The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About12/18/1962i M ow m i LOV` S N"g UBULAtaga 'saAeap: laagog SHAW!) x1rasoa /9/ Aa V(I'1'OIJ 'ALKnOD HaAIB xVIam do SH,3woIsszw AI00 3.L[dnoo 3o ativoa PUB atuF aaeld. 3 Pees l L Pasaq aq pue aeadde Sear Paisaaalul suosaad •epuoi3 'gaeag oaaA, ie 'BPla0i3 'Slunoo aaAFg Uelpul 30 asnoglano0 agl ul pasoq plus 30 03WO aqi uF 'MI '8I jequ3aaaa U0 Iq •y 00:6 le uoaaagl Supea3{ allgnd a. plop IIIA+ Pasoq PIBS •giFMajagi UoF}Dau -u03 OF Puel Sue 03 PUB OF angnd aqi 30 pue 'ePla01a 'SlunoO aaAq, UOTPUI 3o ;gIra Aug Sucuireiastp PUB u30a3aaagi Supinsea PUB uoaaata SUOIleDIPaP Palldjul Pug passaad -xa Ile PUB 'uPTJ0Id 'SiunoD aaAIII UeIPUl 30 spaoaaa allgnd aqi 3o 68 abed 'l; 3loog letd ul papjoaaa se 'UOIsIAIPgnS gaeag eilUOg 'TI PUB 01 307 30 3leq-auo ginoS.agi uaany -aq 2uFysFxa "At3FFeM ,01 a aulaq laarls Plus :laaais altgnd a asola PUB anulluoasFP 'uopaege 'aleaeA o; uoFinlosaa a idope 01 paeoq, Plus Supsanbaa 'ePFaoI3 'SlunoO. aaAFg U81pul 30 s<aattoissFuiwoy Siunoo 3o Paeog aqi qUm uollFlad a POW seg '43'IOVi R ari aimmuz legs UOAIg 4gajaq sl aalioX 3011CN - ' r y 1V3s) (epuolj'A4.-:) jaA!uepul ;jno) imOjyayl }o >Ijal))- - _ r (Ja3euey4 ssaupne� - - ' T ` --- �- --= ~ -------'--------------• -----------' -- o Ae -------- - ----- sl aw aj' V - jO's ns_ pe OM d 'd } P j� .yi qM� , eq! 9 P oY!� s -jadedsMau pies ay4.i.Q-aio!3eoijgndMo4•4uawas14 -janpe sly; 2upmes }o asodind ayl jo} pun}ai jo uo!sslujujoo 'alegaj 'Iunooslp Aue Lollejodjoo jo uu!} `uosjad Aug pas!ujoid jou pied jayl!au sey ay leyi sAes jayijn} ;ue!}}e pue:ivaLues!i -janpe. }o Adoo payoule ayl }o uo!leoilgnd isj!} aqi 2u!paaoajd ixau jeaA auo }o popad a jo} 'epuolj 'Alun) jaA!d ue!pul pies u! 'yoeag ojan u! aoi}}o isod ayi le jailew lieu] sse;o puooas se pajawa uaaq sey pue Al>laam 'epuolj 'A;uno) jaA!d uelpul pies u! pags!lgnd Alsnonu!4UO3 uaaq ajo}olajay sey jadedsmou pies ay leyi pue 'epuolj 'Aluno) jaA!2! ue!pui p!es u! 'gOeaq OJ9A is pagsgqnd jadedsmou a sl leujnoF-ssajd HOODS ojan pies ayl leyi sAes jayijn} luei}}y ------------------------------------------------------ ----- -- ----------------------- ----- -rt--- T � ,,.,-•�---ter -------- - ---------- --- - - - --------- ---- --- }o sanss! ayl u! ja a smau pies w paysp ndsena ` jno---------------------- ----- -- ----- ------ a44 u! ---------------------- ---------- ------------------- ---------- ------------------------------- zX"l � -r--r"� f - — -- —------- —— ---- -- - 1,...,.�J.� � 'L - }o jaliew aqj ui ----- ------------------------------- - - -------- -- -- - - - -- e 2utaq 'luaw -as!;janpe }o Ado:) payoeile eyi leyi :ep!jolj 'Aluno) janry uelpul u! yoeaS ojan le pailsggnd jadedsmou Alilaann a `lewno(-ssajd gOWO@ ojan ayl }o jalleueliy ssau!sng s! ay 4NI sAes gieo uo ogtA 'uuewnyos { -r pajeadde AIIeuosjed Aluoyine pau2lsjapun aqj ajopq WIM011 d0 31V1S :V3A1b NVIaNI d0 A1Nno:) eplaoid IA4uno:) wanly uelpul '43ea8 oaaA AI'IaaM PO4sllgnd IVNvn0f-SS3bd H:)V39 0113A •paTaPw aq of amos pus peoegins-aa aq of amos `asaA SuTwoo eqj uT anoadwT of supTd aq jPgj sppoa uo laodaa p aAP2 'aeauTfug Ajuno0 'aaxonwgos pa •pazTaoglnp aq amps aqj jPgj 'pataapo ATsnowtupun pus TTappPM aauoTssTmmOD Aq papuooas 'pTpuopopw aauoTssTwwo0 Aq appw sPM uoTION -Arm -jo-jg2Ta ppog pupTosog aoj Aggpuaaqd •says 30 saTaq aqi of 00*00ZS of do Apd of uoTjszTaoq:j .np paXsP'ag •aa:j:jpw aqj oquT aagjang �joago of pa:lonaIs -VT spm R9uaoj2V Ajuno0 aqj •A-junoo aqi o:j.waTgoad pup asuadxa up alTnb asnpo pTnoo sTgl pup A119d0ad 91EATad uo aaaM SOTITTTin aqj sp ppox osspgrm 4saM gjTM e1gnozz o3uT una pvq aq apgj pa3aodaa Aauao33V aqj •.Auvdmo0 quamdotanaa tpaau85 gITM aapao UT spuoq aqj 302 03 f,apssaoau se uoTjop Bons a-)Ipi 03.palona39uT aq Aauaojjy Ajuno0 aqj jPgj 'paTaapo ATsnomTusun pus saaTTnOaid aauOTssTMOD Aq papuooas 'TTapppM.a8u0TssTww00 Sq appm spm uoT3oY1 'uoTssnosTp amos aa3jp pup Aupdmoo :juawdoTanaQ Tpaauag g3Tm uoTasn3T9 amps aq-4. SuT:1:19$ aaam am :.tpq3 pa:Ip313`osTp aH •pauaaouoo' ST uoTsTATpgns`sTq:3 sa xvj se :Ino up maga 9AT2 pTnom sTg2 :Iggnog2 ag pug pepua:Ixe uaaq aanau pvq puoq.ag3• req: punoj aq 'uoTsTATpgnS suopap0 TpoTdoay ozeA ;o puoq aqi SuTlaago ae3je 3ag3 paaaodaa Aauaoj3V A3uno0 aqj U 1. 08 The Chairman read the foregoing notice and asked if anyone present wished to be heard. Attorney L.B. Vocelle, representing Mrs. Bradley' presented a sketch for plans for a new walkway, if the old walkway is abandoned. Mr. Bill Robinson read the following objections to the abandon - ment. Statement of W. B. Robinson - 12/18/62 Gentlemen: My remarks are directed to two, and only two points. FIRST POINT I respectfully submit that this Board has no jurisdiction to entertain this Petition, because this Petition seeks to confiscate an interest in real estate, vested by a recorded instrument, which the Petitioner transferred to me, my assigns and grantees, for a valid consideration. I will present documentary evidence supporting this claim at the conclusion of my re- marks. Such evidence consists of: (a) Copy of the relevant section, Bonita Beach Plat, as recorded; (b) A Deed of Easement, recorded in Indian River County Deed Book 106, p. 150 from Petitioner to Mrs. Robinson and myself, referring to said plat and granting us, our heirs, executors, administrators, grantees and assigns the right - and I quote - "to come and go at will from the North 165' or any portion or portions thereof to the Atlantic Ocean over Cavalla Road, the 25' strip at the East and of Cavalla Road and that cer- ten foot walkway running from said 25' strip to the Atlantic Ocean, all as shown on the Plat of Bonita Beach". Unquote. (c) Two letters of Tudge D. C. Smith, who represented me at the closing of my purchase of one-half of Bonita Beach, and who wrote on February 16, 1956 that he would deliver my check against delivery of (1) deed for one-half of Bonita Beach subdivision, and (2) grant from this Petitioner to me of an easement to us and our assigns and grantees over that certin 10'x, shown on 'the Plat. -These documents to gather clearly indicate: 1: That the Robinson and their grantees have a recorded vested, easement in the strip which In the subject matter of this Peition. This Is a property right in real estate. It is not, as this Petition would imply, a license arising by implication iron the tact that the Plat shows a walk- we alk- w X. it is not a right which can be taken away by the act of a governmental body, except of course in an eminent domain proceeding, and this is not an *misers domain proceeding, 2: That this v"ted easement was obtained for a legal consideration at the time the Petitioner, acting as a broker, sold us our fee property in . t ch D= Bea. Judge Snaith would not have cleared the title and closed the transaction without trier, as his letters prove. 044 b*Wq tate tants,, this Board, I respectfully submit, has no jurisdiction to 60e2tsin this Rdtift. To do so would ma lni it an accessory to -a breach by thO ROAUfter of bar ecaftat granting this easement, and would condemn P*Vlkt* Weperty (my seeorded easemak) for private purposes. •Isenbaa szqj Auap paeog s-rgj jegj 'pazaaso 1,Tsnourrueun pup pTeuopoeN aauozssTwwoO Aq papuooas 'TTappeM aauo-rssT'D Aq apeaz sem uozloyl '4uasaad suosaad TTe Suiavau aajjy •juamuopuege atp o:. $u-poaCgo TTe 'saallaT snoaaumu paquasaad mm:E-tetjO agy • 3uaumopuege aLp of uo-r:loargo u -r paa-eadde osTe ueTT3NOvW • aW -aoeTd 91T axed pTnom quo Mau a gegl pauopuege sem AemxTem agl JT leql aas of aaagl aaam Aagl aegJ paje-3s 'umgeaO AxjjoaoQ • says ' ao-cg Aglex • says •uoslasduloo aol thio magj ITurgns uleo I s juatuno -op 9TIll sale asagj se jnq 'saTdoo aqj �joago of aaTsap notS ;T 'saajjaT s,tijTmS abpnp ;o pue paaQ juetuaseg Am ;o sTW; bTao aql aTv tnlm aneq I -but paaooad sp 1.;o paooaa pgoT;;o aqj ;o javd a apvw aq Aagj jegj jsenba.z pure `anoge of paaaa;aa I sjuauznoop agl ;o pule juauzalejs slgl ;o saTdoo ITuzgns mou I -UoTlTlad sTtil ;0 TaTuep aqj seaTnbaa 'jsaaajuT oTtgnd atTl 0311T `aao;aaatij 'AlTnbe alBA1.1d •u*ie os op of jdaoxe `uo,pTTad sTgl buTBuTaq uT gm of algTuaaosTp esodmd ou aneq ulea ogm pule ajgle -ja:gj,e an 11 ,zapuaa of ls'ed axil uT PTe =,& jgBnos seq ogem . `aauoTITlad agj To uoTpuad000 aqj ulTm ajgtn9')J. W ATuo ST OT l0Z 10 JM-auo gjaoN .xnq •g 407 OaTdn000 lI •go8ag nTuoS uT ST auroq anO •01 10`Z Tjas of aagjabol buplab jnogv ajgnoaj ou aq pTnom aaagj IV44 paom aaq leo pule Md s,aauoTlTlad sTtil leo 8Ou_gjaa uT `,q Tv; poo$ u1 passgo.md ',g5 9Tgvja3j,zeuzun STaaljn tre gjTm jlaT aq pTnotA suosujgoH agj 's joT omj 04UT luo t}usaoo ;o ,ggT .zaq aPTATP 01 lgbTa aql `azo aq aouo jgbnos aqs se `uMgo uagl pTnoo pule juetuaslea Aemxlsm .OT aql a,&ouraa pTnoo .zauoppad sTgj;o pnuep aql A. vapoo aqj uo leaTnbai scop jI •aauoTlTlad sTgj 01;aTjea Aue 'aaopaagj 'aaTnbaa jou scop Ajlnbe ajenTarT • jax.z8tu am go lorI fail ;o RV4-auo Am BuTpjoq Aq je: z.nm aql ju ajglne3jx8mtn OT jo'I jp MLI -EMO s,aauoppgcd etp aapuez of iduzelle loupjnom Pue lou a,&eq I •9Tglss90 -ole AlmMT rls `1e9ale ano UT sjoT juoapMoo pazTs .zeTT MS ao; aTes ;o auzTI ata ll 91 ja3lsetu aqj aoTad ae4sjlegm 11 'p uti-auo aaq Bulaa;;o UT u1of TTTM aauoTlllad aql 9", Atm eTes ,zo; eq of anulluoo ITTm Puv 'ST OT loll ;0 ITleq-auo uoMgo*a agl lvil djaTTgnd eaag 91VW of gsTm I • juoapusaoo aTgeajesun po ,gg gjTtA aauoT4ped sezeaa; loll ;M-auo MIjo dpjsaeumo ano Iltn `9,&911 r -aq aTdoed euros pjol me I s8 'anal jou sT lI 'OT loll ;o ,5g glsON ao 41M -auo aaxijo aql umo I pule uosujgoH •s -Irl •0T lo�l ;0 ,gg tnnog ao g q-auo Pug TT jorl 10 TTv "eqj sumo. exp •pu*el ano paswgoand saagjo pule I uagm g0iw8 BlTuog $uTgTaasap sg paluasaade.z aqs Paid axil of BuTtuaopuoo sloT uT q3WIS InTu0S UT PST luo z; xz1830 aeg ;o 11V la' aJvw MIs tm 'PeTuap ST uoll -Tied aaq ;T `etiS 'aauoTjTjed sTgl Io spTa aqj uo dlTrnbe alugad sl aag4191,1 -papaooaz aq jou PTnoo 8u1pWld os jou IvTcl V ITgI Rmgns I 'ulea3o aqT of sseaae eAvq SAvA%Tt3 TTw suoTsTATpgm juoayxsaoo uT sloj juoapueeoo-uou jo saaMo and lvtj slsTsuT oar Is welaT 0Tlgnd ' BjBjd Bons uodn BuTAjaa szedoje&ap gone taoa; pM pemvgo�tnd ensq 'azeq se `osTlated aagjo eaagee ATsvjn*T4jjd eigv cT p®paooaa sTegl mt joeBa z 9v saadoTa,&ap uoTsTnTP-qns Aq pejuwb sjgbl z pav uodn stua'MTXWea ;o AlAbOTM sql BuTuTt$j 4vw buTgaq AjowTO eT lsexrrjuT Mand eqs 'U40Tj* gans a pbea pjnotA AlTnbe elvATad jou jsaaeWl 3TTgnd aagjTau ` jTjed SRI lib of uoTjOTPsT C azegl eae� -=OCT MOONS -3 ebsd Charles Herring AlA right-of-way attorney, reported that the deeds were on the way for 3500 feet next to the Inlet Subdivision. Motion was made by Commissioner Hamilton, seconded by Commis- . sioner Waddell and unanimously carried, that the salary of Douglas Baker, Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners, be increased from $650.00 per month to $750.00 per month, effective December 1, 1962, and the fol- lowing Item to Item transfer approved. ITEM TO ITEM TRANSFER GENERAL REVENUE FUND TO FROM 212 Salary Clerk to Board $1,000.00 951 Contingencies $1,000.00 Attorney Dick Stikeleather,•appeared before the Board and pre- sented a petition for abandonment of a road adjacent to H. D. Ruffner property. Motion was made by Commissioner Macdonald, seconded by Commis- sioner Hamilton and unanimously carried, that public -hearing be set for January 22, 1963, at 9:00 o'clock, A. M. Motion was made by Commissioner McCullers, seconded by Commis- sioner Hamilton and unanimously carried, that Commissioner Waddell's trip to Jacksonville to the Board of Directors meeting on December 14, 1962, be approved. Motion was made by Commissioner Macdonald, seconded by Commis- sioner McCullers and unanimously carried, that the County Judge is authorized to purchase roller shelving. ' Motion was made by Commissioner Waddell, seconded by Commissioner Hamilton and unanimously carried, to authorize advertisement for bids on fire truck at 11:00 o'clock, A. M., Tuesday, January 8, 1963. The several bills and accounts against the County, having been audited, were examined and found correct, were approved•`and warrants issued in settlement of same as follows: General Revenue Fund,'Warrant'Nos 1464 to 14.99, both inclusive; Road and Bridge Fund, Warrant Nos. 900 to 923, F both inclusive; and Fine and Forfeiture.Fund, Warrant Nos. -113 to 116, both .inclusive: Such 'bills and accounts tieing on file in the office of the Clerk of•the Circuit Court, the warrants so issued.from'the respective funds being Clerk