HomeMy WebLinkAbout11/17/1998� MINUTES ATTACHED i
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
A G E N D A
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17,1998 - 9:00 A.M.
County Commission Chamber
County Administration Building
1840 25th Street, Vero Beach, Florida 32960
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
John W. Tippin, Chairman (District 4)
Kenneth K Macht, Vice Chairman (District 3)
Fran B. Adams (District 1)
Caroline D. Ginn (District 5)
Ruth Stanbridge (District 2)
James E. Chandler, County Administrator
Charles P. Vitunac, County Attorney
Jeffrey K. Barton, Clerk to the Board
9:00 a.m. 1. CALL TO ORDER BACKUP
2. INVOCATION PAGES
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Comm. Fran B. Adams
4. ADDITIONS to the AGENDA/EMERGENCY ITEMS
1. Add Item S.C., Proclamation Designating November 15 though 21,1998 as "Shaken Baby Syndrome Awareness week" in Indian
River County.
2. Add Item MALL, Comments regarding Legislative Delegation matters
3. Add Item 13.A.2., Swearing In Citizens at Board Meetings,
5. PROCLAMATION and PRESENTATIONS
A. Proclamation Designating Week of Nov. 22-28,1998
as "Christian Heritage Week" in Ind. Riv. Co. 1
B. Proclamation Designating November 19, 1998
as "The Great American Smoke Out" in I.R.C. 2
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Regular Meeting of October 27, 1998
7. CONSENT AGENDA
A. Received & Placed on File in Office of Clerk to
the Board: 1) Report of Convictions - Oct., 1998,
2) Fla Inland Navigation Dist. (FIND) - District
Map, Budget and Meeting Schedule for FY 1998-99
B. Approval of Warrants
(memorandum dated November 5, 1998) 3-17
C. Payments to Vendors of Court Related Costs
(memorandum dated November 6, 1998) 18
D. Harmony Oaks, Inc. Request for Board Acknowledg-
ment of Bargain Sale/Purchase of the Harmony Oaks
LAAC Site, for Purposes of Income Tax Credit
(memorandum dated November 9, 1998) 19-24
BOOK 107 PAGE 009
BOOK
7. CONSENT AGENDA Lcont'C:
E. Bid Award: IRC Bid #9019 Removal of Diesel
Fuel Storage Tanks (Utilities Dept.)
(memorandum dated November 9, 1998)
F. 13th St. SW Right -of -Way Acquisition
(memorandum dated November 6, 1998)
G. Request for Floodplain Cut and Fill Balance
Waiver for Lot 5, Block 16, Vero Lake Estates,
Unit 3
(memorandum dated November 6, 1998)
H. Professional Services Agreement for 66th Ave.
Paving & Drainage Agreement
(memorandum dated November 6,1998)
107 urF 10
BACKUP
PAGES
25-34
35-41
42-44
45-61
I. Approval of Correction to Reconciliation of Costs
Statement Regarding County/State Purchase of
the DeGuzman Parcel of the Round Island South
LAAC Site
(memorandum dated November 10, 1998) 62-74
J. Recently Acquired Property - Tax Cancellation
(memorandum dated November 9, 1998) 75-79
K. Required Improvements - Fairways at Grand Harbor,
a Planned Residential Development
(memorandum dated November 10, 1998) 80-88
8. CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS and
GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES
None
9:05 A.M. 9. PUBLIC ITEMS
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. First Church of God of Vero Beach Inc.'s
Request for Special Exception Approval
for a Primary and Secondary School Facility
(continued from meeting of 10/27/98)
(memorandum dated November 10, 1998) 89-105
2. Indian River Land Trust Inc.'s Request
for Special Exception Use Approval for
McKee Botanical Garden (Quasi -Judicial)
(memorandum dated November 10, 1998) 106-120
B. PUBLIC DISCUSSION ITEMS
None
C. PUBLIC NOTICE ITEMS
None
10. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S MATTERS
None
11. DEPARTMENTAL MATTERS
BACKUP
A.
Community Development
PAGES
None
B.
Emergency Services
None
C.
General Services
None
D.
Leisure Services
None
E.
Office of Management and Budget
None
_ F.
Personnel
None
G.
Public Works
County Beach Scraping
(backup will be provided separately)
H.
Utilities
1. Kings Subdivision Water Main Project
Bid No. 8051
(memorandum dated November 5, 1998)
121-124
2. North Beach Reuse Study
(memorandum dated October 30, 1998)
125-141
L
Human Services
None
12. COUNTY ATTORNEY
A.
Surety Bonds for Constitutional Officers
(memorandum dated November 5, 1998)
142-144
B.
Request to Remove Development Restriction
on Lots 14-20, Colonial Heights Subdivision
(memorandum dated October 7, 1998)
145-155
13. COMMISSIONERS ITEMS
A.
Chairman John W. Tiepin
B. Vice Chairman Kenneth R Macht
C. Commissioner Fran B. Adams
moK 107 PAGE I i
BOOK 107 PAGE G I °�
BACKUP
13. COMMISSIONERS ITEMS (contd.):
D. Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn PAGES
E. Commissioner Ruth Stanbridge
Appointment to P & Z Commission
from District 2
14. SPECIAL DISTRICTSBOARDS
A. Emergency Services District
None
B. Solid Waste Disposal District
1. Approval of Minutes - meeting of 10/20/98
2. Approval of Minutes - meeting of 10/27/98
3. Bid Award: #9007 Annual Contract for Fill
Dirt
(memorandum dated November 6, 1998) 156-160
4. Landfill Security Service, Bid No. 9015
(memorandum dated November 5,1998) 161-172
C. Environmental Control Board
None
15. ADJOURNMENT
Anyone who may wish to appeal any decision which may be made at this meeting will need
to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and
evidence upon which the appeal will be based.
Anyone who needs a special accommodation for this meeting may contact the county's
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) coordinator at 567-8000 x408 at least 48 hours in advance
Df meeting.
Meeting may be broadcast live on TCI Cable Channel 13 - rebroadcast various times
throughout the week
Falcon Cable Channel 35 - rebroadcast Friday evening
INDEX TO MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING
OF BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
1. CALL TO ORDER ............................................... 1-
2. INVOCATION ................................................. .1-
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND SWEARING IN OF NEW
COMMISSIONERS ............ ............................... -1-
4. ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA ................................... 1-
5. PROCLAMATIONS AND PRESENTATIONS ......................... 2-
5.A. PROCLAMATION - "CHRISTIAN HERITAGE WEEK" ............2-
5.B. PROCLAMATION -"THE GREAT AMERICAN SMOKE OUT' .... -3-
5.C. PROCLAMATION - "SHAKEN BABY SYNDROME AWARENESS
WEEK" ................................................. 4-
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES ....................................... .5-
7. CONSENT AGENDA ........................................... .5-
7.A. REPORTS ................................................. 5-
7.B. LIST OF WARRANTS ........................................ .5-
7.C. PAYMENTS TO VENDORS OF COURT RELATED COSTS .............. .15-
7.D. HARMONY OAKS, INC. AND RIVERPOINT, INC. - REQUEST FOR BOARD
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF BARGAIN SALE/PURCHASE OF THE HARMONY OAKS
LAAO SITE FOR PURPOSES OF INCOME TAX CREDIT ............... .16-
7.E. BID #9019 - REMOVAL OF DIESEL FUEL STORAGE TANKS - UTILITIES - FRED
RICE & ASSOCIATES, INC .................................... .18 -
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-1-
BOOK 10'7
PAGE 613
A
r
BOOK IN PAGE G14
71. GEORGE AND SARITA JOHNSTON -13TH STREET RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION
...................................................... .19-
7.G. MGB CONSTRUCTION, INC. - FLOODPLAIN CUT AND FILL BALANCE WAIVER
- LOT 5, BLOCK 16, VERO LAKE ESTATES, UNIT 3 ................. .20-
7.H. 66TH AVENUE PAVING AND DRAINAGE PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING
SERVICES AGREEMENT - CARTER ASSOCIATES, INC . ............... .22-
7.I. ROUND ISLAND SOUTH LAAC SITE - DEGUZMAN PARCEL - CORRECTION TO
RECONCILIATION OF COSTS STATEMENT REGARDING PURCHASE ...... .23-
7.J. RESOLUTION 98-128 CANCELLING TAXES - BARNETTE AND HARIOT GREENE
- AND RESOLUTION 98-129 CANCELLING TAXES - GRIFFIN AND CAMILLE
GREENE (RECENTLY ACQUIRED PROPERTIES) ................... .24-
7.K. FAIRWAYS AT GRAND HARBOR, PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT -
CONTRACT FOR REQUIRED IMPROVEMENTS - CASH DEPOSIT AND ESCROW
AGREEMENT ............................................ .29-
9.A.1. PUBLIC HEARING - FIRST CHURCH OF GOD OF VERO BEACH, INC. -
REQUEST FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPROVAL FOR PRIMARY AND
SECONDARY SCHOOL FACILITY (CONTINUED FROM OCTOBER 27, 1998
............................................................ .30-
9.A.2. PUBLIC HEARING - INDIAN RIVER LAND TRUST, INC. - REQUEST FOR
SPECIAL EXCEPTION USE APPROVAL FOR MCKEE BOTANICAL
GARDEN (Quasi -Judicial) ....................................... .40-
I I.G. COUNTY BEACH SCRAPING ................................... .47-
11.H.1. KINGSWAY SUBDIVISION - WATER MAIN PROJECT UW -97 -09 -DS -
BID #8051 - TREASURE COAST CONTRACTING ................... .51-
11.H.2. NORTH BEACH REUSE STUDY - PROJECT US -97 -04 -ED - BROWN
& CALDWELL............................................... .52-
12.A. SURETY BONDS FOR CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS .............. .53 -
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-2-
12.B. COLONIAL HEIGHTS SUBDIVISION, LOTS 14 THROUGH 20 - REQUEST
TO REMOVE DEVELOPMENT RESTRICTION (ZORC - HERAN) ...... .54-
13.A.1. LEGISLATIVE DELEGATION MATTERS .................... .60-
13.A.2. SWEARING IN CITIZENS AT BOARD MEETINGS ............ .60-
13.E. COMMISSIONER STANBRIDGE - PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION -
DISTRICT 2 - RESIGNATION OF WILLIAM MCNAMEE - APPOINTMENT
OF DR. DAVID COX .......................................... .60-
14.B. SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL DISTRICT ............................ .62 -
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-3- BOOK 107 FACE
November 17, 1998
REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS
The Board of County Commissioners of Indian River County, Florida, met in Regular
Session at the County Commission Chambers, 1840 25' Street, Vero Beach, Florida, on
Tuesday, November 17, 1998, at 9:00 a.m. Present were John W. Tippin, Chairman;
Kenneth R. Macht, Vice Chairman; Fran B. Adams; Caroline D. Ginn; and Ruth Stanbridge.
Also present were James E. Chandler, County Administrator; Charles P. Vitunac, County
Attorney; and Patricia "PJ" Jones, Deputy Clerk.
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Tippin called the meeting to order.
2. INVOCATION
Dr. Don Watkins of Morningstar Church delivered the Invocation.
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND SWEARING IN OF NEW
COMMISSIONERS
Commissioner Adams led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
Executive Aide Alice White swore in the new Commissioners Ruth Stanbridge and
John Tippin.
4. ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA
Chairman Tippin requested three (3) additions to today's Agenda:
1. Item 5.C., Proclamation Designating November 15 through 21, 1998 as
"Shaken Baby Syndrome Awareness Week" in Indian River County.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-1- BOOK 107 FnE 6.1.6
Fr- -7
BOOK 107 PAGE 617
2. Item 13.A.1., Comments regarding Legislative Delegation matters.
3. Item 13.A.2., Swearing in citizens at Board meetings.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously added the above items to the Agenda.
5. PROCLAMATIONS AND PRESENTATIONS
S.A. PROCLAMA TIONDESIGNA TING WEEK OFNOVEMBER 22-28,
1998 AS "CHRISTIANHERITAGE WEEK" ININDIANRIVER
COUNTY
The Chairman presented the following Proclamation to Robert Johnson of the Indian
River County Family Association:
PROCLAMATION
DESIGNATING THE WEEK OF
NOVEMBER 22 - 28,1998
AS "CHRISTIAN HERITAGE WEEK"
IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
WHEREAS, in America's first written constitution, the Mayflower Compact, the Pilgrim
fathers made a Covenant with Almighty God to "form a civil body politic" for the glory of God and
the advancement of the Christian faith," and
WHEREAS, our Founding Fathers recognized that obedience to our Sovereign Lord was the
key to national prosperity and security, and
WHEREAS, the Lord is recognized in all fifty state constitutions as the Chief Cornerstone
of civil government and of all other American institutions, and
WHEREAS, Abraham Lincoln proclaimed that, "it is the duty of nations to own their
dependence on the overruling power of God" and, "That those nations only are blessed whose God
is the Lord," and
WHEREAS, we measure time in the United States and in the western world from the birth
of the Son of God:
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLA34ED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the week ofNovember 22 -
28, 1998 be designated as
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
CHRISTIAN HERITAGE WEEK
in Indian River County. The Board, in conjunction with the Indian River County Family
Association, recognizes the importance of our Christian Heritage in family life.
Adopted this 17 day ofNovember,1999
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
'rw
S.B. PROCLAMATIONDESIGNATINGNOVEMBER 19.1998AS
"THE GREATAMERICANSMOKE OUT"ININDIANRIVER
COUNTY
The Chairman read the following Proclamation:
PROCLAMATION
DESIGNATING NOVEMBER 19,1998
AS "THE GREAT AMERICAN SMOKE OUT"
IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
WHEREAS, smoking is the most preventable cause of death in Florida, and 24.60/a of adult
Floridians are smokers; and
WHEREAS, in 1992, approximately 28, 176 Floridians died as a result of tobacco, which
translates to one in five deaths among Florida residents; and
WHEREAS, the 1992 Florida Youth Risk Behavior Survey concluded that 64% of 9-12
graders surveyed had tried smoking, and 25% of current 12th graders smoke; and
WHEREAS, persons with under twelve years of education and non -college bound students
have much higher smoking rates than those who complete high school or go on to higher education;
and
WHEREAS, there is an.urgent need to target dropout and vocational/technical school
students:
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIN[ED BY TEE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN -RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that November 19, 1998 is
designated as
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-3- BOOK 107 PAGE
BOOK i0_7 FACE
"THE GREAT AMERICAN SMOKE OUT"
in Indian River County, and the Board urges all parents and teachers to make the children aware of
the danger of smoking and the serious consequences derived from this activity.
Adopted this 17 day of November, 1998.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
r�
Jon . Tippin, C an
S.C. PROCLAMA TIONDESIGNA TING NOVEMBER 15-21 1998 AS
"SHA KEN BA B Y S YNDR OME A WARENESS WEEK" ININDL4N
RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
The Chairman read the following Proclamation:
PROCLAMATION
DESIGNATING NOVEMBER 25-21,1998
AS "SHAKEN BABY SYNDROME AWARENESS WEEK"
IN INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
WHEREAS. head trauma is the leading cause of disability among abused infants and
children, and shaking a baby, even if for only a few seconds, can cause bleeding inside the head and
increased pressure on the brain, injuring the baby for life; and
WHEREAS, Shaken Baby Syndrome is a condition that can result when a baby is vigorously
shaken; and
WHEREAS, Shaken Baby Syndrome occurs most 5requmdy in infants less than six months
old, yet can occur up to the age of three years, often with no obvious outward signs of inside injury,
even though almost 25% of babies with Shaken Baby Syndrome die; and
WHEREAS, an important mission of the Exchange Club of Indian River is to educate the
Public about the harmful effects -of shaking a baby..
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLA&= BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
CONMSSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA that the week ofNovember 15-21,
1998 be designated as
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
SHAKEN BABY SYNDROME AWARENESS WEEK
in Indian River County.
Adopted this 1701 day of November, 1998.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, TWn W. Tippin, a an
6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The Chairman asked if there were any corrections or additions to the Minutes of the
Regular Meeting of October 27, 1998. There were none.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved the Minutes of the Regular
Meeting of October 27, 1998, as written.
7. CONSENT AGENDA
Commissioner Ginn requested that Item 7.D. be pulled for discussion.
7.A. REPORTS
Received and placed on file in the Office of the Clerk to the Board:
1. Report of Convictions, October, 1998
2. Florida Inland Navigation District (FIND) - District Map, Budget and Meeting
Schedule for FY 1998-99
7.B. LIST OF WARRANTS
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 5, 1998:
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
E'UDP( iF PAGE G22®
FF,_ I
BOOK 107 PACE 6 2-1
TO: HONORABLE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DATE: NOVEMBER 5, 1998
SUBJECT: APPROVAL OF WARRANTS
FROM: EDWIN M. FRY, JR., FINANCE DIRECTOR
In compliance with Chapter 136.06. Florida Statutes, all warrants issued
by the Board of County Commissioners are to be recorded in the Board minutes.
Approval is requested for the attached list of warrants, issued by the Clerk
to the Board, for the time period of October 29 to November 5. 1998.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved the list of Warrants as issued
by the Clerk to the Board for the period from
October 29, 1998 through November 5, 1998, as
recommended by staff.
CHECK NAME CHECK CHECK
0019671
TEAMSTERS LOCAL ONION NO 769
1998-10-29
4,043.60
0019672
KEY TRUST COMPANY
1998-11-03
760.25
0019673
MASI, JANICE
1998 -11 -OS
15.60
0251593
A A FIRE EQUIPMENT, INC
1998-11-05
300.80
0251594
ABC-CLIO INC
1998 -11 -OS
283.55
0251595
ACE PLUMBING, INC
1998-11-05
42.00
0251596
A G L L
1998 -11 -OS
14.70
0251597
AIRBORNE EXPRESS
1998-11-05
60.45
0251598
ALPHA ACE HARDWARE
1998-11-05
33.18
0251599
ANIMAL CARE EQUIPMENT AND
1998 -11 -OS
93.17
0251600
APPLE MACHINE & SUPPLY CO
1998-11-05
358.24
0251601
AT YOUR SERVICE
1998 -11 -OS
1,911.20
0251602
ATCO TOOL SUPPLY
1998-11-05
224.00
0251603
AUTO SUPPLY CO OF VERU BEACH,
1998-11-05
131.59
0251604
ANDERSON, MICHAEL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251605
ADAM'S MARK HOTEL
1998-11-05
225.00
0251606
AQUAGENIX LAND -WATER
1998 -11 -OS
191.00
0251607
ALL POWER SERVICES, INC
1998-11-05
394.00
0251608
ANKENY, JOHN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251609
ABARE, EDWARD J III
1998-11-05
58.76
0251610
APCO INTERNATIONAL
1998-11-05
60.00
0251611
A T & T WIRELESS SERVICES
1998-11-05
42.01
0251612
A T & T
1998 -11 -OS
48.06
0251613
AMERICAN DESALTING
1998-11-05
25.00
0251614
ASHWORTH INC
1998-11-05
32.00
0251615
AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251616
AUTO PARTS OF VERO, INC
1998 -11 -OS
641.61
0251617
ALEXANDER, MIKE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251618
ANDERSON, STEVE RON
1998-11-05
30.00
0251619
A T & T
1998-11-05
43.27
0251620
ANCESTRY PUBLISHING
1998-11-05
54.90
0251621
AMA20N.CO4
1998-11-05
286.80
0251622
ARCADIA PUBLISHING
1998-11-05
20.49
0251623
ANDERSON, WILLIAM D
1998-11-05
9,266.62
0251624
ADKINS JEWELRY
1998-11-05
102.00
0251625
ASSOCIATES COMMERLIM CORP.
1998-11-05
7,310.16
0251626
APA -FLORIDA CHAPTER
1998-11-05
125.00
0251627
ALLSTATE
1998-11-05
563.02
0251628
B & B INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY
1998-11-05
125.14
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CHECK
SER
DATE
AMOUNT
0251629
BAITA, DAVID M
1998-11-05
30.00
0251630
BAKER DISTRIBUTING CO
1998-11-05
1,797.91
0251631
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
1998-11-05
11,042.86
0251632
SOLING, STAN
1998-11-05
48.00
0251633
BREATHING AIR SYSTEMS DIVISION_
1998-11-05
342.00
0251634
BROWN, PAUL F
1998-11-05
30.00
0251635
BARTON, JEFFREY K -CLERK
1998 -11 -OS
1,472.50
0251636
BERGGREN EQUIPMENT CO, INC
1998-11-05
4,098.97
0251637
BAKER & TAYLOR INC
1998-11-05
162.00
0251638
BULLARD, EDWARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251639
BOOKS IN MOTION
1998-11-05
10.00
0251640
BLATUS, JAMES
1998-11-05
352.01
0251641
BAUMGARTNER, MICHAEL
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251642
BAILES, EMORY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251643
BOYNTON PUMP & IRRIGATION
1998-11-05
5.64
0251644
BROWER, MATTHEW
1998-11-05
30.00
0251645
BAXTER, RONALD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251646
BASS, GEOFFREY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251647
BILLING SERVICES INC
1998-11-05
42.97
0251648
BESANCON, MARK
1998-11-05
30.00
0251649
BLAKESLEE MAINTENANCE
1998-11-05
150.00
0251650
BOOKS ON TAPE INC
1998-11-05
275.50
0251651
BAKER & TAYLOR ENTERTAINMENT
1998-11-05
224.99
0251652
SET -1 -SOUTH MOBILITY
1998 -11 -OS
15.00
0251653
BELLSOUTH
1998-11-05
222.61
0251654
BAUER, JANICE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251655
BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF
1998-11-05
11,122.38
0251656
BRAUGHTON, DON
1998-11-05
30.00
0251657
BRENNAN, RANDALL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251658
BRINSON, GERALD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251659
BASCOMBE, ROBERT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251660
BROWNE, J MIKE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251661
BOLLMAN, TERRY L
1998-11-05
30.00
0251662
BRISKIE, RON
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251663
BAKER, LAWRENCE C
1998-11-05
30.00
0251664
BURNS, GEORGE R
1998-11-05
30.00
0251665
BLANCHARD, KENDALL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251666
BAKER, RANDY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251667
BROWN, LAWRENCE J
1998-11-05
30.00
0251668
BARKWELL, CHAD
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251669
GIGGLES, MARK
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251670
BOUGH, GEORGE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251671
BRADDY, MARTY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251672
BATCHELDER, CLARENCE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251673
BLACKBURN, COLE
1998-11-05
14.16
0251674
BARRETT, ERIC C
1998-11-05
1,125.00
0251675
BIENES CENTER FOR TEE LITERARY
1998 -11 -OS
15.00
0251676
CAMP, DRESSER & MCKEE, INC
1998-11-05
30,000.00
0251677
CENTRAL WINDOW OF
1998-11-05
47.50
0251678
CHANDLER EQUIPMENT CO, INC
1998 -11 -OS
196.53
0251679
CITRUS MOTEL
1998-11-05
360.00
0251680
COLD AIR DISTRIBUTORS
1998-11-05
35.80
0251681
COMMUNICATIONS INT'L INC
1998 -11 -OS
263.25
0251682
CORBIN, SHIRLEY E
1998-11-05
262.50
0251683
CREASER, GEORGE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251684
CHEMSEARCH
1998-11-05
244.84
0251685
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
1998-11-05
20.00
0251686
CLEARFIELD COMPANY, INC
1998-11-05
219.65
0251687
CLINIC PHARMACY
1998-11-05
134.21
0251688
COLVIN, DANNY
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251689
CRUCE, AUGHTMAN E
1998-11-05
30.00
0251690
CREDIT, NORMAN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251691
CAIRNS, JAMES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251692
COALITION FOR THE HOMELESS OF
1998-11-05
3,795.07
0251693
CROWE, MICHAEL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251694
CALL ONE, INC -
1998-11-05
25.07
0251695
C4 IMAGING SYSTEMS INC
1998-11-05
1,647.00
0251696
CLIFFORD, MIKE
1998-11-05
200.00
0251697
CACCAVONE, JOHN JR
1998-11-05
30.00
0251698
CORPORATION OF THE PRESIDENT
1998-11-05
52.00
0251699
CYBERGUYS
1998-11-05
77.78
0251700
CARTER, CYNTHIA L
1998-11-05
9.00
0251701
CUMMINGS, BOBBY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251702
COOPER, GEORGE
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251703
CLIFFORD, DEBBIE
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251704
CENTER FOR EMOTIONAL AND
1998-11-05
310.00
0251705
COLVIN, THOMAS
1998-11-05
30.00
0251706
CHILDERS, JIM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251707
CRUCE, JIMMY E
1998-11-05
30.00
0251708
COX; ROBERT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251709
CURTIS, ROBERT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251710
COSNER, CHRIS
1998-11-05
30.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-7-
BOOK 107 PAGE 0
I
BOOK iG' 7 PnF 623
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0251711
CAMPBELL, GLEN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251712
COLBERG, PAUL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251713
COLEMAN, DONALD
'1998-11-05
30.00
0251714
CONE, PAUL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251715
COUGHLIN, JOHN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251716
COB, ROBERT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251717
CREAMER, MICHAEL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251718
CUETO, GIOVANNI
1998-11-05
30.00
0251719
COPH CONTINUING ED
1998-11-05
10.00
0251720
CZECH HERITAGE SOCIETY
1998-11-05
19.95
0251721
CENTRAL AIR CONDITIONING &
1998-11-05
147.63
0251722
DAILY COURIER SERVICE
1998-11-05
616.00
0251723
DAVES SPORTING GOODS
1998-11-05
129.28
0251724
DELTA SUPPLY CO
1996-11-05
484.68
0251725
DICKEY SCALES, INC
1998-11-05
710.00
0251726
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS
1998-11-05
148.94
0251727
DOCTOR'S CLINIC
1998-11-05
1.00
0251728
DON SMITH'S PAINT STORE, INC
1998-11-05
149.85
0251729
DATA SUPPLIES, INC
1998-11-05
1,309.99
0251730
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF
1998-11-05
250.00
0251731
DIVE RESCUE INT'L, INC
1998 -11 -OS
90.00
0251732
DEGRAFFENREID, JAMES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251733
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF
1998-11-05
675.00
0251734
D'ANGLEO, LEONARDO
1998-11-05
30.00
0251735
DILTS, GARY
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251736
DIEHL, TERRY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251737
DURLING, RICHARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251738
DUNKELSERGER ENGINEERING &
1998-11-05
8,255.00
0251739
DADE PAPER COMPANY
1998-11-05
212.66
0251740
DYKE, RODNEY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251741
DAVIS, RICHARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251742
DOWNTOWN PRODUCE INC
1996-11-05
55.20
0251743
DARCY, DENNIS
1998-11-05
30.00
0251744
DILLARD, CASSIE
1998-11-05
15.45
0251745
DRENNING, RICHARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251746
DORSETT, ESROM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251747
DIRECTORY DISTRIBUTING ASSOC
1998-11-05
89.76
0251748
DECO COMPUTER SUPPLIES
1998-11-05
235.00
0251749
DICTAPHONE
1998-11-05
37.00
0251750
DIRECTORY PUBLICATION OFFICE
1998 -11 -OS
78.94
0251751
DATACAP SYSTEMS, INC.
1998-11-05
50.00
0251752
DELORME
1998-11-05
44.95
0251753
DOWN TO EARTH IRRIGATION
1998-11-05
30.00
0251754
E -Z BREW COFFEE SERVICE, INC
1998-11-05
60.50
0251755
ERRETT, NANCY
1998-11-05
71.92
0251756
EVERHART, MARK
1998-11-05
30.00
0251757
ETTER, TONY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251758
ENDRES, BRUCE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251759
EDLUND & DRITENBAS
1998-11-05
11,895.13
0251760
ExPEDITER INC, THE
1998-11-05
180.08
0251761
ELLIS, TOM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251762
ENLOW, THEODORE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251763
EDWARDS, CHARLES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251764
E D DESIGNER HATS
1998-11-05
210.00
025176'5
ECKERD DRUG CO
1998-11-05
51.74
0251766
EASLICK, GARY E
1998-11-05
30.00
0251767
ENDRES, PAUL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251768
EBECUTIVE TOOL COMPANY, INC.
1998 -11 -OS
617.91
0251769
EZ GOLF
1998-11-05
696.00
0251770
FERE%
1998-11-05
16.00
0251771
FINNEY, DONALD G
1998-11-05
26.68
0251772
FLORIDA EAST COAST RAILWAY CO
1998-11-05
142,640.06
0251773
FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
1998-11-05
1,741.06
0251774
FLORIDA DEPT OF LABOR/EMPLOYMT
1998 -11 -OS
2,335.82
0251775
FLINN, SHEILA I
1998-11-05
570.50
0251776
FEATHERS, MICHAEL,
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251777
FALCON CABLE
1998-11-05
25.10
0251778
FLORES, JESSE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251779
FT PIERCE, CITY OF
1998-11-05
1,527.91
0251780
FRIEDEWOLD, KURT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251781
FENDLEY, LLOYD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251782
FOWLER, LESTER
1998-11-05
30.00
0251783
FLORIDA EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS
1998-11-05
150.00
0251784
FANTAUZZI, NELSON
1998-11-05
30.00
0251785
FOSTER, JIMMIE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251786
FLOOD, STEPHEN ADAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251787
FLOOD, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251788
FIDGEoN, PETER
1998-11-05
30.00
0251789
FULLER, KIP
1998-11-05
30.00
0251790
FPL
1996-11-05
317.30
0251791
FLORIDA BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL
1998-11-05
750.00
0251792
FALANA, DANA F
1998-11-05
30.00
0251793
FLOOD, DONNIE
1998-11-05
30.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
s e •
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
SCR
NUMBER
DATE
AMOK
0251794
GENEALOGICAL PUBLISHING
1998-11-03
72.25
0251795
GLIDDEN COMPANY, THE
1998-11-05
36.30
0251796
GOODKNIGHT LAWN EQUIPMENT, INC
1998-11-05
432.91
0251797
GRAYBAR ELECTRIC CO INC
1998-11-05
1,128.40
0251798
GABBERT, JOSEPH
1996-11-05
30.00
0251799
GOODYEAR AUTO SERVICE CENTER
1998-11-05
651.72
0251800
GIBSON, KEVIN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251801
GENEALOGY UNLIMITED SOCIETY
1998-11-05
35.00
0251802
GUY, SEA
1998-11-05
30.00
0251803
GEE, DAVID
1998-11-05
30.00
0251804
GILLETTE, TIMOTHY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251805
GREEN, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251806
GLENTON, JOHN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251807
GLASER, AMY SMYTH
1998 -11 -OS
49.44
0251808
GAY, DAVID R
1998-11-05
30.00
0251809
GRILL REFILL, INC
1998-11-05
68.00
0251810
GAITHER, TIMOTHY L
1998-11-05
30.00
0251811
GREEN, FREDDIE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251812
GOLLNICK, PEGGY
1998-11-05
1,263.50
0251813
GERMAN GENEALOGICAL DIGEST
1998-11-05
322.00
0251814
HARRIS SANITATION, INC
1998-11-05
606.86
0251815
HELENA CHEMICAL CO
1998-11-05
85.00
0251816
HUNTER AUTO SUPPLIES
1998-11-05
947.44
0251817
HALLOCK, RAYMOND
1998-11-05
30.00
0251818
HOLIDAY BUILDERS, INC
1998-11-05
500.00
0251819
HERITAGE BOOKS, INC
1998-11-05
41.50
0251820
HOWARD, D E JR
1998-11-05
30.00
0251821
HARPER, MAX R
1998-11-05
30.00
0251822
HELD, PATRICIA BARGO
1998-11-05
140.00
0251823
HARTSFIELD, PHILLIP JR
1998-11-05
30.00
0251824
HUNT, RON
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251825
HALLIDAY, ROBERT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251826
HAAS, BRUCE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251827
HARGREAVES, JAMES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251828
HILL MANUFACTURING
1998-11-05
2,040.26
0251829
BALL, GREGORY
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251830
HINTON, GEORGE C
1998-11-05
30.00
0251831
HARRIS COTHERMAN & ASSOCIATES
1998-11-05
29,000.00
0251832
BAILEY, REB
1998-11-05
30.00
0251833
HODGE, TED
1996-11-05
30.00
0251834
HILL, PETER
1998-11-05
30.00
0251835
HEWETT, DEAN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251836
HICKS, HARRY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251837
HASENAUER, KRIS
1998-11-05
16.50
0251838
HURLEY, LARRY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251839
HOWARD, JEFFREY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251840
HOBBS, JAMES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251841
HIGHTOWER, MARY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251842
HARDWICK, EARL
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251843
HAMILTON, EDWARD
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251844
HARRELL, JAMES
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251845
HARE, DEANNA
1998-11-05
425.00
0251846
STANLEY HATFIELD & VINCENT
1998-11-05
225,000.00
0251847
HEPTINSTALL, MICHAEL L
1998-11-05
30.00
0251848
HODGSON, JACK
1998-11-05
30.00
0251849
HARTSFIELD, PHILLIP SR
1998-11-05
30.00
0251850
INDIAN RIVER ACE HARDWARE
1998-11-05
17.04
0251851
INDIAN RIVER BATTERY, INC
1998-11-05
655.15
0251852
INDIAN RIVER BLUE PRINT, INC
1998-11-05
311.04
0251853
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY UTILITY
1998-11-05
1,876.59
0251854
INGRAM LIBRARY SERVICES
1998-11-05
140.51
0251855
INDIAN RIVER ANIMAL HOSPITAL
1998-11-05
44.00
0251856
IRVINE MECHANICAL, INC
1998 -11 -OS
583.17
0251857
IBM CORPORATION
1998-11-05
1,513.47
0251858
INDIAN RIVER ALL -FAB, INC
1998-11-05
464.70
0251859
INDIAN RIVER CLUB
1998-11-05
19,175.58
0251860
IRC EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE-
1998-11-05
102,745.93
0251861
IRON OFFICE SOLUTIONS
1998-11-05
260.19
0251862
ISAACS, DANNY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251863
INTEL GROUP, THE
1998-11-05
775.00
0251864
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY SHERIFF'S
1998-11-05
75.00
0251865
INDIAN RIVER COMMUNITY COLLEGE
1998-11-05
1,188.00
0251866
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY SCHOOL
1998-11-05
203.50
0251867
IRRIGATION CONSULTANTS UNLIMIT
1998-11-05
19.41
0251868
J C PENNEY
1998-11-05
311.94
0251869
JANIE DEAN CHEVROLET, INC
1998-11-05
1,009.25
0251870
JUDICIAL & ADMINISTRATIVE
1996 -11 -OS
264.00
0251871
JR REPORTING ASSOCIATES, INC
1998-11-05
32.50
0251872
JORDAN, KENNETH
1998-11-05
30.00
0251873
JOELSON CONCRETE PIPE COMPANY
1998-11-05
1,192.08
0251874
JAY, KENNETH
1998-11-05
30.00
0251875
JENKINS, MICHAEL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251876
JONES, GUS
1998-11-05
30.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
1-07 2
BOOK D_9 PAGE 625
CHECK NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0251877
JEFFERSON, LORENZO
199811-05
30.00
0251878
JENKINS, RALPH S
1998-11-05
30.00
0251879
JENKINS, BRUCE E
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251880
JONES, CYRIL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251881
JACOBSON, AL
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251882
JOSEPH, RENNETS
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251883
JOHNSON, LETISHA
1998-11-05
255.20
0251884
JI*ff RIPPLE STUCCO INC
1998-11-05
450.00
0251885
JOHNSON, ROY LEE JR
1998-11-05
30.00
0251886
BEATING, ROBERT M
1998 -11 -OS
48.00
0251887
KELLY TRACTOR CO
1998 -11 -OS
245.00
0251888
KOKOCHAK, WARREN G
1998-11-05
30.00
0251889
KENNEDY GROVES INC
1998 -11 -OS
37,569.70
0251890
KELLER, SCHLEICSER &
1998 -11 -OS
1,200.00
0251891
TEMP, HAROLD E
1998-11-05
30.00
0251892
RNIEF, MARK A
1998-11-05
30.00
0251893
KIRBY AUTO SUPPLY FT PIERCE
1998 -11 -OS
109.39
0251894
KLINK, RICHARD
1998-11-05
1,408.00
0251895
BLOTZER, ROBERT
1998-11-05
30.00
02SIS96
KISIO, MICHAEL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251897
KIRKLAND, CLENT
1998-11-05
30.00
0251898
KERSEY, JACK
1998-11-05
30.00
0251899
KING, TOM
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251900
LAWYERS DIARY & MANUAL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251901
LOFF, HAROLD JOE JR.
1998-11-05
30.00
0251902
LOWE'S SOME CENTERS, INC
1998-11-05
360.50
0251903
LYCZAK, RICHARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251904
LEWIS, RUTH A
1998 -11 -OS
54.00
0251905
LIGHT SOURCE BUSINESS SYSTEMS
1998-11-05
1,018.10
0251906
LFI VERO BEACH, INC
1998-11-05
3,823.04
0251907
LESCO, INC
1998-11-05
74.97
0251908
LEWIS, BRIAN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251909
LEWIS, MARK
1998-11-05
30.00
0251910
LETTS, BRIAN J
1998-11-05
30.00
0251911
LUTZ, HARRY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251912
LOWE'S SOME CENTERS, INC
1998-11-05
40.90
0251913
LARGENT, TIMOTHY S
1998-11-05
30.00
0251914
LANCE, KENNETH
1998-11-05
30.00
0251915
LICARI, LINDA
1998-11-05
30.00
0251916
LASTER, EARL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251917
LANDSCAPE CONNECTION
1998-11-05
95.00
0251918
MAXWELL PLUMBING, INC
1998-11-05
155.95
0251919
MILNER DOCUMENT PRODUCTS
1998-11-05
3,074.10
0251920
MITCHELL, RICHARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251921
MAP LINK, INC
1998-11-05
22.24
0251922
MEDICAL RECORD SERVICES, INC
1998-11-05
18.10
0251923
MILLER, JERALD D
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251924
METZ, JOHN L
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251925
MAIN STREET HARDWARE, INC
1998-11-05
117.25
0251926
MARC INDUSTRIES
1998-11-05
557.88
0251927
MAYER, ARTIE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251928
MORUZZI, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0251929
MARRERO, LUIS
1996-11-05
30.00
0251930
MEDCHECK
1998-11-05
759.64
0251931
MGB CONSTRUCTION INC
1998-11-05
500.00
0251932
MATTESON, CHRIS
1998-11-05
30.00
0251933
MILLER, LEE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251934
MILLER, JOSEPH C
1998-11-05
30.00
0251935
MCNEAL, PATRICK
1998-11-05
30.00
0251936
MYERS, GREGG
1998-11-05
30.00
0251937
MERGLER, LENORA J
1998-11-05
84.00
0251938
R A MORELLO CONTRACTING
1998-11-05
500.00
0251939
MORSE, JEFFREY R
1998-11-05
30.00
0251940
MARRONE, JOE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251941
MCCULLERS, MIRE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251942
MARLIN DEVELOPMENT
1998-11-05
500.00
0251943
MCCREARY CORPORATION
1998 -11 -OS
51.40
0251944
NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION
1998-11-05
565.00
0251945
NATIONAL PROPANE CORP
1998 -11 -OS
142.91
0251946
NAGY, BELA
1998 -11 -OS
69.30
0251947
NORTHERN SAFETY COMPANY
1998-11-05
144.02
0251948
NICHOL, ROBERT F
1998-11-05
30.00
0251949
NAPIER, WILLIAM MATT
1998-11-05
25.52
0251950
NORMAN, JAMES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251951
NICHOLSON, ADOLPHUS
1998-11-05
30.00
0251952
NUGENT, EDWARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251953
O'REEFE, BRADFORD
1998-11-05
30.00
0251954
OFFICE PRODUCTS & SERVICE
1998-11-05
934.63
0251955
OGILVIE, LIONEL H
1998-11-05
30.00
0251956
ON IT'S WAY
1998-11-05
471.25
0251957
O'NEIL, LEE & WEST
1998-11-05
8,695.89
0251958
OOLEY, DANNY
1998-11-05
30.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-10-
s
•
CHECK NAME
NUMBER
CHECK
CHECK
DATE
AMOUNT
0251959 O'NEIL, JAMES
1998-11-05
0251960 OCEANA PUBLICATIONS, INC
1998-11-05
30.00
0251961 O'DARE, RELLIE M
1998-11-05
145.83
0251962 PAN AMERICAN ENG CO
1998 -11 -OS
93.75
0251963 PERKINS DRUG, INC
1998 -11 -OS
240.00
0251964 PERKINS INDIAN RIVER PHARMACY
1998 -11 -OS
377.84
0251965 PERRY, TBEOLA
-11 -OS
359.211998
0251966 PHILLIPS, LINDA R
1998-11-05
650.56
0251967 PIPER, INC
1998-11-05
147.00
0251968 KEN pUTTICR BUICK CADILLAC
1998-11-05
6.34
0251969 PRIDE OF FLORIDA
1998-11-05
200.00
0251970 PORT PETROLEUM, INC
1998-11-05
280.00
0251971 PRESS JOURNAL
1998-11-05
561.21
0251972 POSTMASTER
1998-11-05
371.25
0251973 POST, ROGER
1998-11-05
128.00
0251974 PRICE, CHARLES
1998-11-05
30.00
0251975 PAGENET OF FLORIDA
1998-11-05
2,360.00
0251976 PARRISH, RICK
1998-11-05
189.09
0251977 PEASE, CLINTON
1998-11-05
30.00
0251978 PECK, PAUL
1998-11-05
30.00
0251979 PEOPLES TITLE, INC THE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251980 PANGBURN, TERRI
10,000.00
0251981 PRESS JOURNAL
1998-11-05
24.00
0251982 PRESCITI, VICTOR J
1998-11-05
1998-11-05
117.00
0251983 PEACE, JOHNNY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251984 PERRY, GENE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251985 POST, GUS
1998-11-05
30.00
0251986 PAYNE, GEORGE
1998-11-05
30.00
0251987 PERSONNEL PLUS INC
1998-11-05
30.00
0251988 PELICAN pETE'S
1998 -11 -OS
1,600.39
0251989 QUEEN, FLOYD D
1998 -11 -OS
1,209.48
0251990 RAWLS, WILLIAM CARLTON
1998-11-05
30.00
0251991 RENDA, ROCKY
1998-11-05
30.00
0251992 RUSSELL CONCRETE, INC
1998-11-05
30.00
0251993 WEBB, MARC
1998-11-05
4,234.27
0251994 ROHANI, SABAN
1998-11-05
30.00
0251995 RICHMOND HYDRAULICS INC
1998-11-05
136.13
0251996 ROBERTS & REYNOLDS pA
1998-11-05
594.47
0251997 REED, DONALD
12,506.89
1998-11-05
30.00
0251998 RUDD, ALAN E
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0251999 RUBBER STAMP EXPRESS & MORE
1998-11-05
9.60
0252000 REDDIE, HARRIS
1998-11-05
30.00
0252001 ROGALA, GEORGE
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252002 RAWLEY, LINZEY
1998-11-05
18.03
0252003 RYAN, KEVIN P
1998-11-05
30.00
0252004 RENTAL 1
1998-11-05
443.82
0252005 RIMES, JAMES
1998-11-05
30.00
0252006 ROSS, LUVINE
1998-11-05
30.00
0252007 RUSSELL, JOSEpHUS
1998-11-05
30.00
0252008 RSR
1998-11-05
1,194.72
0252009 RAUTH, GENE
1998-11-05
8.20
0252010 SEBASTIAN BUSINESS SUPPLY, INC
1998-11-05
164.48
0252011 SEWELL HARDWARE CO, INC
1998-11-05
402.08
0252012 SIR SPEEDY
1998-11-05
298,87
0252013 SOUTHERN BUILDING CODE
1998-11-05
95.00
0252014 SOUTHARD, TERRY
1998-11-05
30.00
0252015 SOUTHERN ELECTRIC SUPPLY
1998-11-05
86.24
0252016 SOUTHSIDE ANIMAL HOSPITAL
1998-11-05
30.00
0252017 STANDARD & POOR'S
1998-11-05
2,684.00
0252018 SERVICE REFRIGERATION CO, INC
1998-11-05
673.51
0252019 SUSDORF, JEFFREY
1998-11-05
30.00
0252020 SHADY OAK ANIMAL CLINIC
1998-11-05
36.50
0252021 SORIANO, RAFAEL
1998-11-05
30.00
0252022 SOUTHERN SEWER EQUIPMENT SALES
1998-11-05
874.99
0252023 SUN BELT MEDICAL SUPPLY, INC
1998-11-05
3,866.00
0252024 SOFTWARE CITY
1998-11-05
205.00
0252025 SELIG CHEMICAL IND
1998-11-05
48.00
0252026 STEVENS BROTHERS FUNERAL HOME
1998-11-05
800.00
0252027 STEFFEN, KURT
1998-11-05
30.00
0252028 SEELEY, HAROLD R JR
1998-11-05
30.00
0252029 STREETER, JOHN
1998-11-05
30.00
0252030 SYSCO FOOD SERVICES OF
1998-11-05
657.72
0252031 STEWART MINING INDUSTRIES INC
1998-11-05
3,312.75
0252032 SLUSSER, WALTER
1998-11-05
30.00
0252033 SCHILL, LARRY
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252034 SOUTHEASTERN EMERGENCY EQUIP
1998-11-05
55.20
0252035 STAMBAUGH, JOHN
1998-11-05
30.00
0252036 SULLIVAN, BENJAMIN III
1998-11-05
30.00
0252037 SOUTHERN LOCK AND SUPPLY CO
1998 -11 -OS
93.83
0252038 SAWYER, CRAIG
1998-11-05
30.00
0252039 SMITH, J VICTOR
1998-11-05
30.00
0252040 SOUTHERN SECURITY SYSTEMS OF
1998-11-05
851.10
0252041 SAFETY PRODUCTS INC
1998-11-05
368.50
0252042 STEPHENS, JOSEPH
1998-11-05
30.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-11-
BOOK 107 pn
Fr-
( ROOK+ FADE 62 7
CHECK NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0252043 SKOK, ROBERT S
1998-11-05
30.00
0252044 STIFFEN, EDWARD J
1998-11-05
30.00
0252045 SMITH, GERALD
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252046 SMITH, JEAN
1998-11-05
30.00
0252047 SOVINE, CARL
1998-11-05
30.00
0252048 STEVENSON, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0252049 STROLLO, ROCCO
1998-11-05
30.00
0252050 SMALLEY, CHAD
1998-11-05
30.00
0252051 SAMPSON, DENNIS
1998-11-05
30.00
0252052 SRDS
1998 -11 -OS
449.00
0252053 STANBERRY, MARLENE
1998-11-05
30.00
0252054 SIMON & SCHUSTER
1996-11-05
35.54
0252055 SPILLIS CANDELA & PARTNERS,INC 1998-11-05
22,212.50
0252056 SHIELDS, VANESSA
1998-11-05
29.61
0252057 SIMMONS SR,VINCENT R.
1998-11-05
356.00
0252058 SCHMUCKER, DARREN
1998-11-05
30.00
0252059 SUN STAR BUILDERS, INC.
1998-11-05
500.00
0252060 TREASURE WAST REFUSE CORP
1998-11-05
223.09
0252061 TEMPACO, INC
1998-11-05
7,96
0252062 TERRA
0252063 TANNER, DAVID
1998-11-05
1,108.75
0252064 TREACY, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
1998-11-05
30.00
0252065 TINDALE OLIVER & ASSOC., INC
1998-11-05
30.00
5,836.79
0252066 TRANE PARTS CENTER OF SOUTH
1998-11-05
403.50
0252067 TREASURE COAST COUNCIL OF
1998-11-05
100.00
0252068 THOMAS, JAMES JR
1998-11-05
30.00
0252069 TREASURE COAST COUNCIL OF
1998-11-05
225.00
0252070 TABAR, JEFFREY
1998-11-05
458.56
0252071 TRUGREEN CHEMLAWN
1998-11-05
705.00
0252072 TROUTMAN, BRENDA
1998-11-05
30.00
0252073 SMITH, TERRY L
1998-11-05
14.21
0252074 TOLFA, RONALD D
1998-11-05
30.00
0252075 TACKETT, WILLIAM C
1998-11-05
30.00
0252076 TREASURE COAST COURT
1998-11-05
150.00
0252077 TEAGUE, ROSEMARY
0252078 T C BILLING CORPORATION
1998-11-05
152.38
0252079 TRADESHOW WEEK
1998-11-05
9,881.28
0252080 TRAFFIC MONITORING
1998-11-05
1998-11-05
349.00
0252081 TAILORED TOURS PUBLICATION
1998-11-05
440.00
205.55
0252082 THE TAMPA TRIBUNE
1998-11-05
40.06
0252083 THOMPSON, DENNIS
1998-11-05
30.00
0252084 TYNDALL, GARY
1998-11-05
30.00
0252085 T A P SOD
1998-11-05
2,214.00
0252086 IIS FILTER DISTRIBUTION GROUP
1998-11-05
894.08
0252087 IIS IMAGING INC
1998 -11 -OS
313.70
0252088 UNIPSYCH BENEFITS OF FL,INC
1998-11-05
2,OB9.80
0252089 TRIPP, CHALMER
0252090 TRoUTMAN, ANNIE
1998-11-05
30.00
0252091 VALENTINE, ROBERT SR
1998-11-05
1998 -11
30.00
0252092 VERO BEACH, CITY OF
-OS
1998-11-05
30.00
5,326.10
0252093 VERO CHEMICAL DISTRIBUTORS,INC
1998-11-05
176.08
0252094 VERO LAWNMOWER CENTER, INC
1998-11-05
248,90
0252095 VONBUELOW, ROBERT
1998-11-05
60.00
0252096 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
1998 -11 -OS
15.91
0252097 VERO BEACH, CITY OF
1998-11-05
163.50
0252098 VERO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
1998-11-05
25.00
0252099 VERO BEARING & BOLT
1998-11-05
140.72
0252100 VOLUNTEER ACTION CENTER
1998-11-05
0252101 VILLENEAUVE, RICHARD
1998-11-05
75.00
30.00
0252102 VANTAGE EQUIPMENT CO
1998-11-05
271.80
0252103 VOTRUBA, WILLIAM E
1998-11-05
30.00
0252104 VICKERS, DAVID S
1998-11-05
30.00
0252105 VALENTINE, ROBERT JR
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252106 VOTZI, MICHAEL
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252107 VALENTINI, PATRICK
1998-11-05
30.00
0252108 WALSH, LYNN
1998-11-05
48.72
0252109 WILSON'S PETROLEUM EQUIPMENT,
132.50
0252110 WOLSTENHOLME, SHIRLEY1998-11-05
1998-11-05
15.64
0252111 W W GRAINGER, INC
1998-11-05
102.30
0252112 WIGINTON FIRE SPRINRLERS,INC
1998-11-05
0252113 WILLHOFF, PATSY
1998-11-05
1.971.35
0252114 WILLIAMS, BETTY R, RN
1998-11-05
130.00
94.00
0252115 WHEELER PUBLISHING, INC
1998 -11 -OS
139.99
0252116 WILSON, MARGARET F
1998 -11 -OS
75.38
0252117 WHEATLEY, ALAN
0252118 WORKSRIGHT SOFTWARE INC
1998-11-05
1998-11-05
30.00
0252119 WAGNER, DANIEL,
1998 -11 -OS
1,500.00
0252120 _WILSON, ELWOOD
1998-11-05
30.00
0252121 WRAP N' SHIP
1998-11-05
30.00
0252122 WINTERFELD, GARY
1998-11-05
78,20
0252123 WODTKE, RUSSELL
1998-11-05
30.00
0252124 WALKER, DONALD
1998-11-05
30.00
30.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0252125
WOOLFORK, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0252126
WILES, GARY
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252127
WOODIWISS, SETH
1998-11-05
30.00
0252128
WILLIAMS, VAN
1998-11-05
30.00
0252129
WOOD, EDGAR
1998-11-05
30.00
0252130
WEST GROUP PAYMENT CTR
1998-11-05
70.00
0252131
WELLS, MMM
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252132
WATTERS, DAVID K
1998-11-05
30.00
0252133
WICKER, JOANNE
1998-11-05
30.00
0252134
WARD, CHARLES
1998-11-05
30.00
0252135
WIGGLESWORTH, HAROLD
1998-11-05
30.00
0252136
WILLIS, EDDRICK
1998-11-05
30.00
0252137
WOLSTENHOLME, THOMAS
1998-11-05
30.00
0252138
WADSWORTH, MITCH
1998-11-05
30.00
0252139
XEROX CORPORATION
1998-11-05
1,410.00
0252140
YELLOW SPRINGS INSTRUMENT CO,
1998-11-05
2,042.19
0252141
YOUNG, JERRY
1998-11-05
30.00
0252142
YATES, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
30.00
0252143
YOUNG, FRANCES (BUD)
1998 -11 -OS
30.00
0252144
YOUNG, LEON
1998-11-05
30.00
0252145
ZANCA, LEONARD
1998-11-05
30.00
0252146
ZEPHYRHILLS NATURAL SPRING
1998-11-05
1.70
0252147
TRAMMELL, DENISE
1998-11-05
393.76
0252148
STROLLO, ROCCO
1998-11-05
221.34
0252149
BELL, MICHAEL L
1998-11-05
52.51
0252150
TASSI, GUIDO
1998-11-05
52.51
0252151
PATNODE, EDWARD
1998-11-05
54.70
0252152
EAKIN, WILLIAM & JOY
1998-11-05
55.71
0252153
FREEMAN, JOHN C
1998-11-05
55.62
0252154
FESTA, JENNIFER A
1998-11-05
53.02
0252155
COON, ROBERT L
1998 -11 -OS
51.60
0252156
MORTON, JACQUELYN P
1998-11-05
55.12
0252157
KOTTWITZ, LISA M
1998-11-05
53.36
0252158
BAIRD, WILMA
1998-11-05
105.04
0252159
SMITH, RICHARD G
1996 -11 -OS
105.04
0252160
BEARD, JAMES W
1998-11-05
54.25
0252161
DUBOSE, SIDNEY
1998-11-05
54.12
0252162
STIPP, LUNN C
1998 -11 -OS
53.24
0252163
FOULKS II, RONALD H
1998-11-05
53.03
0252164
TOZZOLO BROTHERS
1998-11-05
50.76
0252165
BRANDON CAPITAL CORP
1998 -11 -OS
74.10
0252166
BRYANT, JOHN C
1998-11-05
11.94
0252167
ALEXANDER, SARAH
1998-11-05
40.00
0252168
GRAHAM, MARGARET
1998-11-05
40.00
0252169
R ZORC & SONS BUILDERS INC
1998-11-05
86.35
0252170
HART, MARIA
1998-11-05
33.98
0252171
DUNN, WILLIAM T
1998-11-05
26.79
0252172
ELLIS, GEORGE L
1998-11-05
21.19
0252173
JONES, RUTH& MAE
1998-11-05
70.42
0252174
MARCCLEY, JOAN N
1998-11-05
51.52
0252175
HOLIDAY BUILDERS
1998-11-05
50.00
0252176
PATTON III, GEORGE
1998-11-05
50.00
0252177
ZANCA, LEN
1998-11-05
79.33
0252178
MC INTYRE, MOLLY A
1998 -11 -OS
39.27
0252179
LESNESKI, JOHN W
1998-11-05
26,22
0252180
JONES, TANIA A
1998-11-05
16.87
0252181
GOULD, KEITH
1998-11-05
57.15
0252182
FLINN, CHRISTOPHER
1998-11-05
19.47
0252183
HURST, STEWART W
1998-11-05
29.62
0252184
MADDENS, FAWN M
1998-11-05
20.82
0252185
WILLIAMS, DOROTHY M
1998-11-05
67.61
0252186
JOHN LLOYD BUILDERS INC
1998-11-05
68.86
0252187
CAMPBELL, TODD
1998-11-05
9,92
0252188
WHEELER, LISA NELSON
1998-11-05
27.96
0252189
DIVAN, DENNIS & DEBRA
1998-11-05
44.01
0252190
MAXWELL III, JAMES R
1998-11-05
82.77
0252191
MEADE, JAMES
1998-11-05
45.38
0252192
LEIFHELM, JOHN
1998-11-05
32.23
0252193
MAC GLENNON, KATHLEEN
1998-11-05
81.48
0252194
VANDYKE, DAVID M
1998-11-05
67.07
0252195
MGB CONSTRUCTION INC
1998-11-05
43.77
0252196
JOHNSON, ROBYN
1998-11-05
48.60
0252197
CATHOLIC DIOCESE
1998-11-05
44.83
0252198
PERUGINI CONSTRUCTION
1998-11-05
37.51
0252199
GROZA BUILDERS
1998-11-05
40.12
0252200
RITTER, KARI & JOHN
1998 -11 -OS
3.64
0252201
BEAZER HOMES FLORIDA INC
1998-11-05
31.56
0252202
BRIGHT, LEVONIA TORY
1998-11-05
10.08
0252203
HOLIDAY BUILDERS
1998 -11 -OS
73.18
0252204
RAYMO INC
1998-11-05
66.01
0252205
AULD, MICHAEL S
1998-11-05
26.88
0252206
LUCAS, PAUL & T.Tea
1998-11-05
33.25
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-13-f, 5-12
booK 1.07 PAGE
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CBECK
NUMBER
DATE
AMOUNT
0252207
RUMAN, CALENE
1998-11-05
18.04
0252208
LOUIS, DONALD
1998-11-05
20.70
0252209
SNOW, ANNA
1998-11-05
57.85
0252210
WARNER, JANET
1998-11-05
25.67
0252211
SEAGRAVE, MARC S
1998-11-05
333.35
0252212
SHELLS N THINGS
1998 -11 -OS
40.91
0252213
BIDER, MARK & TEPI=
1998-11-05
19.56
0252214
BIGGS, FRANK
1998-11-05
18.68
0252215
SACKETT, BRANDI
1998-11-05
33.70
0252216
THOMAS, WINSTON
1998-11-05
24.69
0252217
MAYES II, JAMES
1998-11-05
5.64
0252218
WENDT, MICHAEL J
1998-11-05
14.49
0252219
HERDEMAN, TED J
1998-11-05
42.19
0252220
VINAGRE, NORBERTO
1998-11-05
27.21
0252221
PASSAGE ISLAND HOMES
1998-11-05
74.10
0252222
BARBERENA, ROSARIO
1998-11-05
51.31
0252223
HEATH, TINA
1998-11-05
23.02
0252224
VINCENT, ROSEMARIE
1998-11-05
14.99
0252225
ELLISON, LYNNE
1998-11-05
61.71
0252226
CARPENTER, CRAIG E
1998-11-05
28.88
0252227
JONES & JONES INC
1998-11-05
100.00
0252228
WILSON JR, HOBERT A
1998-11-05
25.27
0252229
GUERRA, RAYMOND & NANCY
1998-11-05
37.34
0252230
SCHLITT, MARY LYNNE
1998-11-05
31.62
0252231
PURCELL, MICHAEL J
1998-11-05
67.16
0252232
AMERITREND HOMES
1998-11-05
6.62
0252233
WALKER, CURTIS L
1998-11-05
3.54
0252234
MISIEWICZ, MICHAEL
1998-11-05
70.29
0252235
CLEAVER, RICHARD
1998-11-05
2.31
0252236
IERNA, PAUL
1998-11-05
91.55
0252237
ESPOSITO, THERESA ANN
1998-11-05
64.25
0252238
REVS LE, JAMES D
1998-11-05
2.29
0252239
LOUDERMILK, SARA
1998-11-05
36.57
0252240
REYNA, ROBERT CARLOS
1998-11-05
9.54
0252241
RICHARD & ELIZABETH A
1998 -11 -OS
620.09
0252242
*-A'-*AND JOHNSON
1998-11-05
1,250.00
0252243
SECURITY TITLE OF INDIAN
1998-11-05
620.09
0252244
BLOCK & TAYLOR, ATTY
1998-11-05
620.09
0252245
BETTY J WARD
1998 -11 -OS
20.00
0252246
COMMERCIAL TITLE SERVICES INC
1998-11-05
203.52
0252247
COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INS CO
1998-11-05
602.07
0252248
GENE R & JOANN R OHL
1998-11-05
3.23
0252249
NEERAJI M & JAYA PUNGLIA
1998-11-05
45.00
0252250
GRACE LANDING, LTD
1996-11-05
1,970.04
0252251
PROFESSIONAL TITLE OF INDIAN
1998-11-05
108.36
0252252
THE CLOSING TABLE INC
1998-11-05
436.43
0252253
LAURA LOPEZ
1998-11-05
20.85
0252254
JANET S SONES
1998 -11 -OS
14.78
0252255
PRITCHARD SWEETING
1998 -11 -OS
14.14
0252256
PRITCARD SWEETING
1998-11-05
12.68
0252257
SCHLITT JR, ROBERT
1998-11-05
7.84
0252258
GRAHAM MD, PAUL ABRAM
1998-11-05
56.21
0252259
MOTHERS WORK INC
1998-11-05
71.88
0252260
CORNING REVERE FACTORY STORES
1998-11-05
167.10
0252261
GHO VERO BEACH INC
1998-11-05
93.73
0252262
CORNERSTONE SELECT HOMES INC
1998-11-05
25.15
0252263
MGB CONSTRUCTION INC
1998-11-05
119.08
0252264
GROZA BUILDERS
1998-11-05
9.60
0252265
CHRISTMAN, KEVIN
1998-11-05
15.26
0252266
READING, MELISSA P W
1996-11-05
39.91
0252267
SCOTT, PEGGY
1998-11-05
74.49
0252268
BRANDON CAPITAL CORP
1998-11-05
41.44
0252269
ALLOPENNA, PHILIP
1998-11-05
11.60
0252270
ROBE, BAYARD
1998-11-05
100.00
0252271
STRANG, FLORENCE
1996-11-05
17.71
0252272
KLINE, LARRY
1998-11-05
41.38
0252273
R ZORC & SONS BUILDERS INC
1998-11-05
37.41
0252274
BIRD, RICHARD N
1998 -11 -OS
61.74
0252275
OLESKOW JR, MATHEW
1998-11-05
60.32
0252276
JAMES DOOLITTLE & ASSOC
1998-11-05
68.42
0252277
KOCAS, LISA
1998-11-05
23.63
0252278
SHIVERS JR, DANIEL
1998-11-05
47.83
0252279
DARDEN, ALICE MAE
1998-11-05
25.80
0252280
RIDGEWAY, CLARENCE
1998-11-05
43.58
0252281
BEAZER HOMES FLORIDA INC
1998-11-05
101.74
0252282
BRETT, MARY S
1998-11-05
105.90
0252283
SMITH, CRYSTAL M
1998-11-05
26.34
0252284_
JONES, LITISA
1998 -11 -OS
49.28
0252285
BOURDEAU, RICK & CINDY
1998-11-05
4.51
0252286
CAVIT CONSTRUCTION INC
1998-11-05
29.96
0252287
WEINTRAUB, JERRY
1998-11-05
48.10
0252288
KYLE'S RUN
1998-11-05
17.67
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
• -14-
•
•
CHECK
NAME
CHECK
CHECK
NUMBER
693.00
DATE
AMOUNT
0252289
VNA HOSPICE
1998-11-05
84.53
0252290
SMITH, FREDERICK
1998-11-05
30.55
0252291
REEVES, WILLIAM
1998-11-05
55.54
0252292
MILLER, GAYLE R
1998-11-05
3.77
0252293
BOWEN JR, THANIEL A
1998 -11 -OS
13.62
0252294
PIAZZA, MARIANNE
1998-11-05
66.74
0252295
FOSTER MANAGEMENT
1998-11-05
88.18
0252296
AMERITREND HOMES
1998-11-05
62.85
0252297
NATIONAL HOUSING BUILDING CORP
1998-11-05
317.50
0252298
FORBES, PRECIOUS D
1998-11-05
15.88
0252299
FIELDS, EMMA JEAN
1998-11-05
63.47
0252300
BROWN, JACQUELINE
1998 -11 -OS
16.28
0252301
KOWN, STEPHANIE
1998-11-05
58.30
0252302
MARTINE, STEVEN & LINA
1998-11-05
90.14
0252303
MARK BRACKETT
1998 -11 -OS
1,505.00
876,838.92
7. C. PAYMENTS TO VENDORS OF COURT RELATED COSTS
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 6, 1998:
TO: Board of County Commissioners V
VfP
FROM: Terrence P. O'Brien, Assistant County Attorney I
DATE: November 6, 1998
SUBJECT: Payments to Vendors of Court Related Costs
The Office of the County Attorney has processed and approved payment to the following vendors
for the week of November 2, 1998. Listed below are the vendors names and the amount of each
court related costs.
JR Reporting Associates
Transcription
32.50
Peggy Gollnick
Transcription
693.00
Shirley E. Corbin
Transcription
262.50
Medical Record Services, Inc.
Record Research
9.05
Medical Record Services, Inc.
Record Research
9.05
Pat B. Held
Transcription
66.50
Linda R. Phillips
Transcription
147.00
Pat B. Held
Transcription
38.50
Pat B. Held
Transcription
35.00
Sheila I. Flinn
Transcription
570.50
Peggy Gollnick
Transcription
483.00
Lenora J. Mergler
Transcription
21.00
Lenora J. Mergler
Transcription
35.00
Lenora J. Mergler
Transcription
28.00
Peggy Gollnick
Transcription
87.50
Edward J. Abare, Ill, Esq.
Witness Reimbursement
58.76
Treasure Coast Court Report
Court Reporter
150.00
Vero Beach Polic Department
Photos
15,91
Eric Barkan, Esq.
Legal Services
1,125.00
Big Dipper Productions
Expert Witness
106.74
Barbara G.Schopp
Transcription
49.00
Linda Copeland
Transcription
115.50
Shirley E. Corbin
Transcription
80.50
Shirley E. Corbin
Transcription
140.00
Brabara G. Schopp
Transcription
24.50
Linda Copeland
Transcription
367.50
Shirley E. Corbin
Transcription
77.00
Shirley E. Corbin
Transcription
45.50
Sheila 1. Flinn
Transcription
94.50
Patricia B. Held
Transcription
35.00
Esquire Reporting
Court Reporter
68.75
Esquire Reporting
Transcription
65.50
Lenora J. Mergler
Transcription
105.00
Peggy Gollnick
Transcription
371.00
Shirley E. Corbin
Transcription
63.00
Federal Express
Overnight mail
14.75
Federal Express
Overnight mail
26.25
Robert J. Brugnoli, Ph.D.
Clinical Evaluation
500.00
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
•
-15- WK U7 FACE '3'
Medical Record Services
Medical Record Services
Federal Express
Federal Express
James T. Long, Esq.
James T. Long, Esq.
James T. Long, Esq.
Total
Record Research
Record Research
Overnight Mail
Overnight Mail
Public Defender Conflict - Felony
Public Defender Conflict - Misd.
Public Defender Conflict - Juvenile
NO ACTION REQUIRED OR TAKEN.
BOOK 107 Ff+..GE GH
39.01
9.28
15.75
16.00
10,200.00
2,400.00
900.00
19,797.80
7.D. HARMONY OAKS. INC AND RIVERPOINT. INC - REQUEST FOR BOARD
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF BARGAIN SALEIPURCHASE OF THE HARMONY
OAKS LAA C SITE FOR PURPOSES OF INCOME TAX CREDIT
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 9, 1998:
TO: James E. Chandler
County Administrator
DEP TMENT HEAD CONCURRENCE:
17111
R eaimg, AICD
Community Development
FROM: Roland M. DeBlois
Chief, Environmental Planning
DATE: November 9, 1998
SUBJECT: Harmony Oaks, Inc. Request for Board Acknowledgment of Bargain sale/
Purchase of the Harmony Oaks LAAC Site, for Purposes of Income Tax Credit
It is requested that the information herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of
County Commissioners at its regular meeting of November 17, 1998.
On April 21, 1998, the Board of County Commissioners approved purchase of the Harmony Oaks
property under the County environmental lands program. The +90 acre property is located at the south
county line, east of U.S. #1 and south of Vero Shores Subdivision (see attached map). On May 28, 1998,
county staff closed the purchase, and is now finalizing after -the -fact 50016 cost -share reimbursement from
the Florida Communities Trust (FCT).
The purchase price of the Harmony Oaks property was $299,500, 83% of the $360,000 approved
appraised value. David Blair, president of Harmony Oaks, Inc. and Riverpoint Inc., the sellers of the
property, considered the transaction a bargain sale. Now, W. Blair is requesting that the Board
acknowledge the bargain sale/purchase on federal income tax forms, whereas the seller(s) can apply for a
tax credit (see attached letter and forms). As such, this matter is herein presented for the Board's
consideration to acknowledge the bargain purchase.
The "Harmony Oaks" purchase consisted of two contiguous parcels, one owned by Harmony Oaks, Inc.,
and the other owned by Riverpoint, Inc. Both companies were represented by David Blair, who is
president of both companies. Accordingly, attached are two income tax forms, one for each company.
When the Harmony Oaks purchase was reviewed by the County Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
(LAAC), the Committee recommended that the Board approve the purchase prior to obtaining cost -share
fiords because the seller had agreed to sell the property at a discount (83% of approved appraised value).
According to David Blair, the sellers were willing to sell the property at a discount because the County
agreed to close the purchase in a relatively short time -frame and seek after -the -fact reimbursement vs.
the normal, longer time -flame of an FCT cost -share joint closing.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
•
•
Cooperation with sellers to allow for federal income tax credit is a negotiation tool used by county staff
to promote bargain sales, consistent with the County Land Acquisition Guide. It is staff s position that it
is in the County's interest to cooperate with sellers on income tax credit, since it promotes bargain sales
and benefits the County's overall acquisition program
of county bond funds. in terms of negotiations and prudent expenditure
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners acknowledge the discount sale and purchase
of the Harmony Oaks LAAC site, and authorize the Board Chairman to sign the attached sellers'
federal income tax credit forms.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
HA 4wj 0�4x.S
ru -17- 619
BOOK Ili 7 PAGE bu
Boa 107 FnE G33 7
Commissioner Ginn noted that tax credits are not specifically mentioned in the
County's Land Acquisition Guide. She felt that the Lost Tree Islands could have been
purchased under a friendly condemnation and was troubled by the seller requesting these
credits after -the -fact.
Commissioner Adams believed these credits work the same way as a charitable
contribution on your personal income taxes.
Commissioner Ginn requested that staff present a proposed addition to the Guide
regarding these credits.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED
by Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously
acknowledged the discount sale and purchase of the
Harmony Oaks LAAC site and authorized the
Chairman to sign the sellers' federal income tax
credit forms, as recommended by staff.
COPIES OF FORMS ARE ON FILE IN THE
OFFICE OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
7.E. BID #9019 -REMOVAL OF DIESEL FUEL STORAGE TANKS- UTILITIES -
FRED RICE & ASSOCIA TES, ING
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 9, 1998:
DATE:
November 9, 1999
TO:
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
THRU:
James E. (bsOdler, C=* Administrator
H T. "Sooay" Dean, General ServioeZV DnB��'"
FROM:
Fran Boynton -Powell, Pmcbasing
SUBJECT:
Bid Award IRC Bid X9019 Removal of Diesel Fuel Storage Tanks
_
Utilities Department
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Bid Opening Date:
September 23,1998 at 2:00 P.M.
Advertising Dates:
September 4, & 9,1998
Specifications Mailed to:
Seventeen (17) Vendors
Rept:
Six (6) Vendors
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
BID TABULATION
SE, onus W WTp
SOUTH COUNTY wwrp
TOTAL
Cape Canaveral Marine Services,
$2,730.00
$2,175.00
•S4,95,00
Caw Canaveral, FL
Fred Rice dt Associates Inc
54,200.00
$4,200.00
$8400.00
Ft Pierce, FL
'
Florida Spill Response
$4,500.00
$4,500.00
$9,000.00
Cocca, FL
McKenzie Service Co
$4,578.00
- $4,578.00
$9,156.00
Jacksonville FL
Glasgow Equipment Services
$7,557.00
$8,557.00
$16,114.00
West Palm Beech, FL
Evans Enviromental
Dista --died, did not
Melbourne, FL
use County forms
*Note: This bid was rejected because the bid form was moomplete and non-respounvm Staff was unable to
contact them because of incorrect phone mrmbas listed ou the bid farm and no phone numbers listed for
references.
TOTAL AMOUNT OF BID $8,400.00
SOURCE OF FUNDS 1%fi iW`sM Qr/Otho Canhaot W Savioes (471-218-536-033.49)
ESTIMATED BUDGET $10,000.00
RECONDGZM710N
Staff recommends that the bid be awarded to the send low bidder, Fred Rice and Associates Incas the
lowest most responsive and responsible bidder meeting specifications as set forth in the Invitation to Bid (See
Department Memo.)
In addition, staff requests auth nzatioa for the C hamaeu to awcam the original agreenw of when the enclosed
sample agreement has been reviewed and approved as to farm by the County Attorney.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously awarded Bid #9019 to Fred Rice and
Associates, Inc. and authorized the Chairman to
execute the agreement when reviewed and approved
by the County Attorney as to form, as recommended
by staff.
15
AGREEMENT SON FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF • THE BOARD.
7. F. GEORGE AND SARITA JOHNSTON -13T f SWSTREET RIGHT-OF-WAY
ACQUISITION
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 6, 1998:
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-19-F.�uEe
°�4
BOOK D'
PAGt �•��
TO: James E. Chandler
County Administrator
THROUGH: James W. Davis, P.E.
Public Works Director CONSENT AGENDA
FROM: Donald G. Finney, SRA, ounty -of-Way Agent
SUBJECT: 13's Street SW Right -of -Way Acquisition
DATE: November 6, 1998
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
Fifty feet (50) of additional right-of-way is needed on the north side of 13' Street SW. The Sellers
have executed a Contract for the Purchase of a 29 wide right-of-way at $9,150.00. The Sellers have
executed both deeds, one for the right-of-way purchase and the second deed for the 30' wide
dedicated right-of-way. Delivery of both deeds are being held in trust pending Board approval and
closing.
The Public Works staff considers the Contract For Sale and Purchase reasonable and equitable.
RECOMMENDATIONS AND FUNDING
Staff requests the Board of County Commissioners approve the $9,150.00 purchase and authorize
the Chairman to execute the contract. Funding to be from the One Cent Sales Tax Account No. 315-
214-541-066.12.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved the Contract with George D.
Johnston, Jr. and Sarita B. Johnston in the amount of
$9,150 and authorized the Chairman to execute
same, as recommended by staff.
CONTRACT IS ON FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
7. G. MGB CONSTRUCTION. INC -FLOODPLAIN CUT AND FILL BALANCE
WAIVER -LOTS BLOCK 16 VERO LAKE ESTATES UNIT 3
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 6, 1998:
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
TO: James Chandler
County Administrator
THROUGH: James W. Davis, P.E.
Public Works D recto CONSENT AGENDA
FROM: David B. Cox, P.E., Civilngineer Qc-
SUBJECT: Request for Floodplain Cut and Fill Balance Waiver for Lot 5, Block 16, Vero
Lake Estates, Unit 3
REFERENCE: Project No. 98100042
DATE: November 6, 1998
DESCRIPTION AND CONDITIONS
MGB Construction, Inc. has submitted a building permit application for a single family residence on
the subject property. The site is looted in an AE special flood hazard zone, base flood elevation 22.3
1 N.G.V.D. In the attached letter from the applicant's engineer dated November 4, 1998, a waiver
of the cut and fill balance requirement is requested. The lot area is 1.08 acres. The volume of the
100 year floodplain displaced by the proposed grading plan is estimated to be 1,150 cubic yards.
ALTERNATIVES AND ANALYSIS
The waiver request has been reviewed by staff and appears to meet the criteria of Section
930.07(2)(d)4. of the Stormwater Management and Flood Protection Ordinance for lots located in
the Vero Lake Estates Municipal Services Taxing Unit.
Alternative No. 1
Grant the cut and fill balance waiver based on the criteria of Section 930.07(2)(d)4.
Alternative No. 2
Deny the cart and fill waiver. Require an on site retention area be provided to compensate for the
proposed floodplain displacement.
RECMATIONS
Staff recommends approval of Alternative No. 1.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously granted the floodplain cut and fill
balance waiver for Lot 5, Block 16, Vero Lake
Estates, Unit 3, based on the criteria of Section
930.07(2)(d)4, as recommended by staff.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-21- BOOK 107
PAGE
Fr- -7
BOOK 10.1 PAGE 637
7.H. 66THAVENUE PAVING AND DRAINAGE PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING
SERVICESAGREEMENT - CARTER ASSOCIATEs. ING
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 6, 1998:
TO: James E. Chandler,
County Administrator
FROM: James W. Davis, P.E.,
Public Works Director
SUBJECT: Professional Services Agreement for
66°h Avenue Paving & Drainage Agreement
DATE: November 6, 1998
At the March 10, 1998, of County Commissioners regular meeting, the
staff requested and Board approved authorization to advertize for
Engineering services to design a two lane road along 66th Avenue
between SR60 and 12th Street. Staff selected Carter Associates
during the selection process and has negotiated a contract for
professional engineering, surveying, drainage design, environmental
permitting, and related services in connection with the project.
The scope includes a preliminary study for bridging the Indian
River Farms Water Control District Main Relief Canal. After the
preliminary design is approved, staff will negotiate an amendment
to the contract for final bridge design.
Staff recommends the Chairman execute the attached Engineering
Services Agreement. Funding to be from 109-214-541-
067.74 (Secondary Road Construction Fund - Gas Tax Revenue)in the
amount of $66,000; plus reimbursables (copies, postage, etc.) at
this time.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved the Professional Engineering
Services Agreement with Carter Associates, Inc. and
authorized the Chairman to execute same, as
recommended by staff.
CONTRACT IS ON FILE IN THE OFFICE
OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
•
Z L ROUND ISLAND SOUTH LAA C SITE - DEGUZMAN PARCEL -
CORRECTION TO RECONCILIATION OF COSTS STATEMENT REGARDING
PURCHASE
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 10, 1998:
TO: James E. Chandler
County Administrator
DE CO
DATE: November 10, 1998
M. ting, AICP '
Community Development Director /
FROM: Roland M. DeBlo'
Chief, planning
SUBJECT: Approval of Corrected "Statement of Grant Award (Cost -share) Calculations" Regarding
County/State purchase of the DeGuzman parcel of the "Round Island South" LAAC Site
It is requested that the information herein presented be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of November 17, 1998.
The Board of County Commissioners, at a public hearing on September 8, 1998, approved county purchase of six of
nine parcels in the Round Island South LAAC project, with a 50% cost -share grant from the Florida Commtmnes Trust
(FCT). Subsequently, on October 20, 1998, the Board approved closing documents associated with the purchase,
including "Statements of Grant Award (Cost -Share) Calculations" (see attached minutes).
One of the six parcels is being acquired from the DeG»z"Ana County staff in coordinating with FCT's attorney and
the DeGuzman's attorney for closing of that parcel, learned that the Statement of Grant Award Calculation for the
DeGuzman parcel inadvertently did not include a $200 fee relating to title insurance. For that reason, attached is an
Amended purchaser's Reconciliation of Total project Costs" statement relating to the DeGuzman parcel for the Board's
approval consideration.
The DeGuzman reconciliation statement provides a break -down of acquisition costs, and details concerning the cost -
share amount that the County will receive from the FCT. The amended statement accounts for the $200 fee that was
inadvertently left out of the statement approved by the Board on October 20". As provided for on the revised statement,
5001a of the fee will be paid by the FCT, thus the con=tlon reflects $100 in additional cost to the County than what has
already been approved.
Staff recommends that the Board of Comity Commissioners approve the attached "Amended purchaser's Reconciliation
Of Total Project Costs" statement relating to the DeGuzman parcel of the Round Island South site, and authorize the
Board Chairman to execute said document
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved the Amended Purchaser's
Reconciliation of Total Project Costs statement
relating to the DeGuzman parcel of the Round Island
South site and authorized the Chairman to execute
same, as recommended by staff.
COPY OF AMENDED RECONCILIATION IS
ON FILE IN THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-23-
•
BOCK 107 PAGE 038
Fr- -I
BOOK 107
PAGE 639
7.J. RESOLUTION 98-128 CANCELLING TAXES - BARNETTE AND HARIOT
GREENE -AND RESOL UTION 98-129 CANCELLING TAXES - GRIFFIN
AND C"ILLE GREENE - (RECENTLY&QUIRED PROPERTY)
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 9, 1998:
TO: Board of County Commissioners
'/
FROM: Lea R. Keller, CLA
Legal Assistant - County Attorney's Office
DATE: November 9,1998
RE: Recently Acquired Property - Tax Cancellation
The County recently acquired some property and, pursuant to Section 196.28,
F.S., the Board of County Commissioners, after formally accepting it, is allowed
to cancel and discharge any taxes owed on the portion of the property acquired
for public purpose. Such cancellation must be done by resolution with a
certified cosy being forward to the Tax Collector (along with copies sent to the
Property Appraiser and Fixed Assets).
Reouested Action. Board authorize the Chairman to sign the attached
resolutions canceling taxes upon lands the County recently acquired.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously adopted Resolution 98-128 cancelling
certain delinquent taxes upon publicly owned lands,
pursuant to Section 196.28, Florida Statutes
(Barnette and Hariot Greene - 58' Avenue R/W
[Oslo to 26]).
Re: R/W - 68th Ave. (Oslo to 28)
Barnette 6 Hadot Greene
RESOLUTION NO. 98-12 8
A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
CANCELLING CERTAIN DELINQUENT TAXES UPON
PUBLICLY OWNED LANDS, PURSUANT TO SECTION 186.28,
FLORIDA STATUTES.
WHEREAS, Section 196.28, Florida Statutes, allows the Board of County Commissioners
of each County to cancel and discharge any and all liens for taxes, delinquent or current, held or
owned by the county or the state, upon lands heretofore or hereafter conveyed to or acquired by
any agency, governmental subdivision, or municipality of the state, or the United States, for road
purposes, defense purposes, recreation, reforestation, or other public use; and
WHEREAS, such cancellation must be by resolution of the Board of County
Commissioners, duly adopted and entered upon its minutes properly describing such lands and
setting forth the public use to which the same are or will be devoted; and
WHEREAS, upon receipt of a certified copy of such resolution, proper officials of the
county and of the state are authorized, empowered, and directed to make proper entries upon the
records to accomplish such cancellation and to do all things necessary to carry out the provisions
of Section 196.28, F.S.;
NOVEMAER. 17,1998
-24-
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The right of way Is hereby accepted and any and all liens for taxes, delinquent or current,
against the property described in OR Book 1239, Page 2755, which was recently acquired by
Indian River County for future fight of way are hereby canceled, pursuant to the authority of
Section 196.28, F.S.
2. The Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners is hereby directed to send a certH7ed copy
of this resolution to the Tax Collector and the Property Appraiser.
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner d m and the motion was
seconded by Commissioner Ginn . and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as
follows:
Chairman John W. Tippin Aye
Vice Chairman Kenneth R. Macht Aye
I.
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams Aye
Commissioner Ruth Stanbridge Aye
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this 1_ day of
November .1998.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
John ,
P
Chairman
-25-
urian ww ca Approved Dais
Admin / )p
legal � .
Su0get
O;:pL
Risk Mgr.
BOOK 1,07 PAGE 64
I
11
N
O�
0
z
0
J
�o
00
M
CD
k-------------- SCALE 1"=100'
� I 523.00 ----------- -- --
c 174.33 ' 65959 04' -I
PARCEL 113W
_ 174.33 '
h I Trocf Line—�_ i I `c
KING'S HIGHWAY lb I I
— — I I
Section Line — —
SE cor Sec 8
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
The West 76 feet of the East 156 feet of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of Section 8, Township 33 South,
Range 39 East, according to the lost general plot of the lands of the Indian River Farms Company recorded
in Plat Book 2, Page 25 of the Public Records of St. Lucie County, Florio, LESS the South 523 feet, ALSO
LESS the North 659.04'.
Containing 0.30 acres, lying in Indian River County, Florida.
CERTIFICATION
I, Charles A. Cromer, hereby certify that I am a registered Professional Land Surveyor .licensed to practice in the state
of Florida, that this sketch was mode under m immediate supervision, and that it
certify that this sketch meets the Minimum Technical standards as described in Chapterr 21 HHe 6 of theis accuratand yect. I Florida Admin
istrative Code, pursuant to F.S. Chapter 472.
PREPARED FOR INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
p z "64" ea ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
Charles A. Cramer, P.L.S. Reg. #4094
Indian River County Surveyor
99LZSd6CZ I uo
1840 25th St, Vero Beach, FL 32960 THIS IS NOT A SURVEY
(407) 567-8000
SKETCH TO ACCOMPANY LEGAL DESCRIPTION
C"
0
ti
m
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously adopted Resolution 98-129 cancelling
certain delinquent taxes upon publicly owned lands,
pursuant to Section 196.28, Florida Statutes (Griffin
and Camille Greene - 58' Avenue R/W [Oslo to
26]).
Re: RNV - 58th Ave. (Oslo to 25)
GdRln d Camille Greene
RESOLUTION NO.98- 129
A RESOLUTION OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
CANCELLING CERTAIN DELINQUENT TAXES UPON
PUBLICLY OWNED LANDS, PURSUANT TO SECTION 196.28,
FLORIDA STATUTES.
WHEREAS, Section 196.28, Florida Statutes, allows the Board of County Commissioners
Of each County to cancel and discharge any and all liens for taxes, delinquent or current, held or
owned by the county or the state, upon lands heretofore or hereafter conveyed to or acquired by
any agency, governmental subdivision, or municipality of the state, or the United States, for road
purposes, defense purposes, recreation, reforestation, or other public use; and
WHEREAS, such cancellation must be by resolution of the Board of County
Commissioners, duly adopted and entered upon its minutes properly describing such lands and
setting forth the public use to which the same are or will be devoted; and
WHEREAS, upon receipt of a certified copy of such resolution, proper officials of the
county and of the state are authorized, empowered, and directed to make proper entries upon the
records to accomplish such cancellation and to do all things necessary to carry out the provisions
of Section 196.28, F.S.;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF INDIAN RIVER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that
1. The right of way Is hereby accepted and any and all liens for taxes, delinquent or current,
against the property described in OR Book 1239, Page 2767, which was recently acquired by
Indian River County for future right of way are hereby canceled, pursuant to the authority of
Section 196.28, F.S.
2. The Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners is hereby directed to send a cert/fled copy
of this resolution to the Tax Collector and the Property Appraiser.
The resolution was moved for adoption by Commissioner --Adams. and the motion was
seconded by Commissioner G i n n . and, upon being put to a vote, the vote was as
follows:
Chairman John W. Tippin Aye
Vice Chairman Kenneth R. Macht Aye
Commissioner Caroline D. Ginn Aye
Commissioner Fran B. Adams Aye
Commissioner Ruth Stanbridge Aye
The Chairman thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this " day of
November .1998.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
NOVEMBER 179 1998
I e Cn Approved Dele
Legal
budgO
Mgr.
-27- BOOK 107 PAGE 64Z
•
N
00
•
z
0
r�
I
---- —_-- -- --SCALE: 1"-100'
69�' 316.21'
m 342.83' I
I N PARCEL 114W is
c ZDI 316.21' Tract Line—�
I I
01
Ito co KING'S HIGHWAY CD
I I I
Section Line ��
Sc co, Sec 8
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
The West 76 feet of the East 156 feet of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of Section 8, Township .33 South,
Range 39 East, according to the lost general plot of the lands of the Indian River Forms Company recorded
in Plot Book 2, Page 25 of the Public Records of St. Lucie County, Florida, LESS the South 697.33 feet,
ALSO LESS the North 342.83'.
Containing 0.55 acres, lying in Indian River County, Florida. a
CERTIFICATION '
I, Charles A. Cromer, hereby certify that I am a registered Professional Land Surveyor licensed to practice in the state
of Florida, that this sketch was made under my immediate supervision, and that it Is accurate and correct. I further
certify that this sketch meets the Minimum Technical standards as described in Chapter 21 HH -6 of the Florida Admin— g
istrative Code, pursuant to F.S. Chapter 472.
PREPARED FOR INDIAN RIVER COUNTY �
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT a
Charles A. Cromer, P.L.S. Reg. #4094 1840 25th St, Vero Beach, FL 32960 THIS IS NOT A SURVEY
Indian River County Surveyor (407) 567-8000
SKETCH TO ACCOMPANY LEGAL DESCRIPTION
89LZ9d6CZ I bo
rn
Q
7.K. FAIRWAYSAT GRAND HARBOR, PLANNED RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
-CONTRACT FOR REQUIRED IMPROVEMENTS- CASIYDEPOSIT AND
ESCROWAGREEMENT
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 10, 1998:
TO: The Board of County Commissioners
FROM: ►✓l,*iIliam G. Collins II - Deputy County Attorney
DATE: November 10, 1998
SUBJECT: Required Improvements - Fairways At Grand Harbor, a Planned
Residential Development
Certain required improvements at the Fairways At Grand Harbor, a Planned
Residential Development remain to be completed, and the developer, Fairways
At Grand Harbor, Ltd., a Florida limited partnership, has entered into a Contract
for Construction of Required Improvements with the County and has posted the
necessary amount equal to 115% of the cost of construction of those required
improvements.
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the attached Cash Deposit and Escrow Agreement and accompanying
Contract for Construction of Required Improvements No. PD -98-01-01-U1 and
authorize the Chairman of the Board of County Commissioners to execute same.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved the Contract for Required
Improvements and Cash Deposit and Escrow
Agreement with Fairways at Grand Harbor, Ltd. and
authorized the Chairman to execute same, as
recommended by staff.
DOCUMENTS ARE ON FILE IN THE OFFICE
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
-29-
BOOK 107 PAGE 644
BOOK W FAGE 645
mu ;1 Py
�v
9.A.1. PUBLIC HEARING — FIRST CHURCH OF GOD OF
VERO BEACH. INC. — REQUEST FOR SPECIAL
EXCEPTION APPROVAL FOR PRIMARY AND
SECONDARY SCHOOL FACILITY
(THIS ITEM CONTINUED FROM MEETING OF OCTOBER 27, 1998)
PRESS -JOURNAL
Publisfod Daily
Vero Beach, Indian Rives County, Florida
COUNTY OF MM RIVER: STATE OF FLORIDA
Before the undersigned authority, Personally, appeared Darts K Hicks who an
oath says that he m President of the Press.lournal, a dally rhehnrapaper pubtGsthed at Vero Beach
h Irhdian River Courcy. Fbriaa that the attached copy of adveniserrnent, being
a
h the Cort, was pup.
®stied in said nevspaper in the issues of
Af lant further Says that the said Press4onrrnel Is a newspaper published at Vero Beach. In
Indfart River con�Wu+ousiy published said In River County, Florida. ea a aarnd has been enteredFlorida, and do the n heretalbre as
second Gass mal matter at tthe post office h Vero Beach, In said Indian River County, Florida,
nor a period of ane year nwd preceding the first publication of the attached copy or
advrrrdsernent; and affiant further says that he has neither paid nor prorrised any person, firm
aor corporation � a rehrhd tar purpose of securing this
ublication In said newspaper.
:= rrNr•r.••1
` bed before me t�_LLL
• 1
2
• K waKS
Mr COMMIssior filrlllis ? •
i * : IMUAtt 01, 2001
Z COMM. No.CC6110113
Notary Public, State of Florida
ST�t��� My Commtssbn f. Gl, 2001
r.rn rrpr (;Amm. hla. f iCi 811
Personally Krhotvn or Produced ID 0
Type of ID Produced
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
NOTICE•OF PUBLIC HEARING r '
Notice of hem" to consider.
the granting of special exception
use approval For a 1x nary and
secondary school in conjunction
with a now place of worship and
child care fadliy on properly pros+
erdly owned by First Church of
God of Vero Beach, Inc and
located at the southwest corner of
12th Street and- 58th Avenue In
Section 8, Township 33 and Range
39. Sar, the • above -map for the
location.' c' .
A public hearing at. which par•
i ties In inderest and citizens shall
have an opporhmity'to be heard,
will the held• by. the Board of
CouMy' • Commissieners -of-Indian
River County, Florida, in the
County Commission Chambers of
tha County Admigistration Building,
located' at 1840 ?.5th Street, Vero
Beach, flarido on Tuesday, Octo-
ber 27,1498 at 9405W,
Please direct planning -related
questions to the current develop -
mo t planning section at 567-
8000, ext: 242.
Anyone who may wish to
appeal any decision which may be
made at this meeting will need to -
ensure that a verbatim record of
the proceedings : iss. made, which
inchndeni taHmohyt ontd evfdahoe
upon which the appeal is based.
ANYONE 'WHO NEEDS A SPE-
CIAL ACCOMMODATION FOR
THIS MEETING MUST CONTACT
THE COUNTY'S AMERICANS
WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA)
COORDINATOR AT 567-8000
X223 AT LEAST 48 HOURS IN
ADVANCE OF THE MEETING.
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS
BY -it -John W. Tip^
Chairman ..
�9�...; 11211c.
-30-
0 0
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 10, 1998:
TO: James E. Chandler
County Administrator
D998VN HEAD CONCURRENCE:
201— 40
Obert M. Keating, CP
Community Development r
THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP
Planning Director, Current Development
FROM: John McCoy, AICP/5 A
Senior Planner, Current Development
DATE: November 10, 1998
SUBJECT: First Church of God of Vero Beach Inc.'s request for Special Exception
Approval for a Primary and Secondary School Facility (Continuation)
It is requested that the data herein be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of November 17, 1999.
At its regular meeting of October 27, 1998, the Board of County Commissioners held a public
hearing to consider special exception use approval for a primary and secondary school for the First
Church of God. The proposal is to locate a primary and secondary school on approximately 40 acres
located southwest of 586 Avenue and 12"' Street. The applicant bas already obtained site plan and
administrative permit use approval for a place of worship and daycare at this location.
During the October 27, 1998 public hearing, a number of area residents spoke in opposition to the
proposed school, citing concerns regarding traffic and compatibility with agricultural uses. Most
of the Board's concerns expressed at the hearing related to buffering and compatibility with
agricultural uses. At the conclusion of the public hearing, the Board voted (3-1) to continue the
public hearing until November 17, 1998, so that the applicant and staff would have time to revisit
agricultural compatibility and so there would be a full five member Board to consider the request.
Subsequent to the October 27, 1998 meeting and consistent with the Board's discussion, staff met
with the applicant and re -addressed certain aspects of the proposed site plan. The following analysis
briefly addresses the traffic concerns and reexamines the agricultural compatibility/buffer issue.
■ Traffic Impact: As part of the initial application, the applicant prepared a traffic impact
analysis (TTA) for the project. This MA) was reviewed and approved by the County's
Traffic Engineering Division. The analysis indicated that an acceptable level of service
(LOS) would be maintained after development. In addition, the applicant committed to
certain required project related traffic improvements, including paving a portion of 12'" Street
and providing a left -tum lane on 12' Street at the project's easternmost 12ib Street driveway.
Staff notes that for many years 581h Avenue and 121 Street have both been planned as major
roadways, and are slated for improvement with or without this project.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-31- BOOK 107PA11
BOOK 107 PAGE �
■ Agricultural Compatibility/Buffers: Staff's reexamination of the agricultural
compatibility/buffers focused on the site's west perimeter. The east perimeter abuts 58*
Avenue ( a major roadway) which coincides with the Urban Service Area boundary, and the
site design provides a significant building/= setback from the ultimate 58* Avenue right-
of-way (over 160). Likewise, the north perimeter abuts a major roadway (126 Street) and
the site design provides an ample setback to the north perimeter (over 150' to the 126 Street
right-of-way). The south perimeter abuts a large tract of active citrus but provides the site's
most significant building/use setback (over 620' from the south perimeter). The west
perimeter abuts a smaller tract of active citrus.
Along the west perimeter, the applicant proposes a variety of outdoor recreational
improvements. After the October 27, 1999 hearing, staff asked the applicant to provide
more separation and a buffer between the west perimeter and the proposed recreational
fields. In response, the applicant modified the site plan to move the proposed Phase M
education building east of the perimeter parking lot road, resulting in a setback of over 360'
from the west perimeter. The revised plans also increase the setback for the soccer, and
baseball facilities from 30' to 50' and from 30' to 100' for the tennis facility. Staff also
recommended that the applicant provide a Type "B" buffer (the county agricultural buffer)
along the west perimeter and that the buffer be planted "up -front" with Phase I
improvements. The applicant has depicted these items on the revised site plan. The
modified plans include interim outside recreation areas north of the north parking lot, east
of perimeter parking lot road and 350' feet from the west perimeter. In addition, staff
recommends that the recreation improvements proposed in Phase III (2008) be reviewed
in the finure by the Planning and Zoning Commission for final site plan approval.
In summary, since the October 27th hearing, the applicant has revised the site plan to establish a
buffer along the west perimeter, to increase setbacks from the west perimeter, and to go through final
site plan review in the future prior to development and use of recreational areas on the site's west
side. Based on the above analysis, staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners gaunt
special exception use approval for the education facility with the following conditions:
1. Prior to site plan release, the applicant must confirm that the educational facilities will meet
the minimum spatial requirements, utilized by the Indian River County school board and the
State ofFloirda
2. The property owner shall not permit the planting of and shall allow for the removal of any
wild growing Caribbean fruit fly host plants.
3. Prior to issuance of a C.O. for Phase I, the sidewalk along 586 Avenue shall be constructed
or otherwise guaranteed in accordance with county regulations.
4. Prior to the issuance of a C.O. for Phase I, the project's 126 Street frontage shall be paved
from 586 Avenue to the nearest 12* Street driveway.
5. Prior to issuance of a C.O. for Phase I, the developer shall construct a west -bound left -tum
land for the project's easternmost 12* Street driveway.
6. That the lighting of any recreational field must be approved by the Planning and Zoning
Commission.
MI
7�1 �, T7 y .�. �1 • _�� ..1 . .,
qD ._. �• �� , .• .���
a . _ . 1 1
_:.7
'. • 1 ' ., - 91 7 l T7a .)OF-!; I CA I1
=,. 1 • 1• 11 1 • .,111 y.,
1 S . S:• lzhl
. t c YID C. •1
! . 1 .. _,1 OO
Y_ 1 _.�. ..y �y. Ip 1! .1
*NOTE: Conditions 7,8, and 9 have been added since the October 27, 1998 hearing.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-33-
mill
it
al!
toor 107
fl
I
Min
it
al!
toor 107
I
BOOK W PAGE G49
RM4
ISO
Nit
R.2 42
oamt
mao
e.a.
®� p�■y eeee7e .omt0 - i LR ..
a>aman .
a SJW t p. CU AC yy AC } r r
..�.
INri� sl! ff� nT r :Slr: :r E a:E SES uM `
�_ emmw1On oe°pm1O.. °® ern _
mn ac ar .: au c � = •••
am ac
A-1
- --- - -•
TR 10 y------------------ ----- 12TH ST -----
R.12
' Met, SUBJECT
SITE % �-Iq ---
v
as
TR 15
1.
iCA
TP 15
ease.
na
m
Lx
a®u
oem:a
meo�OWs
:
eeeoc
o�A
ee.eu
ae 1
e�
27a •:
g
q
�
e®u
•`
o00VD
.sn
I
,
°
leve•
1
aamaa
eJ:
lf�o
�a c
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-34-
•
Planning Director Stan Boling noted that this matter had been considered last month
and continued to this morning. The church and daycare have been approved by Planning &
Zoning but a special exception use approval is required for the private school.
Director Boling again briefly reviewed the project and advised that after the last
meeting, staff and the applicant met and made a few changes, mostly involving the westerly
portion of the site. The recreational uses have been moved further to the east, the setback
has been increased from 30 feet to 50 feet from the west line, and a 100 -foot setback has
been added for the tennis courts which are also being moved further east. The applicant has
increased the southern buffer from a Type "C" to a Type `B" buffer. On the west side of the
site, there is a 50 -foot setback to the soccer and baseball fields, with a Type `B" buffer. Use
of the recreational area is not allowed until the buffer has been established. Staff has set out
the additional conditions for approval as Items 7, 8 and 9 in the Memorandum.
Melanie Clark of Kimley-Horn believed the important issues were the buffers; the
suitability of the project adjacent to active citrus groves; and the traffic. They have tried to
accommodate the buffer issue and increased the west setback. Kimley-Hom believes that
residential development is moving west and that any concerns regarding aerial spraying by
the grove owners could be resolved by coordinating the spraying with the school to eliminate
any exposure.
Ms. Clark also noted a number of other schools in the county which have been or are
currently surrounded by active citrus groves. She noted that it is very difficult to find a
sufficiently large parcel of land on a major roadway in an established residential area.
John Atz, traffic engineer with Kimley-Hom, noted that a traffic study had been
prepared and the roadways to be impacted will operate at acceptable levels. He also noted
that this type of use is unique as to times of use.
The Chairman opened the public hearing and asked if anyone wished to be heard
regarding this matter.
County Attorney Charles Vitunac reminded the audience that the special exception
request only applies to the school and administered the oath to everyone wishing to testify
in this matter.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-35- BOOK 107 PAGE 650
BOOK iU 7 PAGE U)
Ken Long, 225 31' Avenue SW, noted he had been swom. He is the Senior Pastor
at the Church and they presently have an approved school up to second grade. They plan to
add a grade each year; starting with kindergarten, then first and second grades.
Skip Barkett, 5850 12' Street, noted he had been swom and reiterated his concerns
about the traffic, stating that Kings Highway was second only to SR -60 for treachery even
before Sam's, Wal-Mart, and all the other recent development. He stated that less than 2
years ago the County denied a request to change the zoning in that area from 5 units per acre
to 1 unit per acre. He again asked the Board to consider the children being bused or driven
by car twice a day to the area while large flatbed trucks are coming and going to pick up fruit
and haul it out. He noted that several groves in close proximity to schools have been forced
to do away with spraying because of the potential harm to students. He believed that the
groves will eventually disappear because of the schools and the added legal liability to the
grove owners.
Commissioner Ginn questioned whether Mr. Barkett had raised his family in that area
with an active grove in operation, and Mr. Barkett stated that they kept their water tank
covered and closed the windows when spraying was taking place.
Ron Jaffe, 642012' Street, noted he had been sworn and reiterated his concerns with
the additional traffic, stating he passes the current Church several times a day and has noted
more than 40 cars in the parking area, sometimes as many as 70. Last Sunday, 11/8/98, at
12:20 p.m., there were 211 cars at the Church. 1211 Street has a deep ditch on the south side
and is a dirt road while Kings Highway has a deeper and larger canal on the east side. At the
comer of 12' Street and Kings Highway, there have been 3 fatal accidents and 1 near -fatal,
his mother-in-law who was critically injured but survived. As a physician, he does not know
what these chemicals being sprayed by the groves can do to young minds and bodies. He felt
that increasing the buffers was akin to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. He also
noted that his request to build one of his children a house on his property of 7.5 acres was
denied by the County about 2 years ago.
Lex Kromhout, 6380 12' Street, noted he had been sworn and stated that he is not
at all opposed to the Church but is opposed to the school and the impact it will have on that
area. He believed that if the Board is going to keep'this as an agricultural area, they must
take into consideration the impact of new projects. He felt that asking grove owners in this
area to make changes by force is very unfair and asked the Board to do everything possible
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-36-
0 0
C7
to maintain its contract with the citizens of this County as the development pressures on them
now will shape this County for years to come.
Commissioner Ginn asked whether Mr. Kromhout had been raised at that address and
whether there had been grove activity at that time.
Mr. Kromhout responded that he had lived there by choice.
Paul Westcott noted that he had been sworn and continued that his daughter is a
student at the school and he attends the Church. They live in Kingswood Estates and are
surrounded on 3 sides by active citrus and have not seen or had any problems. As an
attorney he took land use planning courses in law school and noted that a school is
considered an accepted and desired use. He believed the County has demonstrated astute
leadership and that this would be an appropriate use in this area. He did not see the threat
of spraying as legitimate as everyone who has complained had been living with the spraying
for years. On behalf of his family, he asked that the Board grant the special exception.
Robert Cook, 710 Riomar Drive, was administered the oath. He stated that he is a
member of the Church and a citrus grower, as well as an applicator, and knows a lot about
spraying. He sprays all over the County and has never been required to notify anyone. He
presented some statistics regarding a droplet having a spectrum of 0 to 600 microns. 95%
of the total volume is in 5% of the droplets and 95% of the total spectrum is in 5% of the
volume. Spray drifts for miles, sometimes up to 38 miles. He felt that if spraying is
restricted, grove owners will abandon their groves and put a cow on the property to maintain
their agricultural exemptions. He also offered literature if anyone was interested.
Commissioner Ginn pointed out that mosquito control trucks spray all the time and
we are all thankful for it.
Henry Schacht, 610012' Street, urged the Board not to ignore the current residents.
He and his neighbors have outlined numerous risks and felt it would be impossible to support
this project on this site. No one in his neighborhood is against low density growth but they
are all against this plan which will impact their area far more than 200 new single-family
homes.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-37- Ei00K
•
BOOK PAGE
Tammy Bogart, 540 39°i Court SW, was administered the oath. She stated that she
did not attend this church but does have 2 children who attend Christian school and is
concerned that there are no Christian junior or senior high schools in this county that cater
to middle-income families. She believed this is desperately needed and begged the Board
to consider the hundreds of families who will be beneficially impacted for years to come by
this project.
David McKenzie, 1055 3 V Avenue, stated he had been sworn. He is a third
generation citrus grower and has 3 small children. He knows pesticides and dermal toxicity.
Private industry experts spend billions of dollars studying these products and if you look at
those most commonly used, dermal toxicity is just as high for common lawn applications.
Cameron Hayes, 380 SW 29' Court, was administered the oath and stated that he
believed that if spraying is as dangerous as has been presented here, we need to cordon off
58' Avenue. There are a lot of other people here who want to have the school for their
children.
The Chairman asked if anyone else wished to be heard regarding this matter. There
being none, the Chairman closed the public hearing.
Chairman Tippin noted that he and his brothers, along with hundreds of other Indian
River County men, sprayed by hand using DDT and parathion.
Commissioner Adams felt that the problem is really the "old" versus the "new". She
believed that we all expect things to stay as they are and resist change whatever the item, be
it a shopping center, assisted living facility, etc. The threat of suits against the grove owners
is the real threat and the fears of financial and emotional damage are real. The effect of a
600 student population on the neighborhood is still a problem.
Commissioner Ginn commented that she had driven around the area after the last
meeting and noted that the homes are set back 200 to 300 feet. She did not believe they
would be very affected by the noise. She also noted that she had been raised near a peach
orchard with the attendant spraying. She believed that this is a very good place for the
school within the area of Indian River Community College which is in the process of
expanding by 116 acres and has donated 5 acres for our west county library branch.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-38-
•
ON MOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED
by Commissioner Macht, the Board, by a 3-2 vote
(Commissioners Adams and Stanbridge opposed)
granted the special exception use approval for the
education facility with the following conditions: (1)
prior to site plan release, the applicant must confirm
that the educational facilities will meet the minimum
spatial requirements utilized by the Indian River
County School Board and the State of Florida; (2)
the property owner shall not permit the planting of
and shall allow for the removal of any wild growing
Caribbean fruit fly host plants; prior to the issuance
of a Certificate of Occupancy for Phase I, (3) the
sidewalk along 58'b Avenue shall be constructed or
otherwise guaranteed in accordance with County
regulations; (4) the project's 12' Street frontage
shall be paved from 58'h Avenue to the nearest 12`h
Street driveway; (5) the developer shall construct a
westbound left turn lane for the project's
easternmost 12" Street driveway; (6) that the lighting
of any recreational field must be approved by the
Planning and Zoning Commission; (7) between the
west site boundary and the proposed tennis courts, a
setback of at least 100 feet shall be maintained and
a 50 foot setback shall be maintained for the
proposed soccer and baseball fields; (8) prior to
issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for Phase I,
a Type "B" buffer shall be installed and maintained
along the entire west property line; and (9) prior to
construction or use of all fields and outdoor
recreational improvements within Phase III, the
applicant shall obtain final site plan approval for
such uses/facilities from the Planning and Zoning
Commission.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-39-
•
BOOK 10.7 PnE 654
BOOK 10 .7 PAGE �►�
9.A.2. PUBLIC HEARING - INDIAN RIVER LAND TRUST, INC.
- REQUEST FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION USE
APPROVAL FOR MCKEE BOTANICAL GARDEN
(Quasi -Judicial)
Mss-JOURNM
Published Daily
Vero Beach, Indian River County, Florida
COLWTY OF MM RIVER: STATE OF FLORIDA
oath Saye the he Pre of the Press,iouma a defy newspaper�pubiiahed gash
I,
hdian Rh ar County, Fbrida that the attached Copy of fit, beteg
in the ' s . Oourt, was pub-
lished h shed said newspaper h the Issues of w,„,age
Af ffl further says that the said Press.iorrnal is a newspaper published at Vero Mach in
SaW Mari River County=&Ux* publishedh said It1 R� that the acidFlorida, 00% has F�eretofore been
ft
secand aese mss matter at the post office Ian Vi a qty,
for a period rn ane year neat prece ft the Ihrt publication rn the attached copy rn
and aff�nt further says that he has neitlter paid nor promised arty person. firm
h��t foVypublic rebate. or refund for the purpose of aearhg this
Q••o 0 !PII �N before me D.1
frT/1i
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
0
-40-
Wanting of special exception
approval for a Civic and Cul -
1 Foci*/Botanical Gar* on,
presently •.owrod': by
fang River'. land Jrus1;.
I*CK” :ale• pordam F�
ded-;at.%'sotdheod-cprner of
1 ' and Indian River.86ulmord i
i�ctloa' 13, To , p X33 and
o�;ti
fi't wldch ar-
Iyd ghxwi lfft to be heard,
,Jow� heW ►-ka-•9oord
.01
CoilliviW7.4
nOkm
• �OYnty: •.
ti'Cmissta+►• Chotrrben, of
194 Q SIFed hero
ch'., rigb 'leo- 4esdoy;
�embeF'J 7, .1998 at 9:05aw .
lease', dired planning -related
iti=n to the aureM develop•
t planning sect*- at 567-
9, end. 242. : -`
Myo"* .who mar .wish to
eel .ory decision which may be
Ric 201
mum
spp(ci11093 c
°• y (SEAL) ��••�
••�' '•••�
Notary Public, State of Florida
••'•.�;e
My Commission Jan. 01, 2001
Comm. No. CC 611
Ic. S�pt,;o•••
Mersonslq Krtown Wor Produced ID O
Typot IO Produced
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
0
-40-
Wanting of special exception
approval for a Civic and Cul -
1 Foci*/Botanical Gar* on,
presently •.owrod': by
fang River'. land Jrus1;.
I*CK” :ale• pordam F�
ded-;at.%'sotdheod-cprner of
1 ' and Indian River.86ulmord i
i�ctloa' 13, To , p X33 and
o�;ti
fi't wldch ar-
Iyd ghxwi lfft to be heard,
,Jow� heW ►-ka-•9oord
.01
CoilliviW7.4
nOkm
• �OYnty: •.
ti'Cmissta+►• Chotrrben, of
194 Q SIFed hero
ch'., rigb 'leo- 4esdoy;
�embeF'J 7, .1998 at 9:05aw .
lease', dired planning -related
iti=n to the aureM develop•
t planning sect*- at 567-
9, end. 242. : -`
Myo"* .who mar .wish to
eel .ory decision which may be
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 10, 1998:
TO: James E. Chandler
County Administrator
DMSION HEAD CONCURRENCE:
Robert M. Keating, AI
Community Development Di or
A. P) .
THROUGH: Stan Boling, AICP
Planning Director, Current Development
FROM: John McCoy, AICP /do YA
Senior Planner, Current Development
DATE: November 10, 1998
SUBJECT: Indian River Land Trust Inc.'s Request for Special Exception Use Approval
for McKee Botanical Garden
It is requested that the data herein be given formal consideration by the Board of County
Commissioners at its regular meeting of November 17, 1999.
Kimley Horn and Associates Inc., on behalf of Indian River Land Trost Inc., has submitted an
application for major site plan and special exception use approval to construct and create a botanical
garden at the southeast comer of U S 1 and Indian River Boulevard. The property is split zoned with
a portion zoned OCR (Office, Commercial, Residential) and a portion zoned RM -10 (Residential
Multi -family up to 10 units/acre). Botanical gardens are classified as civic and cultural facilities,
a use which requires special exception approval in the RM -10 zoning district Therefore, such
approval is required for this project.
The applicant is proposing three phases of construction. The first phase will consist of 8 new
buildings which include an officeladlumur<aative building, a ticket booth, gi8/book shop, and
accessory buildings. Parking, landscaping and stormwater management improvements will be
included as part of the first phase. The second phase will include a cafe, classrooms, and an open air
pavilion. The third phase will include greenhouses and shade houses, conversion of the
administrative/office building into a library, and construction of a new administ rativeloffice
building.
At its regular meeting of October 22, 1998, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted
unanimously (6-0) to recommend that the Board of County Commissioners grant special exception
use approval, subject to the conditions in their report. Also, the Planning and Zoning Commission
granted major site plan approval subject to Board of County Commissioners approval of the special
exception use request (see attachment #7). Therefore, the Planning and Zoning Commission's site
plan approval will become effective upon Board of County Commissioners approval of the special
exception use request.
The Board of County Commissioners is now to approve, approve with conditions, or deny the
special exception use request. Pursuant to Section 971.05 of the LDRs, the Board of County
Commissioners is to consider the appropriateness of the requested use for the subject site and
surrounding area The county may attach any conditions and safeguards necessary to mitigate
impacts and to ensure compatibility of the use with the surrounding area.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-41- BOOK PAGE
BOOK 107 PAGE 6577
ANAL.YSIS-
1. Overall Parcel Size: 17.12 acres
2. Zoning Classifications: OCR, Office, Commercial, Residential: 9.00 acres; and
RM -10 Residential Multi -Family (up to 10 units/acre):
8.12Acres
3. Land Use Designations: C/I Commercial Industrial: 9.00 acres; and
M-2, Medium Density 2, (up to 10 unitstacre): 8.12 acres
4. Building Area: Phase I 9,329 sq. R
Phase II 4,131 sq. R
Phase g 4,200 sa,ft
Total 17,660 sq. &
5. Open Space: Required: 5.59 acres or 33% of the site (prorated: based upon
35% open space required in OCR and 30% required in
RM -10)
Provided: 15.15 acres or 88.5% at buildout
6. Off Street Parking: Phase I Required. 12 Spaces
Provided: 159 Spaces
Phase II Required: 70 Spaces
Provided: None
Phase III Required: 6 Spaces
Provided: None
Total Required: 88 Spaces (50'/0 or 44 required to be
paved)
Provided: 159 Spaces (50 paved, 109
stabilized/tmpaved)
Note: The applicant is proposing 50 paved spaces and 109 perviouststabilized spaces.
Section 954.08(4) of the parking ordinance allows 50% of required spaces for parks and
spa' uses to be unpaved. Therefore, only 50% of the required number of spaces are
required to be paved. The remaining spaces will be stabilized as approved by Public Works.
Traffic Circulation:
The site will be accessed from U S 1 and from Vista Gardens Trail. A new right in/right out
driveway is proposed on U S 1, while a full movement driveway is proposed onto Vista
Gardens Trail. Vista Gardens Trail provides access to U S 1 and Indian River Boulevard
The plan also proposes some changes to the U S 1 / Vista Gardens Trail entrance. These
changes will include a raised traffic separator, enhanced traffic control and pavement
marking and new landscaping along Vista Gardens Trail. New internal driveways will
provide access to the proposed parking spaces, including a large parking area located in the
southwest comer of the site. Most of the project's 109 unpaved spaces will be located in the
southern portion of the site. The internal circulation has been approved by the Traffic
Engineering Division.
A traffic impact statement has been submitted and approved by the Traffic Engineering
Division. Based on the approved traffic statement, no off-site improvements are required
However, the applicant is proposing to provide a a right tum/decel lane at the U S 1 new
driveway entrance.
8. Stormwater Management. The stormwater management plan has been reviewed and
approved by the Public Works Department. The applicant will need to obtain a Type "A"
permit prior to site release.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
• -42- •
9. Landscape Plan: The landscape plan is in conformance with Chapter 926. This includes
a Type "D" buffer along the site's eastern property line, as required for civic and cultural
facilities in the RM -10 district. Much of the required landscaping will be met by the
preservation of existing material. However, significant new landscape material will be added
along all project perimeters and in the area of new constriction.
10. Utilities: The project will be serviced by county water and sewer. These utility provisions
have been approved by the County Department of Utility Services and the Environmental
Health Departmen.
11. Dedication and Improvements:
■ Pursuant to the County's comprehensive sidewalk and bikeway plan, a sidewalk is
required along the project's U S 1 frontage. The sidewalk is depicted on the plans
and will either need to be built or bonded -out prior to the issuance of a Certificate of
Occupancy.
■ Presently, the Indian River Farms Water Control District (1RFWCD) and the county
Utilities Department use this site to access the south relief canal right-of-way for
maintenance and for access to utility unprovements. The applicant is proposing
improvements within an existing 15' access easement that the District and Utilities
Services use for access. The improvements should not affect the use of the access
easement. There will be reciprocal agreements between the District, Utilities
Department and McKee Gardens which make provisions for formal access in
coordination with the new development on-site. These agreements will need to be
in place (executed) prior to site plan release.
12. Concurrency: The developer has executed a concurrency aclmoledgment agreement which
satisfies the project's concurrency in relation to site plan approvaL
13. Environmental Issues:
■ Wetlands: There are several small isolated wetlands on the site that will be
enhanced as part of the project. No wetlands alteration permitting is
required.
• Uplands: Although the site is over 5 acres, the environmental planning staff has
evaluated the site and determined that much of the vegetation is non-
native and that no part of the site constitutes a native upland
community. Therefore, no native upland set aside is required.
14. Surrounding Land Use and Zoning.
North. Vista Gardens Trail / CG
South: Indian River Farms South Relief Canal, Commercial and
Multi -Family / CL, RM -10
East. Multi -Family Units / RM -10
West: U S 1, FEC RR, Mobile Home Park / RMH-6
15. Historic Preservation: The two historic structures on the site, the Hall of Giants and the
Spanish Kitchen, are being restored as part of a separate project. These buildings were
designed by Waldo Sexton. The historically significant garden landscape design by William
Lyman Philips is being restored where intam
16. Specific Land Use Criteria: The following specific land use criteria apply to the portion of
the Botanical Garden in the RM -10 zoned portion of the site:
1. No building shall be located closer than fifty (50) feet to any lot line which abuts
a residentially designated property.
Note: No building is proposed to be located within 50' of a lot line which
abuts a residentially designated property•
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-43-
•
BOOK 10.9 PAGE 658
BOOK FAUE
2. No off-street parking or loading space shall be located closer than twenty-five (25)
feet to any property line abutting a residentially designated property.
Note: All off-street parking is located within the commercially zoned (OCR)
portion of the site and is proposed to be located more than 25' from any
property line abutting a residentially designated property.
3. Any accessory restaurant or ticket sales activities to be included as part of the
cultural or civic facility shall be conducted entirely within the building.
Note: All of the above referenced activities are proposed to occur within the
commercially zoned (OCR) portion of the site. Therefore, no such activities
will be conducted outside of a building within the RM -10 zoning district
4. The facility must have thoroughfare road frontage.
Note: The facility has frontage on U S 1, which is designated as an arterial
road on the thoroughfare plan.
5. Type "D" sing shall be provided between the facility and adjacent properties
that are agriculturally or residentially designated.
Note: A Type "D" landscape buffer has been provided between the facility
and adjacent properties that are residentially designated. The buffer, located
along the site's east perimeter, must be installed prior to issuance of a
Certificate of Occupancy for Phase 1. There is an existing 8' high wall along
the east property line which was built with Vista Villas development. The
wall is located on the Vista Villas site and will remain, providing additional
buffering.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Based on the above analysis, staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners grant
special exception use approval, with the following conditions:
1. Prior to site plan release, the developer shall execute reciprocal access agreements with the Indian
River Farms Water Control District and the County Department of Utility Services to ensure access
to the south relief canal and utilities improvements.
2. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the applicant shall either build or bond -out
the required sidewalk improvement along the site's U S 1 frontage.
3. Prior to the issuance of a C.O. for Phase I, a Type "D" buffer must be constructed along the
project's east property line.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
• -44-
•
1
•:1
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-45-
Como
Y t `
� a -
%WA C.QCM COW[
7A BRIM[
i
✓ 0
BOOK 107 FAGE 660
BOOK 107 PAGE �..
Planning Director Stan Boling noted that this project is a botanical garden and
associated facilities which abut Vista Gardens to the east. The request is for an approval to
re-establish the gardens. All commercial development will be on the west side of the site
including the parking lot, a cafe, and a small office. Existing trees will be preserved with
additional trees to be planted. There are many phases to the project.
Janet Alford, 1645 9 - Street SW, stated that the first phase will take approximately
2 to 4 years.
The Chairman opened the public hearing and asked if anyone wished to be heard
regarding this matter. There being none, the Chairman closed the public hearing.
The Chairman commented that the plans were very impressive.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously granted the special exception use
approval with the following conditions: (1) prior to
site plan release, the developer shall execute
reciprocal access agreements with the Indian River
Farms Water Control District and the County
Department of Utility Services to ensure access to
the south relief canal and utilities improvements; (2)
prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy
the applicant shall either build or bond out the
required sidewalk improvement along the site's
U.S.#1 frontage; and (3) prior to the issuance of a
Certificate of Occupancy for Phase I, a Type "D"
buffer must be constructed along the project's east
property line; all as recommended by staff.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-46-
• 0
11.G. COUNTY BEACH SCRAPING
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 12, 1998:
TO:
James E. Chandler,
County Administrator
RECEIVED
TBROIICiH:
James W. Davis, P.E. ,
Public Works Director.
NOV j g 1598
CLERK TO THE BOARD,
FROM:
Jeffrey R. Tabar
Coastal Engineer
SUBJECT:
Proposed Excavation of the Beach Face (Beach Scraping)
DATE:
November 12, 1998
At the November 10, 1998 Board of County Commissioners regular
meeting, the Board authorized staff to investigate the issuance of
an emergency beach scraping permit to allow some temporary relief
following Tropical Storm Mitch. Beach scraping is a technique used
to construct temporary sand berms to protect severely eroded
beaches.
Florida Statutes Chapter 161.085(3) states that "if erosion occurs
as a result of a storm event which threatens private structures or
public infrastructures and a permit has not been issued pursuant to
Subsection (2), the agency, political subdivision, or municipality
may install or authorize installation of rigid Coastal armoring
structures for the protection of private structures... as along as
the following items are considered and incorporated into such
emergency measures:
a) Protection of the beach dune system;
b) Siting and design criteria for the protective structure;
c) Impacts on adjacent properties;
d) Preservation of public beach access;
e) Protection of native coastal vegetation and nesting
marine turtles and their hatchlings."'
Chapter 62B-33.0054(5) Rules & Procedures for Coastal Construction
& Excavation, Coastal Armoring & Related Structures, Emergency
Protection, contains more specific language which pertains to
emergency permit issuance by local governments for beach scraping
activity in accordance with the following practices:
1) A maximum of one foot depth may be excavated from the
area of the beach between the previous days wrack line
and the mean low water line. This material shall be
placed in a uniform manner landward of the wrack line and
seaward of the dune escarpment or the old dune line.
Excavated material shall not be transported laterally
along the beach. This activity may be done only once.
Any subsequent scraping or excavation shall require a
permit from the Department pursuant to this Chapter.
2) Only sandy material may be excavated.
3) No material excavated from the beach may be moved
landward of either the established first line of
buildings or the post -storm dune escarpment, whichever is
more seaward.
4) In areae -dominated by storm overwash, excavation of the
beach shall not be allowed.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-47-
BOOK 107 Fngcr. 662
J
BOOK 10 .7 PAGE
ALTERNATIVES AND ANALYSIS
Staff has conducted a survey of the shoreline to identify areas of
severe erosion. Table No. 1 lists the areas which would be
considered for emergency permit issuance for beach scraping.
Tabla No 12 Potantlal Raaoh Seraninc Areas
LOCATION
Length of
Comments
End -loader
Shoreline
$270/day
Treasure Shores Park
300 ft.
Lost 10-15 ft of Dune.
$540/day
Repairs required to dune
crossover.
Golden Sands Park
600 ft.
Lost 10-15 ft of Dune.
Repairs required to dune
crossover.
Wabasso Beach Park &
300 ft. &
Lost 10-15 ft of Dune.
Summerplace
500 ft.
Unprotected property
severely eroded.
Other areas of the County were severely eroded as well, however, the
lack of sand in the system would not warrant beach scraping activity at
this time.
The majority of the areas listed in Table No. 1 are reported as areas of
"critical erosion" in the County's Beach Preservation Plan and are
recommended for a beach restoration project during the fall of the year
2000. Where "critical erosion" is defined as:
A segment of coastline where natural processes or human activity have
caused erosion to a degree that upland development, recreational
interests, wildlife habitat, or cultural resources are threatened or lost.
In considering the costs associated with conducting beach scraping
activity, Table No. 2 list the relative costs of utilizing County
personnel and equipment to complete the work. The end -loader would be
used to complete the beach scraping and the bulldozer would be needed to
assist the end -loader when exiting the beach.
Table No. 22 Relatad Aosta
EQCIP140 w
OPERATOR in=
TOTAL COST
End -loader
$150/day $120/day
$270/day
D-7 Bulldozer
$150/day $120/day
$270/day
$540/day
Equipment cost associated with the preparation of the end -loader are
described below. The end -loader is equipped with a rake and would
require a bucket to perform the beach scraping activity.
• Purchase used bucket/shipping/labor $ 91000
Time: 2-3 weeks
• Purchase new bucket/shipping/labor $12,000
Time: 2-3 weeks
Other miscellaneous cost associated with beach scraping would include
the following:
• Purchase sand to construct access ramps $ 1,500/per access
In analyzing the condition of the shoreline, staff has prepared the
following alternatives.
Alternatives No. 1
Approve the issuance of an emergency permit for beach scraping
in those areas identified in Table No. 1 utilizing County
personnel and equipment to complete the work. Public property
would be funded from the County's Beach Preservation Fund
while unprotected private property would be required to pay
the cost -in accordance with Table No. 2.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
•
Alternative No
Approve the issuance of an emergency permit for beach scraping
in those areas identified in Table No. 1 utilizing County
personnel and equipment to complete the work only in areas of
Public property, funding would be from the County's Beach
Preservation Fund. Access would be obtained through Wabasso
Beach Park.
Unprotected private property owners, located in those areas
identified in Table No. 1 which would include five (5)
properties, would be required to apply for and obtain
individual permits from the County Public Works Department to
complete beach scraping.
Obtain permits to place sand in those areas identified in
Table No. 1. The associated costs with sand placement would
range between $ 4-6 per/cy plus related equipment costs to
distribute the sand. Sand would be purchased from a local
upland source.
A?terna_tiye No 3
Allow the dune and beach system to recover naturally.
Staff recommends Alternative N0.2, whereby an emergency permit would be
issued to allow County personnel and equipment to complete beach
scraping activity in areas of public property (ref. Table No.l) while
areas of unprotected private property (ref. Table No.l) would be
required to apply for permits through the Public Works Department.
The authorized beach scraping activity would be in accordance with the
following practices:
1) A maximum of one foot depth may be excavated from the area of
the beach between the previous days wrack line and the mean
low water line. This material shall be placed in a uniform
manner landward of the wrack line and seaward of the dune
escarpment or the old dune line. Excavated material shall not
be transported laterally along the beach. This activity may
be done only once. Any subsequent scraping or excavation
shall require a permit from the Department pursuant to this
Chapter.
2) Only sandy material may be excavated.
3) No material excavated from the beach may be moved landward of
either the established first line of buildings or the post -
storm dune escarpment, whichever is more seaward.
4) In areas dominated by storm overwash, excavation of the beach
shall not be allowed.
In addition to the recommended beach scraping, purchase 300 cubic yards
of sand per park. This sand will provide added storm protection.
Cost
Personnel/Equipment (5 days of Work)
End -Loader (used bucket) $2.000
$9,000
Access Ramp $1,500
Additional Sand Placement eA C,,,.
$17,000
Funding would be from the Beach Restoration Fund.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-49-
B®OK 10 F'1GE G'
0
BOOK 107 P3 5
Coastal Engineer Jeff Tabar stated that a county -wide survey had been performed and
a large portion of the County's beach was hit very hard by -Tropical Storm Mitch. In some
areas there is insufficient sand to benefit from beach scraping as the sediment is not
recoverable. A bucket would need to be purchased for the grader at $9,000 to $12,000 with
additional costs for fuel, etc. of approximately $270 to $300 per day. Wabasso Beach Park
could be used as an access area and funding would come from the Beach Restoration Fund
in the total amount of approximately $17,000. Staff is recommending that the Board approve
Alternate #2.
Commissioner Adams asked about increasing the amount of sand to 1,000 cubic
yards, and Mr. Tabar believed that the State would be willing to issue a permit for 1,000
cubic yards of sand.
Cheryl Gerstner was recognized by the Chairman and noted that the State is still
micro -managing each seawall request while the situation has become a crisis.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved Alternative No. 2 [i] approve
the issuance of an emergency permit for beach
scraping in those areas identified in Table No. 1 of
staffs Memorandum utilizing County personnel and
equipment to complete the work only in areas of
public property with funding from the County's
Beach Preservation Fund and access through
Wabasso Beach Park; [ii] unprotected private
property owners, located in those areas identified in
Table No. 1 which would include 5 properties, will
be required to apply for and obtain individual
permits from the County Public Works Department
to complete beach scraping; and [iii] obtain permits
to place sand in those areas identified in Table No.
1; all pursuant to recommendations by staff with an
increase in the purchase of sand per park to the
amount of 1,000 cubic yards per park, with any
surplus to be stockpiled and a direction to staff to
coordinate the private permits with the County's
beach scraping.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
11.H.1. KINGSWAY SUBDIVISION -WATER MAIN PROJECT
UW -97 -09 -DS - BID #8051 - TREASURE COAST CONTRACTING
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 5,,1998:
DATE:
NOVEMBER 5, 1998
TO:
JAMES E. CHANDLER
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM:
DONALD R. HUBBS, P.E.
DIRECTOR OF UTILITY S S
PREPARED
MICHAEL C. HOTCHKISS, P.E. m
AND STAFFED
ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEER
BY:
DEPARTMENT OF UTILITY SERVICES
SUBJECT:
KINGSWAY SUBDIVISION WATER MAIN PROJECT
INDIAN RIVER COUNTY PROJECT N0. UW -97 -09 -DS
WIP NO. 473-000-169-339.00
BID NO. 8051
On April 14, 1998, the Board of County Commissioner's awarded Bid
No. 8051 to Treasure Coast Contracting (see attached agenda item
and minutes) in the amount of $55,349.00 to provide water service
and fire protection to the above -referenced project. The project
is now complete and the Department of Environmental Protection has
issued clearance to begin connecting customers. The Department of
Utility Services is now prepared to make final payment to the
contractor.
The contractor was previously paid $45,494.10 for 82°6 of the
project. Utilities staff is now prepared to make final payment in
the amount of $9,854.90 to complete the County's $55,349.00
obligation to the contractor.
The staff of the Department of Utility Services recommends that
the Board of County Commissioners approve final payment in the
amount of $9,854.90 to Treasure Coast Contracting and authorize
the Chairman to execute same, as presented.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Macht, the Board
unanimously approved the final payment in the
amount of $9,854.90 to Treasure Coast Contracting,
as recommended by staff.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-51- BOOK .d.7 fAGEba
BOOK 107 PAGE 1`0
11.H.2. NORTH BEACH REUSE STUDY - PROJECT US -97 -04 -ED
- BROWN & CALDWELL
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of October 30, 1998:
DATE: October 30, 1998
TO: JAMES E. CHANDLER
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
FROM: DONALD R. HUBBS, P.E.
DIRECTOR OF VI
PREPARED AND WILLIAM F. MCCAIN,
STAFFED BY: CAPITAL PROJECTS EN
DEPARTMENT OF LTIIM SERVICES
SUBJECT: NORTH BEACH REUSE STUDY, INDIAN RIVER
COUNTY PROJECT NO. US -97 -04 -ED
On October 14, 1997, the Indian River County Board of County Commissioners approved a
contract with Brown and Caldwell to study alternative irrigation water services to the Barrier
Island. (Please see attached copy of agenda item and minutes) This report is now complete and
staff is requesting the Board's acceptance of the report and authorization to begin the
implementation program.
Due to the length of the report, staff has only attached a copy of the final chapter of the document
entitled, 'Development, Screening and Evaluation of Alternatives. " A full copy of the report is
on file in the Clerk's office.
Based on the information provided in Table 5-2 of the report, staff wishes to proceed as follows:
1. Begin in-house corridor study for pipeline routing between the North County
Wastewater Treatment Plant and John's Island West.
2. Negotiate a survey contract with our Continuing Survey Consultant, Kimley Horn
and Associates, Inc., who is next in the rotation for contracts.
3. Design in-house and bid the construction of a 16" effluent main from the North
County Wastewater Treatment Plant to John's Island West, along with effluent
pump modifications at the plant to deliver eluent prior to the implementation of
the Bent Pine Pumping Facility.
4. Proceed with discussions with John's Island Water Management Board regarding
the mutual benefit of a future reclaimed water supply and possible shared use of
their existing raw -water line from the mainland to the Barrier Island to transport
effluent across to the Barrier Island.
5. In the event staff assistance is needed during inter -agency negotiations, an
addendum to the existing contract with Brown and Caldwell is envisioned and
will be brought back for consideration when needed.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
40 0
6. Authorize staff to proceed with a St. John's River Water Management District
grant application to possibly defray a portion of the construction costs associated
with project implementation.
Funding for this work effort will be from Account No. 472-000-169-323.00.
The staff of the Department of Utility Services recommends that the Board of County
Commissioners approve staff's plan of action as outlined above.
Utility Services Director Don Hubbs noted that his department has been working on
this study for more than a year and a number of alternatives have been analyzed. This is a
small portion of the plan.
Commissioner Ginn expressed a desire to have some of the items in the study go
before the Utility Advisory Committee, and Commissioner Adams suggested that a workshop
be held to reintroduce the master plan to the new commissioner after the first of the year.
CONSENSUS was reached that an updated utility department workshop would be
held after the first of the new year.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Macht,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved staff's plan of action as
outlined in the Memorandum.
COPY OF STUDY IS ON FILE IN THE
OFFICE OF THE CLERK TO THE BOARD
12.A. SURETY BONDS FOR CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of November 5, 1998:
TO: Board of County Commissioners
er n-�(,,) :7i, ..
FROM: Charles P. Vitunac, County Attorney
DATE: November 6, 1998
RE: Surety Bonds for Constitutional Officers
By Chapter 98-34, Laws of Florida, effective 711198, the Florida Legislature removed a
long-standing requirement that Boards of County Commissioners and Constitutional
Officers, among others, provide surety bonds before assuming office.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-53- BOOK 10.7 PAGE U�j0
BOOK 10 7 F'A,E a69
This new law, codified in relevant part as Section 137.04, Florida Statutes, gives the
Board of County Commissioners the power to reinstate a surety bond requirement for
Itself or any of the Constitutional Officers it feels should have such a bond. The law
indicated that the bond should be set after taking into account the amount of money and
property in the control of the political office In question.
On October 23, 1998, the Board directed our office to prepare a draft ordinance
establishing bond requirements after discussing with the Constitutional Officers the
amount of cash they may have on hand at one time. Attached Is such an ordinance,
which is presented for consideration by the Board, and If the Board so desires, the
ordinance would be advertised and brought back for a public hearing.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Ginn, the Board
unanimously approved advertising the ordinance for
a public hearing.
12.B. COLONIAL HEIGHTS SUBDIVISION. LOTS 14
THROUGH 20 - REQUEST TO REMOVE DEVELOPMENT
RESTRICTION (ZORC - HERAN)
r
The Board reviewed a Memorandum of October 7, 1998 and a letter of July 27, 1998:
TO: The Board of County Commissioners
FROM: �L William G. Collins II - Deputy County Attorney
DATE: October 7, 1998
SUBJECT: Request to Remove Development Restriction on Lots 14-20,
Colonial Heights Subdivision
On January 14, 1981 the Board of County Commissioners approved a
preliminary plat of Colonial Heights Subdivision with certain conditions. Among
them was that Lots 14-20 abutting Colonial Terrace were to be built as single-
family residential - one unit per lot. The final plat for Colonial Heights was
approved by the County Commission on July 15, 1981 with a note included in
the dedication that Lots 14-20 are restricted to one single-family unit per lot.
A site plan application has been submitted which proposes triplexes on the lots.
Because the restriction of Lots 14-20 to single-family was a condition of the
development approval, the Community Development Department cannot process
the application unless that condition of approval is lifted.
All owners of property within the Colonial Heights Subdivision have recorded
revocations of the restriction in the Dedication limiting Lots 14-20 to single-family
units. As a result, the private deed restriction no longer exists. However, the
limitation to single-family use of Lots 14-20 as a development condition still
applies. (If the 1981 Commission had desired to restrict the use of Lots 14-20 to
single-family, it would have been more appropriate to initiate a rezoning of those
lots to a single-family district. Possibly to avoid time delays involved in the
rezoning process, the developer agreed to the restrictive language on the plat as
a condition of approval The property is currently zoned RM -6.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
•
11
The rationale for removing the development condition restricting Lots 1420 to
one single-family unit per lot is set out in the attached letter from Bruce Barkett
dated July 27, 1998 on behalf of the property owners of Lots 1420. (Exhibits A
through D referenced in Mr. Barkett's letter are available for review in my office.)
Residents of Colonial Terrace, the subdivision immediately west of Lots 1420
ow Lots
are opposed to any change in development conditions which would all
1420 to be developed as other than single-family homes. The other lots at
Colonial Heights are developed as multi familiy.
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the attached resolution removing the development condition which
restricts Lots 1420 of Colonial Heights Subdivision to single-family use.
-ROAM CW7}� NKAI. OTAT= LAW VOL
--ALSD AOY7Tm N TIO ONf77rr =- CN;I,MA
John Tippen, Chairman
Indian River Board of County Commissioners
1840 25th Street
Vero Beach, FL 32960
Re: Colonial Heights Subdivision, Lots 14 through 20
Dear Mr. Chairman:
I represent the Heran family, which owns several lots in Colonial Heights Subdivision,
in h,dmg lots 14 through 20. Colonial Heights is a 25 lot multi family subdivision; however, when
placed, the County Commission imposed a restriction on the plat which restricted lots 14 through
20 to single-family units.
Every property owner in Colonial Heights Subdivision has agreed to the revocation of this
restriction on the plat. I enclose copies the Revocations signed by each property owner (Exhibit A).
These Revocations have bees recorded in the public records.
The purpose of this letter is to request that the County Commission endorse the property
owners' Revocation by adopting a county resolution revoking that sentence on the plat which states:
Lots 14 through 20 are restricted to one single-funfly unit per lot.
The zoning on this subdivision at the time of platting was RM -s, which permitted multi_
family development. Today, the land use designation is L-2, and the zoning is RM -6, which still
Permits muhl-61111Hy development. The restriction to single-family development was imposed upon
the developer as a condition by the County in 1980. The restriction was probably not valid at the
time, and is not valid today. In Florida, once all legal requirements are met for plat approval, the
approval process is not discretionary with the County Commission. In other words, as long as the
zoning at the time permitted mull -family development, and the preliminat}, pial met all of the
objective requirements in the ordinance, such as for right of way, open space, drainage, lot
dimensions, etc., then the County Commission could not lawfully impose other conditions not
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-55-
Boa 107
PAGE 670
Col-
�- r���
uns, Brown, Caldwell,
i
'
Barrett, Rosswa,,
Garavaglaa & Moore
tiC^JUS X998 w
,
OHARTm1®
t! 1 �•
CA
O •��'�
ATTOIliVs AT LAW
pt tom: v
7W BWApLAM ucuL"AIO
WRJQ M iWdTT
VOW =AM
CALVIN t OCWN
MMEMA
wauyNy w. CALOWdi.
SUSAN A. CAL77I
W1-ul -QQ
NCI[ "MO
VOC MACK PLONmA SaA
EWM 6 CO • OM
PAM IH •SL•67/!
OIdNOI NL COL "- m-
YQNA61 6AIAVAOLA^
jam t MeaNs I--
NNAOI.IV W. NOSEWAV
LOAN. THCMP ON
July 27, 1998
-ROAM CW7}� NKAI. OTAT= LAW VOL
--ALSD AOY7Tm N TIO ONf77rr =- CN;I,MA
John Tippen, Chairman
Indian River Board of County Commissioners
1840 25th Street
Vero Beach, FL 32960
Re: Colonial Heights Subdivision, Lots 14 through 20
Dear Mr. Chairman:
I represent the Heran family, which owns several lots in Colonial Heights Subdivision,
in h,dmg lots 14 through 20. Colonial Heights is a 25 lot multi family subdivision; however, when
placed, the County Commission imposed a restriction on the plat which restricted lots 14 through
20 to single-family units.
Every property owner in Colonial Heights Subdivision has agreed to the revocation of this
restriction on the plat. I enclose copies the Revocations signed by each property owner (Exhibit A).
These Revocations have bees recorded in the public records.
The purpose of this letter is to request that the County Commission endorse the property
owners' Revocation by adopting a county resolution revoking that sentence on the plat which states:
Lots 14 through 20 are restricted to one single-funfly unit per lot.
The zoning on this subdivision at the time of platting was RM -s, which permitted multi_
family development. Today, the land use designation is L-2, and the zoning is RM -6, which still
Permits muhl-61111Hy development. The restriction to single-family development was imposed upon
the developer as a condition by the County in 1980. The restriction was probably not valid at the
time, and is not valid today. In Florida, once all legal requirements are met for plat approval, the
approval process is not discretionary with the County Commission. In other words, as long as the
zoning at the time permitted mull -family development, and the preliminat}, pial met all of the
objective requirements in the ordinance, such as for right of way, open space, drainage, lot
dimensions, etc., then the County Commission could not lawfully impose other conditions not
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-55-
Boa 107
PAGE 670
BOOK 10'/ FAGE 671
addressed by ordinance. Yet that is exactly what happen, as the minutes make dear. A copy of
the miantes are attached for your review as Exhibit B.
flunilY sAt the public on the approval of the plat, the residents of Colonial Terrace, a single.
n, objected to the platting of Colonial $eights for muhi�'amily use. The Colonial
Terrace residents felt that their drinking water might be adversely unp�ed by �_
development on a septic system is Colonial Heights. iivaily
While that concern was invalid at the time, because your ordinances addressed it at the time,
It is even more inappropruft thy_ I enclose as Exhibit C. a sketch which shows Colonial Heights
Subdivision and also Colonial Terrace immediately to the West Your staff will confirm that every
Colonial Terrace residence adjacent to Colonial Fleiglrts is connected to and currently rently using coin,
water. Further, the Colonial Terrace residents themselves are on a septic system. It is luthedicrous to
think that a septic system in Colonial liaghts would affect the dr� water
Colonial
Terrace homes, which am on the county water system, when the Colonial Terrace homes themselves
arc on a septic system. Thar own septic systems are much doser to their
Of Colonial Heights could ever be.drinl[ing water than
those
Sybil Investments Partnership, Ltd., is the enterprise of the Heran family, which has worked
diligently over the last 9 years to improve its other holdings in Colonial Heights. One Heran family
metriber, Dean, lives directly across the sorest from the subject lots. The He= family phuts to build
11611 9uafty, 3 bedroom 2 bath homes m a triplex attangemeat on the subject lots, Most of the lots
are in excess of 200 feet deep. The current zoning, RM61 pen this type of construction, and a
site plan has already leen submitted for approvaL The processing of the site plan is being held up
Pending this board's revocation of the plat restriction. A copy of the preliminary site plan is
attached for your review as Exhibit D.
Please note that Colonial Terrace and Colonial Heights will have sbetignificant
as long as the plat restriction is lifted. That is because the County ordinances require
an but they iv notrequire buffer between �-�Y development and g°BI'-�Y development,
to develop �8 between 2 singe -fan* subdivisions. In fact, if these lots were
already�°Y restidences, the developer could strip them of the vegetation which is
CM the PmPefty, leaving no buffer Further, there is a tight of way betwem Colonial Heights
and Colonial Terrace which was created, I believe, by the old drainage district At a nm,, this
right of way is 15 fink and may be as much as 30 feet. This provides a distance
the 2 tons+ and that any fears Colonial Terrace residents may
h� j�ed,
Finally, Colonial Heights ants between dee single_flunfly Colonial Terrace Subdivision to the
west and commercially zoned property on Old Dixie E%hway to the east As a multi
subdivision, Colonial Heights Subdivision acts as a buffer between the single-family project and the
commWciaVmdgh*`aY Property to the east. This makes planning sense, as to
Heigbts is allowed to develop as a multi- long as Colonial
20 to single -Y, when Proj It makes no sense to restrict lots 14 through
would single -fa �Y have sat unused for 17
Years, because no reasonable
person
goods � ���y lot � �-family units is a muni -family Prof The lots are "damaged
Pnfec dy suited for multi -family development
We urge the Board of County Commissioners to schedule this matter for a resolution to
revoke the resumer August restriction
th that is n�opment of this property in accordance with the RM -6 zoning
Possible, Please schedule it after September 5th.
BRUCE BARIETT
For Sybil Investment PartIIership Ltd
/mjw
Enclosures
cc: Robert M Keating, AICP
Charles Vnimac, County Attorney
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
0
-56-
4 A C L IC
r � �1
2s
JI- I W v a Baa a o a I I I
RWD)
•7H (Cons
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
19Y, t rC � to 1C AL
U*
a .c
-57-
BOOK 107 PAGE 672
=
z
'
a
o
J
O
to c
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
19Y, t rC � to 1C AL
U*
a .c
-57-
BOOK 107 PAGE 672
IrIr�F 73
IF �
BOOK PAGE '
Deputy County Attorney Will Collins recommended that the Board lift the deed
restriction by passing a resolution. He believed that any court would uphold this action.
Attorney Bruce Barkett, representing property owners Bill and Dean Heran, noted
that the property is zoned RM -6 but the lots are useless as long as they bear this deed
restriction. The Colonial Terrace neighbors have nothing to fear from this project or from
properly installed septic tanks. An agreement could be reached to install the septic systems
in the front and they will be connected to County water. There is no legitimate reason to
prevent this development.
Attorney L. B. "Buck" Vocelle, 620 Colonial Drive, attorney for Colonial Terrace
Property Owners' Association and private property owners, stated that he had been sworn.
This plat was approved in 1981 and at that time, Mr. Frank Zorc (the prior owner) offered
this condition. The condition was not contingent upon anything. He agreed to have single-
family residences with lots to be the same size as lots in Colonial Terrace. This was
approved by the Board in 1981 and "Lots 14 through 20 are restricted to one single-family
unit per lot". The Heran family purchased this property knowing of these restrictions.
Margaret Stewart, 646 Glenview Terrace, President of Colonial Terrace Property
Owners' Association, was administered the oath by County Attorney Vitunac. She was quite
strongly opposed to lifting the restriction and noted that the Colonial Terrace property
owners purchased their homes because the area was quiet. They do not want rentals in the
neighborhood.
Randy Bertolette, 715 10' Court, asked the Board to support the restriction and felt
that septic tanks on those lots would affect their wells. Colonial Heights is on a sand ridge
and is higher than Colonial Terrace.
Roberta Austin, 66610' Court, expressed her objection to multi -family housing and
related an incident that occurred about 2 years ago where some boys from the rental housing
threw grapefruit through windows and robbed a house in Colonial Terrace.
Ralph Lindsey, 1126 7`' Place, asked the Board to keep the restrictions on the
property.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-58-
9 0
Rawleigh Tremain, 675 Colonial Drive, felt this is a question of what people in
rental housing bring to local areas. He asked the Board to retain the restrictions.
Scot Stradley asked the Board not to rush to change the agreement.
Attorney Vocelle believed this is a situation of the purchaser knowing the restrictions
before he purchased the land.
Glenn Schuessler, Assistant Director of Environmental Health, noted that the area can
accommodate septic tanks with no evidence of contamination to others.
Bill Tiernan felt that the multi -family property will be well maintained and will
enhance the neighborhood.
Glenn Heran, 9 10 11' Court, commented that they run a tight ship and have excellent
maintenance and landscaping standards.
Dean Heran, 652 9' Court, said that he is a schoolteacher and a builder. Colonial
Heights is a separate neighborhood from Colonial Terrace. He is a "rental" person and other
"rental" persons in that area are lawyers, police, doctors and working-class people. This is
a family neighborhood and he felt the concerns expressed are not justified.
Jack Grossett, Vero Beach Councilman, noted he is here today as a private citizen
and a resident of Indian River Shores. He believed the Herans are outstanding solid citizens,
honest, and willing to do what it takes to build a quality development.
Attorney Collins believed the 1981 decision was wrong and probably invalid.
Commissioner Adams felt that the Board needed additional backup in order to make
an informed decision, as did Commissioner Stanbridge.
Commissioner Ginn stated that she drove around the neighborhood yesterday and
could not see where multi -family housing would be deleterious to Colonial Terrace.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Ginn, SECONDED
by Commissioner Macht, the Board unanimously
tabled the matter for 1 week.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-59- BOOK 10 7 PAGE 674
BOOK o_ 7 ma U I
13.A.1. LEGISLATIVE DELEGATION MATTERS
Chairman Tippin asked the Commissioners to propose matters to be presented to the
Legislative Delegation.
Commissioner Adams especially wanted some legislative support for channeliza Ron
through the Intracoastal Waterway Johnson Seagrass beds. Boats are now going in all
directions over the flats and tearing up the beds. She felt that State funding of the
approximately $150,000 which will be needed for mitigation should be taken to the
legislative delegation.
CONSENSUS was reached to have Commissioner Adams make a presentation to the
delegation.
ON MOTION by Commissioner Adams,
SECONDED by Commissioner Macht, the Board
unanimously approved a request to the legislative
delegation meeting asking for legislative support for
the State to fund a channelization effort through the
Johnson Seagrass beds from the Intracoastal
Waterway to Sebastian Inlet and support for
legislative issues that have been taken before the
delegation in the past.
13.A.2. SWEARING IN CITIZENS AT BOARD MEETINGS
Chairman Tippin requested that staff set up a workshop at a future date to formalize
the procedures and circumstances under which citizens should be administered an oath.
13.E. COMMISSIONER STANBRIDGE - PLANNING &
ZONING COMMISSION - DISTRICT 2 - RESIGNATION
OF WILLIAM MCNAMEE - APPOINTMENT OF DR.
DAVID COX
The Board reviewed a letter of October 23, 1998 and a Memorandum of November
16, 1998:
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
Cdober 23, 1998
�( Mrs. Carolyn Eggert, County Commissioner
Mr. Leyland N. Gibbs, 3r., Chairnian;,Planning a Zoning Commission
Because I Have been seiecled to rill the vacancy on Lhe Indian lover Shores Town
Council, it Is necessary that I retire from the Planning & Zoning Commission at this
titne.
My membership on the Commission has been enjoyable and a rewarding
experience. I wish to thank lily fellow Cornmissioners, who have been dedicated to
their Planning & Zoning responsibility and always supportive of my participation. My
thanks also to the competent staff` personnel, who consistently have presented
proi'essionai-caliber analyses and rec:ommendataons.
It has been a privilege for me to be involved. I know that the Planning & Zoning
Commission will be in very good hands.
Sincerely,
Big
William A. McNamee
Ido
)Ien4 , r ;r-L�'
November 16, 1998
MEMORANDUM
TO: John Tippin, Chairman
FROM: Ruth Stanbridge, Commissioner, District 2,
3
SUBJECT: Appointment to Planning and Zoning Commission
I would like to appoint Dr. David L. Cox to the Planning and Zoning Commission as my
representative from District 2. From the attached resume you can see that Dr. Cox has impressive
credentials and a background that will quickly enable him to understand the complex world of
planning and zoning. He also has the ability to work well with others and will benefit us all with
his good common sense and easy-going temperament. Definite qualifications needed for a
planning and zoning commissioner.
Thank you for your consideration of this appointmem.
NOVEMBER 17, 1998
-61- BOOK N� 7 FADE U f�
BOOK i0_7 PAGE 6 77/
ON MOTION
by Commissioner Macht,
SECONDED by Commissioner Adams, the Board
unanimously accepted, with regret, the resignation of
William A. McNamee, and appointed Dr. David Cox
to the Commission.
U.B. SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL DISTRICT
The Chairman announced that immediately upon adjournment, the Board would
reconvene as the Board of Commissioners of the Solid Waste Disposal District. Those
Minutes are being prepared separately.
There being no further business, on Motion duly made, seconded and carried, the
Board adjourned at 12:53 p.m.
ATTEST:
J. arton, Clerk
Minutes Approved /
NOVEMBER 17, 1998