreak Farms
BACKGROUND.
On May 11, 2017, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (the "Department") issued the
attached Notice of Intent to Issue Permit for a Domestic Wastewater Facility Permit for Sunbreak Farms,
LLC located in Indian River County and St. Lucie County. Indian River County (the "County") had until
Monday, June 12, 2017, to file a petition for administrative hearing. On May 31, 2017, County staff met
with representatives from Sunbreak Farms, LLC to discuss the proposed facility. On June 9, 2017, Stan
Boling, County Community Development Director, sent a letter to Sunbreak Farms, LLC requesting
confirmation concerning a number of issues pertaining to the proposed facility. The letter is attached.
County staff did not file a petition for administrative hearing, but instead submitted the attached letter to
the Department raising various concerns with the proposed facility. St. Lucie County did file a petition
for administrative hearing, which is also attached. It is my understanding that St. Lucie County has
requested that the matter not be immediately forwarded to the Division of Administrative Hearings, in
order to allow time for St. Lucie County staff to work with Sunbreak Farms, LLC to resolve outstanding
issues. Jill Grimaldi with CDM Smith has prepared the attached memorandum raising various issues
concerning the application for the Domestic Wastewater Facility Permit for Sunbreak Farms, LLC.
I would like to seek guidance from the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners (the
"Board") as to whether the Board would like to intervene in the St. Lucie County petition. I have reached
out to counsel for St. Lucie County who has expressed that there is no objection to Indian River County
intervening in the matter.
FUNDING.
Funding for any costs of intervening will be provided by a budget amendment from General Fund/Reserve
for Contingency to General Fund/County Attorney/Legal Services (00110214-033110).
F:Idlmrny1D.d.1GENFJLCUB CCW&e daA,—%FDEP,9i-1;d. Pw—itd.
Board of County Commissioners
June 14, 2017
Page Two
RECOMMENDATION.
The County Attorney's Office recommends that the Chair allow for public comment on this matter and
then have the Board vote whether to authorize the County Attorney's Office to move to intervene in the
St. Lucie County petition.
ATTACHMENT(S).
Notice of Intent to Issue Permit
Letter from Stan Boling to Toby Overdorf, dated June 9, 2017
Letter from Jason Brown to Florida Department of Environmental Protection, dated June 12, 2017
St. Lucie County Petition for Administrative Hearings
Memorandum from Jill Grimaldi, to Katherine Barbieri, dated May 16, 2017
F.*1Att—y U.h1GEARAL18 C CWW dnM .."FPB1M0d1 P—t.dx
P268
0
-'enter 4. -
May 11, 2017
In the Matter of an
Application for Permit by:
Sunbreak Farms, LLC
Patrick B Cheney
5101 Minute Maid Rd
Fort Pierce, Florida 34945-4351
Email: pbcheney@colvin-co.coin
Florida Department of
Environmental Protection
Southeast District Office
3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1
West Palm Beach, FL 33406
561-681-6600
File Number FLA979830-001-DW 1 S
St. Lucie and Indian River Counties
Sunbreak Farms Compost Facility
INTENT TO ISSUE
Rick Scott
Governor
Carlos Lopez-Cantera
Lt. Governor
Ryan E. Matthews
Interim Secretary
The Department of Environmental Protection gives notice of its intent to issue a permit (copy of conditions attached)
for the proposed project as detailed in the application specified above, for the reasons stated below.
The applicant, Sunbreak Farms, LLC, applied on March 14, 2017, to the Department of Environmental Protection
for a permit to construct and operate a Type I Biosolids Management Facility with a permitted Class AA compost
production of 500 dry tons per day. The facility will be located at Latitude: 27' 13 ' 28.05" North Longitude: 800
32' 50.96 West on 5101 Minute Maid Road, Fort Pierce, Florida 34945 in St. Lucie and Indian River Counties.
The Department has permitting jurisdiction under Chapter 403, Florida Statutes, and applicable rules of the Florida
Administrative Code. The project is not exempt from permitting procedures. The Department has determined that a
wastewater permit is required for the proposed work.
Based upon the application and supplemental information, the Department has determined that the applicant has
provided reasonable assurance that the above described wastewater project complies with the applicable provisions
of Chapter 403 of the Florida Statutes and Title 62 of the Florida Administrative Code.
Under Section 403.815, Florida Statutes, and Rule 62-110.106, Florida Administrative Code, you (the applicant) are
required to publish at your own expense the enclosed Notice of Intent to Issue Permit. The notice must be published
one time only within 30 days of receipt of this intent to issue in the legal ad section of a newspaper of general
circulation in the area affected. For the purpose of this rule, "publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the
area affected" means publication in a newspaper meeting the requirements of Sections 50.011 and 50.031, Florida
Statutes, in the county where the activity is to take place. Where there is more than one newspaper. of general
circulation in the county, the newspaper used should be one with significant circulation in the area that may be
affected by the permit. If you are uncertain that a newspaper meets these requirements, please contact the
Department at the address or telephone number listed below. The applicant must provide proof of publication to the
Department's Southeast District Office, 3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1, West Palm Beach, Florida 33406-3007,
within two weeks of publication. Failure to publish the notice and provide proof of publication within the allotted
time may result in the denial of the permit under Rule 62-110.106(11), Florida Administrative Code.
The Department will issue the permit with the attached conditions unless a timely petition for an administrative
hearing is filed under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes, within fourteen days of receipt of notice. The
procedures for petitioning for a hearing are set forth below.
P269
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's proposed permitting decision may petition for
an administrative proceeding (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57; Florida Statutes. The petition must
contain the information set forth below and must be filed (received by the Clerk) in the Office of General Counsel of
the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000.
Under Rule 62-110.106(4), Florida Administrative Code, a person may request an extension of the time for filing a
petition for an administrative hearing. The request must be filed (received by the Clerk) in the Office of General
Counsel before the end of the time period for filing a petition for an administrative hearing.
Petitions by the applicant or any of the persons listed below must be filed within fourteen days of receipt of this
written notice. Petitions filed by any persons other than those entitled to written notice under Section 120.60(3),
Florida Statutes, must be filed within fourteen days of publication of the notice or within fourteen days of receipt of
the written notice, whichever occurs first. Section 120.60(3), Florida Statutes, however, also allows that any person
who has asked the Department in writing for notice of agency action may file a petition within fourteen days of
receipt of such notice, regardless of the date of publication.
The petitioner shall mail a copy of the petition to the applicant at the address indicated above at the time of filing.
The failure of any person to file a petition or request for an extension of time within fourteen days of receipt of
notice shall constitute a waiver of that person's right to request an administrative determination (hearing) under
Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes. Any subsequent intervention (in a proceeding initiated by another
party) will be only at the discretion of the presiding officer upon the filing of a motion in compliance with Rule 28-
106.205, Florida Administrative Code.
A petition that disputes the material facts on which the Department's action is based must contain the following
information, as indicated in Rule 28-106.201, Florida Administrative Code:
(a) The name and address of each agency affected and each agency's file or identification number, if known;
(b) The name, address, any e-mail address, any facsimile number, and telephone number of the petitioner, if
the petitioner is not represented by an attorney or a qualified representative; the name, address, and
telephone number of the petitioner's representative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes
during the course of the proceeding; and an explanation of how the petitioner's substantial interests will be
affected by the determination;
(c) A statement of when and how the petitioner received notice of the Department's decision;
(d) A statement of all disputed issues of material fact. If there are none, the petition must so indicate;
(e) A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts the petitioner contends
warrant reversal or modification of the Department's proposed action;
(f) A statement of the specific rules or statutes the petitioner contends require reversal or modification of the
Department's proposed action, including an explanation of how the alleged facts relate to the specific rules
or statutes; and
(g) A statement of the relief sought by the petitioner, stating precisely the action petitioner wishes the
Department to take with respect to the Department's proposed action.
Because the administrative hearing process is designed to formulate final agency action, the filing of a petition
means that the Department's final action may be different from the position taken by it in this notice. Persons whose
substantial interests will be affected by any such final decision of the Department have the right to petition to
become a party to the proceeding, in accordance with the requirements set forth above.
Mediation under Section 120.573, Florida Statutes, is not available for this proceeding.
P270
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC.
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
Executed in West Palm Beach, Florida.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONME PROTECTION
Mgy 11 2017
Diane Pupa Date
Program Administrator
Permitting and Waste Cleanup
Southeast District
FILING AND ACKNOWLEDGMENT
PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FILED, on this date, under Section 120.52, Florida Statutes, with the designated Deputy Clerk, receipt of which is
hereby acknowledged.
[Clerk]
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
May 11, 2017
Date]
The undersigned hereby certifies that this INTENT TO ISSUE and all copies were mailed before the close of
business on May 11, 2017, to the listed persons.
Enclosure
Certified copies furnished to:
Jeff Christian, DEP/SED, Jeff.Christianna.dep.state.fl.us
Michael Bechtold, DEP/SED, Mike.Bechtoldnaden.state.fl.us
Maurice Barker, DEP/TLH, Maurice.BarkerMdep.state.fl.us
Denise Watts, DEP/WPB, Denise.Watts@—dgp.state.fl.us
Bruce Kay, DEP/WPB, Bruce.KayQdeD.state.fl.us
Tyler Bruch, Kip Cullers, tyler kipcullers.com
Toby Overdorf, Engineering and Design Construction, Inc., tobyoverdorf@edc-inc.com
David C. Baggett, P.E., Engineering and Design Construction, Inc., davudbaggeft@ede-inc.com
Gary R. Priest P.E., South Florida Water Management District, gpriest@sfwmd.gov
Raulie Raulerson, Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services,
Raulie.Raulerson@freshfromflonda.com
P271
May 11, 2017
Name
Date
Enclosure
Certified copies furnished to:
Jeff Christian, DEP/SED, Jeff.Christianna.dep.state.fl.us
Michael Bechtold, DEP/SED, Mike.Bechtoldnaden.state.fl.us
Maurice Barker, DEP/TLH, Maurice.BarkerMdep.state.fl.us
Denise Watts, DEP/WPB, Denise.Watts@—dgp.state.fl.us
Bruce Kay, DEP/WPB, Bruce.KayQdeD.state.fl.us
Tyler Bruch, Kip Cullers, tyler kipcullers.com
Toby Overdorf, Engineering and Design Construction, Inc., tobyoverdorf@edc-inc.com
David C. Baggett, P.E., Engineering and Design Construction, Inc., davudbaggeft@ede-inc.com
Gary R. Priest P.E., South Florida Water Management District, gpriest@sfwmd.gov
Raulie Raulerson, Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services,
Raulie.Raulerson@freshfromflonda.com
P271
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT
FLA979830-001-DW 1 S
The Department of Environmental Protection gives notice of its intent to issue a permit to Sunbreak Farms, LLC,
5101 Minute Maid Rd, Fort Pierce, Florida 34945 to construct and operate an 80,000 Dry Tons/year Type I domestic
biosolids treatment facility which would compost biosolids that adds yard/green and
agricultural wastes as a bulking agent to biosolids. The process consists of an accelerated aerated static pile
composting methodology to produce Class AA Biosolids. The facility will be located at Latitude: 27° 13 '28.05"
North Longitude: 80° 32' 50.96 West on 5101 Minute Maid Road, Fort Pierce, Florida 34945 in St. Lucie and
Indian River Counties.
The Department has assigned permit file number FLA979830 to the proposed project.
The permit application file and supporting documentation is available electronically at the following link:
hMs://dgpedms.dgp.state.fl.us/Oculus/servlet/hitlist?action=hitlist&searchResuItParam=from SearchResu]tPage
The intent to issue and application file are also available for public inspection during normal business hours, 8:00
a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday; except legal holidays, at the Department's Southeast District Office, 3301
Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1, West Palm Beach, Florida 33406-3007, at phone number (561)681-6600.
The Department will issue the permit with the attached conditions unless a timely petition for an administrative
hearing is filed under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes, within fourteen days of publication of notice.
The procedures for petitioning for a hearing are set forth below.
A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's proposed permitting decision may petition for
an administrative proceeding (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes. The petition must
contain the information set forth below and must be filed (received by the Clerk) in the Office of General Counsel of
the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000.
Under Rule 62-110.106(4), Florida Administrative Code, a person may request an extension of the time for filing a
petition for an administrative hearing. The request must be filed (received by the Clerk) in the Office of General
Counsel before the end of the time period for filing a petition for an administrative hearing.
Petitions filed by any persons other than those entitled to written notice under Section 120.60(3), Florida Statutes,
must be filed within fourteen days of publication of the notice or within fourteen days of receipt of the written
notice, whichever occurs first. Section 120.60(3), Florida Statutes, however, also allows that any person who has
asked the Department in writing for notice of agency action may file a petition within fourteen days of receipt of
such notice, regardless of the date of publication.
The petitioner shall mail a copy of the petition to the applicant at the address indicated above at the time of filing.
The failure of any person to file a petition or request for an extension of time within fourteen days of receipt of
notice shall constitute a waiver of that person's right to request an administrative determination (hearing) under
Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes. Any subsequent intervention (in a proceeding initiated by another
party) will be only at the discretion of the presiding officer upon the filing of a motion in compliance with Rule 28-
106.205, Florida Administrative Code. _
A petition that disputes the material facts on which the Department's action is based must contain the following
information, as indicated in Rule 28-106.201, Florida Administrative Code:
(a) The name and address of each agency affected and each agency's file or identification number, if known;
(b) The name, address, any e-mail address, any facsimile number, and telephone number of the petitioner, if
the petitioner is not represented by an attorney or a qualified representative; the name, address, and
telephone number of the petitioner's representative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes
during the course of the proceeding; and an explanation of how the petitioner's substantial interests will be
affected by the determination;
(c) A statement of when and how the petitioner received notice of the Department's decision;
(d) A statement of all disputed issues of material fact. If there are none, the petition must so indicate;
P272
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
(e) A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts the petitioner contends
warrant reversal or modification of the Department's proposed action;
(f) A statement of the specific rules or statutes the petitioner contends require reversal or modification of the
Department's proposed action, including an explanation of how the alleged facts relate to the specific rules
or statutes; and
(g) A statement of the relief sought by the petitioner, stating precisely the action petitioner wishes the
Department to take with respect to the Department's proposed action.
Because the administrative hearing process is designed to formulate final agency action, the filing of a petition
means that the Department's final action may be different from the position taken by it in this notice. Persons whose
substantial interests will be affected by any such final decision of the Department have the right to petition to
become a party to the proceeding, in accordance with the requirements set forth above.
Mediation under Section 120.573, Florida Statutes, is not available for this proceeding
P273
E
L
'\ental
Florida Department of
Environmental Protection
Southeast District Office
3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1
West Palm Beach, FL 33406
561-681-6600
Rick Scott
Governor
Carlos Lopez-Cantera
Lt. Governor
STATE OF FLORIDA
DOMESTIC WASTEWATER FACILITY PERMIT
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
Authorized Representative:
Patrick B Cheney FILE NUMBER: FLA979830-001-DWIS
5101 Minute Maid Rd EFFECTIVE DATE: DRAFT
Fort Pierce, Florida 349454351 EXPIRATION DATE: DRAFT
Email: pbcheney@colvin-co.com
FACILITY:
Sunbreak Farms, LLC
5101 Minute Maid Road
Fort Pierce, FL 34945
St. Lucie and Indian River Counties
Latitude: 27° 13'28.05"N Longitude: 80° 32'50.96 W
Ryan E. Matthews
Interim Secretary
This permit is issued under the provisions of Chapter 403, Florida Statutes (F.S.), and applicable rules of the Florida
Administrative Code (F.A.C.). This permit does not constitute authorization to discharge wastewater other than as
expressly stated in this permit. The above-named permittee is hereby authorized to construct and operate the
facilities in accordance with the documents attached hereto and specifically described as follows:
BIOSOLIDS TREATMENT FACILITY:
A new, Type I Biosolids Management Facility with a permitted Class AA compost production of 500 dry tons per
day. Sunbreak Farms will utilize the Modified Static Aerated Pile (MSAP) method to achieve the required compost
treatment of biosolids as approved by EPA. The MSAP method has been approved as a method modification by
EPA Region 9 (July 1, 2003), granted an equivalency determination as an alternative PFRP. Biosolids will be
blended at the facility with bulking agents that primarily consist of chipped yard trash debris and other green waste
and mixed at a ratio of 3 -to -1 (green waste to biosolids). They may include other organic wastes like chicken.and
other animal wastes mixed with the biosolids. Composting of these other wastes without mixing with biosolids can
be under a solid waste compost permit at the option of the Permittee. Prior to placing blended biosolids in the
management area a 50:50 blend of ground yard trash and screened compost from screening during post -processing,
shall be used to create a 12 -inch base layer upon which active composting will be placed. The blended biosolids
will be placed into windrows constructed to dimensions that are approximately 16 feet wide and 8 feet tall. Once
each windrow or windrow section is complete Sunbreak Farms staff shall apply a 12 -inch layer of bulking agent.
Pathogen reduction standards for Class AA compost will be achieved by maintaining a minimum temperature of
131degrees F (55 degrees C) in each windrow for a minimum period of 15 consecutive days. Vector attraction
P274
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER-- FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
reduction of Class AA compost will be achieved by maintaining aerobic composting with a temperature greater than
40 degrees C for 14 days or longer after the Pathogens period of 15 days. Once Sunbreak Farms has confirmed the
compost product meets all permitted criteria for a Class AA fertilizer it will be distributed and marketed as fertilizer
with a Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FRAC) issued fertilizer license.
IN ACCORDANCE WITH: The limitations, monitoring requirements, and other conditions set forth in this cover
sheet and Part I through Part IX on pages 1 through 14 of this permit.
REPORTING AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS
A. Limitations and Monitoring and Reporting Requirement
I . The permittee shall provide safe access points for obtaining representative samples which are required
by this permit. [62-600.650(2)]
2. Monitoring requirements under this permit are effective on the first day of the second month following
the effective date of the permit. Until such time, the permittee shall continue to monitor and report in
accordance with previously effective permit requirements, if any. During the period of operation
authorized by this permit, the permittee shall complete and submit to the Department Discharge
Monitoring Reports (DMRs) in accordance with the frequencies specified by the REPORT type (i.e.
monthly,.quarterly, semiannual, annual, etc.) indicated on the DMR forms attached to this permit.
Unless specified otherwise in this permit, monitoring results for each monitoring period shall be
submitted in accordance with the associated DMR due dates below. DMRs shall be submitted for each
required monitoring period including periods of no discharge.
REPORT Type on DMR
Monitoring Period
Submit by
Monthly
first day of month - last day of month
28'x' day of following month
Quarterly
January 1 - March 31
April 28
April 1 - June 30
July 28
July I - September 30
October 28
October 1 - December 31
Janu 28
Semiannual
January 1 - June 30
July 28
Jul 1- December 31
January 28
Annual
January 1 - December 31
January 28
The permittee may submit either paper or electronic DMR forms. If submitting electronic DMR forms,
the permittee shall use the electronic DMR system approved by the Department (EzDMR) and shall
electronically submit the completed DMR forms using the DEP Business Portal at
httpJ/www.fldepportal.com/go/. Reports shall be submitted to the Department by the twenty-eighth
(28th) of the month following the month of operation. Data submitted in electronic format is equivalent
to data submitted on signed and certified paper DMR forms.
If submitting paper DMR forms, the permittee shall make copies of the attached DMR forms, without
altering the original format or content unless approved by the Department, and shall mail the
completed DMR forms to the Department's Southeast District Office at the address specified in Permit
Condition I.A. 3. by the twenty-eighth (28th) of the month following the month of operation.
[62-620.610(18)1[62-600.680(l)]
Unless specified otherwise in this permit, all reports and other information required by this permit,
including 24-hour notifications, shall be submitted to or reported to, as appropriate, the Department's
Southeast District Office at the address specified below:
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
Southeast District
3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1
West Palm Beach, Florida 33406-3007
P275
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, I.LC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
Phone Number - (561)681-6600
[62-620.305)
4. All reports and other information shall be signed in accordance with the requirements of Rule 62-
620.305, F.A.C. [62-620.305]
II. BIOSOLIDS MANAGEMENT REQUIREMENTS
A. Basic Requirements
1. Biosolids generated by this facility may be distributed and marketed or disposed of in a Class I solid
waste landfill. [62-620.320(6), 62-640.880(1)]
2. The permittee shall monitor and keep records of the quantities of biosolids generated, received from
source facilities, treated, distributed and marketed, land applied, used as a biofuel or for bioenergy,
transferred to another facility, or landfilled. These records shall be kept for a minimum of five years.
[62-640.650(4)(a)]
3. Biosolids quantities shall be monitored for each composting site by the permittee as specified below.
Results of all compost sites distributed and marketed that month shall be reported on the permittee's
Discharge Monitoring Report for Monitoring Group RMP -Q in accordance with Condition I.A.3.
[62-640.650(5)(a)1j
4. Biosolids quantities shall be calculated as listed in Permit Condition 11.3. and as described below:
Monitoring Site Number
Biosolids Limitations
Monitoring Requirements
RMP -01
See Specific
Condition H. A. 5.
RMP -02
See Specific
Frequency
Sample
Monitoring
Parameter
Units
Max/
Limit
Statistical Basis
of Analysis
Type
Site
Min
Number
Biosolids Quantity
(Distributed &
ton (d)
Max
Report
Monthly Total
Monthly
Calculated
RMP -01
Marketed in FL
Biosolids Quantity
(Distributed &
ton (d)
Max
Report
Monthly Total
Monthly
Calculated
RMP -02
Marketed outside FL
Biosolids Quantity
(Landfilled
ton (d)
Max
Report
Monthly Total
Monthly
Calculated
RMP -03
Biosolids Quantity
(Received)
ton (d)
Max
Report
Monthly Total
Monthly
I Calculated
I RMP -04
[62-640.650(5)(a)1j
4. Biosolids quantities shall be calculated as listed in Permit Condition 11.3. and as described below:
Monitoring Site Number
Descri tion of Monitorin Site Calculations
RMP -01
See Specific
Condition H. A. 5.
RMP -02
See Specific
Condition H. A. 5.
RMP -03
See Specific
Condition II. A. 5.
RMP -04
See Specific
Condition H. A. 5.
P276
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
5. The following are the approved Monitoring Site Calculations:
• Dry tons = gallons of biosolids x 8.34 lbs./gallon x ton/2000 lbs. x percent solids/100
• Dry tons = cubic yards (wet) of biosolids x bulk density of biosolids/cubic yard x ton/2000
lbs. x percent solids/100
• Dry tons = wet tons x percent solids/I00
• If a biosolids analysis is not available then the percent total solids can be estimated using 1.75
% total solids for liquid biosolids and 17.75 % total solids for dewatered "cake".
• Percent solids will be obtained from the annual biosolids analysis required by the permit. The
gallons are the total transferred to another facility, used as a biofuel/for bioenergy or
landfilled. As a guide, a typical load of liquid biosolids removed by truck is usually 6,000
gallons.
6. The treatment, management, transportation, use, land application, or disposal of biosolids shall not
cause a violation of the odor prohibition in subsection 62-296.320(2), F.R.C. [62-640.400(6)]
7. Storage of biosolids or other solids at this facility shall be limited to 15 days unless the Permittee
submits and receive approval of the Facility Biosolids Storage Plan. Afterwards, storage of biosolids or
other solids at this facility shall be in accordance with the Facility Biosolids Storage Plan. [62-
640.300(4)]
8. Biosolids shall not be spilled from or tracked off the treatment facility site by the hauling vehicle. [62-
640.400(9)]
B. Treatment and Monitoring Requirements
1. The permittee is authorized to produce Class AA biosolids.
2. The permittee shall achieve Class A pathogen reduction by meeting the pathogen reduction
requirements in section 503.32(a)(7) (Use of PFRP (Processes to Further Reduce Pathogens -
Composting — Temperatures are monitored on a daily basis at depths of 10", 20", 30", and 40" at every
100' along pile or another method as approved in the operating protocol. Temperatures are greater
than 131 degrees F at all locations in the pile for a minimum of 15 days.) of Title 40 CFR Part 503.
[62-640.600(1)(a)]
3. The permittee shall achieve vector attraction reduction for Class A or B biosolids by meeting the
vector attraction reduction requirements in section 503.33(b)(5) (Use aerobic processes at greater than
40°C (average temperatures 45°C) for an additional 14 days or longer after completion of pathogens
reduction (e.g., during biosolids composting) of Title 40 CFR Part 503. [62-640.600(2)(a)]
4. The time and temperature shall be routinely monitored to demonstrate compliance with pathogen
reduction requirements specified in Rule 62-640.600, F.A.C. [62-640.650(3)(a)2]
5. The time and temperature shall be routinely monitored to demonstrate compliance with vector
attraction reduction requirements specified in Rule 62-640.600, F.A.C. [62-640.650(3)(a)2]
6. Treatment of liquid biosolids or septage for the purpose of meeting the pathogen reduction or vector
attraction reduction requirements set forth in Rule 62-640.600, F.A.C., shall not be conducted in the
tank of a hauling vehicle. Treatment of biosolids or septage for the purpose of meeting pathogen
reduction or vector attraction reduction requirements shall take place at the permitted facility. [62-
640.400(7)]
P277
PERMITTF.F: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
7. Class AA biosolids shall comply with the limits and be monitored by the permittee as specified below.
Results shall be reported on the permittee's Discharge Monitoring Report in accordance with Permit
Condition I.A.3. Biosolids shall not be distributed and marketed or land applied if a single sample
result or the monthly average of sample results for any parameter exceeds the following Class AA
parameter concentrations:
-trimer me recal conrorm limit or salmonella sp. ltnttt must be met.
"Note, monthly averages of parameter concentrations shall be determined by taking the arithmetic
mean of all sample results for the month. [62-640.650(3)(a)(3), 62-640.700(5)(a), 62-640.700(5)(h)
and 62-640.850(4)7
9. Class AA biosolids that are stored for more than 45 days shall be re -sampled for fecal coliform or
Salmonella sp. every Month until removed from the storage pads. [62-640.650(3)(a)51
Sampling and analysis shall be conducted in accordance with 40 CFR Part 503.8 and the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency publication - POTW Sludge Sampling, and Analysis Guidance
Document, August 1989. In cases where conflicts exist between 40 CFR 503.8 and the POTW Sludge
SamplinAnalysis Guidance Document, the requirements in 40 CFR Part 503.8 will apply. [62-
640.650(3)(a)11
9. All samples shall be representative and shall be taken after final treatment of the Biosolids but before
land application or distribution and marketing. [62-640.650(3)(a)51
P278
Biosolids Limitations
Monitoring Requirements
Frequency
Sample
Monitoring
Parameter
Units
Max/
Limit
I
Statistical Basis
of
Type
Site Number
Min
Analysis
Nitrogen, Sludge, Total, Dry
Weight as N)
percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Phosphorus, Sludge, Total, Dry
Weight (as P
percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Potassium, Sludge, Total, Dry
Weight as K
percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Arsenic Total, Dry Weight,
mg/kg
Max
41.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Sludge
Max
75.0
Single Sample
Cadmium, Sludge, Total, Dry
mg/kg
Max
39.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Weight as Cd
Max
85.0
Single Sample
Copper, Sludge, Total, Dry
mg/kg
Max
1500.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Weight. as Cu)Max
4300.0
Single Sample
Lead, Dry Weight, Sludge
mg/kg
Max
300.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Max
840.0
Single Sample
Mercury, Dry Weight, Sludge
mfg
Max
17.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Max
57.0
Single Sample
Molybdenum, Dry Weight,
Sludge
mg/kg
Max
75.0
Single Sample
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Nickel, Dry Weight, Sludge
mg/kg
Max
420.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Max
420.0
Single Sample
Selenium Sludge Solid
mg/kg
Max
100.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Max
100.0
Sin a Sample
Zinc, Dry Weight, Sludge
Mg/kg
Max
2800.0
Monthly Average
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Max
7500.0
Sile Sam le
pH
S.U.
Max
Report
Single Sample
Monthly
Grab
RMP -AA
Solids, Total, Sludge, Percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
percent
Max
Report
Single Sample
Monthly
Composite
RMP -AA
Coliform, Fecal
MPN/g
Max
1000.0
Single Sample
Monthly
Grab
RMP -AA
Salmonella Sludge
MPN/4g
Max
3.0
Single Sample
Monthly
Grab
RMP -AA
-trimer me recal conrorm limit or salmonella sp. ltnttt must be met.
"Note, monthly averages of parameter concentrations shall be determined by taking the arithmetic
mean of all sample results for the month. [62-640.650(3)(a)(3), 62-640.700(5)(a), 62-640.700(5)(h)
and 62-640.850(4)7
9. Class AA biosolids that are stored for more than 45 days shall be re -sampled for fecal coliform or
Salmonella sp. every Month until removed from the storage pads. [62-640.650(3)(a)51
Sampling and analysis shall be conducted in accordance with 40 CFR Part 503.8 and the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency publication - POTW Sludge Sampling, and Analysis Guidance
Document, August 1989. In cases where conflicts exist between 40 CFR 503.8 and the POTW Sludge
SamplinAnalysis Guidance Document, the requirements in 40 CFR Part 503.8 will apply. [62-
640.650(3)(a)11
9. All samples shall be representative and shall be taken after final treatment of the Biosolids but before
land application or distribution and marketing. [62-640.650(3)(a)51
P278
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
10. Biosolids samples shall be taken at the composting site locations listed in II. B. 7. and as described
below:
C. Distribution and Marketing
Biosolids or biosolids products may be distributed and marketed only if the biosolids or biosolids
products meet Class AA standards and are either sold or given -away under a Florida fertilizer license
or distributed and marketed to a person or entity that will sell or give-away the biosolids or biosolids
products under Florida fertilizer license. Biosolids composts that are enrolled and certified under the
U.S. Composting Council's Seal of Testing Assurance (USCC STA) program do not have to be sold or
given -away under a Florida fertilizer license except if distributed and marketed within the Lake
Okeechobee, St. Lucie River, and Caloosahatchee River watersheds. [62-640.850]
Within 24 hours of discovering that distributed and marketed biosolids did not meet the Class AA
standards, the permittee shall notify the Department and all persons to whom they delivered or
distributed and marketed the Class AA biosolids. [62-640.650(6)(8)]
3. The permittee shall make the following information available to users by product labels or other
means:
a. The fertilizer label required by Florida fertilizer law or the equivalent information required by the
USCC STA program;
b. The name and address of the facility or person that produced the Class AA biosolids;
c. A statement that the biosolids or biosolids product meets the criteria of subsection 62-64.0.700(5),
F.A.C.;
d. Recommendation that biosolids be applied at a rate that does not exceed crop or plant nutrient
needs and;
e. Recommendations on proper storage of the biosolids or biosolids product prior to use. For
distributed quantities of biosolids or biosolids products greater than one dry ton, the
recommendations shall include that biosolids may not be stored on property for more than seven
days unless stored to prevent runoff of biosolids or stormwater that has been in contact with
biosolids, violation of the odor prohibition in subsection 62-296.320(2), F.A.C., and vector
attraction.
[62-640.850(5)]
D. Disposal
Disposal of biosolids, septage, and "other solids" in a solid waste disposal facility, or disposal by
placement on land for purposes other than soil conditioning or fertilization, such as at a monofill,
surface impoundment, waste pile, or dedicated site, shall be in accordance with Chapter 62-701, F.A.C.
[62-640.100(6)(6) & (c)]
P279
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
E. Receipt.
The permittee shall enter into a written agreement with each source facility that it intends to receive
biosolids from. The agreement shall address the quality and quantity of the biosolids accepted by the
permittee. The agreement shall include a statement, signed by the permittee, as to the availability of
sufficient permitted capacity to receive the biosolids from the source facility, and indicating that the
permittee will continue to operate in compliance with the requirements of its permit. The agreement
shall also address responsibility during transport of biosolids between the facilities. The permittee shall
submit a copy of this agreement to the Department's Southeast District Office at least 30 days before
transporting biosolids from the source facility to the permittee. [62-640.880(1)(c)]
III. , GROUND WATER REQUIREMENTS
1. Section III is not applicable to this facility.
IV. ADDITIONAL REUSE AND LAND APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS
1. Section IV is not applicable to this facility.
V. OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE REQUIREMENTS
A. Staffing Requirements
During the period of operation authorized by this permit, the wastewater facilities shall be operated
under the supervision of one or more operators certified in accordance with Chapter 62-602, F.A.C. In
accordance with Chapter 62-699, F.A.C., ibis facility is a Type I Biosolids Treatment Facility and, at a
minimum, operators with appropriate certification must be on the site as follows:
The level of operator staffing at a biosolids treatment facility shall be Class A Operator for 8 hours/day
for 5 days/week.
2. An alternative to the above staffing is as follows:
A Certified Compost Program Manager certified by the Solid Waste Association of North America
(SWANA), in partnership with the U.S. Composting Council's Professional Credentials Committee or
a Florida Professional Engineer. A lead/chief operator shall be present at the facility at least 8 hours
per week. 62-640.880(2)6)4.
A lead operator assistant under the direct supervision of the lead/chief operator shall be present at the
facility 8 hours/day for 5 days/week. If the lead/chief operator is present more than 8 hours per week,
the lead/chief operator can substitute for the lead operator assistant coverage on an hour for hour basis
for hours over the minimum 8 hours per week. The lead/chief operator and the lead operator assistant
shall work together at the plant for at least 8 hours per week unless the lead/chief operator works more
than 8 hours/day for 5 days/week. 62-640.880(2)0)4.
3. A lead/chief operator or a Florida Professional Engineer (P.E) shall be available during all periods of
plant operation. "Available" means able to be contacted as needed to initiate the appropriate action in a
timely manner. Due to the nature of the composting operations, seldom will a lead/chief operator or
P.E. be needed outside normal work schedules. [62-699.311(10), (6) and (1)]
B. Capacity Analysis Report and Operation and Maintenance Performance Report Requirements
1. The application to renew this permit shall include a detailed operation and maintenance performance
report prepared in accordance with Rule 62-600.735, F.A.G. [62-600.735(1)]
C. Recordkeeping Requirements
P280
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
1. The permittee shall maintain the following records and make them available for inspection on the site
of the permitted facility.
a. Records of all compliance monitoring information, including all calibration and maintenance
records and all original strip chart recordings for continuous monitoring instrumentation,
including, if applicable, a copy of the laboratory certification showing the certification number of
the laboratory, for at least three years from the date the sample or measurement was taken;
b. Copies of all reports required by the permit for at least three years fi-om the date the report was
prepared;
c. Records of all data, including reports and documents, used to complete the application for the
permit for at least three years from the date the application was filed;
d. Monitoring information, including a copy of the laboratory certification showing the laboratory
certification number, related to the residuals use and disposal activities for the time period set forth
in Chapter 62-640, F.A.C., for at least three years from the date of sampling or measurement;
e. A copy of the current permit;
f. A copy of the current operation and maintenance manual as required by Chapter 62-600, F.A.C.;
g. A copy of any required record drawings;
h. Copies of the licenses of the current certified operators;
i. Copies of the logs and schedules showing plant operations and equipment maintenance for three
years from the date of the logs or schedules. The logs shall, at a minimum, include identification
of the plant; the signature and license number of the operator(s) and the signature of the person(s)
making any entries; date and time in and out; specific operation and maintenance activities,
including any preventive maintenance or repairs made or requested; results of tests performed and
samples taken, unless documented on a laboratory sheet; and notation of any notification or
reporting completed in accordance with Rule 62-602.650(3), F.A.C. The logs shall be maintained
on-site in a location accessible to 24-hour inspection, protected from weather damage, and current
to the last operation and maintenance performed; and
j. Records of biosolids quantities, treatment, monitoring, and hauling for at least five years.
[62-620.350, 62-602.650, 62-640.650(4)]
VI. SCHEDULES
1. The following self-improvement actions (the following schedule is not a compliance schedule) areplanned
by the Permittee according to the following schedule:
Improvement Action Completion Date
11 1. Completion construction of composting facility July 1, 2020
2. Prior to placing the new facilities into operation, the Permittee shall submit and have approved by the
Department an Operation and Maintenance Manual that will include but not limited to detail monitoring and
calculation requirements contained in Section 11 of this permit. [62-4.070 (1) & (3).
3. Prior to placing the new facilities into operation or any individual unit processes into operation, for any
purpose other than testing for leaks and equipment operation, the Permittee shall complete and submit to the
Department DEP Form 62-620.910(12), Notification of Completion of Construction for Wastewater
Facilities or Activities. [62-620.410(7)]
4. Within six months after a facility is placed in operation, the permittee shall provide written
certification to the Department on Form 62-620.910(13) that record drawings pursuant to Chapter 62-
620, F.A.C., and that an operation and maintenance manual pursuant to Chapters 62-600 and 62-610,
P281
PERMITITFE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
F.A.C., as applicable, are available at the location specified on the form. [62-620.410(6) and 62-
620.630(7)]
The permittee is not authorized to produce distribute and market composted biosolids after the
expiration date of this permit, unless:
a. The permittee has applied for renewal of this permit at least 180 days before the expiration date of
this permit using the appropriate forms listed in Rule 62-620.910, F.A.C., and in the manner
established in the Department of Environmental Protection Guide to Permitting Wastewater
Facilities or Activities Under Chapter 62-620, F.A.C., including submittal of the appropriate
processing fee set forth in Rule 62-4.050, F.A.C.; or
b. The permittee has made complete the' application for renewal of this permit before the permit
expiration date.
[62-620.335(1) - (4)]
VII. INDUSTRIAL PRETREATMENT PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS
This facility is not required to have a pretreatment program. [62-625.500]
VIII. OTHER SPECIFIC CONDITIONS
In the event that the treatment facilities or equipment no longer function as intended, are no longer safe
in terms of public health and safety, or odor, noise, aerosol drift, or lighting adversely affects
neighboring developed areas at the levels prohibited by Rule 62-600.400(2)(a), F.A.C., corrective
action (which may include additional maintenance or modifications of the permitted facilities) shall be
taken by the permittee. Other corrective action may be required to ensure compliance with rules of the
Department. Additionally, the treatment, management, use or land application of residuals shall not
cause a violation of the odor prohibition in Rule 62-296.320(2), F.A.C. [62-600.410(5) and 62-
640.400(6)]
The permittee shall provide verbal notice to the Department's Southeast District Office as soon as
practical after discovery of a sinkhole or other karst feature within an area for the management or
application of wastewater, wastewater residuals (sludges), or reclaimed water. The permittee shall
immediately implement measures appropriate to control the entry of contaminants, and shall detail
these measures to the Department's Southeast District Office in a written report within 7 days of the
sinkhole discovery. [62-620.320(6)]
IX. GENERAL CONDITIONS
The terms, conditions, requirements, limitations, and restrictions set forth in this permit are binding
and enforceable pursuant to Chapter 403, Florida Statutes. Any permit noncompliance constitutes a
violation of Chapter 403, Florida Statutes, and is grounds for enforcement action, permit termination,
permit revocation and reissuance, or permit revision. [62-620.610(1)]
2. This permit is valid only for the specific processes and operations applied for and indicated in the
approved drawings or exhibits. Any unauthorized deviations from the approved drawings, exhibits,
specifications, or conditions of this permit constitutes grounds for revocation and enforcement action
by the Department. [62-620.610(2)]
3. As provided in subsection 403.087(7), F.S., the issuance of this permit does not convey any vested
rights or any exclusive privileges. Neither does it authorize any injury to public or private property or
any invasion of personal rights, nor authorize any infringement of federal, state, or local laws or
regulations. This permit is not a waiver of or approval of any other Department permit or authorization
P282
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
that may be required for other aspects of the Total project which are not addressed in this permit. [62-
620.610(3)]
This permit conveys no title to land or water, does not constitute state recognition or acknowledgment
of title, and does not constitute authority for the use of submerged lands unless herein provided and the
necessary title or leasehold interests have been obtained from the State. Only the Trustees of the
Internal Improvement Trust Fund may express State opinion as to title. [62-620.610(4)]
This permit does not relieve the permittee from liability and penalties for harm or injury to human
health or welfare, animal or plant life, or property caused by the construction or operation of this
permitted source; nor does it allow the permittee to cause pollution in contravention of Florida Statutes
and Department rules, unless specifically authorized by an order from the Department. The permittee
shall take all reasonable steps to minimize or prevent any discharge, reuse of reclaimed water, or
biosolids use or disposal in violation of this permit which has a reasonable likelihood of adversely
affecting human health or the environment. It shall not be a defense for a permittee in an enforcement
action that it would have been necessary to halt or reduce the permitted activity in order to maintain
compliance with the conditions of this permit. [62-620.610(5)]
6. If the permittee wishes to continue an activity regulated by this permit after its expiration date, the
permittee shall apply for and obtain a new permit. [62-620.610(6)]
7. The permittee shall at all times properly operate and maintain the facility and systems of treatment and
control, and related appurtenances, that are installed and used by the permittee to achieve compliance
with the conditions of this permit. This provision includes the operation of backup or auxiliary
facilities or similar. systems when necessary to maintain or achieve compliance with the conditions of
the permit. [62-620.610(7)]
8. This permit may be modified, revoked and reissued, or terminated for cause. The filing of a request by
the permittee for a permit revision, revocation and reissuance, or termination, or a notification of
planned changes or anticipated noncompliance does not stay any permit condition. [62-620.610(8)]
9. The permittee, by accepting this permit, specifically agrees to allow authorized Department personnel,
including an authorized representative of the Department and authorized EPA personnel, when
applicable, upon presentation of credentials or other documents as may be required by law, and at
reasonable times, depending upon the nature of the concern being investigated, to:
a. Enter upon the permittee's premises where a regulated facility, system, or activity is located or
conducted, or where records shall be kept under the conditions of this permit;
b. Have access to and copy any records that shall be kept under the conditions of this permit;
c. Inspect the facilities, equipment, practices, or operations regulated or required under this permit;
and
d. Sample or monitor any substances or parameters at any location necessary to assure compliance
with this permit or Department rules.
[62-620.610(9)]
10. In accepting this permit, the permittee understands and agrees that all records, notes, monitoring data,
and other information relating to the construction or operation of this permitted source which are
submitted to the Department may be used by the Department as evidence in any enforcement case
involving the permitted source arising under the Florida Statutes or Department rules, except as such
use is proscribed by Section 403.111, F.S., or Rule 62-620.302, F.A.C. Such evidence shall only be
used to the extent that it is consistent with the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure and applicable
evidentiary rules. [62-620.610(10)]
10
P283
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
11. When requested by the Department, the permittee shall within a reasonable time provide any
information required by law which is needed to determine whether there is cause for revising,. revoking
and reissuing, or terminating this permit, or to determine compliance with the permit. The permittee
shall also provide to the Department upon request copies of records required by this permit to be kept.
If the permittee becomes aware of relevant facts that were not submitted or were incorrect in the permit
application or in any report to the Department, such facts or information shall be promptly submitted
or corrections promptly reported to the Department. [62-620.610(11)]
12. Unless specifically stated otherwise in Department rules, the permittee, in accepting this permit, agrees
to comply with changes in Department rules and Florida Statutes after a reasonable time for
compliance; provided, however, the permittee does not waive any other rights granted by Florida
Statutes or Department rules. A reasonable time for compliance with a new or amended surface water
quality standard, other than those standards addressed in Rule 62-302.500, F.A.C., shall include a
reasonable time to obtain or be denied a mixing zone for the new or amended standard. [62-
620.610(12)]
13. The permittee, in accepting this permit, agrees to pay the applicable regulatory program and
surveillance fee in accordance with Rule 62-4.052, F.A.C. [62-620.610(13)]
14. This permit is transferable only upon Department approval in accordance with Rule 62-620.340,
F.A.C. The permittee shall be liable for any noncompliance of the permitted activity until the transfer
is approved by the Department. [62-620.610(14)]
15. The permittee shall give the Department written notice at least 60 days before inactivation or
abandonment of a wastewater facility or activity and shall specify what steps will be taken to safeguard
public health and safety during and following inactivation or abandonment. [62-620.610(15)]
16. The permittee shall apply for a revision to the Department permit in accordance with Rules 62-
620.300, F.A.C., and the Department of Environmental Protection Guide to Permitting Wastewater
Facilities or Activities Under Chapter 62-620, F.A.C., at least 90 days before construction of any
planned substantial modifications to the permitted facility is to commence or with Rule 62-620.325(2),
F.A.C., for minor modifications to the permitted facility. A revised permit shall be obtained before
construction begins except as provided in Rule 62-620.300, F.A.C. [62-620.610(16)]
17. The permittee shall give advance notice to the Department of any planned changes in the permitted
facility or activity which may result in noncompliance with permit requirements. The permittee shall
be responsible for any and all damages which may result from the changes and may be subject to
enforcement action by the Department for penalties or revocation of this permit. The notice shall
include the following information:
a. A description of the anticipated noncompliance;
b. The period of the anticipated noncompliance, including dates and times; and
c. Steps being taken to prevent future occurrence of the noncompliance.
[62-620.610(17)]
18. Sampling and monitoring data shall be collected and analyzed in accordance with Rule 62-4.246 and
Chapters 62-160, 62-600, and 62-610, F.A.C., and 40 CFR 136, as appropriate.
a. Monitoring results shall be reported at the intervals specified elsewhere in this permit and shall be
reported on a Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR), DEP Form 62-620.910(10), or as specified
elsewhere in the permit.
b. If the permittee monitors any contaminant more frequently than required by the permit, using
Department approved test procedures, the results of this monitoring shall be included in the
calculation and reporting of the data submitted in the DMR.
11
P284
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
c. Calculations for all limitations which require averaging of measurements shall use an arithmetic
mean unless otherwise specified in this permit.
d. Except as specifically provided in Rule 62-160.300, F.A.C., any laboratory test required by this
permit shall be performed by a laboratory that has been certified by the Department of Health
Environmental Laboratory Certification Program (DOH ELCP). Such certification shall be for the
matrix, test method and analyte(s) being measured to comply with this permit. For domestic
wastewater facilities, testing for parameters listed in Rule 62-160.300(4), F.A.C., shall be
conducted under the direction of a certified operator.
e. Field activities including on-site tests and sample collection shall follow the applicable standard
operating procedures described in DEP-SOP-001/01 adopted by reference in Chapter 62-160,
F.A.C.
f. Alternate field procedures and laboratory methods may be used where they have been approved in
accordance with Rules 62-160.220, and 62-160.330, F.A.C.
[62-620.610(18)]
19. Reports of compliance or noncompliance with, or any progress reports on, interim and final
requirements contained in any compliance schedule detailed elsewhere in this permit shall be
submitted no later than 14 days following each schedule date. [62-620.610(19)]
20. The permittee shall report to the Department's Southeast District Office any noncompliance which may
endanger health or the environment. Any information shall be provided orally within 24 hours from
the time the permittee becomes aware of the circumstances. A written submission shall also be
provided within five days of the time the permittee becomes aware of the circumstances. The written
submission shall contain: a description of the noncompliance and its cause; the period of
noncompliance including exact dates and time, and if the noncompliance has not been corrected, the
anticipated time it is expected to continue; and steps taken or planned to reduce, eliminate, and prevent
recurrence of the noncompliance.
a. The following shall be included as information which must be reported within 24 hours under this
condition:
(1) Any unanticipated bypass which causes any reclaimed water or effluent to exceed any permit
limitation or results in an unpermitted discharge,
(2) Any upset which causes any reclaimed water or the effluent to exceed any limitation in the
permit,
(3) Violation of a maximum daily discharge limitation for any of the pollutants specifically listed
in the permit for such notice, and
(4) Any unauthorized discharge to surface or ground waters.
b. Oral reports as required by this subsection shall be provided as follows:
(1) For unauthorized releases or spills of treated or untreated wastewater reported pursuant to
subparagraph (a)4. that are in excess of 1,000 gallons per incident, or where information
indicates that public health or the environment will be endangered, oral reports shall be
provided to the STATE WATCH OFFICE TOLL FREE NUMBER (800) 320-0519, as soon
as practical, but no later than 24 hours from the time the permittee becomes aware of the
discharge. The permittee, to the extent known, shall provide the following information to the
State Watch Office:
(a) Name, address, and telephone number of person reporting;
(b) Name, address, and telephone number of permittee or responsible person for the
discharge;
(c) Date and time of the discharge and status of discharge (ongoing or ceased);
(d) Characteristics of the wastewater spilled or released (untreated or treated, industrial or
domestic wastewater);
(e) Estimated amount of the discharge;
(f) Location or address of the discharge;
(g) Source and cause of the discharge;
12
P285
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC. PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
(h) Whether the discharge was contained on-site, and cleanup actions taken to date;
(i) Description of area affected by the discharge, including name of water body affected, if
any; and
(j) Other persons or agencies contacted.
(2) Oral reports, not otherwise required to be provided pursuant to subparagraph b.l above, shall
be provided to the Department's Southeast District Office within 24 hours from the time the
permittee becomes aware of the circumstances.
If the oral report has been received within 24 hours, the noncompliance has been corrected, and
the noncompliance did not endanger health or the environment, the Department's Southeast
District Office shall waive the written report.
[62-620.610(20)]
21. The permittee shall report all instances of noncompliance not reported under Permit Conditions IX.17.,
IX.18., or IX.19. of this permit at the time monitoring reports are submitted. This report shall contain
the same information required by Permit Condition IX.20. of this permit. [62-620.610(21)]
22. Bypass Provisions.
a. "Bypass" means the intentional diversion of waste streams from any portion of a treatment works.
b. Bypass is prohibited, and the Department may take enforcement action against a permittee for
bypass, unless'the permittee affirmatively demonstrates that:
(1) Bypass was unavoidable to prevent loss of life, personal injury, or severe property damage;
and
(2) There were no feasible alternatives to the bypass, such as the use of auxiliary treatment
facilities, retention of untreated wastes, or maintenance during normal periods of equipment
downtime. This condition is not satisfied if adequate back-up equipment should have been
installed in the exercise of reasonable engineering judgment to prevent a bypass which
occurred during normal periods of equipment downtime or preventive maintenance; and
(3) The permittee submitted notices as required under Permit Condition IX.22.c. of this permit.
c. If the permittee knows in advance of the need for a bypass, it shall submit prior notice to the
Department, if possible at least 10 days before the date of the bypass. The permittee shall submit
notice of an unanticipated bypass within 24 hours of learning about the bypass as required in
Permit Condition IX.20. of this permit. A notice shall include a description of the bypass and its
cause; the period of the bypass, including exact dates and times; if the bypass has not been
corrected, the anticipated time it is expected to continue; and the steps taken or planned to reduce,
eliminate, and prevent recurrence of the bypass.
d. The Department shall approve an anticipated bypass, after considering its adverse effect, if the
permittee demonstrates that it will meet the three conditions listed in Permit Condition IX.22.b.(1)
through (3) of this permit.
e. A permittee may allow any bypass to occur which does not cause reclaimed water or effluent
limitations to be exceeded if it is for essential maintenance to assure efficient operation. These
bypasses are not subject to the provisions of Permit Condition IX.22.b. through d. of this permit.
[62-620.610(22)]
23. Upset Provisions.
a. "Upset" means an exceptional incident in which there is unintentional and temporary
noncompliance with technology-based effluent limitations because of factors beyond the
reasonable control of the permittee.
13
P286
PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC.
FACILITY: Sunbreak Farms
PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830
(l) An upset does not include noncompliance caused by operational error, improperly designed
treatment facilities, inadequate treatment facilities, lack of preventive maintenance, careless or
improper operation.
(2) An upset constitutes an affirmative defense to an action brought for noncompliance with
technology based permit effluent limitations if the requirements of upset provisions of Rule
62-620.610, F.A.C., are met.
b. A permittee who wishes to establish the affirmative defense of upset shall demonstrate, through
properly signed contemporaneous operating logs, or other relevant evidence that:
(1) An upset occurred and that the permittee can identify the cause(s) of the upset;
(2) The permitted facility was at the time being properly operated;
(3) The permittee submitted notice of the upset as required in Permit Condition IX.20. of this
permit; and
(4) The permittee complied with any remedial measures required under Permit Condition IX.5. of
this permit.
c. In any enforcement proceeding, the burden of proof for establishing the occurrence of an upset
rests with the permittee.
d. Before an enforcement proceeding is instituted, no representation made during the Department
review of a claim that noncompliance was caused by an upset is final agency action subject to
judicial review.
[62-620.610(23)]
Executed in West Palm Beach, Florida.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
DRAFT
Diane Pupa Date
Program Administrator
Permitting and Waste Cleanup
Southeast District
14
P287
FACTSHEET
FOR
STATE OF FLORIDA DOMESTIC WASTEWATER FACILITY PERMIT
May 8, 2017 DRAFT
PERMIT NUMBER: FLA979830-001
FACILITY NAME: Sunbreak Farms
FACILITY LOCATION: 5101 Minute Maid Road, Fort Pierce, FL 34945
St. Lucie County
NAME OF PERMITTEE: Sunbreak Farms
PERMIT WRITER: Bruce R. Kay
1. SUMMARY OF APPLICATION
a. Chronology of Application
Application Number: FLA979830-001-DWIR
Application Submittal Date: March 14, 2017
b. Type of Facility
Domestic Wastewater Treatment Plant
Ownership Type: Private
SIC Code: 4952
c. Facility Capacity
Existing Permitted Capacity: N/A
Proposed Increase in Permitted Capacity: 500 DryTons per Day
Proposed Total Permitted Capacity: 500 Dry Tons per Day
d. Description of Wastewater Treatment
A new, Type I Biosolids Management Facility with a permitted Class AA compost production of 500 dry tons per day.
Sunbreak Farms will utilize the Modified Static Aerated Pile (MSAP) method to achieve the required compost treatment of
biosolids as approved by EPA. The MSAP method has been approved as a method modification by EPA Region 9 (July 1,
2003), granted an equivalency determination as an alternative PFRP Biosolids will be blended at the facility with bulking
agents that primary consist of chipped yard trash debris and other green waste and mixed at a ratio of 3 -to -1 (green waste to
biosolids). They may include other organic wastes like chicken and other animal wastes mixed with the biosolids.
Composting of these other wastes without mixing with biosolids can be under a solid waste compost permit at the option of
the Permittee. Mixing is by mechanical means to thoroughly mix the biosolids and bulking agent together. Where
possible, the most freshly ground yard trash shall be set aside separately due to its ideal properties for mixing directly into
the biosolids (relatively low moisture content and high porosity). Windrows for active composting shall be constructed
directly on a compost pad. Prior to placing blended biosolids in the management area a 50:50 blend of ground yard trash
and screened compost from screening during post -processing, shall be used to create a 12 -inch base layer upon which active
15
P288
composting will be placed. Based on availability of material, this ratio is 100 percent of either material or any other ratio.
The blended biosolids will be placed into windrows constructed to dimensions that are approximately 16 feet wide and 8
feet tall. Once each windrow or windrow section is completely formed and mixed, Sunbreak Farms Staff shall apply the
Harvest Quest proprietary catalyst to the entire pile surface. When the windrow is completely covered by the catalyst,
Sunbreak Farms staff shall apply a 12 -inch layer of unscreened finished compost or ground yard trash (in any ratio). The
purpose of this capping layer is to serve as an instant biofilter to reduce odors, add in aeration of the compost and insulation
of the compost piles to maintain proper temperature. Pathogen reduction standards for Class AA compost will be achieved
by maintaining a minimum temperature of 131 degrees F (55 degrees C) in each windrow for a minimum period of 15
consecutive days. Within several days, the entire pile will exceed the required 131 degrees F (55 degrees C). Composting
of the materials shall continue for 3045 days with the windrow remaining undisturbed. Vector attraction reduction of
Class AA compost will be achieved by maintain aerobic composting with a temperature greater than 40 degrees C for 14
days or longer after the Pathogens period of l5 days. At any time, the piles can be turned if needed for aeration or for
moisture control. After turning, the pathogens standards and vector attraction reduction standards may have to be repeated
if it had not finished prior to the turning. After complying with both pathogens and vector attraction standards, the pile is
considered completed. The Permittee may extend the composting time with additional turning of the piles for better curing.
After curing, the product is screened and cooled. Another alternative for vector attraction reduction is for the incorporation
of class AA with respect to pathogens within 8 hours of discharge from the compost per EPA 503.33 Z(b)(10)(ii). Once
Sunbreak Farms has confirmed the compost product meets all permitted criteria for a Class AA fertilizer it will be
distributed and marketed as fertilizer.
Instead of the typical biosolids treatment facility that concentrates the operation in one area, the Applicant plans to spread
out the piles within the farm that it owns. A farmer (User of the compost) is under contract with the land owner (the
Applicant) to farm the property. The farmer grows corn that will produce silage. The complete removal of the corn
including the stalk requires rejuvenating the site after each harvest. Compost is superior product to add organic material to
the field (soil amendment) and some of the fertilizer demand. Without the composting, the fields will lose more nutrients to
the groundwater and potential discharge off site during heavy rainstorm events. By spreading the sites to each of the forty
fields, there is a minimal amount of runoff from the compost operation which is first discharged to a retention ditch
downgradient to the compost areas. The composting areas will be constructed with a 2% slope towards an internal v -ditch
(inside containment berm). This will promote drainage away from the piles. The v -ditch will be constructed with sufficient
storage to retain over 2.4" of runoff from the compost areas. Per FDEP's Evaluation of Stormwater Design Criteria within
the State of Florida (Harper, 2007) this captures approximately 90% of annual rainfall events. Perimeter berms shall be
formed around the composting areas prior to construction of windrows. The berms will be a minimum of 24" in height and
will provide 100% containment of the 100 -year, 3 -day storm event over a typical compost area. No discharge from the
compost areas to either the fields or perimeter ditches will occur. Most of the rainfall is pumped .from the
stormwater/irrigation ditches to a large irrigation storage pond (640 Acres). The site is within a large farming operation
with around 6580 acres. Forty large fields (average slightly over 115 acres each) are surrounded by stormwater/irrigation
system (ditches). Between the ditches and the fields are lime rock areas that are used for internal farm road system. On the
western side of the fields are major road beds. The road beds of these sides are elevated above the fields. The fields have a
slight slope from West to East. Therefore, the stormwater from the compost area will travel long distances from the
compost area to the stormwater/irrigation ditches. The ditches are part of the stormwater management system and are not
consider surface waters. Only when the ditches are pumped to the area canals, which are jurisdictional, do water quality
standards apply. The general area has the rainfall near the amount of evaporation. The farmer plans to minimize discharge
from the stormwater/irrigation ditches to the area canals. If wasting the rainwater to area canals would require the farmer to
either be short of irrigation water or have to supplement from other sources. This supplemental of other sources of water
may not be available when needed. The internal ditches are both used to irrigate the field during crop crowing periods and
stormwater management during rainfall events. The composting operation will be generally conducted after the crop has
been harvested and before planting for the next crop. They plan on two crops per year. When the fields are outside the
growing season, the ditches are kept really dry. During the summer raining season, the crops are not growing due to too hot
for corn production. During the growing season, the compost operation should be completed or just about completed. The
irrigation of the fields is by raising the water level in the stormwater/irrigation ditches. The level can be isolated by
working weirs in the ditch system. The level is regulated by either pumping into the storage pond or discharge from the
storage pond. A small area (less than 2 acres each) along the highest elevation road beds are being planned for the
composting area. There is wide area where the composting operation can occur perpendicular to the elevated roads. The
16
P289
compost areas will be bermed on all four sides. The compost area is higher or at the same elevation as the eastern berm that
lies between the compost retention pond and the fields. This location prevents stormwater flowing into the compost area
from adjacent properties. And, the drainage from the composting area will prevent wetting of the compost. Flooding the
compost is not recommended as it will prevent the compost from reaching Class AA Biosolids Standards, and will be too
wet for corn production. The size of each field composting area will be dependent on the availability of the biosolids and
will be limited to the requirements of the adjacent fields. The compost product will replace other fertilizer that is faster
leaching from the sites. The net effect will be reduction in fertilizer use and reduced discharge of nutrients to the area
canals. The complete management of the compost will be contained in the facilities operation and maintenance (O & M)
manual that is require prior to startup. Any changes in the operation would require updating of the O & M Manual.
2. SUMMARY OF SURFACE WATER DISCHARGE
This facility does not discharge to surface waters. South Florida Water Management District has issued Stormwater
Permit 56-00111-S
3. DISCUSSION OF CHANGES TO PERMIT LIMITATIONS
The facility is a new BIO -SOLIDS TREATMENT FACILITY
5. BIOSOLIDS TREATMENT REQUIREMENTS
Biosolids generated by this facility may be distributed and marketed or disposed of in a Class I solid waste landfill.
See the table below for the rationale for the Class AA biosolids limits and monitoring requirements.
Parameter
Units
Max/
Min
Limit
Statistical Basis
Rationale
Nitrogen, Sludge,
Tot, Dry Wt as
percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
62-640.650(3)(a)3. FAC
Phosphorus, Sludge,
Tot, Dry Wt as P
percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
62-640.650(3)(a)3. FAC
Potassium, Sludge,
Tot, Dry Wt as K
percent
Max
Report
Monthly Average
62-640.650(3)(a)3. FAC
Arsenic Total, Dry
Weight, Sludge
mg/kg
Max
75.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5)(a) & 650(3 a)3. FAC
Max 41.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Cadmium, Sludge,
Tot, Dry Weight (as
Cd
mg/kg
Max
85.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5)(a) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Max 39.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Copper, Sludge,
Tot, Dry Wt. (as
Cu
mg/kg
Max
4300.0
Sin a Sample
62-640.700(5)(0 & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Max 1500.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Lead, Dry Weight,
Sludge
mg/kg
Max
840.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5)(a) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Max 300.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Mercury, Dry
Weight, Sludge
mg/kg
Max
57.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5)(a) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Max 17.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Molybdenum, Dry
Weight, Sludge
mg/kg
Max
75.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5)(a) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Nickel, Dry Weight,
Sludge
mg/kg
Max
420.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5 a) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Max 420.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
Selenium Sludge
Solid
mg/kg
Max
100.0
Single Sample
62-640.700(5)(a) & 650(3)(a 3. FAC
Max 100.0 Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
mg/kg
Max
7500.0
Single Sam le
62-640.700(5&) & 650(3) a 3. FAC
17
P290
Parameter
Units
Max/
Min
Limit
Statistical Basis
Rationale
Zinc, Dry Weight,
Sludge
Max
2800.0
Monthly Average
62-640.700(5)(b) & 650(3)(a)3. FAC
H
S.U.
Max
Report
Single Sample
62-640.650(3)(a)3. FAC
Solids, Total,
Sludge, Percent
percent
Max I
Report
Single Sample
62-640.650(3)(a)3. FAC
Max Report I Monthly Average
62-640.650(3)(a)3. FAC
Coliform, Fecal
MPN/
Max
1060.0-1
Single Sample
62-640.600 1 a FAC
Salmonella Sludge
MPN/4g
Max
3.0
1 Single Sample
62-640.600(1)(a) FAC
Monitoring Frequency
All Parameters
62-640.650(3)(a)4. & .850(4)(c) FAC
Pathogen and vector attraction
reduction monitorin
dry tons
All Parameters
62-640.600 & 650(3)(a)1. FAC
See the table below for the rationale for the biosolids quantities monitoring requirements.
Parameter
Units
Max/
Limit
Statistical Basis
Rationale
Min
Biosolids Quantity
dry tons
Max
Report
Monthly Total
62-640.650(5)(a)]. FAC
(Landfilled)
Biosolids Quantity
dry tons
Max
Report
Monthly Total
62-640.650(5)(a)]. & 850(4)(a) FAC
(Distributed &
Marketed outside FL
Biosolids Quantity
dry tons
Max
Report
Monthly Total
62-640.650(5)(a)1. & 850(4)(a) FAC
(Distributed &
Marketed in FL
Biosolids Quantity
dry tons
Max
Report
Monthly Total
62-640.650(5)(a)l. & 850(4)(a) FAC
(Receive)
Monitoring Frequency
All Parameters
—62-640.650(5)(a) FAC
6. GROUND WATER MONITORING REQUIREMENTS
This section is not applicable to this facility.
7. PERMIT SCHEDULES
a. The following self-improvement actions (the following schedule is not a compliance schedule) are planned by the
Permittee according to the following schedule:
Improvement Action Completion Date
1. Completion of construction of compoWpg compostingfacility July 1 2020
b. Prior to placing the new facilities into operation or any individual unit processes into operation, for any purpose
other than testing for leaks and equipment operation, the Permittee shall complete and submit to the Department DEP
Form 62-620.910(12), Notification of Completion of Construction for Wastewater Facilities or Activities. [62-
620.410(7)]
18
P291
c. Within six months after a facility is placed in operation, the permittee shall provide written certification to the
Department on Form 62-620.910(13) that record drawings pursuant to Chapter 62-620, F.A.C., and that an operation
and maintenance manual pursuant to Chapters 62-600 and 62-610, F.A.C., as applicable, are available at the location
specified on the form. [62-620.410(6) and 62-620.630(7)]
9. ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS (AO) AND CONSENT ORDERS (CO)
This permit is not accompanied by an AO and has not entered into a CO with the Department.
10. REQUESTED VARIANCES OR ALTERNATIVES TO REQUIRED STANDARDS
No variances were requested for this facility.
IL . THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
The administrative record including application, draft permit, fact sheet, public notice (after release), comments
received and additional information is available for public inspection during normal business hours at the location
specified in item 13. Copies will be provided at a minimal charge per page.
12. PROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR PERMIT ISSUANCE
Notice of Intent to Issue May 8, 2017
Publication
May 15, 2017
Notice of Permit Issuance June 1, 2017
13. DEP CONTACT
Additional information concerning the permit and proposed schedule for permit issuance may be obtained during
normal business hours from:
Bruce Kay
Engineer 11
Southeast District Office
3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1
West Palm Beach, FL 33406-3007
Telephone No.: (561) 681-6695
19
P292
June 9, 2017
Mr. Tobin R. "Toby" Overdorf
EDC
10250 SW Village Parkway
Suite 201
Port St. Lucie, FL 34987
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
1801 27th Street, Vero Beach FL 32960
772-226-1237 / 772-978-1806 fax
www.iregov.com
RE: Sunbreak Farms Proposed Biosolids Management Facility
Dear Mr. Overdorf
Indian River County staff appreciated the opportunity to meet with you and Mr. Patrick Cheney
regarding the proposed ± 6,600 acre facility located on contiguous acreage within St. Lucie
County (5,100 acres) and Indian River County (1,500 acres). At this time, Indian River County
staff asks that you confirm the following regarding the proposed 6,600 acre facility.
1. That the facility will be used solely to amend the soil on the 6,600 acre site in support of
actively and continuously farming feed corn or a similar crop over the entire subject site
except for the Minute Maid Road Reservoir area.
2. That the overall site will continue to be managed for farming under the Florida
Department of Agricultural Services (FDACS) bestmanagement practices program,
including any FDACS best management practices and recommendations for preventing
leaching of run-off from biosolids into the soil.
3. That the facility will cease accepting compost or biosolids on site if and when the
continuous farming of crops on-site ceases..
4. That mulch from vegetative debris and biosolids will be accepted on-site only twice a
year during fallow periods between crops (roughly June — August and November —
January).
5. That no mulching will be conducted on site .and compost will be tilled into the soil within
90 days of receipt on site; compost will not be stored on site for more than 90 days.
6. That no water or compost will be marketed, sold, or exported from the site.
Note: It was stated in a recent meeting that no water or compost will be exported
from the site. That statement is contrary to a portion of the FDEP application (see
attachment 2). Will the applicant correct or clarify the application?
P293
7. That the 1,500 acre portion of the site lying within Indian River County drains into the
overall system of the 6,600 acre overall site and the 640 acre Minute Maid Road
Reservoir that lies within St. Lucie County.
S. That the 6,600 acre facility is subject to South Florida Water Management District
(SFWMD) stormwater management permitting requirements and that compost
containment areas will be established and maintained so as to contain run-off from a 100 -
year 3 -day storm.
Note: At this time staff is still awaiting access to stormwater management permit
plans and data to review and confirm this item, to confirm what construction is
required to establish and maintain a stormwater system for the compost areas to
meet the 1.00 -year 3 day storm design, to confirm that the system will be adequately
completed and then inspected by an outside agency prior to compost or biosolids
being brought to the site, and to understand and confirm that an adequate back-up
plan is in place. in the event that any necessary pumping facilities fail.
Staff appreciates your continuing offer to meet and County Public Works will
continue to coordinate with you on stormwater run-off issues.
9. That the facility will cease accepting compost or biosolids on site if and when the facility
stormwater management system fails to meet the 3 day 100 -year storm design standard.
10. That the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) permit holder .notify
the Indian River County Administrator at the time any pen -nit extension or modification
request is made to the FDEP or its successor agency.
Indian River County .appreciates the opportunity to confirm information about the project and to
understand project commitments. If you have any questions, please do .not hesitate to contact me
at (772) 226-1253.
Sincerely,
Stan Bolin CP
COmrnul]l evelopment Director, Indian River County
Attachment: Excerpt from FDEP Application
cc: Jason Brown (via email)
Richard B. Szpyrka, P.E. (via email)
Vincent M. Burke, P.E. (via email)
Roland. M. DeBlois, AICP (via email)
John W. McCoy, AICP (via email)
John Lang, SJID Administrator (via email)
Patrick B. Cheney (via email)
David Gunter, IRFWCD Superintendent (via email)
Christine. Kelly-Begazo (via email)
Dylan Reingold, Esq. (via email)
William K. DeBraal, Esq. (via email)
MASB\2017 Correspondencek$unbreak farms Itr to Overdorf 060717.docx
P294
Sunbreak Farms Biosolids Composting May 2017
Section 3 - Facility Design and Operations
3,1 Overview, Background, and Site Design
The agricultural operation associated with this plan is currently known as Sunbreak Farms.
The proposed activities associated with this operations plan include the on-site composting of
aerobically digested and dewatered biosolids with yard trash debris (green waste). There will
be subsequent land application of the Class AA product on Sunbreak's farm acreage. Prior to
land application the compost shall meet the regulatory and licensing requirements of 62-
640.850, F.A.C. for distribution and marketing.
Sunbreak Farms is located approximately 2.25 miles west of Interstate 95, north of the Florida
Turnpike. The farm is located mostly in St. Lucie County with the northern portion lying in
Indian River County. See Section 6 for a location map of the property.
Sunbreak Farms consists of 6580 acres of farm land, of which, 640 acres consists of an above
ground impoundment used for the storage of Irrigation and drainage.
The project will occur on an existing agricultural operation that was formerly known as Cloud
Grove. The previously farm operation served as citrus groves for Coca-Cola and Minute Maid
since the 1960's. Historically, the farms surface water and water,use permits have been
regulated and issued by SFWMD (56-00111=S). All site permits are currently in compliance.
Irrigation has primarily (and will continue to be) provided by permitted water use from the
SFWMD C-25 Canal and storage of water in the above ground impoundment. There are 2
existing, permitted, 100 gpm wells within the boundary of the farm. Per SFWMD
documentation these wells are cased to 450+ feet and are not associated with potable water.
The previous agricultural property and impoundment were purchased by Sunbreak Break
Farms, LLC. The previous citrus groves have been eliminated. The beds and furrows have
been knocked down with intent to reestablish the fields in order to grow row crop. Fertility
testing by the owner has indicated a reduction in the .nutrient and organic profile of the on-site,
soils.
Sunbreak Farms will establish management areas where composting of aerobically digested
and dewatered blosolids to .the permitted Class AA standards will be achieved. Biosolids and
bulking agents shall only be brought to areas once the berming and grading depicted on the
exhibits of Section 6 have been constructed.
Biosolids will be obtained primarily from municipal wastewater treatment plants. The facility is
designed to accept 500 tons of biosolids per day on a five day basis. Based on soil fertility
testing and recommendations by the facilities farming operations manager, Sunbreak Farms
demand for compost is approximately 10 tons per acre. While most deliveries will take place
Mon -Fri, the farm requests authorization to accept materials on weekends as needed. The
appropriate staffing, record keeping, and monitoring will be made available for such occasions.
E N OINEERiNG DE8104 & CON'STR
UC_
TI ON. _INC
CiVIL ENGINEERS & SURVEYORS SPECIALIZING IN LAND DEVELOPMENT
10250 SIM V,Ilape Paskry Suite 201
Poct-Sc Lode. FL 94987
772-482-2d55
Page 7
P295
Sunbreak Farms Biosolids Composting
May 2017
As further outlined in this report, Sunbreak Farms is designed to accept all bulking agents
necessary for the complete composting of the biosolids. The bulking agent will consist of
chipped yard trash (green waste) and Is exempt from Chapter 62-709, F.A.C.
Sunbreak Farms will utilize the Modified Static Aerobic Pile (MSAP) methodology as the
primary method of composting. The MSAP methodology is currently accepted by both the US
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and FDEP. This is evident by other permitted facilities
in the State of Florida utilizing this method to produce Class AA fertilizers. The method is in
compliance with CFR 503,32(a) for pathogen reduction and CFR 503.33(0) vector attraction
reduction. Sunbreak Farms will also incorporate turning the windrows as needed to achieve
the necessary pathogen and vector attraction reductions.
Prior to land application on the farm the compost shall meet the regulatory and licensing
requirements of 62-640.850, F-A.C. for distribution and marketing. The purpose of the
composting is for on-farm use only and composting operations are not intended to be
continuous at this point in time. There will be no storage of excess biosolids. Biosolids will be
accepted and compost will be generated on an as -needed basis to .meet to demands of the
normal tarm operations. A licensed tertilizer applicator receiving the biosolids will
the proauct lnio the rarm DiocKS son prior to plantings. In the event there are any biosolids or
compost materials on-site that exceed the farms fertilization needs these materials will be
given away (distributed and marketed) to an acceptable agricultural operation. It is the
responsibility of Sunbreak Farms to ensure sufficient licensing, labeling, and packaging in
accordance with FDAC's rules for such distribution. As a last resort, excess material may be
transported off-site to a landfill. All distribution and marketing will be done in accordance with
62-640.850, F.A.C.. and rules referenced therein. Sunbreak shall make available to all users of
its biosolids compost information regarding the name and address of the farm; analysis of the
compost; a statement of the compost's compliance with quality standards; and
recommendations on compost storage and usage that does not exceed agronomic application
rates.
Please see Section 6 for the enclosed composting area exhibits.
3.2 Bulking Agent Receiving and Processing
The proposed compost piles required the incorporation of a bulking agent. The bulking agent
must consist of chipped yard trash debris (green waste) and mixed at a ratio of 3 -to -1 (yard
trash to biosolids). When possible the bulking agent will be brought on-site in .a suitable
chipped form, however, Sunbreak Farm is capable of processing the material on-site. Weight
of materials will be recorded at the front office of the farm. The amount of bulking agent
brought on-site will be quantified by the shipping contractors and report to the farms front office
prior to being placed on-site. All loads will be inspected for suitable materials. Any
unacceptable materials will be hauled off-site to the appropriate disposal facility. Additionally,
the processed yard trash is required to form a 12° base sayer that will optimize the passive
windrow aeration,
ENGINEERING DESIGN & C O N S T R U C T I O N_ INC
CIVIL ENGINEERS 8& SURVEYORS SPECIALIZING IN LAND DEVELOPMENT
10;50 SW Wiese Porhm, Suite 201
Poll Sl. Lucie, FL 94987
712-462.2456
Page 8
P296
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
(ro'VExp C�
.lune 12, 2017
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
Southeast District Office
3301 Gun Club Road, MSC 7210-1
West Palm Beach, FL 33406
561-681-66.00
RE: Sunbreak Farms, LLC; FDEP File No. FLA979830-001-DWI S
To whom it may concern:
On May 11, 2017, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (the "Department") issued an i
"Intent to Issue;" which states that the Department intends to issue a permit to Sunbreak Farms, LLC
("Applicant"), for the construction and operation of a Type 1 Biosolids Management Facility ("Proposed
Facility") on property located at 5101 Minute Maid Road, Ft. Pierce, located in both St. Lucie County and
Indian River County. On May 16, 2017,.Indian River County (the "County") received a copy .of the
Department's Intent to Issue. The County's deadline for filing a petition for a formal administrative f
hearing concerning the Proposed Facility was 5:00 p.m. on May 30, 2017. After the County submitted a
Request for Enlargement of Time to File Petition for Administrative Hearing, the Department extended
the.deadline to 5:00 p.m. on June I2s'.
Although the County appreciates both the extension of time granted by the Department and the
opportunity to meet with the Applicant; the County still has concerns with the Proposed Facility and its
impact on the Indian. River Lagoon and potential impacts on groundwater. The County isconcerned
about the discharge and potential leaching from the Proposed Facility and what .appears to be lenient
Department permit discharge reporting criteria and maximum biosolid limits within said discharge. The
County has requested from the Applicant detailed information on how the biosolid containment cells will
be constructed, where the water will discharge to when the biosolid containment cells reach maximum
stormwater holding capacity, and where the ultimate discharge of the Proposed Facility is located.
However, at this time the County does not believe that it has gathered enough information in this brief
period of time to file a petition for an administrative hearing. The County, therefore, expects the staff
experts at the Department to ensure that the Applicant complies with the requirements of'the permit, the
Florida Administrative Code, Florida Statutes and federal environmental laws.
In the event, a petition for administrative hearings is filed by another party, the County wishes to preserve
its rights to raise these issues, and others, if left unaddressed by the Applicant and file a motion to
intervene per section 28-106.205, Florida Administrative Code. The County also retains the right to raise
these issues, with respect to any South Florida Water Management District permit.
rely,
laso_ rmi
n
Cou ty istrator
OFFICE OF THE COUNTYADMMISTRA TOR
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
180127" SOM, Vero Beach, F1 32960-3388
PHONE: 772-226-1408 - FAX: 772-978-1822
NNM
RECEIVED
1June 12—,2-0-1-71
STATE OF FLORIDA Dept. of Wronmentel Protection
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION Office of General Counsel
ST. LUCIE COUNTY,
Petitioner,
VS. OGC File No. 17-0251
SUNBREAK FARMS, LLC and
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION,
Respondents.
ST. LUCIE COUNTY'S
.PETITION FOR FORMAL ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING
Petitioner, St. Lucie county, Florida (the "County"),
acting through the Board of County Commissioners of St. Lucie
Cb-dnty, respectfully submits this petition for a formal
administrative hearing, pursuant to theFloridaDepartment of
Environmental Protection's order Granting.Request for Extension
of Time, and in accordance with Sections 120.56-9., 1.20.5711), and
403.412(5), Florida Statutes, and Rule 28-106.2..01,. Florida
Administrative Code ("F.A.C."). This petition concerns the
intent to issue a permit (the "Intent to 1"ue',') and.draft
Domestic Wastewater Facility Permit (the "Draft Permit,) that
FDEP issued to Sunbreak Farms, LLC (the "Applicant"), fpt the,
construction and operation of a Type I Bios-olids.- Management
Facility (the "Type I Biosolids Management Facility" or
I
P299
"Proposed Facility") on property located at 5101 Minute Maid
Road in St. Lucie County,. Florida. In support of this petition,
the County states:
The Parties
1. ' Petitioner, St. Lucie County, is a political
subdivision of the State of Florida and its main office is
located at 2.300 Virginia Avenue, Ft. Pierce, Florida 34982. For
the purposes of this proceeding; all legal papers and
correspondence should be served upon the County's environmental
counsel, Mr. David. S. Dee, and a copy provided to the County
Attorney's Office in care of Ms. Katherine Barbieri: The
contact information for Mr. -Dee is provided on the last page of
this petition. The contact information for Ms. Barbieri is
provided in the Certificate of Service, which is attached to
this petition. The telephone number for the County Attorney's
Office is (772) 462-1420.
i
2. Respondent, the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (the "Depart'ment:" or '"FDEP"), is an agency of the
.State of Florida. The Department's address is 3900 Commonwealth
Boulevard, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2400. The telephone
number for the Department's Office of General Counsel is (850)
24:5-2242.
2
P300
3. Respondent, Sunbreak Farms, LLC, is the applicant
seeking the issuance of the Draft Permit for the Proposed
Facility.
Notice of Agency Action
4.. On May 11, 2017, the County received a copy of the
Department's Intent to Issue the Draft Permit (FDEP Fil.e.No.
FLA979830-001-DWIS). The Department's Intent to Issue states
that anyone wishing to challenge the Department's proposed
agency action must file a petition for a formal administrative
hearing, or. a request for an extension of time to file a
petition, with the Department's Clerk in the Office of General
Counsel no later than 14 days after the Intent to Issue is
received. On May 23, 2017, the County timely filed "St. Lucie
County's Request for Enlargement of Time to File P-e,tition for
Administrative Hearing." On June 7., 2017; the Department issued
its "Order Granting Request for Extension of Time.," which
granted the County an extension of time to file a petition in
this .matter until 5 p.m. on June 12.., 2017'. Since. this petition
is being filed before the FDEP4s deadline, this petition is
timely.
Background
5.. If the Draft Permit becomes ..final., the Applicant will
be authorized to construct and operate the Type I Biosolids
Management Facility in unincorporated areas of St.. Lucie County
3
P301
and Indian River County, Florida. The Proposed Facility will
accept and process "biosolids," which is defined by FDEP to mean
the "solid, semisolid, or liquid residue generated during the
treatment of domestic wastewater in a domestic wastewater
treatment facility. . . (formerly known as residuals). See
FDEP Rule 62-540.200(.6), F.A.C. More specifically, the Draft
Permit would authorize the Facility to receive and process Class
B biosolids, other.organic wastes (e.g., chicken and anima.,
manure), and bulking agents to produce up to 500 dry tons per
day of Class AA biosolids. To produce this quantity of Class AA
biosolids, it appears the Proposed Facility may receive up to
2,500 wet tons (5,004,00:0 pounds) of biosolids each day.
6. The Proposed Facility will be constructed and operated
on a parcel ,of land (the "Site") that is approximately 6,580
acres in size and primarily located in the unincorporated areas
of St. Lucie County. The Site is in the watershed of the St.
Lucie River, which the Florida Legislature has identified as one
of the "critical-wate`.r. resources o.f the state." Fla. Stat. §_
373.4595(1)(x). Surface water runoff and other discharges from
the Site will drain into the estuary of the St. Lucie River (the
"Estuary") visa the C-25 canal and Taylor Creek. The Estuary has
been designated as an "izripaired water" by FDEP because the water
quality .in the.Estuary_fails to Comply with the state standards
for Class III surface waters, which were "established to protect
In
P302
fish consumption, recreation and the propagation and maintenance
of a healthy, well-balanced population of fish and wildlife."
FDEP:Rule 62-302.400(4), F.A.C. The poor water quality in the
Estuary is caused in part by excessive amounts of nitrogen and
phosphorus that drain into the Estuary from upstream areas,
including agricultural lands. Given these water quality
problems, the Florida Legislature established various programs
and requirements for the protection of the St. Lucie River
watershed and the Estuary. See, e.g.., Fla. Stat. §�
373.4595(l), (4), (5), and (8). Notwithstanding these efforts
by the Legislature, and notwithstanding the efforts of the FDEP
to.implement the Legislature's directives, the Estuary and .the
downstream waters .in the Indian River Lagoon (the "Lagoon") have
experienced major algae blooms in recent years. These algae
blooms have been unprecedented in their scope and severity,
causing large areas of the Estuary and Lagoon to becoveted in
thick mats of toxic blue-green algae. The impacts were
devastating to the local ecosystems and dramatically reduced the
usb .of the Estuary and Lagoon for.fishing, boating, and other
recreational purposes. Indeed, the County declared a "State of
Local Emergency" in 2016 and 2017, pursuant to Section
252.38(.3), Florida Statutes, based on the Countyrs determination
that the algae in the local waterways. posed ;a danger to health,
5
P303
life; property, and the economic well-being of St. Lucie County
residents.
7. The County is concerned the Applicant's proposed Type
I Biosolids Management Facility will have significant adverse
impacts on the County, its property, and the natural resources
located in the. County, including but not limited to the Estuary.
Accordingly, the County retained a professional engineering and
consulting firm, CDM Smith, to assist the County with its review
of the Draft Permit. CDM Smith's engineers and other
professionals have .extensive experience with biosolids and
biosolicls maxiaggetnerit facilities. CDM Smith has reviewed the
Department's.files for the proposed Type I Biosolids Management
Facility, including Sunbreak Farms' permit application and the
Draft Permit, but CDM Smith still has unresolved questions and
concerns about .the 'Proposed Facility and the Draft Permit:,
St.. Lucie County's Verified Petition
8. St. Lucie County is. a political subdivision of the
State of Florida and., pur'suaLtit to Section 403.412 (5) , Florida
Statutes, St..Luci.e County has standing to initiate a formal
administrative hearing by filing a verified petition asserting
that the activity to.be licensed or permitted will have the
effect of impairing, polluting, or otherwise injuring the air,
water, :.or other, natural resources of the State. In .the instant
case, St. Lucie .County asserts that the proposed activity to be
0
P304
permitted by FDEP will have such effects, unless the Proposed
Facility is.properly located, designed, built, operated,
maintained, and regulated. Unfortunately, the Applicant's
submittal to the FDEP appears to be unclear, incomplete, and
internally inconsistent in certain respects, and thus does not
provide reasonable assurance that the Proposed Facility will
comply with all of the applicable statues and FDEP rules. The
County's essential assertions about these matters are verified
by Dr. K. Richard Tsang, Ph.D., P..E., B.C.E.E. Dr. Tsang is a
licensed Professional Engineer in Florida and three other
states, he has many years of experience with .the management of
biosolids, and he is a Senior Vice President of :CDM Smith. Dr.
Tsang's affidavit is attached her'e.to as Exhibit A and
incorporated herein.
St. Lucie County's Substattial Interests
9. In addition to having standing in this case under
Section 403.412(5), Florida Statutes; S . Lucie County also has
standing because the proposed Type I Bib8bli:ds Management
Facility and the proposed activities to be:permitted by the FDEP
could reasonably be expected to adversely 'affect the County's
substantial interests. As noted above, the Proposed Facility is
located within the watershed of the St..LtiiCie River and the Site
drains into the Estuary. The surface water runoff from the
Bite, as well as the water that may be pumped from the 640 -acre
7
P305
stormwater reservoir on the Site, may cause or contribute to
water quality violations in the Estuary. It appears that the
Applicant's existing permits would allow the Applicant to
discharge up to 190,000 gallons of water per minute (273,600,000
gallons per day) from the Site. The discharges from the 'Site
could reason -ably be expected to increase the nutrient loading to
the St. Lucie River watershed and thus exacerbate the water
quality problems in the Estuary.
10, The County has four public parks that could be -
adversely affected by the Applicant's proposed activities.
First, the County owns and operates the Harbour Pointe Park on a.
20 -acre parcel of land that is bordered on two sides by the
Estuary. The Harbour Pointe Park is adjacent to the mouth of
Taylor 'Creek - i.e., the location where the surface water
discharges frbM the Site will leave Taylor Creek and enter the
Estuary. Second, the County operates Wesley's Island Park on a
Stato=owned island 'that is in the Estuary and relatively close
to the: .mouth of Taylor Creek. Third, the County owns and
operates the South Causeway Island Park, which has a lengthy
border abutting the Estuary, relatively close to the mouth of
Taylor Creek. Fourth, the County leases and operates,.C.00n
,Island., another island in the Estuary.
1.1. All four of these properties- (i.e,., Harbour Pointe
Park; 'Wesley's Island Park; South Causeway Island Park; Coon
M
P306
Island) are maintained and operated by the County. The County
has removed exotic vegetation, provided shelters and amenities,
and taken other steps to promote the public's use of these four
properties. The County's goal is to enhance the, environmental
and social value of these properties so that they are an
attractive destination for the County's residents and tourists,
who use these.properties.for various purposes, including but not
limited to fishing, boating, birdwatching, and picnicking.
12. The County's substantial interests in these four
properties would be materially and adversely affected by the
Proposed Facility if the Facility's surface water discharges
cause or contribute to water quality violations and toxic algae
blooms in the Estuary. The County's residents and tourists will
curtail their use of the County's properties if the Estuary
again experiences a massive algae bloom that turns the water
green, coats the shoreline with ,gelatinous mats of toxic blue-
green algae, kills the fish and _other aquatic creatures, and
causes respiratory distress _for humans in the vicinity of the
Estuary. Under such circumstances, the County's substantial
interests also will be adversely affected because the County
will need to clean-up the shoreline bordering its four
properties. The clean-up.will require the County to expend its
time, energy, money, and other resources. The clean-up will
place the County's employees and%.or contractors at risk because
2
P307
they will be exposed to the algae, dead fish, and other dead and
dying organisms along the shoreline of the Estuary.
Disputed Issues of Material Fact
13. Based on its. preliminary review of the Applicant's
permit application, the relevant FDEP files, and the Draft
Permit, the County has identified the following disputed issues
of material fact in this case:
a. Whether the Applicant has provided reasonable
assurance that the activities to be authorized by
the Draft Permit will comply with all of the
applicable FDEP rules and statutes.
b. Whether the Applicant has provided reasonable.
assurance that the activities to .be authorized by
the Draft Permit will not cause or contrbute.to
violations of the FDEP water quality standards,
for surface water or groundwater,
c. Whether the Applicant has provided reasoziable
assurance that the activities to be authorized .by
the Draft Permit will not increase the nutrient
loading in the St. Lucie River watershed,
including but not limited to the Estuary_
d. Whether the Applicant has provided reasonable
assurance that the activities to be authorized by
10
P308
the Draft. Permit will not cause violations of the
FDEP prohibition against objectionable odors.
e. Whether the general and specific conditions in
the Draft Permit provide reasonable assurance
that the activities authorized by the Draft
Permit will be conducted in compliance with the
applicable FDEP rules.
f. Whether, and the extent to which, the Applicant
will discharge nutrient -enriched water from the
Site pursuant`to the Applicant,, s existing
Environmental Puesource Permit (ERP No. 56-00111-
5) ,
The County reserves its right to raise additional disputed
issues of material fact and law that may be identified in the
future as a result of the County's further review of the FDEP
files or discovery conducted in this case.
Statement Of Ultimate Facts Entitling St.. Lucie County to Relief
14. The Applicant has not provided reasonable assurance
that the proposed construction and operation of the -Type I
Biosolids Mamagement Fadility will domply with all applicable
FDEP rules, including but not limited to Chapter 62-640, F.A.C.
Among other things, it appears the activities to be authorized
by the Draft Permit may -result in objectionable odors,
discharges of nutrient -enriched water to surfare waters in the
li
P309
St. Lucie River watershed, and violations of water quality
standards in the Estuary. It also appears the general and
specific conditions in the Draft Permit do not provide
reasonable assurance that the activities authorized by the Draft
Permit will be conducted in compliance with the applicable FDEP
requirements.
Statutes and Rules Entitling St. Lucie County to Relief
15. St. Lucie County is entitled to relief in this case
pursuant to Chapters 120, 373, and 403, Florida Statutes, and
Chapters 62-4,, 62-302, 62-520, and 62-640, F.A._C.. Aimong.other
things, it appears that the proposed activities to be authorized
by the, Draft Permit may result in violations of: (a} the FDEP
prohibition against objectionable odors, as set forth in FDEP
Rules 6.2-640.400(6) and 62-296.32°0(2). F.A.C. (b) the'FDEP
surface water or ground water quality standards, as set forth in
FDEP Rules 62-640.400(2), F.A.C., and Chapters 62-302 and 62-
520,
2-520; F.A.C.; and (c) the FDEP prohibition against actin ties
that cause an increase in the nitrogen or phosphorus loadings in
the watershed of the St. Lucie River., as set forth in 'FDEP Rule
62-640.400(12), F.A.C. and Section 373.4595, Florida Statutes.
Relief Requested
DliEREFORE, St. Lucie County respectfully requests
1.2
P310
a. the Department to forward this petition to the
Division of Administrative Hearings for the assignment of axi
Administrative Law Judge;
b. the Administrative Law Judge to conduct a formal
administrative hearing pursuant to Sections 120.569 and
120.57(1), Florida Statutes;
C. the Administrative Law Judge to issue a recommended
order denying the Applicant's permit application or modifying
the Draft Permit; and
d. the Department to issue a final order denying the
Applicant's permit application or.modifying the Draft Permit.
Respectfully submitted this 12th day of June, 2017.
GARDNER, BIST, BOWDEN, BUSH,
DEE, LAVIA & WRIGHT, P. A.
David S. Dee
Florida Bar No. 281999
ddqe@gbwlegal.com
John, T. LaVia, III
Florida Bar No. 853666
jlavia@gbwlegal.com
1300 Thomaswood Drive
Tallahassee, FL 32308
Phone: (8,50) 385-0070
Fax: (850) 385-5416
ATTORNE-Y.-S FOR ST. LUCIE
COUNTY
13
P311
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy ofthe foregoing
was served electronically this 12th day of June, 2017, to:
Francine Ffolkes (Francine.ffolkes@dep.state.fl.us)
Kirk White (kirk.white@dep.state.fl.us;
dep.enforcement@dep.state.fl.us),
Logan.Whiddon@dep.state.fl.us),
Department of Environmental Protection
3900 Commonwealth Blvd., Mail Station 35
Tallahassee; Florida 32399-3000
Bruce Kay (bruce.kay@dep.state.fl.us)
Department of Environmental Protection
Southeast District
3301 Gun Club Road, MSC7210-1
West Palm Beach, Florida 33406
Katherine Barbieri (Barbierik@stluciec.o.org)
St. Lucie County Attorney's Office
23°00, Virginia Avenue
Fort Pierce, .Florida 34982
Dennis Corrick (DCorrick@deanmead.com)
Dean, Mead, Minton & Zwemer
1903 South 25th Street, Suite 200,,
Fort Pierce, Florida 34947
Attorney
14
P312
Exhibit A
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
ST. LUCIE COUNTY, )
}
Petitioner, }
Vs. ) OGC File No. 17-0251
}
SUNBREAK FARMS, LLC. and }
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT }
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION, )
Respondents. }
AFFIDAVIT OF DR. K. RICHARD TSANG
STATE OF: NORTH CA-AotiNA
COUNTY OF: WAKE
BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared
Dr. K. Richard.Ts.ang, Ph:.:U., P._E:, B.C.E.E., who after being
first duly sworn, depose.s and.states as follows:
1. My name is Dr. K. Richard Tsang and I have personal
knowledge of the matters set forth herein.
2_ I am over eighteen (1:$) years of age and otherwise
competent to testify,
3. I an a licensed. Professional Engineer in Florida and I
am employed by CDM Smith. CAM Smith is 'a full-service
engineering and professional consulting 'firm that has been
retained by St. Ld.cie County to as.bist. the County in its review
of the Florida Departirkoht, of Environmental Protection ("FDEP")
file (FDEP File No., FIA979.8:30=001-DWIS) and .draft permit ("Draft
I
P313
Exhibit A
Permit") concerning Sunbreak Farms, LLC's proposed Type I
Biosolids Management Facility in St. Lucie County, Florida. I
am making the statements herein as a Senior vice President of
CDM Smith, in reliance on the work performed and information 1
1
obtained by me and other professionals employed by CDM Smith.
St. Lucie County authorized me to make the statements herein in F
support of the verified petition for formal administrative
hearing that is being filed by St. Lucie County with FDEP.
4. As a general proposition, a Type I Biosolids
i
Management Facility located in St. Lucie County, Florida, will
i
impair, pollute, or otherwise injure the air, water,, and other
natural resources of the State of Florida, unless the facility
is properly located, designed, constructed, operated,
F
maintained, and monitored. In the instant case,, the application
filed by Sunbreak Farms, LLC, and the Draft Permit issued by the n
FDEP are not entirely clear about.the activities authorized by
the Draft Permit or the requirements imposed on those activities
by E.DEP.: Consequently, it appears that Sunbreak.Farms, LLC, has
not. provided reasonable assurance that the activities to: be
F
authorized b the Draft Permit will com.l..
y p y .faith all of the i
applicable: FDEP requirements. Based on GDM Smith's preliminary
review of the FDEP file and Draft Permit concerning the Type I
Bios:olids Management Facility proposed by sunbresk E`arnts, LLC.;
it appears that the activities to be authorized by the Draft
2
i
7
P314
Exhibit A
Permit may have the effect of impairing, polluting, or otherwise
injuring the air, water, or other natural resources of the State
of Florida.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.
By: K. RICHARD
Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of June,#
2017, by K..RICHARD.TSANG, -who personally appeared before me. And
did take an Oath, K. RICHARD TSANG - is personally known'to
me orproduced Yiyt.�SQ�� as identification.
.0
Votar Public
rint Name:
-A.commission Expires: 6).?
3
P315
Smith
Memorandum
To: Ms. Katherine Barbieri
From: Jill Grimaldi, BCES
K. Richard Tsang, Ph.D., PE, BCES
Date: May 1b, 2017
Subject: Review Comments on Sunbreak Farms
St. Lucie County (County) is in the process of developing an ordin ce'�i O'',Sed to regulate commercial
composting facilities within unincorporated areas of the County. While tK6N :bance`will not be
'Jt
presented to the Commission for several weeks, a Notice - tint to Issue h"s.'gWublished by the
Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDER ora . that is bei rj ,proposed in the
County. CDM Smith has reviewed the application, aloffers J�trarvindr.inf8tmation_
The application was made by Sunbreak -
Residuals/Septage Management Facili Q
proposed project is dgs¢e a
■ Located tt 5101 Minut
K�
•
WAR
farm, including
1'A1;M �a/irrigation water
10111
. SO
S, LLC, forme` k"p'ta�'n��a'`as Cloud Grove, for a
EP's applicati�rr br domestic wastewater facilities. The
jt`'Qn as follows:
Ft.c' FL 34945
abo a ground impoundment for storage of
■ Agri �rf peration inclu f on composting of aerobically digested and dewatered
Class B bi> with yard. aste (no liquid biosolids will be accepted).
■ Yard waste t fid and mixed at a ratio of 3 -parts yard waste to 1 -part biosolids
■ Land applicatioif resulting Class AA product on Sunbreak Farms property
• Biosolids to be obtained primarily from municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTP)
■ Design to accept 500 dry tons per day (5 -day operation)
• Composting via modified aerated static pile (MASP) method and application of proprietary
organic catalyst
Application Comme ts.doet
P316
Ms. Katherine Barbieri
May 16, 2017
Page 2
■ Proposed temperature control in excess of FDEP's required 131 degrees Fahrenheit
■ Vector attraction via temperature control and/or reduction of volatile solids, as well as turning
windrow piles as needed
■ Incorporation of applied compost into soil within 6 hours of application, typically
CDM SMITH COMMENTS ON APPLICATION DOCUMENTS
RECEIVING, MIXING, PROCESSING
1. All receiving, storage, mixing and composting activities ear to be "iro os outdoor
activities (no enclosed building).
��
2. The MSAP Composting method, as stated in the applicatind to provide ' , re
uniform/stable temperatures and oxygen levels within theypiles. does tend to reduce the
need for mechanical agitation of the piles, thereby reducing poten dial to be
disturbed and tracked by vehicles. This method s for longer ned periods of
higher temperatures within the piles. This a Aerate verall pro s; however, it also
makes the piles more susceptible to smolde° anon s�., _ ire incidents.
3. Composting method — the MSAP m 'propose -'pear 'o ave been practiced in other
places. Composting will be outclobjn piles, and :,p lar' s surface. This will violate the
z
proposed ordinance requireme c7�ultiple areas.
4. The propos �oiitf3posting�11
ni' ilize urning to provide the needed oxygen. The
_..c .
ITI
conven6nal aerated step composto.' od utilizes blowers to maintain the piles
aero .This is not propos #e1. CDM S�" isnot familiar with the catalysts being proposed,
rri� g
b, <,taintainin aerobic con ;a% is criti 'I in the piles..Pile turning, particularly in the early
�. composting can oft "'suit in odor issues. : -
S. The t is proposing to He the windrow areas with a yard trash mix to form a 12 -inch
thick basase, as stby the applicant, is intended to absorb free liquids from
biosolids. S ht detpul is not provided to determine if free liquids would be fully contained in
this layer, ora oiefi�p'percolate through into the land surface.
6. Page 10 of the 9Arations Plan states that staff will mix the biosolids and yard waste thoroughly
to form the windrow piles; no specific detail is given for how the mixing will be performed
without disturbing the base layer described above.
7. The applicant should further clarify if the curing area (identified to be separate from the active
composting area) will consist of a similar base/pad, or be in direct contact with land surface.
ApplIe ion CommenKdo
P317
Ms. Katherine Barbieri
May 16, 2017
Page 3
END USE OF COMPOST
1. The operations plan indicates that the compost material will be "for on-farm use only" and will
be generated on an "as -needed basis to meet demand of normal farm operations." The plan
further states, however, that if"there are any bkzsoUdyorcompost materials on-site that
exceed the farm's fertilization needs, these materials will be given away ... to an acceptable
agricultural operation.' The applicant would be required to obtain additional approvals to do so
(listed in the rat | "licensing").
2. The application indicates that all compost produced will s on is unclear if the farm
has demands equivalent to the rated capacity it can pro as pro s ton/acre
number is quoted in the plan but it is unclear if this is th H in nu If i e nt
'bd thus
frequency. It is also unclear how much of the approximat acres ill b M.
can use compost (vs. the portions used for maintenance, st 'ions,
roadways, buildings, etc.).
1 The applicant is proposing to "caV the win pile screpne0iosolids or ground yard
trash in an effort to abate odor generation : I ilte h on unofficially defines
"unscreened" biosolids as material t asi6t Y'le 'een sc to remove oversized wood
residuals from the finished Weenal. Th! ditio woody material may or may not
hen mixed ds. A cap consisting of solely woody
material (no integrated bio! function more effectively as a biofilter.
ap @16AW C-`56 ces the need for mechanical turning of the
21-149'erefoore red -1
piles enelrat __r y allowing the cap layer to remain intact and
a b -odor); however, in th contr , ection of the Operations Plan, 2 of the 3 identified
ors to odors are to be remedied by "windrow turnin&" which seems
*tribut
gi
c Pry. CDM Smith ac ledges that MSAP does not fully eliminate the need for
turni ver it is unclea, he limited turning required for MSAP would be sufficient to
addres dors cann imultaneously be addressed by not turning (to lessen odor
genera ion) in remedy generated odors) windrow piles.
1. Existing Environmental Resource Permit (ERP)No. 56-00111-S was transferred from Cloud Grove
to Sunbreak Farms in2016. This ERP allows for discharging of water from agricultural lands
(SunbreekFanns)totheC'25canm|xystemxiaone10,OO8gprnandnine201]OOgpmpumps. It is
unclear from the preliminary review of readily available permit transfer documents,if this
discharge has been maintained for use by Sunbreak Farms. If the discharge is being maintained,
there is a significant potential for transfer of surface water from the project site to the C-25
Appfi=tionmmments.dom
Ms. Katherine Barbieri
May 16, 2017
Page 4
canal/surface water system. CDM Smith would require additional review time to confirm the
intent and configuration of this discharge arrangement. ...
2. The application excludes information pertaining to Section 3.A. of the form, "Discharges to
Surface Waters." If the ERP mentioned above is being maintained, there is a significant potential
for offsite discharge. Applicant should be asked to clarify operation.
3. Overflow for the 640 -acre impoundment is identified as discharge t the Minute Maid Canal
(with ultimate discharge to the C-25 Canal). Again, no disc
ter information is
provided in the application form. This appears to be an a lication d or inconsistency
in the documents that should be clarified.
4. Applicant states that perimeter berms willfully, contain t ear, 3 -day s
and
that "no discharge from the compost areas to either the f rimet r ditch 11 occur."
Applicant should clarify what runoff is being stored in the'0-a oundment (and
potentially discharged offsite) if not from the compost areas.
S. Regulatory -agencies typically require a pre- v n pollutan PRad analysis prior to
Issuance of drainage permits. It is unclear, r tha e tIo7ed above, if other
stormwater permits have been secured or iior ater rt
as been prepared in suppo
of such a permit. The pollutart load' A. alysisty ally in es nutrient loading calculations
i I o a
that are of interest to the Count' wit . . . . . .
�y 1, itive St. Lucie Watershed.
%�pjrpecially h,
6. Page 15 of the
the water wA
, V!o Wfi 6400
13 " piles be A
l detail should b';";"i
is action. Specifically,
0 e areas to ensure
Mat if staff observe ponding within the windrow areas,
Ate,,
it WN
grit areas, and that "in no case shall runoff from the
arj"V
elt' - y to an adjacent farm ditch or off-site."
to d - ibe the "other containment area(s)" to be utilized
oullbe!provided on what safeguards will be in place in
*e is no direct contact with offsite discharge.
3. It is assumes ftre� e description in the Operations Plan, the "catalyst" is safe not only for
plants, as stateificrops intended for human consumption. This is understood to be a
proprietary enzy hat produces bacteria or fungus, which accelerates the composting
process; howev no details are given addressing long-term buildup of the byproduct within the
site soils or impacts to surface waters. .
4. Water Use Permit (WUP) No. 56-00111-W was transferred to Sunbreak Farms in 2016 and
expires In 2025. The permit allows for withdrawal of irrigation water from the Upper Floridan
Aquifer via two, 500 feet deep (approximately) wells rated at 100 gallons per minute (gpm). A
fu II review of the site modeling would be required to confirm impacts on surface waters from
Amfic*bn CommentLd=
P319
Ms. Katherine Barbieri
May 16, 2017
Page 5
pumping wells at this depth, but hydrogeology in the area, coupled with the modeling review
that was likely completed by SFWMD would indicate that the impact on'wrface Waters from this
withdrawal would be negligible. The WUP also allows for withdrawal from the C-25 canal via
one, 24 -inch axial flow pump rated for 18,000 gpm to meet irrigation water demands.
5. The applicant states in the Operations Plan dated May 2017, that the two onsite groundwater
wells are "not associated with potable water." CDM Smith was not able to confirm in the short
review period what year these wells were constructed in. CD oul commend
confirming the well construction details to ensure that th n AM. -I Kr 'head components
are located above the 100 -year flood elevation on the p Z,p`.:ty as c configured.
Wellhead components that lie below the flood plain elelion prW I condjuit for
41 e a
downward flow of surface waters into the well, thereby potential to ation
of the aquifer with surface water. Additionally, well constr etalls weren 11
available. Older agricultural wells are occasional construdMffd - - - - - le tool methods, which do
not provide a proper sanitary seal between the various aquifers b land
Aurface and total
depth of the well (in this case, 500 feet +J-). Mor. rnmethods stallation (rotary
mud and reverse air) doprovide this sanita 11
would lessen 4epotential for cross
contamination of aquifers. Any potential nwa o - f rface waters on a site of
this nature, introduces the potential forc I c "amin
the underground source of
drinking water if proper seals and s girds are in pla uch migration could have future
impacts on neighboring agric Itputal sers of the a, Smith would request additional
time to review well constructio ils.
6. The most
amount
man stormwater, as wlaii
with the use of berms
5 percent solids ranE
to tons of this mates
colle storage withc
minimal lied. The at
via
MONITORING, TESTIN
1. Proposed actl%
requirements.
GENERAL COMMENTS
issue Mt'
propose project ct is the handling of such large
bas area irT . . . . . . . . . 006. It is unclear how the applicant can effectively
ls;.
achate, f vent surface and ground water contamination
icalde tered blosolids from plants in FL are very wet, mostly
lnificant amounts of leachate will be generated by handling up
aily. This leachate will also contain high BOD and nutrients;
treatment would not be sufficient. Surface water runoff is
ication does not discuss potential impacts related to ground water
KEEPING
in this section of the Operations Plan appear to be consistent with regulatory
1. The application repeatedly states that the facility will only accept and compost blosollds in
quantities necessary to meet farming demands. Municipalities require reliable disposal options
for biosolids, no attention has been given in the application to how the contracts will be secured
Application CommerftsA=
Ns. Katherine Barbieri
May 16, 2017
Page 6
or what will be required of municipalities delivering biosolids in the event that there is nota
need for deliveries it the Sunibreak Farms site on a given day.
l The proposed capacity of this facility is huge. Permit application states 500 dry ton per day.
Asaum|nQ6ioso|ids are dewatenedtu2U percent (which most facilities inFLdonot),there will be
2,500 wet tons of biosolids coming to the site. Assuming a truck load holds 20 ton, thenamH|/be
1"25 truckloads to the site per day. This is just for biosolids. Yard waste is proposed to be mixed
inoratio of3:1(yard waste tobimsoU6s).The burden on existing roadways, as well asaccess to
the interior ofthe site should belooked atwith this level o i��°c~^ffeyintruck traffic.
itbthe opnkonof CDM Smith that additional information
further detail the issues ofodor control, stovnwvater
apparent inconsistencies within the application.
cc: Mr. Dan McIntvre. Countv
P.A.
Dylan Reingold, County Attorney
William K. DeBraal, Deputy County Attorney
Kate Pingolt Cotner, Assistant County Attorney
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
Ofce of
INDIAN
MEMORANDUM
Board of County Commissioners
Dylan Reingold, County Attorne�
June 13, 2017
Code Enforcement Board Appointment
Attorney's Matters - B. CC 06.20.17
RIVER COUNTY
ATTORNEY
On September 13, 2011, the Board of County Commissioners adopted Resolution 2011-072, which assigned
to the County Attorney's Office the task of monitoring certain committee member terms, and overseeing the
process of appointments and reappointments. This agenda item is to consider the appointment of an applicant
to fill the "Member at Large" vacancy on the Code Enforcement Board, which term expires in January 2020.
The vacancy has been advertised on the County's website and on Channel 27 in excess of 30 days. The
following is the name of the qualified applicant for this position, whose rdsum6 and application is available
for review in the Commissioners' Front Office area:
Bruce Allan Redus
RECOMMENDATION.
The County Attorney recommends that the Board review the applicant's rdsume and application, and
determine whether to appoint him to fill the unexpired term for the "Member at Large" representative to the
Code Enforcement Board.
ATTACHMENTS
Application
Resume
F;Nttoroey\Christina\COMMTPI MGeneml Matters\BCC Agenda Memos\170620 Committee Appointment (CEB)- RedULdoa
P322
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY APPLICATION
FOR COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT
Name: Bruce Allan Redus Date: 05/08111
Full Name. Bruce Allan RedusEmail Address: brucearedus@gmaii.com
Street Address (No. P.O. Boxes): 99 Springlake Drive #102 Vero Beach, Florida 32962
Home Phone: 772-492-9336 Work Phone: N/A
Cell Phone: 772-559-5404
How long have you been a resident of Indian River County? 2yrs/3mos
Are you a full or part time resident? Check one: Full Time V Part Time
Please list current employer or business- If refired, please list any business experience that may be
applicable to the committee.
Previous resident 1986-92; refired. Past employment as mid-level manager/director in
businessleommunity/economic development. Prior to retirement served as Community
Development Director supervised three departments -Planning & Zoning/Building/Code
Enforcement.
Please list any licenses you presently hold:
None.
Please list any organization of which you are currently a member.
None other than homeownership in the Vista Royale HOA.
Please list any other committees or boards you currently sit on:
None.
Continued on next page
o03
P323
Place a check mark next to the committee(s) you would like to serve on:
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE
❑
AGRICULTURE ADVISORY COMMITTEE
BEACH & SHORE PRESERVATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
CHILDREN'S SERVICES ADVISORY COMMITTEE
El
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT
CONSTRUCTION BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT & APPEALS
F1
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
ENTERPRISE ZONE DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
0
ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL HEARING BOARD
-
El
MPO BICYCLE ADVISORY COMMITTEE
MPO CITIZEN ADVISORY COMMITTEE
NEIGHBORHOOD STABILIZATION PROGRAM — CITIZEN ADVISORY TASK
FORCE
PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION
SCHOOL PLANNING CITIZEN OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
TOURIST DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
TRANSPORTATION DISADVANTAGED LOCAL COORDINATING BOARD
TREASURE COAST REGIONAL PLANNING COUNCIL — COMPREHENSIVE
.ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY
Please print and return the completed application, along with a current resume, to the Board of
County Commission office, 1801 27th Street, Vero Beach, FL. 32960, or by fax at 772-770-5334.
Please note. All applications are kept on file for 6 months.
Print
P324
Bruce A. Redus
99 Springlake Drive, Apt. #102
Vero Beach, Fl. 32%2
772492-9336
Business Development
Industrious, dependable retired professional with .excellent communicationforganizational skills with proven
experience in business development/project coordination seeks challenging position to snatch my background and
experience. I possess the ability to promote and build lasting client relationships by responding to client needs with
a focus on customer service and satisfaction. In summary, I have the ability to communicate, facilitate and negotiate
to achieve positive results and a "Win -Win" for all concerned.
CommunitylEconomic Development
During the past 35 .years, my involvement includes community, economic and project development at the executive
director and project manager level wittipublic/public-private partnerships and private sector development requiring
strong communication, coordination and organizational skills at all levels. I have developed an understanding of
various business finance programs, regional cooperation and building .private sector and intergovernmental
relationships. This is important in facilitating new industry recruitment and existing business/industry retention and
expansion. My most recent responsibilities in community development included City Administrator directed
projects and supervising three departments- Planning/Zoning, Building Inspection and Code Enforcement.
Work History (Related)
City of Canon City -Canon City, Colorado
Fremont Economic Development Corporation -Canon City, Colorado
Lake County Board of County Commissioners (Industrial Park) Tavares, Florida
Economic Development Commission of Mid-Florida-Orlaudo, Florida
American Revenue Corporation/Guardian Development Corp. (Industrial Park) -Orlando, Florida
Treasure Coast Private Industry Council -Port St. Lucie, Florida
Indian River County Chamber of Commerce/Council of 1110 -Vero Beach, Florida
Fiasco Development Corporation-Nortlt Palm Beach/Delray Beach, Florida
Community Board/Committee Service {past)
Action 22 .Board (22 Southeast Colorado County Consortium)
Workforce Investment Board (4 Colorado County Consortium)
Cornell Companies Community Relations Board -Carton City, Colorado
Federal Bureau of Prisons Community Relations Committee, Florence, Colorado
Fremont County Airport/Airport Industrial Park Advisory Committee -Fremont County, Colorado
Holcim, Inc. Community Advisory Committee -Portland, Colorado
Pueblo Community College Citizens Advisory Committee -Fremont County, Colorado Campus
Sangre de Cristo Resource and Conservation District Board -Pueblo, Colorado
Southern Colorado Economic Development District Board (12 County Consortium) -Pueblo, Colorado
Town of Sahuarita, Arizona Volunteer Assistant to the Economic Development. Manager
Green Valley/Sahuarita Arizona Chamber of Commerce Economic Development & Gov. Relation Committees
Green Valley Coordinating Council -Planning & Architectural Committee -Green Valley, Arizona
Metropolitan Pima Alliance Economic Development Committee -Tucson, Arizona
Military Service
U.S_ Navy (E -5) -Honorable Discharge
Education
Boulder High School -Boulder,. Colorado (graduate)
University of Central Florida -Orlando, Florida-B.A. Communications (Cum Laude)
University of South Florida -Tampa, Florida -Basic Economic Development Course Syllabus/Certification
U.& Border Patrol (Tucson, Arizona_ Sector) Citizens Academy
Ttgctl
0t9;:�. v:
P325
/&)9
DISTRICT
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
MEMORANDUM
TO: Honorable Emergency Services District Board of Commissioners
THROUGH: John King, Director
Department of Emergency Services
FROM: Brian Burkeen, Assistant Chief
Indian River County Fire Rescue
DATE: June 7, 2017
SUBJECT: Approval of Property Lease Extension for Temporary Location of Fire
Rescue Station No. 7
It is respectfully requested that the information contained herein be given formal consideration by the
Emergency Services District Board of Commissioners.
DESCRIPTION:
On June 23, 2015, Joseph G. Miller and Indian River County entered into a lease agreement for the
use of the property located at 1893 90th Avenue, Vero Beach, Florida to serve as a short term location
for modular Fire -Rescue Station No. 7. On May 2, 2017, Lessor and Lessee entered into an
Amendment to Lease Agreement, reflecting St. Lucie Battery and Tire Company as the Lessor on the
Lease Agreement. The Lease Agreement allows the Lessee to renew the Lease Agreement, at its sole
discretion, for 3 additional one (1) year terms. Staff is requesting to renew the Lease Agreement for
the first one (1) year term, and shall expire on June 23, 2018.
FUNDING:
The lease amount for Fire -Rescue Station No. 7 will remain at $12,000.00 a year.
ITEM
Amount
Account Number
Fire -Rescue Station No. 7 Property
Lease
$12,000.00
11412022-034410
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of the lease extension.
ATTACHMENTS:
Two Original Copies of the Lease Extension Agreement
P326
RENEWAL OF LEASE AGREEMENT
THIS RENEWAL OF LEASE AGREEMENT ("Renewal") is entered into as of the
2& day of June, ' 2017 by and between St. Lucie Battery and Tire Company, a Florida
corporation, ("Lessor") and Indian River County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida
(the "Lessee"):
RECITALS
WHEREAS, on June 23, 2015, Joseph G. Miller and Lessee entered into a lease
agreement (the "Lease Agreement") for the use of the property located at 1893 90th Avenue,
Vero Beach, Florida (the "Leased Premises") to serve as a short term location for a modular Fire
Station #7; and
WHEREAS, on November 2, 2016, Joseph G. Miller, individually, and as Trustee of the
Joseph G. Miller Revocable Living Trust, dated October 2, 1986, deeded the Leased Premises to
Lessor; and
WHEREAS, on May 2, 2017, Lessor and Lessee entered into an Amendment to Lease
Agreement, reflecting St. Lucie Battery and Tire Company as, the Lessor on the Lease
Agreement; and .
WHEREAS, the Lease Agreement allows the Lessee to renew the Lease Agreement, at
its sole discretion, for 3 additional one (1) year terms; and
WHEREAS, it is the intent of the Lessor and the Lessee that the Lease Agreement be
renewed for the first one (1) year term;
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual undertakings herein and other good
and valuable consideration, the receipt and adequacy of which is hereby acknowledged, the
parties agree, as follows:
1. Recitals. The above recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein.
2. Renewal. The Lease Agreement, as amended by the Amendment to Lease Agreement,
shall be renewed for the first one (1) year term, and shall expire on June 23, 2018.
3. All other provisions of the Lease Agreement, as amended by the Amendment to Lease
Agreement, shall remain in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Lessor and Lessee have executed this instrument this 20U' day
of June, 2017.
Page I of 2
P327
Witnessed by:
signature:
Printed name:
signature:
Printed name:
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Dylan Reingold, Esq.
County Attorney
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Joseph E. Flescher, Chairman
Board of County Commissioners
Date Approved:
ATTEST: Jeffrey R. Smith
Clerk of the Court and Comptroller
St. Lucie Battery and Tire y
By: G. Douglas it
Title: President
APPROVED
County Administrator
Page 2 of 2
P328