HomeMy WebLinkAbout4/15/1997� MINUTMATTACHED
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY. FLORIDA
A G E N D A
TUESDAY, APRIL 15, 1997
9:00 A.M. - COUNTY COMMISSION CHAMBER
County Administration Building
1840 25th Street
Vero Beach, Florida
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Carolyn K. Eggert, Chairman (District 2)
John W. Tippin, Vice Chairman (District 4)
Fran B. Adams (District 1)
Caroline D. Ginn (District 5
Kenneth R. Macht (District 3)
9:00 a.m. 1. CALL TO ORDER
James E. Chandler, County Administrator
Charles P. Vitunac, County Attorney
Jeffrey K. Barton, Clerk to the Board
BACKUP
PAGES
2. INVOCATION Mike Oliver
1 st United Methodist
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Comm. Caroline D. Ginn
4. ADDITIONS to the AGENDA/EMERGENCY ITEMS
1. _Item 12, Comments regarding seawall
Lawsuit.
2. _ Item 13-A-2, computer equipment for Board of
County Commissioners.
3. Item 13-A-3, Council of Community services.
4. Item 13-B, Emerging Technologies Forum.
5. Item 13-C, Fairgrounds Advisory subcommittee.
5. PROCLAMATION and PRESENTATIONS
Presentation of Proclamation Designating April 19, 1997
as Great Florida Cleanup Day in Indian River County 1
6. , _ APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Regular Meeting of March 25, 1997
7. CONSENT AGENDA
A. Received & Placed on File in Office of Clerk
to the Board: 1) Report of Convictions, March,
1997, 2) Sebastian River Water Control District
Annual Financial Report, Sept. 30, 1996, and
3) I.R Farms Water Control District Minutes of
the Board of Supervisors' Meetings for the Period
from Oct., 1995 through Sept. 1996
B. Approval of Warrants
(memorandum dated April 3, 1997) 2-8
n
C. Request to Approve Agreements Between the County 1 j"
& MPO and the County & FDEP for Cooperative
Mapping Work
(memorandum dated April 3, 1997) 9-13
7. CONSENT AGENDA (cont'd.): Bo ) -'j FAGS PA
PAGGERES
CKUP
D. Sebastian Water Expansion - Ph. 2 Request
for Execution of Survey Contract
(memorandum dated April 4, 1997) 14-21
E. Award of Bid for Legal Advertising
(memorandum dated April 2, 1997) 22-33
8. CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS and
GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES
None
9:05 A.M. 9. PUBLIC ITEMS
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
First Hearing:. Communications Tower/Antenna-
Proposed LDR Amendments - -
(memorandum dated April 3, 1997) 34-84
B. PUBLIC DISCUSSION ITEMS
None
10. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S MATTERS
None
11. DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS
A. Communift Development
Request to Re -address the State's Proposed North
County Tower Site
(memorandum dated April 3, 1997) 85-89C
B. Emergency Services
None
C. General Services
None
D. Leisure Services
None
E. Office of Management and Budget
None
F. Personnel
None
G. Public Works
1. Resolutions to Provide for the Paving and
Drainage Improvements to and set Public
Hearing Date for: 101 st Ave. between 79th
St. and 87th St. in Vero Lake Estates S/D
(memorandum dated April 2, 1997) 90-119
_
EMACKUP
11. DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS (cont'd.):
PAGES
G. Public Works (cont'd.):
2. Resolutions to Provide for the Paving and
Drainage Improvements to and set Public
Hearing Date for: 60th Ave. South of 45th
St. in Ponderosa Estates Subdivision
(memorandum dated April 1, 1997)
120-133
3. Gifford Park Water & Sewer Improvements
Approval of Contract
(memorandum dated April 2, 1997)
134-138
4. Fla. East Coast Railway Company -
Blanket Utility Crossing Agreement
(memorandum dated April 7, 1997)
139-155
H. Utilities
None
12. COUNTY ATTORNEY
None
13.
A. Chairman Carolyn K. Eggert
Murphy Act 156-159
B. Vice Chairman John W. Tippin
C. Commissioner Fran B. Adams
D. Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn
-- �-== -I eeneth-R Marh#=
Placement of Benches Adjacent to New Courthouse
(backup will be provided separately)
14. SPECIAL DISTRICTSBOARDS
A. Emergency Services District
1. Approval of Minutes - Reg. Meeting of 3/18/97
2. Approval of Minutes - Reg. Meeting of 3/25/97
BoJK U PAGE i o
K
14. SPECIAL DISTRICTSB1 i PAUJI1 BACKUPOARDS (cont c�i:
A. Emergency Services District (cont'd): PAGES
3. Authorization to Execute Purchase Agreement
on Sole Source Basis with Ten -8 Fire Equip.,
Inc. for a 1995 Pierce Quantum Pumper to Re-
place -a 1967 Hahn Pumper (Veh. #570) Which
is Unserviceable
(memorandum dated April 7, 1997) 160-162
B. Solid Waste Disposal District
None
C. Environmental Control Board
None
15. ADJOURNMENT
Anyone who may wish to appeal any decision which may be made at this meeting will need
to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and
evidence upon which the appeal will be based.
Anyone who needs a special accommodation for this meeting may contact the county's
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) coordinator at 567-8000 x408 at least 48 hours in advance
or meetm .
Meeting broadcast live on TCI Cable Channel 13 - rebroadcast 5: 00 p.m. Thursday through
5: 00 p. m. Friday
Falcon Cable Channel 35 - rebroadcast Friday evening
INDEX TO AIINUTES
APRIL 15, 1997
REGULAR MEETING OF BOARD OF COUNTY CO1VMOSIONERS
ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
PROCLAMATIONS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
Great Florida Cleanup Day - April 19, 1997 . . . . . . .
1
APPROVAL OF MINUTES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
CONSENTAGENDA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
A. Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
B. List of Warrants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
C. Cooperative Mapping Work - Geographic Information
System (GIS) -Agreements with MPO and FDEP . . . .
8
D. Sebastian Water Expansion - Phase 2 - Survey
Contract=--Masteller, Moler & Reed . . . . . . . .
10
E. Bid #7040 -.Legal Advertising - Press Journal . . .
11
PUBLIC HEARING - COMMUNICATIONS TOWER/ANTENNA LDR AMENDMENTS -
FIRST HEARING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
12
NORTH COUNTY TOWER SITE PROPOSED BY STATE DOT - RE -ADDRESS
17
PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS - 101ST AVENUE BETWEEN 79TH
STREET AND 87TH STREET - VERO LAKES ESTATES . . . . . .
18
PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS - 60TH AVENUE SOUTH OF 45TH
STREET - PONDEROSA ESTATES SUBDIVISION . . . . . . . . .
41
GIFFORD PARK WATER AND SEWER IMPROVEMENTS - HUTCHINSON
UTILITIES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
50
FLORIDA EAST COAST (FEC) RAILWAY COMPANY LICENSE AGREEMENT -
BLANKET UTILITY CROSSING AGREEMENT . . . . . . . . . . .
50
SEAWALL LAWSUIT COM14ENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
51
MURPHYACT . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
52
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT_- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS . . . . .
58
COUNCIL OF COMMUNITY SERVICES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58
EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES FORUM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
59
FAIRGROUNDS ADVISORY SUBCOMMITTEE . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
60
NEW COURTHOUSE BENCHES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
61
EMERGENCY SERVICES DISTRICT . : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
62
1 BOOK 1,01 PACs JJJ )
April 15, 1997
The Board of County Commissioners of -Indian River County,
Florida, met in Regular Session at the County Commission Chambers,
1840 25th Street, Vero Beach, Florida, on Tuesday, April 15, 1997,
at 9:00 a.m. Present were Carolyn R. Eggert, Chairman; John W.
Tippin, Vice Chairman; Fran B. Adams; Kenneth R. Macht; and
Caroline D. Ginn. Also present were James E. Chandler, County
Administrator; Charles P. Vitunac, County Attorney; and Patricia
"PJ" Jones, Deputy Clerk.
Chairman Eggert called the meeting to order. Reverend Mike
Oliver of 1st United ----Methodist gave the Invocation, and
Commissioner Ginn led_the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
ADDITIONS TO TSE_ AGENDA
Chairman Eggert requested four additions to today's Agenda:
1. Item 13-A-2, computer equipment for Board of
County Commissioners.
2. Item 13-A-3, Council of Community Services.
3. Item 13-C, Fairgrounds Advisory SubCommittee.
4. Item..12, Comments regarding Seawall Lawsuit.
Commissioner Tippin requested the addition of Item 13-B,
Emerging Technologies --Forum: -_ -
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht, SECONDED by
Commissioner Ginn, the Board unanimously added the
above items to the Agenda.
PROCLAMATIONS
Great Florida Cleanup Day - April 19, 1997
Chairman Eggert presented the following Proclamation to Dane
Roberts:
eoQr 1 rd PAGE 113
APRIL 159 1997 1
Boar, lm
BION
PROC LAMA _
_
DESIGNATING APRIL 19,
1997 AS GREAT FLORIDA
CLEANUP DAY IN INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY
WHEREAS, the Keep Indian River Beautiful affiliate of Keep
America Beautiful and Keep Florida Beautiful has designated April
19, 1997 as the Great Florida Cleanup Day in Indian River County;
and
WHEREAS, Keep Indian River Beautiful is a county -wide system
for educational and promotional support for litter abatement,
recycling, beautification and other environmental programs; and
WHEREAS, successful implementation of our programs requires
cooperation of the City of Vero Beach, City of Sebastian, Town of
Indian River Shores, City of Fellsmere, Indian River County and
various other governmental agencies; and
WHEREAS, roadside and shoreline litter is becoming an
increasing problem in many areas of Indian River County:
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that April 19, 1997
is designated as
GREAT FLORIDA CLEANUP DAY
in Indian River County, and the Board urges all residents and civic
organizations to participate in this worthwhile effort.
Adopted this_15 day of April, 1997.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
ei4-o-�'el 4_Pt'1.e_4.JA_
Carolyn t. Eggert airman
Dane Roberts presented a map of the County marked with red
dots showing the areas to be cleaned and noted that the cleanup
will begin at 8:00 A.M., Saturday, April 19, 1997.
"RM 159 1997 2
The Chairman asked if there were any corrections or additions
to the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of March 25-, 1997. There
were none.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED by
Commissioner Adams, the Board unanimously approved
the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of March 25,
1997, as written.
CONSENT AGENDA
A. Reports
Received and placed on file in the office of the Clerk to the
Board:
1. Report of Convictions, March, 1997.
2. Sebastian River Water Control District Annual Financial
Report, September 30, 1996.
3. Indian River Farms Water Control District Minutes of
Board of Supervisors' Meetings for the Period from
October, 1995 through September, 1996.
B. List of Warrants
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 3, 1997:
TO: HONORABLE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DATE: APRIL 3, 1997
SUBJECT: APPROVAL OF WARRANTS
FROM: EDWIN M. FRY, JR., FINANCE DIRECTOR
In compliance with Chapter 136.06, Florida Statutes, all warrants issued
by the Board of County Commissioners are to be recorded in the Board minutes.
Approval is requested for the attached list of warrants, issued by the Clerk
to the Board, for the time period of March 27 to April 3, 1997.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously approved
the list of Warrants as issued by the Clerk to the
Board for the period from March 27, 1997 through
April 3, 1997, as recommended by staff.
BOOK � �.� FAGf IIS
"RM 159 1997 3
BOOK 101 PACE 1 6
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0018285
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
3/21/97
l'E!D
0018308
BARTON, JEFFREY K -CLERK
3/27/97
.00
935.45
0018309
GIBSON, PATRICIA FOR CIARA
4/02/97
300.00
0215767
ADAMS, COOGLER, WATSON &
1/16/97
L11J) .00
0220193
A A FIRE EQUIPMENT, INC
4/03/97
736.25
0220194
AERO PRODUCTS CORP
4/03/97
167.50
0220195
ALPHA ACE HARDWARE
4/03/97
2.39
0220196
AMERICAN CORRECTIONAL
4/03/97
35.00
0220197
APPLE MACHINERY & SUPPLY
4/03/97
500.00
0220198
ATCO TOOL SUPPLY
4/03/97
738.56
0220199
A B S PUMPS, INC
4/03/97
9,724.93
0220200
ALL POWER SERVICES, INC
4/03/97
2,261.30
0220201
A T & T
4/03/97
11.28
0220202
A T & T
4/03/97
19.10
0220203
ALL RITE WATER CONDITIONING
4/03/97
82.50
0220204
ADVANCED MEDICAL & PHARMACY
4/03/97
30.74
0220205
ADAMS, COOGLER, WATSON &
4/03/97
553.62
0220206
ADAM'S MARK HOTEL
4/03/97
210.00
0220207
ADESHILE, ADONAI & F P & L
4/03/97
45.00
0220208
ATLANTIC COASTAL TITLE CORP
4/03/97
56.00
0220209
ALL COUNTY EQUIPMENT COMPANY
4/03/97
5.85
0220210
ANTHONY BAIL BONDS
4/03/97
497.00
0220211
AMERICAN LIBRARY ASSOCIATION
4/03/97
52.75
0220212
AVATAR UTILITY SERVICES, INC
4/03/97
8,486.05
0220213
AMERICAN REPORTING
4/03/97
102.00
0220214
ARE -JAY INVESTMENTS OF INDIAN
4/03/97
236.18
0220215
BAIRD, JOSEPH A
4/03/97
39.44
0220216
BAKER & TAYLOR, INC
4/03/97
2,748.37
0220217
BAKER BROTHERS, INC
4/03/97
366.71
0220218
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
4/03/97
5,163.99
0220219
BENSONS LOCK SERVICE
4/03/97
27.75
0220220
BROOKS, RONALD R
4/03/97
96.99
0220221
BELLSOUTH MOBILITY
4/03/97
66.23
0220222
BARTON, JEFFREY K -CLERK
4/03/97
2,137.75
0220223
BERGGREN EQUIPMENT CO, INC
4/03/97
1,190.28
0220224
BAKER & TAYLOR BOOKS
4/03/97
64.48
0220225
BIGGINS, SEAN ESQ
4/03/97
220.00
0220226
BOYNTON PUMP & IRRIGATION
4/03/97
248.68
0220227
BILLING SERVICE, INC
4/03/97
6.42
0220228
BROWN CONTRACTORS, INC
4/03/97
220.00
0220229
BLAKESLEE MAINTENANCE
4/03/97
200.00
0220230
BAKER & TAYLOR ENTERTAINMENT
4/03/97
189.97
0220231
BARNET°T BANK OF THE TREASURE
4/03/97
11.35
0220232
BELLSOUTH
4/03/97
389.97
0220233
BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF
4/03/97
17,182.00
0220234
BARRY STROCK CONSULTING ASSOC
4/03/97
131.22
0220235
BUHLMAN, HERMAN J,
4/03/97
500.00
0220236
BIRDS EYE VIEW
4/03/97
250.00
0220237
BELLSOUTH
4/03/97
31.38
0220238
BILINGUAL PUBLICATIONS CO
4/03/97
161.70
0220239
CAMERON & BARKLEY COMPANY
4/03/97
991.80
0220240
CAMP, DRESSER & MCKEE, INC
4/03/97
30,550.00
0220241
CHANDLER EQUIPMENT CO, INC
4/03/97
136.65
0220242
CHLORINATORS, INC
4/03/97
296.90
0220243
CHUCK'S ELECTRIC MOTORS, INC
4/03/97
424.00
0220244
CLEMENTS PEST CONTROL
4/03/97
19.00
0220245
COASTAL GRAPHICS
4/03/97
137.00
0220246
COLKITT SHEET METAL & AIR, INC
4/03/97
17.10
0220247
COMMUNICATIONS INT'L INC
4/03/97
272.74
0220248
CORBIN, SHIRLEY E
4/03/97
196.00
0220249
CLARK WATER CONDITIONING
4/03/97
47.50
0220250
COASTAL FUELS MARKETING, INC
4/03/97
16,983.57
0220251
CLINIC -PHARMACY
4/03/97
314.89
0220252
CLOVE HITCH FOUND, INC
4/03/97
350.00
0220253
COOGAN, MAUREEN AND
4/03/97
540.20
0220254
CAVENAUGH PLUMBING
4/03/97
1,817.66
0220255
CENTER FOR EMOTIONAL AND
4/03/97
28.50
0220256
0220257
CH2M HILL INC
CLARK,
4/03/97
3,400.00
0220258
ROUMELIS & ASSOCIATES
CENTRAL A/C & REFRIG
4/03/97
4,341.67
0220259
SUPPLY,
DEMCO INC
4/03/97
131.82
4/03/97
78.89
APRIL 199
15, 7 4
� s
0
CHECK NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0220260
DICKERSON FLORIDA, INC
4/03/97
131,967.45
0220261
DICKEY SCALES, INC
4/03/97
223.00
0220262
DOCTOR'S CLINIC
4/03/97
684.00
0220263
DIXON, PEGGY C
4/03/97
311.50
0220264
DUVALL FORD
4/03/97
15,754.00
0220265
DAVIDSON TITLES, INC
4/03/97
164.58
0220266
DARRIN, STEWART
4/03/97
75.80
0220267
ENVIROMETRICS, INC
4/03/97
389.50
0220268
EBSCO SUBSCRIPTION SERVICES
4/03/97
�9 186.02
0220269
EMED CO, INC
4/03/97
423.54
0220270
ERHARDT, SUSIE
4/03/97
169.29
0220271
EDL UND & DRITENBAS
4/03/97
744.71
0220272
FATHER & SON APPLIANCE CO
4/03/97
73.60
0220273
FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP
4/03/97
185.86
0220274
FLORIDA STATE HORTICULTURE
4/03/97
115.00
0220275
FLORIDA COURT REPORTERS
4/03/97
133.60
0220276
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
4/03/97
19,725.73
0220277
FLORIDA EQUIPMENT & SERV INC
4/03/97
12,822.78
0220278
FLORIDA LIBRARY ASSOCIATION
4/03/97
208.00
0220279
F P & L
4/03/97
5,676.53
0220280
FLORIDA RIBBON & CARBON
4/03/97
120.00
0220281
FLORIDA RURAL WATER
4/03/97
50.00
0220282
FOURTH DISTRICT COURT OF
4/03/97
250.00
0220283
FRASER ENGINEERING & TESTING
4/03/97
1,095.00
0220284
FLOWERS BAKING COMPANY OF
4/03/97
48.62
0220285
FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT
4/03/97
12,491.00
0220286
FRANKLIN PRODUCTS CORP
4/03/97
2,688.40
0220287
FAIRBANKS SCALES
4/03/97
33.39
0220288
FLORIDA MEDICAID COUNTY
4/03/97
42,628.78
0220289
FELLSMERE, CITY OF
4/03/97
63.07
0220290
FLORIDAFFINITY, INC
4/03/97
1,139.00
0220291
FUTURE HORIZONS, INC
4/03/97
647.70
0220292
FLORIDA LEAGUE OF CITIES, INC
4/03/97
1,050.00
0220293
FOOT & ANKLE ASSOC OFFLORIDA4/03/97
17.85
0220294
FLORIDA NENA CONFERENCE
4/03/97
15.00
0220295
GATOR LUMBER COMPANY
4/03/97
13.21
0220296
GENERAL INSURANCE UNDERWRITERS
4/03/97
87.00
0220297
GLIDDEN COMPANY, THE
4/03/97
157.03
0220298
GRAYBAR ELECTRIC CO, INC
4/03/97
492.49
0220299
GALLS, INC
4/03/97
210.95
0220300
GNB TECHNOLOGIES
4/03/97
33.30
0220301
GEORGIA RUBBER
4/03/97
881.70
0220302
GONZALEZ, KATHLEEN A
4/03/97
8.12
0220303
GREENFIELD MEDICAL PRODUCTS
4/03/97
164.70
0220304
GIS WORLD, INC
4/03/97
47.00
0220305
GOTEBORGS,EMIGRANTEN
4/03/97
300.00
0220306
HARRISON-COMPANY, THE
4/03/97
354.55
0220307
HARRISON UNIFORMS
4/03/97 -
21,635.24
0220308
HAZELLIEF, JEANNIE E
4/03/97
276.50
0220309
HECTOR TURF, INC
4/03/97
10,324.53
0220310
HENRY FISCHER & SONS, INC
4/03/97
6,593.00
0220311
HUDMAN ENTERPRISES
4/03/97
100.00
0220312
HUNTER AUTO SUPPLY
4/03/97
2,868.50
0220313
HOLMSTROM, ROBERT MD
4/03/97
33.00
0220314
HACH SUPPLY
4/03/97
1,591.22
0220315
HARRIS SANITATION, INC
.4/03/97
46,238.06
0220316
HEALTHSOUTH TREASURE COAST
4/03/97
1,188.00
0220317
HARVARD UNIVERSITY
4/03/97
15.00
0220318
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
4/03/97
100.00
0220319
I S I INSTRUMENTATIONS
4/03/97
165.40
0220320
INDIAN RIVER BLUE PRINT, INC
4/03/97
166.96
0220321
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
4/03/97
1,122.12
0220322
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
4/03/97
198,730.00
0220323
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
4/03/97
1,013.82
0220324
INSURANCE SERVICING &
4/03/97
1,995.00
0220325
IRVINE MECHANICAL, INC
4/03/97
583.17
0220326
IBM CORP-DVU
4/03/97
579.25
0220327
INDIAN RIVER ALLFAB
4/03/97
384.86
0220328
IRC EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE-
4/03/97
206,857.43
0220329
IKON OFFICE SOLUTIONS
4/03/97
1,012.06
0220330
IDENTIFAX OF PALM BEACH
4/03/97
726.32
APRIL 15, 1997 5
BOOK 101 PAGE 117
BOOK -1.01 FACE118
CHECK NAME
COCK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0220331
INDIAN RIVER HAND
4/03/97
263.00
0220332
JACKSON ELECTRONICS
4/03/97
3.20
0220333
JUDICIAL & ADMINISTRATIVE
4/03/97
130.00
0220334
JENKINS, JAMETHIA
4/03/97
434.00
0220335
JUDAH, KAREN E
4/03/97
140.13
0220336
J A SEXAUER INC
4/03/97
79.98
0220337
JANITORIAL DEPOT OF AMERICA -
4/03/97
881.52
0220338
JEWETT ORTHOPAEDIC CLINIC
4/03/97
21.60
0220339
JACKSON-HIRSH, INC
4/03/97
119.12
0220340
KEEN'S FOODTOWN
4/03/97
190.00
0220341
KIMLEY-HORN & ASSOCIATES, INC
4/03/97
17,419.54
0220342
KELLY TRACTOR
4/03/97
964.39
0220343
KEITH & SCHNARS
4/03/97
598.29
0220344
KTRBY AUTO SUPPLY
4/03/97
180.01
0220345
JOHN J KIRLIN, INC OF FLORIDA
4/03/97
128,250.00
0220346
KLINK, RICHARD
4/03/97
902.00
0220347
LEGAL PUBLICATIONS, INC
4/03/97
195.00
0220348
LAB SAFETY SUPPLY, INC
4/03/97
395.81
0220349
LIGHT SOURCE BUSINESS SYSTEMS
4/03/97
885.90
0220350
LFI VERO BEACH, INC
4/03/97
1,282.89
0220351
MARSHALL CAVENDISH CORP
4/03/97
71.87
0220352
MAXWELL PLUMBING, INC
4/03/97
140.79
0220353
MCCORKLE RADIOLOGY
4/03/97
277.00
0220354
MID COAST TIRE SERVICE, INC
4/03/97
20.00
0220355
MISCO, INC
4/03/97
259.93
0220356
MCLEOD, PETER H
4/03/97
30.00
0220357
MCMASTER-CARR SUPPLY COMPANY
4/03/97
87.90
0220358
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE CO
4/03/97
40.60
0220359
M & R SPORTSWEAR
4/03/97
70.94
0220360
MR BOB PORTABLE TOILET
4/03/97
1,076.12
0220361
MICROSOFT CORPORATION
4/03/97
20.00
0220362
MAIN STREET HARDWARE, INC
4/03/97
32.85
0220363
MGE UPS SYSTEMS INC
4/03/97
7,500.00
0220364
MEDCHECK
4/03/97
141.50
0220365
NATIONAL BUSINESSWOMAN'S
4/03/97
69.00
0220366
NATIONWIDE ADVERTISING
4/03/97
197.22
0220367
NORTH SOUTH SUPPLY
4/03/97
127.72
0220368
NORMENT INDUSTRIES, WSA INC
4/03/97
4,660.00
0220369
NETMANAGE
4/03/97
970.20
0220370
NOLEN, VICKIE L
4/03/97
20.19
0220371
NAPIER, WILLIAM MATT
4/03/97
10.50
0220372
OFFICE PRODUCTS & SERVICE
4/03/97
4,005.94
0220373
ON IT'S WAY
4/03/97
139.95
0220374
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
4/03/97
22.85
0220375
OFFICE DEPOT, INC
4/03/97
245.89
0220376
OSCEOLA PHARMACY
4/03/97
44.81
0220377
OMNI ROSEN HOTEL
4/03/97
240.00
0220378
O'NEIL, LEE & WEST
4/03/97
19,892.07
0220379
PHILLIPS, LINDA R
4/03/97
66.50
0220380
KEN PUTTICK BUICK CADILLAC
4/03/97
200.00
0220381
PRESS JOURNAL
4/03/97
119.29
0220382
PELT TIER, CLAUDETTE A
4/03/97
60.15
0220383
PRECISION CONTRACTING
4/03/97
12,879.62
0220384
PRIMESTAR BY TCI CABLE
4/03/97
39.95
0220385
PIONEER METALS, INC
4/03/97
446.00
0220386
PANGBURN, TERRI
4/03/97
35.00
0220387
RINKER MATERIALS CORPORATION
4/03/97
345.00
0220388
RUSSO PRINTING, INC
4/03/97
113.80
0220389
RAY PACE'S WASTE EQUIPMENT,INC
4/03/97
112.77
0220390
ROBINSON EQUIPMENT COMPANY,INC
4/03/97
156.60
0220391
ROBERTS & REYNOLDS PA
4/03/97
4,023.93
0220392
PANKS, JONATHAN & JEROME
4/03/97
6.31
0220393
RODGERS, J MD
4/03/97
57.00
0220394
RADISSON TWIN TOWERS HOTEL
4/03/97
95.00
0220395
ROGERS, MARILYN
4/03/97
88.00
0220396
REGIONAL ENGINEERS,
4/03/97
14,677.45
0220397
SCOTT'S SPORTING GOODS
4/03/97
114.70
0220398
SEBASTIAN BUSINESS SUPPLY, INC
4/03/97
19.64
0220399
SHELL OIL COMPANY
4/03/97
39.22
0220400
SHERWIN-WILLIAM.S
4/03/97
78.61
0220401
SMITH, BRUCE J ESQUIRE
4/03/97
1,000.00
APRIL 159 1997 6
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0220402
SOUTHERN BUILDING CODE
4/03/97
238.00
0220403
SOUTHERN EAGLE DISTRIBUTING,
4/03/97
518.30
0220404
SUN COAST CLEANING SUPPLIES,
4/03/97
90.06
0220405
S R SCHOLARLY RESOURCES, INC
4/03/97
80.53
0220406
SIMON & SCHUSTER CONSUMER
4/03/97
222.23
0220407
SCHOOL DISTRICT OF IRC
4/03/97
1,500.00
0220408
SOUTHERN JANITOR SUPPLY
4/03/97
51.50
0220409
SAFETY EQUIP COMPANY
4/03/97
5,091.00
0220410
SOUTHERN SEWER EQUIPMENT SALES
4/03/97
177.95
0220411
SUN BELT MEDICAL SUPPLY, INC
4/03/97
1,162.80
0220412
SELIG CHEMICAL IND
4/03/97
74.75
0220413
SUPERIOR PRINTING
4/03/97
915.00
0220414
SYSCO FOOD SERVICE
4/03/97
868.17
0220415
STEWART INDUSTRIES
4/03/97
3,274.79
0220416
SYS ADMIN
4/03/97
39.00
0220417
SOUTHEASTERN EMERGENCY EQUIP
4/03/97
52.91
0220418
SUBSCRIPTION SERVICES
4/03/97
32.00
0220419
ST JOHNS RIVER WATER MGMT DIST
4/03/97
100.00
0220420
SEBASTIAN RIVER AREA CHAMBER
4/03/97
640.00
0220421
SIGN PRO
4/03/97
99.38
0220422
SOUTHERN SECURITY SYSTEMS OF
4/03/97
220.00
0220423
SEBASTIAN COMMUNITY HOSPITAL
4/03/97
509.30
0220424
SA SO COMPANY
4/03/97
205.37
0220425
SUB ROSA INVESTIGATIONS
4/03/97
650.00
0220426
SECURITYLINK FROM AMERITECH
4/03/97
75.00
0220427
STAPLES OFFICE SUPPLY
4/03/97
45.93
0220428
SEIFER, RONALD -MD _
4/03/97
142.00
0220429
TEN -8 FIRE EQUIPMENT, INC
4/03/97
9,578.19
0220430
TITLEIST DRAWER CS
4/03/97
389.61
0220431
TRODGLEN PAVING, INC
4/03/97
692.50
0220432
TREASURE COAST REFUSE CORP
4/03/97
68.90
0220433
TOTAL PRINT, INC
4/03/97
150.70
0220434
TERRA INTERNATIONAL, INC
4/03/97
160.00
0220435
TECHNOLOGY PARTNERS
4/03/97
1,005.88
0220436
TCI MEDIA SERVICES
4/03/97
75.00
0220437
TRANS -GENERAL LIFE INSURANCE
4/03/97
5,401.30
0220438
TOTALINE OF FLORIDA
4/03/97
583.85
0220439
TRI -COUNTY GAS
4/03/97
111.03
0220440
TRUGREEN CHEMLAWN
4/03/97
625.00
0220441
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA, THE
4/03/97
55.00
0220442
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
4/03/97
165.00
0220443
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
4/03/97
62.00
0220444
VERO BEACH, CITY OF
4/03/97
21,656.08
0220445
VERO CHEMICAL DISTRIBUTORS,INC
4/03/97
303.80
0220446
VERO LAWNMOWER CENTER, INC
4/03/97
45.40
0220447
VETROL DATA SYSTEMS, INC
4/03/97
530.15
0220448
VERO BEACH, CITY OF
4/03/97
539.06
0220449
VERO ORTHOPAEDICS
4/03/97
48.00
0220450
VERO BEACH, CITY OF
4/03/97
939.19
0220451
VERO BEACH -POLICE -DEPARTMENT
-4/03/97.-
20.00
0220452
VEY, CARRIE
4/03/97-_.
90.25
0220453
VERO BEARING & BOLT
4/03/97
471.03
0220454
VICKERS, LINDA
4/03/97
283.00
0220455
WAL-MART STORES, INC
4/03/97
10.75
0220456
WEST PUBLISHING PAYMENT CTR
4/03/97
1,928.75
0220457
W W GRAINGER, INC
4/03/97
565.82
0220458
WAL-MART STORES, INC
4/03/97
191.13
0220459
WILLHOFF, PATSY
4/03/97
130.00
0220460
WHAT'S NEW IN HOME ECONOMICS
4/03/97
29.00
0220461
WORKERS COMPENSATION SEMINARS
4/03/97
150.00
0220462
WHITTINGTON, MEGAN
4/03/97
147.25
0220463
XEROX CORPORATION
4/03/97
1,564.51
0220464
ZIMMERMANN, KARL
4/03/97
50.85
0220465
PAN AMERICAN ENGINEERING CO
4/03/97
34.44
0220466
THAMES, IRENE
4/03/97
46.27
0220467
EALY JR, SAMUEL
4/03/97
26.71
0220468
CHIARELLA, LYNNE
4/03/97
28.92
0220469
HINES, RANDY
4/03/97
23.61
0220470
JEWELS, GRACE
4/03/97
45.55
0220471
BOGGS, RICHARD
4/03/97
93.98
0220472
MC CORMICK, REX ALAN
4/03/97
43.99 r
APRIL 159 1997 7 BOOK l 0i PAGE
1,200,063.89
C. Cooperative Mapping Work - Geographic Information System (GIS) -
Agreements with MPO and FDEP
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 3, 1997:
TO: James Chandler
County Administrator DATEr April 3, 1997
THROUGH: Robert M. Keating, AICPKikly-
Community-Development Director
FROM: Keith Burned, AICP
MPO Planner
SUBJECT: REQUEST TO APPROVE AGREEN CRTS BETWEEN THE COUNTY & MPO
AND THE COUNTY & FDEP FOR COOPERATIVE MAPPING WORK
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal
consideration by the Board of County Commissioners at their
regular meeting of April 15, 1997.
At its February 11, 1997 meeting, the Indian River County Board
of County Commissioners approved three related Memoranda of
Understanding by which the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (DEP) will perform work related to geodetic control
and the establishment of reference ties to township corners
APRIL 159 1997 8
BOOK
-CHECK
NUMBER
NAME
CHECK
CHEF
DATE
AMOUNT
0220473
GRIZZELL, WILLIAM G
4/03/97
43.16
0220474
GIAMPILIS, PETER
4/03/97
28.43
0220475
CARL, FRANK
4/03/97
60.34
0220476
MARK ODOM CONSTRUCTION
4/03/97
31.09
0220477
PUNCHES, JAMES G
4/03/97
50.18
0220478
MINTERN, JOHN & ROSE MARIE
4/03/97
42.26
0220479
ROMANI, WILLIAM G
4/03/97
31.07
0220480
DUPREE, HATTIE
4/03/97
3.75
0220481
FARRELL, CLIFFORD P
4/03/97
10.48
0220482
SNEED, LEHOTER
4/03/97
52.35
0220483
COLLIER, TESHA
4/03/97
41.00
0220484
CORNERSTONE SELECT HOMES INC
4/03/97
62.83
0220485
SIMON DE BARTOLO GROUP INC
4/03/97
5,609.91
0220486
CORNETT, ANNA
4/03/97
24.36
0220487
MASON, KATHARINE
4/03/97
77.29
0220488
PERUGINI CONSTRUCTION
4/03/97
51.95
0220489
ANDERSON, HUGH
4/03/97
34.78
0220490
LANDRUM;-DON A
4/03/97
37.56
0220491
NEVIL, JOHN --
4/03/97
28.91
0220492
BEAZER HOMES FLORIDA INC
4/03/97
136.73
0220493
TALBERT, EVE
4/03/97
11.97
0220494
BRADY, JOSEPH F
4/03/97
53.06
0220495
WASHINGTON, EDWARD F
4/03/97
73.17
0220496
FECCA, LAURA A
4/03/97
18.77
0220497
PADGETT, CHARLES
4/03/97
2.65
0220498
BROWN, BETTY
4/03/97
86.33
0220499
BUCHANAN, LINDA & NORMAN
4/03/97
38.66
0220500
NEWMAN, CAROLE
4/03/97
33.13-
0220501
EGER, ANDREW W
4/03/97
19.05
0220502
KYLE'S RUN
4/03/97
1,217.30
0220503
HAYNES, DONALD
4/03/97
44.65
0220504
CONSTRUCTION SERVICE & MGMT
4/03/97
78.32
0220505
CITICORP MORTGAGE,INC
4/03/97
16.93
0220506
GRANGE, PAUL & SHEILA
4/03/97
50.00
0220507
BEENS CONSTRUCTION
4/03/97
44.31
0220508
HOVDE, GLEN
4/03/97
28.30
0220509
BODY SHOP #039
4/03/97
28.30
0220510
HAWES, JEAN
4/03/97
38.05
0220511
YOUNG, MR & MRS MICHAEL S
4/03/97
26.52
1,200,063.89
C. Cooperative Mapping Work - Geographic Information System (GIS) -
Agreements with MPO and FDEP
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 3, 1997:
TO: James Chandler
County Administrator DATEr April 3, 1997
THROUGH: Robert M. Keating, AICPKikly-
Community-Development Director
FROM: Keith Burned, AICP
MPO Planner
SUBJECT: REQUEST TO APPROVE AGREEN CRTS BETWEEN THE COUNTY & MPO
AND THE COUNTY & FDEP FOR COOPERATIVE MAPPING WORK
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal
consideration by the Board of County Commissioners at their
regular meeting of April 15, 1997.
At its February 11, 1997 meeting, the Indian River County Board
of County Commissioners approved three related Memoranda of
Understanding by which the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (DEP) will perform work related to geodetic control
and the establishment of reference ties to township corners
APRIL 159 1997 8
within Indian River County. The principal purpose of these
projects is to enhance the usability of the county's Geographic
Information System (GIS).
The three Memoranda of Understanding approved by the Board are as
follows:
1. The County and the MPO agree that the County will complete
the geodetic control work, which consists of developing a
grid densification master plan and the setting of points in
the field. The actual setting of points, a multi-year
effort, will be by Task Order so that the work may be
undertaken as funding and administrative resources permit.
2. The County and the DEP agree that the DEP will complete
geodetic control work for the County. This work is also to
be completed by Task Orders, with the County providing funds
in advance of each Task Order. This agreement is necessary
so that DEP may receiva funds in advance of each task, with
the MPO reimbursing the County at the conclusion of each
task (the MPO receives its funding through the Florida DOT
on a reimbursement basis).
3. The County and the DEP agree that the DEP will complete work
to reference ties to township corners of common use. This
work has been budgeted in FY 1996/97 by the Public Works and
Utilities Departments, and is to be done on a Task Order
basis. The County will also provide funds in advance of
this work being completed.
As submitted for the Board's approval, the Memoranda of
Understanding referenced in item 3 above contained language that
DEP would be reimbursed for the work, rather than the County
providing funds in advance for the work. While the staff report
indicated that funds would be provided in advance, the actual
Memorandum of - Understanding contained erroneous language.
In order to correct the Memoranda of Understanding, the Board
should approve the revised document attached to this staff
report. All other aspects of the document remain the same. The
other two documents approved at the February 11, 1997 meeting
contain correct language, and do not need revision.
Staff recommends -that the -Board -of County Commissioners review
the information provided herein, authorize the Chairman to
execute the revised Memoranda of Understanding attached to this
staff report, and authorize staff to issue work orders to
commence the work.
a Commissioner .Adams questioned the date of completion, and
Community Development Director Bob- Keating advised this is an
ongoing project -and all completion dates will be on an interim
basis. - - - -- -
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously approved
the Memorandum of Understanding with The Bureau of
Survey and Mapping, Department of Environmental
Protection, authorized the Chairman to execute same,
and authorized staff to issue work orders to
commence the work, as recommended by staff.
MEMORANDUM IS ON FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
B00r� 10 1 FAar 1
APRIL 159 1997 9
BOOK 10i PAG -C 2
D. Sebastian Water Expansion - Phase 2 - Survey Contract - Masteller}
Moler & Reed
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 4, 1997:
DATE: APRIL 4, 1997
TO: JAMES E. CHANDLER
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR -
FROM: TERRANCE G. PINTO
DIRECTOR OF UTILI SERVICES
PREPARED MICHAEL C. HOTCHKISS, P.E. X g
AND STAFFED ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEER
BY: DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
SUBJECT: SEBASTIAN WATER EXPANSION -PHASE 2
REQUEST FOR EXECUTION OF SURVEY CONTRACT
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY PROJECT NO. UW -96 -20 -DS
BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS
On March 25, 1997, the Board of County Commissioners approved a
contract for survey services with Masteller, Moler and Reed, Inc.
in the amount of $144,900.00 for the above -referenced project.
Attached is a copy of the contract for execution by the Chairman.
RECOMMENDATION
The staff of the Department of Utility Services recommends that the
Board of County Commissioners authorize the Chairman to execute the
attached survey contract in the amount of $144,900.00, as
presented.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously approved
Specific Work Authorization No. 1 with Masteller,
Moler & Reed,- Inc. and authorized the Chairman to
execute same, as recommended by staff.
AUTHORIZATION IS ON FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
APRIL 159 1997 10
E. Bid #7040 - Legal Advertising - Press journal
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 2, 1997:
TO: Board of County Commissioners'
FROM: Terrence P. OBrien, Assistant County Attorney -11-061
DATE: Apri12, 1997
SUBJECT: AWARD OF BID FOR LEGAL ADVERTISING
The County issued RFP #7040 "Publication of Official Notices and Legal
Advertisements." The County only received one proposal and that was from the
Press Journal. The unit price quoted was one column inch at $4.95. The Press
Journal has recently changed its column width so that last years prices cannot
be directly compared. An analysis and comparison of 1996-1997 prices vis a
vis 1997-1998 prices is attached. Under the new prices single run ads are less
expensive and multiple run ads are more expensive. Display ads have
increased 10%.
On balance and considering that there is no competition, the costs are not out
of line. It is recommended that the Board of County Commissioners accept the
bid of the Press Journal.
As an ancillary matter, the cost of advertisements can be reduced by reducing
the amount of information provided to the public in the newspaper. For
example, see a copy of the attached advertisement for Consulting Services for
Indian River County's Water Treatment Plants dated 3/19/97. This ad could
be reduced by 60%. It could give a short description of the services needed.
Eliminate "General Criteria for Selection," "Form of Proposals - Proposal
Content," "Insurance Requirements" and tell the public that complete
information may be obtained fcou7 the Purchasing Manager. 'There is no legal
requirement to provide all of these details in the ad.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously awarded
Bid 17040 to The Press Journal, as recommended by
staff .
AGREEMENT
WILL
BE ON
FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF
THE
CLERK
TO THE BOARD
WHEN EXECUTED AND RECEIVED
BOOKJIU� FACE
APRIL 15, 1997 11
BOOK . 1 PAGEV4
PUBLIC HEARING - CON NUMCATIONS TOWMANTENNA LDR
• I�! 1 I� I' :1 1
P.O. Box 1268 Vero Beach, Florida 32961 562-2315
0 Preto Journal
COUNTY OF INDIAN RIVER: STATE OF FLORIDA
Before the undersigned authority rersonally appeared Darryl X
Hicks who on oath sacs that he is President of the Press -Journal, a
daily newspaper published at Vero Beach in Indian River County,
Floridabilled__
was published in said newspaper in the issue(s) of
S-om to and subscribed before me this
Of �-- 7- 9 7
p PRF
µyyyy President
• �p�Pp....s�lj;.; .
• s 1n.\•DP.:.. PRESr=T. P• -=.,r..
My Cotten Expires Naie4-ones WCc
Augus125. 1997 c a ee -.�, .:. �. aP.: cc: :•v
=• No CWtu80.5
lTfOFF....0
(SEAL)
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE OF AMENDMENT TO LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS (LDRS) CHANGING THE LIST OF
COMMUNICATION TOWER USES ALLOWED WITHIN
ALL ZONING DISTRICTS, AND ESTABLISHING AND
MODIFYING REGULATIONS AFFECTING COMMU-
NICATIONS TOWERS AND ANTENNAS.
THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROPOSES TO ADOPT AN ORDI-
NANCE AMENDING THE LIST OF COMMUNICATIONS
TOWER USES ALLOWED IN ALL ZONING DISTRICTS, AND
ESTABLISHING AND MODIFYING REGULATIONS AFFECT-
ING COMMUNICATIONS TOWERS AND ANTENNAS. PRO-
POSED CHANGES INCLUDE AMENDMENTS TO LDR
CHAPTERS 901, 911.912.917.954, AND 971. _
THE FIRST OF TWO PUBLIC HEARINGS ON THE PRO-
POSED ORDINANCE AMENDING THE LIST OF COMMUNICA-
TIONS. TOWER—USES •ALLOWED WITHIN ALL -'ZONING
DISTRICTS AND MODIFYING REGULATIONS AFFECTING
COMMUNICATIONS TOWERS AND ANTENNAS WILL BE
HELD ON TUESDAY, APRIL 15, 1997 AT 9:05 A.M. THE
HEARING WILL BE HELD IN THE BOARD OF COUNTY COM-
MISSIONERS CHAMBERS, 1840 25th STREET, VERO
BEACH, FLORIDA. A COPY OF THE PROPOSED ORDI-
NANCE WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR THE PUBLIC BEGINNING
APRIL 8, .1997, IN THE OFFICE TO THE CLERK TO THE
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IN THE COUNTY AD-
MINISTRATION BUILDING LOCATED AT 1840 25th STREET,
VERO BEACH, FLORIDA. CITIZENS SHALL HAVE AN OP-
PORTUNITY TO BE HEARD AT THE PUBLIC HEARINGS,
THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE, IF ADOPTED, WOULD BE
EFFECTIVE IN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF INDIAN
RIVER COUNTY, AS DEPICTED ON THE LOCATION MAP
SHOWN BELOW.
Anyone who may wish to appeal arry dem wnx� may be
made at this meeting will need to ensure that a verb W record
of the proceedings is made, which includes testitnony and evi-
dence upon wMM the appeal is based.
Questions about the substance of the proposed ordinance
should be directed to the planning division at 567.8000, ext.
237.
ANYONE WHO NEEDS A SPECIAL ACCOMMODATION FOR
THIS MEETING MUST CONTACT THE COUNTY'S AMERI-
CANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA) COORDINATOR AT
567-8000 X223 AT LEAST 48 HOURS IN ADVANCE OF THE
MEETING.
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
BY -s- Carolyn K. Eggert. Chairman
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 3, 1997:
TO: James Chandler
County Administrator
DION HEAD CONCURRENCE:
o ert M. Keat n AICP,
Community Devve/ljopment Ib ector
FROM: Stan Boling; AI'CP
Planning Director
DATE:- April 3, 1997
SUBJECT: First Hearing: Communications Tower/Antenna Proposed LDR
Amendments
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal
consideration by the Board of County Commissioners at its regular
meeting of April 15, 1997.
APRIL, 159 1997
12
Last summer, in response to an increase in requests for new towers,
the Planning and Zoning Commission and staff initiated amendments
to the county's existing communications tower LDRs. After input
from the Professional Services Advisory Committee (PSAC), the
Planning and Zoning Commission, on October 10, 1996, reviewed
proposed changes to the county's existing communications tower LDRs
and made recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners.
Soon after the Planning and Zoning Commission's review, the Board
of County Commissioners enacted a 6 -month moratorium on
applications for new towers. That moratorium expires on May 5,
1997. The Board also directed staff to perform additional research
and conduct public workshops on tower issues. Board workshops were
held on November 13, 1996; December 19, 1996; and February 20,
1997.
At its February 20, 1997 workshop, the Board reviewed the "post
10/10/96 Planning and Zoning Commission" version of a
communications tower LDR amendments proposal as well as 27
additional, specific alternatives. The Board "approved" in concept
the LDR amendments proposal, and directed staff to incorporate 23
of the 27 alternatives in a revised tower LDR amendment proposal.
The Board also indicated that some of the 23 "chosen" alternatives
might not be approved during final review (see attachment #5).
Staff has incorporated the alternatives into the attached, revised
LDR amendment proposal (see attachment #6). These changes have
been further refined based upon input from the March 14, 1997 PSAC
workshop, meeting (see attachment #7) and from the March 27, 1997
Planning and Zoning Commission meeting (see attachment #8). The
Board is now to review the proposed amendments, direct staff to
make any necessary changes, invoke the pending ordinance doctrine
for the revised proposal, and announce its intention to adopt the
revised ordinance at its May 6, 1997 meeting.
The specific alternatives that the Board, at its February 20th
workshop, directed staff to incorporate into the proposed LDR
amendments are as follows:
eLimiting Proliferation of New Towers:
Require applicants proposing certain towers to submit a
written justification for not collocating on existing
structures; justification to include: determination of service
area for wireless service(s) proposed [San Francisco
ordinance], specific search area based on determined service
area and inventory of applicant's existing infrastructure
[Cobb County ordinance], tentative "5 year plan" projections
(San Francisco ordinance), and RF (radio frequency) pattern
data based on field tests (suggested by Commissioner Macht).
Require applicant's justification for not collocating to apply
to requests for non -camouflaged and non -monopole towers under
150' in height.
At applicant's expense, county will hire a third party. RF
engineering consultant to independently evaluate an
applicant's justification and to write-up and present
findings/opinion to the county [Palm Beach ordinance].
*Promoting Collocation on Existing Structures
At applicant's expense, county will hire third party RF
consultant to evaluate applicant's justification report (same
as third alternative above).
(Incentive) Exempt antennas attached to utility transmission
line poles (maximum height 150').
*Screening or Hiding Towers and Antennas
Establish increased setbacks from property boundaries and/or
existing residences and rights-of-way [Orange County, F1.
ordinance].
Color towers to "blend -in" with surroundings [Hialeah
ordinance].
Increase landscaping material quantity and/or height at time
of planting.
EDor _ 01 FA6E_ 12!'
APRIL 159 1997 13
* Require equipment buildings that support antennas attached to
buildings to match material and color of main buildings
[Hialeah ordinance]. .
* Require screening of all or portion of building -mounted
antennas (especially roof mounts) [Hialeah ordinance].
* Require all stand alone equipment buildings (color and
materials) to blend in with surroundings [Cobb County & Napa
County ordinances].
* Limit height of equipment buildings [e.g. 15': Napa County
ordinance].
* Limit projections of antennas mounted to walls of buildings
(e.g. 4' from wall), and limit area of wall face covered by
antenna (e.g. 50 sq. ft. per wall face) [Napa County
ordinance].
* Require roof mounted antennas to be set back from building
edge [e.g. for antennas over 10' high, set back height of
antenna: Napa County ordinance].
*Addressing Other Compatibility Aspects
* Restrict new towers over 150' tall to AG -2 and AG -3 areas.
* Restrict districts in which various heights of towers are
allowed (see above).
* Require increased setbacks from property boundaries and/or
residences and rights-of-way [Orange County, F1. ordinance].
* (Incentive) Allow taller towers on large county owned sites
(regardless of zoning) where significant setbacks from
existing and potential future residences can be required and
ensured.
* Apply 2 mile separation requirement between non -camouflaged,
single user tower [Napa County ordinance]. NOTE: this
alternative is not recommended by staff and has not been
incorporated into the proposed LDR amendments. However, based
upon -discussion at the March 27th Planning and Zoning
Commission meeting, staff is recommending separation distances
used in the Orange County, Florida ordinance (see item below),
subject to certain exemptions that would allow tower
"Clustering" where desired.
* Require special setbacks (750' - 5,0001) between.towers.,by
tower height and type [Orange County, F1. ordinance], subject'
to specific exemptions. y
* Require applicant to execute a removal agreement with county.,
for towers of significant size [Napa County ordinance].°}
The alternatives have been borrowed from various ordinances,,.
including those from: Collier County, Florida; Hialeah, Florida;
Orange County, Florida; Palm Beach County, Florida; Cobb County,
Georgia; Napa County, California; San Francisco, California. These -
alternatives will limit new tower proliferation, promote
collocation, and address other compatibility concerns expressed
during workshops.
Staff has proposed increased incentives for camouflaged towers that
were not agreed to by consensus at the February 20, 1997 Board
workshop. The incentives, shown at the top of page it of
attachment #6, would allow camouflaged towers up to 150' tall to be
approved at a staff level, subject to certain criteria. At its
February 20th workshop, the Board indicated that such
"incentivized" towers should be limited in height to 100'. In
staff's opinion, the proposed incentives (camouflaged towers up to
150') will be used by the telecommunications industry and will
result in a reduction in negative visual impacts that use of non -
camouflaged towers would produce. However, if the camouflaged
tower incentives are limited to 100' towers, then such incentives
would be -significantly less useable within Indian River County and
more non -camouflaged towers would result.
In addition to items specifically workshopped at the February 20,
1997 Board meeting, staff has incorporated concepts and proposals
from local amateur radio operators to address some of their
concerns and suggestions that were briefly discussed at the
February 20th Board workshop.. The amateur radio proposals that are
APRIL 15, 1997 14
i �
now incorporated into the proposed amendments are the result of
discussion at the March 14th PSAC meeting (see last page of
attachment #6), and were clarified and affirmed at the March 27th
Planning and Zoning Commission meeting.
The format of the proposed amendments is based upon a more thorough
breakdown of tower categories (amateur vs. commercial) and tower
types (camouflaged, monopole, and remaining tower types) by tower
height (various thresholds: 70', 80', and 150'). In general, the
proposed LDR amendments create incentives for use of camouflaged
towers and antenna attachments to a variety of structures
(collocation), and establish more restrictions and greater scrutiny
(e.g. via the special exception use process) for all other types of
tower proposals. As indicated on page 18 of the LDR amendment
proposal, staff recommends approval of a separation between towers
requirement only in conjunction with certain exemptions from the
separation requirement.
:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Direct staff to make any necessary revisions to the LDR
amendments proposal (4/3/97 version).
2. Invoke the pending ordinance doctrine for the revised
ordinance.
3. Announce its intention to adopt the revised ordinance at its
regular meeting of May 6, 1997.
Planning Director Stan Boling gave a brief overview of the
proposed ordinance and noted several changes to be made to the
draft as follows: (1) on page 54 of the backup, an additional
definition of "utilities"; (2) on page 64, add language to Item E
to make sure "setbacks do not increase the degree of setback
nonconformity"; (3) on page 66, at the top of the page, in
paragraph 4, the section number should read "Section 917.06 (8) (d) ";
(4) on page 71, the separation distance in Item 2 only applies to
lattice type towers 150 feet or over.
In response to a question, Director Boling stated that there
a some circumstances where it would be advantageous to have a
cluster of towers. Those circumstances would be related to the
size of the towers, not the size of the area.
Chairman Eggert inquired how the County determines charges for
towers, and Emergency Services Director Doug Wright stated that
research has discovered that an average charge would be
approximately $40,000 to co -locate with a $1,500 monthly fee, with
the understanding that the company will provide its own source of
electricity and its own maintenance building.
Commissioner Ginn suggested that FEMA policies should be
incorporated, and Director Wright felt the County has already
addressed those policies in its catastrophic hurricane plan.
The Chairman opened the public hearing and asked if anyone
wished to be heard in this matter.
BOOK hi PAGE V- 7
APRIL 159 1997 15
&o9r, 1 1 FACE 128
Jeff Sluggett, representative for Nextel Communications and
Sprint Spectrum, felt this will be a very good set of regulations
which will protect residents and provide for users. Mr. Sluggett
suggested that the exemptions cited on Page 18 of the proposed
ordinance be expanded to include situations where reduced distances
between towers would be allowed, and that the second bullet on
Page 16 should list a minimum of 2 users.
Sheri Brower, representing amateur radio operators, stated
that 70 feet used to be the arbitrary limit for their use. 70 feet
does not give the average user access to effective communication,
especially when co -locating UHF and/or VHF antennae. During an
emergency, such as a hurricane, users would need both types of
antenna and 80 feet would give an adequate range for both long
distance and short distance communications.
The Chairman asked if anyone else wished to be heard in this
matter. There being none, she closed the public hearing.
Commissioner Adams felt a little uncomfortable with the
regulations for "grandfathered" towers, and Chairman Eggert
suggested that not allowing the setbacks to be decreased would be
a means of control.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Ginn, the Board unanimously directed y
staff to make revisions to the ordinance to
incorporate a clause that setback requirements
cannot be decreased on "grandfathered" towers; add a
better definition of "utility transmission" lines;
include a reference to the FEMA regulations; include
language to incorporate Mr. Sluggett's comments
regarding adding an exemption to the separation
distance requirement in cases where obeying the rule
would require companies to build more towers;
invoked the pending ordinance doctrine for the
revised ordinance; and approved May 6, 1997 as the
date for adoption of this ordinance, pursuant to
staff's -recommendations.
APRIL 15, 1997 16
� a �
NORTH COUNTY TOWER SITE PROPOSED BY STATE DOT - RE-
ADDRESS
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 3, 1997:
TO: James E. Chandler
County Administrator
D SI HEAD CONCURRENCE:
Ro drt MT KeAtinQ AlC
Community Development rector
FROM:
Stan Boling, AICP
Planning Director
DATE: April 3, 1997
SUBJECT: Request to Re -address the State's Proposed North County
Tower Site
It is requested that the data herein presented be given formal
consideration by the Board of County Commissioners at its regular
meeting of April 15, 1997.
On March 11, 1997 the Board of County Commissioners agreed to allow
the state to construct a 1350' multi-user communications (lattice)
tower at a site on 102nd Terrace, in lieu of the "original" I-95/CR
512 interchange location. At the end of March, planning staff was
notified by state staff that the FAA (Federal Aviation
Administration) had reviewed the state's aeronautical study for the
102nd Terrace site and had restricted tower height at that location
to 103 feet.
Recently, the state wrote Commissioner Adams a letter stating that,
due to FAA's severe restriction on the site, the 102nd Terrace site
is not useable (see attachment #2). The letter requests that the
Board now send the state a letter indicating the Board's approval
of locating the tower at the original I-95/CR 512 interchange site.
The state's letter further indicates that the state would be
willing to beautify the interchange site with landscaping.
The Board must now consider the state's request for county
"approval" of the original interchange site for construction of a
±3501 multi-user lattice tower.
During initial county/state discussions, state staff indicated that
there were no apparent problems with the FAA review of the 102nd
Terrace site. However, after learning of the FAA's determination,
county staff contacted FDOT staff who regularly comment on
development and tower impacts on airport operations. The FDOT
staff then contacted FAA staff and learned that the FAA's 102nd
Terrace site determination was based on FAA's future plans to
install, an instrument approach at an affected Sebastian airport
runway. Thus, FAA's restriction is based on a planned Sebastian
airport improvement that state staff were not initially aware of.
State staff have also confirmed that an FAA authorization for the
original interchange tower location, that was obtained 2 years ago,
is still valid. Thus, state staff are of the opinion that the
original interchange site is useable, and that construction of the
tower needs to proceed quickly to accommodate the proposed users,
including FDOT's need for a tower spot to implement its I-95 call
box system.
Although there are no publicly owned alternative tower sites
immediately available that could be•authorized by the FAA, the
Carson Platt property could include a feasible tower site and could
be acquired by the public in a fairly short time period. Even
though the state has indicated that it could landscape and upgrade
BOOK 1.0i PAGE 1�
APRIL 15, 1997 17
I 1�
�o
- �rl INA
the interchange appearance, a ±350' lattice tower could not be
screened from view. In staff's opinion, the county should inform
the state that the county does not accept the interchange site and
that the state should allow more time to find an acceptable,
alternative site. If further efforts to arrange for an alternative
site fail, then the county could provide the state with "approval",
subject to specific aesthetic improvements along I-95.
Staff recommends that the Board respond to the Department of
Management Services with a letter stating that Indian River County
does not approve of the I-95/CR 512 interchange location and will
continue to work with all parties involved to find an acceptable,
alternative site not located at a major entranceway to the county.
Rick Rewiski of the Department of Management Services, State
of Florida, land acquisition agent, wanted to be sure that a
location at I-95 or west of there would be agreeable to the Board.
Their tower will cover the majority of the County and is very
important to their system. One of their requirements is that they
must be able to receive over a range of up to 10 miles into the
ocean for the marine patrol.
Mr. Rewiski continued that Indian River County is in Phase II
of their project and the County's law enforcement communications
will be affected.
Commissioner Adams suggested that the DEP property west of I-
95 would be another alternative.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously approved a
letter from the Chairman stating that the County
does not approve of the I-95/CR-512 interchange
location and will continue to work with all parties
involved to find an acceptable, alternative site not
located at a major entranceway to the County, as
recommended by staff.
PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVE IENrS - 101ST AVENUE
BETWEEN 791M STREET AND 87TH STREET - VERO LAKES
ESTATES
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 2, 1997:
TO: James Cbandler
County Administrator
/ 1
THROUGH: James W. Davis, P
Public Works Director /
;,
and
f�
Roger D. Cain, P.E. �"/County
Engineer
FROM: Michelle A. Gentile, CET
Civil Engineer
SUBJECT: Resolutions to Provide for the Paving and Drainage Improvements to and set
Public Hearing date for.
101st Avenue between 79th Street and 87th Street in Vero Lake Estates
Subdivision
DATE: April 2, 1997
APRIL 15, 1997 18
� a �
L_]
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaar�aaaaaa
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
The County Public Works Department has initiated a public improvement assessment for road
paving and drainage improvements for 101st Avenue between 79th Street and 87th Street in Vero
Lake Estates Subdivision in cooperation with the Vero Lake Estates Property Owners Association
and Drainage Committee. A providing resolution is presented for adoption by the- Board.
A separate resolution is presented for adoption to hold a Public Hearing to discuss the
advisability, cost and amount of the assessment against each property owner. This Public
Hearing has been scheduled for Tuesday, May 13, 1997, at 9:05 A.M. in the County Commission
Chambers.
An assessment roll and plat has been prepared and filed with the Clerk to the Board of County
Commissioners.
RECOMMENDATION AND FUNDING
It is recommended that the Board:
1) Adopt the resolution providing for the paving and drainage improvements for the projects
subject to the terms outlined in the resolution. The applicable interest rate shall be
established by the Board of County Commissioners at the time the final assessment roll
is approved.
2) The project cost is estimated to be $251,688.33. The following Revenues are
recommended:
Vero Lake Estates MSTU $232,353.59 Account No. 185-214-541-066.51
Special Assessment 19.334.74 Account No. 111-214-541-035.51
TOTAL $251,688.33
3) Adopt the resolution setting the time and place of the Public Hearing.
After discussion, the public hearing date was changed from May
13th to May 20th, 1997.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Tippin, the Board unanimously adopted
Resolution 97-028 providing for certain paving and
drainage improvements to 101st Avenue between 79th
Street and 87th Street in Vero Lake Estates.
Providing (First Reso.)
RESOLUTION NO. 97-28
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR
CERTAIN PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO 101ST
AVENUE BETWEEN 79TH STREET AND 87TH STREET IN VERO
LAKE ESTATES, PROVIDING THE TOTAL ESTIMATED COST,
METHOD OF PAYMENT OF ASSESSMENTS, NUMBER OF ANNUAL
INSTALLMENTS, AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE AREA
SPECIFICALLY BENEFITED.
WHEREAS, the County Public Works Department has been
petitioned for Road Paving and Drainage Improvement for 101st
Avenue between 79th Street and 87th Street in Vero Lake Estates
Subdivision.
WHEREAS, the construction of paving and drainage
improvements by special assessment funding is authorized by Chapter
206, Section 206.01 through 206.09, Indian River County Code; and
cost estimates and preliminary assessment rolls have been completed
BOOK " I PAGES I
APREL 15, 1997 19
ROOK PAGE,
No. 97--g
by the Public Works Department; -and the total estimated cost of the
proposed paving and drainage improvements is TWO HUNDRED FIFTY ONE
THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED EIGHTY EIGHT DOLLARS and THIRTY THREE CENTS
($251,688.33); and
WHEREAS, the special assessment provided hereunder shall,
for any given record owner of property within the area specially
benefited, be assessed to the owner at the rate of $2.00 per front
foot. The amount to be assessed under the Special Assessment is
$19,334.74 which is approximately 7.68% of the total estimated cost
of the project and the balance of $232,353.59 shall come from other
revenue sources; and
WHEREAS, the special assessment shall become due and
payable at the Office of the Tax Collector of Indian River County
ninety (90) days after the final determination of the special
assessment pursuant to Section 206.08, Indian River County Code;
and
WHEREAS, any special assessment not paid within said ninety
(90) day period shall bear interest beyond the due date at a rate
established by the Board of County Commissioners at the time of
preparation of the final assessment roll, and shall be payable in
two (2) equal installments, the first to be made twelve (12) months
from the due date and subsequent payments to be due yearly; and
WHEREAS, after examination of the nature and anticipated
usage of the proposed improvements, the Board of County
Commissioners has determined that the following described
properties shall receive a direct and special benefit from these
improvement, to wit:
Vero Lake Estates, Unit L, Block F Lot 17 through
Lot 32; Block G, Lot 1 through Lot 16;
Vero Lake Estates, Unit K, block F, Lot 17 through
Lot 32; Block G, Lot 1 through Lot 16;
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J, Block K, Lot 1 through
8; Block L, Lot 1 through Lot 7; Block N, Lot 1
through Lot 8; Block M, Lot 1 through Lot 7;
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I, Block K, Lot 9 through
Lot 16; Block L, Lot 9 through Lot 16; Block M, Lot
1 through Lot 8; Block N, Lot 1 through Lot 8.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows:
1. The foregoing recitals are affirmed and ratified in
their entirety.
2. A project providing for paving and drainage
improvements to 101st Avenue between 79th Street and 87th Street in
APRIL 159 1997 20
No. 97-28
Vero Lake Estates; heretofore designated as Public Works Project
No. 9309 is hereby approved subject to the terms outlined above and
all applicable requirements of Chapter 206, et seq. Indian River
County Code.
The foregoing resolution was offered by Commissioner
Adams who moved its adoption. The motion was seconded
by Commissioner Tippin and, upon being put to a vote, the
vote was as follows:
Chairman Carolyn K. Eggert Aye
Vice -Chairman John W. Tippin Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams Aye
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn Aye
Commissioner Kenneth R. Macht Aye
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution passed and
adopted this 15 day of April 1997.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
CAROLYN . EGGER , Chairman
Attest.. -�
J K. BARTON, Clerk
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Tippin, the Board unanimously adopted
Resolution 97-029 setting a time and place at which
the owners of property on 101st Avenue between 79th
Street and 87th Street in Vero Lake Estates
Subdivision and other interested persons may appear
before the Board of county Commissioners and be
heard as to the propriety and advisability of making
paving and drainage improvements to said property.
BO0r 1 PAE13""
13
1
AP1 159 Mi 21
Door 101 PAGE 10 1
Time and Place (Second Reso.)
RESOLUTION NO. 97- 2 9
A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, SETTING A TIME AND PLACE AT WHICH
THE OWNERS OF PROPERTY ON 101ST AVENUE
BETWEEN 79TH STREET AND 87TH STREET IN VERO
LAKE ESTATES SUBDIVISION AND OTHER
INTERESTED PERSONS MAY APPEAR BEFORE THE
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND BE
HEARD AS TO THE PROPRIETY AND ADVISABILITY
OF MAKING PAVING AND DRAINAGE
IMPROVEMENTS TO SAID PROPERTY AS TO THE
COST THEREOF, AS TO THE MANNER OF PAYMENT
THEREFOR, AND AS TO THE AMOUNT THEREOF TO
BE SPECIALLY ASSESSED AGAINST EACH PROPERTY
BENEFITED THEREBY.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County has,
by Resolution No. _17 - 2 8 , determined that it is necessary for the public welfare
of the citizens of the county, and particularly as to those living, working, and owning
property within the area described herein, that paving and drainage improvements
be made to said property; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has caused an assessment roll
to be completed and filed with the Clerk to the Board; and
WHEREAS, Section 206.06, Indian River County Code, requires that the Board
Of County Commissioners shall fix a time and place at which the owners of the
properties to be assessed or any other persons interested therein may appear before
the Board of County Commissioners and be heard as to the propriety and advisability
Of making paving and drainage improvements to said property, as to the cost thereof, '
as to the manner of payment therefor, and as to the amount thereof to be assessed
against each property benefited thereby,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows:
I. The County Commission shall meet at the County Commission chambers in the
County Administration Building at the hour of 9:05 A.M. on Tuesday May 20
1997, at which time the owners of the properties to be assessed and any other
interested persons may appear before said Commission and be heard in regard
to said property. The area to be improved and
APRIL 159 1997 22
RESOLUTION NO. 97- 29
the properties to be specially benefited are more particularly described upon
the assessment plat and the assessment roll with regard to the special
assessments.
2. All persons interested in the construction of said improvements and the special
assessments against the properties to be specially benefited may review the
assessment plat showing the area to be assessed, the assessment roll, the plans
and specifications for said improvements, and an estimate- of the cost thereof
at the office of the Clerk to the Board any week day from 8:30 A.M. until 5:00
P.M.
3. Notice of the time and place of this public hearing shall be given by the
Department of Public Works by two publications in the Vero Beach Press
Journal Newspaper a week apart. The last publication shall be at least one
week prior to the date of the hearing. The Indian River County Department
of Public Works shall give the owner of each property to be specially assessed
at least ten days notice in writing of such time and place, which shall be served
by mailing a copy of such notice to each of such property owners at his last
known address.
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner Adams , and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner T i p p i n , and, upon being put to a vote,
the vote was as follows:
Chairman Carolyn K. Eggert
Aye
Vice Chairman John W. Tippin
Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams
Aye
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn
Aye
Commissioner Kenneth R. Macht
Aye
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this
15 day of April 1997.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By .
CARO K. EG T
Chai an
st: ----
Jeffrey�a e k
�G�;IN E'�Gc 00
"RM 159 1997 23
s
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
c COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
1. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0070-00001.0 349.09 $2,00
Box 610727 Lots I to 4, Block G, $698.18
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
2. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0070-00005.0 300.00 $2.00
Box 610727 $600.00
Lots 5 to 8, Block G,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L d,
(OR BK 467 PP 534) nt
3. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0070-00009.0 300.00 $2.00 $600.00
Box 610727 Lots 9 to 12, Block G,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
4. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0070-00013.0 300.00 $2.00 $600.00
Box 610727 Lots 13 to 16, Block G,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
01
kn
7.4
101AVPRE.WK1 a
01 -Apr -97 !��j
ELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74 a
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST PER FRONT FOOT ............... $2.00 Cf'
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
5. Raymond H. & Ruth Mary Burg 33-31-38-00003-0060-00017.0 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
15701 Minnetonka Blvd. Lot 17, Block F,
Minnetonka, MN 55343 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
6. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0060-00018.0 225.00 $2.00 $450.00
Box 610727 Lots 18, 19, 20, Block F,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
7. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0060-00021.0 300.00 $2.00 $600.00
Box 610727 Lots 21 to 24, Block F,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
8. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0060-00025.0 300.00 $2.00 $600.00
Box 610727 Lots 25 to 28, Block F,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
101 AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
14
i
P
kn
r
00
Lai
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL' Y PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH ST Ie,EET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST PER FRONT FOOT ............... $2,00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
9. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00003-0060-00029.0 349.04 $2.00 $698.08
Box 610727 Lots 29 to 32, Block F,
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit L
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
10. Lawrence W. & Brenda Young 33-31-38-00002-0070-00001.0 88.86 $2.00 $177.72
8295 101st Avenue Lot 1, Block G,
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K �O
N
11. Timothy J. & Cynthia A. Sherman 33-31-38-00002-0070-00002.0 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
8293 101st Avenue Lot 2, Block G,
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
(OR BK 634 PP 2142)
12. Eric S. & Melinda W. Fisher 33-31-38-00002-0070-00003.0 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
2071 Misty Meadow Rd. Lot 3, Block G,
Finksburg, MD 21048 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
in
101 AVPRE.WK1 01 -Apr -97
r
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101 ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37 Q
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74
COST PER FRONT FOOT ..............
• $2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
13. Bloomfield Construction Co. 33-31-38-00002-0070-00004.0 225.00 $2.00
338 Cedarville Street Lots 4, 5 & 6, Block G, $450.00
Pittsburg, PA 15224 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
14. Kerry A. & Loraine Heider 33-31-38-00002-0070-00007.0 75.00 $2.00
3902 Dowling Avenue Lot 7, Block G, $150.00
Wilkins Township, PA 15221 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
(OR BK 478 PP 32) N
15. Michael E.& Lynn M.Baumgartner 33-31-38-00002-0070-00008.0 150.00 $2,00
8205 101st Avenue Lots 8 & 9, Block G, $300.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
16. Nick & Jeanne Gazzola 33-31-38-00002-0070-00010.0 75.00 $2.00
342 S Pacific Avenue Lot 10, Block G, $150.00
Pittsburg, PA 15224 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
O�
O�
rl
101AVPRE.WK1 !7
01 -Apr -97 �yy
si
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101 ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
17. Michael & Linda M. Galley 33-31-38-00002-0070-00011.0 TOTAL COST
Lot 11, Block G,
8165 101st Avenue 75'00 $2.00 $150.00
Sebastian, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
18. Ann E. Brack 33-31-38-00002-0070-00012.0
117 Royal Palm Street Lot 12, Block G, 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
Sebastian, FL 32958 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
a
19. Coolidge Corp.rp. 33-31-38-00002-0070-00013.0 150.00
Box 610727 Lots 13 & 14, Block G, $2 $300.00
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
20. William W. & April A. Moolenaar 33-31-38-00002-0070-00015.0
8115 101st AvenueLot 15, Block G,
75.00 $2.00$150.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
21. William W. & April A. Moolenaar 33-31-38-00002-0070-00016.0
8115 101st AvenueLot 16, Block G, 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
101AVPRE.WK1 a
01 -Apr -97
1
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT: ROLL 1 'OR PAVING AND DRAINAGE
TO: 101 ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
IMPROVEMENTS
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
34
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. 9667.37
COST PER FRONT FOOT ............... $19,3 $2.74
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION
22. Nicholas & Gilda Addesa33-31-38-00002-0060-00017.0 FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
00
370 S Waverly Place, Apt. 4-C Lots 17 & 18, Block F, 150. $2.00 $300.00
Vero Beach, FL 32960 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
23. Sanfra Lynn Key 33-31-38-00002-0060-00019.0
8136 101st Avenue Lot 19, Block F, 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
24. Harry & Lillian Greenberg 33-31-38-00002-0060-00020.0
11734 Folkstone Lane Lot 20, Block F, 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
Los Angeles, CA 90077 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
25. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00002-0060-00021.0
Box 610727 Lots 21 to 24, Block F, 300'00 $2.00 $600.00
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
26. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00002-0060-00025.0
Box 610727 Lots 25 to 28, Block F, 300'00 $2.00 $600.00
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
101AVPRF.WK1
01 -Apr -97
r -t
101AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
1
0
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING
"`
TO:
AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
9,667.37
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS ..............
$19,334.74
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS
27. Joseph & Julia D. Kosich
LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE
33-31-38-00002-0060-00029.0 COST/F.F.
TOTAL COST
6715 Tuxedo Road
Lot 29, Block F, 75.00 $2.00
$150.00
San Diego, CA 92119
Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
28. Glenn E. & Dorothy L. Ferrall
33-31-38-00002-0060-00030.0
2509 Bordeaux Way
Lot 30, Block F, 75.00 $2.00
$150.00
Lutz, FL 33549
Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
29. Mary Ann Rannou
33-31-38-00002-0060-00031.0
8276 101st Avenue
Lots 31 & 32, Block F, 163.93 $2.00
$327.86
Vero Beach, FL 32967
Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
Plat Book 5, Page 83
30. Coolidge Corp.
33-31-38-00001-0140-00001.0
Box 610727
Lot 1, Block N, 75'00 $2.00
'$150.00
N. Miami, FL 33160
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
31. Ann Vignovich
33-31-38-00001-0140-00002.0
2311 West Wade Street
150.00 $2.00
Lots 2 & 3, Block N,
$300.00
Aliquippa, PA 15001
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
101AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
1
0
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101 ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74
COST PER FRONT FOOT ............... $2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
TOTAL COST
32. Arthur & Bertie Dibble 33-31-38-00001-0140-00004.0
RR 1 Box 1059 75.00 $2•�
Lot 4, Block N,
$150.00
Three Springs, PA 17264 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
33. Regis H. & Margaret E. Ryan 33-31-38-00001-0140-00005.0
Lots 5 & 6, Block N,
P.O. Box 614 150.00 $2.00 $300.00
Rockledge, FL 32956-0 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
34. Nellie C. Walker 33-31-38-00001-0140-00007.0
8306 93rd Avenue Lots 7 & 8, Block N, 150.00 $2.00 $300.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
35. Collidge Corp. 33-31-38-00001-0130-00001.0
Box 610727 Lot 1, Block M, 131.74 $2.00 '$263.48
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
(OR BK 467 PP 534)
36. W. Ray & Anne G. Laseter 33-31-38-00001-0130-00002.0
1038 Ray Wyatt Road Lot 2, Block M, 75'00 $2.00 $150.00
Ashville, AL 35953 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
101AVPRjF.WK1
01 -Apr -97
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR
PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPR
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
OVEMENTS
T-4
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. 9,667.37
COST PER FRONT FOOT ............... $19.334.74
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION
FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
37. Charlotte A. &John D. Cole 33-31-38-
Jr. TOTAL COST
00001-0130-00003.0
8455 101st Avenue Lot 3, Block M, 75.00 $2.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 $150.00
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
38. Joseph Sortino 33-31-38-00001-0130-00004,0
C/o Florence Wolfling Lot 4 Block M 75.00 $2.00
475 Center Street $150.00
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J N
East Aurora, NY 14052
M
39. Raymond C. & Julia C. Raub
33-31-38-00001-0130-00005.0
1501 SW Edinburg Drive Lot 5, Block M, 75.00 $2 00
Pt. St. Lucie, FL 34953 $150.00
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
(OR BK 153 PP 384)
40. Madeline Nistico 33 -31 -38 -MI -0130-00006.0
552 Third Street Lots 6 & 7, Block M, 150.00 $2.00
Clairton, PA 15025 $300.00
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
CA
r -t
V1
rl
101AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97 Q.i
RELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74 c�
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
41. Coolidge Corp. 33-31-38-00001-0110-00009.0 150.00 $2.00
Box 610727 Lots 9 & 12, Block K, $300.00
N. Miami, FL 33160 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
(OK BK 467 PP 534)
42. Sally & George E. Petticrew, Jr. 33-31-38-00001-0110-00010.0 75.00
8326 101st Avenue Lot 10, Block K $2 $150.00
,
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit K
43. Mary Agnes Martin 33-31-38-00001-0110-00011.0 75.00 $2.00
c/o Eleanor Schachern, Executor Lot 11, Block K, $150.00
2421 Front Street Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
Monica, PA 15061
44. Rita Hudmon 33-31-38-00001-0110-00013.0 75.00 $2
8360 101st Avenue Lot 13, Block K, 00 $150.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
45. Rita F. Hudmon 33-31-38-00001-0110-00014.0 75.00 $2,00
8360 101st Avenue Lot 14, Block K, $150.00
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
101AVPRE.WK1
01—Apr-97
M
c�
1
rl
k
CO)
If
u a
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE
TO: 101ST AVENUE
IMPROVEMENTS
FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
tn
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
9,667.37
cri C:1
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS ..............
$19,334.74
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
TOTAL COST
46. Collidge Corp.
33-31-38-00001-0110-00015.0 150.00
Box 610727
$2.00
Lots IS & 16, Block K,
$300.00
N. Miami, FL 33160
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
(OK BK 467 PP 534)
47. Collidge Corp.
33-31-38-00001-0120-00008.0 225.00
Box 610727
$2.00
Lots 8 to 10, Block L,
$450.00
N. Miami, FL 33160
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
(OK BK 467 PP 53)
48. Marvin & Gayle Reaume
33-31-38-00001-0130-00011.0
13520 NW 4th Manor
75.00 $2.00
Lot 11, Block L,
$150.00
Plantation, FL 33325
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
49. Tommy J. & Jean Runion
33-31-38-00001-0120-00012.0
1713 Linwood Avenue
75.00 $2.00
Lot 12, Block L,
$150.00
Ft. Pierce, FL 34982
Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
101 AVPRE. WK1
01 -Apr -97
d�
M
1
101AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
01
kn
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101 ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
9,667.37
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS ..............
PROJECT NO. 9309
$19,334.74
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
eel
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
TOTAL COST
50. Tommy J. & Jean Runion 33-31-38-00001-0120-00013.0 75.00 $2.00
$150.00
1713 Linwood Avenue Lot 13, Block L,
Ft. Pierce, FL 34982 Vero Lake Estates, Unit J
51. Michael K. & Nina E. Neady 33-31-38-00001-0120-00014.0 131.56 $2.00
$263.12
3902 74th Avenue Lot 14, Block L,
Hyattsville, MD 20784 Vero Lake Esates, Unit J
52. Kathleen L. Craig 28-31-38-00006-0140-00001.0 71.00 $2.00
4250
$142.00
Sardis Road Lot 1, Block N,
Murrysville, PA 15668 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
53. Ernest G.& Christin Gerber,l11 28-31-38-00006-0140-00002.0 75.00 $2.00
$150.00
8575 101st Avenue Lots 2, Block N
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit 1
54. John Lloyd 28-31-38-00006-0140-00006.0 75.00 $2.00
$150.00
9432 U.S. Highway 1 Lots 3, Block N
Sebastian, FL 32958 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
1
101AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
01
kn
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS.............. $19,334.74
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST PER FRONT FOOT............... $2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
55. Fred Anderson 28-31-38-00006-0140-00004.0 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
1001 Foster Road Lot 4, Block N,
Sebastian, FL 32958 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
56. Joseph & Gertrude Blood 28-31-38-00006-0140-00005.0 75.00 $2.00 $150.00
8545 101st Avenue Lot 5, Block N,
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit 1
57. Southern Bell T & T Co. 28-31-38-00006-0140-00006.0Cw
75.00 $2.00 $150.00
c/o Bellsouth Telecomm Tax Lot 6, Block N,
Rm. 5E03 Campanile Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
Atlanta, FL 30367-6 (OR BK 721 PP 1444)
58. David W. & Delia Badders 28-31-38-00006-0140-00007.0 146.00 $2.00 $292.00
11146 Del Rio Road Lots 7 & 8, Block N,
Spring Valley, CA 91978 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
(OR BK 495 PP 747)
59. Stuart E. & Lucille Glover 28-31-38-00006-0130-00001.0 77.07 $2.00 $154.14
10101 87th Street Lot 1, Block M,
Vero Beach, FL 32967 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
101 AVPRE. WK1 01-Apr-97
1
1
1
101 AVPRF.WK1
01 -Apr -97
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT
ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101 ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
9,667.37
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS ..............
$19,334.74
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2,00
NAME & ADDRESS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
TOTAL COST
60. Patricia L. Carey
28-31-38-00006-0130-00002.0
75.00 $2.00
$150.00
8675 101st Avenue
Lot 2, Block 7,
Vero Beach, FL 32967
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
(OR BK 484 PP 706)
61. Virginia & Raymond Taylor, Jr.
28-31-38-00006-0130-00003.0
150.00 $2.00
$300.00
1076 Great Road
Lots 3 & 4, Block M,
Lincoln, RI 02865
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
62. Edmund N. Ansin, Trustee
28-31-38-0006-130-00005.0
225.00 $2.00
$450.00
1401 79th Street Causeway
Lots 5 to 7, Block M,
Miami, FL 33141
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
(OR BK 467 PP 485)
63. Alexandra A. & Anasta Alexander
28-31-38-00006-0130-00008.0
70.00 $2.00
$140.00
328 Granada Parkway
Lots 8 & 9, Block M,
Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
101 AVPRF.WK1
01 -Apr -97
Cn
LO
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT
ROLL FOR PAVING
AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO:
101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO
87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
9,667.37
a
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS ..............
$19,334.74
cri
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST PER FRONT FOOT :..............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
TOTAL COST
64.
Donald Paul & Maria Ricc Zappa
28-31-38-00006-0110-00009.0
71.00
$2.00
$142.00
224 S Evaline Street
Lot 9, Block K,
Pittsburg, PA 15224
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
65.
Frank S.& Susan. Ernst
28-31-38-00006-0110-00010.0
75.00
$2.00
$150.00
15713 Davis Cup Lane
Lot 10, Block K,
Ramona, CA 92065
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
66.
Karol Poderski
28-31-38-00006-0110-00011.0
75.00
$2.00
$150.00
1625 Martin Hwy. #714
Lot 11, Block K,
Palm City, FL 34990
Vero Lake Estates, Unit 1
67.
Edmund N. Ansin, Trustee
28-31-38-00006-0110-00012.0
75.00
$2.00
$150.00
1401 79th Street Causeway
Lot 12, Block K,
Miami, FL 33141
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
(OR BK 467 PP 485)
68.
Mary A. Secola
28-31-38-00006-0110-00013.0
150.00
$2.00
$300.00
521 Dorseyville Road
Lots 13 & 14, Block K,
Pittsburg, PA 15238
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
101 AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
�I
co
cn
RELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING
AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO:
101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
9,667.37
a
PROJECT NO. 9309 COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS ..............
$19,334.74
`
COST PER FRONT FOOT ...............
$2.00
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
69. John H. Francisco 28-31-38-00006-0110-00015.0
TOTAL COST
Houston Paving Co. Lot 15, Block K, 75.00 $2.00
$150.00
80 Houston Road Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
Little Falls, NJ 07424
70. Wanda Lepien 28-31-38-00006-0110-00016.0
107 McGregor Street 71.00 $2.00
g Lot 16, Block K,
$142.00
Harligen, TX 78550 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
0%
M
(OR BK 414 PP 240)
71. George Lins 28-31-38-00006-0120-00009.0
P.O. Box 266 Lots 9 & 10, Block L, 145.00 $2.00
$290.00
Brielle, NJ 08730 Vero Lake Estates, Unit 1
72. Ronald & Joan Ciccozzi 28-31-38-00006-0120-00011.0
120 Heather Drive 75.00 $2.00
Lot 11, Block L,
$150.00
Monaca, PA 15061 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
73. Orval B. & Marjorie O. Archer 28-31-38-00006-0120-00012.0
2799 Wright Avenue SE Lot 12, Block L, 75'00 $2.00
$150.00
01
Palm Bay, FL 32909 Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
rl
101AVPRE.WK1
01 -Apr -97
X1,1
Lr:�
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS
TO: 101ST AVENUE FROM 79TH STREET TO 87TH STREET
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 9,667.37
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS .............. $19,334.74
PROJECT NO. 9309
COST PER FRONT FOOT............... $2
NAME & ADDRESS
74. Maggie L. McDaniel
8666 101st Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
75. Thomas H. & Donna S. Sherrod
RCI Box 107-N
Lake City, FL 32055
101 AVPRE. WK1
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
28-31-38-00006-0120-00013.0
Lots 13 & 14, Block L,
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
(OK BK 440 PP 913)
28-31-38-00006-0120-00015.0
Lots 15 & 16, Block L,
Vero Lake Estates, Unit I
FRONT FOOTAGE COST/F.F.
150.00 $2.00
152.08 $2.00
TOTAL COST
$300.00
$304.16
TOTAL 9,667.37 $2.00 $19,334.74
FRONT FOOTAGE COST PER F.F. TOTAL COST
01 -Apr -97
0
IV
1 1 1 1 I 1' I DI W 1 I: i• .'H 0
OF 45TH STREET - PONDEROSA ESTATES SUBDIVISION
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 1, 1997:
TO: James Chandler
County Administrator
THROUGH: James W. Davis, RE1
Public Works Directo !A., . .�.
and W i L�
Roger D. Cain, P.E.`v
County Engineer
J
FROM: Michelle A. Gentile, CET
Civil Engineer
SUBJECT: Resolutions to Provide for the Paving and Drainage Improvements to and set
Public Hearing date for:
60th Avenue South of 45th Street in Ponderosa Estates Subdivision
DATE: April 1, 1997
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
Tice County - Public Works Department has received a petition for a public improvement
assessment for road paving and drainage improvements for 60th Avenue south of 45th Street in
Ponderosa Estates Subdivision.
The petition was signed by 13 of the 18 property owners in the proposed benefited area. This
represents 72% of the property owners in the proposed benefited area who are in favor of having
this road paved. A providing resolution is presented for adoption by the Board.
A separate resolution is presented for adoption to hold a Public Hearing to discuss the
advisability, cost and amount of the assessment against each property owner. This Public
Hearing has been scheduled for Tuesday, May 13, 1997, at 9:05 A.M. in the County Commission
Chambers.
An assessment roll and plat has been prepared and filed with the Clerk to the Board of County
Commissioners.
RECOMMENDATION AND FUNDING
It is recommended that the Board:
1) Adopt the resolution providing for the paving and drainage improvements for the projects
subject to the terms outlined in the resolution. The applicable interest rate shall be
established by the Board of County Commissioners at the time the final assessment roll
is approved.
2) Allocate $67, 909.91from the Petition Paving Account #111-214-541-035.39.
3) Adopt the resolution setting the time and place of the Public Hearing.
After discussion, the public hearing date was changed from May
13th to May 20th, 1997.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Ginn, the Board unanimously adopted
Resolution 97-030 providing for certain paving and
drainage improvements to 60th Avenue south of 45th
Street in Ponderosa Estates.
EO'J� ' 10�,
"RM 159 1997 41
K'9r 101 PAGE154
Providing (First Reso.)
RESOLUTION NO. 97-30
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR
CERTAIN PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO 60TH
AVENUE SOUTH OF 45TH STREET IN PONDEROSA ESTATES,
PROVIDING THE TOTAL ESTIMATED COST, METHOD OF
PAYMENT OF ASSESSMENTS, NUMBER OF ANNUAL
INSTALLMENTS, AND LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE AREA
SPECIFICALLY BENEFITED.
WHEREAS, the County Public Works Department has been
Petitioned for Road Paving and Drainage Improvement for 60th Avenue
south of 45th Street in Ponderosa Estates.
WHEREAS, the construction of paving and drainage
improvements by special assessment funding is authorized by Chapter
206, Section 206.01 through 206.09, Indian River County Code; and
cost estimates and preliminary assessment rolls have been completed
by the Public Works Department; and the total estimated cost of the
proposed paving and drainage improvements is SIXTY SEVEN THOUSAND
NINE HUNDRED AND NINE DOLLARS and NINETY ONE CENTS ($67,909.91);
and
WHEREAS, the special assessment provided hereunder shall,
for any given record owner of property within the area specially
benefited, be in an amount equal to that proportion of seventy-five
percent (75%) of the total cost of the project ($50,932.43) which
the number of lineal feet of road frontage owned by the given owner
bears to the total number of lineal feet of road frontage within
the areas specially benefited and twenty-five percent (25%) of the
total cost of the project ($16,977.48) will come from Petition
Paving Account. Assessments are to be levied against all lots and
lands adjoining and contiguous or bounding and abutting upon the
improvements or specially benefited thereby and further designated
by the assessment plat with respect to the special assessments; and
WHEREAS, the special assessment shall become due and
payable at the Office of the Tax Collector of Indian River County
ninety (90) days after the final determination of the special
assessment pursuant to Section 206.08, Indian River County Code;
and
WHEREAS, any special assessment not paid within said
ninety (90) day period shall bear interest beyond the due date at
a rate established by the Board of County Commissioners at the time
of preparation of the final assessment roll, and shall be payable
in two (2) equal installments, the first to be made twelve (12)
months from the due date and subsequent payments to be due yearly;
and
APRIL 159 1997 42
No. 97- 30
WHEREAS, after examination of the nature and anticipated
usage of the proposed improvements, the Board of County
Commissioners has determined that the following described
properties shall receive a direct and special benefit from these
improvement, to wit:
Lots 1 thru 25 and that lot shown as "NOT INCLUDED"
on the plat of Ponderosa Estates, Unit 1 as
recorded in Plat Book 6, Page 81 in the Public
Records of Indian River County, Florida
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows:
1. The foregoing recitals are affirmed and ratified in
their entirety.
2. A project providing for paving and drainage
improvements to 60th Avenue south of 45th Street in Ponderosa
Estates; heretofore designated as Public Works Project No. 9536 is
hereby approved subject to the terms outlined above and all
applicable requirements of Chapter 206, et seq. Indian River County
Code.
The foregoing resolution was offered by Commissioner
Adams who moved its adoption. The motion was seconded
by Commissioner Ginn and, upon being put to a vote, the
vote was as follows:
Chairman Carolyn K. Eggert Aye
Vice -Chairman John W. Tippin Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams Aye
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn Aye
Commissioner Kenneth R. Macht Aye
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution passed and
adopted this 15 day of April , 1997.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
CAROLYN . EGGER Chairman
Attest:
J FREY K. BARTON, Clerk
APRIL 15, 1997 43
B00r, .� PAGE��
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Ginn, the Board unanimously adopted
Resolution 97-031 setting a time and place at which
the owners of -property on 60th Avenue south of 45th
Street in Ponderosa Estates and other interested
persons may appear before the Board of County
Commissioners and be heard as to the propriety and
advisability of making paving and drainage
improvements to said property.
Tlme and Place (Second Reso.)
RESOLUTION NO. 97- 31
A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, SETTING A TIME AND PLACE AT WHICH
THE OWNERS OF PROPERTY ON 60TH AVENUE
SOUTH OF 45TH STREET IN PONDEROSA ESTATES
AND OTHER INTERESTED PERSONS MAY APPEAR
BEFORE THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AND BE HEARD AS TO THE PROPRIETY AND
ADVISABILITY OF MAKING PAVING AND DRAINAGE
IMPROVEMENTS TO SAID PROPERTY AS TO THE
COST THEREOF, AS TO THE MANNER OF PAYMENT
THEREFOR, AND AS TO THE AMOUNT THEREOF TO
BE SPECIALLY ASSESSED AGAINST EACH PROPERTY
BENEFITED THEREBY.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County has,
by Resolution No.g 7 _ s p , determined that it is necessary for the public welfare
of the citizens of the county, and particularly as to those living, working, and owning
property within the area described herein, that paving and drainage improvements ,
be made to said property; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has caused an assessment roll
to be completed and Sled with the Clerk to the Board; and
WHEREAS, Section 206.06, Indian River County Code, requires that the Board
of County Commissioners shall fix a time and place at which the owners of the
properties to be assessed or any other persons interested therein may appear before
the Board of County Commissioners and be heard as to the propriety and advisability
of making paving and drainage improvements to said property, as to the cost thereof,
as to the manner of payment therefor, and as to the amount thereof to be assessed
against each property benefited thereby,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, as follows:
1. The County Commission shall meet at the County Commission chambers in the
County Administration Building at the hour of 9:05 A.M. on TuesdayMay 20,
"RM 159 1997 44
RESOLUTION NO. 97- 31
1997. at which time the owners of the properties to be assessed and any other
interested persons may appear before said Commission and be heard in regard
to said property. The area to be improved and
the properties to be specially benefited are more particularly described upon
the assessment plat and the assessment roll with regard to the special
assessments.
2. All persons interested in the construction of said improvements and the special
assessments against the properties to be specially benefited may review the
assessment plat showing the area to be assessed, the assessment roll, the plans
and specifications for said improvements, and an estimate of the cost thereof
at the office of the Clerk to the Board any week day from 8:30 A.M. until 5:00
P.M�
3. Notice of the time and place of this public hearing shall be given by the
Department of Public Works by two publications in the Vero Beach Press
Journal Newspaper a week apart. The last publication shall be at least one
week prior to the date of the hearing. The Indian River County Department
of Public Works shall give the owner of each property to be specially assessed
at least ten days notice in writing of such time and place, which shall be served
by mailing a copy of such notice to each of such property owners at his last
known address.
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner Adams , and the
motion was seconded by Commissioner G i n n , and, upon being put to a vote,
the vote was as follows:
Chairman Carolyn K. Eggert Aye
Vice Chairman John W. Tippin Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams Aye
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn Aye
Commissioner_ Kenneth R. Macht _ _ Aye_
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this
15 day of April 1997.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
CARO N K. EG"1
Chairm
Jeffrey B Clerk
� Dec
A'
Attachment: ASSESSMENT ROLL
60ayset.res
_L FADE lib
APRIL 15, 1"7 45
p
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO:
60TH AVENUE SOUTH OF 45TH STREET IN PONDEROSA ESTATES
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 2520.16
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS... $50,932.43
PROJECT NO.9536 COST PER FRONT FOOT .... $ $20.21
FRONT TOTAL
NAME & ADDRESS LEGAL DESCRIPTION FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST ASSESSMENT COST
1. John C. & Elizabeth T. Bishop
29 32 39 00001 0040 00002.0
173.46
$20.21
$3,505.62
$3,505.62
4457 60th Avenue
Indian River Farms Company Subdivision
Vero Beach, FL 32967
PBS 2} 12 N 304.46 Ft of W 130.57 Ft
of Tract 4 in N 1/2, Less Canal Less
S 101 Ft
i
2. Julkwa C. Haney
29 32 39 00001 0040 00003.0
131.00
$20.21
$2.647.51
$2,647.51
4455 60th Avenue
Indian River Farms Company Subdivision
Vero Beach, FL 32967
PBS 2} 12 S 13J Ft of N 334.46 Ft of W
130.57 Ft of Tract 4 in N 1/2
3. Anthony H. & D(mma L. Labarre
29 32 39 00003 0000 00001.0
112.18
$20.21
$2,267.16
$2,267.16
4476 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6)81
Vero Beach, FL 32967
Lot 1 & N 22 Ft of Lot 2 (OR Bk 448
PP 777)
4. lose 0. Quinones
29 32 39 00003 0000 00002.0
112.70
$20.21
$2,277.67
$2,277.67
P.O. Box 2124
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6}81
Vero Beach, FL 32961-2124
Lot 2, Less N 22 Ft, & N 1/2 of Lot 3
(OR Bk 42 PP 453)
S. Ruth E. Jaynes
29 32 39 00003 0000 00003.0
134.70
$20.21
$2,722.29
$2,722.29
4456 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6}81
Vero Beach, FL 32967
S 1/2 of Lot 3 & All of Lot 4
60avpre.wkl
01 -Apr -97
1
1�
1
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO:
60TH AVENUE SOUTH OF 45TH STREET IN PONDEROSA ESTATES
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 2520.16
COST TO PRO
PROJECT NO.9536
NAME & ADDRESS
6.
Robert M. & Patricia A. Carlton
4450 60th Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
7.
Daniel C. & Deborah F. Robinson
4426 60th Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
8.
Richard B. & Elizabeth J. Steele
4366 60th Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
9.
Christopher & Jodi Simon
4356 60th Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
10.
Thomas M. & Teresa H. Giles
P.O. Box 1391
Vero Beach, FL 32961-1391
60avpre.wkl
PERTY OWNERS... $50,932.43
COST PER FRONT FOOT .... $ $20.21
FRONT TOTAL
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
29 32 39 00003 0000 00005.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6181
Lot 5 & N 1/2 of Lot 6 (OR Bk 438
PP 697)
29 32 39 00003 0000 00006.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6}81
S 1/2 of Lot 6&all ofLot 7
29 32 39 00003 0000 00008.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6}81
Lot 8&N 30 Ft ofLot 9
29 32 39 00003 0000 00009.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6}81
Lot 9 Less N 30 Ft & Lot 10 Less S 30
Ft (OR Bk 454 PP 602)
29 32 39 00003 0000 00010.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6}81
S 30 Ft of Lot 10& Lot 11 (OR Bk
503 PP 608)
FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST ASSESSMENT COST
134.70 $20.21 $2,722.29
$2,722.29
134.70 $20.21
119.80 $20.21
119.60 $20.21
119.80 $20.21
$2,722.29
$2,421.16
$2,417.11
$2,421.16
$2,722.29
$2,421.16
01 -Apr -97
�1
0
60avpre.wkl
01 -Apr -97
00
O
in
1
C
LZI
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO:
60TH AVENUE
SOUTH OF 45TH STREET IN PONDEROSA ESTATES
aT
TOTAL FRONT FEET..........
2520.16
e�
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS...
$50,932.43
`LI
PROJECT NO.9536
COST PER FRONT FOOT .... $
$20.21
FRONT
TOTAL
NAME & ADDRESS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST
ASSESSMENT COST
11. Robert E. & Virginia Hickerson
29 32 39 00003 0000 00012.0 135.60 $20.21 $2.740.47
$2,740.47
4316 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6181
Vero Beach, FL 32967
Lot 12 & N 45.8 Ft of Lot 13
(OR Bk 456 PP 564)
12. Timothy A. & Carolyn C. Hendren
29 32 39 00003 0000 00013.0 133.80 $20.21 $2,704.10
$2,704.10
4308 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6181
Vero Beach, FL 32967
S 44 Ft of Lot 13 & All Lot 14 (OR
Bk 494 PP 205)
13. Joseph C. & Catherine Rossmell
29 32 39 00003 0000 00015.0 179.60 $20.21 $3,629.71
$3,629.71
4315 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6181
Vero Beach, FL 32967
Lots 15 & 16
14. Luke N. & Luise Martin
29 32 39 00003 0000 00017.0 134.70 $20.21 $2,722.29
$2,722.29
4325 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6}81
Vero Beach, FL 32967
Lot 17 & S 1/2 of Lot 18 (OR Bk 496
PP 692)
15. Vincent A. Novakowsld
29 32 39 00003 0000 00018.0 154.70 $20.21 $3,126.49
$3,126.49
4345 60th Avenue
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6181
Vero Beach, FL 32967
N 1/2 of Lot 18, All Lot 19 & S 20 Ft
of Lot 20
60avpre.wkl
01 -Apr -97
00
O
in
1
1
PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR PAVING AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO:
60TH AVENUE SOUTH OF 45TH STREET IN PONDEROSA ESTATES
TOTAL FRONT FEET.......... 2520.16
PROJECT NO.9536
NAME & ADDRESS
16. Jeffrey Craig & Kimberly Morgan
4365 60th Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
17. Gary Furless
4445 601h Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
18. Bruce G. & Valerie Kennison
4451 60th Avenue
Vero Beach, FL 32967
60avpre.wkl
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
29 32 39 00003 0000 00020.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit 1 PBI 6}81
Lot 20 Less S 20 Ft & S 54.9 Ft of Lot
21 (OR Bk 443 PP 814)
29 32 39 00003 0000 00021.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6)81
N 34.90 Ft of Lot 21 & All of Lots 22
& 23 (OR Bk 484 PP 873)
29 32 39 00003 00(0 00024.0
Ponderosa Estates Unit I PBI 6181
Lot 24 & S 60.4 Ft of Lot 25 (OR Bk
399 PP 664)
COST TO PROPERTY OWNERS... $50,932.43
COST PER FRONT FOOT .... S $20,21
FRONT
TOTAL
FOOTAGE COST/F.F. TOTAL COST ASSESSMENT COST
124.70 $20.21 $2,520.19
$2,520.19
214.50 $20.21
149.92 $20.21
$4,335.04
$3,029.88
2520.16 $20.21 $50,932.43
TOTAL PRONT COST PER P.R 7107AL COST
FOOTAGE
$4,335.04
$3,029.88 '
$50,932.43
TOTAL ASSE4SMt>tVV'T
01 -Apr -97
0)
IV
GIFFORD PARK WATER AND SEWER IM PRO + + S -
HUTCHINSON UTILUMS
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 2, 1997:
TO:
James E. Chandler,
County Administrator
FROM:
James W. Davis, P.E.
Public Works Director
SUBJECT:
Gifford Park Water & Sewer Improvements
Approval of Contract
DATE:
April 2, 1997 Y -
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
On March 11, 1997, the Board approved the award of bid to Hutchinson Utilities for water
and sewer improvements to Gifford Park in the amount of $28,728.30.
RECOMMENDATIONS AND FUNDING
Staff recommends authorization for the Chairman to execute the attached contracts.
After execution from the Board, staff will issue the Notice to Proceed.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED by
Commissioner Adams, the Board unanimously approved
the Agreement with Hutchinson Utilities for Gifford
Park Water and Sanitary Sewer Improvements, as
recommended by staff.
AGREEMENT IS ON FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
FLORIDA EAST COAST (FEC) RAILWAY COMPANY LICENSE
AGREEMENT - BLANKET UT LrrY CROSSING AGREEMENT
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 7, 1997:
TO: James E.- Chandler,
County Administrator
FROM: James W. Davis, P.E.,
Public Works Director 4
SUBJECT: Florida East Coast Railway Company -
Blanket Utility Crossing Agreement
REF. LETTER: M.O. Bagley, Manager, FECRR Industrial Development and Real Estate Office, to
_ Jim Davis dated Mar. 26, 1997
DATE: April 7, 1997
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
As the Public Works Department has constructed various drainage pipes and traffic signal
conduit beneath the FEC Railway tracks, individual agreements for each project were
approved to provide for the County facilities in the 100' railroad right-of-way. A yearly
APRIL 159 1997 50
license fee of $50. per year has been required to be paid by the County. At this time, the
FECRR requests that the County execute one blanket agreement for all three pipe
crossings instead of having three individual agreements on record. In addition, the annual
license fee is increasing substantially between 1997 and 2000, for one crossing as much
as 700%. The total yearly fee for the three pipes will be $150 for 1997 and $725 in 2000
and thereafter.
ALTERNATIVES AND ANALYSIS
As usual, the FECRR is very autonomous in requiring right-of-way users to execute
agreements such as the one attached. The alternatives are as follows:
Alternative No. 1
Approve the agreement and authorize the Chairman's signature.
Alternative No. 2
Do not approve the agreement and remove the two storm sewer pipes (one
under the 16P Street and one under 12"' Street) and traffic signal conduit at
Highland Drive.
RECOMMENDATIONS AND FUNDING
Staff recommends Alternative No. 1 whereby the agreement is approved. Funding to be
from Road and Bridge Division Fund 111-214.
Public Works Director Jim Davis- -advised the Board that the FEC
has the authority to charge local governments for use of their
rights-of-way.
After general discussion, Commissioner Adams felt the railroad
has as much responsibility and liability for the water flow as the
County and felt our arm is being twisted. The railroad is
evidently looking at these fees as a revenue source and there are
only 3 of these. Utilities will be bringing more agreements before
the Board.
Commissioner Ginn suggested that staff contact the railroad in
an effort to get them to see the mutual benefit to the agreements
and possibly lower their fees.
ON NOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED by
Commissioner Adams, the Board -unanimously approved
deferring this -item for one week to allow staff an
opportunity to attempt to further negotiate with
Florida East Coast Railway.
SEAWALL LAWSUIT COAEMnK rS
County Attorney Charles Vitunac announced that during the last
week the DEP permit for the Millar and Somoza seawalls became
permanent which makes the County's emergency seawall permit null
and void. Therefore, the County has no need to defend the straight
line concept discussed in relation to the lawsuit filed by Clemens.
APRIL 159 1997 51
RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF RETAINING THE MURPHY ACT
The Board reviewed a copy of Senate Bill 2410 and a Press
Release of April 11, 1997:
'j"iuy,lyy: u8: 24 9044883373 LAND MANAGEMENT SERV PAGE 02
A DMSON OF CU3
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Section 1. Section 253.82, Florida Statutes, is
amended to read:
253.82 Title of state or private owners to Murphy Act
lands. --
1 a 1 .'F3 }faf . The interest of the state in any land
which was acquired by the state under chapter 18296, Laws of
Florida, 1937,'but which is listed on a county tax assessment
roll as being owned by a person other than the state and on
which ad valorem taxes have been paid. -at least since January
1. 1971, is hereby released to such person. The rights that
are released under this paraarauh sabseet_en are all rights in
the land, including state -held subsurface rights.
1
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
APRIL 159 1997 52
•
�_
•-!*.i Rl� ,..ri..,.r �-. _..moi—_:�Ifiry�f�l6ClffdO�I��
f���U
- SWATS BII1 2 �{ l o BY j i /i f. G2 f T 1997 ItEGiJI.AR SFSSIOh
A bill to be entitled
R _:-•:
- An act relating to Murphy Act lands; amending
s. 253.82, F.S.; providing for the expiration
4
of government claims to such lands when a
5
landowner of record'or the landowner's
~1
predecessor in title has paid ad valorem taxes
7
_ on the lands for a specified period or the land
•_e
has been exempt from ad valorem taxation for a
9
specified period; providing for certain
10
information to be recorded; requiring a
11
governmental entity claiming an interest in
.12
-
such lands to record a statement of its claim
13
,: and provide a copy of the statement to the
14
landowner of record; providing a time
'15
limitation for suits on such claims; providing
1.6
an effective date.
17
18
Be
It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Section 1. Section 253.82, Florida Statutes, is
amended to read:
253.82 Title of state or private owners to Murphy Act
lands. --
1 a 1 .'F3 }faf . The interest of the state in any land
which was acquired by the state under chapter 18296, Laws of
Florida, 1937,'but which is listed on a county tax assessment
roll as being owned by a person other than the state and on
which ad valorem taxes have been paid. -at least since January
1. 1971, is hereby released to such person. The rights that
are released under this paraarauh sabseet_en are all rights in
the land, including state -held subsurface rights.
1
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
APRIL 159 1997 52
0-3/ M 159 i 08:24
LAND MANAGEMENT SERV
PAGE 8
"oii''.equest by any person, the county tax
a �eeofd Un the official records of the county
' ccated a certificate that the.taxes have•
>=e an Ary -1;' 19717, by'. the iandovnez oz the
e ecessor in title, if in tact the taxes have
uc'h'certificate is conclusive evidence of that
ZeO
�•fi'ttat The title to .
any land that which was
l=ed -Oy :the :state under chapter 18296, Laws of Florida,
_ jexcept those parcels that which have been sold,
onv'eyed; dedicated, or released by the state pursuant to
Paragraph (a) �subseeeiea- t}}. -is hereby vested in the Board of
�_ X1'3 Trustees of the Internal -Improvement Trust Fund.
MUS .
?•tbt Land to which title is vested in the board of
?5 trustees by subparagraph 1.
paragraph -tat shall be treated in
:�7.: 16 the same manner as other nonsovereignty lands owned by the
�=�• •""= 17 bosid. However,
y title
which is
18 vested in the Board of parcel drusteeslof the eInternal oImprovement
19 -Trust Fund pursuant to this subsection section which is 5
20 acres or less in size and has an appraised market value of
-"_J21 '$000400 or less is
hereby declared surplus and ma
y be sold_22 any in
manner provided by law, All proceeds from the sale of
23 such land shall be deposited into the Conservation and
24 Recreation Lands Trust Fund.
25
1 --tet The holder of a claim or lien against land
26 vested in the board of trustees by subparagraph 1, paragraph
Z7 tat, including p
a or special taxing district, has
28 until October t, 1985, to institute suit in a court of
29 competent jurisdiction to establish or enforce the claim or
30 lien. The failure to institute suit by October 1, 1985, is
31 -conclusive evidence of abandonment of the claim or lien, and
2
CODING: Words st-Tiz*en are deletions; words underlined are additions.
ZJ3L PAG,
PRM 15, 1997 53
L-: W MASUU3EMEWT SERV
21-1424A-97
P49iE 04
1 such claim or lien will become unenforceable. This
2 subvaraaranh paragraph shall not operate to revive any claim
3 or lien previously extinguished by operation of law.
4 ltd} Any person who has a claim to Murphy Act lands
5 based upon a defect in a deed executed by the Hoard of
6 Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund has until
7 October 1, 1985, to institute suit in a court of competent
8 jurisdiction to establish the claim, or it will.be forever
9 barred.
10 off} This subsection aectien does not affect
11 marketability of title established pursuant to chapter 712
12 prior to October 1, 1984.
13 Je_1{5} This subsection seetien does not affect the
14 validity of previous conveyances of Murphy Act lands by the
15 board of trustees or previous reservations or restrictions in
16 such conveyances made prior to July 1, 1991.
17 (2)(a) The interest of the state or a local government
18 in any land that was acquired by the state under chanter
19 18296, Laws of Florida, 1937 expires on July 1, 1997 when:
20 1. The landowner. and any predecessor in title of the
21 landowner, has vaid ad valorem taxes on the land since July 1
22 1971, or until such time after July 1 1990, when the'broderty_'
23 became tax exempt; or .
24 2. If the land was on July 1 1990 exempt from ad
25 valorem taxes and has remained continuously exempt since that
26 date, the landowner has shown that the landowner or the
27 landowner's vredecessor in title was issued a buildino permit
28 for a structure on all or Rart of the land in which the state
29 or local government claims an interest or that a structure
30 owned by the landowner has been in place on the land since
31 July 1, 1990 and the state or local government has not
3 :.
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined�are.additiorii-
APRIL 159 1997 54
UJ o'*1fiVy'8_2 ` «M9844883379 LAND MANAGEMENT SERV PAGE 05
'demanded the removal of the structure or otherwise notified
2 the landownero_f its objection to the placement of_ the
3 structure on the land.
4 (b) Upon reguest by the landowner, the countXtax
5 collector shall record in the official records of the county
6 in which the land is located a certificate that the taxes have
7 been paid since January 1, 1971, by the landowner or the
8 landowner's predecessor in title, if in fact the taxes have
9 been paid. If the landowner, and any predecessor in title of
10 the landowner, have not been liable for taxes since at least
a 11 Julv 1, 1990, a copy of the building permit or other evidence
12 that would be acceptable to the tax assessor to prove
13 construction of a buildino on the land in which the state or
14 local government claims an interest shall be recorded in the
15 official records of the county.
16 '(3) All interest of the state or a local government in
17 any land that was acquired by the state under chanter 18296,
18 Laws of Florida, 1937, and that is not
19 subseotherwise described in
ction (1) or subsection (2) expires July 1 2002 unless
20 before that date, the overne►ental entitY claiming the
21 interest files a statement of its claim in the official
22 records of the county documenting its right to the claim and
23 provides a copy of the statement to the De son shown on the
24 official records of the count as the fee simple owner of the
25 land. A landowner has 2 years after receiving the statement
26 to institute anv legal action to challenge the governmental
27 entity's claim
28 Section 2. This act shall take effect July 1, 1997.
.29 -
30
31
4
CODING: Words strieken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
APRIL, 159 1997 55
Awftz.:+ *.$I-S-988-5396
81st .65018
1937 Murphy ACt To Be Revhfted
T&4hWek H—Senate'MU-2410 filed by NO"rough County, Senaw jatne�Hqpu.
. ._ . ;tri bring relief to tltourudr At
F*W miqs whose des~
clouWed by• 1937 Murphy'Ad mad m=mnt& Many propeny awnea-amumonm.1ha -
--7--"rjRvpfttm" haim a State dales an them s*Id.)eaWVjokknWn,-Predderd..
T
Strect, Busincis CbalittoP in Munpa. Ut problem come to lightvhcA pw dplini-1kd
p.oft
viir
SUM in T=p& to 'a low low dMded hl&* Was reveded In: W
property and busincissowners : arc'ifrald they win not be,piid'tl*-fuU-v&lve
their_ *istuimts although they paid tabes oo these unknown, roa-*=smCnU
over OW Years. thinking they owned all the land deeded to them Venkytdo VaUadaim
*id hb.*0t MIOWWW-lkwt $1 14.000.in vrop7w vahe on A* Unpa 1ivii16-tima-m'
believe that 49OYi6*tiO'&: TIM read Ca6lieamt.
tt law diaL.Kt)k43.p't+!I.lLoften homatexdN*se--+The-,Vagadnerfindir-&d-.I.—.
Can mn thiF�tyyran ago seed State lawpass.ed'i I
Carl. 937 who sem -
v
41se. dW.t pay their taxes Is unfle and. wrong, when proper%y-mvners after Oiit*hrm
paid d4unvivir* We+ fled fiom Cmw only io be robbeff by the Amcsica.k
of alvasun, Ky'nokhelp the Vagadm* faim
&�.Phuqe the nu Wd
Mrs. jnhhson-Ow doe$ not want to we thit Opedence gated for 4M it.trter
i*hcr-* Pi6 owners throughout the .state, but she Feamilt -All. if SmAtdr N
plen� I 1�
mmum falls. Many Litic companies. LrA�em.midReaitursmvcuas:kd.iiii "omX'
thise suitiomed"MeM, Onts for years and vnstopectlaglpyers-am the ones who
eventually ice damaged.when a mad mines through she said:. This is.the first iiwe -the:
kfWaury has-attempted to correct this. b4 year Oldrontsho-&-d&
goverall", w
gmtt 11
!s BiU' -
n convct govenunent abuse of dfiien jim.peny rights 'irid
7,"
insure th7.,am compensated at fair market value the said... Property Appralsen faced
with
colilplailiti about taxing ga,vemtapt eaAem.mft:to unsuqj.eqh.#& and
P" PPOPCeWoWnen will tie relieve;; by.paasage of this bilL Air,tidi
-';'WPMV APPilm Rob.'TuMeri Umpa ofte. it -wiU taim.'staff jlj fiitygArs to
identify and try to Implement away tohandlethe government:eascincrit queom of
t1tation. '-When SenaLpr'Haqpett's Bill'becime known athong gpvaTTt cirdes in+
Tallahassee; the walls .vibrated reports vA# of S=tor JH "Mrc is arsmt!� e wasu
edledtYled'to ame Warc the
jttdidacy,ind Natural.
malfill Osiwcd into Law an July 1+ of this Mrs. Johnson
C
PO Lbeir.Senator and RePmentative acid ask thein to suppQd this for% over-duc.. .
rop�rty fights nwAsure. PAssing this-Bill warew= o4vamfidence In the z)stem:
'-.MPD*2.•-LlA40f.GMyR=kan,ifthe Apostiortc.RockChurch whose au!ch.!!!"-
stay bc.sphlt by an unknown dalmed'nnT mad +casctnau tbiev knew nothing about
APRIL 15, 1997 56
whom thcv •ptgdu d in 1993. In last months meeting of thaTemple Crest Civlc-0ub
iln-Tampa. loiiidtab and members also voiced support of Senator. -Eia�ir hVilatim
_ actias� to cu a the. pmblem:. T ase against. chis 81I1 just .want to continue to talke
hmateitd and -business values from atiizctta and that lsvitottg and Mm-.jolu;aorG
--Cov�rttmatt idols report thta planet . 11<ill. ooxtld W +aibcr to is • •*+� �_ :- -
lfuttuiE t+ugdright Of vinyt That -is a icamtacm sight, naw aaly a few db vd _
�: _..
gwiiers foot shat bW *kdIt othtts pay nathn'out of theftpmperty valura::said Mrs.,
,jahnPon.**At leaat now everyone pays equanY thangh gu, taus, not just: & fewabuwd
4 2etc who. haver paid ixopesty WxrA on all their land juat_lik a those rwho. have -no
TIrm 1036 eascment..Senttte. Hill 2410 must be passed she aaid. .
Public Works Director Jim Davis advised that if the Murphy Act
revisions pass, all Murphy Act rights-of-way will expire 7/1/97.
Some of this right-of-way has structures in it and if all rights-
of-way are abandoned, the County will need to acquire monumental
amounts of right-of-way.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht, SECONDED by
Commissioner Ginn, the Board unanimously adopted
Resolution 97-32 to the Legislature of the State of
Florida in favor of retaining The Murphy Act.
RESOLUTION NO. 97-32
A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, TO
THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA IN
FAVOR OF RETAINING THE MURPHY ACT.
WHEREAS, Senate and House Bills have been filed with the Legislature of the
State of Florida, which would in fact repeal the Murphy Act, which has been in effect since
1937; and
WHEREAS, the right of way protected by the Murphy Act has enabled Florida
counties and cities to construct and improve better and safer roadways for the protection
of all of the residents of Florida, and, if local governments can no longer rely on Murphy
Act rights of way and must instead purchase the same rights of way, the ability of local
governments to provide safe roadways will be severely impaired;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that Indian River County
respectfully requests that the Legislature of the State of Florida retain the Murphy Act as it
has been for the last 60 years.
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner Macht, and the motion
was seconded by Commissioner Ginn, and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as
follows:
Chairman Carolyn K. Eggert
Aye
Vice Chairman John W. Tippin
Aye
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn
Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams
Aye
Commissioner Kenneth R. Macht
Aye
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this
15th day of April, 1997.
Attest:
Jeffre .B on, Clerk 0_XIi
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
APRIL 159 1997 57
By
arolyn K4:�.
Chairman
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT - BOARD OF COUNTY COAINMSIONERS
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 10, 1997:
To: Board of County Commissioners
From: Alice E. White, Executive Aide
Date: April 10, 1997
Subject: Computer for Commissioner Ginn`s use.
Commissioner Ginn has requested a computer for her use. I have looked at
the surplused computers which have been turned into Purchasing, and they
will not suit our needs. The computer that Commissioner Macht has been
using is being moved to the front desk for use by Commissioner Macht and
whoever has the front desk duty each week.
I have talked to Joe Baird and he informs me that there is a little over $1600
left in the Auditor's account which will be enough to cover the purchase of a
computer. Since my workload on the computer will be heavier, if the Board
approves the purchase, I intend to use the new computer at my station and
give my recently upgraded computer to Commissioner Ginn.
Please approve the purchase of a computer with funds to be transferred from
account 001-101-511-033.21 to account 001-101-511.
a4b. il/
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht, SECONDED by
Commissioner Adams, the Board unanimously approved
the purchase of the computer equipment.
COUNCIL OF COMMUNIrY SER CES
Chairman Eggert stated that she has been paying these dues
individually while representing the Board on this Council.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED by
Commissioner Adams, the Board unanimously approved
the payment of the $15 annual dues for Chairman
Eggert.
APRIL 159 1997 58
O
EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES FORUM
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 9, 1997:
$MERGING TECHNOLOGIES BRIEFING
LOCAL GOVERNMENT ISSUES AND CONCERNS
APRIL 9, 1997
By E. Eugene Webb PhD
PHLSifl TA'iION UATE: MAY 7, 1997 AK
I. RBGOLATSD VERM C:OMPRTITIVE EMYIRQ$WWNT
A. TELEC0r4sMCA?IONS AND COMPETITIOV
I. CABLE INDUSTRY
2. TSLEPMXWE I)MUSTRY
3..WIRRLRBS INDUSTRY
B. E"NCTS OF COMFETITION
1. CONSUM M
2. LOCAL GGT
XI_ LOCAL GOVERNMENT REGULATORY ISSUES
A. RIGHT OF %MY MANAGE16M
D. LAND USS Z88=5
1. 7.o 146 FOR TOWERS
2. ORDINLNM
a. UTILlTY BLIGHT
C. ANTENNA AMD TOWER SITE PROLIFMW40N
1. USE OF MwerPAL PRAPRWM
2. COLZ10=20N 18SUE8
3. DOWNWM MIGRATION OF WIRSLE*S SYSTSMB
D. a9XVICB PROgISIow IR =SIMMTIAL pe"
E. FEDEM PRZOWTIOINS
1. TAMING
2. HEALTH AND AAPSTY
F. STAW RaGUL&TO" ACTIOM
III. LOCAL GOVEEMN7' OPPORZURITIES
A. RC"7ME OPPORTMTISS
Ft. PROCUIiMWT OPPORTUNITIES
C. ECOSOMIC DWELOPMENT ISSUES
IV. QUESTIONS ARD ANSWERS
Commissioner Tippin stated that Eugene Webb, PhD. will make a
presentation, discussing towers and right-of-way fees on May 7,
1997, Wednesday, at 10 AM, in Room 101, County Administration
Building, Virginia Avenue, Ft. Pierce. This presentation is being
sponsored by the Treasure Coast Council of Local Governments.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht, SECONDED by
Commissioner Adams, the Board unanimously authorized
the Commissioners and staff to attend the Emerging
Technologies Forum to be held Wednesday, May 7,
1997, at 10:00 a.m. in Room 101 at the St. Lucie
County Administration Building, Ft. Pierce.
APRIL 159 1997 59
BOOK F'A.Gc irk
I V.1- I III" R-1100 I. 10101VUNDW
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of April 10, 1997:
To: Board of County Commissioners
From: Fran B. Adams 06*
County Commissioner
Date: April 10, 1997
Subject: Fairgrounds Advisory Subcommittee
When the Fairgrounds Advisory Committee was first formed, it was for the
purpose of developing a master plan for the fairground. This has been
accomplished, and the committee did not meet for several years. It was then
made a subcommittee of the Parks and Recreation Committee and was
restructured to include mostly agriculture representatives.
Inasmuch as the fairground comes under the purview of the Parks and
Recreation Committee, I believe that committee can handle enhancement to
the fairground, with assistance from the Agriculture Advisory Committee if
necessary. I would recommend that the Fairgrounds Advisory Subcommittee
be abolished and taken off our lengthy committee list. When we are dealing
with the fairground issues, the Firefighters representatives will be included in
the discussions.
At the request of County Attorney Vitunac, the Board reviewed
a letter of April 3, 1997:
lt►ritla I)t ltarinu nt t►f 1rt it ttltnrt & I aut�nnu r tit r� it t
11011 CIIIINVI"(1111), Coni In
Th" (:altilol • T,allaliassve. Fl, :2399-01;111)
Plea— H—pond to:
Division of Marketing and
Development
541 Past Tennessee Street
Tallahassee. Florida 32108
904/487-4322
April 3, 1997
Mr. Toby D. Turner
Firefighters Indian River County Fair C , G�►;��'7y: •� `'
1818 Commerce Avenue
Vero Beach, Florida 32960
Dear Mr. Turner: -
Thank you for the informative telephone conversation last week. As we discussed, the
Department has been permitting your annual fair under a 1987 agreement between the Indian River
Board of County Commissioners, the Vero Beach Firefighters Association and Doyle Conner, who
was the Commissioner of Agriculture at that time. At this point it will be necessary for the
Firefighters Indian River County fair to form a fair association as prescribed by law in Chapter 616
of the Florida Statutes. These statutes govern the formation and operation of all county fairs.
APRIL 159 1997 60
I am enclosing a copy of that Chapter 616 for your perusal. Please keep in mind, your
organization will need to form a fair association under these guidelines in order to qualify for future
premium and awards funds.
If I may he of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me at the Bureau of State
Markets, phone (904) 487-4322. 1 look forward to working with you in the future.
Sincerely,
BOB CRAWFORD
CONI[ /7/IIS/SI/O/NE)R OF AGRICULTURE
Carl Penn
Development Representative If
County Attorney Vitunac felt Indian River County's is the only
fair in the state which has worked very well and now the State is
attempting to require that it become a private corporation.
Commissioner Adams stated that the Parks and Recreation
Committee will follow through on this and consult with the
Firefighters.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams, SECONDED by
Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously voted to
abolish the Fairgrounds Advisory Subcommittee.
NEW COURTHOUSE BENCHES
The Board reviewed a letter of February 6, 1997:
P.O. Box 969 • Vero Beach, FL 32961-0969 (407) 567-4303
February 6, 1997 r
Ken Macht
3240 16th Street
Vero Beach, Florida 32960
Dear Ken,
I know you share my love of Vero Beach and the lifestyle we enjoy living here. As
you know, I have been active in an effort to restore the "Historic Downtown" section of
Vero Beach. Much progress has been made, but there is still much to do, and it will
take all of us conscientiously working together to make this dream a reality.
I am enclosing a brochure on park benches to be placed in the downtown area. I
selected the benches (with city approval), to be installed by the city at selected locations
beginning with the model block. The benches are a classic cast iron frame with
mahogany slats and each bench will have a bronze plaque honoring someone or
something.
APRIL 159 1997
61
k
We all have family members or know someone who has in some way made Vero
Beach a better place. Let's honor those that have made our lives better, or maybe you
would just like to donate a bench. Actual cost is $750.00 per bench - bronze plaques
will be installed free. (No one is making a profit from this project). I hope you will join
me in this exciting project.
Sincerely
R rt
L. Brackett
Commissioner Macht asked for permission to place two benches
on the breezeway at the new courthouse at no cost to the County.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht, SECONDED by
Commissioner Tippin, the Board unanimously approved
2 benches to be placed on either side of the
entrance at the new Courthouse.
EMERGENCY SERVICES DISTRICT
The Chairman announced that, immediately upon adjournment, the
Board would reconvene as the Board of Commissioners of the
Emergency Services District. Those Minutes are being prepared
separately.
There being no further business, on Motion duly made, seconded
and carried, the Board adjourned at 10:36 a.m.
ATTEST:
v
J. B ton, Clerk
Minutes Approved:
APRIL 159 1997
57- C-9-7
62
J,4�� ze
CarolK. Egge Chairman